Motion of a rigid sphere rising through hydrogel suspension. Ilia Demiri Noah Rietveld January 22, 2026 Abstract In this experiment, the motion of a modified ping-pong ball rising through a viscous medium was studied. The ball, filled with water and a small magnet to achieve a mass of 16.4 g, was released in a granular hydrogel suspension with a concentration of 6 g/L. The position of the ball as a function of time was recorded for different liquid heights by systematically reducing the volume of the hydrogel. The experiment was performed using two cylindrical containers with different diameters to investigate possible boundary effects. The recorded trajectories were analyzed to study the influence of the diameter of the containers and the height of the suspension on the motion of the ball. The results showed that for different ratio’s of the height of the hydrogel suspension and diameter of the containers, the motion of the ball changes. S TUDENT NUMBERS 12859915 & 14262924 P RACTICE GROUP Group 1 S UPERVISOR Joshua Dijksman S UBJECT Research Practicum A SSIGNMENT Practice Report V ERSION Draft B ACHELOR Physics & Astrophysics 1 Introduction The motion of objects through fluids is an important topic in classical mechanics. Unlike motion in vacuum, an object moving through a fluid experiences resistance from the surrounding medium, which affects how its velocity changes over time. As a result, the motion of the object differs from simple uniformly accelerated motion. In this experiment, the vertical motion of a modified ping-pong ball rising through a viscous hydrogel suspension is studied. A hydrogel is a substance that consists of water combined with a polymer, forming a thick, gel-like non-Newtonian fluid that strongly resists motion [1][2]. This makes it suitable for observing the effects of fluid resistance over relatively short distances and times. By recording the position of the ball as a function of time, the influence of the viscous medium on the motion can be investigated. The height of the liquid was varied, and the experiment was repeated using cyllindrical containers with different diameters to study possible effects of the available travel distance and container size. The aim of this experiment is to investigate the vertical motion of the ping-pong ball rising through a hydrogel suspension, focusing on how the ratio of the height of the hydrogel suspension in the container and the diameter of the container influence the observed motion. Figure 1: A ping- pong ball is left to rise through a hydrogel suspension in a cylindrical vase. Figure 3: The ball Figure 2: The exper- was pushed to the iment was repeated center of the bottom for different heights of the vase with a of the suspension. metal rod, and then released from there. 2 2 Method and Setup 2.1 Experimental Setup For the experiment a viscous medium consisting of a hydrogel suspension was prepared in two cylindrical vases of different diameter and height. The hydrogel suspension was prepared by first heating Amsterdam tap-water until it reached boiling temperature, as to remove air from the water. Otherwise this air would later cause cavities in the hydrogen suspention and change its properties. The same water was then allowed to cool so that the vases, which were not heat resistant, would not break. Once cooled, small portions of hydrogel powder were gradually added to the water while continuously stirring gently. This process of adding powder and mixing was repeated until a homogeneous suspension was obtained. For the second vase, which had a diameter of 14.3 cm, a total volume of 2.35 L of water was used, requiring 14.61 g of hydrogel powder, corresponding to a concentration of approximately 6 g/L. For the first vase, with a diameter of 18.6 cm the suspension was an older sample with the same concentration, although the volume of the water was not known. This concentration was taken with accordance to [1] where in a similar experiment the the same concentration was used. The object used to rise through the hydrogel suspension was a standard orange ping-pong ball modified by adding weight in the form of water and a small magnet inside, resulting in a total mass of 16.4 g. The weight was added to slow the rising of the ball through the hydrogel suspension. The camera used was a Nikon 400Digital. The camera was set on a tripod placed at a distance of around 5 meters, away from the vase. The tripod ensured the stability of the video and vertical alignment to the motion of the bal. The distance of the camera to the vase was to minimize perspective distortion, which becomes significant when filming from close range. When recording a spherical object at short distances, small deviations in camera angle can Figure 4: A micrographic representation of the experimental setup of both cases. At the back of the container A3 paper was used to cover the vase, so that back-round reflections did not interfere with the experiment. The light source was placed a few centimeters away from the vase. The ping-pong ball was then released from the bottom, while filming it.(Hydrogel particles not to scale). 3 lead to apparent changes in position of the ping-pong ball that do not correspond to its actual motion. At the back of the vases paper sheets were taped to create a uniform background. In this way the ping-pong ball could be easily separated from the the background in later data processing and analysis. 2.2 Experimental Method To calibrate the measurement of positions in the videos, a ruler was placed in the field of view and a photograph was taken. This allowed the conversion of pixel distances to physical units (meters). The vases were filled with the hydrogel suspension to a certain height. Then the ball was pushed to the centre of the bottom of the vase using a thin metal rod, with a circular end, see figure 3. Then the ball was released and its trajectory to the top op the suspension captured on video with the Nikon 400Digital. After each video was taken, approximately 1 Liter of hydrogel suspension was removed and the procedure was repeated again. This was done by scooping with a beaker, which was first gently pushed into the suspension and then slowly moved around inside as to let the suspension settle and not change the concentration of the hydrogel. Between each take the suspension was stirred for a few minutes to get rid of the air bubbles that were formed by the scooping. 2.3 Data Analysis The recorded videos were analyzed using tracking software called ImageJ to obtain the vertical position of the ball as a function of time. We optimalised this proces by splitting the video in GBG color tracks. The blue track was most optimal for usage as the ball is orange and thus created a dark spot in the blue track. On this blue track a threshold was set by hand to isolate the ball from the background. Then tracking was used to record the horizontal position of the bal in each frame. Frame numbers were converted to time using the known frame rate of the recording, and pixel positions were converted to physical distances using the calibration from the ruler photograph. 3 Results The main experimental results are shown in figure 5 for the experiment in the vase with a diameter of 18.6 cm and 6 for the experiment in the vase with a diameter of 14.3 cm. Note that the time and distance axes are normalized. This was done to better compare the type of 4 motion for different runs of the experiment, as the traveling distance and time get shorter as the height of the hydrogel in the vase decreased. Figure 5: Repeated rising experiment in a vase with diameter of 18.6 cm filled with decreasing heights of hydrogel suspention of concentration 6 g/L. Each experiment is labeled by the ratio of the heigth of the hydrogel in the vase and the diameter of the vase (H/D). Time and travel distance are normalized. Discussion From the results we observe that the type of motion changes for different ratio’s of the height of the hydrogen suspension and the diameter of the vase. For higher ratio’s the curve is more convex while for lower ratio’s the curve becomes more concave. However in all curves there seems to be at least some part of the curve that is linear. Somehow the motion of the ball seems to be influenced by the boundary conditions, although this is not understood. In figure 6 a plateau can be clearly seen, with a size increasing as the height of the hydrogel decreases. This is an effect of the normalization. The plateau is caused by the ball reaching the top of the hydrogel, popping its “head” out of the suspension and slowing down. On shorter traveling lengths and so shorter experiment run-times, this plateau is percentage-wise longer, and so seems larger in the figure. It should be noted that the suspension in the vase of diameter 18.6 cm was old and contained dirt particles, which likely disturbed the properties of the suspension. Also in the experiment on this vase we had not yet optimized gentle scooping, and probably took more water 5 Figure 6: Repeated rising experiment in a vase with diameter of 14.3 cm filled with decreasing heights of hydrogel suspention of concentration 6 g/L. Each experiment is labeled by the ratio of the heigth of the hydrogel in the vase and the diameter of the vase (H/D). Time and travel distance are normalized. out than hydrogel particles and so altered the concentration on the suspension to some degree. The changing of the type of motion could thus be influenced by this. However the same change in motion-type is observed in the experiment on the vase with a diameter of 14.3 cm in which we were careful not to change the concentration. For future experiments, researchers could look at using vases of different shape to further investigate the effect of the boundary conditions on the motion of the particle. Another thing to look at is the motion of the ping-pong ball when it’s released from different heights inside the suspension, and the influence of this on the motion also compared to the data obtained by us. Conclusion In this experiment, we studied the rise of a weighted ping-pong ball in a hydrogel suspension and investigated how the motion depends on the ratio of the height of the suspension and the vase diameter. By introducing the height-to-diameter ratio, we were able to compare measurements performed in different containers in a consistent way. The results show that the rise of the sphere depend systematically on the height-to-diameter ratio. This demonstrates that the height of the hydrogel and the size of the vase play a significant role in the observed motion. 6 Although the results are interesting further experimentation is needed to understand the cause of this behavior. References [1] Joshua A. Dijksman and Tom Mullin. “Creep control in soft particle packings”. In: Physical Review Letters 128.23 (June 2022). DOI: 10.1103/physrevlett.128.238002. [2] Joshua A. Dijksman and Tom Mullin. “Confinement controls the creep rate in soft granular packings”. In: Soft Matter 20.19 (2024), pp. 4015–4020. DOI: 10.1039/d3sm01755a. 7
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )