Psychology 379
Youn Offenders
Kevin S. Douglas, LL.B., PhD.
Rates of correctional involvement declining
Average daily counts
› ~ 6,000 youth in correctional services
› ~ 90% under community supervision
› ~ 700 youth incarcerated
› ~ 75% non-violent
› ~ 35% decrease since 2013-2014
Annual totals
› ~ 17,000 youths sanctioned
› ~ 1300 incarcerated
5
60% 16-17 years old
75% male
40% Indigenous
6
Very few (10%) receive youth custody
› Most (90%) custody sentences short (< 6 mo)
Majority (60%) receive extra-judicial
sanctions (warnings; community service)
Many receive probation (30%)
7
Youth 12-17
Purposes
Extrajudicial measures
Increased sentencing options
Psychological reports
Sentencing
8
Affirms that “youth are different”
UN Convention on Rights of the Child
“Step-Ladder” approach to consequences
› Must rule out that a lesser sanction cannot meet the goals of
the YCJA, in order to impose a stricter sanction
9
Cases Completed in Youth Court
Important!
Assessment
Treatment and management
(Mediation / reparation)
16
Results of interviews
Any applicable information, including…
› Age, maturity, character, behaviour, attitude
› Willingness to make amends
› Plans to improve self
› Services, and willingness to comply
› Relationship with parents and extended family
› School and employment
Risk and treatment based
17
◦ Peer influences
◦ Risk taking
◦ Temporal perspectives
◦ Reactions to stress
} Legal policy should reflect these differences
} “the complexity and sophistication of the
process of individual decision-making as it is
affected by a range of cognitive, emotional,
and social factors” (Cauffman & Steinberg, 2000)
Responsibility
• Capacity to make
autonomous
choices
independent from
external influences
(peers/adults)
• Become less
responsive to peer
influences with age
• Development of a
coherent sense of
identity
Temperance
Perspective
• Ability to control
impulses & selfrestraint
• Adolescents > risk
takers, sensation
seeking, impulsivity &
> susceptible to mood
changes (hormones)
• Development of
regulatory competence
develops later in
adolescence
• Time perspective:
ability to see short& long-term
consequences
• Perspective taking:
ability to understand
how actions affect
others
• Ability to weigh
costs & benefits of
decisions
• Teens value
potential gains over
potential losses &
short-term vs. longterm goals
Steinberg & Cauffman, 2000
The brain's center of reasoning
and problem solving (frontal lobes)
is among the last to mature.
National Institute of Mental Health
and UCLA Study
v Sample: 4 – 21 years old
v MRI of normal brain development
v "higher-order" brain centers do not
fully develop until young
adulthood.
v Last areas of the brain to develop:
frontal lobes (specifically the prefrontal cortex) which govern
decision-making, judgment, and
impulse control (executive
functioning).
Moffitt’s Taxonomy
› Adolescent-limited
› Life-course persistent
Cumulative risk vs developmental pathways
22
Peers
Parents
Impulsivity
Emotional maturity
Personality
Education
24
What are they?
Main effects model
Interaction model
25
Risk assessment scheme which includes
24 risk items (rated low, moderate, high)
› Historical
› Social and contextual
› Individual/clinical
Also includes 6 “protective factors”
› Rated present or absent
An SPJ measure
26
Historical Factors
History of violence
History of
nonviolent
offending
Early initiation of
violence
Past supervision/
intervention failures
History of self-harm
or suicide attempts
¢ Exposure to violence
in the home
¢ Childhood
maltreatment
¢ Parental/caregiver
criminality
¢ Early caregiver
disruption
¢ Poor school
achievement
27
Social/Contextual Risk Factors
Peer delinquency
Peer rejection
Stress and poor coping
Poor parental management
Community disorganization
28
Individual/Clinical Risk Factors
Negative attitudes
Risk taking/impulsivity
Substance use difficulties
Anger management problems
Low empathy/remorse
Attention deficit/hyperactivity difficulties
Poor compliance
Low interest/commitment to school
29
Protective Factors
Prosocial involvement
Strong social support
Strong attachments and bonds
Positive attitude toward intervention and
authority
Resilient personality traits
30
1. Treatment context: The State has an obligation to
provide mental health services to youth in need.
2. Adjudicative context: Fairness, particularly for waiver of
rights, competence to stand trial, and mitigation in the
adjudication of alleged offenses.
3. Public safety: Understanding the relationship between
mental disorders and aggressive behavior. Risk
assessment and risk management. Relevant to sentencing.
Ø Rate of mental disorders is higher among
youth in juvenile system than peers in general
population.
Ø Suicide threats and actual suicide attempts are
not uncommon.
Ø Non-Suicide Self Injury (NSSI) high, especially
among girls.
Ø Many juvenile offenders have experienced
physical & sexual abuse, parental neglect.
Much of our research on assessment and interventions
have focused on boys.
v Girls’ rates of aggression still lower than boys, but increasing
v Girls also more likely to be held in detention than in past
v Girls are more likely than boys to have:
v Women who were physically or sexually abused as children
are far more likely to enter into abusive relationships as
adults
Ø
Many programs are effective in helping children and
youth and reducing delinquent behavior.
Ø
It is never too early but also never too late to
intervene.
Ø
Interventions should:
Ø
Ø
Ø
Ø
start as early as possible
be comprehensive and long-term
attempt to interrupt developmental pathways before
serious, chronic delinquency emerges.
Interventions should:
Ø
focus on family, school, peer, and neighborhood factors,
not just the individual alone.
Ø Primary prevention interventions take place before a problem
is developed and are directed at a population in general rather
than specific individuals.
Ø Secondary prevention programs are directed at specific
groups, but the intervention takes place early before
significant problems have developed.
Ø Tertiary prevention takes place long after problems have
developed, and are usually quite costly as they often involve
institutional care and intensive case management. Also,
serious criminal behavior, including violence, has already
occurred.
Seriously Delinquent Youth
v Intensive Support and Supervision
Program (ISSP, in YCJA): BC program
offered to high-risk youth as a communitybased alternative to custody and to help youth
transition from custody to the community. Aim
is to reduce recidivism by increasing
supervision and supporting activities to reduce
participants’ criminogenic needs.
v Multisystemic Therapy. Targets multiple levels
including youth, family, peers, school.
Youth in program have
› Reduced reoffending by 26-69%
› Decreased drug use
› Increased school attendance, etc.
Cost savings of $131,900/ youth (including
victim costs)
4 year randomized study of MST in 4 Ontario
communities
409 youth participated:
› half received MST
› half continued with the usual services in the local system
Results: 2 groups not distinguishable on any
outcome measure suggesting no treatment effect
Cunningham, A. (2002). One step forward: Lessons learned from a
randomized study of multisystemic therapy in Canada. London, ON:
Praxis.
v Same principles and findings as with adults
v Target criminogenic needs
v Higher doses for higher risk youth
v Techniques
v Identify maladaptive thoughts and behavior
v Anger management skills
v Role playing
v Reinforcement