CUPGA FALLS NIAGARA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES CUPGA NOVEMBER 2007 CANADIAN USER PRODUCER GROUP FOR ASPHALT GREY ASPHALT SURFACES JOHN EMERY PRESIDENT JEGEL GROUP, TORONTO ADJUNCT PROFESSOR, McMASTER UNIVERSITY CALABOGIE RACE TRACK PAVING ONTARIO’S FIRST NEW MOTOR SPORTS RACE TRACK IN 35 YEARS ASPHALT TOPICS FALL 2006 PHOTO COURTESY OF CALABOGIE RACE TRACK jemery@jegel.com JEGEL PARTNERS IN QUALITY INFRASTRUCTURE ISO 9001 www.jegel.com THE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE OF DIETER STOLLE, PEIJUN GUO, ISLAM ABU-HALIMEH AS PART OF JOINT JEGEL-McMASTER APPLIED ASPHALT TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH IS GRATEFULLY ACKNOWLEDGED ISLAM ABU-HALIMEH’S M.A.Sc 2007 THESIS – SURFACE EFFECTS ON THE THERMAL BEHAVIOUR AND MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF HOT-MIX ASPHALT – IS BASED ON THIS ONGOING RESEARCH THE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE OF ALAIN DUCLOS AND JESSICA HERNANDEZ IS ALSO GRATEFULLY ACKNOWLEDGED CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 ADVANTAGES OF HYDRATED LIME USE IN HOT-MIX ASPHALT LITTLE AND EPPS, 2001 AND WITCZAK AND BERRY 2004, FOR INSTANCE – SEE www.lime.org • • • • • SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION IN STRIPPING POTENTIAL (MOISTURE SUSCEPTIBILITY) SOMEWHAT REDUCED DESIGN ASPHALT BINDER CONTENT IMPROVED TOUGHNESS AND RESISTANCE TO FRACTURE GROWTH AT LOW TEMPERATURES REDUCED AGE HARDENING OF THE ASPHALT BINDER INCREASED MIXTURE STABILITY, DURABILITY AND DYNAMIC MODULUS ADVANTAGES OF HYDRATED LIME USE ON ASPHALT CONCRETE SURFACES • • • • • ENHANCED RESISTANCE TO EARLY TIRE SCUFFING (RACE TRACK SURFACES FOR INSTANCE) REDUCED SURFACE TEMPERATURE, SUBJECT TO APPROPRIATE APPLICATION SOMEWHAT ENHANCED FRICTIONAL RESISTANCE DUE TO LOWERED TEMPERATURE REDUCED RUNOFF-WATER TEMPERATURE DUE TO LOWERED TEMPERATURE SOMEWHAT ENHANCED REFLECTANCE NOTE – RESILIENT MODULUS OF ASPHALT CONCRETE IS A ‘FUNCTION’ OF PAVEMENT TEMPERATURE JEGEL No Lime Lime Treated HYDRATED LIME SURFACE TREATMENT HAS BEEN SHOWN TO REDUCE ASPHALT PAVEMENT TEMPERATURES (BLACK BODY ABSORPTION) CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 COMPOSITE PAVEMENT REPAIR AT PEARSON AIRPORT – 2002 SURFACE COURSE HMA POLYMER MODIFIED TACK COAT OCTOBER 2002 GTAA THE REPAIR OF THE COMPOSITE PAVEMENT THAT HAD SEVERELY SHOVED DUE TO SLIPPAGE OF THE ASPHALT CONCRETE ON TOP OF THE CONCRETE PAVEMENT BASE FROM HEAVY AIRCRAFT MOVEMENTS INVOLVED REMOVAL OF THE ASPHALT CONCRETE, TRANSVERSELY GRINDING AND CLEANING THE EXPOSED CONCRETE SURFACE, APPLICATION OF A POLYMER MODIFIED TACK COAT, PLACEMENT OF HIGH STABILITY HOT-MIX ASPHALT LOWER COURSE (PGAC 64-28), PLACEMENT OF HOT-MIX ASPHALT SURFACE COURSE (PGAC 70-28, POLYMER MODIFIED) AND APPLICATION OF HYDRATED LIME ON THE FINISHED HOT-MIX ASPHALT CONCRETE UPPER COURSE TO REDUCE TEMPERATURE EFFECTS A LIGHT APPLICATION (‘DUSTING’) OF HYDRATED LIME WAS APPLIED TO THE ASPHALT PAVEMENT SURFACE (SMALL ROTARY SPREADER) WHILE STILL WARM FOLLOWING CONVENTIONAL FINISH ROLLING. THE APPLIED HYDRATED LIME WAS THEN ROLLED INTO THE ASPHALT PAVEMENT SURFACE WITH MULTIPLE PASSES OF A LIGHT, UNBALLASTED, RUBBER-TIRED ROLLER. (THE HYDRATED LIME AND ROLLING PROCESS CAN BE REPEATED, AS NECESSARY, TO ACHIEVE A UNIFORM ‘OFF-WHITE’ – GREY – SURFACE COLOUR CONDITION.) NOTE – THE HYDRATED LIME SURFACE TREATMENT IS MOST EFFECTIVE WHEN APPLIED TO A WARM ASPHALT CONCRETE SURFACE INCORPORATING POLYMER MODIFIED ASPHALT BINDER AND WITH GOOD MACROTEXTURE CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 COMPOSITE PAVEMENT REPAIR AREAS AT PEARSON AIRPORT – 2006 REPAIR AREA CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 THE EFFECT OF ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS ON ASPHALT PAVEMENT TEMPERATURE Pavement absorbed energy Pavement emitted energy Direct Solar Radiation Diffuse Solar Radiation Cloud Wind Convection Outgoing Shortwave Radiation Input Longwave Radiation Outgoing Longwave Radiation Pavement Conduction Base Layer SUN, JIA AND QIN, ISAP 2006 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 McMASTER UNIVERSITY RESEARCH ON HMA SURFACE TEMPERATURES ISLAM ABU-HALIMEH’S M.A.Sc 2007 THESIS EFFECT OF HYDRATED LIME AMOUNT ON SURFACE TEMPERATURE OF HMA LABORATORY PAVEMENT WITH TIME CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 McMASTER UNIVERSITY RESEARCH CONTINUED ISLAM ABU-HALIMEH’S M.A.Sc 2007 THESIS EFFECT OF HYDRATED LIME AMOUNT ON SURFACE TEMPERATURE OF FIELD HMA PAVEMENT CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 CURRENT JAPANESE RESEARCH ON HEAT-SHIELD ASPHALT PAVEMENTS COMPARED TO ORDINARY ASPHALT PAVEMENTS, HEAT-SHIELD PAVEMENTS REDUCE THE SURFACE TEMPERATURE BY MORE THAN 15°C, AND ARE EXPECTED TO IMPROVE THE THERMAL ENVIRONMENT IN URBAN AREAS PWRI, PIARC SEPTEMBER 2007 HEAT-SHIELDING COATING MATERIALS (SPECIAL PAINT) THAT PRIMARILY REFLECT INFRARED RAYS ARE INCORPORATED INTO THE PAVEMENT SURFACE. INTENSIVE REFLECTION OF INFRARED RAYS REDUCES ACCUMULATED HEAT IN THE PAVEMENT. CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 CASE STUDY GREY ASPHALT SURFACES ASPHALT PAVEMENT STRUCTURE DESIGNS HYDRATED LIME JEGEL 2006 LONG-LIFE FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT STRUCTURES – DA’AN TO JILIAO SECTION IN RUYANG COUNTY ERLIANHAOTE TO GUANGZHOU EXPRESSWAY, HENAN PROVINCE, CHINA JEGEL FOR HENAN RUXIN EXPRESSWAY LIMITED CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 OVERLOADED TRUCKS JEGEL NEW YELLOW RIVER BRIDGE NEAR ZHENGZHOU OVERLOADED TRUCKS ARE A SIGNIFICANT PROBLEM FOR PAVEMENT AND BRIDGE DESIGN AND MAINTENANCE IN CHINA THERE ARE ALSO DIFFICULT SOIL CONDITIONS, SEMI-RIGID PAVEMENT PERFORMANCE PROBLEMS AND QUALITY ISSUES TO BE DEALT WITH CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 TOP-DOWN CRACKING (TDC) OF CHINESE ASPHALT PAVEMENTS TYPICAL SEVERE TRANSVERSE THERMAL CRACK WITH SOME TOP-DOWN CRACKING (TDC) IN WHEELPATHS CLOSE-UP OF TDC SHOWING ASSOCIATED DISTRESSES SUCH AS SECONDARY CRACKING AND RAVELLING CLOSE-UP OF TYPICAL TRANSVERSE THERMAL CRACKING AND TDC IN OUTER WHEELPATH TYPICAL HEAVILY OVERLOADED TRUCK WITH POOR AXLE AND TIRE DISTRIBUTION OF LOADINGS JEGEL TYPICAL SEVERE TRANSVERSE THERMAL CRACKING AND TOP-DOWN CRACKING (TDC) OF RELATIVELY NEW SEMI-RIGID ASPHALT PAVEMENT NEAR HOTHOT, INNER MONGOLIA, CHINA THE TDC AND ASSOCIATED DISTRESSES ARE MOST SEVERE IN THE OUTER WHEEL PATH CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 LONG-LIFE FLEXIBLE PAVEMENTS TECHNOLOGY CONCEPT OF PERPETUAL (LONG-LIFE) FLEXIBLE (ASPHALT) PAVEMENTS RESURFACING CAN BE RECYCLED HOT-MIX ASPHALT (HMA) OR HOT IN-PLACE RECYCLED 40 TO 75 mm SMA, OFC OR SUPERPAVE HMA 100 mm ZONE to OF HIGHEST 150 mm COMPRESSION HIGH MODULUS RUT RESISTANT HMA (THICKNESS FROM PAVEMENT DESIGN) FATIGUE RESISTANT HMA (75 mm to 100 mm) MAXIMUM TENSILE STRAIN LIMIT BENDING TO < 70 µ (MONISMITH, VON QUINTUS, NUNN, THOMPSON) GRANULAR BASE AND SUBBASE REPEATED DEFORMATION CAN LEAD TO RUTTING REPEATED BENDING CAN LEAD TO FATIGUE MAXIMUM COMPRESSIVE STRAIN LIMIT VERTICAL COMPRESSION TO < 200 µ SUBGRADE (MONISMITH, NUNN) ADAPTED FROM ASPHALT PAVEMENT ALLIANCE CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 DESIGN OF LONG-LIFE ASPHALT PAVEMENTS LOG LOG N HIGH ASPHALT BINDER CONTENT LOG COMPRESSION COMPRESSION LOW ASPHALT BINDER CONTENT LOG N TENSION TENSION IMPROVE FATIGUE RESISTANCE WITH HIGH ASPHALT BINDER CONTENT LOWER COURSE HOT-MIX ASPHALT MINIMIZE TENSILE STRAIN WITH ASPHALT PAVEMENT STRENGTH AND THICKNESS AMERICAN PERPETUAL PAVEMENT APPROACH EUROPEAN APPROACH ADAPTED FROM ASPHALT PAVEMENT ALLIANCE THERE ARE TWO APPROACHES FOR FATIGUE RESISTANCE JEGEL TYPICALLY USES A COMBINATION OF THESE TWO APPROACHES CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 SIMPLIFIED MECHANISTIC PAVEMENT DESIGN PROCEDURE FOR LONG-LIFE FLEXIBLE (ASPHALT) PAVEMENTS TECHNOLOGY MATERIAL PROPERTIES (MODULUS VALUES) HMA PROPERTIES ARE A FUNCTION OF TEMPERATURE MINIMIZE LIKELIHOOD OF TENSILE STRAINS >70 µ, COMP. STRAINS > 200 µ HEAVY VEHICLE LOADINGS PAVEMENT MODEL PAVEMENT RESPONSE (STRAINS, STRESSES, etc.) TRANSFER FUNCTION FINAL DESIGN PAVEMENT LIFE OK? ADAPTED FROM PerROAD CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 MATERIAL PROPERTIES CHARACTERIZATION OF HOT MIX ASPHALT AND PERFORMANCE TESTING OF HOT MIX ASPHALT JEGEL JEGEL NAT APA RESILIENT MODULUS PERMANENT DEFORMATION FATIGUE LINK BETWEEN LABORATORY TESTING AND FIELD PERFORMANCE RUTTING RESISTANCE AND MOISTURE SUSCEPTIBILITY FOR RESILIENT MODULUS OF SUBGRADES AND GRANULAR MATERIALS JEGEL USES FWD, DCP AND McMASTER LABORATORY SOIL DYNAMICS TESTING ASPHALT PAVEMENT ANALYZER AND NOTTINGHAM ASPHALT TESTER IN JEGEL LABORATORY CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 PLOTS OF DEFORMATION WITH NUMBER OF CYCLES IN THE ASPHALT PAVEMENTRutting ANALYZER ATAnalyzer 4% AIR VOIDS) Resistance Test (SAMPLES Using Asphalt Pavement HMA Briquettes @ 4% Air Voids 6.0 AC-13/SP 12.5 SBS 1-D @58°C AC-13/SP 12.5 SBS 1-D @58°C (UW) 5.5 AC-20/SP 19 SBS 1-D @58°C AC-20/SP 19 SBS 1-D @58°C (UW) AC-25/SP 25 70A @58°C 5.0 AC-25/SP 25 A70 @58°C (UW) AC-13/SP 12.5 SBS 1-D @64°C 4.5 AC-20/SP 19 SBS 1-D@64°C Deformation (mm) AC-25/SP 25 70A @64°C AC-13/SP 12.5 SBS 1-D @70°C 4.0 AC-20/SP 19 SBS 1-D @70°C AC-25/SP 25 A70 @70°C 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 Number of Strokes 5000 6000 7000 8000 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 PLOTS OF DEFORMATION WITH NUMBER OF CYCLES IN THE ASPHALT Resistance Test(SAMPLES Using Asphalt Pavement PAVEMENTRutting ANALYZER ATAnalyzer 7% AIR VOIDS) HMA Briquettes @ 7% Air Voids 9.0 AC-13/SP 12.5 SBS 1-D @58°C AC-13/SP 12.5 SBS 1-D @58°C (UW) AC-20/SP 19 SBS 1-D @58°C 8.0 AC-20/SP 19 SBS 1-D @58°C (UW) AC-25/SP 25 70A @58°C 7.0 AC-25/SP 25 70A @58°C (UW) AC-13/SP 12.5 SBS 1-D @64°C Deformation (mm) AC-20/SP 19 SBS 1-D @64°C 6.0 AC-25/SP 25 70A @64°C AC-13/SP 12.5 SBS 1-D @70°C AC-20/SP 19 SBS 1-D @70°C 5.0 AC-25/SP 25 70A @70°C 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 Number of Strokes 5000 6000 7000 8000 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 RESILIENT MODULUS OF ASPHALT CONCRETES TESTED IN THE RESILIENT ASPHALT MODULUS TESTTESTER RESULTS (NAT) NOTTINGHAM Da'an to Jiliao Section of Erlianhaote to Guangzhou Expressway 100000 AC-13/SP12.5, Basalt Aggregates/SBS1-D/Hydrated Lime Air Voids=7.0%, AC Content=5.5%, Diameter=150mm, Xixin Stiffness Modulus (MPa) AC-13/SP12.5 , Basalt Aggregates/SBS1-D/Hydrated Lime Air Voids=4.0%, AC Content=5.5% , Diameter=150mm, Xixin AC-20/SP19, Limestone Aggregates/SBS1-D Air Voids=7.0%, AC Content=4.0%, Diameter=150mm, Yunmeng Hill 10000 AC-20/SP19 , Limestone Aggregates/SBS1-D Air Voids=4.0%, AC Content=4.0%, Diameter=150mm, Yunmeng Hill AC-25/SP25 , Limestone Aggregates/70A Air Voids=7.0%, AC Content=3.8%, Diameter=150mm, Yunmeng Hill 1000 AC-25/SP25 , Limestone Aggregates/70A Air Voids=4.0%, AC Content=3.8%, Diameter=150mm, Yunmeng Hill AC-25/SP25 , Limestone Aggregates/70A Air Voids=7.0%, AC Content=4.0%, Diameter=150mm, Yunmeng Hill AC-25/SP25, Limestone Aggregate/70A Air Voids=4.0%, AC Content=4.0%, Diameter=150mm, Yunmeng Hill 100 15 20 25 30 35 40 Temperature (ºC) 45 50 55 60 65 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 FATIGUE ENDURANCE TESTING IN THE NOTTINGHAM ASPHALT TESTER (NAT) FATIGUE ENDURANCE TESTING IN THE NAT Initial tensile Strain (microstrain) 10000 Project Mixes AC-25/SP25, AV = 7.0%, AC = 4.0% AC-25/SP25, AV = 5.0%, AC = 4.3% Typical Mixes S19 SBS JEGEL Superpave S 25 for Bogotá S 37.5 30/14 HRA SBS Typical British 30/14 HRA (UK) Mixes 20 mm DBM 28 mm DBM 50 1000 100 10 10 100 1000 10000 Number of Cycles to Failure 100000 1000000 10000000 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 SUMMARY OF YUNMENG HILL AGGREGATES RESILIENT MODULUS TESTING GRANULAR BASE/SUBBASE TESTED AT McMASTER UNIVERSITY (a) Variation of Moduli with bulk Stresses Resilient Modulus (MPa) 600 0.6204 Sample 105 Yunmeng Hill, Ruyang Mr = 9.5882q 400 3 psi 5 psi 10 psi 200 15 psi 20 psi Series6 0 Series7 0 200 400 600 800 Power (Series6) Bulk Stress (kPa) (b) Variation of Moduli with Deviator Stresses Resilient Modulus (MPa) 600 400 3 psi 5 psi 10 psi 15 psi 20 psi 200 0 0 50 100 150 200 Deviator Stress (kPa) 250 300 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 TRAFFIC INFORMATION FOR PROJECT Single Axle/Single Tire Loadings 160 TRAFFIC SPECTRA BY HOUR, SINGLE AXLE/SINGLE TIRE 150 1-20 kN 140 21-40 kN 41-60 kN 130 61-80 kN 81-100 kN 120 101-120 kN 121-140 kN 110 Number of Axle Loadings 141-160 kN 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0 -12 2 -24 4 -36 6 -48 8 - 510 10 -612 10 10- -712 12 12 14 Time Increment 14 12- -816 14 16 - 918 18 -10 20 20 11 - 22 22 12 - 24 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 TRAFFIC INFORMATION FOR PROJECT CONTINUED TireSINGLE Loadings TRAFFIC SPECTRA Single BY Axle/Dual HOUR, AXLE/DUAL TIRE 140 130 1-20 kN 21-40 kN 120 41-60 kN 61-80 kN 110 81-100 kN 101-120 kN 100 121-140 kN 141-160 kN Number of Axle Loadings 90 161-180 kN 181-200 kN 80 201-220 kN 221-240 kN 70 241-260 kN 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0-2 1 2-4 2 4-6 3 6-8 4 8 - 10 5 10 - 12 12 10 10--7-14 12 12 Time Increment 6 14 12- -16 8 14 16 - 18 9 18 - 20 10 20 - 22 11 22 - 24 12 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 TRAFFIC INFORMATION FOR PROJECT CONTINUED SINGLE AXLE/SINGLE TIRE LOAD DISTRIBUTION Load (kN) Load (kip) Number Percent 1 - 10 0 - 2 42 1.66% 11 - 20 3 - 5 267 10.53% 21 - 30 5 - 7 487 19.20% 31 - 40 7 - 9 500 19.72% 41 - 50 9 - 11 481 18.97% 51 - 60 12 - 14 405 15.97% 61 - 70 14 - 16 185 7.29% 71 - 80 16 - 18 110 4.34% 81 - 90 18 - 20 33 1.30% 91 - 100 21 - 23 18 0.71% 101 - 110 23 - 25 6 0.24% 111 - 120 25 - 27 0 0.00% 121 - 130 27 - 29 1 0.04% 131 - 140 29 - 32 1 0.04% 95% PERCENTILE 74 kN 2536 100.0% 98% PERCENTILE 83 kN Total CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 TRAFFIC INFORMATION FOR PROJECT CONTINUED SINGLE AXLE/DUAL TIRE LOAD DISTRIBUTION Load (kN) Load (kip) Number Percent 1 - 10 0 - 2 19 0.47% 11 21 31 41 51 61 71 81 91 101 111 121 131 141 151 161 171 181 191 201 211 221 231 241 - 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200 210 220 230 240 250 3 5 7 9 12 14 16 18 21 23 25 27 29 32 34 36 38 41 43 45 47 50 52 54 - 5 7 9 11 14 16 18 20 23 25 27 29 32 34 36 38 41 43 45 47 50 52 54 56 101 446 373 523 453 168 137 190 359 247 182 183 159 128 128 70 53 39 20 4 11 4 3 1 2.52% 11.15% 9.32% 13.07% 11.32% 4.20% 3.42% 4.75% 8.97% 6.17% 4.55% 4.57% 3.97% 3.20% 3.20% 1.75% 1.32% 0.97% 0.50% 0.10% 0.27% 0.10% 0.07% 0.02% 95% PERCENTILE 162 kN 4001 100.0% 98% PERCENTILE 181 kN Total CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 CLIMATE INFORMATION FOR PROJECT PAVEMENT SURFACE TEMPERATURES Hourly Increments January February March April May June July August September October November December 0-4 8.9 12.1 15.8 20.4 30.4 36.8 35.8 39.5 31.9 18.1 15.5 11.1 4-8 8.0 10.8 14.8 18.3 24.7 34.5 34.4 38.1 29.6 16.3 15.3 10.4 8-12 9.0 12.6 18.0 29.9 32.6 40.9 39.0 41.6 34.6 24.2 17.2 11.6 12-16 13.2 16.8 21.9 37.6 39.3 47.6 42.4 45.7 39.4 33.2 16.1 14.2 16-20 12.5 16.9 21.5 34.4 39.4 47.0 42.0 44.9 38.7 31.0 14.2 13.8 20-24 9.8 14.1 13.9 25.0 34.1 40.6 38.4 41.0 34.2 20.7 16.9 12.0 Mean 10.2 13.9 17.6 27.6 33.4 41.2 38.7 41.8 34.7 23.9 15.9 12.2 PAVEMENT TEMPERATURE AT 2 CM DEPTH Hourly Increments January February March April May June July August September October November December 0-4 11.4 14.6 18.3 22.9 32.9 39.3 38.3 42.0 34.4 20.6 18.0 13.6 4-8 10.5 13.3 17.3 20.8 27.2 37.0 36.9 40.6 32.1 18.8 17.8 12.9 8-12 11.5 15.1 20.5 32.4 35.1 43.4 41.5 44.1 37.1 26.7 19.7 14.1 12-16 15.7 19.3 24.4 40.1 41.8 50.1 44.9 48.2 41.9 35.7 18.6 16.7 16-20 15.0 19.4 24.0 36.9 41.9 49.5 44.5 47.4 41.2 33.5 16.7 16.3 20-24 12.3 16.6 16.4 27.5 36.6 43.1 40.9 43.5 36.7 23.2 19.4 14.5 Mean 12.7 16.4 20.1 30.1 35.9 43.7 41.2 44.3 37.2 26.4 18.4 14.7 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 CLIMATE INFORMATION FOR PROJECT CONTINUED NUMBER OF DAYS PER YEAR IN VARIOUS TEMPERATURE RANGES Season 1 2 3 4 5 Total < 25ºC 25º C to 35ºC 35º C to 40ºC 40º C to 45ºC > 45ºC No. Weeks 25 6 7 11 3 52 No. Days 175 42 49 77 21 365 % 48 12 13 21 6 100 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 CLIMATE INFORMATION FOR PROJECT CONTINUED PAVEMENT TEMPERATURE VARIATION WITH DEPTH WITHOUT HYDRATED LIME SURFACE COATING Depth (cm) 1 2 3 4 5 < 25ºC 25º C to 35ºC 35º C to 40ºC 40º C to 45ºC > 45ºC 0 cm, ºC 22.5 32.5 40.0 45.0 47.5 2 cm, ºC 20.0 30.0 37.5 42.5 45.0 7 cm, ºC 20.0 23.0 30.5 35.5 38.0 15 cm, ºC 15.0 17.0 24.5 29.5 32.0 25 cm, ºC 15.0 15.0 22.5 27.5 30.0 PAVEMENT TEMPERATURE VARIATION WITH DEPTH WITH HYDRATED LIME SURFACE COATING Depth (cm) 1 2 3 4 5 < 25ºC 25º C to 35ºC 35º C to 40ºC 40º C to 45ºC > 45ºC 0 cm, ºC 21.5 30.5 37.0 41.0 42.5 2 cm, ºC 19.0 28.0 34.5 38.5 40.0 7 cm, ºC 20.0 23.0 30.5 32.5 35.0 15 cm, ºC 15.0 17.0 24.5 28.5 30.0 25 cm, ºC 15.0 15.0 22.5 26.5 29.0 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 LONG-LIFE ASPHALT PAVEMENT DESIGN ASPHALT CONCRETE RESILIENT MODULUS WITH DEPTH WITHOUT HYDRATED LIME Layer Season 1 2 3 4 5 < 25ºC 25º C to 35ºC 35º C to 40ºC 40º C to 45ºC > 45ºC 20.0 30.0 37.5 42.5 45.0 Depth MPa psi MPa psi MPa psi MPa psi MPa psi AC-13/SP12.5 SBS1-D 2 cm 8,440 1,224,118 3,590 520,685 1,890 274,121 1,230 178,396 1,000 145,038 AC-20/SP19 SBS1-D 7 cm 9,340 1,354,652 7,280 1,055,874 3,910 567,097 2,580 374,197 2,100 304,579 AC-25/SP25 70A 15 cm 12,040 1,746,254 9,530 1,382,209 3,980 577,250 2,220 321,984 1,660 240,763 AC-25/SP25 70A 25 cm 10,630 1,541,751 10,630 1,541,751 4,450 645,418 2,490 361,144 1,870 271,220 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 LONG-LIFE ASPHALT PAVEMENT DESIGN CONTINUED ASPHALT CONCRETE RESILIENT MODULUS WITH DEPTH WITH HYDRATED LIME Layer Season 1 2 3 4 5 < 25ºC 25º C to 35ºC 35º C to 40ºC 40º C to 45ºC > 45ºC 19.0 28.0 34.5 38.5 40.0 Depth MPa psi MPa psi MPa psi MPa psi MPa psi AC-13/SP12.5 SBS1-D 2 cm 9,190 1,332,896 4,260 617,861 2,440 353,892 1,740 252,366 1,530 221,908 AC-20/SP19 SBS1-D 7 cm 9,340 1,354,652 7,280 1,055,874 3,910 567,097 3,310 480,075 2,690 390,151 AC-25/SP25 70A 15 cm 12,040 1,746,254 9,530 1,382,209 3,980 577,250 2,490 361,144 2,090 303,129 AC-25/SP25 70A 25 cm 10,630 1,541,751 10,630 1,541,751 4,450 645,418 2,800 406,106 2,090 303,129 NOTE POISSON’S RATIOS ARE ALSO A FUNCTION OF PAVEMENT TEMPERATURE AND HYDRATED LIME TREATMENT CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 PerROAD ASPHALT PAVEMENT DESIGN RESULTS AADT Percentile (%) 13,900 100 13,900 13,900 11,213 11,213 11,213 13,900 13,900 13,900 11,213 11,213 11,213 Condition Layer Location Criteria Threshold (Microstrain) Percent Below Critical (%) Without Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 90.1 Without Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 Without Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 91.1 Without Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 Without Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 92.0 Without Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 Without Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 90.7 Without Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 Without Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 91.3 Without Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 Without Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 92.3 Without Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 With Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 91.7 With Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 With Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 92.2 With Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 With Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 93.0 With Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 With Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 92.3 With Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 With Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 92.6 With Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 With Lime 3 Bottom of Asphalt Horizontal Strain -70 93.2 With Lime 5 Top of Select Subgrade Vertical Strain 200 100.0 98 95 100 98 95 100 98 95 100 98 95 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 KENPAVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT DESIGN RESULTS CONDITION AXLE LOAD (kN) TIRE LOAD (kN) LOCATION STRAIN CRITERIA MICROSTRAIN WITHOUT LIME 350/350 MPa Single Axle Single Tire Single Axle Single Tire Single Axle Single Tire Single Axle Single Tire 70 90 110 140 35 45 55 70 WITH LIME 400/350 MPa 350/350 MPa 400/350 MPa 40ºC to 45ºC > 45ºC 40ºC to 45ºC > 45ºC 40ºC to 45ºC > 45ºC 40ºC to 45ºC > 45ºC Bottom of HMA Horizontal -68.66 -78.52 -65.14 -73.87 -63.77 -71.89 -60.72 -67.98 Top of SSM Vertical 54.48 57.67 54.07 57.18 52.03 54.64 51.69 54.23 Top of Subgrade Vertical 35.02 36.03 34.63 35.63 34.09 34.93 33.72 34.54 Bottom of HMA Horizontal -83.68 -95.45 -79.32 -89.72 -77.88 -87.64 -74.11 -82.82 Top of SSM Vertical 69.75 73.82 -69.22 73.18 66.63 69.95 66.19 69.43 Top of Subgrade Vertical 45.13 46.43 44.63 45.92 43.94 45.01 43.45 44.51 Bottom of HMA Horizontal -97.19 -110.6 -92.06 -103.9 -90.62 -101.8 -86.18 -96.14 Top of SSM Vertical 84.88 89.79 84.23 89.02 81.10 85.12 80.56 84.47 Top of Subgrade Vertical 55.22 56.80 54.16 56.18 53.76 55.07 53.18 54.47 Bottom of HMA Horizontal -115.0 -130.4 -108.9 -122.3 -107.6 -120.6 -102.2 -113.7 Top of SSM Vertical 107.30 113.40 106.50 112.40 102.50 107.60 101.80 106.80 Top of Subgrade Vertical 70.28 72.28 69.50 71.49 68.43 70.09 67.69 69.33 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 KENPAVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT DESIGN RESULTS CONTINUED CONDITION AXLE LOAD (kN) TIRE LOAD (kN) LOCATION STRAIN CRITERIA MICROSTRAIN WITHOUT LIME 350/350 MPa Single Axle Dual Tire Single Axle Dual Tire Single Axle Dual Tire 160 200 240 40 50 60 WITH LIME 400/350 MPa 350/350 MPa 400/350 MPa 40ºC to 45ºC > 45ºC 40ºC to 45ºC > 45ºC 40ºC to 45ºC > 45ºC 40ºC to 45ºC > 45ºC Bottom of HMA Horizontal -121.80 -137.60 -115.20 -128.90 -114.20 -127.60 -108.40 -120.30 Top of SSM Vertical 118.00 124.50 117.00 123.30 112.90 118.30 112.10 117.30 Top of Subgrade Vertical 79.27 81.51 78.40 80.62 77.20 79.05 76.37 78.20 Bottom of HMA Horizontal -147.10 -165.80 -139.00 -155.30 -138.00 -154.10 -131.00 -145.20 Top of SSM Vertical 146.80 154.90 145.70 153.50 140.50 147.20 139.50 146.00 Top of Subgrade Vertical 98.95 101.70 97.87 100.60 96.38 98.69 95.34 97.61 Bottom of HMA Horizontal -170.60 -191.90 -161.10 -179.60 -160.30 -178.70 -152.00 -168.30 Top of SSM Vertical 175.40 185.00 174.00 183.30 167.90 175.80 166.80 174.40 Top of Subgrade Vertical 118.70 122.00 117.40 120.70 115.60 118.30 114.30 117.10 CUPGA GREY ASPHALT SURFACES NOVEMBER 2007 QUESTIONS? HENAN RUXIN NEW EXPRESSWAY PROJECT JEGEL 2007 NOTE – A HYDRATED LIME SURFACE TREATMENT IS MOST EFFECTIVE WHEN PROPERLY APPLIED TO AN ASPHALT CONCRETE SURFACE INCORPORATING POLYMER MODIFIED ASPHALT BINDER AND WITH GOOD MACROTEXTURE. USE OF THIS TECHNOLOGY IS SUBJECT TO A FULL TECHNICAL EVALUATION FOR SPECIFIC PROJECT APPLICABILITY.