Peace Psychology Book Series Series Editor Daniel J. Christie More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/7298 Shelley McKeown • Reeshma Haji Neil Ferguson Editors Understanding Peace and Conflict Through Social Identity Theory Contemporary Global Perspectives Editors Shelley McKeown Graduate School of Education University of Bristol Bristol, UK Reeshma Haji Department of Psychology Laurentian University Barrie, Ontario, Canada Neil Ferguson Department of Psychology Liverpool Hope University Liverpool, Merseyside, UK ISSN 2197-5779 ISSN 2197-5787 (electronic) Peace Psychology Book Series ISBN 978-3-319-29867-2 ISBN 978-3-319-29869-6 (eBook) DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-29869-6 Library of Congress Control Number: 2016938529 © Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2016 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved by the Publisher, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made. Printed on acid-free paper This Springer imprint is published by Springer Nature The registered company is Springer International Publishing AG Switzerland Acknowledgements This book would have not be possible without the help and support from so many of our colleagues and friends. In particular, we would like to express our sincerest gratitude to Dan Christie for his suggestion to contribute to the Peace Psychology Book Series and for his continued support throughout the editing of this book. We would also like to extend thanks to the two anonymous reviewers of our proposal and to Claire Campbell, Banu Cingöz, Janelle Jones, Laura K. Taylor, Christopher Cohrs, Manuela Thomae, Eve Binks, Juliet Wakefield, Amanda Williams, and Huseyin Cakal, who gave up their free time to review chapter abstracts and offer valuable feedback. Our thanks also goes to Victoria Weatherston, who helped format the chapters, conducted consistency checks, and developed our list of keywords. We would also like to acknowledge our respective institutions: the University of Bristol (the academic home of Henri Tajfel), Laurentian University (particularly Laurentian University Research Fund), and Liverpool Hope University for their support in helping us to get this book past the post. Last but not least, we would like to express our sincere gratitude to every one of our authors who contributed their expertise to this book. You have been a pleasure to work with. v Contents Social Identity and Peace Psychology: An Introduction ............................. Reeshma Haji, Shelley McKeown, and Neil Ferguson xv Part I Theoretical and Contemporary Issues 1 Social Identity Theory ............................................................................ Michael A. Hogg 2 Towards a Clearer Understanding of Social Identity Theory’s Self-Esteem Hypothesis .......................................................... Sarah E. Martiny and Mark Rubin 3 4 Between the Lines of Us and Them: Identity Threat, Anxious Uncertainty, and Reactive In-Group Affirmation: How Can Antisocial Outcomes be Prevented? ..................................... Adrian Lüders, Eva Jonas, Immo Fritsche, and Dimitrij Agroskin Identity and Acculturation Processes in Multicultural Societies ....................................................................... Sofia Stathi and Claudia Roscini 3 19 33 55 5 Tyranny and Leadership ........................................................................ Stephen Reicher, S. Alexander Haslam, Michael Platow, and Nik Steffens 71 6 Crowd Behaviour and Collective Action ............................................... Stephen T. La Macchia and Winnifred R. Louis 89 7 Reintegration of Child Soldiers: The Role of Social Identity in the Recruitment and Reintegration of Child Soldiers..................... 105 Michael G. Wessells vii viii Contents 8 Symbolic Reminders of Identity ............................................................ 121 Rebekah A. Phillips DeZalia and Scott L. Moeschberger 9 Identity and Psychological Health ......................................................... 135 Orla T. Muldoon, Robert D. Lowe, and Katharina Schmid 10 Global Climate Change: A Social Identity Perspective on Informational and Structural Interventions ................................... 145 Mark A. Ferguson, Rachel I. McDonald, and Nyla R. Branscombe Part II Worldwide Perspectives 11 Social Identity Theory as a Theory of Change: The Case of South Africa........................................................................ 167 Ines Meyer, Kevin Durrheim, and Don Foster 12 Social Identity and Conflict in Northern Uganda ................................ 185 Grace Lapwoch and Kennedy Amone-P’Olak 13 Representations of Social Identities in Rwanda ................................... 199 Sigrun Marie Moss 14 Social Identity Theory and Intergroup Conflict in Northern Ireland................................................................................. 215 Neil Ferguson and Shelley McKeown 15 Social Identity in a Divided Cyprus ...................................................... 229 Charis Psaltis and Huseyin Cakal 16 Building National Identity in Newborn Kosovo: Challenges of Integrating National Identity with Ethnic Identity Among Kosovar Albanians and Kosovar Serbs ..................... 245 Edona Maloku, Belle Derks, Colette Van Laar, and Naomi Ellemers 17 Canada, a Fertile Ground for Intergroup Relations and Social Identity Theory ..................................................................... 261 Richard N. Lalonde, Jorida Cila, and Maya Yampolsky 18 Social Identities and Conflict in Chile: The Role of Historical and Political Processes ............................................................................ 277 Roberto González, Monica M. Gerber, and Héctor Carvacho 19 Identity, Contact, and Health Among Majority and Minority Ethnic Groups in Mexico and Chile .............................. 295 Anja Eller, Huseyin Cakal, and David Sirlopu 20 Social Identity and Peace in the Modern Middle East: Insights from the United Arab Emirates............................................... 317 Angela T. Maitner and Robert Stewart-Ingersoll Contents ix 21 Collective and Social Identities in Philippine Peacebuilding: Does a Superordinate Bangsamoro Social Identity Mediate the Effects of Collective Ethnic Identity? .............................. 333 Cristina Jayme Montiel, Ma. Elizabeth J. Macapagal, and Jose Jowel Canuday 22 “Aussie, Aussie, Aussie, Oi, Oi, Oi”: Situating and Understanding Social Identities in Australia ................................ 349 Siew Fang Law and Cynthia Mackenzie 23 Conclusion: The Next Voyage ................................................................ 367 Shelley McKeown, Neil Ferguson, and Reeshma Haji Erratum to: Social Identity and Conflict in Northern Uganda .................. E1 Index ................................................................................................................. 375 Contributors Dimitrij Agroskin University of Salzburg, Salzburg, Austria Kennedy Amone-P’Olak University of Botswana, Gaborone, Botswana Nyla R. Branscombe University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS, USA Huseyin Cakal University of Exeter, Exeter, UK Jose Jowel Canuday Ateneo De Manila University, Quezon City, Philippines Héctor Carvacho P. Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile Jorida Cila York University, Toronto, ON, Canada Belle Derks University of Utrecht, The Netherlands Kevin Durrheim University of Kwa-Zulu Natal, Durban, South Africa Naomi Ellemers University of Utrecht, The Netherlands Anja Eller National Autonomous University of Mexico, Mexico City, Mexico Mark A. Ferguson University of Wisconsin–Stevens Point, Stevens Point, WI, USA Neil Ferguson Liverpool Hope University, Liverpool, UK Don Foster University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa Immo Fritsche University of Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany Monica M. Gerber Escuela de Sociología, Universidad Diego Portales, Santiago, Chile Roberto González P. Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile Reeshma Haji Laurentian University, Barrie, ON, Canada S. Alexander Haslam University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia Michael A. Hogg Claremont Graduate University, Claremont, CA, USA xi xii Contributors Eva Jonas University of Salzburg, Salzburg, Austria Richard N. Lalonde York University, Toronto, ON, Canada Grace Lapwoch University of Ulster, School of Psychology, Coleraine, Northern Ireland, UK Siew Fang Law Victoria University, Melbourne, VIC, Australia Winnifred R. Louis University of Queensland, St Lucia, QLD, Australia Robert D. Lowe Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK Adrian Lüders University of Salzburg, Salzburg, Austria Ma. Elizabeth J. Macapagal Ateneo De Manila University, Quezon City, Philippines Stephen T. La Macchia University of Queensland, St Lucia, QLD, Australia Cynthia Mackenzie Victoria University, Melbourne, VIC, Australia Angela T. Maitner American University of Sharjah, Sharjah, United Arab Emirates Edona Maloku Leiden University, Leiden, The Netherlands Sarah E. Martiny UiT The Arctic University of Norway, Tromsø, Norway Rachel I. McDonald University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS, USA Shelley McKeown University of Bristol, Bristol, UK Ines Meyer University of Cape Town, Rondebosch, South Africa Scott L. Moeschberger Taylor University, Upland, IN, USA Cristina Jayme Montiel Ateneo De Manila University, Quezon City, Philippines Sigrun Marie Moss Department of Psychology, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway Orla T. Muldoon University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland Rebekah A. Phillips DeZalia Coastal Carolina Community College, Jacksonville, NC, USA Michael Platow Australian National University, Canberra, ACT, Australia Charis Psaltis University of Cyprus, Nicosia, Cyprus Stephen Reicher University of St. Andrews, Fife, UK Claudia Roscini University of Greenwich, London, UK Mark Rubin The University of Newcastle, Newcastle, NSW, Australia Katharina Schmid University of Oxford, Oxford, UK David Sirlopu Universidad del Desarrollo, Santiago, Chile Contributors xiii Sofia Stathi University of Greenwich, London, UK Nik Steffens University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia Robert Stewart-Ingersoll UAE National Defense College, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates Colette Van Laar University of Leuven, Leuven, Belgium Michael G. Wessells Columbia University, Beaverdam, VA, USA Maya Yampolsky York University, Toronto, ON, Canada Social Identity and Peace Psychology: An Introduction Reeshma Haji, Shelley McKeown, and Neil Ferguson No man is an island entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main; —John Donne Humans are inherently social beings. Indeed, there is a social psychological perspective that we have a fundamental, evolutionary-based need for interpersonal relationships (Baumeister & Leary, 1995). These social connections can promote cohesive ties, but they can also create or accentuate divisions between us and those who do not belong to our groups. This book will embark on a journey of understanding of how our group memberships, or social identities, can motivate us toward harm or harmony. Peace psychology teaches us that peace is not simply the absence of conflict. Indeed, since decades ago, peace theorists have distinguished between negative peace, or the absence of violent conflict, and positive peace, the integration of society (Galtung, 1964). One key to understanding the transpiration of peace or conflict, and the consequences of these, may be our psychological attachment to our groups. According to social identity theory (SIT; Tajfel & Turner, 1979), our knowledge and emotional attachment to our group memberships have implications for our well-being and behaviour. Additionally, our group memberships provide us with a sense of selfesteem. A positive view of our own group depends in part on comparisons to other groups. In a process called intergroup differentiation, we attempt to distinguish our own group, the in-group, from out-groups, or other groups to which we do not belong. There is considerable evidence for intergroup discrimination, or the favouring of one’s own group in the allocation of rewards. In fact, this even occurs when groups are assigned on trivial basis, such as random assignment to groups and overestimates or underestimates of the number of dots in an array (Tajfel, 1970, see Chap. 1 for a thorough description of SIT). Given the substantial support for intergroup discrimination in resource allocation, it is perhaps not surprising that social identities can be responsible for conflict R. Haji Laurentian University, Barrie, ON, Canada S. McKeown University of Bristol, Bristol, UK N. Ferguson Liverpool Hope University, Liverpool, UK xv xvi Social Identity and Peace Psychology: An Introduction between groups. That is, however, not the whole story. Just as social identities can fuel conflict, they can also be harnessed in the promotion of peace. Through the lens of SIT, this book seeks to evaluate, inform, and explore how psychological attachment to our groups contributes to peace and conflict in today’s global society. Why Now? Why This Book? Identity has been a widely researched construct that has been tackled by different epistemological approaches. It is our hope that this book will be a resource for scholars and students alike, including those from disciplines outside of psychology. Although the book is generally written from a psychological perspective, as a volume of the Springer Peace Psychology Book Series, identity and its role in peace and conflict is a topic of widespread relevance. As such, we apply our understanding of social identity theory within a peace psychology framework. According to Christie, Wagner, and Winter (2001): Peace psychology seeks to develop theories and practices aimed at the prevention and mitigation of direct and structural violence. Framed positively, peace psychology promotes the nonviolent management of conflict and the pursuit of social justice, what we refer to as peacemaking and peacebuilding, respectively. (p. 7) Given the powerful influence of our attachment to our groups, a social identity approach to understanding peace and conflict is highly relevant in today’s world; in which differences in cultural, religious, ethnic, political, and national affiliations seem to underlie most of the conflicts pervading the news. In undertaking this SIT approach, we have applied social identity theory to address both direct and indirect (structural) violence, and in the examination of both positive and negative peace. Whilst identity has been studied in multiple ways, what is new is our approach and, with it, our scope. The current volume attempts to provide a comprehensive theoretical and cross-cultural account of social identity theory applied to peace and conflict. The research and theory chapters trace the historical development of SIT, and bring us up-to-date with the latest innovations and advances. The country case chapters provide a diverse account of social identity as it relates to peace and conflict in different regions of the world. Importantly, this book does not put the emphasis on conflict alone. Rather, the chapters herein attempt to illustrate how social identity can be applied in the promotion of peaceful intergroup relations. Our Travel Itinerary We will embark on essentially two voyages, each with a number of stops along the way. The first, Part I of this volume, provides our theoretical foundation. The second, Part II of this volume, provides us with contextual applications in diverse geographical regions. Together, they aim to deepen our understanding and our Social Identity and Peace Psychology: An Introduction xvii exploration of how social identity can fuel conflict or support the development or maintenance of peace. In Chap. 1, Hogg provides us with a historical development of SIT up to presentday perspectives on the theory. We are given the benefit of the context in which Henri Tajfel formulated his predictions. Key principles of social identity theory and self-categorisation theory are described. The self-esteem hypothesis is introduced. Additionally, we are provided with strategies that groups may use to deal with negative status. We are also provided with more recent perspectives within SIT, such as entitativity and uncertainty-identity theory. In Chap. 2, Martiny and Rubin provide a detailed account of the self-esteem hypothesis, with all its complexities. They emphasise the importance of a valid test of the second corollary of the hypothesis and describe what such a test would entail. We are also given an explanation of specific collective state self-esteem, which is crucial to understanding the nuances of the self-esteem hypothesis. Finally, we are provided with a very useful reformulation of the self-esteem hypothesis, as well as a demonstration of its generality and potential applications. In Chap. 3, we venture deeper into the territory of identity uncertainty. In particular, identity threat is discussed by Lüders, Jonas, Fritsche, and Agroskin in terms of the problems that it poses for intergroup relations. Lüders et al. suggest how anxious uncertainty can be quelled by affirmation of a group to which one belongs and they apply their analysis to the timely issue of the refugee crisis currently being faced by various countries around the globe. In Chap. 4, we arrive at the intersection of SIT and another key theory in the psychology of intergroup relations, intergroup contact theory . In particular, Stathi and Roscini deal with this intersection within the context of multicultural societies, which are increasingly becoming the norm in today’s world. They review traditional and more recent theoretical perspectives on acculturation, the process by which an immigrant community adapts to a host culture, and examine majority-minority dynamics as they relate to identity and social categorisation. We then turn our attention to the application of SIT to the understanding of other socially relevant phenomena. In particular, Chap. 5 deals with the application of SIT to understanding tyranny and leadership. Innovatively, Reicher, Haslam, Platow, and Steffens draw on why people obey tyrannical leaders and offer examples of tyrannical leadership from across the globe as well as psychological studies of tyranny represented in the Stanford Prison Experiment and BBC prison study. At a neighbouring destination, La Macchia and Louis in Chap. 6 provide a much needed and timely integration of SIT and theories of crowd behaviour. Before doing so, they review competing accounts of crowd behaviour and of collective action. Through a social identity lens, they examine the case studies of crowd behaviour in the St. Paul’s Riot, the Battle of Westminster, and the 2011 UK riots. La Macchia and Louis then suggest connections between SIT approaches and theories of crowd behaviour, ending with applications to peace and conflict. In Chap. 7, Wessells takes us on a tour of how social identity can be applied to the perplexing problem of reintegrating into society children who previously served, often involuntarily, as soldiers in a conflict. This is a real-world situation fraught with identity-related challenges. In Chap. 8, Phillips De Zalia and Moeschberger xviii Social Identity and Peace Psychology: An Introduction explore the role of semiotics and symbolic reminders of identity, linking dialogical self theory and social representtation theory to SIT through case studies of Northern Ireland and South Africa. In doing so, they illustrate how symbols are used to promote particular social identities in everyday life. Another application to daily living is provided by Muldoon, Lowe, and Schmid in Chap. 9 that deals with how SIT can be applied in the domain of health. In particular, we are provided with an exploration of the role of social identity as a key driver in psychological well-being and resilience in conflict and post-conflict environments, and how identity can shape reactions to political violence and the outcome of exposure to traumatic stress and political violence. Next we turn our attention to a topic that is of increasing worldwide concern and that has become the subject of policy debates. Specifically, in Chap. 10, Ferguson, McDonald, and Branscombe give us a view of how social identity theory can be used to inform theory and interventions related to global climate change. With these highly relevant applications with SIT in mind, we end our first voyage. Our second voyage, that comprises Part II of the book, entails an expedition through our different country cases that have each dealt with their share of challenges related to peace and conflict. We begin with South Africa in Chap. 11, a country in which identity and social protest continues to be linked to violence since the fall of apartheid and the democratic elections of 1994. In this chapter, Meyer, Durrheim, and Foster offer a historically embedded and currently situated discussion of identity in the rainbow nation. In Chap. 12, we explore Uganda’s postcolonial struggles with ethnic identity issues and related conflicts. Lapwoch and Amone-P’Olak then outline a number of strategies for promoting more harmonious interethnic relations and also emphasise the importance of construction of a national identity. Our next stop is Rwanda, where in Chap. 13 Moss examines the policy of recategorisation into a single group, with the goal of including all Rwandans under a superordinate identity, and what that means for subgroup identities that persist more than two decades since the genocide. The next part of our journey takes place in Europe. In Chap. 14, Ferguson and McKeown explore one of the most prodigious testbeds for SIT, namely Northern Ireland. They chart the history of research on social identity and intergroup conflict in Northern Ireland and explore how research in Northern Ireland has advanced knowledge of SIT and intergroup relations in a number of key areas, such as social categorisation and intergroup relations, the role of identity in embracing the conflict, coping with stress and intergroup contact. Drawing parallels to relations in Northern Ireland, in Chap. 15 Psaltis and Cakal weave a narrative of identity, peace, and conflict in divided Cyprus. They discuss the role of history, narrative, and multiple identities drawing on empirical data amongst both Turkish Cypriots and Greek Cypriots. Our European excursion ends with Chap. 16, where Maloku, Derks, Van Laar, and Ellemers delve into the meanings of the new Kosovar identity that emerged after independence in 2008. This superordinate identity is problematic as the inhabitants associate themselves with the ethnic majority, Albanian; or the ethnic minority, Serbian. Social identity complexity and the common in-group identity model are applied to the analysis. Social Identity and Peace Psychology: An Introduction xix We then travel to the Americas. In Chap. 17, Lalonde, Cila, and Yampolsky teach us about the complexities of social identities in Canada, including clashes between Aboriginal Peoples and non-Aboriginals, between the English and the French, and between immigrants and those already established in the country. Historical and contemporary views of these conflicting identities are provided. In Chap. 18, Gonzalez, Gerber, and Carvacho offer a historical and political analysis of identities in Chile, including the hierarchical relations between the White, mestizo, and indigenous groups. These are traced from their colonial historical roots to present-day status inequities and tensions. There is also an analysis of the migration process in Chile, and how an intensified national identity is associated with opposition to immigration. Our Latin American journey continues in Chap. 19 where Eller, Cakal, and Sirlopu provide a comparative analysis of empirical research conducted in Mexico and Chile. They explore the relationships between ethnic and national identities and health and well-being with samples of mestizos, and indigenous and non-indigenous Chileans and Mexicans. The findings from their studies illustrate the importance of identity abstraction on health and well-being in these two Latin American countries. Finally, we venture to Asia and Australasia. First we travel to the United Arab Emirates in Chap. 20 where Maitner and Stewart-Ingersoll examine social identity at multiple levels, including Emirati identity, Arab identity in the broad sense, and identities relating to a stable multicultural social hierarchy. They also describe a dynamic process in which culture interacts with identity to predict the behaviour of multicultural individuals. Next, we stop at the Philippines in Chap. 21 where Montiel, Macapagal, and Canuday report on the progress which has been made toward peace between Muslims and Christians, but where conflicting ethnic identities remain associated with different reactions to proposed legislation supporting autonomy for Islamic groups in the Mindanao region. Finally, we arrive in Australia in Chap. 22 where constructions of identity in the contemporary diverse society come with their own complexities and challenges. Law and MacKenzie explore how different interpretations of Australian history impact on identity construction in contemporary Australia. In particular, Law and MacKenzie focus on conflicting interpretations of “Australia Day” and contemporary events such as recent terrorism in Sydney to discuss and analyse identity complexities in Australia. At the conclusion of our second voyage, we more closely examine some of the more perplexing themes that pervade this book. In particular, our focus is on how social identity can be applied to the promotion of peace. We also suggest directions for future research, theory, and practice in this area. Importantly, we present possibilities for applying theoretical predictions and research findings related to SIT to complex real-world problems and how we might make this knowledge more readily accessible and more easily consumable. Join us on this journey of understanding and exploration. We hope that you will find it enriching and generative. We also hope that it gives you hope. Just as SIT can be applied to illuminate our understanding of intergroup conflict, it can illuminate potential paths to peace. xx Social Identity and Peace Psychology: An Introduction References Baumeister & Leary (1995). The need to belong: The desire for interpersonal attachments as a fundamental human motivation. Psychological Bulletin, 117, 497–529. Christie, D. J., Wagner, R. V., & Winter, D. A. (Eds.). (2001). Peace, conflict, and violence: Peace psychology for the 21st century. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall. Galtung (1964). An Editorial. Journal of Peace Research, 1, 1–4. Tajfel, H. (1970). Experiments in intergroup discrimination. Scientific American, 223, 96–102. Tajfel, H., & Turner, J. C. (1979). An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In W. G. Austin & S. Worchel (Eds.), The social psychology of intergroup relations (pp. 33–47). Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )