Dimensional analysis, similitude and Modeling
1 The need for dimensional analysis
! In fluid mechanics experimental testing is more often used than in other diciplines because of the limited
availability of analytical solutions for complicated applications and the simplified solutions available
are often not accurate, especially when the flow is turbulent.
! Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) models require large computers depending upon the size and
complexity of the problem.
! Therefore, experimental testing is important for understanding the fluid's behavior and for verification.
1.1 An example application - Inverted nozzle flow meter
A nozzle flow meter is used to measure the flow rate by recording the pressure drop (p) through a nozzle.
Sometimes they are installed in the wrong direction. So engineers want to understand the flow behaviour
for this situation.
Using fluid mechanics knowledge, we guess that p = p1 ¡ p2 has the following functional relationship
p = f (d0; d1; V1; ; ):
! But f () is not known.
! So we need to conduct experiments to uncover how d0; d1; V1; and influence p.
A sample experimental dataset is shown below. Let's say we need 10 data points to fit a smooth curve
between p and each of the 5 independant variables. Therefore, around 105 experiments are needed.
This is not a practical solution.
Using dimensional analysis, the functional relationship p = f (d0; d1; V1; ; ) can be reduced to an equivalent form with dimensionless group of parameters
d0 V1 d0
=
;
:
V12
d1
p
2
Dimensions of each group
p
V12
2
d0
d1
V1 d0
1.2 Modeling and Similitude
Using dimensional analysis, we can setup and conduct limited number of experiments on properly scaled
models. Using the Theory of Models the properties measured on scaled models can be used to predict
the corresponding property on the full sized prototype.
2 Buckingham Pi Theorem
! If an equation involving k variables is dimensionally homogeneous, it can be reduced to a relationship
among k¡r independent dimensionless groups, where r is the minimum number of reference dimensions
required to describe the variables.
u1 = f (u2; u3 ; u4; u5 uk)
)
Pitheorem
1 = F (2; 3 k¡r)
! r is usually equal to the number of fundamental dimensions (or combinations of them) in u1; u2 ; u3;
u4 uk either using MLT or FLT system.
! total number of -terms is fixed but they need not be unique.
2.1 Steps involved in dimensional analysis using Pi theorem
1. List all the variables that are involved in the problem.
2. Express each of the variables in terms of basic dimensions.
3. Determine the required number of -terms.
4. Select a number of repeating variables, where the number required is equal to the number of reference
dimensions (usually same as the number of basic dimensions).
5. Form a -term by multiplying one of the nonrepeating variables by the product of repeating variables
each raised to an exponent that will make the combination dimensionless.
6. Repeat Step 5 for each of the remaining nonrepeating variables.
7. Check all the resulting -terms to make sure they are dimensionless and independent.
8. Rearrange the -terms to simplify the problem or to correspond to customary usage.
2.2 Guidelines for choosing repeating variables in Step 4
1. Never pick the dependent variable. Otherwise, it may appear in all the 's, which is undesirable.
2. The chosen repeating parameters must not by themselves be able to form a dimensionless group.
Otherwise, it would be impossible to generate the rest of the 's.
3. The chosen repeating parameters must represent all the primary dimensions in the problem.
4. Never pick parameters that are already dimensionless. These are 's already, all by themselves.
5. Never pick two parameters with the same dimensions or with dimensions that differ by only an exponent.
6. Whenever possible, choose dimensional constants over dimensional variables so that only one contains
the dimensional variable.
7. Pick common parameters since they may appear in each of the 's (In fluid flow problems we generally
pick a length, a velocity, and a mass or density).
8. Pick simple parameters over complex parameters whenever possible.
2.3 Guidelines for manipulating -terms
! We can take exponent of a term by a dimensional constant.
! We can multiply a term by a dimensionless constant.
! We can form a product of any with any other to replace one of 's in the problem.
! Combination of all these three operations are also allowed.
2.4 Commonly used dimensionless numbers in fluid mechanics
2.5 Dimensions for some common physical quantities
Question 1. Determine a suitable set of Pi terms for the flow through an inverted nozzle flow meter. It
is desired to investigate the pressure drop p through the nozzle. Assume that p = f (d0; d1; V1; ; ):
Determine the required number of pi terms.
Choose repeating variables.
Find the -terms
Check if all the resulting -terms are dimensionless.
Rearrange the -terms to simplify the problem or to correspond to customary usage.
3 Modeling and Similitude
! A model is a representation of a physical system that may be used to predict the behavior of the
system in some desired respect.
! The physical system for which the predictions are to be made is called the prototype.
3.1 Theory of Models
If a given problem is described using 1 = (2; 3 n), then it applies to models as well, i.e., 1m =
(2m; 3m nm). If the model and the prototype are both subjected to similarity conditions (or modeling
laws)
2m = 2
4m = 4
nm = n
then 1m = 1. This is called the prediction equation.
3.2 Similarity conditions
Geometric similarity
Kinematic similarity
Dynamic similarity
Question 2. The drag (D) on a sphere moving in a fluid is known to be a function of the sphere diameter
(d), the velocity (V ), and the fluid viscosity () and density (). Laboratory tests on a 4-in.-diameter
sphere were performed in a water tunnel and some model data are shown in the plot. For these tests, the
viscosity of the water was 2.3 10¡5 lb ∙s/ft2 and the water density was 1.94 slugs/ft3. Estimate the drag
on an 8-ft-diameter balloon moving in air at a velocity of 3 ft/s. Assume the air to have a viscosity of 3.7
10¡7 lb ∙s/ft2 and a density of 2.38 10¡3 slugs/ft3.
D
Using dimensional analysis, we get V 2 d2 = Vd
.