Chapter 7 Pricing the offer Understand the significance of pricing in the preencounter marketing mix Identify external and internal factors that influence pricing decisions Appreciate how online search and transparency influences contemporary pricing strategies Explain quality/pricing strategies in a hospitality context Understand how hospitality organizations set price Describe the practice of dynamic pricing and its role in optimizing revenue Describe the role of price promotions to increase revenue in low demand periods Recognize the complexity of pricing in an international context Pricing is the tool that matches supply and demand Price influences the demand for a product, which in turn determines volume sales Therefore, setting an appropriate price is one of the most important factors in demand management and in generating revenue Revenue management (RM) is the tool used to manage demand through flexing prices in medium and large-sized accommodation businesses Price is the only element of the marketing mix that does not generate costs, but price is also the only element of the marketing mix to generate revenue Price is defined as ‘the summation of all sacrifices made by a consumer in order to experience the benefits of a product’ This definition includes both financial and other sacrifices Different types of hospitality products and different sizes of businesses have different approaches to pricing decisions Large conference, event and hotel companies, and many large independent hotels use dynamic pricing and complex revenue management systems, with sophisticated databases and online booking to manage real-time availability and pricing decisions Influence of the Internet and online technologies has challenged conventional approaches to pricing and introduced more complexity to price decisions for these companies Smaller accommodation businesses and bar, café and restaurant operations use more traditional fixed-price menus and tariffs There is a clear link between the price a customer pays and the customer’s quality expectations The higher the price, the greater the expectations of a high-quality hospitality experience Price is an indicator and a measure of quality, particularly in the absence of other cues Price plays an important part in establishing customers’ perceptions of a product and of a company’s or brand’s position in the marketplace Price is the easiest variable to change in the marketing mix, but is often thought of as the most complex Factors that influence price decisions can be sorted into two major categories: External environmental factors – over which companies have little (if any) control Internal factors – over which companies have a considerable amount of control Figure 7.1 Factors that influence pricing decisions The sales volume of a product that has inelastic price demand does not vary significantly when price changes: essential purchases are price inelastic The sales volume of a product that has an elastic price demand varies significantly when prices change: non-essential purchases are more price elastic The business cycle has significant impact on business and consumer confidence and pricing During periods of economic growth, rising confidence and less price sensitivity from business and consumers and less resistance to price increases During a recession, the loss of business and consumer confidence significantly reduces demand and companies respond by flexing prices downwards Different hospitality sectors have different cost structures, which impact pricing strategies Luxury hotels require a high investment in the building, décor, facilities and staffing ratios The pricing strategies of the five-star hotel sector must reflect the higher investment and operating costs The luxury sector has more potential for price flexibility given the relatively high rack rates Budget hotels which are constructed with pre-fabricated standardized bedrooms, in secondary locations, offering minimal staffing levels and no ancillary facilities The pricing strategies of the budget sector should reflect the lower investment and operating costs The budget sector has limited ability to flex prices due to the relatively low rack rate Prestige pricing Luxury operations adopt a ‘prestige’ or premium pricing objective (i.e. to charge high prices for the top-quality service) and must give the customer a service that matches the premium prices charged Value-for-money Many hospitality operators adopt a ‘best value for money’ objective in a given product class To succeed they need to scan competitors’ prices and ensure that their offer delivers the best perceived value for money Trial or repeat purchase Another marketing-orientated pricing objective is to encourage trial or repeat purchases A new hospitality concept needs to generate interest and one of the tools used is a free drink/meal or discounted trial purchase Repeat visits are encouraged by promotions and loyalty club offers Survival Target return on investment (ROI) Skimming Harvesting Cost-orientated pricing objectives Maximizing sales revenues Penetration pricing strategy Volume Tactical pricing A major factor in pricing decisions is the cost of producing and marketing the product Fixed costs do not vary with sales volume – rent, property taxes, permanent staff, repayment of loans/interest Variable costs vary in proportion to sales – examples include food/beverage purchases, laundry services Semi-fixed costs vary in sympathy with, but not in proportion to, sales volume – examples include energy costs (light, heat, air-conditioning) and part-time wages The prices set must eventually recover the long-term total costs of running the business Two main distribution models in tourism: the ‘agency’ model and the ‘merchant’ model Agency model: Hospitality companies pay a travel agent or online intermediary a fixed commission for each booking Minimum commission paid to travel agents is 8% and the norm varies between 10% and 25% Merchant (or wholesaler) model: Intermediary negotiates an allocation of inventory (cabins, rooms, seats) at an agreed rate from the hospitality operator Discounts for a contract rate vary from 15% to 65% off the rack rates Market leader strategies Well-established hotel companies with a loyal customer base, a strong brand image and high levels of repeat business adopt a market leader strategy where the prices are aligned with the brand’s quality and positioning Market follower strategy New entrants and less-established hotel brands, seeking to build market share by penetration pricing, adopt a market follower strategy, which pitches prices lower than the market leader Unsustainable strategy Some hotels implement over-priced strategies compared with their competitor sets and market conditions, which are unsustainable as a long-term proposition. These companies charge rates higher than the quality can justify. Overtime customers will recognize the poor value for money, and the reputation of the business will suffer Market-led The highest price that customers are willing to pay; considers the competition, demand and profitability, and sets the ceiling for prices Competitor-led Prices simply follow competitors; fails to take into account customers’ willingness to pay, return on investment goals and company costs Profit-led Return on investment target provides internal goals to motivate managers; fails to take into account customers and competitors Cost-led Cost-based pricing sets the floor for prices; fails to take into account customers’ willingness to pay and return on investment goals, is sometimes used to establish the lowest pricing level that a company can charge to remain viable Hospitality companies have adopted computerized yield management systems to maximize their potential revenue by controlling inventory and using price as a demand management tool Known as revenue management (RM), this is a complex form of price discrimination Dynamic pricing flexes prices to match forecast demand with current available capacity Prices change according to the probability of selling the last rooms and are influenced by length of time between the date of booking and the date of arrival, customer demand and different customer segments’ willingness Online technology changed consumer buying behaviour and hospitality companies’ response Transparent pricing, online comparative shopping, sophisticated databases, data management techniques Online prices are flexed using the Best Available Rate (BAR) The BAR is the best rate a customer can book at the time of booking and is determined by the estimated value of the last rooms to sell The BAR fluctuates as the RMS recalculates forecast demand and changes the BAR on a periodic basis (e.g. for every 12 hours) Companies using RM no longer publish online fixed prices; instead rate bands from high to low indicate the likely range of prices to potential customers Contract corporate, aircrew and group negotiated rates have fixed rates or are discounted from the BAR and fluctuate with the BAR One consequence is the requirement to overbook Price promotions need carefully planning to protect revenue streams from the core business and not devalue brand image Hotels offering low demand price promotions ‘rate-fence’ the promotion by having pre-booking conditions (rate restrictions) Price led promotions should make a realistic contribution towards overheads and justify the marketing cost of the promotion Popular promotions include ‘two for the price of one’ or BOGOF (buy one, get one free) Price-led promotions help to boost sales in quiet periods and should attract new customers who are expected to return and pay the normal price Many customers who enjoy a promotional price do not return and there is also the danger of ‘cannibalizing existing customers’; loyal customers may take advantage of the price promotion and business suffers a reduction in sales and profits All sectors of the industry bundle a package of benefits at an all inclusive price Examples include foreign package holidays, activity leisure breaks, 24 hour conference delegate packages, wedding receptions and fast-food and drink combinations. The advantages of product bundling for the consumer include the perception of added value (indeed, really effective packages do provide customers with added value) and the ease of booking all the components of the bundle at one price in one transaction Difficulties in setting a pricing strategy for companies operating in more than one country include: different currency and cost structures between countries different types of competitors – global, regional, national branded chains and local independents different stages of the market/product life cycle in each country different inflation rates and exchange rates ability to repatriate profits varies significantly from country to country Companies aiming to promote and protect their hospitality brands by standardizing the product offer, a uniform price position presents particular problems A pricing strategy can be consistent, for example adopting a market leader strategy and charging the highest prices in the competitor set, however the actual price charged will vary between different countries Customers decide whether the company is charging the right price Although pricing decisions are the easiest element of the marketing mix to change, they remain a complex phenomenon Pricing is the tool that matches supply and demand That price is the only element of marketing mix that does not generate cost; price generates revenue That price, in the absence of other cues, is an indicator of quality and sets customer expectations Companies have little control over the external factors that influence pricing decisions, but considerable control over the internal factors that influence pricing decisions How the Internet has transformed consumer awareness of comparative hospitality products and transparent prices Why pricing decisions should reflect market positioning That medium and larger accommodation-based businesses use dynamic pricing strategies and RMSs to drive revenue Price promotions, linked to product benefit bundles, are extensively used to grow revenue in low-demand periods International pricing decisions are subject to local country environmental factors Burgess, C. (2010). Essential Financial Techniques for Hospitality Managers: A Practical Manual. Goodfellow Publishers. Cross, R. (1997). RM: Hard-core Tactics for Market Domination. Broadway Books. Harris, P. J. and James, P. (1999). Profit Planning. Butterworth-Heinemann. Ingold, A., McMahon-Beattie, U. and Yeoman, I. (2000). Yield Management: Strategies for the Service Industries (2nd ed.). Cassell. Kimes, S. E. (2008). ‘The role of technology in restaurant revenue management’. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly, 49, pp. 297–309. Kotler, P., Keller, K., Brady, M., Goodman, M. and Hansen, T. (2009). Marketing Management. Pearson Prentice Hall. Noone, B. M. and Mattila, A. S. (2009). ‘Hotel revenue management and the Internet: the effect of price presentation strategies and customers’ willingness to book’. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 28, pp. 272–279. Talluri, K. T. and Van Ryzin, Garrett. (2005). The Theory and Practice of Revenue Management. Springer. Tranter, K. A., Stuart-Hill, T. and Parker, Juston. (2008). An Introduction to Revenue Management for the Hospitality Industry. Prentice Hall. Varini, K., Englemann, R., Claessen, B. and Schleusenier, M. (2003). ‘Evaluation of the price-value perception of customers in Swiss hotels’. Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management, 2 (1), pp. 47–60. Yeoman, I. and MacMahon-Beattie, U. (2004). Revenue Management and Pricing: Case Studies and Applications. Thomson Learning.