Motion Detection USB5V
Review and comments
1. Shorting DN with DP in USB-C Done
If you short them:
differential voltage of these lines becomes 0V
host PHY may detect fault conditions
can increase current/noise
may violate USB electrical specs
Please reconsider removing the 0 ohm resistors
2. Using DWA01A as protection IC
o Why using DW01A and FS8205A while the charger IC has its own protection
(Undervoltage overdischarge and Overvoltage or overcharge)?
as a backup for BQ (it is connected directly between gnd and -ve terminal of
BAT) + feasibility recommendation (FM7021DB) which is for 2 cells , dw01a for 1
cell
3. Using inductors instead of ferrite beads (DONE)
o If your intention is to use filtering component for the power rail, use the ferrite
bead instead of actual inductor (ferrite bead is optimized for this job)
4. Adding ferrite bead in XTAL lines (DONE)
o XTAL lines already has high frequency components, which will face impedance by
the ferrite beads you put which may lead to
Phase shift in the crystal signal
Jitter increase
Higher load on the crystal its self
Degradation in the signal
o We recommend removing this bead
5. ESP32-C6 Boot mode (DONE)
Since your intention is the second boot mode, please put GPIO9 to GND
6. Unused pins (DONE)
Please add the X symbol to the unused signal, this make it easier to the assembly engineer to
understand and ignore the signals when debugging.
7. 0 ohms resistors in the SPI lines (DONE)
Is there a reason for the 0-ohm resistors in the SPI lines? It just adds up in the BOM
8. Using pull-down resistor on the PIR sensor output??? Is there a reason? (DONE)
9. Matching circuit component values has range?? (DONE)
Please specify single value and pick up a part number for each one (note that the part
numbers for the capacitors are obsolete)
You can use these combinations (previously tried)
Make sure that the packages are 0402 or smaller and the capacitor type is C0G/NP0 DONE
And make sure that the trace layout is 50 ohms matched (use online calculator) DONE
10. BOM Comments
Please take care of the following:
-
Provide an LCSC part number along with the Digikey part number (because we
mostly order from LCSC)
There are multiple components without part number (please add them)
Remove anything that is not purchasable from the BOM (ex: the PCB antenna)
11. PCB layout comments
- Please consider mounting holes and dimensions of the board with the mechanical
engineer
- Please Consider the 50-ohm impedance of the trace between the matching circuit
and the antenna
- The dimension annotation should be in invisible layer (not the top overlay because
the manufacturer will comment)
- There no need to make the antenna outside the board, there is a room to make it
inside