Research in Science & Technological Education ISSN: (Print) (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/crst20 The effects of combining simulations and laboratory experiments on Zimbabwean students’ conceptual understanding of electric circuits Kevin Manunure, Alice Delserieys & Jérémy Castéra To cite this article: Kevin Manunure, Alice Delserieys & Jérémy Castéra (2020) The effects of combining simulations and laboratory experiments on Zimbabwean students’ conceptual understanding of electric circuits, Research in Science & Technological Education, 38:3, 289-307, DOI: 10.1080/02635143.2019.1629407 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/02635143.2019.1629407 Published online: 19 Jun 2019. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 582 View related articles View Crossmark data Citing articles: 12 View citing articles Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=crst20 RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 2020, VOL. 38, NO. 3, 289–307 https://doi.org/10.1080/02635143.2019.1629407 The effects of combining simulations and laboratory experiments on Zimbabwean students’ conceptual understanding of electric circuits Kevin Manunure a,b , Alice Delserieys c and Jérémy Castéra c a Faculty of Science Education, Bindura University of Science Education, Bindura, Zimbabwe; bTeacher Education, Teachers College, Mutare, Zimbabwe; cEA4671 ADEF, ENS de Lyon, Aix-Marseille Universite, Marseille, France ABSTRACT KEYWORDS Background: Information Communication Technologies are increasingly present in the African educational system at all educational levels. However, their integration into pedagogical practices to improve the quality of teaching and learning across disciplines remains the exception. Purpose: The purpose of the study was to compare the learning achievements of students on the topic of Direct Current Electrical Circuits when they are randomly exposed to different learning environments. Sample: The population of the study consists of 265 secondary students at an urban school in Harare Zimbabwe, 49 (18.5%) of which participated in the study. The school was chosen for convenience purpose. A quasi-experimental design was used to randomly assign two intact classes. One class (n = 24) was assigned as a control group (using real laboratory activities) and the other class (n = 25) as an experimental group (using simulation and laboratory activities together). The sample had not previously received formal instruction on the topic. Participants are of mixed gender (44.9% girls) and their age ranged from 12 to 14 years. Design and methods: The study took place during the first term of 2015. Students’ conceptual level of understanding and the reduction in their misconceptions about electric circuits were measured by a three-tier misconception test, both at pre-test and at post-test. The effect of the treatments was statistically analysed using various statistical tools. Results: There is a significant difference in the level of conceptual understanding in which the experimental group performed higher than the control group. The results also demonstrated that a combination environment had an expected effect of decreasing the proportion of students’ misconceptions on electric circuits more than in the laboratory environment alone. Conclusions: The outcomes of the study suggest the use of simulation and practical activities in parallel as a better way of teaching students the topic of direct current electric circuits. Computer simulations enhance students’ learning of abstract concepts; hence they should be promoted. Conceptual understanding; misconception; simulation; electric circuits; laboratory activity CONTACT Kevin Manunure manunurek@gmail.com Faculty of Science Education, Bindura University of Science Education, Bindura, Zimbabwe This article was originally published with errors, which have now been corrected in the online version. Please see Correction (https://doi.org/10.1080/02635143.2019.1641926) © 2019 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group 290 K. MANUNURE ET AL. Introduction Information communication technologies (ICTs) are increasingly present in Zimbabwean systems at all levels from pre-school to university and are mainly being taught as a separate discipline. However, their integration to pedagogical practices to improve the quality of teaching and learning across disciplines remains the exception (Layard 2009). Research has also shown that new digital technologies in Sub-Saharan Africa have the potential to increase the quality of subject teaching and learning when carefully integrated into the classroom. Teachers and teacher trainers are further challenged to integrate ICTs into subject teaching and learning using contemporary pedagogical approaches (Hennessy, Harrison, and Wamakote 2010). According to Konyana and Konyana (2013), Zimbabwe’s education sector seems to miss out on the full benefit of ICT. It is within this context that the research seeks to determine the effect of ICT in instructional method when teaching the topic of Electric Circuits. Several research studies were done in the past to highlight the misconceptions students have on electric circuits (Driver et al. 1994; Hussain, Latiff, and Yahaya 2012; Kollöffel and Jong 2013; Suchai and Thasaneeya 2012; Turgut, Gürbüz, and Turgut 2011). The most frequently reported misconceptions include the assumption of the battery as a constant current source and the confusion between electric current and energy by assuming that current is consumed by electric devices. Several other research studies were also done on the method of instruction that can be used to teach the concepts of electric circuits (Bayrak, Kanli, and Ingec 2007; Farrokhnia and Esmailpour 2010; Tomi; Jaakkola, Nurmi, and Veermans 2011), some of which may actually introduce and reinforces misconceptions (Taşlıdere 2013). literature is shown to favour an instructional method that promotes visualisation and manipulation since physics mostly deals with three-dimensional (3-D) objects (Farrokhnia and Esmailpour 2010). Computer simulations and laboratory practicals are some of the methods that provide both facets of visualisation and manipulation. But to our knowledge, none of these research studies were done in the context of Zimbabwe. Turgut, Gürbüz, and Turgut (2011) emphasised that students’ misconceptions may differ depending on their language, culture and teaching strategy. Since Zimbabwe is a country with its unique language, culture and teaching strategy, it is imperative to do this study within the context of Zimbabwe as was emphasised by Turgut, Gürbüz, and Turgut (2011). This article presents the findings from a study on the comparison of students’ achievements in electric circuits when in Laboratory only and Simulation-Laboratory environment, at an urban school in Harare Zimbabwe. The research question addressed in this study was, essentially: Which method of instruction is more effective in teaching the concept of electric circuits; using Laboratory activities only or using a combination of simulation and laboratory activity? Review of literature Students’ ideas about electric circuits Previous research has shown that students bring to class ideas and interpretations about electricity which they have built from their everyday language and experiences of the RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 291 world. These ideas usually interfere and affect their ability to assimilate scientific ideas introduced in class (Hammer 1996; Zacharia 2007). The ideas are also greatly influenced by the peers, the media and pre-instruction. Although these ideas are often poorly articulated, internally inconsistent and highly context-dependent, they offer tremendous explanatory power for the students (Clément 2003; Lee and Law 2001). Due to this reason, students’ ideas can be different, and the distance between students’ ideas and the correspondent scientific concept should be investigated meticulously by educators (Ozgur 2013). Students’ ideas can be resistant to change and easily interfere with students’ abilities to learn scientific concepts (Hammer 1996; Tommi; Jaakkola and Nurmi 2008; Treagust and Duit 2008). Students’ ideas about a scientific concept or phenomena are functional in students’ minds. If not well challenged through rigorous questioning, it is difficult for students to define new ideas that are consistent with the scientific model targeted by the teacher whether or not knowledge about the subject is integrated into students’ cognitive structures (Ozgur 2013). These ideas are often referred in the literature as preconceptions, alternative conceptions or misconceptions. In this paper, we will use the term misconception as it has been broadly studied in the context of students’ understanding of the electric circuits. Regarding the concept related to electric circuits, there are two main ideas that students bring to class: 1) they tend to assume that the battery is a constant current source, showing confusion between current and voltage; 2) they tend to make a confusion between the electric current and energy by assuming that current is consumed by electric devices (Engelhardt and Beichner 2004; Turgut, Gürbüz, and Turgut 2011). Though the two previous ideas are central, several research studies have revealed many other misconceptions among students. Without giving much detail of the individual studies, the common misconceptions in the related literature are the following (Peşman and Eryılmaz 2010; Suchai and Thasaneeya 2012; Taşlıdere 2013). (1) The Sink Model (M1); students think that only a single wire connection between an electrical device and a power supply allows the electricity to sink from the power supply to the electrical device thereby powering the device. (2) The Attenuation Model (M2); students think that an electric current travelling around an electric circuit in one direction decreases gradually due to the consumption of it by devices within the circuit. Students assume that the second bulb in a circuit will be less bright than the first bulb because it will be receiving less current. (3) The Shared Current Model (M3); students think that an electric current is shared equally by electrical devices within the circuit. (4) The Clashing Current Model (M4); students think that positive electrons come from positive terminal while negative electrons move from the negative terminal of a power supply. The positive and negative electrons meet at a device and clash, thereby powering the device. (5) The Empirical Rule Model (M5); students think that the bulbs which are further away from the power supply are dimmer than the closer bulbs. Students assume that distance from the power supply is more important regardless of how the bulbs are arranged in a circuit or the direction of current flow. (6) The Short-Circuit Misconception (6); students tend to ignore wires with no electrical devices when they are analysing an electrical circuit. 292 K. MANUNURE ET AL. (7) The Power Supply as a Constant Current Source (M7); students think that any power supply provides an electric circuit with a constant electrical current rather than electrical energy. (8) The Parallel Circuit Misconceptions (M8); resistors are thought of as an obstacle to current flow, assuming any increase in the number of resistors in parallel to increase total resistance. (9) The Sequential Model (M9); students think that a change before the bulb affects the brightness of the bulb in circuits connected in series, but the same bulb is not affected by change anywhere in the circuit after the bulb. (10) Local Reasoning (M10); students focus their attention upon one point in a circuit ignoring what is happening elsewhere. The local part is focused on instead of a global analysis. (11) Current Flow as Water Flow (M11); students view electric flow in a wire like water flow in a pipe. Most of the current goes straight and less amount of it goes to the wire which is not straight. Unlu and Dokme (2011) have shown that even after a systematic and fairly advanced study of the topic Electric Circuits in a college, students were still unable to qualitatively analyse simple circuits. It is evident that misconceptions in the topic persist from elementary through secondary and tertiary and even after formal instruction (Kollöffel and Jong 2013; Peşman and Eryılmaz 2010; Suchai and Thasaneeya 2012; Zacharia 2007). In this article, a study was conducted on one course of Electric Circuit at secondary Junior Level. A multiple choice three-tier Simple Electric Circuit Diagnostic Test (SECDT) was used to test and compare students’ misconceptions and level of conceptual understanding when exposed to two different learning conditions (Laboratory only and Laboratory-Simulation environment). Bridging the gap between simulations and laboratory practicals Computer simulations and laboratory practicals have been regarded as one of the methods that provide both facets of visualisation and manipulation which is critical for the understanding of electrical circuit concepts (Farrokhnia and Esmailpour 2010). However, the two methods have been traditionally treated as substitute or competing methods in science teaching. Over the last few decades, with the development of technologies and changes in instructional methods, the use of computers in the educational environment becomes popular. Some researchers argue that computer simulations have all the facets of conceptual development and can be used to replace laboratory practicals (Bajpai 2013; Finkelstein et al. 2005a). Other researchers maintain that simulations should only be used as a surrogate to laboratory practicals (Marshall and Young 2006). In this study, laboratory activities are defined as the specific instructional strategy where students are actively engaged in manipulating real laboratory materials. Students are ‘hands on’ and closely involved in managing and organising the laboratory materials. They make instant decisions where necessary, for example, if they suspect that the battery or switch is not functional by replacing them. In case of short-circuit connections, students have the opportunity to smell or feel the heat produced as a result of the connection error. The opportunity to smell, feel the heat or encounter unfunctional RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 293 materials is limited in a simulation environment that uses ideal materials. Simulations are defined as the transfer of events with specific limitations in daily life to the computerbased learning environment. Students have the opportunity to manipulate the circuit materials by dragging them into position and instantly see the effect. Ideal materials are used and this help in limiting unnecessary confusions. However, the opportunity to feel other salient effects like smell and heat are limited. The combination of simulation and real laboratory activities can promote students’ understanding of electricity most efficiently (Tomi Jaakkola, Nurmi, and Veermans 2011; Unlu and Dokme 2011). It has been shown that simulations can help students to understand the theoretical principles of electricity. A practical activity then challenges students’ misconceptions, as laws and principles that are discovered through a simulation also prove to apply in reality. This is important in bridging the gap between theory and reality (Tomi Jaakkola, Nurmi, and Veermans 2011). Students can use the positive traits of both virtual and real materials for more conceptual and deeper learning (Farrokhnia and Esmailpour 2010). McDermott and Shaffer (1992), illustrated that students may not be able to recognise the relationship between the features of a circuit diagram and the electrical elements and wires that comprise the physical system. Recent research studies argue that simulations constrain the students in productive ways by avoiding ambiguity, for example, in determining whether a light bulb is on, or whether wires are connected. They are designed to provide clear visual cues that emphasise the necessary conditions, which otherwise can cause trouble for student using real circuits in an unconstrained environment (Finkelstein et al. 2005b; Tomi; Jaakkola, Nurmi, and Veermans 2011). However, to the researcher’s knowledge, there seems to be no literature on how students understand the symbols represented in simulation in comparison to the real circuits. Simulations help students gain more conceptual knowledge with a long retention period and the ability to quickly assemble real circuits and describe how it worked (Bayrak, Kanli, and Ingec 2007; Finkelstein et al. 2005a). Through quizzes that were given soon after the laboratory activities, Rytting (2016) demonstrated that simulations can be more effective than real laboratory activities in fostering conceptual understanding of physics concepts. Though research points out that simulations are effective, instructors are warned that the effectiveness is not self-evident, but it depends on the way it is used (Smetana and Bell 2012). By engaging in real laboratory practicals, students are also engaged to experience phenomena and to gain some tacit knowledge through measurement, estimation and observation by manipulating real laboratory materials. Lack of familiarity with real batteries and bulbs can be a serious handicap when students attempt to relate electrical concepts to real circuits (McDermott and Shaffer 1992). Students gain indescribable knowledge on what is happening or what is supposed to happen as opposed to the norm in which they seek to understand how and why things behave that way. It is also through laboratory activities that students are familiarised with the world around them and that cannot be achieved through any other way (Kirschner and Huisman 1998). Current research has also shown that students view laboratory practicals as more effective than simulations (Rytting 2016). 294 K. MANUNURE ET AL. Conceptual understanding Most students bring to the class ideas from the world which do not match scientific explanation (Hammer 1996; Zacharia 2007). For the student to, therefore, understand and accept the correct scientific phenomena, s/he has to undergo a process of conceptual change. Conceptual change in science learning is rooted in Piagets’ constructivist ideas. It considers learning to be a process where new knowledge builds on existing knowledge (pre-conceptions). This can be achieved through revision, by modifying the pre-conception to accommodate new knowledge. Instructional activity should not fit students’ existing ideas to promote dissatisfaction and then it should explain the anomaly to promote fruitfulness (Duit and Treagust 2003). When the learner is firmly committed to prior conceptions, accommodation of the new concept may involve changes in one’s fundamental assumptions about the world, about knowledge, and about knowing and that such changes can be strenuous and potentially threatening (Posner et al. 1982). For a conception to be fully accommodated by the learner, it has to be intelligible (sensible and understandable), plausible and fruitful for further inquiry (Posner et al. 1982; Treagust and Duit 2008). A student who shows conceptual understanding is one who is able to explain the concept in line with scientific explanation. The curricular objectives, content, teaching strategies and the teacher’s role are important factors in providing a rational basis for a conceptual change in students (Posner et al. 1982). Methods Experimental design, population and sample The population of the study consists of 265 secondary students at an urban school in Harare Zimbabwe, of which 49 (18.5%) participated in the study. The school was chosen for convenience purpose since it was the working station for the researcher. A quasi experimental and a between-subject design was used to randomly assign two classes. Two intact classes of first-year secondary students were selected as the sample because previously they had not received formal instruction on Direct Current Electric Circuit (DCEC). One class (n = 24) was randomly assigned as a control group (using real laboratory activities), and the other class (n = 25) was assigned as an experimental group (using simulation and laboratory activities together), refer to Table 1. Participants are of mixed gender (44.9% girls) and their age ranged from 12 to 14 years, refer to Table 2. Tools Simple electric circuit diagnostic test (SECDT) A three-tier Simple Electric Circuit Diagnostic Test (Figure 1) developed and validated by Peşman and Eryılmaz (2010) was used to measure students’ conceptual understanding Table 1. Experimental design of the study. Groups Experimental group Control Pre-Test Method Combining real laboratory and simulation activities Laboratory activities only Post-Test RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 295 Table 2. Number of students within groups according to their gender and age. Gender Groups Experimental group Control group Total M 14 13 27 Age F 11 11 22 12y 7 12 19 13y 14 10 24 14y 4 2 6 Total 25 24 49 Figure 1. Sample question from the simple electric circuit diagnostic test (SECDT). and misconceptions in Direct Current Electric Circuit (DCEC). The test consists of 12 items, measuring 11 misconceptions. A misconception can be measured by more than one item depending on how the student answers the items at three-tier level. The characteristics of the test are that each item has three tiers; the first tier is a conventional multiple-choice question with at least two choices. The second tier presents some reasons for the given answer to the first tier on which a student is forced to select a choice. This gives the researcher an opportunity to make sense of whether a wrong choice to the first tier of an item is due to a misconception and/or if a correct answer to the first tier is because the student actually understands the scientific concept being tested. The third tier examines if the student is confident about his/her answers for the previous first two tiers. The answer will reveal if a student has a misconception or if the two previous answers were due to lack of knowledge. This is crucial for remediation purposes since a student with misconceptions may need different help to a student who lacks knowledge. This will also help in determining the type of instruction, whether it should be centred on eliminating misconception or directed towards acquisition of knowledge (Peşman and Eryılmaz 2010; Taşlıdere 2013). On the second tier, a free response option is given to allow the learner to express his/her idea about the concept being tested, in case the learner feels there is no reasonable answer from the given options. The response option will allow the researchers to identify more undocumented misconceptions on electric circuits. Suchai and Thasaneeya (2012) revealed that the more research on electric circuits; the more misconceptions that are revealed. Identification of new misconceptions is however beyond the scope of this research. 296 K. MANUNURE ET AL. Three-tier multiple-choice tests are fast, easy to administer and analyse and provide a deep understanding of students’ responds (Peşman and Eryılmaz 2010; Taşlıdere 2013; Turgut, Gürbüz, and Turgut 2011). In this study, the test recorded a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.60 as the reliability coefficient, in Peşman and Eryılmaz (2010) it was 0.55 and 0.81 reliability coefficient in Taşlıdere (2013) study. Variables and data collection To measure conceptual understanding, four variables (understanding at first-tier level, understanding at second tier level and confidence at third-tier level; i) considering firsttier scores only and ii) considering first and second tier scores were obtained using the Answer Key (Table 3), and an example showing how understanding scores were produced is shown in Table 4. To measure confidence in second-tier responses, if a students’ answer to the third tier is ‘Yes, I am’ and both responses to the first and second tiers were correct; then, the score was coded as 1 or otherwise as 0 under column 3.2. To measure confidence in first-tier responses, if a students’ answer to the third tier is ‘Yes, I am’ and the response to the first tier was correct; then, the score was coded as 1 or otherwise as 0 under column 3.1. To measure understanding at second tier level, if a student answered the first and second tier correctly, it was coded as 1 or otherwise it was coded 0 under column 2. To measure understanding at first-tier level, if a student answered the first tier correctly; then, the score was coded as 1 or otherwise as 0 under column 1. The scores at each tier level range from 0 to 12 on a quasi-interval scale, where 0 is the minimum score while 12 is the maximum score that can be obtained. At the third tier (column 3.2), a score of 12 shows total understanding and with confidence while score 0 indicate total lack of confidence in responses given in the second tier. In column 3.1, the scores represent the level of confidence to first-tier responses only. At tier 2, score 12 represents the highest level of understanding while score 0 indicates lack of deep concept understanding. The score provided a stronger indication about students’ understanding beyond that provided by the first-tier score. At tier 1, the scores represent understanding only at the first-tier level. To measure misconceptions, a binomial scale was used. All three tiers of the items were considered using alternative sets indicating each misconception. If a students’ answer to the third tier is ‘Yes, I am’ and both answers to the first and second tiers were Table 3. Answer key for the SECDT. 1.1B 1.2C 1.3A 2.1B 2.2B 2.3A 3.1A 3.2B 3.3A 4.1A 4.2B 4.3A 5.1B 5.2D 5.3A 6.1B 6.2B 6.3A 7.1A 7.2C 7.3A 8.1A 8.2A 8.3A 9.1B 9.2C 9.3A 10.1B 10.2D 10.3A 11.1B 11.2A 11.3A 12.1C 12.2A 12.3A Table 4. Example showing how understanding scores were produced on Microsoft excel. Scores at different tier levels Student 1 2 Sex M M 1 4 4 2 4 1 3.1 3 4 3.1 2 0 RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 297 correct; then, it was coded as 0 or otherwise it was coded 1. The code 0 reflects no existence of that particular misconception while code 1 reflects the existence of the specific misconception. A misconception can be assessed by more than one item. The average frequency of misconceptions for each of the 11 misconceptions in a group was considered for evaluation. Low percentage average score shows that the group had little misconception while a higher average percentage score means the group had a strong misconception on that particular item. To statistically evaluate the level of conceptual understanding, an online Social Science Statistics (Stangroom 2018) package programme was used. The Mann–Whitney U test was used to compare the conceptual understanding of the two groups at pre-test while an independent samples t-test was used to compare the effects of treatment at post-test. A Wilcoxon test was used to assess the effect of treatment within each group. Spearman’s Rho (correlation) and Pearson correlation coefficient were used to determine the relationship between understanding scores and level of confidence at pre-test and post-test, respectively. To statistically evaluate the magnitude of misconceptions, the Mann Whitney and Wilcoxon test were used. Two independent scores were used in measuring student performance in misconceptions and in conceptual understanding. The concept of misconceptions and conceptual understanding are strongly believed to be closely related. The relationship is however not always linear, for example, consider child ‘A’ who has no idea on how current flows and light a bulb in an electric circuit, child ‘B’ shows lack of understanding and has a misconception on current flow. This research, therefore, considers that child ‘B’ may require a different mode of instruction to child ‘A’ in order to accommodate a conception that is consistent with scientific explanation and disregard the misconception s/he has. Simulation Physics Education Technology (PhET), Circuit Construction Kit (CCK) simulation (Figure 2) was used in this research. The software is freely available online https://phet.corolado. edu/, can be downloaded, making it more suitable to be used even in countries like Zimbabwe where there are challenges in network connections. The simulation is easier for teachers to use because it provides teaching resources, teaching tips and reviews. It is also user-friendly to students. The software simulates the behaviour of simple electric circuits. It provides an open workspace where students can manipulate resistors, light bulbs, wires and batteries. The learner can measure voltage, resistance or current using installed voltmeter and ammeter by simply dragging the elements into proper position. Learners are given the chance to directly manipulate initial conditions and immediately see the impact (Zacharia 2007). Treatment and procedure The implementation of the study lasted for seven and half hours (71/2 h) and was spread over 3 weeks (21/2 h a week) in the Junior Science Laboratory. Duration of the lessons was two 60 min and one 30-min periods per week. In order to control for the possible teacher effect, one teacher was the main instructor with two research assistants. The computers (laptops) with installed simulation were collected soon after lessons and 298 K. MANUNURE ET AL. Figure 2. A snapshot of a CCK (slightly edited). The students can construct the circuits to compare the magnitude of the current 11, 12 and 1A, 1B. securely kept in order to prevent students from the control group to have access to the software during their free time. A 10-min introduction on the test instrument was given to both learning conditions before administering as a pre-test. Students were given 60 min to write the test. Before the beginning of instruction, the instructors made sure by following on the checklist that all the materials for the lesson were available and in perfect condition. In the control group, students used real laboratory equipment, for example, real batteries and voltmeters for their practical activity while in the experimental group, students did the practical activity using the simulation first, after succeeding with the simulation they repeated the activity with the real laboratory equipment that was placed just next to their computers. It was hypothesised that, it will be more beneficial for students in this environment to discover the theoretical principles using the simulation first and then transfer the gained knowledge into the real circuits to realise that the theoretical laws do actually apply in the real world environment as well (Tomi Jaakkola, Nurmi, and Veermans 2011). Students were grouped into small groups (in pairs or threes), which were permanent and only effective for the period of the study. As individuals; students record their experimental findings on the given worksheets (Figure 3). Students’ progression was controlled by the research assistants. When a group completes a worksheet task, the facilitator will make an assessment of the work through a 5-min discussion. The small discussion allowed the students to resolve their confusion and enhance plausibility. During discussions, reference was made to the real-life experiences on the gained concepts to provide a fruitfulness condition in students (Taşlıdere 2013). When the facilitator is convinced, the group will be allowed to proceed with the next worksheet. During assessment, no grades were being awarded such that students play a major role in judging their own work. Self-assessment RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 299 Figure 3. Sample worksheet used during the intervention. enhances student motivation and achievement (Zimmerman and Schunk 2001; McMillan and Hearn 2008; Andrade and Valtcheva 2009). To compare the effect of the different learning environments, the same instrument used in pre-test was administered again as a post-test a day after completion of the course. The students wrote the test in 60 min under exam conditions, in their natural classrooms. Research questions The following research questions framed this study; Which method of instruction is more effective in teaching the concept of electric circuits: using laboratory activities only or using a combination of simulation and laboratory activity? Two sub-questions were framed; (1) Which method increases students’ conceptual understanding? (2) Which method reduces students’ misconceptions? 300 K. MANUNURE ET AL. Results Conceptual understanding To measure conceptual understanding, the Simple Electric Circuit Diagnostic Test was used. Four variables were obtained (understanding at first-tier level, understanding at second tier level and confidence at third-tier level; i) considering first-tier scores only and ii) considering first and second tier scores. The score at each tier level ranges from 0 to 12 on a quasiinterval scale, where 0 is the minimum score while 12 is the maximum score that can be obtained. When Table 5 is examined, it could be seen that the students in both environments; experimental (N = 25) and control (N = 24) groups seem to exhibit a homogenous structure in terms of their pre-test mean scores on conceptual understanding (MeanExperimental group = 3.68; 1.2; 1.76; .56, MeanControl group = 3.42; 1.5; 1.62; .75) at tier levels 1, 2, 3.1 and 3.2, respectively. A Mann–Whitney U test was used to assess the difference, and the results indicated that the two groups did not differ significantly on their pre-test scores at p < .05 (Z = 1.16, p = .246; Z = 1.07, p = .307; Z = .4, p = .689; Z = .59, p = .555) at tier levels 1, 2, 3.1 and 3.2, respectively. At post-test, the two groups were compared using an independent samples t-test. A Shapiro Wilks test (p > 0.5) and a visual inspection of their histograms, normal Q-Q plots and box plots showed that the post-test scores in both conditions were approximately normally distributed. The independent samples t-test was associated with a statistically significant effect at p < .05 (t = 1.864, p = .0342; t = 2.378, p = .0108; t = 2.223, p = .031; t = 2.087, p = .042) at tier levels 1, 2, 3.1 and 3.2, respectively, therefore it can be inferred that learning using real practicals and simulations together were associated with a statistically significant larger mean conceptual understanding score. Cohens’ d was estimated at 2.09. Both groups, control (N = 24) and experimental (N = 25) recorded a positive mean marginal change after treatment, M = 1.54 (4.96–3.42); 1.79 (3.29–1.5); 1.42 (3.04–1.62); 1.87 (2.62–0.75) at tier 1, 2, 3.1 and 3.2, respectively, in the control group and M = 2.04 (5.72–3.68); 3.04 (4.24–1.2); 2.24 (4.0–1.76); 2.88 (3.44–0.56) at tier 1, 2, 3.1 and 3.2, respectively, in the experimental group. A Wilcoxon test was used to assess the effect of treatment in each condition. Results indicated that there was a significant difference in performance in both conditions at p ≤ 0.05 significant level. In the control group, Z = 3.4159, p = .00062; 3.5875, p = .00034; 3.0182, p = .00252; 3.8079, p = .00014; at tier levels 1, 2, 3.1 and 3.2, respectively, with participants performing better in the post-test. In the experimental group, Z = 3.8796, p = .0001; 4.1286, p = 0; 3.6802, p = .00024; Table 5. Basic results for the pre-test and post-test mean scores and SD on conceptual understanding at different tier levels. Pre-test Treatment Control N 24 Experimental 25 Total 49 Tier Level 1 2 3.1 3.2 1 2 3.1 3.2 Mean 3.42 1.5 1.62 .75 3.68 1.2 1.76 .56 14.49 Post-test SD .97 1.10 1.21 .85 .99 1.08 1.2 .65 8.05 Mean 4.96 3.29 3.04 2.62 5.72 4.24 4.00 3.44 31.31 SD 1.43 1.37 1.33 1.25 1.43 1.42 1.66 1.47 11.36 RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 301 4.1516, p = 0; at tier levels 1, 2, 3.1 and 3.2, respectively, with participants performing better in the post-test. The mean score in the first tier is expected to be higher than in the second tier unless if the student fully understands the concepts, in which case the mean scores will be similar at M = 12. The difference between the first tier mean scores and second tier mean scores reduced after treatment in both groups, from M = 1.92 (3.42–1.5) to M = 1.67 (4.96–3.29) in the control group and by a larger margin from M = 2.48 (3.68–1.2) to M = 1.48 (5.72–4.24) in the experimental group. The analysis was used to estimate the effect of treatment in reducing false positive results which indirectly give an indication of understanding. To statistically test if there was a significant association between understanding and confidence, understanding scores (first and second tier scores) and third tier confidence scores at pre-test and post-test were analysed. At pre-test, Spearman’s rho correlation test results indicated a significant correlation coefficient of understanding scores and confidence scores for the control group (r = .55,718, p = .00468; r = .505,149, p = .01181) at first and second tier scores, respectively. In the experimental group, first-tier understanding scores did not appear to be significantly correlated to confidence scores (r = .12,473, p = .055247) while second-tier scores appeared sufficiently correlated to confidence scores (r = .43,689, p = .02898). Pearson’s correlation coefficient results at posttest showed a strongly more positive correlation between understanding and confidence scores for the control group (r = .571; r = .8851) for the first and second tier scores, respectively, and for the experimental group (r = .6152; r = .8019) for the first and second tier scores, respectively. Misconceptions Basing on the results presented in Table 6, it can be seen that there is a greater numerical decrease in the misconceptions held by students in the experimental group after treatment M = 4.42 (18–13.58). By comparison, the average misconceptions held by students in the control group decreased by M = 2.5 (21.27–18.77) after treatment. A Wilcoxon test was used to assess the difference in magnitude of misconceptions in the experimental group; W = 5, p = .022, with participants performing better in the posttest than in the pre-test (M = 27.5, SD = 9.81). In the control group, there was no significant decrease in the magnitude of misconceptions held by students, W = 11, p > .05, with a mean difference of .51. A Mann–Whitney U test was used to assess the difference in the magnitude of misconceptions between the control and experimental group at pre-test and at post-test. The results indicated that there was no significant difference in the magnitude of misconceptions before and after treatment U = 49, p = .472 and U = 42, p = .238, respectively. In the experimental group, several misconceptions decreased with the exception of short-circuit misconception (M6) and power supply as a constant current misconception (M7) which seem to have increased after treatment. In the control group, 5 out of the possible 11 misconceptions decreased after treatment, 3 remain constant and the other 3 increased. 302 K. MANUNURE ET AL. Table 6. Diversity of misconception magnitude from pre-to-post-test in the experimental and control groups. Control Group Misconception The Sink Model (M 1) The Attenuation Model (M 2) The Shared Current Model (M 3) The Clashing Current Model (M 4) The Empirical Rule Model (M 5) The Short Circuit Misconception (M 6) The Power Supply as a Constant Current Source (M 7) The Parallel Circuit Misconceptions (M 8) The Sequential Model (M 9) Local Reasoning (M 10) Current Flow as Water Flow (M 11) Average p-value Pre 16.7 20.9 18.1 60.1 23.6 33.4 5.6 20.9 8.3 15.3 11.1 21.27 >.05 Post 6.3 20.9 25.0 41.7 16.7 36.1 5.6 16.7 8.3 13.9 15.3 18.77 Experimental Group Pre 6.0 20.0 16.0 48.0 12.0 30.7 9.3 20.0 16.0 10.7 9.3 18 ≤ .05 Post 4.0 8.0 14.7 24.0 10.7 32.0 9.3 16.0 12.0 12.0 6.7 13.58 * Significant at 0.05 Discussion and conclusion The aim of the present study was to compare the effects of combining laboratory experiments with simulations vs laboratory experiments only, on students’ conceptual understanding and reducing their misconceptions on electric circuits. According to the results, the combination environment had an expected effect of increasing students’ conceptual understanding and in decreasing their misconceptions on electric circuits more than when the real laboratory experiments are used alone. Both conditions however succeeded in improving students’ conceptual understanding of electric circuits significantly at all three tier levels. The experimental group also succeeded in reducing the levels of misconceptions significantly. Findings of this study, therefore, suggest that the laboratory experiments and the simulations complement each other in fostering students’ conceptual understanding and in reducing misconceptions and should be preferred when teaching the topic of electric circuits (Tomi Jaakkola, Nurmi, and Veermans 2011; Unlu and Dokme 2011; Zacharia 2007). The results also suggest that in the context of Zimbabwe, the combination of real practical and simulation has the effect of improving the effectiveness of students’ learning the topic on electric circuits. These results are in line with similar previous studies that were done in different contexts (Tomi Jaakkola, Nurmi, and Veermans 2011; Unlu and Dokme 2011). The success in both learning conditions can be attributed to the careful conduction of the research and to the active participation of the control and experimental group into the teaching and learning environment. In the two learning conditions, students were directly involved in the construction of knowledge through guided construction and manipulation of different circuits. Group discussions and constant guidance from research assistants made students to internalise the different concepts under study. As constructivist approach (Jenkins 2000; Malik and Khurshed 2011) implied, students were involved in the construction of new knowledge through practically interacting/manipulating the materials for the practicals, and they had enough time to express their preconceptions. As (Duit and Treagust 2003; Treagust and Duit 2008) reported, discussions led to disequilibrium and students had conceptual conflict. Doing the practicals provided constructive feedback and the follow-up questions further increased participants’ RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 303 curiosity. The scientific explanations and feedback encouraged students to think critically for the plausibility. Finally, the presentation and discussions on the daily life applications reinforced students’ learning for the fruitfulness. Separate studies conducted on concept cartoons (Ekici, Ekici, and Aydin 2007; Taşlıdere 2013) and on real practicals (Marshall and Young 2006) reported positive effects of using them in science education. It would seem obvious therefore to assume that the use of real practicals, concept cartoon, and the constructivist approach would bring significant learning gains in all the learning conditions. Additionally, in the experimental group, running the simulation makes students visualise some of the underlying processes and mechanisms that are invisible in the real circuits and are important for theoretical understanding, for example, visualising the flow of current emphasises that current is conserved. Visualisation also creates necessary conflict with pre-conceptions, for example, the preconception that current flows from both terminals of the battery to clash in a device, and this is necessary for conceptual change to take place. It was observed that students found it easier to manipulate simulation circuits and they made several repeats, explored further by adding more bulbs to gain deeper understanding of the concepts. A significant difference in performance between the control and the experimental group at all tier levels can therefore safely be attributed to the fact that students in the experimental group have used the positive traits of real circuits and simulation to gain a deeper conceptual understanding. These results are in-line with findings from (Tomi Jaakkola, Nurmi, and Veermans 2011; Unlu and Dokme 2011; Zacharia 2007). After treatment, higher mean scores and a greater reduction in the difference between the first- and second-tier mean scores in the experimental group is an indication that more students who correctly answered the first tier also answered the second tier correctly. This was possibly because the combination environment provided alternative explanations that complement each other in reducing the magnitude of false positive answers and instead foster understanding in a more effective way when compared to only the use of laboratory experiment in the control group. The results have also showed that conceptual understanding is core-related with confidence. As the level of understanding increases, so does the level of confidence. In this research, the post-test confidence level significantly increased and it becomes more positively corerelated when the level of understanding increased in the post-test. This could be because when students seem to understand the concepts, they become more confident in their answers. This trend was described as normal and expected in (Cataloglu 2001; Sabah 2007) research. Though there was no significant difference in the magnitude of misconceptions between the experimental and control group, the magnitude of misconceptions significantly decreased in the experimental group when the pre-test is compared to the post-test. The results point to the effectiveness of the treatment. From the results presented in Table 6, it can be seen that students come to class with pre-conceptions, most of which are scientifically incorrect (Hammer 1996). Some of the conceptions are very strong in students’ minds, for example, short-circuit misconception (M6). The fact that M6 increased and the power supply as a constant current source (M7) remained constant after treatment in both learning conditions, is an indication of how persistent some students’ pre-conception are and how difficult it is to change them (Hammer 1996; Zacharia 2007). Caleon and Subramaniam (2010) highlighted that misconception frequency above 10% should be considered as 304 K. MANUNURE ET AL. serious misconceptions. Considering the results of this research, attenuation model misconception (M2) and empirical rule model misconception (M5) in the experimental group and only sink model misconception (M1) in the control group did change from the serious misconception level after treatment. There was a comparative enormous decrease in M2 in the experimental group compared to the control group. Students in the experimental group had the chance to use ideal materials like batteries and bulbs, and the level of brightness was easily distinguishable in the simulation than in the real circuits. Students using the simulation had an added advantage of using more bulbs so they can clearly appreciate the concept of the conservation of energy. This was not possible in the control group due to limited amounts of bulbs that were available. There is also a large decrease in the clashing current model of misconception (M4) in the experimental group as compared to the control group. This can be attributed to the fact that the students actually saw the movement of current in one direction during the simulation activities and hence the pre-conception of having the current moving in the opposite direction is replaced. In the control group, students relied on imagination and on the teachers’ explanations. If all the 11 misconceptions are considered, it can be seen that the combination environment was more effective in reducing the students’ misconceptions. A close inspection of the frequency distribution of the students’ misconceptions will raise a big question; what aspects of the simulation (for example) cause the increase in Local reasoning misconception (M10) after treatment in the experimental group? Definitely, this question cannot be answered without further research. It may also not be surprising that some aspects of the simulation/real practicals may actually introduce or reinforce some misconceptions. During instruction, it was emphasised that energy to light the bulbs is coming from the moving electrons. Interestingly, some students noted that the concept was not represented/shown on the simulation. The research, therefore, suggests that there could be an addition on the simulation whereby the colour or size of electrons will change after they have passed through a bulb to show that some energy from electrons has been lost in lighting the bulb. An inspection of the students’ answer sheets showed that some students had written long answers on selected questions to express their opinion about the expected answer. Long answers were not part of the conventional multiple-choice options. To the researchers, this was a call for further study to determine if these answers reveal new/undocumented misconceptions; if so, it will be in consistence with Suchai and Thasaneeya (2012) argument that the more research in electric circuits the more misconceptions are revealed. The long answers could also serve to highlight other issues that demand for further research, for example, the clarity of questions. The determination of new misconceptions and modification of the instrument were however beyond the scope of this research. There is a thin line between increasing conceptual understanding and reducing misconceptions. It is a general understanding that when the student understanding of the key concepts increases, it follows that his/her levels of misconceptions will decrease. However, the relationship is not always linear, for example, a student may show lack of understanding and having no misconception while the other student may show lack of understanding at the same time having misconception/s. RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 305 Acknowledgments The authors would like to acknowledge the support by the (Scholarship name). Gratitude is also extended to all the students and instructors who were involved in this project. Without their cooperation and support, this project would not have been possible. Disclosure statement No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors. ORCID Kevin Manunure Alice Delserieys Jérémy Castéra http://orcid.org/0000-0003-2020-5524 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-3542-0676 http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1520-3620 References Andrade, H., and A. Valtcheva. 2009. “Promoting Learning and Achievement through Self-Assessment.” Theory Into Practice 48: 1. doi:10.1080/00405840802577510. Bajpai, M. 2013. “Developing Concepts in Physics through Virtual Lab Experiment: An Effectiveness Study.” TechnoLearn: an International Journal of Educational Technology 3 (1): 43–50. Bayrak, B., U. Kanli, and S. K. Ingec. 2007. “To Compare the Effects of Computer Based Learning and the Laboratory Based Learning on Students’ Achievement regarding Electric Circuits.” Online Submission 6 (1): 15–24. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1102463.pdf Caleon, I., and R. Subramaniam. 2010. “Development and Application of a Three-Tier Diagnostic Test to Assess Secondary Students’ Understanding of Waves.” International Journal of Science Education 32 (7): 939–961. doi:10.1080/09500690902890130. Cataloglu. 2001. Development and Validation of an Achievement Test in Introductory Quantum Mechanics: The Quantum Mechanics Visualization Instrument (QMVI). The Pennsylvania State University. https://etda.libraries.psu.edu/catalog/5937 Clément, P. 2003. “Situated Conceptions and Obstacles. The Example of Digestion/Excretion.” In Science Education Research in the Knowledge-Based Society, edited by Psillos D, Kariotoglou P, Tselfes V, Hatzikraniotis E, Fassoulopoulos G, and Kallery M, 89–97. Dordrecht: Springer. Driver, R., A. Squires, P. Rushworth, and V. Wood-Robinson, eds. 1994. “Electricity.” In Making Sense of Secondary Science: Research into Children’s Ideas, 117–125. London, UK and New York, NY: Psychology Press. Duit, R., and D. F. Treagust. 2003. “Conceptual Change: A Powerful Framework for Improving Science Teaching and Learning.” International Journal of Science Education 25 (6): 671–688. doi:10.1080/09500690305016. Ekici, F., E. Ekici, and F. Aydin. 2007. “Utility of Concept Cartoons in Diagnosing and Overcoming Misconceptions Related to Photosynthesis.” International Journal of Environmental and Science Education 2 (4): 111–124. Engelhardt, P. V., and R. J. Beichner. 2004. “Students’ Understanding of Direct Current Resistive Electrical Circuits.” American Journal of Physics 72 (1): 98–115. doi:10.1119/1.1614813. Farrokhnia, M. R., and A. Esmailpour. 2010. “A Study on the Impact of Real, Virtual and Comprehensive Experimenting on Students’ Conceptual Understanding of DC Electric Circuits and Their Skills in Undergraduate Electricity Laboratory.” Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 2 (2): 5474–5482. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2010.03.893. Finkelstein, N. D., W. K. Adams, C. J. Keller, P. B. Kohl, K. K. Perkins, N. S. Podolefsky, S. Reid, and R. LeMaster. 2005a. “When Learning about the Real World Is Better Done Virtually: A Study of 306 K. MANUNURE ET AL. Substituting Computer Simulations for Laboratory Equipment.” Physical Review Special TopicsPhysics Education Research 1 (1): 010103. doi:10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.1.010103. Finkelstein, N. D., K. K. Perkins, W. Adams, P. Kohl, and N. Podolefsky. 2005b. In Can Computer Simulations Replace Real Equipment in Undergraduate Laboratories?, edited by Marx. J, Heron. P and Franklin. S, Vol. 790, 101–104. Melville, NY: Iop Institute of Physics Publishing. https://aip.scitation.org/doi/pdf/10. 1063/1.2084711 Hammer, D. 1996. “More than Misconceptions: Multiple Perspectives on Student Knowledge and Reasoning, and an Appropriate Role for Education Research.” American Journal of Physics 64 (10): 1316–1325. doi:10.1119/1.18376. Hennessy, S., D. Harrison, and L. Wamakote. 2010. “Teacher Factors Influencing Classroom Use of ICT in Sub-Saharan Africa.” Itupale Online Journal of African Studies 2 (1): 39–54. Hussain, N. H., L. A. Latiff, and N. Yahaya. 2012. “Alternative Conception about Open and Short Circuit Concepts.” Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 56: 466–473. doi:10.1016/j. sbspro.2012.09.678. Jaakkola, T., S. Nurmi, and K. Veermans. 2011. “A Comparison of Students’ Conceptual Understanding of Electric Circuits in Simulation Only and Simulation-Laboratory Contexts.” Journal of Research in Science Teaching 48 (1): 71–93. doi:10.1002/tea.20386. Jaakkola, T., and S. Nurmi. 2008. “Fostering Elementary School Students’ Understanding of Simple Electricity by Combining Simulation and Laboratory Activities.” Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 24 (4): 271–283. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2729.2007.00259.x. Jenkins, E. W. 2000. “Constructivism in School Science Education: Powerful Model or the Most Dangerous Intellectual Tendency?” Science & Education 9 (6): 599–610. doi:10.1023/A:1008778120803. Kirschner, P., and W. Huisman. 1998. “‘Dry Laboratories’ in Science Education; Computer-Based Practical Work.” International Journal of Science Education 20 (6): 665–682. doi:10.1080/0950069980200605. Kollöffel, B., and T. Jong. 2013. “Conceptual Understanding of Electrical Circuits in Secondary Vocational Engineering Education: Combining Traditional Instruction with Inquiry Learning in a Virtual Lab.” Journal of Engineering Education 102 (3): 375–393. doi:10.1002/jee.v102.3. Konyana, S., and E. Konyana. 2013. “Computerisation of Rural Schools in Zimbabwe: Challenges and Opportunities for Sustainable Development (The Case of Chipinge District).” African Journal of Teacher Education 3: 2. doi:10.21083/ajote.v3i2.2156. Layard, R. 2009. The 3rd OECD World Forum on ‘Statistics, Knowledge and Policy’ Charting Progress, Building Visions, Improving Life. OECD, Busan. Korea. Lee, Y., and N. Law. 2001. “Explorations in Promoting Conceptual Change in Electrical Concepts via Ontological Category Shift.” International Journal of Science Education 23 (2): 111–149. doi:10.1080/ 09500690119851. Malik, S. K., and F. Khurshed. 2011. “A Proposed Constructive Instructional Design (CID) for Teaching of Social Studies at Elementary Level.” European Journal of Social Sciences 23 (4): 531–552. Marshall, J. A., and E. S. Young. 2006. “Preservice Teachers’ Theory Development in Physical and Simulated Environments.” Journal of Research in Science Teaching 43 (9): 907–937. doi:10.1002/ tea.20124. McDermott, L. C., and P. S. Shaffer. 1992. “Research as a Guide for Curriculum Development: An Example from Introductory Electricity. Part I: Investigation of Student Understanding.” American Journal of Physics 60 (11): 994–1003. doi:10.1119/1.17003. McMillan, J. H., and J. Hearn. 2008. “Student Self-Assessment: The Key to Stronger Student Motivation and Higher Achievement.” Educational Horizons 87 (1): 40–49. https://files.eric.ed. gov/fulltext/EJ815370.pdf Ozgur, S. 2013. “The Persistence of Misconceptions about the Human Blood Circulatory System among Students in Different Grade Levels.” International Journal of Environmental and Science Education 8 (2): 255–268. doi:10.12973/ijese.2013.206a. Peşman, H., and A. Eryılmaz. 2010. “Development of a Three-Tier Test to Assess Misconceptions about Simple Electric Circuits.” The Journal of Educational Research 103 (3): 208–222. doi:10.1080/ 00220670903383002. RESEARCH IN SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGICAL EDUCATION 307 Posner, G. J., K. A. Strike, P. W. Hewson, and W. A. Gertzog. 1982. “Accommodation of a Scientific Conception: Toward a Theory of Conceptual Change.” Science Education 66: 211–227. doi:10.1002/ (ISSN)1098-237X. Rytting, M. C. 2016. Comparison of Simulation and Hands-On Labs in Helping High School Students Learn Physics Concepts. Provo, UT: School of Technology; Brigham Young University. https:// scholarsarchive.byu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7132&context=etd Sabah, S. A. 2007. “Developing Two-Tiered Instrument with Confidence Levels for Assessing Students’ Conception of Direct Current Circuits.” In Department of Learning and Instruction, Faculty of the Graduate School. Buffalo edited by Liu, Xiufeng, 68 (12), 148. New York: State University of New York. https://ubir.buffalo.edu/xmlui/handle/10477/42681 Smetana, L. K., and R. L. Bell. 2012. “Computer Simulations to Support Science Instruction and Learning: A Critical Review of the Literature.” International Journal of Science Education 34 (9): 1337–1370. doi:10.1080/09500693.2011.605182. Stangroom, J. 2018. “Social Science Statistics.” https://www.socscistatistics.com/tests/ Suchai, N., and R. N. Thasaneeya. 2012. Students’ Understanding about the Brightness of Light Bulbs Connected in DC Electric Circuits. In, 951. Engineers Australia. https://search.informit.com.au/ documentSummary;dn=237908333039573;res=IELENG Taşlıdere, E. 2013. “Effect of Conceptual Change Oriented Instruction on Students’ Conceptual Understanding and Decreasing Their Misconceptions in DC Electric Circuits.” Creative Education 4: 273. doi:10.4236/ce.2013.44041. Treagust, D. F., and R. Duit. 2008. “Conceptual Change: A Discussion of Theoretical, Methodological and Practical Challenges for Science Education.” Cultural Studies of Science Education 3 (2): 297–328. doi:10.1007/s11422-008-9090-4. Turgut, Ü., F. Gürbüz, and G. Turgut. 2011. “An Investigation 10th Grade Students’ Misconceptions about Electric Current.” Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 15: 1965–1971. doi:10.1016/j. sbspro.2011.04.036. Unlu, Z. K., and I. Dokme. 2011. “The Effect of Combining Analogy-Based Simulation and Laboratory Activities on Turkish Elementary School Students’ Understanding of Simple Electric Circuits.” Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology-TOJET 10 (4): 320–329. Zacharia, Z. C. 2007. “Comparing and Combining Real and Virtual Experimentation: An Effort to Enhance Students’ Conceptual Understanding of Electric Circuits.” Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 23 (2): 120–132. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2729.2006.00215.x. Zimmerman, B. J., and D. H. Schunk. 2001. Self-Regulated Learning and Academic Achievement: Theoretical Perspective. 2nd ed. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers. https:// psycnet.apa.org/record/2001-06817-000
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )