OM 4570 Project 1 Quality & Productivity Project Report Michelle Canchola, Ethan Comfort, Angel Velazquez California State University - Stanislaus OM 4570 Quality & Productivity Management Professor James Kelleher November 25th, 2025 OM 4570 Project 2 Introduction Executive Summary This project will address the persistent issue of late deliveries and damaged goods within Amazon’s fulfillment operations, specifically within Amazon’s OAK4 distribution center located in Tracy, California. By applying the PDCA cycle (Plan, Do, Check, Act), and leveraging certain quality tools like the Ishikawa Diagram, the team aims to reduce the overall average damage rate by ten percent within one month. This initiative is expected to improve customer satisfaction, reduce operational costs, and align with Amazon’s broader goals of efficiency and reliability. The Issue at Hand Amazon’s reputation for fast and reliable delivery is central to its brand, and key to its overall success. However, recent feedback and internal observations of this specific fulfillment center have highlighted a troubling rise in late deliveries and damaged packages. These issues not only diminish customer trust, but they also create financial losses, line downtime, and strain operational resources. Problem Definition Amazon has experienced an increase in customer complaints because of high rates of damaged deliveries. Since customers are receiving damaged goods, this has resulted in returns, refunds, and customer dissatisfaction. As Amazon's business model is known for being fast, accurate, and reliable, having damaged products produces a negative brand perception. Initial brainstorming revealed contributing factors such as inconsistent carrier performance, poor packaging, and weather-related delays. These insights were gathered through team discussions and process observations at the OAK4 fulfillment center. OM 4570 Project 3 Goal Setting The project goal is to reduce the overall average delivery damage rate by ten percent within one month by implementing improvements in packaging, handling, and the delivery process. The progress towards this goal will be measured using customer feedback surveys, internal damage rate analytics and delivery performance tracking metrics. This goal follows the SMART framework by being specific in focusing on damage shipment reduction, measurable through tracking damage rate metrics and providing feedback, attainable through support by targeted interventions, relevant to Amazon's core commitment to reliable and high quality delivery services, and with a clearly defined one month implementation window. Brainstorming Insights During the initial team brainstorming session, several root causes were identified that contributed to Amazon's high rate of late deliveries and damaged goods. Inconsistent carrier performance was one of the significant factors, as there were seemingly varying standards and practices that were present within the facility. Poor packaging included inadequate materials and improper packaging techniques that increased the likelihood of damaged products during the delivery process. External factors such as weather related delays also played a role in extended delivery times. Additionally, staffing issues and rushed conditions during peak operational hours added pressure to workers resulting in reduced attention to detail in packing quality and handling procedures. These insights were informed by our selection of tools and the intervention planning. Approach & Planning To guide implementation, the team will utilize the Plan, Do, Check, Act cycle, which is the ideal framework for continuous improvement. This cycle ensures that changes are planned, tested, and refined before full-scale deployment. One tool that we will be utilizing to support our OM 4570 Project 4 approach is the Ishikawa Diagram (also known as the Fishbone). This will help us map out and visualize the key root causes that are contributing to the late and damaged deliveries. The PDCA cycle will be executed through a defined set of implementation steps. During the Plan phase, the team will be collecting baseline data for damages, define SMART goals, and identify specific changes needed in packing and handling workflows. In the Do phase, the team will be implementing changes in the OAK4 fulfillment center. This project will focus on materials, material handling protocols and updating training for staff. The Check phase will involve analyzing data, reviewing operational metrics and gathering staff and customer feedback. During the Act phase, the team will make any necessary refinements based on the findings and scale improvements. This structured approach allows for flexibility while maintaining accountability and focus. Constraints During the initial team meeting, several potential constraints we identified contributed to the late deliveries and product damages. These insights were gathered through discussions, observations and preliminary data analyses. Several constraints were identified that could impact project success: Limited availability of staff and resources during peak hours creates operational challenges, especially in a high volume environment like Amazon's OAK4 fulfillment center. When the order volumes surge, the workforce is overwhelmed which leads to rushed tasks with poor attention to detail, and a higher chance of mistakes such as improper packaging or misscanned items. Work stations and equipment bottlenecks occur because many associates compete for the same resources which creates frustration in the workplace. These pressures contribute directly to late deliveries and elevated damage rates. OM 4570 Project 5 Budget limits pose an obstacle for this project, especially if we have to adopt new packaging materials while delivering staff training aimed at reducing damage rates and enhancing delivery performance. Upgrading to more durable packaging, such as reinforced boxes, better quality dunnage, and improved labeling, will cost more and must be aligned with the fulfillment center’s financial strategy. Implementing training programs demands financial investment and paid work hours. Budget restrictions influence improvements that can be made, how quickly they can be taken out, and level of impact. If we place further strain on an already limited setting, teams will be forced to focus on only the most immediate needs, delaying more long term initiatives. Technology limitations pose a difficult challenge, especially when needing to update tracking and training software. Old and inefficient tracking systems lead to mistakes in package monitoring, slower issue detection, and reduced visibility across the delivery process. Without modern software, employees may not be able to adapt to the demand, as well as efficiently learn new procedures and packaging standards properly and in a timely manner. These technology gaps become more difficult to identify and address root causes of delays and damages. Upgrading and implementing new technology becomes a priority, but may also require time and funding which further complicates the improvement process. External factors like weather and traffic will affect delivery timelines. Big storms with heavy rain, or even extreme heat can create road conditions that slow down drivers or even stop deliveries altogether. Traffic jams and road closures also make it harder for carriers to stay on schedule. Since these issues are completely outside the fulfillment center's control, they can disrupt operations but the focus of our project is within scope and weather is outside of that.. As a result packages may arrive late, customer expectations aren't met, and the whole delivery process becomes harder to predict and manage. OM 4570 Project 6 Resources Needs In order to implement the proposal changes, the following resources are required: To carry out the proposed changes human and material resources will be needed for the completion of daily tasks but also for training tasks and procedures. Having the right people available ensures that new processes can be learned and applied correctly without slowing down operations. Packaging materials will also be required. The upgraded packages will consist of upgraded boxes, fillers for packaging, and protective materials designed to reduce the risk of damage during the handling and delivery. These stronger materials will support the goal of lowering damage rates and improving customer satisfaction. In addition to staffing and materials, the project will require financial support to cover the cost of new supplies, software updates, and process improvements. New technology like improved tracking systems, better training, and documentation tools, will be essential for boosting efficiency and helping staff stay consistent with new procedures. Reliable delivery vehicles are also necessary to ensure packages reach customers on time and in good condition. Dedicated training software will help employees quickly learn new standards and workflows, making the transition easier and more efficient. These resources from the foundation need to be successful to implement the proposed improvements. Each resource is linked to a specific module of the project, ensuring targeted investment and efficient use. Scope Definition The scope of this project focuses on important areas within the fulfillment and delivery process. The fulfillment center will go through the process changes that are supported by the staff training to ensure that employees understand and follow the updated procedures. The project also includes upgrades to packaging materials and improvements to documentation in OM 4570 Project 7 order to reduce product damage and maintain consistency. Second, tracking systems will be updated with new software to improve the monitoring technology and visibility throughout the delivery process. Finally, staging zones will be reorganized to improve the workflow, reduce the bottlenecks, and creative feedback loops from employers will help to quickly identify and correct issues. These areas define the boundaries and inner scope of the project and highlight where improvements will be implemented. What is excluded from our project scope includes any changes to the external carrier control logistics. These operations fall outside the scope of Amazon's direct control and cannot be guided through internal process adjustments. The broader supply chain redesign is also excluded from the scope because they involve large-scale structural changes that extend beyond the fulfillment center. The focus will remain on improvements that can realistically be managed and implemented at the OAK4 facility itself. Defining our exact scope and what is to be excluded clearly helps prevent scope creep and keeps the team focused on actionable improvements. Process Observations To understand the operational flow and identify inefficiencies, the team conducted on-site observations (Gemba walk) at Amazon’s OAK4 fulfillment center. Key findings included: ● Staff Rushing: Warehouse staff were often hurried during parcel handling, increasing the risk of damage. ● Outbound Timing: Delays in Outbound item processing created bottlenecks. ● Driver Roles: Ambiguity between parcel and truck driver responsibilities affected accountability. OM 4570 Project 8 ● Process Flow Gaps: Lack of a clear process map made it difficult to assign and track action items. These observations informed the need for better training, clearer role definitions, and process documentation. Data Collection Accurate data is essential for measuring progress and validating improvements. The team identified the following key metrics: ● Delivery Date Records - To track timelines ● Damage Rate - Primary metric for success ● Supplier Delivery Counts - Needed to establish a baseline and monitor improvements. Initial findings revealed gaps in data tracking, particularly in counting delivered items and linking them to supplier performance. Addressing these gaps is a priority for the next phase. Business Justification Solving the issues of late deliveries and damaged goods offers tangible benefits including: Cost reduction, fewer damaged items mean lower replacement and return costs. Customer retention, timely, intact deliveries improve satisfaction and loyalty. Operational efficiency, streamlined processes reduce delays and staff strain. Strategic alignment supports Amazon’s goals of reliability, speed, and customer-centric service. By linking project goals to company objectives, the team ensures that the initiative delivers measurable value. OM 4570 Project 9 Conclusion This project represents a focused effort to improve delivery quality and operational performance within Amazon’s fulfillment network. Through structured planning, team collaboration, utilization of quality tools and the PDCA cycle, and data-driven analysis, the team is poised to achieve a ten percent damage rate reduction within one month. Next Steps Finalize process flow documentation and implement training modules. Launch pilot changes in selected center and monitor metrics, adjust based on feedback. OM 4570 Project 10 Reference(s) Summers, Donna. (2010). Quality (Fifth). Prentice Hall.
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )