1
Mittal
This Story is Not About Hate
Resistance in Steven J Ross’s “The Secret War Against Hate”
What does it mean to love a country that doesn’t love you back? This question pulses
through the opening chapters of Steven J. Ross’s The Secret War Against Hate. Ross chronicles a
nation divided between its founding ideals and the festering hatred lurking beneath them. The
war may have ended in Europe, but for Americans like Ross’s parents—Holocaust survivors who
changed their name from Rosenwaks to Ross—out of fear—it had just begun at home. Ross
realizes that January 6th, 2021, the riot against the Capitol in Washington DC, was not an
aberration, but the visible tip of a deeply buried, long-growing root system of hate—one that
began growing in the soil of post-WWII America. The story he tells is not a comfortable one; but
it is essential.
Ross makes a powerful case. After WWII, America split into two camps—those who
returned from war believing in the rising racial and religious equality, and those who felt
betrayed by the spread of tolerance, integration and intersectionality. The latter—the “Betrayed
Generation”—were not fringe lunatics but decorated veterans. They had just learned to kill and
were now eager to kill again: Black neighbors, Jewish colleagues, civil rights organizers, labor
unions; except this time, combat for a twisted vision of Americanism rooted in White Christian
supremacy. Those who believed equality was betrayal were convinced that what they were doing
was correct: attempting to “finish the job Hitler started.” The book documents the rise of postwar
fascism in America, noting significant faces such as those of Samuel Green, George Lincoln
Rockwell, and Jesse Stoner, who wanted to return undisputable white dominance. They revived
the Ku Klux Klan—or KKK— and founded new fascist parties, openly planning assassinations.
2
Mittal
A striking aspect of Ross’s account is how often the institutions of law and order that are
meant to have protected people didn’t. The FBI, for example, under J. Edgar Hoover ignored the
Klan’s violence, dismissed anti-fascist activists as “nothing more than a self-serving Communistinfluenced organization,” (35) and instead focused its efforts on “left-wing radicals” and
“communists”—which, as Ross shows, often meant Jewish Americans. Police departments,
ironically, were full of Klan members. One congressman referred to the Anti-Defamation
League—henceforth “ADL”—as a “Gestapo for the Bnai Brith” or “Yiddish Ku Klux Klan” and
“accused them of “carrying on the most vicious prosecution of white Gentiles ever known in this
country” (30). That is not just hateful—it is almost as if it was meant to inspire negative
stereotypes—and transitively, more hate.
But, The Secret War Against Hate is not a story about hate. It’s a story about the war
against it— it is a story about resistance—quiet, dangerous, and incredibly brave resistance. This
failure of institutions forced everyday citizens to take action. Organizations like the ADL, the
American Jewish Committee, and the Non-Sectarian Anti-Nazi League began organizing a
massive, secret, resistance movement. Ross introduces a cast of unlikely heroes: spies. People
who infiltrated hate groups, risked their lives, and worked in secret to protect the country from its
own citizens. James Sheldon, for example, the Methodist who ran the Non-Sectarian Anti-Nazi
League, who hired spies to rise in fascist organizations and sabotage them internally. Or, Stetson
Kennedy, for instance, was a journalist who joined the KKK under a fake name “John S.
Perkins” and attended meetings every Monday night, writing detailed reports for the AntiDefamation League and other groups. He was not a superhero; he was a man shaped by pain,
who saw something wrong and decided not to look the other way.
3
Mittal
Another instance, truly Ross’s unlikely hero, Kennedy, who infiltrated the Klan’s most
violent faction—the Klavalier Klub—which specialized in beatings and lynchings. If exposed, he
would have been tortured so much that death would be a sweet release. Ross describes how
Kennedy “began sleeping with a .32 automatic under his pillow” (24) because death felt
imminent and probable. Think about it—a spy in a white robe, reciting oaths he believes against,
surrounded by murderers who would likely auction the chance for his blood if they knew the
truth. That horrifying image, fragile but defiant, encapsulates the book’s emotional gravity. Many
of the spies weren’t even Jewish—they were Christians, veterans, and civil servants who worked
to protect human rights.
Ross’s writing insists that this history is not distant. It is not a museum piece. Ross draws
a straight line from 1945 to Charlottesville in 2017 to the Capitol riots in 2021. The slogans may
change, but the logic of white supremacy doesn’t. Ross’s writing shows us that hate doesn’t
always announce itself with a swastika. It often shows up in small ways: a housing committee
monitoring who sells to Black families, a judge who turns a blind eye, a radio show that spreads
fear. In the 1940s, Atlanta’s police department, city council, and judiciary were all infiltrated by
the Klan. The image of a Black veteran returning from war—still in uniform—only to be beaten
or murdered for trying to vote, should enrage anyone who believes in justice. And yet, as Ross
points out, it happened again and again. And it still happens, in different ways, today.
It’s easy to call people like Kennedy and the spies heroes, but Ross doesn’t romanticize
them. They were scared, flawed, and deeply human—as are we. They didn’t always agree, and
they didn’t always win, but they kept going. And maybe that’s the most important takeaway of
all: resistance is possible. Not perfect and never easy—but possible. And it is urgent. After all,
The Secret War Against Hate doesn’t ask us to be spies. It just asks us not to be silent.
4
Mittal
Hi Rishima,
An excellent review. I thought you captured the spirit of the book and its main argument.
I also thought your concluding paragraph was powerful and on the money. This is your best
writing yet.
GRADE: A