SEPSIS PREVENTION IN APPENDICITIS MORRIS ET ALll THE PREVENTION OF POST-APPENDICECTOMYSEPSIS BY METRONIDAZOLEAND CEFAZOLIN: A CONTROLLED DOUBLE BLIND TRIAL' WILLIAMT. MORRIS',DAVID6. INN&, RALPHA. RICHARDSON3, ALAN J. LEE4 and RODERICK6. ELLIS-PEGLER5 Department of Surgery, University of Auckland A double blind, randomized, controlled trial was carried out at two hospitals to try the effect of metronidazole, which Is effective against most anaerobes, and cefazolin, which is effective against many aerobic organisms, singly and in combination, on the incidence of wound sepsis following appendlcectomy, Patients were placed at random Into one of four groups; to receive metronidazole and placebo, cefazolin and placebo, metronidazole and cefazolin, or double placebo. Patients with generalized peritonitis were excluded for ethical reasons. Treatment was started before operation and continued eight-hourly for twenty-four hours. All patients in the trial were followed up at about two weeks after discharge from hospital and their wounds inspected. Two hundred and seventy-one patients were assessed. Sepsis rates at the two hospitals were similar. On the untreated controls, 30% discharged pus from their wounds, and in the groups receiving one drug only, about 20%. In those receiving both drugs the infection rate was 3%, a highly significant difference from that In the other three groups. Wound sepsis occurs in up to 30% of patients after appendicectomy (Lancet, Editorial 1971). Willis et alii (1 976) reported an incidence of 19% in patients not given perioperative antibacterial drugs, Everson et alii (1 977) reported a 29% infection overall rate, Greenall et alii (1978) a rate of 69% in perforated a'ppendicitis, and Bird et alii (1971) a 27% infection rate after the removal of 33 normal appendices with an overall infection rate of 30%. Wound infection results in increased morbidity and perhaps mortality and is costly in terms of hospital facilities and loss of work by the patient. Sepsis is almost invariably due to enteric organisms which are presumably implanted in the wound at the time of operation. Both aerobic and anaerobic organisms may be isolated from septic complications, and some experimental work indicates that both may be needed to establish an I 1. Ph.D.. F.R C.S.. Senior Lecturer in Surgery, University of Auckland. 2, F R C.S.. F R.A.C.S., Surgical Tutor Specialist, Middlemore Hospital 3. M.Sc., Ph.D., Toxicologist. Auckland Hospital 4. Ph.D.. Lecturer in Mgthematics, University of Auckland 5. F.R.A.C.P.. Clinical Microbiologist, Auckland Hospital. 6. Supported by: (i)A grant and supplies of metronidazoie and placebo from May and Baker. New Zealand, Limited, and (ii) Supplies of cefazolin and placebo by Eli Lilly (N.Z.) and Co. Reprints. W. T. Morris, Department of Surgery, Auckland Hospital, Park Road, Auckland, New Zealand. AUST. N.Z. J. SURG.VOL. 50-NO. 4, AUGUST,1980 intraabdominal abscess (Onderdonk et alii, 1974). The need, however, to use drugs active against both groups in order to prevent sepsis is not certain. There have been many studies involving the prophylactic use of antibacterial agents given either systemically or into the wound at operation, over a wide range of surgical procedures. In this study we assessed the effect on post-appendicectomy wound sepsis of prophylactic antibacterial drugs given at the time of operation only. We selected metronidazole, effective against most anaerobes, and cefazolin, a cephalosporin effective against most aerobes likely to be encountered in this situation, and compared their effects both singly and in combination. Metronidazole is reliably absorbed when given in rectal suppositories, and cefazolin can be given intramuscularly, without much pain, or intravenously. As far as we are aware this particular comparison, using drugs with relatively well-defined spectra of activity, both singly and in combination, for a brief time only, has not been made before. PATIENTS AND METHODS The trial was conducted in two hospitals, Auckland and Middlemore, and all the surgical 429 teams supplied patients aged fourteen years and over. Patients with diabetes or receiving antibacterial or steroid therapy, or found to have peritonitis severe enough for the operating surgeon to consider that antibacterial therapy was necessary, were excluded. Patients known to be sensitive to cephalosporins were also excluded. All patients gave their informed consent, and the study was approved by the ethical committees of both participant hospitals. Materials Suppositories of metronidazole one gram and placebo were kindly supplied by May and Baker New Zealand Limited. Cefazolin 0.5 gm for intramuscular and intravenous injection and placebos were kindly supplied by Eli Lilly (N.Z.)and Company Limited. Randomization Drug packs each containing four suppositories and four injections were made up by May and Baker. Seventy of these contained metronidazole and the placebo injection, 70 contained cefazolin and a placebo suppository, 70 contained both active drugs, and 70 contained both placebos. The packs were labelled 1 to 280, using random numbers arranged so that each consecutive 1 2 packs contained three of each type of pack: in this way the numbers in each group of patients could be kept almost equal throughout the trial. The packs were used in numerical order. If a patient was removed from the trial after entry, the drug pack was replaced by an identical one and used at the next opportunity. Patien ts and Routine All eligible adult patients due to undergo emergency or elective appendicectomy were included. Treatment regimen. - Each patient was given a rectal suppository and an intravenous or intramuscular injection from the appropriate drug pack half an hour to two hours before operation. The time was noted on a data sheet together with the drug pack number, and the patient's name was written on the drug pack. The data sheet,and the drug pack then accompanied the patient to the operating theatre and finally to the ward. A further injection and suppository were given eight-hourly to a total of four doses. Data Recorded Preoperative data. - The length of history, temperature, leucocyte count and degree of illness, assessed as mild, moderate or severe, were recorded. Operative data. - The type of incision, the duration of operation, the body build, and the type AUST.N.Z. J. SURG.VOL. 50-NO. 4 , AUGUST. 1980 MORRIS ET ALll TAELE1 Scoring System for Degree of Appendicular Inflammation Found at operation Score 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Operative Findings Normal Appendix Mild inflammation Inflammation with oedema Gangrene without perforation Abscess Perforation with free pus and position of a drain if used, were recorded. A blood sample was taken by the anaesthetist during the operation to estimate blood drug levels. The pathology found was recorded and given a score (Table 1). Postoperative data. - Each day during hospitalization the wound was inspected and signs of sepsis recorded. The presence of pus in the wound was the criterion of sepsis, but stitch abscess alone was classified as no sepsis. All but two of the patients were followed up at about two weeks after their discharge from hospital. The two not followed up were foreign seamen who had left the country, and these were excluded from analysis of the results. At follow-up the wounds were inspected and the patients questioned about any wound discharge. If there was any suspicion that a wound infection might be developing, the patient was brought back a week later for further assessment. Pharmacology. - Blood samples were taken during operation, and rnetronidazole levels were estimated quantitatively by gas-liquid chromatography using a modification of the method of Wood (1 975). Cefazolin levels were assayed by measuring inhibition zones produced in cultures of B. subtilis on agar plates. Analysis of results. - Generalized linear models (GLIM) (Nelder and Wedderburn, 1975) were fitted to the data where appropriate and significance tests were performed on the various hypotheses of interest. RESULTS A total of 271 consecutive patients was assessed, 107 from Middlemore and 164 from Auckland Hospitals. A further 69 were withdrawn, 15 because antibacterial preparations were given before operation, and 23 because of peritonitis found at operation. Twelve were found at operation to have a condition other than appendicitis, and 14 received antibacterial drugs for reasons unrelated to wound infection. One patient developed a rash after receiving metronidazole, and two foreign seamen were lost to follow-up and were also excluded. Two were excluded because of deviation from the 430 14452197a, 1980, 4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1445-2197.1980.tb04158.x by Sara Tarek Zaki - Egyptian National Sti. Network (Enstinet) , Wiley Online Library on [27/08/2026]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License SEPSIS PREVENTION IN APPENDICITIS MORRIS ET ALll protocol. There were 24 withdrawals from the double placebo group, 13 from the cefazolin only group, 18 from the metronidazole only group and 14 from the metronidazole/cefazolin group. All but seven patients were replaced in the trial by replacing their drugs packs with identical ones which were used at the next opportunity. Seven were not replaced because the fact that they had received additional antibacterial treatment was not realized until the case notes were scrutinized after the trial was finished. There was no statistical difference in sex, age, or severity of appendicular infection between the groups. Sepsis Rates The sepsis rates in the groups at each hospital were not different. The similarity was tested by fitting a binomial-logit model to the infection rates with hospitals and drugs as explanatory variables = 1.472, P ) 0.05). (x’ TABLE2 significantly higher than in the other groups (P ( 0.007). In only two patients was there sepsis more severe than wound infection. One patient in the metronidazole/cefazolin group was readmitted to hospital fourteen days after operation with presumed pelvic sepsis. This rapidly settled without surgical or antibacterial therapy. The other was in the double placebo group, and was readmitted five days after appendicectomy with an inflammatory pelvic mass. This also resolved without surgical treatment, but on discharge from hospital he was given a week‘s treatment with amoxycillin. Wound infection rate related to operative findings. - The wound infection rate was directly related .to the degree of inflammation found at operation = 36.96, P ( 0.005) (Table 4). (x’ TABLE4 Number lnfected in the Different Treatment Groups according to Degree of Appendicular lnflammafion. (Total Numbers in Each Category in Brackets). See also Table I . Overall Sepsis Rates in the Differenf Treatment Groups + + + + Placebo Placebo Cefazolin Placebo Metronidazole Placebo Cefazolin Metronidazole ~~ Total Sepsis No. (%) 66 71 67 67 20 (30.3) 14 (19 7) 14 (20.9) 2 (3) ~~ ~~ ~ The sepsis rate (Table 2) in the controls was over 30%, and in the patients receiving one drug only, about 20%. In those receiving both drugs, however, only two out of 67 showed any sign of sepsis. The difference between this group and the other three was highly significant (P (0.001 in each case). There was no significant difference between the control group and either the cefazolin only group (P ( 0.04) or the metronidazole only group (P ( 0.05). In some patients, wound infections only became apparent after their discharge from hospital (Table 3). In about 50% of patients with postoperative sepsis, in each group except the metronidazole only group, sepsis was only apparent after discharge from hospital. In the metronidazole only group, 12 out of 14 infections (84%) became apparent only after discharge from hospital, an incidence Operative Findings Drugs 3 4 2 1 + + + + Length of hospital stay. - The mean length of hospital stay was 4.1 days for those without sepsis, 10.7 days for those with sepsis in hospital (P ( O.OOl), and 4.6 days for those who developed sepsis after discharge (P ) 0.9). Influence of operative drainage on sepsis. - The results were analysed, taking into account the operative findings and drug regimens (Table 5). Drainage through the wound significantly increased the incidence of wound sepsis (P ( 0.005). Five uninfected patients and one infected patient had drains through separate stabs. Other data related to outcome. - There was no discernible relationship between wound sepsis and TABLE5 Classification of Operative Findings lncidence of Sepsis Appearing Only after Discharge from Hospital Total with Sepsis + + + + 5 Placebo Placebo 2(2) l(1) 2(2) 6(35) 2(9) 7(17) Cefazolin Placebo 2(2) l(1) 5(8) 5(38) O(4) l(17) Metronidazole Placebo l(2) O(1) 5(7) 4(37) 3(6) l(14) Cefazolin rnetronidazole O(0) O(0) 016) 2(35) 0(9) O(l7) TOTAL 5(6) 2(3) 12(23) 17(145) 5(28) 9(66) 83% 66% 52% 12% % 18% 14% TABLE3 Placebo Placebo Cefazolin Placebo Metronidazole Placebo Cefazohn Metronidazole 6 No. (%)with Delayed Sepsis 20 14 14 2 AUST. N.Z. J. SURG.VOL. 50-NO. 4, AUGUST,1980 Number of lnfected Wounds Tabulated according to the Degree of Appendicular Disease and ihe Presence or Absence of a Draiq. (Total Number of Patients in each Calegory in Brackets). Drain Nodrain 6 5 4(4) l(2) 2(2) 0(1) 4 3 2 1 TOTAL 5(7) 6(16) l(4) O(2) 18(35) 7116) ll(129) 4(24) 9(64) 32 (136) 431 14452197a, 1980, 4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1445-2197.1980.tb04158.x by Sara Tarek Zaki - Egyptian National Sti. Network (Enstinet) , Wiley Online Library on [27/08/2026]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License SEPSIS PREVENTION IN APPENDICITIS age, body build, sex, temperature on admission, leucocyte count or length of history, but there were weak positive correlations with the degree of illness and length of operation (P ( 0.025 for both). Drug levels. - Drug estimations on blood samples taken at operation showed measurable metronidazole levels in all patients who had received the drug. Five patients receiving cefazolin did not have measurable drug levels (viz., ( 2.5 m g / l ) . This must have represented slow absorption or late administration, and because these patients were known to have received the drug, they were not excluded from the study. Six patients not receiving cefazolin and found to have inexplicable antibacterial activity in the cefazolin assay were withdrawn, being included in the group who had been given antibiotics before surgery. The operative drug levels are shown in Table 6. There was no simple relationship demonstrated between mean drug levels and the likelihood of subsequent wound sepsis. The metronidazole levels were low, and this probably represents slow absorption from the rectum. Adverse reactions. - One patient developed a maculopapular rash while receiving metronidazole. Treatment was stopped and the patient was withdrawn from the trial. One receiving cefazolin developed a mild macular rash. This was sucessfully reversed with chlorpheniramine maleate and treatment continued. Both reactions were mild. DISCUSSION The incidence of wound infection in the placebo group is higher than the generally accepted rate of sepsis after appendicectomy. Many of the figures reported, however, are based on observations made only while the patients have been in hospital, thus giving a falsely low overall figure (Public Health Laboratory Service, 1960; Cole and Bernard, 1961 ; Wright, 1963; Williams and Hale, 1965; Stoller, 1965; Brickman and Leon, 1966; Mittelpunkt and Nora, 1966; Kingsley, 1969; Mountain and Seal, 1970; Kazarian et alii, 1970; Brumer, 1970; Longland et alii, 1971 ; Bates et alii, 1974; Lewis et alii, 1975). In our series about half the wound infections were not apparent until after the patients had left hospital. It is likely that the rate would have been even higher had not many patients with the severest degrees of appendicitis been excluded from the trial for ethical reasons. The main factors influencing wound sepsis were, in order of importance, the drug regimen, the degree of inflammation of the appendix, and the presence of a drain through the wound. The combination of metronidazole and cefazolin produced a dramatic 432 reduction in wound sepsis, while each drug given separately produced only a moderate reduction. Metronidazole given alone was as effective as cefazolin given alone, but in the metronidazole only group, most infections only became apparent after the patients had left hospital. If the in-hospital sepsis rates only had been compared, metronidazole alone would have appeared to be as effective as the combined therapy. This emphasizes the importance of outpatient follow-up in trials of this sort when patients may only be in hospital for a short time. There was an incidence of infection following the removal even of normal appendices, but the incidence was much higher when the appendix was gangrenous or perforated, thus confirming the observations of Gilmore et alii (1 973). Preoperative measurements such as temperature level and leucocyte count are cf no use in predicting postoperative sepsis. The only factor of some value is the degree of illness, and the association was not very strong. It would be desirable to limit the administration of prophylactic antibacterial preparations to patients at high risk of sepsis, but the sepsis risk is not known until the appendix is seen at operation. The question is, therefore, should all patients be given antibacterial prophylaxis, or would the drugs if given at the time of operation when the state of the appendix is apparent work just as well? It is likely that the answer to the question would be “yes”, for experimental work by Burke (1 961) in animals showed that antibiotics‘ given at the time of incision are hardly less effective than when given one hour before. If this were so in man it would simplify the decision of the surgeon, for he could then give prophylactic drugs to patients at high risk only. The fact that a drain through the wound increased the incidence of wound infection is not surprising. Gilmore et alii (1 973) noted this effect also, and the presence of a foreign body in a potentially infected field is ever likely to increase the risk of sepsis. The incidence of wound sepsis was directly related to the length of operation. Two factors are likely to lengthen the procedure - the degree of difficulty of the operation and inexperience on the part of the surgeon. Either of these factors might be expected to increase the risk of sepsis. Two conclusions of economic importance can be drawn from these results. The first is that prevention of wound infection reduces the length of hospital stay following appendicectomy, and in this respect a combination of metronidazole and cefazolin is very effective. The second is that in this respect metronidazole alone is almost as effective, for only two patients treated with metronidazole alone AUST. N.Z. J. SURG.VOL. 50-NO. 4 , AUGUST, 1980 14452197a, 1980, 4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1445-2197.1980.tb04158.x by Sara Tarek Zaki - Egyptian National Sti. Network (Enstinet) , Wiley Online Library on [27/08/2026]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License MORRIS ET ALll SEPSIS PREVENTION IN APPENDICITIS showed sepsis in hospital, and the patients whose sepsis appeared after discharge were in hospital for no longer than those who had no sepsis at all. There is evidence that agents with activity against aerobes alone or anaerobes alone may affect mixed infections (Gorbach and Bartlett, 1974; Sharp et alii, 1977), and indeed our study provides some support for this. However, we have shown that, used in the brief perioperative period only, an antibacterial regimen which includes both activities is dramatically more effective than either alone, a result which one would intuitively expect. Metronidazole has been shown by lngham eta//; (1 977) to enhance the neutrophil phagocytosis of facultative organisms in mixed infections. Onderdonk et alii (1 979) have shown that the drug has in vivo activity against aerobic organisms provided that a metronidazolesusceptible anaerobe is present. It may be that it requires a more prolonged administration than we used for either of these experimental observations to reach clinical relevance. This might explain the dramatic efficacy of seven days of metronidazole alone (Willis etalii, 1976), which was not equalled by the short course of drugs used in this study. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors are grateful to the general surgeons of Middlemore and Auckland Hospitals who allowed their patients to be studied, to the registrars who did the operations, the nurses of both hospitals who administered the drugs, the staff of the microbiology and chemical pathology laboratories of both hospitals for the laboratory investigations, and to Eli Lilly (N.Z.) and Co. and May Baker New Zealand Ltd for financial support. AUST.N.Z. J. SURG.VOL. 50-NO. 4, AUGUST,1980 MORRIS ET ALll REFERENCES BATES. T., DOWN,R M L.. HOUGHTON, M. C. V. and LLOYD,G. J. (1 974), Brit. 3. Surg., 61 :489. 61 D, G. G., BUNCH,G. A., CROFT,C B., HOFFMAN, D. C., HUMPHREY, RHIND, J. R., ROSENBERG, I. L., WHITTAKER, M., c. WILKINSON, A. R. and HALL,R. (1971), Brit. J. Surg., 58:447. I. D. and LEON,W. (1966), Surgery, 60:1083. BRICKMAN, BRUMER, M. (1970). Brit. J. Surg., 57:93. BURKE, J. F. (1961), Surgery, 50:161. COLE,W. R. and BERNARD. H. R. (1961). Amer. Surg., 27:29. EVERSON. N. W.. FOSSARD. D. P.. NASH.J. R. and MACDONALD, R. C, (1 977).'Brit. J. Surg., 64:236: B. N. (1973). GILMORE.0. J. A.. MARTIN,T. D. M. and FLETCHER, Lancet. 1:220. GORBACH.S. L. and BARTLETT, J. G. (1974). New EngI. J. Med., 290:1289. A. V. (1978), Brit. J. Surg., GREENALL, M. J., EVANS, M. and POLLOCK, 65:880. INGHAM, H.R., SlSsON, P. R., THARAGONNET, D., SELKON,J. 6 . and CODD,A. A. (1977), Lancet, 2:1252. W. J. and MERSHEIMER, W. L. (1 970), Amer. KAZARIAN, K. K., ROEDER, J. Surg., 119:681. KINGSLEY. P. E. (1969), Brit. J. Surg., 56:491 LANcEr, Editorial (1971), 2:195. LEWIS.F. R.. HOLCROFT. J. W.. BOEY.J. and DUNPHYJ. E. (1975). Arch. Surg., 1103677: LONGLAND, C. J.. GRAY,J. G.. LEES,W. andGARRETT, J. A.M. (1971), Brit. J. Surg., 58:l 17. MITTELPUNKT, A. and NORA,P. F. (1966), Surgery, 60:971 MOUNTAIN, J. C. and SEAL,P. V. (1 970), Brit. J. din. Prac., 2 4 : l l l . NELDER.J. A and WEDDEREURN, R. W. M. (1975). . . J. Toy. Stat. SOC. A., 135:370. ONDERDONK, A. B., LOUIE,T. J., TALLEY.F. P. and BARTLETT. J. G. (1 979), J. Antimicrob. Chem.. 5:201 ONDERDONK, A. B.,WEINSTEIN, W. M I SULLIVAN,N. M., BARTLETT, J. G. and GORBACH. S. L. (1 974), Infect. lmmun.. 10:1256. PUBLIC HEALTH LABORATORY SERVICE (1 960), Lancet, 2.659. SHARP, D J., CORRINGHAM. R. E. T., NYE, E. 6. et alii (1977). J. Antimicrob. Chem.. 3:233. STOLLER, J. L. (1965). Brit. J. d i n . Prac.. 19:687. WILLIAMS, J. S. and HALE,H. W. (1965), Ann. Surg., 162:208. WILLIS. A. T.. FERGUSON. I. R . . JONES,P. H..PHILLIPS,K. D.. TEARLE. P V., BERRY,R. 6.. FIDDIAN,R . V., GRAHAM, D. T.,HARLAND, D. H. C., INNES, D. B., MEE.W. M., ROTHWELLJACKSON, R. L., SUTCH,I., KILBEY,C. AND EDWARDS D. (1 976), Brit. Med. J., s., ~I I.?lR WOOD, N:F.-(l975), J. pharm. Sci., 63:1048 WRIGHT,R. 6 . (1963). Lancet, 2:475. 433 14452197a, 1980, 4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1445-2197.1980.tb04158.x by Sara Tarek Zaki - Egyptian National Sti. Network (Enstinet) , Wiley Online Library on [27/08/2026]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License SEPSIS PREVENTION IN APPENDICITIS
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )