Maps & library wayfinding
Jim Hahn & Alaina Morales, University of Illinois,
Undergraduate Library
Android App: Library Helper
2
CAD
• CAD map – architectural layout
– CAD maps are to scale
• Also does not auto-rotate
– But not preferred by students
4
Five users per map
• Process
– We asked students in the library to try out our app
– Think aloud, interview, observation for each map
Comments from CAD Maps
• If the map had labels on top showing the Dewey
ranges, with sections labeled to understand where
you are.
• helpful if it told you what section you were in
• Student wants more exact map rather than general
area
6
Upper and Lower level
• 2nd iteration: map scope is 2 floors and uses
directional arrows
8
Comments for
nd
2
map
• if the arrows worked it wouldn’t be confusing
• want to see the entire floor and then zoom in
• Map did not reload to lower level
– Students confused by directional arrows
9
Distorted maps
• Student conceptual frame is a bookstore
model
– They expect the library to be organized by
subjects like a bookstore so they liked how the call
numbers were shown as sections on the map – as
opposed to individual stacks.
Third iteration
• Scope of map reduced to one level
12
Single floor view
• Confused by directional arrows
• Wish I could see the title of the book (on map),
if I see the title, I could remember what I’m
looking for
• Surprised that it could find the aisles of the
books, saved time in looking it up
13
Final iteration
• Before we uploaded to Android Market we
removed directional arrows since it seemed
those worked against wayfinding.
Future Data Points
• Datapoints
– Worldview map / Placefinder map (you are here)
• Libraries need gaming mechanists to help build
immersive and engaging maps
– Influenced by Google maps
• Turn by turn directions
15
Worldview data
16
Turn by turn
17
Questions?
• Alaina
– morale26@illinois.edu
• Jim
– jimhahn@illinois.edu
18
Publications
• Hahn, J. & Morales, A. (2011). Rapid prototyping a collections-based
mobile wayfinding application. Journal of Academic Librarianship 37 (5)
– http://hdl.handle.net/2142/24001
• Hahn, J. & Zitron, L. (2011). How first-year students navigate the stacks:
implications for improving wayfinding. Reference & User Services
Quarterly 51 (1)
– http://hdl.handle.net/2142/24002
19
Acknowledgements
Presenters wish to acknowledge the Research and Publication
Committee of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Library and the University of Illinois Campus Research Board,
which provided support for the completion of this research.
Many thanks also to Dennis Matthews, PhD candidate in the
department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University
of Illinois for his technical expertise in the development of the
wayfinding app and in building positioning software.
20