The Tank Company Case
Group members:
Ali Elguermai – 0891087
Meftah Dakheel – 0888617
1. Main Characters and Their Roles, and the Objective of Each
Planning Type
Main Characters:
Joseph Owner/Operations Leader
Joseph leads The Tank Company and sets the overall strategic direction, he prioritizes
high product quality while strongly emphasizing cost minimization, his guiding principle
“the lowest cost is always boss” drives all operational decisions, he also suggests
maintaining an initial inventory of 500 units to avoid stockouts.
Dina Production Manager
Dina is responsible for developing the company’s capacity plan, she evaluates different
strategies (level, chase, or mixed) to meet demand at the lowest possible cost while
maintaining quality and avoiding shortage, and she collaborates with both production
and sales teams.
Caroline Sales Manager
Caroline forecasts customer demand and represents market needs, she prefers a
flexible approach, suggesting production should match demand directly to avoid
unnecessary inventory.
Production Team
The production team prefers a stable and predictable workflow, meaning consistent
production levels and minimal workforce fluctuations, their preference aligns with a level
production strategy.
Objectives of Each Planning Type:
Level Production Strategy
The aim is to generate the same quantity of units monthly, and the workforce will be
constant.
•Benefits: Stability in the workforce, predictability, increased morale, and
easier planning.
Costs -Inventory carrying costs can rise during the low-demand months.
•Purpose: The reduction of fluctuations in hiring, layoffs, and month-to-month
fluctuations.
Chase Production Strategy
The aim is to meet the needs of the months by beaming the workforce up and down
accordingly (recruiting/firing).
•Benefits: Minimal inventory holding expenses.
•Costs: There could be an increase in the costs of hiring, training, and layoffs.
•Purpose: Reduction in inventory accumulation and, at the same time, fulfilling
the demand of each month exactly.
2. Development of Chase and Level Plans and Identification of the
Lower-Cost Option
Given Data
Total Demand = 5,376 units
Average Demand = 448 units/month
Starting Inventory = 500 units
Cost per unit = $1,000
Holding cost = $18/unit/month
Hiring cost = $1,000/worker
Layoff cost = $500/worker
1 worker = 160 hours/month
1 unit = 10 hours
Level Plan
Workforce Calculation
Monthly production = 448 units
Required hours = 448 × 10 = 4,480 hours
Workforce = 4,480 ÷ 160 = 28 workers
Starting workforce = 10 → Hire 18 workers
Hiring Cost = 18 × $1,000 = $18,000
Inventory Plan
Month
Demand
Production
Ending Inventory
Jan
407
448
541
Feb
425
448
564
Mar
500
448
512
Apr
575
448
385
May
525
448
308
Jun
500
448
256
Jul
475
448
229
Aug
450
448
227
Sep
500
448
175
Oct
400
448
223
Nov
325
448
346
Dec
294
448
500
Holding Cost Calculation
Total inventory over the year = 4,266 units
Holding Cost = 4,266 × $18 = $76,788
Total Level Plan Cost
Hiring Cost = $18,000
Holding Cost = $76,788
Total = $94,788
Chase Plan
Workforce & Hiring/Layoff Plan
Month
Demand
Workers
Hire
Layoff
Jan
407
26
16
0
Feb
425
27
1
0
Mar
500
31
4
0
Apr
575
36
5
0
May
525
33
0
3
Jun
500
31
0
2
Jul
475
30
0
1
Aug
450
28
0
2
Sep
500
31
3
0
Oct
400
25
0
6
Nov
325
21
0
4
Dec
294
19
0
2
Cost Calculation
Total Hiring = 29 workers → $29,000
Total Layoffs = 20 workers → $10,000
Holding Cost = minimal (starting inventory used early)
Total Chase Plan Cost
Hiring Cost = $29,000
Layoff Cost = $10,000
Total = $39,000
Final Comparison
Level Plan Total Cost = $94,788
Chase Plan Total Cost = $39,000
Thus, chase plan is cheaper by $55,788
3. How Dina Could Further Reduce Costs and Challenge Assumptions
Dina can further reduce costs by improving assumptions and adopting a more flexible
strategy:
1. Use a Mixed Strategy
Combine level and chase approaches:
Maintain a stable base workforce
Adjust slightly during peak months
This reduces both inventory and hiring/layoff costs
*2. Reduce Initial Inventory
Starting with 500 units creates high holding costs.
Reducing to 300–400 units would lower total inventory costs without risking stockouts.
3. Improve Productivity
Reducing production time from 10 hours to 9 hours per unit:
Lowers required workforce
Reduces labor-related costs
4. Use Overtime Instead of Hiring
Instead of hiring temporary workers:
Use overtime during peak months
Avoid hiring and layoff costs
5. Maintain Safety Stock Instead of Excess Inventory
Keep a smaller buffer (150 to 250 units) instead of large inventory levels to reduce
holding costs while still protecting against uncertainty.
Conclusion:
The analysis shows that while the level strategy provides stability, it results in high
inventory holding costs. The chase strategy minimizes inventory and results in
significantly lower total cost.
The chase plan is the optimal solution, saving $55,788 compared to the level plan.
Further improvements can be achieved through a mixed strategy, better inventory
management, and increased productivity.