Name: Talia Muscara
Student number: 21226062
Subject: BUS1BUE
Tutorial: 10 am Wednesday
Tutor: Dr Kris Ivanovski
Topic: The cost-benefit principle: Take no action unless its marginal benefit is
at least as great as its marginal cost – Donald Trump and mass deportations
Word Count: 1,199
Statement of AI usage: I used Grammarly to help with my spell check and
grammar but that was the extent of using AI for this assignment.
1
Newly re-elected US president Donald Trump is well known for being a
successful businessman, and it was under the guise that his knowledge of
business and economics would help improve the American economy and the
cost-of-living situation that many American citizens struggle with. However,
with the mass deportations that the Trump administration is committed to, it
seems that the cost-of-living situation is only going to become more
troublesome for American citizens. As these mass deportations impact legal
American citizens, their grocery bill and their ability to access housing, it
becomes abundantly clear that the Trump administration has not considered
the cost-benefit principle when establishing and enforcing these mass
deportations.
The act of deporting a person is not for free, and with the agenda to deport
every undocumented individual, which would be roughly 8.1 billion people
(Vergara & Unidos US, 2024), the process would be costly. With an estimate
of USD 46.8 billion to deport every undocumented citizen (Vergara & Unidos
US, 2024), whether the benefit is worth the cost or if there are other
opportunities to better spend taxpayers' money will need to be evaluated.
First, it is essential to understand that while attempting to deport as many
illegal aliens as quickly as possible, legal American citizens have also been
deported. A total of 7 citizens have been deported since January, including a
man having been identified as a migrant with a different name and a child who
at the time was being rushed to the hospital (Walker, 2025). With billions of
2
dollars being spent on deporting illegal immigrants, errors that jeopardise the
health of American citizens, such as the child, should not have been made.
Another man, despite having his social security card present, was also
detained and handcuffed while on his way to work (Walker, 2025). This is not
only a waste of taxpayers' money to incorrectly detain US citizens, but it is
also proving to be a hassle for businesses when their workers are being
forcibly removed from the workforce. Not only is this deportation scheme
costing resulting in the loss of billions of dollars directly, but many indirect
costs are becoming apparent.
Furthermore, it should be noted how valuable illegal immigrants are to the
American economy. Most illegal immigrants are incredibly hardworking, and
their jobs contribute significantly to the prices of everyday purchases,
including groceries and food. It has been reported that while only 5% of illegal
immigrants make up the total workforce in America, 50% of the farmworkers
are illegal immigrants (Pedraza et al., 2025). Furthermore, an estimated 1015% of the food preparation
workforce is also made up of illegal
immigrants (Pedraza et al., 2025). If
all immigrants were to be removed,
Note: a graph that shows the percentage of different American citizenships and their contribution to the food and
agriculture industries. By USDA and Pew Research Center
there would be massive gaps in
(https://minnesotareformer.com/2024/11/25/graphic-heres-why-mass-deportation-could-affect-the-nations-foodsupply/) Copyright 2024 by USDA and Pew Research Center
these industries. This would result
in limited food access, whether at the grocery store or in restaurants. It has
3
previously been proven that there is little benefit to gain from these mass
deportations, as the Law MB-56 in Alabama has proven that when there is a
crackdown on citizenship, whether it is landlord refusing housing or local
police also checking citizenship status when pulling a car over, immigrants
would naturally leave the area, which resulted in an estimated $2.3 - USD
10.8 billion loss (Pedraza et al., 2025). This further contends that mass
deportations do the opposite of exceeding benefits to the community
compared to the costs. Unfortunately, these actions do not benefit American
society and will result in the citizens suffering the most loss.
While it is understandable to believe that the mass deportations will alleviate
the housing crisis in the US, this is only a temporary impact, and soon, even
affordable housing will become difficult to find. The temporary relief in the
housing sector will be short-lived as the mass deportations will reduce the
construction industry, resulting in minimal housing being created to support
the growth of the American nation. A study by Brian Maffly at the University of
Utah finds that with countries with increases and intense immigration
enforcement, a year's worth of construction is lost over four years (2025). Not
only does this hinder access to housing, but also the construction of other
essential facilities, such as schools and hospitals, resulting in more than a
financial loss, but a loss in health and education. This mass deportation also
typically does not equate to more job opportunities, as one may assume.
Maffly’s study also found that most jobs that opened due to a deported
4
employee could not be filled by an American, especially those within the
lower-skilled and lower-paying occupations Maffly (2025). This will create
massive disruption in the labour market, further hurting economic productivity
and causing a GDP loss (American Immigration Council, 2024, p.3), in an
already struggling economy. Again, these mass deportations provide little to
no benefit to American society.
Despite the many clear losses that the American public will suffer with these
mass deportations, many still believe that mass deportation is something that
must occur. Lora Ries is one of the many with the limited capacity to think and
analyse the cost-benefit of mass deportation. She believes one cannot put a
‘price on the safety and well-being of the American people,’ (Ries, 2024). Yet,
as previously mentioned, multiple Americans have been detained and
deported despite having evidence in their identification, and even a child was
denied medical access. For someone who is concerned about the American
people, how has she not considered the many other opportunities that the
spending on mass deportations could be reallocated towards? Funding for the
deportations can be used to assist the medical or educational sectors in dire
need (American Immigration Council, 2024, p.2). Wasting the taxpayer's
money to deport valuable members of working society rather than helping
children receive the education they need is a wasted opportunity to actually
‘make America great again.’ Furthermore, Ries claims that it has been
estimated that USD 88 billion per year will be spent on deporting illegal
5
immigrants and that it is an insignificant amount when compared to the Biden
Administration spending $22 billion over the four years on mitigation and
refugee assistance in addition to the $31 billion to provide culturally
appropriate linguistic services (Ries, 2024). In total, that is USD 53 billion,
which is still USD 35 billion less than what is being spent to deport illegal
immigrants and ruin the economy and community. While also paying attention
to the $88 billion spent in one year and the $53 spent over the four years. One
cost is clearly more financially responsible than the other when all the crucial
factors are considered (The Core Team, 2017).
To conclude, it is evident that the Trump administration had put little thought
into the impact of mass deportation and had not considered the tremendous
societal and financial cost that this burden will bear through the deportation of
legal US citizens, as well as the price increase in the food and housing
industry. The American community will struggle with many, such as Ries,
struggling to comprehend how bad decisions lead to bad results. Economically
speaking, there are minimal benefits to mass deportations, and thus, these
deportations should not have occurred. Still, taxpayer money should be spent
on something societally and financially valuable.
6
References
American Immigration Council. (2024). Mass Deportation Devastating Costs to
America, Its Budget and Economy. In American Immigration Council (pp. 1–
54). https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/mass-deportation
Bamberg, J. (2024, November 25). One graph that show how mass
deportation could affect the nation’s food supply • Minnesota Reformer.
7
Minnesota Reformer. https://minnesotareformer.com/2024/11/25/graphicheres-why-mass-deportation-could-affect-the-nations-food-supply/
Maffly, B. (2025, January 24). What “mass deportation” means for housing
costs - @theU. Utah.edu. https://attheu.utah.edu/business/what-massdeportation-means-for-housing-costs/
Pedraza, F. I., Morín, J. L., & Collingwood, L. (2025, February 18). Deporting
millions of immigrants would shock the US economy, increasing housing, food
and other prices. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/deportingmillions-of-immigrants-would-shock-the-us-economy-increasing-housing-foodand-other-prices-245342
Ries, L. (2024, November 22). America Is About To Show the World the
Benefits of Mass Deportations. The Heritage Foundation.
https://www.heritage.org/border-security/commentary/america-about-showthe-world-the-benefits-mass-deportations
The Core Team. (2017). 2.2 Economic decisions: Opportunity costs, economic
rents, and incentives. In The economy: economics for a changing world.
Oxford University Press. https://www.core-econ.org/theeconomy/microeconomics/02-technology-incentives-02-economicdecisions.html?query=cost+benefit+
Vergara, J., & UnidosUS. (2024, December 6). The Economic Costs of Mass
Deportations of Long-Time Residents. UnidosUS.
8
https://unidosus.org/blog/2024/12/06/the-economic-costs-of-massdeportations-of-long-time-residents/
Walker, C. (2025, April 7). Trump Administration Has Detained Citizens as Part
of Mass Deportation Actions. Truthout. https://truthout.org/articles/trumpadministration-has-detained-citizens-as-part-of-mass-deportation-actions/
9