Luis Hernandez
Dr.Brian Malone
EWRT D001A Composition And Reading
11 July 2021
A Portrayal of a Just History
Have you ever thought of the impact a musical can have on society? Or how people
would react and be influenced by it. To grasp this, we need to understand what visionary fiction
exactly is, a type of genre in writing that is about creating a just world free of modern-day
problems, for example, racial inequality. This is shown in the iconic musical Hamilton: An
American Musical, created by Lin-Manuel Miranda. The show follows the life of Alexander
Hamilton, an orphan from the Caribbean, set on making a better life for himself. When he arrives
in New York, he meets different people such as Aaron Burr, Lafayette, John Laurens. Eventually,
Hamilton ends up marrying his wife, Eliza, and helps win the Revolutionary War. As the story
moves forward, Hamilton is faced with more problems, such as Thomas Jefferson disagreeing
with Hamilton on having a national bank. Tragedy also strikes with the death of Hamilton’s son,
and Hamilton’s eventual end is his affair, which led to his son’s death. Ultimately, Hamilton is
shot to death in a duel against Aaron Burr. Despite its popularity, Hamilton doesn’t represent
visionary fiction by erasing the issue of slavery, not having an accurate representation of women,
and whitewashing history.
By having an inaccurate representation of history, the narrative can easily be changed to
accommodate modern times. Lyra D. Monteiro explains in “Race-Conscious Casting and the
Erasure of the Black Past in Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hamilton” how the reality of slavery was
unavoidable in everyday life. She states, “During the Revolutionary era, around 14 percent of
New York City’s inhabitants were African American, the majority of whom were enslaved. In the
Caribbean, in the 1790s, a slave was present in one in five of the city’s white households.”
(Monteiro 93/94). By not including slaves and the history of slavery within the musical when
they had many chances, the show completely erases the fact that slavery existed, even though
owning slaves was common. This portrayal clashes with reality. In the musical, Hamilton is seen
as a man who wants to help everyone be free, but as Jennifer Schuessler points out in “Alexander
Hamilton, Enslaver? New Research Says Yes,” Hamilton actually owned and sold slaves for the
Schuyler family and also others, she writes. “Hamilton married into the powerful Schuyler
family in 1780. Slavery was common among New York State’s elite, and the Schuylers were
some of the largest slaveholders in their area, with more than 40 people enslaved at the Albany
mansion and another estate over the years.” (13). Omitting this information furthers the narrative
of erasing slavery from the story. Since audiences don't concern themselves with problems that
don't appear in the story, those staples of history are taken away. This leaves no representation
for a group that has been underrepresented for centuries, ultimately portraying Hamilton in a
positive light once again.
Some might argue that downplaying slavery makes history easier to digest, similar to
how some schools whitewash history to make white figures stand out. However, I reject this
argument. Bending history to make it seem 'nicer' than reality actually hurts those involved.
Changing the narrative to imply that the era of slavery was kind—or ignoring it entirely—does
harm to the audience because it removes a key piece of history. Denying its existence is an
offense in itself.
Furthermore, the lack of female representation beyond simple commodities hurts the narrative
more than it helps. Even the women who are introduced, like the Schuyler sisters, seem to exist
only to further Hamilton’s journey to power. Angelica Schuyler explains this clearly in the song
“Satisfied” when she describes her standing in society: “I’m a girl in a world in which / My only
job is to marry rich.” This line highlights how a woman’s role was often seen as a tool for
someone else's gain. Angelica later sings, “He’s after me cuz I’m a Schuyler sister / That elevates
his status.” Because the Schuyler sisters are high-class, whoever marries into the family gains
their power; the women are viewed as vehicles for that status. Additionally, the other women in
the play seem to exist solely to help or hurt Hamilton's image. On one hand, you have Eliza, the
supportive wife who would do anything for her husband. On the other hand, you have Maria,
who causes the affair that crumbles his legacy. Both characters are limited because they only
serve to further a man's story rather than playing a larger role. Even though Angelica mentions
that men and women aren't equal, the musical never elaborates on it, leaving the representation
of women shallow.
The erasure of slavery and the whitewashing of history go hand in hand; both serve to
maintain a narrative where white historical figures are perceived as heroic while minimizing the
roles of others. Lyra D. Monteiro points out in “Race-Conscious Casting and the Erasure of the
Black Past in Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hamilton” that people of color were among the first to fight
and die in the Revolutionary War, yet their contributions are ignored. She writes, “This pattern of
erasing the presence of black bodies continues throughout the play, as the role of people of color
in the Revolution itself is silenced” (Monteiro 94). Reading this puts the whitewashing into
perspective. I wasn't even aware of these contributions until I studied them in specific textbooks,
which shows how deep the erasure goes. Moving through the musical without explaining these
realities leaves a sour taste; we need this information to understand the true context, but omitting
it sanitizes the problematic history of the Founding Fathers. Take Thomas Jefferson, for example.
He is notorious for being a slave owner, yet the musical introduces him without ever addressing
that fact. Whitewashing history in a musical that claims to be 'historically accurate' is a major
mistake. It fails to address issues head-on, creating a vacuum where people fill in the gaps with
false history. In the long run, this harms the audience by convincing them that a sanitized version
of history is the truth.
In the end, Hamilton: An American Musical does a lot of right and wrong, but it places
more emphasis on the wrong by not including the problems of slavery, having an inaccurate
representation of history to help white people, and not giving women a real voice. The reason for
asking these questions was to make the audience think more than just consuming art, whether it
was good or bad, and to think about the consequences art can have even if the content isn't
accurate. Additionally, you should care if Hamilton succeeds as visionary fiction since the just
society explained in the musical could become reality if people want a better world. But it still
brings consequences to have a world where history isn't accurately represented, and people get
hurt because others don't know the true history. But in the end, this paper is important because it
helps you get a better sense of your own thoughts and ideas so you can form your own opinions.
Cited Works
Schuessler, Jennifer. “Alexander Hamilton, Enslaver? New Research Says Yes.” The New York
Times, The New York Times, 9 Nov. 2020,
www.nytimes.com/2020/11/09/arts/alexander-hamilton-enslaver-research.html.Accessed 12 July
2021.
Miranda, Lin-Manuel, composer. Hamilton: An American Musical. 2015. Disney,2020.
Monteiro, Lyra D. “Race-Conscious Casting and the Erasure of the BlackPast in Lin-Manuel
Miranda’s Hamilton” Public Historian, vol. 38,February 2016,No. 1,2016,89-98.