Autonomous Vehicles
The Trolley Problem
ππ¨
Group B
(basically the trolley problem but make it sigma π¨π¨)
Computer Science Ethics Homework
Background - what even is this
The Trolley Problem:
πβ‘οΈπ₯π₯π₯π₯π₯
•
•
•
basically theres a trolley going mad fast and it's gonna hit 5
people
u can pull a lever and it hits 1 person instead
do u pull it?? thats the whole dilemma lol
Now but for SELF DRIVING CARS:
•
•
•
the car is gonna crash no matter what (brakes failed fr fr)
it has to CHOOSE who to hit - this is literally coded in
someone programmed this decision. thats kinda wild ngl π
no cap this is actually a real ethical debate happening rn
or
πβοΈπ€
The INPUTS (what the car can see)
basically the car has loads of sensors so it knows whats around it:
π· Cameras - sees people, signs, lanes etc
πΊοΈ GPS - knows where it is and whats nearby
π‘ LiDAR - like radar but with lasers, maps everything in
3D
οΈ AI object detection - figures out if its a person or just a
bin
β‘ Speed sensors - knows how fast its going
π Prediction models - guesses where ppl are gonna move
basically its like the car has sigma vision ποΈ - it sees everything but still has to make a W or L decision
Key Decision Points + Conditions used
The car goes through these checks (like an if statement basically):
Conditions (the actual rules coded in):
1. Is the crash actually unavoidable?
2. Whats in each direction? (how many ppl)
β
Utilitarian = hit less people
β
Passenger safety = protect the driver
β
Kids/elderly = treated differently
3. Person or object? (the AI has to classify this)
β
< 80% sure? just brake
β Never go into oncoming lane
4. Whats the survival chance each way?
5. → pick the option that causes least harm
β οΈ basically its like: IF person detected AND crash unavoidable THEN choose path with lowest casualties
Ethical Risk of a Wrong Decision π
ok so if the car gets it wrong this is literally what happens:
Wrong Classification = L
Coded in Bias = biggest W or L
if the AI thinks a bin bag is a person it might swerve and
actually hit someone. sensor error = actual death π
whoever coded it decided whose life matters more. thats not a
tech decision thats a moral one. kinda sus ngl
Who gets blamed tho??
Pedestrians never consented bro
if someone dies - is it the driver? the company? the engineer??
the law literally has no answer for this rn
random person walking has no idea a car algorithm might
decide to sacrifice them. that is genuinely wild fr fr
basically every option is an L. theres no right answer and thats the whole point of the trolley problem πΏ
Conclusion - who decides?? π€
3 main groups that should be deciding this but all of them are kinda failing:
Engineers π¨π»
Role: they write the actual if/else code
Government ποΈ
Role: supposed to make laws about who gets sued
β οΈ problem: they're just putting their own morals into the code without
asking anyone
β οΈ problem: they're moving mad slow and the cars are already on the
roads
Society (us) οΈ
Role: we should probably have a say in this
β οΈ problem: most people dont even know this is happening rn π
π Key Takeaway: the trolley problem isnt just philosophy anymore - its literally being coded rn and nobody's really in charge of making sure its
ethical. kinda scary ngl