Jones 1
Dayton Jones
Dr. Lueras
HIST 2503.01
13 March 2025
Surviving the New South: Resistance, Reform, and Resilience
Following the Civil War and the Reconstruction Era, life for African Americans in the
New South was challenging. Lynching, disenfranchisement, and economic oppression were the
tools of white supremacy to curb Black Americans' freedom and rights. Yet, African Americans
responded to such harsh conditions with economic independence, activism, and political
activism. Women like Ida B. Wells-Barnett and Booker T. Washington were two different types
of resistance, and events like the Wilmington Race Riot showed the terrible resistance to Black
progress. African Americans struggled to pursue justice and equality through overwhelming odds
in the New South.
One of the most vocal activists against racial violence was arguably Ida B. Wells-Barnett,
a journalist and anti-lynching crusader. She laid open the horrific truth of lynching, something
that was usually justified by false claims against Black men. In her "Lynch Law in America,"
Wells-Barnett explained, "Our country's national crime is lynching. It is not the creature of an
hour, the sudden outburst of uncontrolled fury, or the unspeakable brutality of an insane mob. It
represents the cool, calculating deliberation of intelligent people who openly avow that there is
an 'unwritten law' that justifies them in putting human beings to death without complaint under
oath, without trial by jury, without opportunity to make defense, and without right of appeal.
Jones 2
(Wells-Barnett, 10)” This remark emphasized the fact that lynching was not a case of random
violence but a well-planned attempt to continue white supremacy.
Furthermore, in "A Red Record," Wells-Barnett challenged that lynching was simply in
defense of white women and wrote, "Statistics show that not one-third of the victims of
lynchings are even charged with such crimes.” (Wells-Barnett, 10) Through gathering evidence
and insisting on global awareness, she sought to dismantle false accounts used for racial violence
excuses. Her activism laid the groundwork for future civil rights activity, demonstrating that
legal change and visibility were needed to combat racial terror. Wells-Barnett’s struggle ties in
with when federal soldiers were withdrawn from the South after the Compromise of 1877. White
supremacist violence reached new heights and federal action was lacking to curb it leading the
Ku Klux Klan and other terrorist organizations to grow, and Wells-Barnett's calls for
legal fixes and federal action becoming more urgent. But without national support, African
Americans were all the more vulnerable to state-sanctioned racial violence.
Whereas Wells-Barnett pursued a direct form of activism, Booker T. Washington
promoted a different approach. Washington advocated economic self-sufficiency, vocational
education, and gradual social change. In an oration in tribute to Abraham Lincoln, he argued that
economic independence was necessary to racial advancement: "Freedom from debt, comfortable
homes, profitable employment, intelligence, bring a self-respect and confidence, without which
no race can get on its feet. (Washington, 1)" He believed that African Americans would focus on
industrial education and wealth rather than active politics in the immediate future. Washington
also encouraged Black Americans to be proud of their labor, for he proclaimed, "We must learn
to put brains and skill into the common occupations about our doors, and we must learn to
dignify common labor. (Washington, 2)" His philosophy resonated with many white Americans,
Jones 3
particularly in the South, because it did not openly reject the existing racial hierarchy. Some
African Americans and civil rights activists, however, criticized his approach for being too
acquiescent to white supremacist ideology. Despite these criticisms, Washington's philosophy
had a lasting and deep impact on Black economic advancement and education. His efforts
to create schools like the Tuskegee Institute provided African Americans
with tangible abilities and opportunities and allowed them to build communities
that offered strength and resilience.
African American attempts at political engagement were responded to with brutal
counterattacks, like the Wilmington Race Riot of 1898. White supremacist politicians, among
them Alfred M. Waddell, instigated a violent coup d'état to overthrow the city's multiracial
government. Waddell justified the brutality by saying, "We will not live under these intolerable
conditions. No society can stand it. We intend to change it, if we have to choke the current of the
Cape Fear River with carcasses. (Waddell, 1)" His words are a testament to the extreme measures
white supremacists employed to stop Black political activity. The violence that followed the riot
left the Black community in fear and reversed the progress they had made. Waddell boasted that
the coup had been so successful in repressing Black resistance, quoting, "Rumors fly here and
there that the negroes are arming. There is no truth in that. They are utterly cowed and crushed,
and are not going to interfere with anybody. (Waddel 3)" This event demonstrated that even with
the aspirations of political participation of African Americans, white supremacist groups used
violence and intimidation to maintain their dominance.
African Americans responded in varied ways to the new reality of the New South. Booker
T. Washington advocated economic self-sufficiency and vocational education as the path to
achieve improvement, and Ida B. Wells-Barnett organized activism and press campaigns against
Jones 4
racial terror. Thereafter followed the Wilmington Race Riot to illustrate African Americans'
forcibly encountered opposition if they sought equality in politics. These diverse responses
reflected the greater struggle for civil rights—a struggle that would burn late into the 20th
century. Even amidst constant oppression, African Americans pressed on in their fight for justice,
setting the stage for future generations to resist racial inequality.
Jones 5
Works Cited
Waddell, Alfred M. “The Story of the Wilmington, NC Race Riots.” Collier’s Weekly, 26 Nov.
1898.
Washington, Booker T. Speech #2. Abraham Lincoln Day Address
Wells-Barnett, Ida B. A Red Record. 1895. Reprinted in Southern Horrors and Other Writings:
The Anti-Lynching Campaign of Ida B. Wells, 1892-1900, edited by Jacqueline Jones
Royster, Bedford Books, 1997, pp. 73, 75-78, 80-81, 82-87, 131-32, 138-40, 146-147,
153-155.
Wells-Barnett, Ida B. “Lynch Law in America.” The Arena, vol. 23, Jan. 1900, pp. 15-24.