Outline: From Myth to Reason: The Transition from Divine Explanations to Scientific Inquiry in Ancient Greece Philosophy has been around for thousands of years, and Greek mythology is equally extensive in how many myths exist — from detailing the Labors of Heracles to describing the nature and deeds of each Olympian god like Hera or Zeus. There are also famous poems such as The Odyssey and The Iliad, which tell the stories of heroes like Odysseus and Achilles. In ancient Greece, the Greeks believed deeply in those gods and would pray to and honor certain gods over others. As said by Dr. Bremmer, “In ancient times, religion was an integral part of society. You saw statues everywhere. If you swore an oath, you did it by the gods. Birth, maturity, death — everything was put within a context of religion.” Because religion was so central to their lives, when philosophy was first introduced into their society, it caused a lot of backlashes. This opposition became so strong that even a famous ancient Greek philosopher like Socrates was executed by the Athenians for questioning the gods themselves. Socrates is known today for creating the Socratic method, which forces people to rely on reason and not divine intervention from the gods. Now, if the Athenians killed Socrates for questioning the gods and what they believed, how did that belief change — from thinking that the gods caused disasters to questioning life itself and inspiring the beginning of science in the world? As mentioned before, Greek mythology is extensive, and for almost everything that was unexplainable in ancient Greece there was a god connected to it. A few examples of these gods include Poseidon, the god of the sea, who could cause storms and earthquakes to happen. In present times, we now know that earthquakes are caused by tectonic plates and storms by water moisture in unstable air, but back in ancient Greece they did not know these things and would say Poseidon caused them. Another famous goddess is Artemis, who was believed to have the power to send plagues or bring sudden death to mortals — or to heal them. And while these myths are Greek, this does not mean they only apply to Greek mythology, because more often than not, different religions have their own versions of similar stories of the gods. As said by Robert Graves in the book The Greek Myths, he often tells the reader a Greek myth, then gives his own interpretation of it as well as discusses what other religions say about what happened. An example of this is when he talks about two philosophical creation myths; he also talks about how they had a similar myth in Genesis: “The Jews, as inheritors of the 'Pelasgian', or Canaanitish, creation myth, had felt the same embarrassment: in the Genesis account...” So now that we have a good idea of what type of mythology there is in Greek mythology and how it is correlated to the real world lets talk about famous philosophers likes Socrates and Plato. Socrates is a famous philosopher from the second half of the 4th century BC and while he has written no works himself a lot of works are told by secondhand stories by people like Plato, Aristophanes, and Xenophon. And while they all talked about Socrates teachings. Plato is the most famous one as he was known to be a student of Socrates as well as creating Plato’s academy which is said to be the ultimate ancestor of the modern university as said by Britannica. He was also there to record Socrates’ defense plea when he was set to be executed by Athens back in 399 BC. Now why did Socrates get executed well from his defense plea we can learn a lot of why he got executed, why he did it and his stance on his execution. Socrates was executed for being a philosopher — for constantly questioning his fellow citizens to the point that it ultimately led to his death. What exactly did he question? In his Apology, he tells the story of a friend who, before dying, asked the oracle at Delphi to name the wisest man in the world. The oracle responded that it was Socrates. When Socrates learned of this, he said, “When I learned this, I asked myself, ‘What can the god's oracle mean?’ For I knew I had no wisdom. After thinking it over for a long time, I decided that I had to find a man wiser than myself so I could go back to the god's oracle with this evidence.” Socrates’ decision to question the oracle was, in the eyes of the Athenians, the same as questioning the gods themselves. In his pursuit of understanding, Socrates went around Athens meeting the men who were considered the wisest in the city — politicians, poets, and craftsmen — to see if they were truly wise. What he found, however, was that none of them possessed real wisdom; they only believed they did. This realization angered many powerful and wealthy citizens, who accused him of corrupting the youth by teaching them to question authority and religious belief. At this point in time, philosophy was highly looked down upon in Athens, since the city claimed that it obscured traditional teachings about the gods and encouraged disbelief. Many feared it made the younger generation turn away from religion, exposing how little the people truly knew about the world. These accusations ultimately led to Socrates’ death sentence. Yet even when he knew that his execution was certain, he remained true to his beliefs. When asked if he regretted his actions, he replied, “Don't you regret what you did since now it might mean your death?" To these I answer, ‘You are mistaken. A good man should not calculate his chances of living or dying. He should only ask himself whether he is doing right or wrong — whether his inner self is that of a good man or of an evil one.’” Socrates was a philosopher until the very end, and his teachings would go on to have a far deeper impact than he could have ever imagined. His philosophy centered on questioning the world itself and finding logical reason in it rather than relying on divine intervention. When it comes to Greek mythology, it was believed that the gods and the Fates controlled every aspect of the world, but people like Socrates challenged that idea. When the oracle at Delphi declared him the wisest man, he didn’t simply accept it as divine truth — he questioned it and sought proof. This line of reasoning became the foundation of his philosophy: to question the world around you and to never accept something without understanding it. Even though this belief led to his death, Socrates stayed loyal to his pursuit of truth. In Plato’s Apology, during his defense speech, Socrates gives an example of his defiance. The court offered to let him live if he promised to stop questioning others, but he refused, saying, “I will never stop doing philosophy.” His goal was not to please others but to continue seeking truth and questioning what is right or wrong. And this belief would end up causing his death but even in death he said this “Well, my fellow Athenians, you must now decide whether to acquit me or not. But whichever you do, understand that I will never change my ways, not even if I have to die many rimes. To talk daily about what makes us good, and to question myself and others, is the greatest thing man can do. For the unexamined life is not worth living.”. Socrates would end up being put to death shortly afterword after a jury debated on it. But philosophy does not end here after the execution of Socrates his final speech was about sending a powerful message about questioning life and his message inspire his students to continue his work. His most famous student was Plato deeply affected by his death Plato by showing just how dangerous it was to pursue truth in that society which was rooted in tradition and religious belief. Plato chose to continues Socrates teaching and expanded and preserve them to leave them for the world. Since unlike his predecessor Plato wrote things down and because he wrote things down. Plato is the soul reason as to why we have Socrates apology message since even though Socrates never wrote anything him self everything about his teachings were survived because of Plato’s dialogues (Kraut,2025). Because through these works Plato ensured that Socrates method of questioning, reasoning, and seeking truth would not die with him. And because of this in many ways the death of Socrates transformed philosophy as a whole from a spoken practice of just talking about it to a written tradition that could be passed down to the future as a way to teach the future generation on what philosophy is and how they can expand on it Plato did way more than just record Socrates ideas him self though he also built upon them and created his own system of philosophical thought. I would say one of these most important contributions to philosophy and science as a whole was the founding of Plato’s academy in Athens, which is widely regarded as the first university in the western world to day( Meinwalt, 2025). According to Britannica the academy became a place where scholars gather to study philosophy, mathematics, astronomy, and natural science using logic and reason rather than mythology. His creation of the academy marked a significant departure from divine explanations where the gods were the cause of natural disasters to instead establishing a foundation for scientific inquiry. The academy allowed for students to be able to understand the world in a way that was scientific and proved by evidence and rational analysis instead of relying on the gods for answers And with the creation of the academy just like Socrates, Plato himself also had some students and one of the most important people that Plato taught was Aristotle who studied at the academy for nearly twenty years and while Plato mainly focused on abstract truths and philosophical ideal by writing the theory of forms which argued that perfect, unchanging ideas exist Beyond the physical world( Philosophy now). Aristotle on the other hand believed that knowledge should be gained through direct observation of the natural world and under Plato’s guidance, Aristotle learned to apply logic to real world phenomena. This application of applying logic to real world phenomena would become the foundation of scientific investigation. This would lead away from believing in the god where goddess like Artemis which was known to send plagues and bring death and diseases would later be known to be caused by germs a bacteria far in the future and this is all because Aristotle searched for physical causes and natural laws of the world. A Greek God that is very popular is Apollo the brother of Artemis and along with Artemis he was also known to send illness to mortals as a way of punishment. So when ever a person in ancient Greece got sick they would attribute it to them angering the gods but because of Aristotle method of empirical and logical approach they would eventually discover and examine the biological process and physical conditions of the human body and eventually move away from the gods and rejecting them as a mean of explanation for everything and instead look for the natural causation of how things occur. Aristotle’s works would end up later influencing the romans with their education and Islamic science and European universities during the Middle Ages and renaissances(Britannica). Aristotle emphasis on classification, cause and effect, and the empirical observation would end up help defining on what modern science would become But before this philosophical transformation from Socrates to Aristotle we should look back on just how dominant Greek mythology was on the people and how they understood it. Any type of natural disasters, disease, seasons, and even human behavior was believed to be the doing of the Gods. Just like how it was said that Poseidon caused earthquakes and storms, Zeus was known for controlling lighting and Demeter was known for governing agriculture and the harvest. Because of this belief people would pray to the gods and as for favor for there crops or to let there be no bad weather as a mean to help provide meaning to natural forces at a time where scientific knowledge did not exist yet(Graves, 1993). Because just as Robert Graves has explained, many Greek mythos were not only religious stores but also early attempts on how to make sense of the natural worlds that why there are so many different versions of myths across different religions because people were trying to understand the world Robert graves would often compare Greek creation myths to biblical stories such as Genesis in the bible, to demonstrate and show how two different cultures and religions used divine explanations and while the myths may be different key parts like the story of Noah’s Ark where he made a ark to survive a massive flood that flooded the world . In Greek mythology a similar event happened which was named the Deucalion’s Flood where Instead of GOD in the bilbe causing the flood to wipe out the human race because of their sins. Zeus flooded the world in rage because Zeus was angered by the sons of Lycaon who sacrificed a boy to him and in anger he then disguised himself as a poor traveler and was treated poorly by the sons of Lycaon and in anger flooded the world and just like the bible when the world was flood a the king of Pythia Deucalion created an Ark just like Noah in the bible(Graves, 1993). And so while these are two different religions with two completely different beliefs that flooded was a common event that happened in the world, and each religion explained it in their own was. This was the reason why people believed in the Greek gods back then because using them they were able to explain the natural mysteries of the world. This explanation of the world would not last long though because when philosophers came around like Socrates and Plato they challenged this way of thinking by insisting that truth must be discovered through reasoning rather than tradition. So even though Socrates was executed for believing in philosophy and challenging religious authority by encouraging people to question tradition and life itself his death strengthen the philosophical movement he began. The Athenians execuated him because they saw his view of question to be dagnrous as it disrupted their belief in diving control and exposed how much people relied on divine explanation( Garrett). Yet it was because of this questioning spirt by Socrates that gave rise to philosophy. And though Plato’s writing of what Socrates taught and the academy teaching this to the public. Socrates’ ideas survived beyond Athens spreading to the world allowing it to reshape how people thought about the world. And when Aristotle started to apply his own philosophy to the physical world he would give the birth to modern science. What started as one man questioning an oracle in a time were believing in the gods was very common would end up leading to scientific discoveries that would end up defining modern society Greek mythology played a major role in shaping early Greek thought, but Socrates represented a turning point. His willingness to challenge divine authority paved the way for later philosophers and scientists who sought natural explanations instead of supernatural ones. As time moved forward, people began relying less on the gods for answers and more on their own capacity for reasoning. As said by Velasquez, the translator I used for Socrates’ defense, “Philosophy is the quest for wisdom: an unrelenting devotion to uncover the truth about what matters most in one's life.” And rather then Plato giving up philosophy to survive. Plato would end up preserving his teachers’ ideas through written dialogue and would end up founding the academy which would give birth to even more philosophers with people like Aristotle. who would started to apply reason to nature itself to understand the natural world and move away with just believing in the myths. The transition of myth to reason is not a easy or fast transition in ancient Greece. It took time and required lots of people to help create what modern science is today and it all starts with Socrates with his sacrifice and Plato continuing his legacy and furthering expanding upon it with his own theory and having his own disciples like Aristotle. These people helped moved society away from one to where they would believe in the gods to avoid or cause natural events to understanding how the world work though natural laws and laid the foundation for the roots of scientific inquiry to take place and give the birth of modern science to the world . References Bremmer, J. (n.d.). Did the ancient Greeks believe in their myths? Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften. https://www.oeaw.ac.at/en/news/did-the-ancient-greeks-believe-in-their-myths Encyclopædia Britannica. (n.d.). Aristotle. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Aristotle Garrett, J. (n.d.). Did Socrates “teach new deities”? Homer’s gods, Plato’s gods. https://people.wku.edu/jan.garrett/pgods.htm Graves, R. (1993). The Greek myths: Combined edition. Penguin Books. Kraut, R. (2025, October 9). Socrates. Encyclopædia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Socrates Meinwald, C. C. (2025, October 17). Dialogue form of Plato. Encyclopædia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Plato/Dialogue-form Philosophy Now. (n.d.). Plato: A theory of forms. https://philosophynow.org/issues/90/Plato_A_Theory_of_Forms Velasquez, M. (Trans.). (n.d.). The defense speech (“Apology”) of Socrates (abridged). https://people.wku.edu/jan.garrett/103/Apol_Velasq_Tr.htm
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )