SI Demo
Find the Error:
Equivalent Resistance
Matthew Schwarzer
Find the Error: Equivalent Resistance
Main Topics
Equivalent Resistance, Current, Voltage, Ohm’s Law
Resistor Circuit Problem
total current in the circuit
Instructions – Think, Pair, Share
Work in pairs. The solution below contains an error. Identify which step(s) are incorrect, explain
why using circuit rules (series/parallel), and write corrected steps. When you are finished,
compare with other groups.
(Do the problem first by yourself then compare to Andy’s solution to find where he went wrong.)
Hints and Reminders
• What are the series and parallel relationships in this circuit?
• Using the correct relationships, compute REQ step by step.
• Find the current flowing through the circuit.
Given Solution – Andy solved this problem and his solution is listed below. Can you find
the errors he made and identify what step of the problem he made them at?
1. R1 and R2 are in parallel, so R_top = 2/3 Ω.
2. R3 and R4 are in parallel, so R_bottom = 12/7 Ω.
3. Equivalent resistance R_top and R_bottom in series, so R_eq = 50/21 Ω
4. Current through R2 = 5.04A
Analysis
Step(s) flagged as incorrect (circle all that apply): Step 1
Step 2
Why are those step(s) wrong? (Discuss with your partner)
Step 3
Step 4
Find the Error: Equivalent Resistance
Notes and Answer Key
Error Identification
Steps 1 and 2 are incorrect.
Both steps mistakenly apply the parallel formula to resistors that are in series within a branch. R1
and R2 share a single current path (top branch) -- they are in series. Likewise R3 and R4 (bottom
branch) are in series.
Common Misconceptions
• Parallel = same branch: Students apply the parallel formula to any two resistors drawn side-by-side.
Remind them: parallel means sharing the SAME two nodes.
• Series = side-by-side on the diagram: Physical layout does not determine logic. Trace the current
path.
• Forgetting identical branch voltage: In parallel branches, both terminals share V_s = 12.0 V. Each
branch current follows Ohm's law independently.
• Cascading rounding errors: Using 1.81 Ω (rounded) gives 6.63 A instead of 5.71 A. Keep fractions or
extra decimal places until the final answer.
Extension Activity
Ask students to redraw the schematic with different values (e.g., R1=2 Ω, R2=3 Ω, R3=6 Ω,
R4=6 Ω) and compute R_eq from scratch. Then ask: which branch carries more current, and
why?
Corrected Step-by-Step Solution
1. R_top = 3 Ω
2. R_bottom = 7 Ω
3. R_eq = 2.1 Ω
4. I_total = V_s / R_eq = 12.0 / 2.1 = 5.714 A
Final Answers
Script
0:00-1:00
Distribute worksheet. Pairs read the circuit
diagram and pre-solved solution silently.
1:00-3:00
Pairs discuss: 'What rule determines series vs.
parallel?' Circulate and listen.
3:00-5:00
Pairs write corrected steps and compute numeric
answers.
5:00-8:00
Cold-call one pair. Class discussion on why Steps
1 & 2 fail.
8:00-10:00
Instructor live-solves on board using soln above.
Students self-check.
10:00-12:00
Extension: pairs swap resistor values and repeat
calculation.