School of
Engineering
System Stability
Principles of Control
Dr Zhanfang Zhao
Office: T-815
zhaoza@lsbu.ac.uk
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
School of
Engineering
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
Outline
School of
Engineering
• Impulse response as inverse Laplace transform of
system transfer function
• System poles and impulse response
• The s-plane and system stability assessment
• Time constant
• Approximation of higher-order systems by secondorder
• Routh-Hurwitz stability test
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
System Stability
School of
Engineering
Consider a system with input u(t) and output y(t).
Let the transfer function of the system be denoted
H(s);
Y s
H s
U s
Let the input u(t) be a unit impulse;
1 for t 0
u t t
0 otherwise
Thus, H s
Or U s L t 1
Y s Y s
Y s
U s
1
This is Laplace transform of response of the system to a unit
impulse, and is equal to the system transfer function;
Thus, transfer function of system is also referred to as
Laplace transform of IMPULSE RESPONSE of the system.
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
System Stability
School of
Engineering
System impulse response is therefore
ht L1H s
For a system to be stable its impulse response is required to
be bounded by a finite value over time; i.e. the system impulse
response does not grow to infinity over time.
We can assess system stability from its transfer function or
from its impulse response function.
For example, consider
H s
1
, where a is real number. System pole is at s a
sa
ht e at
EEE_5_POC
for a 0, ht is decalying exponential; system stable
for a 0, ht 1 ; system stable
for a 0, ht is growing exponential; system unstable
ZZ/EEE
System Stability
School of
Engineering
For a system transfer function with complex poles,
Let
H s
s a
2
2
,
a and real numbers. System poles : s a j
Impulse response of system is:
ht L1H s e at sin t
for a 0, ht is exponentially decalying sine; system stable
thus for a 0, ht sin t ; system stable
for a 0, ht is exponentially growing sine; system unstable
Therefore, for a system to be stable, require real part of pole
of the system transfer function to be less than or equal to zero.
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
System Stability
School of
Engineering
For graphical assessment of stability of a system we plot poles
of transfer function of the system in the complex s-plane.
2
H s
,
s5
System pole : s 5
3
H s
,
s 1s 2
System poles : s 1, s 2
H s
4
s 3 16
2
System poles : s 3 j 4
Im
Im
Im
,
+j4
–5
(Stable)
Re
–1
+2
(Unstable)
Re
–3
Re
–j4
(Stable)
Thus, for a system to be stable, require poles of the system
transfer function to be on the left-hand-side (LHS) of s-plane.
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
System Stability
School of
Engineering
Time constant: Refers to the time duration at which the
system response changes by a certain percentage.
For example, if a step input is applied to a system then the
system response will reach 63.2% at one time constant.
For a system with transfer function;
a
a
1
H s
, Time constant is , System pole : s
s 1 s 1
For example, for H s 1 ,
s4
System time constant :
System pole : s 4
EEE_5_POC
1
0.25 sec
4
ZZ/EEE
Approximation of Higher-Order
Systems by Second-Order
School of
Engineering
The time response of a stable system is dominated by
negative poles that are closer to the imaginary axis than the
other negative poles of the system which are further to the
left of these poles.
For approximation require two dominant poles that give a
longer lasting transient response, while the transient due to
the other poles dies out much faster.
For example, consider
1
e 10t , Pole at s 10, Time constant : 0.1 sec
s 10
The signal decays to 36.2% of its initial value in 0.1 second
1
e t , Pole at s 1, Time constant : 1 sec
s 1
The signal decays to 36.2% of its initial value in 1 second
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
Approximation of Higher-Order
Systems by Second-Order
School of
Engineering
Consider the third order system
G s
s 1 j 3
Y s
100
2
, Poles :
s 10
U s s 2 s 10 s 10
The transient response is dominated by the two complex
poles, as the transient due to s = –10 is short lived and dies in
about 0.1 seconds;
Thus, the third order system can therefore be approximated
by the second-order system
G s
EEE_5_POC
Y s
10
2
U s s 2 s 10
Note: for s = 0, G(s) = 1 in
both 3rd-order and 2nd-order
systems; Final-Value Theorem
ZZ/EEE
Routh-Hurwitz Stability Test
School of
Engineering
• For low order systems such as first, second or third order, it is
easy to find the poles of system transfer function, and hence
assess whether it is stable or not.
• For higher-order systems one will need numerical algorithms
to find roots of the characteristic polynomial (e.g. NewtonRaphson, repeated bi-section, etc.).
• Since interest will be to determine whether a system is stable
or not, the Routh-Hurwitz method enables one to determine
whether any of the poles are on the right-hand side of the splane.
• The method does not give actual values of poles, but only
number of poles that lie on the right-hand s-plane.
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
Routh-Hurwitz Method
School of
Engineering
Let the characteristic polynomial of a system (denominator of its
transfer function) be given by
as 4 bs 3 cs 2 ds e
Create the Routh-Hurwitz table as follows
a
c
e 0
First row contains alternate coeffients of polynomial
b
d
0 0
Second row contains the remailing alternate coeffients
f
g
0 0
h
0
0 0
g
The first element f in the third row is given by the negative
determinant of 22 matrix formed of first and second columns in
the preceding two rows, divided by the value in bottom left-hand
column of this matrix.
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
Routh-Hurwitz Method
f
a
School of
Engineering
c
b d ad bc bc ad
b
b
b
The second element g in the third row is given by the negative
determinant of 22 matrix formed of first and third columns in
the preceding two rows, divided by the value in bottom left-hand
column of this matrix.
g
a e
b 0 a 0 be be
e
b
b
b
Similarly, the third element in the third row would be the negative
determinant of 22 matrix formed of first and fourth columns in
the preceding two rows, divided by the value in bottom left-hand
column of this matrix, and the outcome will be zero, as the entries
in fourth column are all zero.
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
Routh-Hurwitz Method
School of
Engineering
The fourth row will be similarly constructed by creating 22
matrices from the two rows above it. Thus,
a
c
b
bc ad
f
b
fd bg
h
f
d
be a 0
g
b
f 0 b0
j
f
e
0
0
0
b0 a0
0
b
0
0
TEST FOR STABILITY: Look at the first column of the
resulting table and starting from the top row, find the number of
SIGN changes as you go down the first column. The number of
sign changes is equal to the number of poles in the right-hand
side (RHS) of the s-plane.
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
Routh-Hurwitz Method
School of
Engineering
Example
How many poles, if any, of the following characteristic
polynomial are in the unstable region on the s-plane?
s 4 8s 3 17 s 2 2 s 24
Form Routh-Hurwitz table
1
8
8 17 (2 1) 138
8
8
138 192
2
8
8 8
398
138
8
8
192
8
EEE_5_POC
17
24
0
2
0
0
(24 8) 1 0 192 8 0 1 0
0 0
8
8
8
138
0 (8 0)
8
0
0
0
138
8
0
0
0
ZZ/EEE
Routh-Hurwitz Method
School of
Engineering
The resulting Routh-Hurwitz table is thus
1
17
24 0
8
138
8
398
8
192
8
2
192
8
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
The number of sign changes in the first column is only one as the
fourth positive element changes to a negative value in the fifth
row. Therefore, there is one pole in the right-hand side of the splane
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE
Routh-Hurwitz Method
School of
Engineering
Example-2
Find the number of poles, if any, of the following characteristic
polynomial that are in the unstable region on the s-plane.
s 3 4s 2 s 6
Form Routh-Hurwitz table
1
1
0
4
6
0
1 6 4 1
1 0 4 0
2 .5
0
0
4
4
4 0 2 .5 6
4 0 2 .5 0
6
0 0
2 .5
2 .5
1
1 0
4 6 0
2 .5 0 0
6
0 0
The number of sign changes in the first column is two. Therefore,
there are two poles of the system in the RHS of the s-plane.
EEE_5_POC
ZZ/EEE