Paper: Atkins et a1 Paper Building near trees The developmentof NHBC standards for the foundations of low-rise dwellings Rev F. J. Atkins, CEng, MIStructE R. W. Johnson,CEng, FIStructE J. S . Barrett, BEng, CEng, MIStructE National House-Building Council Synopsis This paper gives background informationon the development of the NHBC Standardfor building near trees - Chapter 4.2. It then reviews the recently published guidance, in Chapter 4.2 (1992), for heave precautions to foundations on shrinkableclay soils. Areas where highly shrmkable clays can be found In Sourh East England. Orher areas outs4de South Easr England Conram shrmkable clays They are not c:nnl#nedto lhls area. B;) Introduction For more than 50 years the National House-Building Council (NHBC) has been the consumer-protection body for theprivate house-building industry. NHBC’s technical requirements are contained within the two volumes of the NHBC Standards’.The Standards take the form of mandatory technical requirements supported by detailed performance standards. Guidance in the form of acceptable construction details is provided in order for the performance standard to be met. Separate sections cover design,materials and sitework under chapter headings for the building elements. The guidance sections have been consolidated from previous NHBC technical literature, publications from authoritative organisations and the results of research and data accumulated over long periods. These data have been collected by NHBC staff from defects, as well as errors and omissions recorded in the field and design submissions for warranty cover and for building control. The guidance is kept under continuous review and is amended in response to claims or difficulties experienced in construction. Part 4 of the NHBC Standards is entitled ‘Foundations’, and it dealswith several related topics in five separate chapters. These chapters deal with the technical requirements and recommendations relating to foundations and subjects covered include site appraisal2, building near trees3, foundation types4.5 and vibratory ground improvement techniques6. This paper describes in more detail the guidance in the chapter dealing with building near trees2,especially in relation to shrinkable soils. Firm, shrinkable clay soils occur throughout the UK, and they are generallycapable of supportinglow-risebuildingsonfairlyshallow foundations. Volume changes in the soil brought about by seasonal variation in soil moisture content and by deeply rooted vegetation removing soil moisture, can cause damage to buildings founded on shrinkable clay soils Fig I . The effect of a willow treeon shrinkable clay v / n : +- --.J Fig 2. Simplified geological driftmap of South East England (Fig 1). These soils shrink with a reduction in moisture content and swell when the moisture content increases. Theclays most susceptible to these movements are found in the South-East of England, as illustrated in the simplified geological map (Fig 2). Clays, e.g. lias, that are subject to swelling and shrinkage can also be found in otherparts of the country. The developmentof NHBC standards Guidelinesregardingtreesonshrinkableclaysoils began toevolve following the drought of 1947. Research by the Building Research Station drew attention to the significance of clay-soil shrinkage produced by treeroot action. The relationship between the tree height, the distance from the tree and damage to buildings led to the development of BRS digest 3 in 19497. Separating trees and buildings by a distance equal to at least the mature height of the tree has subsequently been incorporated in various other guidelines and codes. The Structural EngineerIVolume 72INo 16/16August 1994 253 Paper: Atkins et a1 3. Choose the right kind of foundation for clay soils. On shrinkable clay soil, special foundations are neededfor a dwelling nearel a tree than two thirds of its mature height in the case of Poplars, Elms and willows. The right kind of Must always be engineer-designed in accordance with Rq 5 oi foundation can] the NHBC Technical Requirements. be: Pile and beam Raft. Deep strip. Shallow strip foundations must not be used near trees. Deep stripmustcomplywith clause F0 19(c) of theNHBCTechnical Reauirements. D = distance from house to centre of tree H = expected mature height of tree Species of tree Distance from the dwelling as a proportion of tree heightg H l 1 l l 2 2 1 18 4 3 2 3 Fig 4. Desiccated shrinkable clay A supplement to practice note 3 was also published, entitled A quick way to find the right depth of foundations on clay soilsii.Together with this supplement, the guidance given in practice note 3 had now developed from 4 pages in 1974 to 42 pages in 1985. able The NHBC technical requirements were published as NHBC Standards All Ditto others 1.0 1.2 1.5 2.4 1.5 2.1 Note: Up to 50% extra depth may be necessary where trees are in rows or groupsin 1991. Practice note 3 was incorporated into the new Standards but rewritten in the new style and published as NHBC Standards Chapter 4.2 Fig 3. Clause 3 ofpractice note 3 (1974) (Building near trees) in 1992. During the rewriting the opportunity was taken to elaborate on the precautions for clay heave. Following a series of claims,the then NationalHouse-Builders Registration Council (NHBRC) monitored the performance of low-rise Heave precautions and Chapter4.2 dwellings built on clay soils that had been influenced by trees. It used the Clay heave information obtained along with research to provide practical guidance to When themoisturecontent of shrinkableclayincreases,its volume builders for constructing safe foundations on shrinkable clay sites where increases. The resultant movement can be both vertical and horizontal. The there were, or had been, trees. removal of moisture from clay is often termed as desiccation (Fig 4). Heave The guidance was originally introduced as practice note 3 (Rootdamage is the recovery processfollowing’desiccationwhen the clay moisture content by trees- siting of dwellings and special precautions) in 1969*.The introand therefore the volume increases. duction to this document read as follows: Notand Elm Polar, ptWillow Depth of trench (m) 2.82.12.32.6 1.5 1.9 ‘The scarcity of good building land meansthat many moredwellings are built close totrees. This has given rise to structural problems. This practice note gives guidance about what the NHBRC regards as safe distances while recognising that every site isdifferent. It also suggests some of the specialconstructional precautions that may need to be taken.’ The information contained within the first edition of NHBC practice note 3 was qualitative rather than quantitative. No specific guidance was included regarding construction, but the practice note drew attention to the need for caution when building near trees. In 1974 practice note 3 9 was completely rewritten, and for the first time it recommended minimum foundation depths in heavy clay soils related to the tree species, the distance from the tree and the expected mature height. (Clause 3 of practice note 3, revised April 1974, is reproduced in Fig 3.) The practice note referred to the structural problems caused by trees and gave some guidance on preventative measures. The practice note was widely used for many years and provided guidance on foundationsdepths. However, experience in its use identified the need for more detailed and refined advice. Practice note 3 was again completelyrewritten in 1985 under the new title Building near treesi0. NHBC-sponsored iesearch work, especially in the areas of soil moisture deficiencies for various soil types and tree species and detailed claims analysis. This led to a better understanding of the effects of trees on soils with differing shrinkage potential. The research enabled the foundation depths to be related to the plasticity of the clay and tree species. The 1985 edition of practice note 3 now took account of the following: ( a ) The classification of soils into high-, medium- and low-shrinkage potential based on the plasticity index ( b ) The classification of trees into high, moderate and low water demand and the potential tree heights on clay soils ( c ) The foundation depth required using the classifications for soils and trees. The foundation depths will limit moisture-related movements of foundations but not necessarily eliminate them (6)Climatic variations affecting the foundation depth 254 Seasonal shrinkage and swelling The seasonal movement of clay in the UK arising from the winterhmmer cycle affects the top surface soils. In normal climatic conditions, the clay tends to becomedesiccated in the summer and recovers through the winter. Dry winter weather can reduce winter soil recovery. Foundations on highly shrinkable clay soils are not normally affected by seasonal desiccation and heave if theyare placed ata depth not less than lm. Soil movements are relatively small at this depth, as long as they are not affected by external influences such as tree roots. Ground-bearing concrete slabs can,however, be disrupted by seasonal heave movement, if the slab is laid during a period of dry weather then soils near the surface may be desiccated. As the soils recover, swelling will occur, causing heave and damage to the slab and any partitions built off it. Chapter 4.2 now addresses this problem by recommending that where heaveisprobable,suspendedground-floorslabsare usedwithan appropriate void to allow for heave movement. Shrinkage and swelling due to vegetation In addition to the cyclical nature of seasonal desiccation and heave, soil moisture content can also be affected by the presence of trees and other vegetation. Desiccation can occur in these circumstances to depths of 5m and more. At these depths, however, movements affecting foundations are small and very rarely cause damage to the structure. The guidance given in Chapter 4.2 takes this into account and recommends foundation depths up to a maximum of 3.5m. Unlike seasonal movement, moisture extracted from depths greater than 2m bylarge trees is not always replenished duringa single winter cycle.Tree removal allows the process of rehydration and heave within the soil to occur and it may take many years to reach soil-moisture equilibrium. Foundations placed within the zone of desiccated clay may bedisrupted by both horizontal and vertical heave movement (Fig 5). Appropriate measures need to be taken to avoid damage to the foundations. With desiccation arising from vegetation, there is again a need to avoid heave damage to ground bearing slabs. Chapter 4.2 recommends using suspended ground floor slabs with a void appropriate to the soil type to allow for soil expansion. The Structural EngineedVolume 72/No 16/16August 1994 Paper: Atkins et a1 DIH 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 0.5 1.0 I 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 H o w lo uee thi. tabtm t use this t a ~ Methe w n has a HIGH or UNKNOWNshrlnwe potential (seelabte 1. Design dause WC)). 2 Use Appendix 4.2-8 to esla!3lsh the mature height Hof the tree and its Water demand (see Desipn dause W@). 3 Measure the distance D belween the tree and the face of the loundation. 4 Eswnsh DM ratio and readon the foundation depthwhere n imenects wim the 6Qprcpriate water demand. Repeat for ailtreeswithin their zona of t n f l u m hom the building(for zones 01 influence6wAppendix 4.2-E, Hem 5). Repeat usingdiflerent DM ratios ilnepped IoundaWmsare proposed. 5 Reduce the deplh by 0.05m (%mm) forevery 50 miles norm andwest 01 London (See Appendix 4.2-D). The final fwndation depth musf not be less than tm for HIGH shrinkablltly wits. 6 Appendix 4.2-H or the Foundation Depth Calculator (seeAppendix 4.2-1) may be used as an aitematlve for the determination of foundation depth. NHBC Slardards - Chapler 4.2 Appendix 4 2 a t Fig 6. An example of a foundation depth graph takenfrom Chapter 4.2 (1992) Fig 5. Lateral heave damage toa trenchfillfoundation Foundationdepth tables (continued) Vegetation survey NHBC Standards Chapter 4.1 (Foundations -finding the hazards)* gives technical requirements and recommendations for identifying hazards that need to be considered so that the dwelling foundations and associated works are satisfactory.Careful appraisal of the site and ground, including walkover survey, desk study and ground assessment from trial pits and borings, will give a good indication as tothe hazardous nature of the ground. It is vitalbefore a site iscleared to record the location, heights and species of trees and hedgerows on and adjacent to the site so that appropriate precautions can be taken. If the location of previously removed vegetation is unknown, information can be obtained from historical aerial photographs and local knowledge. Where records are not available and root growth has been notedwithin the clay subsoil, a judgment has to be madeas towhether the clay soil is likely to heave. Soil classification and index tests can be used to establish the soil shrinkage potential". The presence of roots does not necessarily mean that the soil is desiccated. Comparison of moisture content profiles from boreholes in the ground believed to be influenced by trees and in the ground remote from the tree is sometimes used to try and establish the zone of desiccation. This method is useful in indicating the depth of moisture deficit. It should be noted that this form of investigation will give realistic results only if the ground has consistent index and soil properties. BRE guidance indicates that a more definitive method of establishingclay heave potential is the filter paper method of soil suction measurementt2.This form of investigation generally requires the need for the recovery of undisturbed soil samples and the laboratory testing involved is more expensive than simple soil moisture content tests. Work is, however, being carried out using disturbed sampling which would have obvious cost advantages. Foundation depths Where construction takes place in the vicinity of existing trees, or where trees have been removed from the site, foundation depths can be derived from the graphs and tables included in Chapter 4.2. Some examples of The Structural EngineedVolume 72/No 16/16August 1994 TABLE 12 I HIGH SHRINKAGESOIS plwmindex mater than 40% I HIGH water demand BROAD LEAF trees including:- Wmwmhphmhnm Fig 7.An example of a foundation depth table takenfrom Chapter 4.2 (1992) Table 2 Shrinkage potential Minimum High Medium Low depth [m] l.o 0.9 0.75 Fig 8. Minimum foundation depths from Chapter 4.2 (1992) Table 2 these graphs and tables are' shown in Figs 6 & 7. Minimum foundation depths on sites not affected by trees are shown inTable 2 of Chapter 4.2 (Fig 8). The foundation depths arerelated to the shrinkage potential of the soil. Suitable proprietary materialsf o r heave protection There are two distinct types of material that are manufactured to protect substructures from the effectsof heave. The first is a compressible material 255 Paper: Atkins et a1 - Table 8 Minimum-vold under ground floors measured from underside of beam or jolst to ground level, allowing for ventilation T@le 1 Plasticity index Shrinkage potential than Greater 2040% IO-20% H_gh Medium 40% Precast Low Soil heave potential Ifthe shrinkage potentialis unknown, high shrinkage potential should be assumed. Fig 9. SimplGed relationship between plasticity indexand shrinkage potential jrom Chapter 4.2 (1992) Tublel Table 7 - against Minimum vold dimension to accommodate movement foundations and ground beams Underside of ground beam Soil heave potential void dimension [mm1 [mm1 Against side of foundations high medium low concrete Suspended timber void dimension [mm1 void dimension [mm1 225 175 125 250 200 300 Note Suspended in situ concrete floors may only be used in conjunction with suitable void formers. Minimum void dimension values for in situ concrete floors should be taken from Table7, as for underside of ground beam. Fig l l . Minimum allowances to accommodate heave movement henecrth suspended groundfloors fromChapter 4.2 (1992)Table 8 void dimension pressed. There is a need to check that the vertical dead load of the structure is adequate to resist the transferred heave forces. This is especially when true lightweight structures such as garages and conservatories are constructed on 25 pile and ground-beam foundations. The site programme may also have an 0 influence, especially when the substructure is constructed well aheadof the Fig IO. Minimum allowances to accommodateheave movement against superstructure. foundations and ground beams from Chapter 4.2 (1992) Table 7 The lateral pressures imposed by the compressible material on the side of the trenchfill foundations and ground beams will normally be countered by the passive resistanceof the soil. made from low-density polystyrene. The polystyrene should be of the Suspended ground floors should be used where the foundation depth highly-compressible low-density type and must be designed specifically for derived from Chapter 4.2 is greater than 1.5m and where heave can occur this situation. Other polystyrenes may be too denseor too soft andmay not withintheareabounded by the foundations. Thevoiddepthbeneath perform correctly. Because of the relatively high load required to induce suspended ground floor slabs should be in accordance with Table 8 (see Fig compression even of the low-density polystyrene, this material should not 11). be used beneath ground floor slabs to overcome potential heave, unless the be measured to from Table 8 gives the minimum void under ground floors slab and its supports are designed to accommodate the upward vertical theunderside of thebeamor joists tothegroundfloor.Thishas an pressure from the swelling soils. appropriate allowance for ventilation, and the voids are graded according The second type of material used for heave protection is the void-former. to soil-heave potential.Suspended in situ concretefloorsonheaveA void-former is an alternative to the compressible material. It forms a void susceptible sites may be used only in conjunction with a suitable voidinto which clay can heave. Clayboard has been used as such a material, but former. Minimum void dimension values to accommodate heave movement there have been reported instances of degradation of the organic void former below in situ concrete floors should be taken from Table7 (see Fig 10). generating methane gas. The design of the in situ concrete floor and its supports must take into Themanufacturers haveaddressedthisproblem by replacingthe is compressed. hardboard facings with extruded polypropylene sheets. The cardboard core account any pressure transfer induced when the void-former This may call for additional reinforcement to resist moment reversal in the remains practically the same, except that it is now perforated to allow for slab. the easy passage of water. The changes have reduced the biodegradable content of clayboard by up to 90% by weight. However, the possibility of Acceptable foundations methane generation still remains. Heave precautions on shrinkable clay soils are recommended for foundation Certain materials are not suitable for use with suspended in situ ground ( b ) within the zone of floors and the manufacturer should be consulted in all cases. NHBC requiresthat are ( a ) required to be deeper than 1.5m and influence of trees. that proprietary materials forming a critical function in the construction Zones of tree influence are as follows: process should havean independent assessment from BBA, BRE, WIMLAS or a European technical approval body authorised under the Construction 1 . For high-water-demand trees the zone= l .25 x the mature tree height Products Directivelj. 2. For moderate-water-demand trees the zone = 0.75 x the mature tree height Assessment of soil heave 3. For low-water-demand trees the zone= 0.5 x the mature tree height. Chapter 4.2 recommends that the soil heave potential is based on the The l .5m depth rule has been introduced for both practical and theoretical plasticity index of the soil as given in the simplified Table l shown in Fig reasons. If the foundations are less than 1.5m in depth, it is difficult to 9. Where heave is likely to occur, a void, void former or compressible ofthe material shouldbe provided to accommodate that movement. Values for this introduce compressible materialhid-former downthesides foundations, and onlya very small section would actually be used. The 1.5m equivalent void are given in Table 7 (see Fig IO). Rather than specifying depth rule also combines the factors of tree height and distance of the thicknesses of proprietary materials, which manufacturers may change, foundation from the tree in one simple rule. Table 7 gives values of minimum void dimensions for differing soil-heave potential against foundations and ground beams. The allowance for lateral Deep strip foundations.Health and safety requirements limit the use of these heave is less than that for vertical heave because lateral movement is largely foundations to below l .2m in depth. For this reason they have limited use taken up by the vertical fissures that form in clay soil following moisture in clay-heave and shrinkage situations where greater foundations depths removal. Some manufacturersof compressible material are now producing in their would be required. brochures tables that quantify the thickness of their material thatis required Trenchfill fotcndations. Irrespective of any foundation depths derived from to produce the minimum void dimensions Table in 7 (Fig 10). Values of the Chapter 4.2, all foundations should be constructed on soils capable of pressures required to compress the compressible fillhoid-former are also supporting the applied load. For foundations near trees the depths should be being included. established, taking into account the water demand and mature height of the Allowance must be madein the design of ground beams for the pressure trees and the potential movementof the soils. transfer induced when the compressible material or void-former is comhigh medium low 256 150 100 50 35 The Structural Engineer/Volurne 72/No 16/16 August 1994 Paper: Atkins et a1 1 1 I void (seeTable8) vbd (seeTable 8) into beam mtnmum 40 bar orwnd- - m+mto - TaMe 9 Heave nrecautionsfor trench fill foundations Position of dwelling in relationHeave precautions required to trees Dwelling sited withinzone of influence of trees remaining or to be removed,or over trees after remoVal. Compressible materialor void former required against inside face of all external wal foundationsgreater than1.91 deep.No compmsibb material required against faces of internal foundations. Dwellingsited withinzone of influence new of trees. None the so8 has not been desiccated and therefore heave cannot take place. Foundationdepths should be in amordame with Designdause D5 to protect against subsidence. - Fig 12.Heave precautionsfor trenchfill foundutions from Chapter 4.2 (1992) Table 9 -dt=kln Table 10- Heave precautions for plle and ground beam foundations Position of dwelling in relation to trees Heave precautionsrequired Dwellingsited within zone of influence of trees remainingor to be removed, or over trees Piles to be designed with an adequate factor of safety to reslst tenslle heave forces. Piles to be reinforced fortheir full A void, voM fonner or compressbie materialshould be providedbelow all gtoY'nd beams (see Tabie 7). A compressble material or mid former should be prwidedagalnstthe inside face of external groundbeams. Dwellingsited within zone' of influence of new None the soil has notbeendesiccated and therefore heave cannot take ptace. Foundationdepths should be In aawdance with Design dauseD5 to protect against subsidence. after remova.l trees. length. - Fig 13. Heave precautionsfor pile and ground-beam foundations from Chapter 4.2 includes both graphs and tables to establish the foundation Chapter 4.2 (1992) Table 10 depths required in relation to a tree's size, position andsoil thetype. Fig 12 shows a typical section through a trenchfill foundation. The reason why the precautions tobe taken to avoid foundation damage. The substructure design compressiblematerial is placedonthe insideface ofthetrenchfill needs to takeinto account the forces generatedby clay heave. foundation is to reduce the pressure from heaveof the dumpling enclosed The compressible material or void-former required beneath the ground within the foundations. Heave precautions are required only when there is beam reduces the upward pressure on the soffit of the beam. Tying the pile a probability of heave taking place. They are not required when deep to the ground beam with anchorage bars is important to prevent the beams foundations are provided to cope with the future growth of saplings. lifting off the pile head. The compressible materialor void-former placed When the foundation is constructed in desiccated clay, the soil on both on the insideface of the ground beamis required to allow for expansion of sideswillbeinmoistureequilibrium.Withtimetheclaywithinthe foundation will recover its moisture content resulting in an outward pressure the soil within the foundations. The rehydrationof desiccated claysoil can produce skin friction on piled on the foundation. This will normally be resisted by the passive pressureof foundations. The pile should be designed to resist the clay heave whichis the clay on the outside of the foundation. In dry summers and with the normally assumed to act over the top 3.5m of the pile shaft. The heave influence of trees, this clay will be prone to desiccation and hence reduce design should ignore any superstructure loadings, and the resultant heave the passive resistance of the soil. By placing the compressible material or force should be less than the skin friction (resisting force) of the remaining void-former on the inside of the foundation the active pressure is reduced, pile length. and disruption of the foundation is prevented. Rigid slip liners can be used to reduce the tensile forces transmitted to th The outward movement of foundations is a common form of failure pile when the desiccated clay is rehydrated. The piles should also be associated with clay heave (see Fig 5). NHBC has not experienced a claim reinforced for their full length to resist the resulting tension. Polythene where the foundations have moved in the opposite direction. The buttressing should not be used on its own as a slip membrane because it is difficult to effect of foundations to external return walls and internal walls is one place. explanation, and another is the passive resistance of the soil within the The optional rigid slip liner will reduce the upward force only by about foundation. one-third. Further research workis being carried outby the BRE. A compressible material is required only on the inside face of external an engineer's design so that it is deep enough foundations because the heave forces on internal foundations will generally The pile length must be to to resist the upward heave forces, both on the pile and on the ground beam. be in equilibrium and they are also protected from seasonal changes. The This is particularly important on low-rise construction where the dead load compressible material is not taken to the bottom of the foundation in order from the walls above may be relatively low or perhaps where the dead load to prevent the softening of the founding strata by water running down the is not applied for several months or years after the pile has been installed. inside faceof the compressiblematerialhoid former. This also allowsfull a A typical section through a pile and ground-beam foundation indicating bearing width of the foundation to be used. the heave precautions required is shown in Fig 13. The minimum void Polythene is frequently used as slip a membrane to the sidesof trenchfill dimensions to accommodate movement against the ground beam can be foundations, although it is difficult to place satisfactorily. The polythene found in Table 7 (see Fig 10). may reduce the frictional resistance between soil the and concrete. However, The table in Fig 13 indicates the heave precautions for pile and groundthe amount of this reduction is unknown, and itis much more important to beam foundations. achieve a smooth, vertical excavated face for the concrete. If the trench sides are unstable or smooth vertical faces cannot be achieved, thenan alternative Pier and ground beam foundations. As with pile and ground-beam foundations, form of foundation should be used, e.g. pile-and-ground beam. pier and ground-beam foundations should be designed to resist the effects The table in Fig 12 illustrates where the heave precautions are required of clay heave when placed in desiccated ground. Compressible material or for trenchfill foundations. a void-former shouldbe used beneath the ground beams and on their inside face. Pier foundationsmay often be quite large, and in this case, the clay on Pile andground beam foundations.The designof piled foundations should one sideof the pier can be in a different of state desiccation to the other side be based on a thoroughsite investigation that identifies the ground around of the pier, resulting in differential lateral pressures. and below thepiles. Skin friction andsoil movements arising from swelling Where the pad foundations are in excess of l .5m in depth, a void-former or shrinkage must be allowed for in the pile design, and the pile capacity or compressible material should be used to protectall the sides of the pier should be designed using established soil-mechanics methods. from heave movement. This is because the pier does not benefit from the Pile and ground-beam foundations on heave-susceptible sites require The Structural Engineer/Volume 72/No 16/16 August 1994 25 7 Paper: Atkins et a1 Special foundations. Foundations that have been specially designed for heave situations should take account of the recommendationsof Chapter 4.2. NHBC technical requirement R5 states that structural design shall be carried out by suitably qualified persons in accordance with British Standards and Codes of Practice. An example of a special foundation type being developed for heave situations is the use of precast concrete, ground beams, piles and ground floors thus allowing clear voids beneath the structure to accommodate heav movement of the soil. Where vibratory ground-improvement techniques are used on shrinkable soils such as clay fill with a plasticity index of 10%to 40%, the foundations should be designed to accommodate clay swelling and shrinkage. The depth to the underside of the concrete foundation should be in accordance with NHBC Standards, Chapter 4.23. - Table 11 Heave precautionsfor pW and ground beam foundations Position of dwelling in relation Heave precautions requited to trees Dwellii sited withinzone of CompressiMematerialor void former should be providedagainstfaces of dt pier foundat[ons greater than 1.5m deep. A vdd,voWfonnerorcompresslMematerial shouldbeprwidedbelowallground beams (seeTaMe 7). CompreSsiMe materialor void former should be provided againstthe i n s i d e face of external ground beams. Dwellingsited within zone of influenceof new trees. None - the s o i l has not been desiccated and therefore heave cannot take place. Foundation depths should be in accordance with Design clause D5 to protect against influence of trees remaining or to be mBmoyBd, or over trees after removal. Conclusion The NHBC 10-year warranty scheme enables the industry, through monitoring claims, inspections during construction and research to improve standards progressively. An example of this process can be seen in the development of guidance on building near trees, particularlyin relation to shrinkable soils. Adequate precautions taken to avoid shrinkage and heave damage will help to see that the next generation of homes benefits in full from the experience NHBC has gained in the past. Acknowledgements The authors wish to thank their colleague, I. P. Davis, BEng (Hons), CEng, MICE, NHBC Director of Standards, for assistance given in the preparation of this paper. subsidence. Fig 14. Heave precautionsfor pierand ground-beam foundations from Chapter 4.2 (1992)Table I 1 References 1. NHBC Standards Vols 1 & 2, 1992 2. NHBC Standards, Chapter 4.1, Foundations -finding the hazards, I992 buttressing effect of trenchfill or from piles which are anchored in non3. NHBC Standards, Chapter 4.2, Building near trees, 1992 desiccated soil. As with trenchfill, the compressible matenayvoid-former is 1992 4. NHBC Standards, Chapter 4.4,Strip and trenchfill foundations, not taken to the bottomof the foundation in order to prevent the softening 5. NHBC Standards, Chapter 4.5,Raft, pile, pierand beam foundations, of the foundation strata and also to maintain the base areaat the founding 1992 level. 6. NHBC Standards, Chapter 4.6, Vibratorygroundimprovement Fig 14 gives typical detailsof ground-beam and pier foundations showing techniques, 1992 where the precautionsfor heave movement need to be taken. Digestno. 3, Building 7. Housefoundationsonshrinkableclays, The table in Fig 14 details the heave precautions for pier and ground beam Research Station, Garston 1949 foundations. 8. Root damage by trees - siting of dwellings and special precautions, NHBRC Practice note 3, 1969 Raft foundations. Guidance is given for the design of raft foundations on 9. Root damage by trees - siting of dwellings and special precautions, shrinkable soils in Chapter 4.2, the founding depth being derived from the NHBC Practice note 3, 1974 graphs and tables provided. 10. Building near trees, NHBC Practice note 3, 1985 Raft foundations should be placed on fully compacted infill not exceeding 11. A quick way tofindthe right depthof foundations on clay soils,NHBC l m in depth and taken down not less than 50% of the foundation depth Supplement to Practice note 3, 1985 derived for trenchfill foundations in Chapter 4.2. The infill must extend 12. Crilly, M. S., & Chandler, R. J.: A method of determining the state of beyond the edge of the foundation by a distance equal to the natural angle desiccation in clay soils, BRE Information paper IP 4/93, Garston of repose of the infill plus OSm, as shown in Fig 15. The plan of the raft 1993 foundations should generally be rectangular with a side ratio of not more 13. Low-rise buildings on shrinkable clay soils, Part 1, BRE Digest 240, than 2:1. NHBC must be satisfied that the raft would be sufficiently stiff to Garston, 1980 resistany differential movement. Infill in excess of1m deep maybe 14. NHBC Standards, Chapter l. 1, Introduction to the standards and acceptable if it is shown to the satisfaction of NHBC that it can be fully technical requirements, 1992 compacted and resist rotational movements. The raft and fully compacted fill tend to act compositely and, therefore, resist the heave forces being applied to the structure. Heave movement is reduced by replacing up to l m of the most desiccated clay with well compacted granular fill. The fill will provide a more uniform bearing that will cushion the heave effects. Raft foundations, however, are not suitable where there is deep-seated desiccation and where large differential movementis likely to take place. l-4 0.5m Fig 15. Fully compacted infill beneath a raft foundationon shrinkable clay from Chapter 4.2 (1992) 258 The Structural Engineer/Volume 72/No 16/16 August 1994
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )