Conscience VS Guilt
The Importance of
Conscience
Conscience in the teaching of the
Church
∙ Conscience is the voice that calls us to love,
to do what is good and avoid evil
∙ A law inscribed on the human heart by God
∙ Our most secret core, it is where we are
alone with God
∙ Conscience is not a feeling, it is a judgement
3
∙ Conscience is a radical experience of
ourselves as moral agents.
∙ The choice to be authentic (true to
ourselves) or inauthentic (acting against our
own beliefs and values)
4
It often happens that conscience goes astray through
ignorance, which it is unable to avoid
This cannot be said of the person who takes little trouble to
find out what is true and good, or when conscience is
blinded through the habit of committing sin
5
Conscience vs. Superego
∙ Freud believed that our personalities have
three structures:
6
Freud’s Three
Structures
The Id
● The unconscious reservoir of
instinctual drives
(the pleasure principle)
8
The Ego
●
The conscious structure
that regulates the forces of
the Id, the demands of
society and the reality of
the physical world.
9
The Superego
● The standards and
regulations of authority
figures that regulate our
conduct by using guilt and
fear of punishment
10
●
The Superego does play an important role in moral development. Our parents and
others have taught us important lessons.
●
An immature conscience depends on these teachers to guide us. A mature
conscience integrates these important values, so that they become one’s own
values.
●
This does not mean that once we have a mature conscience, we no longer need the
superego
●
We still need it in order to continue to develop based on our experiences
11
Superego = “shoulds” or “have tos”
This comes from the process of absorbing the regulations and restrictions of those who love us
We listen in order not to lose love
Conscience = “wants”
The conscience acts in love to commit ourselves to values
We act this way to be like the people we admire and to carry on the actions that we have come
to learn as moral
We do not act out of fear but out of want
12
Conscience:
● Is not a feeling of guilt, but this feeling can
signal that are actions are wrong.
● Is not based on “shoulds”, or the fear of losing
love and approval.
● Conscience is based on committing ourselves
to a set of values.
13
Three senses of conscience:
3 Senses of Conscience
Conscience as Capacity
Conscience as Process
Conscience as Judgement
-Our capacity to know and
-How to perceive and think
-What I must do in a situation
do good, and avoid evil
correctly through reflection
based on personal
-Sense of value and personal
and analysis
perception and values
responsibility
-Must be formed (through
-Conscience expresses the
-Awareness that there is right
wisdom of others) and
truth of who you are as a
and wrong
examined
person
15
Conscience as Capacity
Conscience as Process
Conscience as Judgement
Capacity, process, judgement
A capacity for knowing and doing what is good, and avoiding what is evil.
A process for discovering the good, discernment, correct seeing and right thinking.
A judgment that moves me from correct seeing and thinking to action and commitment.
An informed conscience
considers:
1. Scripture
2. Church Teachings and Church Tradition *Think about virtues
3. Our present Christian community’s guidance (parents,
chaplain, guidance counsellor, priest, friend)
21
4. Humility (we see over time that we can make
mistakes in judgment)
5. The Eucharist (we believe God’s grace helps
us)
• Factors that can cloud conscience are such
things as ignorance, passions, and conformity.
22
Kinds of
Conscience
23
1.
Well formed Conscience
1. Well formed
Conscience
This conscience is formed by using
the three sources: scripture, church
and community.
• At times, having a well-formed
conscience entails recognizing one’s
own guilt from past wrongdoings
and what such an experience taught.
25
Ex: Once he was released from
prison, Sam turned down his
friend’s offer to rejoin the crime
ring to which Sam had
belonged. While in prison, he
read the bible and was
counselled by a priest that had
shown him the error in his
ways.
26
1.
Well formed Conscience
2. Wrongly formed
Conscience
● Conscience formed on information that is
mistaken, based on faulty reasoning or faulty value
• Ex. Paula was told that her boyfriend was cheating
on her. She broke up with him, only to find out later
that it was a false rumour spread by someone who
hated her.
28
29
1.
Well formed Conscience
3. Lax Conscience
Not being concerned about whether or not an act is
right or wrong.
• Ex. When Joe finished building a basement
apartment in his house, he took all the industrial
garbage and threw it in a ditch down the side of a
county road. He said, “It isn’t very much. It won’t hurt
anyone.”
31
1.
Well formed Conscience
4. Legalistic
Conscience
Obeying rules perfectly; following the letter of the law
rather than the spirit of the law.
• Ex. Beatrice goes to school every day, even when
she is sick.
33
What is Guilt?
Guilt
Guilt is feeling self-conscious and experiencing a sense of distress about your
potential responsibility for a negative outcome.
Like all self-conscious emotions, guilt originates from a process of self-evaluation
and introspection and may involve your perception of how others value you.
Self-conscious awareness of guilt should result in a readiness to take action to undo
or mitigate this wrong
35
Kinds of Guilt
Warranted Guilt
When we know an act is wrong and we do it anyway and then
recognize and accept that what we did was, in fact, wrong.
• Ex. Ron knew that it would seriously hurt Sarah if he stole her
iPod. She loved music so much. He felt guilty after stealing it.
37
Unwarranted Guilt
There is no real justifiable reason to feel guilty. This guilt
occurs when we have a wrongly formed conscience.
• Ex. Huck Finn helped Jim escape slavery and then felt
guilty for helping him because slavery was legal in the civil
law
38
Too Little Guilt
Becoming accustomed to sin and therefore feeling immune to
wrongdoing. This guilt occurs when we have a lax conscience.
• Ex. After selling drugs for 10 years, Jim said he just didn’t care.
He said, “Hey, if people want to buy it, that’s their business. I’m
not responsible.”
39
Excessive Guilt
Guilt out of proportion to the severity of the wrongdoing. This
guilt occurs when we have a legalistic conscience.
• Ex. Tracey cried the first time she was late to class. She felt
like she was a “bad” student.
40