Noah Daily
Mrs. McVay
Research Writing
3/25/26
Trades vs. College: Why Trades Make More Sense
Choosing what to do after high school can be really stressful. Some people think the only way to
succeed is to go to college, but that’s not always true. Trades are a real option that can lead to
good money, job stability, and hands-on work that’s actually fun. I believe pursuing a trade, like
becoming an auto technician, is better for me than going to college. While college has its
benefits, trades give you skills you can use right away, save money, and start making a career
faster.
Some people say college is the best path because it can lead to higher salaries and more
opportunities in some careers. College can teach you things you might not learn anywhere else
and might open doors to different jobs (Carnevale et al. 12). There are also social experiences
and networking that can help you later in life. Going to college can give people a sense of
independence and help them grow as individuals. These are all good reasons, and it’s true that for
some careers, college is required.
But college also has a lot of downsides. First, it’s really expensive. Tuition, books, and fees can
cost tens of thousands of dollars, and most students graduate with a lot of debt (Friedman 45).
Also, going to college doesn’t guarantee a job after graduation. Many college graduates struggle
to find work in their field or start in jobs that don’t pay very much, which can be frustrating after
spending so much money. Meanwhile, trades often pay well right away and usually don’t require
student loans.
Trade careers give people practical, hands-on skills that employers actually need. Auto
technicians, electricians, plumbers, and other tradespeople are always in demand (Bureau of
Labor Statistics). Trades are jobs you can start learning while still in high school or right after
graduation, so you can start earning money much faster than a college student who spends four
years in school. For me, becoming an auto technician means I can learn the skills I want, work
with my hands, and build a career without being buried in debt.
Some might say college offers more flexibility in the long run, and that’s true to a degree.
College can lead to jobs in fields like medicine, law, or business management. However, trades
also offer flexibility and advancement. Skilled tradespeople can open their own businesses,
specialize in certain areas, or work for high-paying companies. In some cases, top tradespeople
earn more than people with a college degree (Miller 78).
Another reason trades make sense is job stability. Many trades are essential, so people will
always need them, no matter what happens in the economy. Cars break down, houses need
wiring, pipes leak, and all of these things require someone who knows what they’re doing.
College graduates might enter fields that are more affected by economic changes or outsourcing.
Trades are practical, reliable, and less likely to disappear.
Besides money and stability, trades are satisfying for people who like working with their hands.
College often focuses on theory, writing papers, and exams, which isn’t for everyone. Being an
auto technician means I get to fix problems, see results, and feel like my work matters. That
hands-on experience is motivating and can make work enjoyable rather than just something you
endure.
Some people worry that trades won’t offer as much personal growth or social networking as
college. While it’s true that college can provide some experiences you don’t get elsewhere, trades
also involve teamwork, problem-solving, and learning from experienced mentors. You can still
meet people, gain independence, and grow without sitting in a lecture hall for four years.
In conclusion, while college has its benefits, trades offer practical skills, less debt, job stability,
and personal satisfaction. For me, becoming an auto technician is the right choice because it
gives me the opportunity to learn a valuable skill, start a career fast, and work in a field I enjoy.
Trades are a path that more people should consider because they provide real opportunities
without the unnecessary stress and expense of college.
Works Cited
Bureau of Labor Statistics. Occupational Outlook Handbook: Skilled Trades. U.S. Department of
Labor, 2023, www.bls.gov/ooh/.
Carnevale, Anthony P., et al. The College Payoff: An Update. Georgetown University Center on
Education and the Workforce, 2021.
Friedman, Zack. The True Cost of College Tuition. Forbes, 10 Aug. 2022,
www.forbes.com/sites/zackfriedman/2022/08/10/the-true-cost-of-college-tuition/.
Miller, Greg. Why Skilled Trades Are a Smart Career Choice. CNBC, 15 Jan. 2023,
www.cnbc.com/2023/01/15/why-skilled-trades-are-a-smart-career-choice.html.