A WORKSHOP INITIATIVE OF EUROPEAN AND RUSSIAN THINK TANKS EUROPEAN-RUSSIAN DIALOGUE: FROM DAMAGE LIMITATION TO RENEWED ENGAGEMENT Rome, Monday 13 October 2014 Confirmed Participants Anatoliy ADAMISHIN, President, ASSOCIATION FOR EURO-ATLANTIC COOPERATION Marco ALBERTI, Head of International and Institutional Affairs, ENEL spa Vladimir ANDRIANOV, Head of Department, Department for Strategic Analysis and Development, Vnesheconombank Giancarlo ARAGONA, President, ISPI José María BENEYTO, Vice President, Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Madrid, Spain Irina BUSYGINA, Professor of the Comparative Politics Department, MGIMO University Sergey CHERNYSHOV, EURASIAN ECONOMIC COMMISSION Vladimir CHKHIKVISHVILI, Former Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of the Russian Federation Jarosław ĆWIEK-KARPOWICZ, Research Director, PISM Marta DASSÙ, Senior Director, European Affairs, The Aspen Institute; Director, Aspenia Benedetto DELLA VEDOVA, Undesecretary of State, ItalianMinistry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation Arnaud DUBIEN, Director, L’Observatoire – Centre D’Analyse de la CCI France Russie Alexander DYNKIN, Director, INSTITUTE OF WORLD, ECONOMY AND INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS Aldo FERRARI, Senior Associate Research Fellow, ISPI Vladimir FEYGIN, President, INSTITUTE OF ENERGY AND FINANCE Silvia FRANCESCON, Director, ECFR Rome Luca GIANSANTI, Director General for Political and Security Affairs, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation Thomas GOMART, Senior Research Fellow, Vice President for Strategic Development, IFRI Alexei GROMYKO, Director, Institute of Europe RAS Manfred HAFNER, Professor, Sciences Po Paris and Associate Researcher, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei (FEEM) Luigi IPPOLITO, Head of Foreign Affairs Desk, Corriere della Sera Wolfgang ISCHINGER, Chairman, Munich Security Conference – MSC Igor IVANOV, President, RIAC Andrey KORTUNOV, Director General, RIAC Sergey KULIK, Director for International Development, Institute for Contemporary Development - INSOR Monica MAGGIONI, Editor in Chief, RAINEWS24 With the support of The Trilateral Commission (Europe) Under the patronage of Paolo MAGRI, Executive Vicepresident and Director, ISPI; Secretary, ITALIAN GROUP OF THE TRILATERAL COMMISSION Manuela MARIANERA, Research Department, Confindustria Neil MELVIN, Senior Researcher, SIPRI Aleksei MESHKOV, Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation Alessandro MINUTO RIZZO, Chairman, NATO Defence College Antonio MISSIROLI, Director, European Union Institute for Security Studies – EuISS James NIXEY, Head of the Russia and Eurasia Programme, CHATHAM HOUSE Andrzej OLECHOWSKI, former Minister of Finance (1992) and Foreign Affairs (1993–1995) of Poland Giuseppe PARIGI, Head of the International Relations Directorate, Banca d’Italia Stefano PONTECORVO, Diplomatic Advisor to the Italian Minister of Defence Nicu POPESCU, Senior Analyst, European Union Institute for Security Studies – EuISS Katri PYNNÖNIEMI, Senior Research Fellow, Finnish Institute of International Affairs - FIIA Lia QUARTAPELLE, Secretary, Foreign and European Community Affairs Standing Committee, Italian Chamber of Deputies Cesare RAGAGLINI, Italian Ambassador to Russia (tbc) Sergey RAZOV, Russian Ambassador to Italy (tbc) Andrea ROMANO, Member of Italian Parliament Paul REVAY, Director, TRILATERAL COMMISSION EUROPE Pierfrancesco SACCO, Head of the Research, Policy planning and historical diplomatic Documentation Unit, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation Ferdinando SALLEO, Vice President, ITALIAN GROUP OF THE TRILATERAL COMMISSION and Former Italian Ambassador to Russia Giuseppe SCOGNAMIGLIO, Executive Vice President, Head of Public Affairs Department, Unicredit Spa Carlo SECCHI, Chairman, ITALIAN GROUP OF THE TRILATERAL COMMISSION Francesca SFORZA, Journalist, La Stampa Natela SHENGELIYA, Head of Representative office of Renova Group in Italy Andrey A. SLEPNEV, Member of the Board (Minister) for Trade, EURASIAN ECONOMIC COMMISSION Liborio STELLINO, Director for Russian Federation, Eastern Europe, Caucasus, and Central Asia, Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation Elena TELEGINA, Director, INSTITUTE OF ENERGY AND GEOPOLITICS Ivan TIMOFEEV, Director of Programs, RIAC Ugo TRAMBALLI, Journalist, Il Sole 24Ore Michele VALENSISE, Secretary General, Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation Armando VARRICCHIO, Diplomatic Counsellor to the Italian Prime Minister Andrew WILSON, Senior Policy Fellow, ECFR Andrew WOOD, Associate Fellow, Russia and Eurasia Programme, CHATHAM HOUSE, Former British Ambassador to Russia Igor YURGENS, Chairman of the Management Board, Institute for Contemporary Development – INSOR Antonio ZANARDI LANDI, Diplomatic Advisor to the Italian President of the Republic With the support of The Trilateral Commission (Europe) Under the patronage of A WORKSHOP INITIATIVE OF EUROPEAN AND RUSSIAN THINK TANKS EUROPEAN-RUSSIAN DIALOGUE: FROM DAMAGE LIMITATION TO RENEWED ENGAGEMENT Rome, Monday 13 October 2014 8.30 - 9.00 a.m. Registration 9.00 - 9.30 a.m. Welcome Giancarlo ARAGONA, ISPI; Igor IVANOV, RIAC; Carlo SECCHI, Trilateral Commission Italian Group Opening Session Aleksei MESHKOV, Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation Benedetto DELLA VEDOVA, Undersecretary of State at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation 9.30 a.m. - 12.15 p.m. Session I “Political and Security Issues” How to increase the level of trust between Russia and Europe taking into account the crisis in Ukraine? How to overcome the legacy of the Cold War? How to live in the common neighbourhood and jointly shape a new European security architecture that minimizes the risks of crises? Kick off: Wolfgang ISCHINGER, Munich Security Conference (MSC); Igor IVANOV, RIAC; Thomas GOMART, IFRI; Alexei GROMYKO, Institute of Europe RAS; Irina BUSYGINA, MGIMO University Chair: Giancarlo ARAGONA, ISPI Debate among participants 12.15 - 1.00 p.m. Buffet Lunch 1.00 - 3.45 p.m. Session II “Economic, Energy and Business Relations” What future for Europe-Russia economic relations in the light of imposed sanction regimes leading to reciprocal measures? What future for EU-Russia energy relations and Arctic cooperation? How to tackle a growing economic continental divide with, in this context, any future for EU-Eurasian Economic Union institutional cooperation? Kick off: Alexander DYNKIN, Institute of world, economy and international relations; Vladimir FEYGIN, Institute of Energy and Finance; Manfred HAFNER, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei/ Sciences Po Paris; Neil MELVIN, SIPRI; Andrey SLEPNEV, Eurasian Economic Commission; Elena TELEGINA, Institute of energy and geopolitics; Andrew WOOD, Chatham House/Former British Ambassador to Russia. Chair: Igor YURGENS, Institute for Contemporary Development (INSOR) Debate among participants Conclusions Giancarlo ARAGONA, ISPI; Igor IVANOV, RIAC; Paul REVAY, Trilateral Commission Europe With the support of The Trilateral Commission (Europe) Under the patronage of