Chapter 4
Developing an innovation
strategy
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
1
CONTENTS
• Introduction
• Elements of corporate innovation strategy
• Conclusions
2
1. INTRODUCTION
3
1.1 Innovation Strategy
Session 4 outline:
• Limitations of the rational planning approach
to strategy
• Positions - national systems & competitors
• Paths - competencies & opportunities
• Processes - specialization versus integration
• Identifying & sustaining capabilities
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
4
1.1 Innovation Strategy
Four factors have a major influence on the
ability of a firm to develop and create value
through innovation:
• The national system of innovation in which
the firm is embedded, and which in part
defines its range of choices in dealing with
opportunities and threats.
• Its power and market position within the
international value chain, which in part
defines the innovation-based opportunities
and threats that it faces.
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
5
Innovation Strategy
Four factors have a major influence on the
ability of a firm to develop and create value
through innovation:
• The capability and processes of the firm,
including research, design, development,
production, marketing and distribution.
• Its ability to identify and exploit external
sources of innovation, especially
international networks.
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
6
1.2 Choice of strategy
Choice of strategy (& luck) are more
important than industry:
• choice of industry
8.35%
• choice of strategy
46.4%
• parent company
0.8%
• unexplained (e.g. luck) 44.5%
% total profitability explained. Source: Richard Rumelt “How much does industry
matter?”, Strategic Management Journal, 1991, 12, 167-186
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
7
1.3 Demands of Innovation Strategy
Key demands of innovation strategy:
• to develop firm-specific knowledge &
capacity to exploit it
• to cope with environmental
complexity & uncertainty
• to create organizational structures &
processes to manage trade-offs
between specialized & broad
knowledge
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
8
1.4 Strategic Management
Two distinct models of strategy:
Rational/Planning
Resource/Capabilitiesbased
top-down
bottom-up
outside-in
inside-out
choice
variation & selection
ahistorical
cumulative
static
dynamic/learning
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
9
1.4.1 Limitations of rational
planning
Limitations of the rational planning:
• Focus on with competitors, not customers
• Difficult to identify internal strengths &
weaknesses e.g. oil firms & 'energy';
computer firms & 'information’
• Strategic objectives do not match internal
capabilities
• The environment is often complex &
uncertain e.g. multi-media industry
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
10
Strategic Management
Rational planning approach ignores constraints:
•
•
•
•
Size & resources of the firm
Existing product & technological base
Technological opportunities for innovation
Market opportunities for innovation
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
11
1.5 Competitor Analysis
Example: Five 'forces' analysis of competitive
environment:
• rivalry amongst existing competitors
• threat of new entrants
• threat of substitute products & services
• power of suppliers
• power of customers
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
12
Competitor Analysis
But innovation affects all five forces:
• rivalry - basis of competition, industry
boundaries
• new entrants - raise or lower entry
barriers
• substitutes- relative price/performance,
new products
• customers & suppliers - switching costs,
relative power, vertical integration
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
13
1.6 Blue Ocean strategy
Concept of Blue Ocean strategies, compared to
traditional strategic thinking, or Red Ocean
strategies:
• Create uncontested market space, rather than
compete in existing market space
• Make the competition irrelevant, rather than beat
competitors
• Create &capture new demand, rather than fight for
existing markets and customers
• Break the traditional value/cost trade-off: Align the
whole system of a company's activities in pursuit of
both differentiation and low cost
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
14
2. ELEMENTS OF CORPORATE
INNOVATION STRATEGY
15
COMPETITIVE AND NATIONAL POSITIONS
TECHNOLOGICAL PATHS
ELEMENTS OF
CORPORATE
INNOVATION STRATEGY
ORGANIZATIONAL AND MANAGERIAL
PROCESSES
16
Key factors in innovation strategy:
• position of the firm - technologies,
processes & products compared to
competitors
• paths open to the firm, given its
competencies & emerging opportunities
• processes to integrate & exploit
competencies within & between firms
Source: Teece & Pisano
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
17
2.1 Positions - national factors
National factors influencing competencies:
•
•
•
•
input prices
natural resources
local buyers tastes
public & private investments
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
18
2.1.1 Positions – Emerging Economies
Firms in emerging economies may pursue different routes
to upgrading through innovation:
• Process upgrading – incremental process improvements
to adapt to local inputs, reduce costs or to improve
quality.
• Product upgrading – through adaptation,
differentiation, design and product development.
• Capability upgrading – improving the range of functions
undertaken, or changing the mix of functions, for
example, production versus development or marketing.
• Inter-sectoral upgrading - moving to different sectors,
for example, to those with higher value-added.
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
19
2.1.2 Positions - competition
Assessing competencies of competitors:
• How do they compare in terms of size &
composition?
• How efficiently are they exploited?
• How effectively do we learn from their
knowledge & experience?
• How do we differentiate, develop &
maintain our innovation advantages?
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
20
2.2 Paths - time horizons
Level, time & focus of innovation strategy:
• Business unit - 2-3 years - improving cost &
quality, new product & service
development
• Group/division - 5 years - positioning &
exploiting synergies across business units
• Corporate - 10 years - environmental
scanning & competence-building
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
21
2.2.1 Paths & Processes - capabilities
& innovation
Products &
services
Processes
Capabilities
Competencies
Resources/assets
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
22
2.2.2 Paths - capabilities & innovation
Innovation & strategic positioning:
•
•
•
•
•
•
pioneering technology, processes, products
accumulated tacit knowledge
complexity
complementary assets
standards
patents
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
23
2.2.3 Paths - capabilities & innovation
Characteristics of competencies:
• firm-specific
• significant benefit or value to customers
• take time to develop
• sustainable as difficult to imitate or
acquire
• unique configurations of resources
• strong tacit content & socially complex
Source: Hall (2000)
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
24
2.3 Processes - Knowledge
Key organizational issue is how to balance
conflicting requirements:
• to identify & develop specialized knowledge
within technologies & markets
• to exploit this knowledge by integrating
across technologies & markets
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
25
2.3.1 Processes - Innovation
Process of strategy formation:
• given uncertainty, explore implication of a
range of possible futures
• encourage the use of multiple sources of
information, debate & scepticism
• ensure broad participation & informal
channels of communication
• plan to change strategy in the light of new
& unexpected evidence
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
26
2.3.2 Processes - Resource Allocation
Resource allocation under uncertainty:
• encourage experimentation, risk-taking &
incrementalism
• apply different criteria for different types
of project
• use simple, transparent criteria
• make rules for termination explicit
• identify & plan for uncertainties
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
27
2.3.3 Innovation Process
Generic phases of the innovation process:
• Searching & scanning the internal &
external environments
• Filtering & selecting potential
opportunities
• acquiring the technical, financial & market
resources
• implementing development &
commercialisation
• reviewing & learning from experience
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
28
2.3.4 Innovation Process
Factors affecting the precise process:
• Sector - competitors, structure & constraints
• Markets - opportunities & rate of change
• Technology - maturity & costs
• Resources - firm & networks
• Location - regulation, policy & systems of
innovation
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
29
3. CONCLUSIONS
30
3.1 Decision-making under
Uncertainty
So, Innovation: Response or strategy?
• “. . . chance favours only the prepared
mind”, L. Pasteur, 1854
• “...the more I practice, the luckier I get…”,
Gary Player (champion golfer)
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
31
3.2 Being the first
Advantages of being first to market:
• reputation as a pioneer
• capture market share
• early learning curve benefits
• definition of standards
• establish entry barriers eg patents
• dominate supply & distribution chains
• earn ‘monopoly’ profits
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
32
Disadvantages of being first to market:
• pioneering costs, educating buyers,
regulatory approval
• demand uncertainty
• changing buyer needs
• low-cost imitation
• followers ‘leapfrog’ technology
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
33
3.3 Conclusions:
Innovation Strategy
Conclusions and implications from observation and
research:
• The elements national systems of innovation
interact to influence the degree and direction of
innovation in a country.
• The uneven global distribution of innovation
demands global search strategies for the
development & commercialization of innovation.
• The position of a firm in an international value
chain will constrain the opportunities for innovation
and entrepreneurship.
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
34
Conclusions:
Innovation Strategy
Conclusions and implications from observation and
research:
• National context influences, but does not
determine the rate and direction of innovation at
the firm level.
• Dynamic capabilities and firm-level processes
contribute to the development and growth of firms.
Sources: J. Bessant & J. Tidd (2007) Innovation and Entrepreneurship (Wiley); J. Tidd
(2006) From Knowledge Management to Strategic Competence (Imperial College
Press, 2nd edition); J. Tidd, & J. Bessant (2009) Managing Innovation: Integrating
technological, market & organizational change (Wiley, 4th edition); S. Isaksen & J.
Tidd (2006) Meeting the Innovation Challenge: Leadership for Transformation and
Growth (Wiley).
© 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
www.managing-innovation.com
35