Ratna Sahay, Vivek Arora, Thanos Arvanitis, Hamid Faruqee, Papa N'Diaye, Tommaso Mancini-Griffoli, and an IMF Team SDN/14/09 EMERGING MARKET VOLATILITY: LESSONS FROM THE TAPER TANTRUM September 2014 IMF ST A FF D ISC U SSIO N N O T E IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND Monetary and Capital Markets Department, Research Department, Strategy and Policy Review Department Prepared by Ratna Sahay, Vivek Arora, Thanos Arvanitis, Hamid Faruqee, Papa N'Diaye, Tommaso Mancini-Griffoli, and an IMF Team1 Authorized for distribution by Ratna Sahay and Vivek Arora DISCLAIMER: This Staff Discussion Note represents the views of the authors and does not necessarily represent IMF views or IMF policy. The views expressed herein should be attributed to the authors and not to the IMF, its Executive Board, or its management. Staff Discussion Notes are published to elicit comments and to further debate. JEL Classification Numbers: E40, E44, E61, E62, G12 Keywords: Tapering, unconventional monetary policy, volatility, macroprudential, capital flow measures, foreign exchange intervention Authors’ E-mail Addresses: rsahay@imf.org; varora@imf.org; aavanitis@imf.org; hfaruqee@imf.org; pndiaye@imf.org; tmancini@imf.org 1 The IMF team includes Ran Bi, Jiaqian Chen, Prachi Mishra, Kenji Moriyama, Lam Nguyen, Silvia Sgherri, Preya Sharma, Esteban Vesperoni, Sebatian Weber, and Gao Yuan. The authors thank the members of the IMF Executive Board for their invaluable input at an informal Board briefing, as well as participants at various IMF seminars for useful comments. The authors also thank Grace Angeles and Gillian Adu for their excellent assistance. 2 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ___________________________________________________________________________ 4 INTRODUCTION __________________________________________________________________________________ 5 FALLOUT FROM UNCONVENTIONAL MONETARY POLICIES IN ADVANCED ECONOMIES ___ 6 A. Capital Flows into Emerging Markets ______________________________________________________ 6 B. Policies in the Run-up to the May 2013 Taper Talk ______________________________________ 12 MARKETS' REACTION TO TAPER TALK, MID-2013 ___________________________________________ 16 A. Anticipated Turmoil in Financial Markets ________________________________________________ 16 B. Emerging Market Policy Responses and Their Effectiveness _____________________________ 22 LESSONS GOING FORWARD ___________________________________________________________________ 24 REFERENCES_____________________________________________________________________________________ 28 FIGURES 1. Unconventional Monetary Policies in Advanced Economies_____________________________________ 7 2. Changing Composition of Gross Capital Flows __________________________________________________ 7 3. Cumulative Net Capital Flows to Emerging Markets _____________________________________________ 8 4. Factors Driving Capital Flows ____________________________________________________________________ 9 5. Top Emerging Market Recipients of Capital Flows_______________________________________________ 9 6. Capital Flows into Emerging Markets __________________________________________________________ 11 7. Surges in Bond Flows __________________________________________________________________________ 11 8. Inflows and Financial Conditions ______________________________________________________________ 12 9. Reserves Accumulation and Capital Inflows ___________________________________________________ 13 10. Fiscal Position in Selected Emerging Markets ________________________________________________ 13 11. External Sector Developments _______________________________________________________________ 14 12. Financial Conditions __________________________________________________________________________ 15 13. Synchronized Emerging Market Slowdown __________________________________________________ 16 14. Growth Forecasts in Emerging Markets ______________________________________________________ 16 15. 10-year Treasury and Short-term Rates ______________________________________________________ 16 16. Variation of Asset Price Responses Across Countries Following May–June 2013 Monetary Policy Shocks ______________________________________________________________________________ 18 17. Effect of U.S. Monetary Policy Announcements ______________________________________________ 19 18. Effect on Bond Yields _________________________________________________________________________ 20 19. Role of Fundamentals in Explaining Differentiated Markets’ Reactions ______________________ 21 20. Changing Role of Fundamentals Over Time and Across Countries ___________________________ 21 21. Policy Tools Deployed by Emerging Markets_________________________________________________ 22 22. Effect of Policy Announcements______________________________________________________________ 23 23. Effectiveness of Foreign Exchange Intervention ______________________________________________ 24 24. Implied Volatility _____________________________________________________________________________ 25 25. Pay-offs from Policy Action __________________________________________________________________ 26 26. Effectiveness of Federal Reserve Communication ____________________________________________ 27 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 3 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY A surge in volatility overtook global financial markets in the summer of 2013 following the markets’ reassessment of the prospects that the U.S. Federal Reserve would wind down its bond-buying program and tighten monetary policy. The brunt was felt acutely by emerging markets (EMs). While changes in advanced-country monetary policy, or even signals of such changes, can reverberate in the rest of the world, the strength of the markets’ reaction took most by surprise. Asset prices and currencies tumbled, and questions about the growth prospects of EMs continued to intensify amidst heightened uncertainty. The shift in market sentiment vis-à-vis EMs came on the heels of a prolonged period of monetary easing in advanced economies, which was essential for preventing an even worse outcome at the start of the global financial crisis (IMF 2013a), and during which emerging economies experienced large inflows of foreign capital. During 2009–12, EMs received close to half of global flows, and while inflows were concentrated in eight to 10 large EMs, several small EMs also attracted large volumes relative to their size. In several cases, the inflows were accompanied by a rapid expansion of credit, fueling an overheating of domestic economies and setting the conditions for a buildup of vulnerabilities. This challenged policymaking, with some EMs raising concerns about the unwelcome side effects of monetary policy in advanced countries. Indeed, a substantial part of the flows could not be explained by EMs’ economic fundamentals. The reactions of markets during the summer of 2013 following talks by the Fed about prospects for gradually unwinding its unconventional monetary policy were unusual both in terms of the size and breadth of the outflows, although the magnitude of adjustment varied significantly across countries. Why did markets react the way they did and what are the policy lessons from this episode? This paper tries to synthesize recent research on this issue. The key findings of this Staff Discussion Note are as follows: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) 4 The Fed’s monetary policy announcements were strongly correlated with movements in asset prices and capital inflows in EMs, with the effects being largest during the phase of unconventional monetary policy (post-2008) and when tapering was first discussed (summer of 2013); During initial periods of acute and systemic market volatility, asset prices and capital flows were hit indiscriminately across countries, but over time there was greater differentiation among EMs; Good macroeconomic fundamentals helped dampen market reactions to U.S. monetary policy shocks. In particular, elevated current account deficits, high inflation, weak growth prospects, and relatively low reserves were important factors affecting market reaction. Where vulnerabilities existed, emerging markets that acted early and decisively generally fared better; Clear and effective communication by advanced-economy central banks concerning exit from unconventional monetary support is important to reduce the risk of excessive market volatility; and The international community has an important role to play to safeguard global financial stability. This includes determined efforts by all countries to cooperate with regional financial arrangements, enhance cross-border cooperation between central banks and regulators, and establish stronger global financial safety net, including through adequate Fund resources. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE INTRODUCTION In May 2013, financial shock waves hit many emerging markets (EMs). The shock waves came on the heels of testimony to Congress by the chairman of the U.S. Federal Reserve (henceforth “the Fed”) that raised the possibility of the Fed tapering its purchase of treasury and agency bonds. This signal followed several years of U.S. monetary easing prior to the global financial crisis, and unconventional monetary policies (UMP) in the United States and other advanced economies (AEs) after the crisis. During this period, EMs generally experienced capital inflows. However, starting in May 2013 and through early 2014 there was a marked rise in financial market volatility, with sharp corrections in EM asset prices and exchange rates, and a reversal in capital flows. Amid significant concerns about a shifting external environment and slowing domestic economic activity in EMs, experiences and policy responses in EM countries varied. This paper examines the impact of the Fed’s policy announcements on asset prices and capital flows into and out of EMs, with a view to explaining the different reactions across countries by looking at domestic and external factors, and to drawing broad policy lessons. Key findings of this study are that (i) the Fed’s monetary policy announcements were correlated with movements in asset prices and capital inflows in EMs; (ii) the effects were greatest during the UMP phase (post-2008) and especially during the period when tapering was first discussed (summer of 2013); (iii) during initial periods of acute and systemic market volatility, asset prices and capital flows were hit more indiscriminately across countries, but over time there was greater differentiation among EMs; (iv) good macroeconomic fundamentals in EMs matter and helped dampen market reactions to U.S. monetary policy shocks; (v) where vulnerabilities existed, emerging markets that acted early and decisively generally fared better; (vi) clear and effective communication by AE central banks concerning exit from unconventional monetary support is important to reduce the risk of excessive market volatility; and (vii) enhanced global cooperation, including a strong global financial safety net, may offer EMs effective protection against market volatility as the global economy transitions away from large-scale liquidity support. This Staff Discussion Note is structured as follows: Section II recounts the developments in EMs prior to the taper talk in May 2013; Section III discusses markets’ reaction during the taper talk and EMs’ policy responses; and Section IV concludes with key lessons going forward. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 5 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE FALLOUT FROM UNCONVENTIONAL MONETARY POLICIES IN ADVANCED ECONOMIES A. Capital Flows into Emerging Markets In the aftermath of the 2008 global financial crisis, unprecedented actions were taken by central banks and governments to support financial and economic activity. Against the risk of severe recession and disruption in financial systems, AE central banks sharply cut policy interest rates down to or near zero. In addition, several central banks, particularly in the United States, United Kingdom, Japan, and the euro area, implemented unconventional monetary policy measures to restore the functioning of financial markets and provide further stimulus at the zero lower bound (Figure 1). This intervention first focused on restoring intermediation and the normal functioning of markets through various liquidity provision measures, and then on asset purchases to reduce long-term yields and rekindle aggregate demand. Quantitative easing (QE) by the United States was one of the largest such programs, resulting in an approximate 750 percent increase in the size of the Fed balance sheet.2 While the impact of QE on stabilizing global economic and financial conditions is beyond the scope of this paper and has been examined elsewhere, recent analysis suggests that it contributed to significant capital flows to EMs, especially to Latin America and Asia (IMF, 2013a). In fact, starting in 2010, there was a marked shift in the flow of capital to EMs, driven by accommodative monetary policy in AEs, a global search for yield, and stronger growth prospects in EMs. During 2010–13, EMs received close to half of all global flows, while capital flows to AEs, particularly to the euro area, declined substantially (Figure 2). This reorientation of flows was most pronounced in Latin America and emerging Asia. In contrast, emerging Europe received substantially fewer flows, as most countries went through a period of deleveraging to reduce high debt built up in the precrisis years. Portfolio flows, particularly debt, played an increasingly important role in capital flows to EMs (Figure 3). In the precrisis period, foreign direct investment (FDI) was the predominant type of inflow into EMs, with portfolio and other flows being relatively modest. Following the global financial crisis, portfolio flows grew to one in every four dollars entering EMs. Excluding China, which is open mainly to FDI flows, the trend is even more pronounced. In contrast, “other flows” (notably trade credits and bank loans) declined in most regions, reflecting cross-border bank deleveraging. This evidence is consistent with recent literature on the role of UMP in changes in the composition of flows towards portfolio flows (Ahmed and Zlate, 2013). 2 This expansion in the Fed balance sheet occurred in three successive stages: QE1 started in late November 2008 when the Fed decided to buy $600 billion in mortgage-backed securities (MBS); QE2 began in November 2010 with the Fed buying $600 billion of treasury securities; and QE3 began in mid-September 2012 with the Fed buying on a monthly basis $40 billion worth of MBS and $85 billion of treasury and agency bonds starting in December 2012. 6 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE The changing composition of flows to EMs was accompanied by a shift toward local currency sovereign and corporate bond markets. Foreign holdings of local currency sovereign debt and nonfinancial corporate bond financing rose markedly. In particular, EM corporate bond issuance reached US$630 billion in 2013, or about 2½ percent of EM GDP, compared with only US$13 billion in early 2000. At the same time, the share of EM debt issued in local currency expanded from close to zero in 2000 to more than half the total by 2013. Figure 1. Unconventional Monetary Policies in Advanced Economies Rock-bottom interest rates… …with an unprecedented expansion in central banks’ balance sheets Central Bank Balance Sheet Assets Policy Interest Rates (percent of GDP; Jan. 2007-Dec. 13) (in percent) 50 6 Lehman event UK APF 1 Fed LSAP 2 Fed LSAP 1 45 35 4 BOJ QQME EA LTRO 30 US Japan Euro UK 3 Fed LSAP 3 UK APF 2 40 5 Fed MEP 25 20 2 15 10 1 5 0 2007 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Source: IMF staff estimates. Figure 2. Changing Composition of Gross Capital Flows Emerging markets received close to half of global inflows after the crisis compared with less than 20 percent before… Composition of Global Capital Flows (Share of total flows) Pre-crisis Post-crisis 2010-2013 Source: IFS Composition of global capital flows (Share of EM flows, in percent) AM 2002-2008 …with Latin America and emerging Asia receiving larger shares. EM 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Pre-crisis 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 China E.Asia Post-crisis E.Europe L.America Other EM Source: IFS INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 7 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Figure 3. Cumulative Net Capital Flows to Emerging Markets (Billions of U.S. dollars) FDI continues to dominate inflows to EMs, but… ..within portfolio flows there has been a marked shift towards portfolio debt flows Emerging Markets 3500 3000 2500 2000 Emerging Markets Debt and Equity Flows 700 Net FDI inflows 600 Net Equity Portfolio inflows Net Portfolio inflows 500 Net Debt Portfolio inflows Net Other inflows 400 300 1500 200 1000 100 0 500 -100 0 -500 2002Q1 2003Q3 2005Q1 2006Q3 2008Q1 2009Q3 2011Q1 2012Q3 Postcrisis, China continues to attract FDI flows, but… Emerging Asia, including China 1000 Net FDI inflows 800 Net Portfolio inflows Net Other inflows -200 2002Q1 2003Q3 2005Q1 2006Q3 2008Q1 2009Q3 2011Q1 2012Q3 ...the rest of emerging Asia receives net portfolio flows. Emerging Asia, excluding China 200 Net FDI inflows 600 Net Portfolio inflows Net Other inflows 150 100 400 50 200 0 0 -200 -50 2009q1 2009q4 2010q3 2011q2 2012q1 2012q4 In Latin America, portfolio flows have been as large as FDI… 600 Latin America Net FDI inflows Net Portfolio inflows Net Other inflows 400 2009q4 2010q3 2011q2 2012q1 2012q4 …while they have outpaced FDI in emerging Europe. 300 Emerging Europe Net FDI inflows Net Portfolio inflows Net Other inflows 200 200 100 0 0 -100 -200 2009q1 2009q4 2010q3 2011q2 2012q1 Source: IMF staff estimates. 8 2009q1 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 2012q4 2009q1 2009q4 2010q3 2011q2 2012q1 2012q4 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Figure 4. Factors Driving Capital Flows There has been an increased role of external factors since …but there were inflows beyond what can be explained by the global financial crisis… fundamentals by an extra $500 billion following the crisis. 6000 Capital Inflows: Domestic vs. External Factors (USD, billion, cumulative) Capital Inflows, Implied by the Model vs. Actual, Q4 2008-2012 (US Dollar billions, Accumulated basis since Q4 2008) 5000 4500 5000 4000 4000 Domestic factors 3500 External factors 3000 Actual $510 bn 2500 3000 2000 Domestic factors 2000 1000 1500 1000 External factors 0 500 Residual 0 -1000 -500 2002-2007 2008Q4 2008-2012 2009Q2 2009Q4 2010Q2 2010Q4 2011Q2 2011Q4 2012Q2 2012Q4 Source: IMF staff estimates. Figure 5. Top Emerging Market Recipients of Capital Flows China continued to receive the most flows, dominated by Mexico and Brazil received one-third of all portfolio flows FDI. postcrisis. 600 Net Capital Flows (Cumulative Billions of USD) 200 Net Portfolio Flows (Cumulative Billions of USD) 2005Q1-2007Q4 500 2005Q1-2007Q4 150 2010Q1-2012Q4 400 2010Q1-2012Q4 100 300 50 100 0 0 -50 S. Africa Thailand Indonesia Malaysia Poland India Turkey China -100 Brazil S. Africa Colombia Peru Indonesia Poland Mexico Turkey India Brazil China -100 Mexico 200 Source: IMF staff estimates. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 9 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE The relative importance of external factors relative to domestic factors increase somewhat in 2008–12 compared with 2002–07. Based on model estimates of the drivers of capital flows, over half of cumulative flows to EMs during 2008–12 were related to external factors (Figure 4), including AEs’ weak growth and expansionary monetary policy, and a global search for yield. But the relative importance of external and domestic factors in explaining capital inflows changed, with external factors driving capital inflows during 2008–11 and domestic factors becoming increasingly more important in driving capital inflows during 2011–12. As global capital flows were redirected toward EMs, they became increasingly concentrated. Postcrisis, 90 percent of net capital flows to EMs (75 percent of gross capital flows) were received by just eight countries (Brazil, China, India, Indonesia, Mexico, Peru, Poland, and Turkey) (Figure 5). This higher concentration reflects the large size of these countries, their higher growth rates vis-à-vis advanced economies, financial sector reforms leading to growing financial depth, and increasing accessibility to international institutional investors. The eight countries account for around 40 percent of the combined weights of all countries in the Emerging Markets Bond Index (EMBI).3 The total inflows into these EMs were larger than their fundamentals would suggest (Figure 6). Model estimates suggest an “overflow” (i.e., the amount in excess of what is explained by fundamentals) of about US$500 billion.4 This overflow was highly concentrated, with six of the large EMs (China, Brazil, Mexico, Turkey, Indonesia, and India) receiving 80 percent of the overflow. Several smaller EMs, however, also received significant inflows relative to the size of their economy.5 In particular, bond flows increased more compared with other flows (Figures 6 and 7). 3 The EMBI includes 55 EM countries from among 153 emerging and developing economies. 4 The determinants of capital inflows into EMs have been estimated using a reduced-form model that relates capital inflows in percent of GDP to external and domestic factors over the sample period (2002Q1–2012Q4) and with a panel of 44 countries. External factors include U.S. GDP growth, U.S. 10-year bond yields, the VIX, the expansion in U.S. Fed balance sheet since QE1, and the interaction between the VIX and U.S. 10 year yields). Domestic factors include GDP growth, domestic interest rates, and the real effective exchange rate misalignment as estimated by the IMF’s External Balance Assessment methodology. The estimated “overflow” is consistent with the April 2014 Global Financial Stability Report estimates of excess inflows (about $480 billion). 5 Alternative measures of capital overflow identify countries where capital inflows, as a share of GDP exceeded the top 30th percentile of the cross-country sample and the countries’ own threshold, set also at the top 30th percentile (Ghosh and others, 2012). 10 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Figure 6. Capital Flows into Emerging Markets The overflow into EMs concentrated into a few EMs. 800 A larger share of EMs experienced a surge in bond flows postcrisis. Cumulative Excess Capital Inflows to EMs Since 2008Q4: Contribution of Large EMs (in Billions of US Dollars) 50 Net surges 45 600 Bond surges 40 400 35 200 30 25 0 -200 -400 20 Mex Others ZAF TUR 15 IDN IND 10 CHN BRA 2011Q4 2012Q2 5 -600 2008Q4 2009Q2 2009Q4 2010Q2 Source: IMF staff estimates. 2010Q4 2011Q2 2012Q4 (In percent) 0 2005Q4 2006Q4 2007Q4 2008Q4 2009Q4 2010Q4 2011Q4 2012Q4 Figure 7. Surges in Bond Flows Emerging markets experienced a surge in bond flows in the postcrisis period. Argentina Brazil Bulgaria Chile China,P.R.: Mainland Colombia Croatia Czech Republic Estonia Hungary India Indonesia Korea, Republic of Latvia Lithuania Malaysia Mexico Pakistan Peru Philippines Poland Romania Russian Federation South Africa Sri Lanka Thailand Turkey Vietnam Egypt Israel Kazakhstan Serbia Ukraine Uruguay Armenia Bosnia & Herzegovina Dominican Republic Ecuador El Salvador Guatemala Jamaica Jordan Lebanon Tunisia Venezuela Morocco Costa Rica Paraguay 2010Q1 2010Q2 2010Q3 2010Q4 2011Q1 2011Q2 2011Q3 2011Q4 2012Q1 2012Q2 2012Q3 2012Q4 2013Q1 2013Q2 2013Q3 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 Source: IMF staff estimates. Note: Blue shaded areas represent episodes of surges in bond flows. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 11 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Cummulative excess flows (12Q4, $bn) Strong credit growth accompanied the surge in capital flows in many countries. While banks continued to channel the bulk of the inflows, the shadow banking sector also grew rapidly in some EMs. At the same time, EM corporates took Figure 8. Inflows and Financial Conditions advantage of the strong appetite for EM debt and Large inflows made it easier for companies to borrow. favorable financing conditions, including for first250 time issuers and lower-rated borrowers (Figure 8). 200 Between 2010 and 2013, EM issuance of below150 investment-grade debt jumped from 15 to 35 R² = 0.3165 100 percent of total debt issuance. India and Turkey experienced particularly large increases. However, 50 elevated corporate leverage increased these 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 countries’ sensitivity to slowing economic growth -50 and earnings, tighter financial conditions and -100 Non-investment outstanding stock 12Q4 (USDbn) higher interest rates, and more depreciated Source: IMF staff estimates. exchange rates. B. Policies in the Run-up to the May 2013 Taper Talk While private inflows and debt increased in many EMs, policy buffers initially increased as well. Having experienced or observed several EM crises during 1980–2000, EMs in Asia and Latin America had learned some important lessons—namely, the value of strong public finances, low inflation, sustainable current account deficits, and building buffers to cushion against negative shocks. The advent of the early 2000s witnessed, by and large, a period of continued fiscal consolidation and relative tranquility. In general, foreign exchange reserves remained comfortable in most EMs, and some countries built reserve positions beyond what could be necessary for precautionary purposes.6 The Eastern European countries were an exception, accumulating significant imbalances prior to 2008, and going through a painful boom and bust. As noted in the previous section, following the global financial crisis, many EMs faced the challenge of absorbing large capital inflows, particularly during 2010–12. While there were significant differences in individual country responses, most met this challenge by allowing their nominal exchange rates to appreciate and by accumulating reserves (Figure 9).7 6 Some exceptions were Turkey, Indonesia, and Ukraine, where external reserves were relatively low, 7 Mexico saw a significant accumulation of foreign assets in the form of reserves by the central bank but also the private sector through outward FDI, portfolio flows, and deposits abroad. In contrast, Turkey had limited foreign asset accumulation. 12 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Figure 9. Reserves Accumulation and Capital Inflows EMs accumulated significantly less reserves after the global financial crisis than before. % GDP 6 Gross Inflows/GDP Reserve Accumulation/GDP GIR Accuml/Gross Inflows (percent, RHS) 180 Net Inflows/GDP Reserve Accumulation/GDP GIR Accuml/Net Inflows (percent, RHS) % GDP 6 160 5 140 4 120 180 160 156.6 5 140 4 120 100 3 80 100 3 80 70.2 2 60 26.0 1 21.7 20 0 0 1992-96 2003-07 2 60 52.0 40 40 33.8 1 20 0 2010-12 0 1992-96 2003-07 2010-12 Source: IMF staff estimates. Note: GIR stands for Gross International Reserves. Over time, stronger exchange rates and domestic demand led to a gradual widening of current account deficits or narrowing of surpluses in most countries (Figures 10 and 11).8 Short-term external debt became a more significant part of financing, rising considerably in some countries (bottom left panel of Figure 11). Figure 10. Fiscal Position in Selected Emerging Markets Looking at the cyclically adjusted primary balance (CAPB) and debt, need for adjustment was clear in some EMs. Fiscal position 5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4 (Percent of GDP) BRA COL TUR PER RUS CHL CHN IDN CAPB Some countries introduced capital flow management measures and intervened in the foreign exchange market to limit appreciation pressure. However, owing in part to the comfortable reserve position built in earlier years and to perceptions regarding the persistence of capital flows, foreign exchange intervention was more limited (in relation to inflows). The resistance index, which measures the share of exchange rate pressures that was met by a change in reserves, fell in 2010–12 and was lower for countries that received the largest share of capital flows (see the top right panel of Figure 11). POL MEX UKR ZAF THA MYS IND 0 20 40 60 80 Gross Debt, percent of GDP Source: Fiscal Monitor 8 In contrast, hard hit by the 2008–09 crisis, most Eastern European countries went through a period of consolidation and narrowing of imbalances. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 13 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Figure 11. External Sector Developments The external positions evolved significantly differently across Countries receiving large capital inflows intervened less. countries receiving capital flows. Capital Inflows and Currrent Account Change Change in current account, percent of GDP (Between 2009-2013) 0.8 1 POL 0 0.7 MEX BRA COL -1 -2 CHN 0.6 0.5 ZAF IND -3 PER -4 IDN -6 0 2 4 6 0.4 0.3 TUR -5 Average Resistance Index (Larger = more intervention) 8 Cumulative Capital Inflow, percent of GDP 0.2 Top 10 net capital inflow receivers during 2005-2013 0.1 Average EMs 0.0 Sources: IFS and WEO 2005Q1 2007Q1 2009Q1 2011Q1 2013Q1 In Mexico, residents’ accumulation of foreign assets did not lead to a sharp widening in the current account... …while in Turkey, there was little accumulation of reserves or private sector foreign assets. Short-term debt increased markedly in Turkey. Reserves remained adequate for most countries Reserve adequacy metric Short-term Debt Change in Short-term Debt, percent of GDP (Between 2009-2013) Reserves as a percent of the IMF average reserve adequacy 7 450 IDN 6 TUR 5 2009 2013 350 4 300 IND CHN 3 250 COL 2 200 PER 1 0 -1 0 5 150 POL BRA MEX 10 100 ZAF 15 20 STD in 2013, percent of GDP Sources: IFS and WEO 14 400 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 25 50 0 PER THA BRA CHNCOL RUS IND CHL POL MEXMYS TUR ZAF IDN UKR Sources: IFS and Staff estimates IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Fiscal and Monetary Policy Fiscal and monetary policy was initially loosened in EMs to counter the negative impact of the global financial crisis on domestic economic activity in 2008–09. But macroeconomic policies remained accommodative even as output gaps closed, equity prices rose, and bond yields fell markedly (Figure 12). This fueled domestic demand, widening current account deficits, and led to an erosion of policy buffers in some countries, reducing the room for maneuver going forward. Higher external financing needs than before the global financial crisis left many EMs more vulnerable to changes in expectations of global financial conditions. Figure 12. Financial Conditions 30 2.5 25 2.0 1.5 20 Percentage points Percentage change Financial conditions (equity prices (EQ) and 10 year bond yields (10YB)) eased significantly. 15 10 5 0 1.0 0.5 0.0 -0.5 -1.0 -1.5 -5 -2.0 -10 -2.5 EQ Dec 31' 07 - May 22'13 May 22'13 - March 18'14 10YB Dec 31' 07 - May 22'13 May 22'13 - March 18'14 Source: IMF staff estimates. Synchronized Slowdown The decline in policy buffers occurred amid a synchronized slowdown in EMs (Figure 13). In around 90 percent of the 25 largest EMs, growth in 2013 was weaker than the average of 2003–07. This slowdown was driven by both cyclical and structural factors, as well as supply-side and structural constraints on investment and potential output. A recent IMF Staff Discussion Note shows that the slowdown in EMs also reflected less favorable external conditions and weaker terms of trade for many commodity exporters, and tighter financial conditions (Cubeddu and others, 2014). These factors continue to weigh on medium-term growth prospects. Indeed, growth projections in the IMF’s October 2014 World Economic Outlook envisage EM medium-term growth at 3 percentage points below where it was predicted to be when the forecast was made in 2010 (Figure 14). The IMF’s medium-term outlook for EMs was progressively marked down by more than a half percentage point per year between 2010 and 2013, suggesting continued deterioration in sentiment toward EMs growth prospects. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 15 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Figure 13. Synchronized Emerging Market Slowdown 1 (Percent of EM countries with real GDP growth slowdowns) 100 (Percent change in GDP growth relative to growth in 2010) 3 Current Slowdown Global Financial Crisis Figure 14. Growth Forecasts in Emerging Markets Oct-10 2 Oct-11 90 Oct-12 1 80 70 Oct-13 0 60 50 -1 40 -2 30 20 -3 10 -4 0 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 Sources: IMF, World Economic Outlook; and staff calculations. 1/ More than 70% of sample countries with real GDP growth below the 20032007 average. 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Source: IMF, World Economic Outlook. MARKETS' REACTION TO TAPER TALK, MID-2013 A. Anticipated Turmoil in Financial Markets Against the backdrop of stronger U.S. recovery Figure 15. 10-year Treasury and Short-term prospects, the Fed began speaking about Rates (percent) prospects for gradually unwinding its 10-year treasury bond unconventional monetary policy in May and June 3-month eurodollar futures June 2015 (RHS) of 2013. This phase—referred to as “taper talk”— and the months that followed saw significant 3.5 1.4 volatility in capital flows into EMs and asset prices 3.0 1.2 globally, particularly in EMs. While 2.5 1.0 unconventional monetary policies by the Fed 2.0 0.8 were not expected to last forever, talk of reducing 1.5 0.6 (or “tapering”) the quantity of its asset purchases surprised markets, which responded by 1.0 0.4 significantly revising their expectations of future 0.5 0.2 rate hikes. Sharp market corrections ensued in 6/4/2014 0.0 0.0 EMs, including rapid currency depreciations, Jan-13 May-13 Sep-13 Jan-14 May-14 Source: Bloomberg, L.P. increases in external financing premia, declines in equity prices, and a slowing in capital flows. These episodes were unusual, and different from the typical market reaction to Fed monetary policy actions. 16 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Why did markets react in the way they did? From the adjustment in long-term and short-term yields, it appears that market participants struggled to read the Fed’s policy intentions and perceived the Fed pre-announcement about tapering asset purchases as a signal of an earlier-than-intended tightening of interest rates (Figure 15).9 The correction in short-term rate expectations after the Fed postponed tapering in September 2013 suggests that market participants eventually learned to better read the Fed’s policy intentions. Stylized Facts Three broad stylized facts can be drawn from the recent experience. First, Fed announcements did not always surprise markets equally over time. To single out the channels through which announcements affect markets, it us useful to distinguish between “signaling shocks,” which capture information about short- to medium-term intentions to move the policy rate, and “market shocks,” which affect term premia and longer-term bonds with information about the degree of policy or macroeconomic uncertainty and the future supply of government bonds.10 The distinction is important, as central banks can more easily mitigate signaling shocks through standard communication. While signaling and market shocks were of roughly equal size during the conventional phase of monetary policy (2000-November 2008), during the taper talk phase, U.S. monetary policy shocks were mostly perceived as market shocks.11 This is similar to the impact of monetary policy announcements in the earlier phase of unconventional monetary policy— from November 2008-May 2013, when bond purchase programs were announced and expanded— when, again, “market” shocks dominated. Second, the size of EM asset price and capital flow movements on days of U.S. monetary policy announcements were markedly higher during the taper talk phase, especially for bond yields and exchange rates. Third, the differentiation in market movements widened across countries on days of U.S. monetary policy announcements. This is true of all phases of U.S. monetary policy, though it is most visible during the unconventional monetary policy phases. This differentiation is illustrated in Figure 16, which plot movements in capital flows, exchange rates, equity prices, and bond yields (normalized by historical variances, yielding so-called Z-scores) over the initial months of the taper talk phase. 9 Markets in EMs may also have reacted to how U.S. markets absorbed the new and surprising narrative by the Fed’s chairman. 10 See Chen, Mancini-Griffoli, and Sahay (2014). 11 Specifically, the May and June 2013 announcements were perceived as strong tightening shocks and the September announcement as a loosening shock. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 17 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Figure 16. Variation of Asset Price Responses Across Countries Following May–June 2013 Monetary Policy Shocks (z-scores) Capital Flows Exchange Rate (Bond & Equity) 3 May 2 3.5 June 3.0 1 2.5 0 -1 2.0 -2 1.5 -3 1.0 -4 0.5 -5 -6 Poland Russia South Africa Thailand Poland Russia South Africa Thailand Turkey Mexico Indonesia India China Mexico Equity Price Brazil Turkey Thailand South Africa Russia Poland Mexico Indonesia India China Brazil 0.0 -0.5 10-year Bond Yield Turkey Indonesia India China Brazil Turkey Thailand South Africa Russia Poland Mexico Indonesia India China 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2 Brazil 0.5 0.0 -0.5 -1.0 -1.5 -2.0 -2.5 -3.0 -3.5 -4.0 -4.5 Source: IMF staff estimates. Explaining Market Reactions As noted above, changes in asset prices and capital flows were largest and most significant during the tapering talk phase.12 In fact, these changes were hardly significant during the conventional monetary policy phase. Their significance grew in the initial part of the unconventional monetary policy period, mostly in response to signaling shocks, although signaling shocks themselves were smaller than market shocks. During the tapering phase, signaling shocks generally had larger effects, although by then market shocks also induced significant movements in EM asset prices and capital inflows (Figure 17). 12 See Chen, Mancini-Griffoli, and Sahay (2014). The analysis is centered on a panel regression across 21 EMs. The regression framework relates changes in asset prices and capital flows by country to U.S. monetary policy shocks measured by market and signal factors. Fixed effects capture differences between countries that stem from countryspecific characteristics that do not vary over time. 18 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE External conditions played an important role in the transmission of U.S. monetary policy shocks during the tapering phase. During periods of higher VIX or lower growth in China, the effects of U.S. tapering shocks were amplified. If growth expectations in China during the tapering episode had been as high as during previous years, the average response of equity prices in EMs to a U.S. monetary policy shock would have been 20 percent lower (bond yields would have responded 5 percent less, and exchange rates about as much). Conversely, when it is high, China’s growth has served as a cushioning factor for many EMs, particularly those that have close trade links with China. Explaining Cross-Country Differentiation Eventual differentiation in market Figure 17. Effects of U.S. Monetary Policy Announcements pressure during the taper talk 0.4 phase was mostly based on 0.3 fundamentals in EMs. Although 0.2 market reaction was 0.1 0 indiscriminate during the initial -0.1 bout of volatility in May-June -0.2 2013, these reactions were short-0.3 lived. Market differentiation -0.4 occurred during the subsequent -0.5 CMP UMPUMPbouts of volatility. Investors Purchases Taper focused particularly on countries Note: The figure depicts the estimated impact of one unit increase in both the market and signal factors on equity prices (red bars), bond yields (green bars) and exchange rates (blue bars) over 3 different with larger external financing phases of US monetary policy. For each asset type in a given phase, the bar on the left corresponds to the average impact of market shocks and the bar on the right correspond to signal shocks. CMP = needs and macroeconomic conventional monetary policy, UMP = unconventional monetary policy. imbalances, exerting severe pressure on countries like Brazil, Source: IMF staff estimates. India, Indonesia, Turkey, and South Africa. These five countries saw, on average, bond yields rise by 2½ percentage points, equity markets fall by 13¾ percent, exchange rates depreciate by 13½ percent, and reserves declined by about 4 percent between May 22 and end-August 2013. Since end-2013, there have been additional bursts of market pressure related in part, but not exclusively, to the Fed’s decision to taper.13 During these episodes, countries that had taken policy action since May 2013 (e.g., made progress in reducing their macroeconomic imbalances) showed more resilience (e.g., India and Indonesia in early 2014). More generally, market pressures during the taper talk period were more subdued in countries with stronger fundamentals, deeper financial markets, and better growth prospects, as well as in countries with greater control on capital flows and tighter macroprudential policies prior to the 13 Additional factors include risks in China’s shadow banking system, idiosyncratic developments in Argentina, and rising political and policy risks in Turkey. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 19 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Macro prudential Trade Linkage 1 yr ahead - Consensus Real GDP growth Stock market cap/GDP Stock of Bank credit/GDP Reserves/GDP Current Account Balance/GDP Inflation Percentage points Figure 18. Effect on Bond Yields tapering talks. Figure 18 shows results (Annualized, unconventional monetary policy and taper phase) for country characteristics taken (Percentage points) separately, and Figure 19 0.0 shows that most results are robust to -0.5 controlling for all characteristics at -1.0 once.14 In particular, -1.5 countries with larger current account -2.0 surpluses, stronger fiscal balances, -2.5 lower inflation, higher GDP growth, lower share of local debt held by foreigners, and more reserves saw smaller depreciation of their exchange Macro Fundamentals Financial Depth EM Growth China MaPP rates, drops in equity prices, and 15 Source: IMF staff estimates. lower increase in bond yields. MaPP stands for macro-prudential policies. Countries with deeper domestic financial markets were over time less affected (e.g., less of a depreciation of exchange rates, fall in equity prices, and rise in bond yields), as the size of these markets meant that investors could move large amounts of capital outside the country or toward other domestic markets without significant changes in prices. Mexico is an example of a country with deeper financial markets than others that has been less affected by the bouts of volatility in 2013 and early 2014. Mexico experienced a large depreciation in the aftermath of the May 22 tapering talk (perhaps because it was used as a proxy hedge for other EM currencies with less liquid financial markets), but its deep markets facilitated the needed adjustment in capital flows and portfolio rebalancing. Mexico experienced little volatility compared with other EMs during the episodes of volatility after the summer of 2013. 16 Countries that in the face of large capital inflows following the global financial crisis had tightened restrictions on those inflows also experienced more muted market reactions, suggesting that these tighter capital flow management measures may have influenced the composition of flows toward less volatile flows. Similarly, countries with a tighter macroprudential policy stance in the run-up to the volatile episodes of 2013 fared better. Exposure to China provides some buffers when the market volatility stems from Federal Open Market Committee announcements. However, when the negative news also emanates from China, then exposure to China does not serve as a buffer. Finally, 14 An event analysis was used to look at the change in bond yields in the two day window around Fed policy announcements and minutes release dates for the January 1, 2013–January 22, 2014 period and for a sample of 21 EMs. The analysis controls for country-specific effects and explores the extent to which macroeconomic fundamentals and structural factors mattered in explaining markets’ reaction. See Mishra and others (2014) and Chen, ManciniGriffoli and Sahay (2014). 15 Bowman, Londono, and Sapriza (2014) find that countries with high interest rates, credit default swap spreads, inflation rates, or current-account deficits, and those with more-vulnerable banking systems, were more affected by changes in U.S. financial variables. 16 If measured by bank credit to GDP, Mexico’s financial markets are not deep. However, its markets are relatively deep based on liquidity measures, e.g., bid-ask spread or turnover in foreign exchange markets. 20 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE signaling shocks seem to induce greater differentiation across countries, whereas market shocks seem to affect all countries similarly. This might be because market shocks affect investors’ overall risk assessment and thus lead to more widespread portfolio reallocations. Figure 19. Role of Fundamentals in Explaining Different Markets’ Reactions Equity Market factor Signal factor Bond yields Market factor Signal factor Exchange rates Market factor Signal factor GDP growth Inflation Currenct Account Share of local debt held by foreign investors Bid-ask spread Note: Green denotes the macro factors that dampen US monetary policy shocks during the UMP phase, and red corresponds to macro factors that amplify the shocks. Striped cells denote coefficients significant at the 10 percent level, and solid cells denote coefficients significant above the 5 percent level. Source: IMF staff estimates. Figure 20. Changing Role of Fundamentals Over Time and Across Countries Reserves vs. Exchange Rate Exchange Rate Change May 22 to Dec 31, 2013 (percent change, - depreciation) 10 POL 5 BGR HUN CHN ROM 0 UKR KAZ -5 PER COL CHL -10 -15 ZAF IND TUR BRA IDN -20 MEX THA RUS PHL MYS ARG -25 -10 -5 0 Current Account Balance 2013 (percent of GDP) Exchange Rate Change (Jan-Feb 2014, percent) Exchange Rate Change vs. Current Account Balance 5 IDN BRA PER IND PHL KOR LTU MYSPOL BGR ROM CHN TUR ZAF MEX HUN COL CHL THA 0 -5 -10 RUS -15 KAZ ARG -20 UKR -25 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 Reserve Change (May 2013 to Jan 2014, percent) Source: IMF staff estimates. Country-specific shocks in January-February 2014, including a surprise devaluation in Argentina, deterioration in the political situation in Russia and Ukraine, and weaker-than-expected Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) data in China, were the main reasons for volatility in global markets. Compared with May 2013-January 2014, when markets focused on countries with large current account deficits (Brazil, India, Indonesia, South Africa, and Turkey), the focus of markets shifted to INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 21 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE countries that experienced relatively large declines in reserves and sizable exchange rate pressures— Ukraine, Argentina, and Kazakhstan (Figure 20). B. Emerging Market Policy Responses and Their Effectiveness EMs deployed a range of policy tools to address market volatility (Figure 21). These included monetary policy, fiscal policy, Figure 21. Policy Tools Deployed by Emerging macroprudential policy, capital flow Markets management measures (CFMs), and Fiscal Macroprudential Monetary policy CFMs Liquidity policy Policy FX provision Intervention foreign exchange intervention, as well as measures Tight Loose Tight Tight Removal Brazil providing liquidity into money markets to India 17 address specific needs. Among these Indonesia policy tools, monetary policy seems to Russia S Africa have been used most often, with most Thailand countries raising rates (Brazil, India, Turkey Poland Indonesia, Russia, South Africa, and Source: Desk economists, recent FSAPs, and Article IV Staff Reports. Turkey).18 Liquidity measures were also undertaken to preserve orderly market conditions by ensuring liquidity in money markets were consistent with the intended monetary policy stance (Brazil, India, Indonesia). As highlighted in the IMF’s October 2013 Global Financial Stability Report, crowded positions in local markets, lengthening duration, and reduced market liquidity had contributed to the volatility in the EMs. Macroprudential measures, CFMs, and foreign exchange intervention were used less widely across countries. Fiscal policy was least used. We assess the effectiveness of policy responses through an event analysis for a sample of 12 EMs. These are the countries that were most hit during May-August 2013—that is, countries for which the exchange market pressure index (which combines changes in exchange rates and reserves) exceeds one standard deviation in at least one of those months. They include Brazil, Colombia, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Mexico, Peru, Poland, Russia, South Africa, Thailand, and Turkey.19 The analysis focuses on markets’ reactions following policy announcements and gauges whether policy responses have had a soothing effect on markets. Specifically, we look at whether the policy announcement had a countervailing effect on exchange rate depreciation, equity price declines, and bond yield increases. 17 The Thai authorities did not change CFMs around the taper talk, but they raised the prospects of introducing them in April (prior to the taper talk) if capital inflows continued unabated. This may have contributed to stemming inflows and starting the reversal of the appreciation of the baht. 18 It is important to underscore that most countries raised rates to fight against rising inflation, not just capital outflows and depreciating currencies. If rates are increased just for the latter purposes, they risk having the opposite effects of undermining investor confidence in a sound policy framework, and slowing down the economy beyond measure, in both cases driving further capital outflows and currency depreciation. 19 See Bi, Sgherri, and N’Diaye (2014) for details. 22 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE The results, which are shown in Figure 22, indicate that many of the policy actions taken were broadly effective in dampening asset price changes (i.e., moderating the impact on currencies, bond yields, and equity prices). Liquidity provision measures dampened the pace of foreign exchange depreciation and the rise in bond yields but did not slow the fall in equity Figure 22. Effect of Policy Announcements1 prices. The impact of liquidity provision Pace of FX Equity Prices Bond Yields measures on the pace of depreciation Depreciation could be interpreted in two different Liquidity Provision Measures ways: (i) it could reflect confidence Interest Rate Hike effects that such measures provide to Tighter Fiscal Policy market participants (by reassuring Removal of CFM on Inflows markets that liquidity needs would be Macroprudential Policies met, this could reduce the urge of some participants to bring forward 1/ IMF Staff estimates. their demand for foreign exchange), or Note: Figures highlighted in yellow are not statistically significant. Period May 2013-January 2014. Green check marks represent instances where policy (ii) it could mean that liquidity was actions had a dampening effect on the selected asset price. Red cross represents instances where policy actions did not have or had a worsening impact on the selected asset price. provided to sterilize some of the Source: IMF staff estimates. effects of foreign exchange interventions. Interest rates hikes, CFMs (removal of restrictions on capital inflows), and macroprudential policies slowed the pace of depreciation, fall in equity prices, and the rise in bond yields. We could not find any statistically significant effect of fiscal policy announcements, which may reflect markets’ assessment that there are greater implementation challenges of such measures or that it takes a long time for fiscal policy to influence macroeconomic outcomes. Finally, we look at the effectiveness of foreign exchange intervention on calming market pressures. Countries intervened in foreign exchange markets in several ways, depending on the source of exchange market pressure. Some countries intervened in forward/swap markets and others intervened in the spot market. For example, Brazil announced a large intervention program, amounting to US$55 billion, and consisting of daily auctions of foreign exchange swaps. This particular type of intervention aimed to allow market participants to hedge their exposure rather than to satisfy demand by markets participants to reduce their exposure to the Brazilian real. Since very few countries announced their intervention plans or published in a timely fashion the amounts and types of foreign exchange intervention, we looked at the effectiveness of intervention over a longer time span, using published intervention for six EMs, for which data are available, and monthly data on reserves accumulation adjusted for valuation effects.20 The analysis follows the work by Adler and Tovar (2011) and looks at the effectiveness of foreign exchange intervention to stem depreciation pressure. It explores the role of global risk aversion (as measured by the VIX), the level of reserves, and macro fundamentals (IMF, 2013b). The empirical analysis relates the rate of 20 The six EMs that publish intervention data are Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Mexico, Peru, and Turkey. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 23 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE change in bilateral exchange rates against the U.S. dollar to a set of fundamentals, including interest rate differentials, EMBI spreads, commodity prices, the VIX, countries’ experience with foreign exchange intervention (which in turn depends on past movements in exchanges rates), the extent of exchange rate misalignment, past volatility in exchange rate, foreign exchange reserves, and sixmonth-ahead rollover need. The results suggest that foreign exchange interventions are effective in slowing the pace of depreciation when inflation is low, the currency is not overvalued, and reserves are adequate (Figure 23). In fact we find that if reserves are not adequate, selling foreign exchange can be destabilizing, and can lead to a faster pace of Figure 23. Effectiveness of Foreign Exchange depreciation. This result is consistent with Intervention the empirical literature on foreign Episodes: FX Selling Interventions: All (2004-13) exchange intervention, which in general Pace of Depreciation provides some support for intervention in Depreciation Effect on FX Selling Intervention helping slow the rate of change in the (improving effectiveness: +) 21 exchange rate. The analysis also indicates More Open Capital Account that the effectiveness of intervention in Tightening of MPPs REER overvaluation slowing the pace of depreciation depends Higher inflation in previous year on the level of uncertainty in global Gross reserves/GDP markets. In particular, the results indicate Low reserves High reserves that when the VIX is above the 75th VIX 25th - 75th percentile percentile, the smoothing effect of Above 75th percentile intervention on exchange rate depreciation Note: Green check marks represent instances where policy actions had a dampening effect on the selected asset price. Red cross represents instances where policy actions did not have or pressure stops being statistically had a worsening impact on the selected asset price. Source: IMF staff estimates. significant. In other words, when markets panic, intervention provides little or no help. LESSONS GOING FORWARD Markets reassess emerging markets’ fundamentals as global conditions change. The global financial system remains far from normal, and the transition path to a sustainable system is not yet risk-free. Indeed, occasional spikes in market volatility since the taper talk in May of 2013 serve as an important reminder. Such bumps during the monetary normalization process can be costly both at 21 Intervention was found to be effective by Sarno and Taylor (2001) for AEs during “periods of high reputation and heavy sterilized intervention” (p. 854), and “if it is publicly announced and concerted” (p. 855), and by Dominguez (2003) for the United States, Japan, and Germany in influencing foreign exchange returns and volatility. Adler and Tovar (2011) find that, for EMs, intervention during episodes of appreciation pressure affects the pace of appreciation but not the level of the exchange rate. Kohlscheen and Andrade (2013) use high-frequency data of foreign exchange and official currency swap auctions in Brazil and demonstrate that public auctions have an economically and statistically significant effect on the foreign exchange rate. In a more general survey of the effectiveness of intervention in EMs, Ostry, Ghosh, and Chamon (2012, p. 12) find that the evidence on the effectiveness of sterilized intervention in EMs is mixed, but generally more favorable than in the advanced economy context. 24 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Percent the national as well as the international level (see the IMF’s 2014 Spillover Report). In this regard, the recent decline in market volatility points to potential Figure 24. Implied Volatility risks going forward (Figure 24). A resurgence of portfolio flows into EMs since April 2014 has pushed Implied U.S. interest rate volatility asset prices near historically high levels. In (MOVE index) 130 5/22/2013 9/18/2013 addition, easier financing conditions have 120 precipitated further compression of credit spreads. 110 100 For example, corporate credit spreads in Brazil and 90 China narrowed by around 70 basis points from June 80 2013 to June 2014, even as corporate profitability 70 60 and interest coverage ratios declined and leverage 50 9/22/2014 increased. An environment of low rates and volatility, 40 if it persists for a long period, may contribute to a Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-13 Jan-14 Source: Bloomberg, L.P. rapid buildup of leveraged positions and credit risk, which could unwind in a volatile manner in the event of sudden shifts in markets’ expectations. Potential adjustments in the term premium, as during the second half of 2013, are particularly relevant in the context of the expected rise in policy interest rates away from the zero lower bound as economic prospects improve in AEs. The analysis in this paper has shown that the effects on EMs of the Fed’s monetary policy announcements during the phase of unconventional monetary policy (post-2008), and especially during the period when tapering was first discussed (summer of 2013), can be sizable. However, after an initial phase of acute and systemic stress during which countries were indiscriminately affected, the effects of such announcements on EMs differed by country based on country fundamentals. Countries with sounder macroeconomic fundamentals were less affected than others. Still, there is no single fundamental that matters for all countries at all times, as markets appear to focus on different fundamentals at different points in time. That said, elevated current account deficits, high inflation, weak growth prospects, and low reserves are dominant factors affecting market reaction. Moreover, emerging markets that acted early and decisively have tended to fare better (Figure 25). In particular, monetary policy tightening was necessary where inflation was high and monetary policy credibility needed to be established. Targeted foreign exchange intervention to reduce volatility where reserves were adequate was also effective. Figure 25 shows that even countries with weak fundamentals were rewarded by markets if they took decisive policy action to address their vulnerabilities. This is illustrated by India and Indonesia, which improved their current account and hardly witnessed a move in their currencies in January compared with the MayDecember period when they had depreciated substantially. Weaknesses in macroeconomic fundamentals need to be addressed through coherent and credible macro policies and frameworks. Improving growth prospects in emerging economies by shifting to a regime in which growth is more balanced and sustainable should also help reduce vulnerabilities— the bouts of volatility in the second half of last year have shown that countries with better growth prospects tend to be affected less. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 25 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Figure 25. Payoffs from Policy Action Exchange Rate Change (May-December 2013) vs. Current Account Balance, 2013 Exchange Rate Change (January to end-March 2014) vs. Current Account Balance, 2014 10 POL 5 HUN CHN ROM R² = 0.0811 0 BGR UKR PER -5 ZAF -10 MEX THA BRA TUR -15 COL CHL IND KAZ IDN -20 ARG -25 -10 -5 0 Current Account Balance 2013 (% of GDP) RUS PHL MYS Exchange Rate Change Jan 1 to Mar 27, 2014 (percent change, - depreciation) Exchange Rate Change May 22 to Dec 31, 2013 (percent change, - depreciation) 10 IDN R² = 0.0295 5 BRA ZAF 0 TUR -5 PER COL IND LTU BGR POL MEX THA ROM CHL -10 -15 MYS CHN HUN RUS PHL KOR KAZ -20 ARG -25 -30 UKR -35 -40 -10 -5 0 5 Current Account Balance 2014 (% of GDP) Source: IMF staff estimates. Looking back to the May 2013 events suggests that AEs have an important role to play considering the numerous challenges associated with the normalization of monetary policy. This relates to how AE central banks communicate their policy intentions. Figure 26 shows the evolution of the U.S. expected short-term interest rates and news over the past six years. The figure suggests that since 2008, U.S. policymakers have aimed through their rate guidance to reduce longer-term interest rates—given the interest rate floor on policy rates—by lowering expected short-term interest rates (two-year-ahead, three-month interest rates). But the way this objective was achieved changed over time. The Fed started with qualitative time-dependent forward rate guidance, then moved to more explicit calendar-based guidance, and finally to state-dependent guidance (i.e., thresholds on unemployment conditional on inflation developments) and taper announcements. Forward guidance has also been complemented by other unconventional actions—namely, large-scale asset purchases (LSAP) by the Fed—to help further reduce longer term interest rates. For advanced economies, exiting from exceptional and unprecedented policies is a new challenge. Surprises about the future course of monetary policy in major advanced economies have particularly strong effects on EM asset prices and capital flows. It is therefore important for AE central banks to provide clear communication and adequate market guidance. Central banks should also aim to minimize excess volatility in longer-term rates. If policy announcements or implementation creates excess volatility in the global economy, which then spills back into the source country, this could limit policy freedom in advanced economies.22 For the global community, there is scope to assess the extent to which the global financial safety net provides adequate support to countries in the context of, but not limited to, monetary policy normalization. For countries affected by policy normalization in advanced economies, there may be gaps in the global financial safety net that leave some countries more vulnerable to capital flow 22 See the IMF’s 2014 Spillover Report for further analysis of “spillbacks” and when they may be important for source countries (IMF, 2014). 26 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE volatility. For instance, not all countries benefit from swap lines with source countries’ central banks. This is an area that could be explored mutually between source and additional recipient countries. Taking steps at the current juncture to identify enhancements to the global financial safety net would help to support both advanced and emerging markets as the global economy transitions away from large-scale liquidity support. Enhancements could include supporting central bank swap lines, cooperating with regional financial arrangements, or developing new IMF facilities. In this regard, the recent completion of the expansion of the ASEAN+3 Chang Mai Multilateral Initiative (CMII) is a potentially useful tool for regional cooperation in providing safety nets for countries that do not have access to currency swap lines with the G5 central banks, or which do not wish to borrow from the IMF’s facilities. Countries could also make greater use of IMF precautionary arrangements if more insurance is needed. At the same time, enhanced cooperation between central banks and financial regulators could help limit the risk of swings in asset prices—including major currencies— and potential balance sheet implications. Finally, an idea worth considering would be an enhanced global financial safety net financed by source and recipient countries alike, as this would reduce incentives for countries to implement uncooperative and inward-looking policies, and would reduce fragmentation of the global financial system as well. Figure 26. Effectiveness of Federal Reserve Communication U.S. Expected Short-Term Interest Rates and Economic News (Two-year ahead interest rate, percent; and surprise index ) 4.0 150 3.5 0.4 100 Citi News Index (rhs) 3.0 Sensitivity to News (Coefficient estimates; Fed funds futures) 0.3 Horizon 50 2.5 0 0.2 2.0 -50 1.5 -100 1.0 -0.1 -200 Feb-09 Aug-09 Feb-10 Aug-10 2 year ahead -150 0.0 Aug-08 0.0 1 year ahead Expected 2yr ahead Fed Funds rate 0.5 0.1 Feb-11 Aug-11 Feb-12 Aug-12 Feb-13 Aug-13 Feb-14 Average sensitivity Sensitivity after qualitative FG Sensitivity after time-dependent FG Sensitivity after June 2013 FOMC meeting Sensitivity after no-taper surprise Source: IMF staff estimates. Note: FG stands for forward guidance. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 27 IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE REFERENCES Adler, Gustavo, and Camilo Tovar, “Foreign Exchange Intervention: A Shield Against Appreciation Winds?” IMF Working Paper 11/165 (Washington: International Monetary Fund). Ahmed, Shaghil, and Andrei Zlate, 2013, “Capital Flows to Emerging Market Economies: A Brave New World?” International Finance Discussion Papers, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Number 1081. Bi, Ran, Silvia Sgherri, and Papa N’Diaye, 2014, “Policy Responses to the May 2013 Market Jitters: What Worked and What Did Not Work?” IMF Working Paper, Forthcoming. Bowman David, Juan M. Londono, and Horacio Sapriza, 2014, ”U.S. Unconventional Monetary Policy and Transmission to Emerging Market Economies,” International Finance Discussion Papers, No. 1109, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. Chen, Jiaqan, Tommaso Mancini-Griffoli, and Ratna Sahay, 2014, “Spillovers from U.S. Monetary Policy on Emerging Markets: Different this Time?” IMF Working Paper, forthcoming. Cubeddu, L., A. Culiuc, Ghada Fayad, Yuan Gao, Kalpana Kochhar, Ayhan Kyobe, Ceyda Oner, Roberto Perrelli, Sarah Sanya, Evridiki Tsounta, and Zhongxia Zhang, 2014, “Emerging Markets in Transition: Growth Prospects and Challenges,” Staff Discussion Note 14/6 (Washington: International Monetary Fund). Dominguez, Kathryn, 2003, “The Market Microstructure of Central Bank Intervention,” Journal of International Economics, Vol. 59, 25-45. Ghosh, Atish R., Jun Kim, Mahvash S. Qureshi, and Juan Zalduendo, 2012, “Surges,” IMF Working Paper12/22 (Washington: International Monetary Fund). International Monetary, Fund (IMF), 2013a, “Unconventional Monetary Policies––Recent Experience and Prospects,” April 18. http://www.imf.org/external/np/pp/eng/2013/041813a.pdf. International Monetary, Fund (IMF), 2013b, “Assessing Reserves Adequacy—Further Considerations,” IMF Policy Paper, 13 November. http://www.imf.org/external/np/pp/eng/2013/111313d.pdf. International Monetary, Fund (IMF), 2014, “IMF 2014 Spillover Report,” July 29. http://www.imf.org/external/np/pp/eng/2014/062514.pdf. Kohlscheen, Emanuel, and Sandro C. Andrade, 2013, “Official Interventions through Derivatives: Affecting the Demand for Foreign Exchange,” Banco Central do Brazil Working Paper 317. Mishra, Prachi, Kenji Moriyama, Papa N’Diaye, and Lam Nguyen, 2014, “Impact of Fed Tapering 28 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE Announcements on Emerging Markets,” IMF Working Paper 14/109 (Washington: International Monetary Fund). Ostry, Jonathan D., Atish R. Ghosh, and Marcos Chamon, 2012, “Two Targets, Two Instruments: Monetary and Exchange Rate Policies in Emerging Market Economies,” IMF Staff Discussion Note 12/01 (Washington: International Monetary Fund). Sarno, Lucio, and Mark Taylor, 2001, “Official Intervention in the Foreign Exchange Market: Is it Effective and, If So, How Does It Work?” Journal of Economic Literature Vol. 39, pp. 839-68. INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 29
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )