Hermes Astrology
Wicca and
Witchcraft
Few topics in contemporary spirituality generate as much
confusion as the relationship between Wicca and witchcraft. The
terms are often used interchangeably in popular culture, leading to
misunderstandings about both. Is Wicca simply another word for
witchcraft? Are all witches Wiccans? Are all Wiccans witches?
These questions have sparked debate among practitioners and
scholars alike for decades.
The answer, as with many things in the study of religion, is both
simple and complex. Simple because the core distinction can be
stated clearly: Wicca is a religion, while witchcraft is a practice.
Complex because the two are deeply intertwined historically, and
many practitioners identify with both.
This introduction aims to provide a comprehensive and accessible
guide to understanding the relationship between Wicca and
witchcraft for the beginner. We will explore their definitions, their
historical development, their areas of overlap and distinction, and
the various ways practitioners understand their own identities.
1. Defining the Terms
1.1 What Is Wicca?
Wicca is a modern Pagan, nature-based religion that was first
publicly promoted in England in the 1950s. Its followers, who call
themselves Wiccans, worship the Goddess and the God, celebrate
the seasonal festivals known as Sabbats, and often practice magic
as part of their religious observance .
The word "Wicca" comes from the Old English wicca, meaning
"male witch." Its modern usage was popularized by Gerald
Gardner, the founder of Gardnerian Wicca, who used the term in
his 1954 book Witchcraft Today. In Gardner's usage, "Wica"
(spelled with one 'c') referred to the group of initiates who practiced
the craft, not the religion itself. Over time, the spelling shifted to
"Wicca" and came to designate the religion as a whole .
Wicca is an initiatory religion in its traditional forms, meaning that
membership is conferred through formal initiation by an existing
member. However, the rise of self-initiation and solitary practice
has led to a proliferation of non-initiatory forms, particularly in
2
North America. Most Wiccans today are solitary practitioners who
have taught themselves through books and online resources .
Key characteristics of Wicca include:
●​ Theology: Veneration of the Goddess and the God,
understood as dual aspects of divinity
●​ Practice: Celebration of eight seasonal festivals (Sabbats)
and monthly Esbats at the full moon
●​ Ethics: The Wiccan Rede, "An it harm none, do what ye
will," and the Threefold Law
●​ Structure: Traditional covens with initiatory lineages, or
solitary practice
●​ Magic: Incorporation of magical practice as part of religious
observance
1.2 What Is Witchcraft?
Witchcraft, often called "The Craft," is the practice of magic—the
art of working with natural and spiritual forces to effect change.
Unlike Wicca, witchcraft requires no specific belief in gods or
goddesses and is not inherently a religion . It is a skill, a technique,
a practice that can be separated from any particular religious
framework.
The definition of witchcraft has varied enormously across cultures
and historical periods. In early modern Europe, witchcraft was
defined by demonologists as a pact with the devil—a definition that
had little to do with the actual practices of accused witches. In folk
traditions, witchcraft was often understood as the use of charms,
herbs, and spells for healing, protection, or harm.
In contemporary usage, witchcraft is generally understood as the
practice of magic. This practice may include:
●​ Spellcrafting and the casting of spells
●​ Divination and fortune-telling
●​ Herbalism and the preparation of charms and potions
●​ Working with energy and intention to influence events
●​ Communication with spirits, ancestors, or other non-physical
beings
Unlike Wicca, witchcraft has no central theology, no required
beliefs, and no universal ethical code. A witch may be an atheist, a
Christian, a Pagan, or follow any other spiritual path. As one
3
practitioner notes, "Witchcraft, the casting of spells and the
practice of magic, is considered to be a learned skill that can be
separated from religious beliefs" .
1.3 The Core Distinction
The essential distinction can be stated simply: Wicca is a religion;
witchcraft is a practice .
This means:
●​ All Wiccans practice witchcraft as part of their religion, but
not all witches are Wiccans
●​ One can be a witch without being Wiccan, practicing magic
within any religious framework or none
●​ One cannot be Wiccan without practicing witchcraft, as
magic is integral to the Wiccan path
This distinction is widely accepted among both scholars and
practitioners, though its application in practice can be more
nuanced, as we shall explore.
2. Historical Development: How the Confusion Began
The confusion between Wicca and witchcraft has historical roots
that reach back to the founding of modern Wicca in the
mid-twentieth century.
2.1 Gerald Gardner and the "Witch-Cult"
When Gerald Gardner first began writing about Wicca in the
1950s, he did not use the word "Wicca" to describe the religion.
Instead, he called what he was practicing "witchcraft." His two
major books are titled Witchcraft Today (1954) and The Meaning of
Witchcraft (1959). In these works, he writes about the "Witch-Cult"
and people who practice witchcraft, referring to himself and his
fellow initiates as witches .
Gardner did use the term "Wica" (spelled with one 'c') in his
writings, but he used it to identify a group of people who practice
witchcraft, not the religion itself. He writes about "the Wica" as
members of the Witch-Cult, people who practice witchcraft. In his
two books, he uses the word "Wicca" nineteen times, almost
4
always preceded by "the" or "these," while using "witchcraft" 277
times .
For Gardner and his early initiates, then, there was no distinction
between Wicca and witchcraft. They were witches practicing
witchcraft, and the religion they followed was simply witchcraft.
This is the source of much subsequent confusion.
2.2 The Emergence of "Wicca" as a Religious Label
The term "Wicca" began to shift from referring to people to
referring to the religion itself in the 1960s and 1970s. As the
movement spread to North America and diversified, practitioners
needed a way to distinguish their specific religious path from
witchcraft more broadly.
The word "Wicca" served this purpose well. It was distinctive, had
ancient roots, and could be used to designate the particular
tradition that traced its lineage back to Gardner and his associates.
Other forms of witchcraft, both older and newer, could then be
distinguished as "traditional witchcraft," "folk witchcraft," or simply
"witchcraft" without the Wiccan label .
By the 1980s and 1990s, with the publication of popular books like
Scott Cunningham's Wicca: A Guide for the Solitary Practitioner,
"Wicca" had become firmly established as the name of a specific
religion within the broader category of Pagan witchcraft .
2.3 The Role of Margaret Murray
An important influence on Gardner's understanding of witchcraft
was the work of Margaret Murray, an Egyptologist and folklorist
who argued that the early modern witch trials were actually a
persecution of a surviving pre-Christian religion. Murray's books,
particularly The Witch-Cult in Western Europe (1921), presented a
picture of an organized, underground Pagan religion that had
survived centuries of Christian persecution .
Gardner drew heavily on Murray's work, presenting his Wicca as
the modern survival of this ancient witch-cult. This narrative gave
Wicca a sense of legitimacy and continuity, even though later
historians have thoroughly debunked Murray's thesis. The idea
that Wicca is an ancient religion, rather than a modern creation,
has contributed to the confusion between Wicca and older forms of
witchcraft.
5
3. Areas of Overlap and Distinction
3.1 Shared Elements
Wicca and witchcraft share many elements, which contributes to
the confusion between them. Both involve:
●​ Magic: The use of spells, rituals, and energy work to effect
change
●​ Natural world: Reverence for nature and the cycles of the
seasons
●​ Tools: Use of similar implements such as athames, wands,
cauldrons, and pentacles
●​ Divination: Practices like tarot reading, scrying, and other
forms of fortune-telling
●​ Herbalism: Knowledge of plants and their magical and
medicinal properties
Because Wicca incorporates witchcraft as part of its practice,
Wiccan rituals often look very similar to the magical workings of
non-Wiccan witches. A non-Wiccan witch might cast a circle, call
the quarters, and invoke deities—all practices associated with
Wicca—while not considering themselves Wiccan.
3.2 Key Differences
Despite these shared elements, important differences remain:
Religious vs. Non-Religious: Wicca is a religion with specific
theological beliefs—the veneration of the Goddess and the God,
celebration of the Sabbats and Esbats, and ethical guidelines like
the Wiccan Rede. Witchcraft, as a practice, requires none of these.
A witch may be an atheist who views magic purely as a
psychological technique, a Christian who uses folk magic within a
Christian framework, or a Pagan who honors different deities than
those of Wicca .
Tradition vs. Technique: Traditional Wicca is passed down
through initiatory lineages, with specific rituals and teachings that
are shared among initiates. Witchcraft, as a practice, can be
learned from books, from family tradition, from mentors, or through
personal exploration. There is no central authority or standardized
curriculum .
6
Community vs. Individual: Wicca, particularly in its traditional
forms, emphasizes coven-based practice and group ritual. While
solitary Wicca exists, the religion's structure and theology
developed around group practice. Witchcraft, by contrast, has
always included solitary practitioners alongside those who work in
groups. A witch may never work with anyone else and still be a
witch .
Ethical Frameworks: Wicca has a relatively consistent ethical
framework centered on the Wiccan Rede and the Threefold Law.
Witchcraft has no universal ethics; different traditions and
individual practitioners may have very different views on what is
acceptable magical practice. Some witches work with baneful
magic (curses and hexes), while others avoid it entirely .
4. The Spectrum of Witchcraft Identities
The relationship between Wicca and witchcraft is not simply a
matter of two categories. In practice, there is a spectrum of
identities and positions.
4.1 Wiccan Witches
Most Wiccans identify as witches. For them, witchcraft is an
integral part of their religious practice. They cast spells, work
magic, and identify with the broader witch community. When
Gardner wrote about "the Wica," he was referring to such
people—witches who practiced a particular form of religious
witchcraft .
These practitioners may refer to themselves as Wiccans, as
witches, or both. They may be initiated into traditional lineages or
practice as solitaries. Their witchcraft is embedded in a religious
framework that includes worship of the Goddess and God,
celebration of the Wheel of the Year, and adherence to Wiccan
ethics.
4.2 Non-Wiccan Pagan Witches
Many Pagans who are not Wiccans also practice witchcraft. They
may honor different deities—Celtic, Norse, Greek, or other
pantheons—or may have a more generic Pagan spirituality. They
may celebrate the same seasonal festivals as Wiccans or follow
different calendars. Their witchcraft may be more central to their
7
practice than deity worship, or they may integrate magic into a
different religious framework .
These practitioners are witches and Pagans, but they are not
Wiccans. They may have no connection to Gardnerian or
Alexandrian lineages, and their practices may differ significantly
from Wiccan norms.
4.3 Secular or Atheist Witches
Some witches practice magic without any religious framework at
all. They may view magic as a psychological technique for
focusing intention and manifesting change, or as a way of working
with natural energies that have no connection to deities or spirits.
These practitioners are often called secular witches or atheist
witches .
For these witches, witchcraft is purely a practice. They may use
many of the same techniques as Wiccan witches—spells, rituals,
divination—but without any belief in gods or goddesses. They are
witches, but they are not Wiccans and may not consider
themselves Pagan.
4.4 Traditional Witches
Some practitioners identify with "traditional witchcraft"—forms of
witchcraft that claim to predate or exist independently of Wicca.
These traditions may draw on folk magic, cunning craft, and other
pre-modern sources. They often have different cosmologies,
different ethics, and different practices than Wicca .
Traditional witches may or may not work with deities. They may
have initiatory lineages, but these are generally separate from
Gardnerian or Alexandrian lines. They may view Wicca as a
modern invention and their own path as older and more
authentic—a claim that is itself contested.
4.5 Witches of Other Religions
Witchcraft can also be practiced within the context of other
religions. There are Christian witches who incorporate folk magic
into their Christian faith, Jewish witches who work within
Kabbalistic traditions, and witches of various other religious
backgrounds. These practitioners are witches, but they are not
Wiccans and often not Pagan .
8
5. The Dictionary Perspective and the Policing of Language
The relationship between Wicca and witchcraft has become a
contentious issue in some quarters, with debates about who has
the right to call themselves a witch.
5.1 Merriam-Webster and Common Usage
As one commentator notes, even dictionary definitions recognize
the connection between Wicca and witchcraft. Merriam-Webster's
dictionary lists the third definition of witchcraft as "Wicca." From a
linguistic standpoint, Wiccans have every right to use the words
witch and witchcraft to describe themselves .
This reflects common usage. In popular culture, "witch" often
means a practitioner of Wicca or similar Pagan traditions. When
television shows feature witches, they are usually depicting
something closer to Wicca than to historical witchcraft.
5.2 The Argument for Inclusive Language
Many practitioners argue against policing the word "witch." They
note that witchcraft is a diverse phenomenon with many valid
expressions. As one writer puts it, "Witchcraft is a word with a
whole host of definitions. I'd never argue that Wicca is the only
type of Witchcraft (if you say you are a Witch, you probably are a
Witch!), but it most certainly is a type of Witchcraft" .
From this perspective, attempts to exclude Wiccans from the
category of witchcraft are historically inaccurate, given Gardner's
original usage, and unnecessarily divisive within the broader
Pagan and magical community.
5.3 The Argument for Distinction
Others argue that maintaining clear distinctions is important for
both scholarly accuracy and practical clarity. They note that
conflating Wicca with witchcraft erases the diversity of witch
identities and makes it harder for beginners to understand the
landscape.
The distinction between Wicca as a religion and witchcraft as a
practice is useful for understanding both. It allows us to recognize
that while Wicca and witchcraft are closely related, they are not
9
identical, and that there are many ways to be a witch that do not
involve being Wiccan.
6. For the Beginner: Navigating the Landscape
For those beginning their exploration of Wicca and witchcraft,
several principles can guide the journey.
6.1 Understand the Distinction
The first step is understanding the core distinction: Wicca is a
religion, witchcraft is a practice. This framework will help you make
sense of the diverse claims you encounter.
When someone says they are a witch, they may mean:
●​ They practice magic within a Wiccan religious framework
●​ They practice magic within another Pagan framework
●​ They practice magic as a secular or non-religious practice
●​ They practice folk magic within a Christian or other religious
framework
When someone says they are Wiccan, they mean they follow a
specific religious path that includes witchcraft, worship of the
Goddess and God, and celebration of the Sabbats and Esbats.
6.2 Read Widely
The best way to understand the diversity of Wiccan and witch
identities is to read widely. Books by different authors will present
different perspectives. Some recommended starting points include:
●​ Wicca: A Guide for the Solitary Practitioner by Scott
Cunningham – A gentle introduction to Wicca as a solitary
path
●​ The Spiral Dance by Starhawk – A feminist,
Reclaiming-tradition perspective
●​ Drawing Down the Moon by Margot Adler – A
comprehensive survey of modern Paganism
●​ The Triumph of the Moon by Ronald Hutton – The definitive
scholarly history of modern Pagan witchcraft in Britain
6.3 Respect Individual Identity
10
How individuals identify is ultimately a matter of personal choice. If
someone says they are a witch, they are a witch. If someone says
they are Wiccan, they are Wiccan. These identities are not
mutually exclusive, and individuals may use them in different ways.
As one forum participant wisely noted, "Ask five people and you'll
get five different answers" . The diversity of opinion reflects the
diversity of the traditions themselves.
6.4 Explore Your Own Path
For those drawn to these traditions, the journey is ultimately about
finding your own path. You may discover that Wicca's religious
framework resonates with you, or you may be drawn to witchcraft
as a practice without the religious elements. You may find a home
in one of the many other Pagan traditions, or you may create your
own eclectic practice.
There is no single correct way to be a witch or a Wiccan. The
traditions are diverse, evolving, and open to individual
interpretation. What matters is finding a path that feels authentic
and meaningful to you.
7. Wicca, Witchcraft, and the Spectrum of Consciousness
As we have explored throughout this series, Wicca and witchcraft
connect with many of the themes we have examined.
From Hermeticism, Wicca draws on ceremonial magic traditions,
the use of ritual tools, and the principle of correspondence. Many
Wiccan rituals reflect Hermetic and Golden Dawn influences.
From shamanism, witchcraft shares practices of journeying,
working with spirits, and connecting with the natural world. Some
forms of witchcraft emphasize these shamanic elements more than
others.
From hoodoo rootwork, witchcraft shares the use of herbs,
candles, and natural materials in magical practice, though the
cultural contexts are distinct and should not be conflated.
From magic intuition and practical intuition, both Wicca and
witchcraft emphasize the development of inner knowing and its
application in daily life.
11
From the chakras and pineal gland activation, many witches
work with subtle energy, visualization, and expanded states of
consciousness.
Wicca and witchcraft are distinct in being complete
systems—Wicca as a religion, witchcraft as a practice—that can
incorporate elements from many sources while maintaining their
own integrity.
Conclusion: Both/And
The relationship between Wicca and witchcraft is best understood
as both/and rather than either/or. Wicca is a form of witchcraft, but
not the only form. Witchcraft is central to Wicca, but can exist apart
from it. Many Wiccans are witches, and many witches are not
Wiccans.
This complexity reflects the nature of living spiritual traditions.
They are not neat categories that can be easily separated. They
overlap, influence each other, and evolve over time. What was true
in Gardner's day is not necessarily true today, and what is true for
one practitioner may not be true for another.
For the beginner, the most important thing is to approach these
traditions with openness and curiosity. Learn the distinctions, but
don't be constrained by them. Listen to how practitioners describe
themselves, but don't expect perfect consistency. Explore, read,
practice, and discover what resonates with you.
As one experienced practitioner put it, "The Craft will tell you if you
listen intently" . Whether you find your home in Wicca, in
witchcraft, or somewhere else entirely, the journey itself is the
teacher.
12
For a limited time, you can receive a free copy of ‘The Astrologer’s
Guide: Mastering Birth Chart Interpretation’ by subscribing to our
newsletter. Get your free book here:
https://hermesastrology.substack.com/p/your-free-book
13
About the Author
Trusted Astrology Expert with 15,000+ Followers.
Hermes Astrology is a digital sanctuary where ancient celestial
wisdom meets modern self-discovery. Named after Hermes—the
divine messenger who bridges worlds—this project seeks to
translate the symbolic language of the stars into practical insights
for contemporary life.
📧
Substack​
Join our newsletter for new articles and exclusive content (10,000+
Subscribers).
✍️
Medium​
Read extended articles and astrological reflections (5,000+
Followers).
14