1. Questions
1.1) The impact test is done to measure a material's resistance to sudden forces. In other words,
it helps to understand whether the material is brittle or ductile.
In this test, a metal bar is taken, and a notch is made in the middle. Then, there is a big hammerlike pendulum, which is released from a height and hits the bar. If the material is ductile, it
absorbs a lot of energy and doesn’t break easily, but if it is brittle, it breaks quickly and absorbs
less energy. This way, the impact resistance of the material is measured.
1.2) Materials fail when they cannot handle too much force, stress, or environmental effects.
If a material experiences a load beyond its limit, it may break or deform. Another reason is
fatigue, where repeated stress over time creates small cracks that eventually cause failure.
Corrosion also weakens materials by making them rust or react chemically. Additionally,
extreme temperature changes can cause expansion and contraction, leading to cracks or
structural weakness. Overall, materials fail because they become weaker over time or face
forces they cannot resist.
1.3)
1.3.1 Ductile Fracture:
1. High Energy Absorption → It absorbs a lot of energy before breaking, making it more
durable.
2. Slow Crack Growth → Cracks grow slowly, and the material does not break suddenly.
3. Fibrous Fracture Surface → The broken surface usually has a rough and fibrous
appearance.
1.3.2 Brittle Fracture:
1. Low Energy Absorption → It absorbs very little energy and breaks suddenly.
2. Sudden Failure → Cracks propagate quickly, causing unexpected failure.
3. Grain Boundary Fracture → The fracture surface often follows the grain boundaries,
creating an irregular structure.
1.4) Ductile-to-brittle transition is when a material that is normally ductile at high temperatures
becomes brittle at low temperatures. This happens because, at low temperatures, the movement
of atoms slows down, making it harder for the material to deform plastically. Instead of
stretching, it breaks suddenly.
For example, low-carbon steels show a clear ductile-to-brittle transition. At high temperatures,
they bend and stretch before breaking, but at low temperatures, they fracture suddenly. On the
other hand, materials like aluminum and copper do not have a clear transition because they stay
ductile even at low temperatures.
Engineers study this transition to make sure materials work safely in cold environments, like
bridges, ships, or pipelines in cold regions.
1.5) There are several ways to increase the strength (toughness) of metals:
1. Work Hardening (Strain Hardening) → When a metal is deformed by hammering or
rolling, its internal structure changes, making it stronger but less ductile.
2. Grain Size Reduction → Smaller grains make it harder for cracks to spread, increasing
strength.
3. Solid Solution Strengthening → Adding different elements makes the metal structure
stronger.
4. Precipitation Hardening → Tiny particles form inside the metal, blocking dislocation
movement and increasing strength.
5. Phase Transformation→ Changing the internal structure of a metal, like turning
austenite into martensite in steel, makes it much harder and stronger.
1.6) Toughness is the ability of a material to absorb energy before breaking, and it directly
affects impact resistance. A tough material can withstand sudden forces without fracturing,
while a brittle material breaks easily. Several factors influence fracture toughness, including
material structure, where fine grains improve toughness, and temperature, as low temperatures
make materials more brittle. The strain rate also matters; if a force is applied too quickly, the
material may not have time to deform and could break suddenly. Impurities, defects, and cracks
weaken the material, reducing its toughness. Additionally, phase composition in alloys affects
toughness, as some phases, like martensite in steel, increase hardness but lower toughness.
2. Discussing the Test Results
According to the Charpy impact test results, the normal specimen showed a ductile-to-brittle
transition at -20°C. This means it was tougher at high temperatures but became more brittle at
low temperatures.
The main reasons for this are:
Microstructure → The material contains ferrite and bainite, which affect impact
resistance.
MnS Inclusions → Manganese sulfide (MnS) particles inside the material reduce
toughness and increase brittleness.
Alloying Elements → Elements like Cr, Ni, and Mo influence the mechanical properties
of the steel.
Temperature Effect → At low temperatures, the steel becomes harder and more brittle.
According to the test results, at -30°C, the material fractured in a brittle manner, while at 200°C,
it remained ductile. These findings are important for understanding how the steel performs in
reactor pressure vessels.
The Figure above shows the fractured surfaces of the specimen after the Charpy impact test.
On the left (-30°C), a brittle fracture is observed, while on the right (200°C), the material
exhibits a more ductile behavior. At low temperatures, the material fractured suddenly in a
brittle manner, whereas at high temperatures, it absorbed more energy and showed plastic
deformation.
3. Calculations
For pencil :53.32 – 44.74 = 8.58 (values for group 2)
4. References
1) Kovács, D., & Kemény, D. (2020). Investigation of VVER-1200 reactor pressure
vessel’s material. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 903(1),
012051.
DOI: 10.1088/1757-899X/903/1/012051
2) Anosov, N. (2018). Differences between critical brittleness temperature and brittleviscous transition temperature of 15Cr2NiMoVA steel. Nuclear Energy Technology, 4,
155-161.
DOI: 10.1016/j.nucet.2018.07.003
3) Shtrombakh, Y. I. (2015). Effect of Ni content on the thermal and radiation resistance
of reactor pressure vessel steels. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 461, 292-300.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jnucmat.2015.03.028