energies Article Effective Simulation Approach for Lightning Impulse Voltage Tests of Reactor and Transformer Windings Piyapon Tuethong, Peerawut Yutthagowith * and Anantawat Kunakorn Faculty of Engineering, King Mongkut’s Institute of Technology Ladkrabang, Bangkok 10520, Thailand; t_piyapon@hotmail.com (P.T.); anantawat.ku@kmitl.ac.th (A.K.) * Correspondence: kypeeraw@kmitl.ac.th; Tel.: +66-(0)2-329-8330 Received: 31 August 2020; Accepted: 4 October 2020; Published: 16 October 2020 Abstract: In this paper, an effective simulation method for lightning impulse voltage tests of reactor and transformer windings is presented. The method is started from the determination of the realized equivalent circuit of the considered winding in the wide frequency range from 10 Hz to 10 MHz. From the determined equivalent circuit and with the use of the circuit simulator, the circuit parameters in the impulse generator circuit are adjusted to obtain the waveform parameters according to the standard requirement. The realized equivalent circuits of windings for impulse voltage tests have been identified. The identification approach starts from equivalent circuit determination based on a vector fitting algorithm. However, the vector fitting algorithm with the equivalent circuit extraction is not guaranteed to obtain the realized equivalent circuit. From the equivalent circuit, it is possible that there are some negative parameters of resistance, inductance, and capacitance. Using such circuit parameters from the vector fitting approach as the beginning circuit parameters, a genetic algorithm is employed for searching equivalent circuit parameters with the constraints of positive values. The realized equivalent circuits of the windings can be determined. The validity of the combined algorithm is confirmed by comparison of the simulated results by the determined circuit model and the experimental results, and good agreement is observed. The proposed approach is very useful in lightning impulse tests on the reactor and transformer windings. Keywords: lightning impulse voltage test; genetic algorithm; reactor and transformer windings; vector fitting 1. Introduction Transformers and reactors are employed in a high-voltage (HV) system in many applications. The transformers are utilized for adjusting voltage levels in the AC transmission and distribution systems. The reactors are utilized for limitation of over voltage, reactive power compensation, tuned and detuned filters, and so on. During the operation of the transformers and the reactors, there are possibilities in insulation failure due to direct lightning and electromagnetic-induced lightning effects. Therefore, it is necessary to test the transformer and reactors with lightning impulse voltage for being an assessment of the insulation performance of the transformers and reactors before installation. The crucial problem in the lightning impulse voltage tests on the transformer and reactor winding is the adjustment of the test voltage waveform according to the standard requirement. As shown in Figure 1, the front time (T1 ), time to half (T2 ), and overshoot rate (βe ) will be in the ranges of 1.2 µs ± 30% (0.84 µs to 1.56 µs), 50 µs ± 30% (40 µs to 60 µs), and less than 5%, respectively [1–5]. Energies 2020, 13, 5399; doi:10.3390/en13205399 www.mdpi.com/journal/energies be (Overshoot rate) 1.0 Voltage [p.u.] 0.9 B Vm Energies 2020, 13, 5399 2 of 19 0.5 0.3 1.0 A Voltage [p.u.] 0.9 e 0 O1 Time T 0.5 0.3 (Overshoot rate) B T1 =10T/6 A T2 Figure 1. Generated lightning impulse voltage waveform. 0 Time O1 the generator T Conventionally, circuit named Marx’s circuit, as shown in Figure 2, is applied in T1 =10T/6 the lightning impulse voltage tests. The charging capacitance (Cs) will be much higher than load T2 capacitance (Cb), since the efficiency of the circuit is necessary to be controlled at a high level Figure Generated lightning voltage waveform. (normally more than 90%). The 1. spark gap (G) is usedimpulse as a high-voltage switch. It will be sparked or Figure 1. Generated lightning impulse voltage waveform. switched on to connect the charging capacitor to the load for the generation of lightning impulse Conventionally, the generator circuit Marx’s circuit, as shown in Figure is applied voltage. For the front time and time to half,named according to the standard requirement, the2,front time in the lightning impulse voltage tests. The charging capacitance (C ) will be much higher than s and tail time resistances (Rd and Re) can be calculated by Equations (1) and (2) [6]. load capacitance (Cb ), since the efficiency of the circuit is necessary to be controlled at a high level C + Cb as a high-voltage switch. It will be sparked (normally more than 90%). The spark gapT(G) is used Rd = 1 s (1) 2.96 Cto Cthe load for the generation of lightning impulse or switched on to connect the charging capacitor s b voltage. For the front time and time to half, Taccording 1 to the standard requirement, the front time and = 1 by Equations (2) tail time resistances (Rd and Re ) can beRecalculated (1) and (2) [6]. 0.73 C s + Cb ! T Cs + C Practically, in the low frequency range Rd (below = 1 10 kHz)b the winding can be represented well by (1) 2.96 a capacitor. Cs Cb an equivalent circuit of an inductor in parallel with It is noticed by Glaninger that, if the ! circuit is quite difficult to apply and inductance of the winding is less than 15 mH, the conventional T1 1 Re 40 = μs [7]. Therefore, Glaninger’s generator circuit, as (2) it is difficult to adjust T2 to longer than 0.73 Cs + Cb illustrated in Figure 3, is recommended to apply in the lightning impulse voltage test. G Cs Rd Re Low frequency model of winding load Cb LL Figure 2. Conventional generator circuit used in the lightning impulse voltage tests, where Cs is a Figure 2. Conventional circuit in time the lightning voltage where a charging capacitor, G isgenerator a spark gap, Re used is a tail resistor, Rimpulse time tests, resistor, Cb isCas is load d is a front charging capacitor, a spark gap, Re is a tail time resistor, Rd is a front time resistor, Cb is a load capacitor, and LL isGa is load inductor. capacitor, and LL is a load inductor. Practically, in the low frequency range (below 10 kHz) the winding can be represented well by an equivalent circuit of an as inductor with capacitor. It is noticed by additional Glaninger that, if the In Glaninger’s circuit, shownin inparallel Figure 3, theaparallel connection of the inductor the winding is less 15 mH, theisconventional circuit quite difficult to apply and (Linductance d) with the of front-time resistor (Rthan d) is used. This for the purpose of isextending the time to half init is difficult adjust T2 to longer thanconnection 40 µs [7]. Therefore, Glaninger’s generator as illustrated the impulsetowaveform. The parallel of the additional parallel resistorcircuit, (Rp) with the test in Figure 3, is for recommended in the lightning voltage test. object is used controlling to theapply overshoot rate of theimpulse generated waveform. In 1978, K. Feser [8] In Glaninger’s circuit, shown in Figure 3, the parallel connection of the additional inductor (Ld ) proposed the approach for as the selection of the appropriate circuit parameters—i.e. the charging with the front-time resistor (Rd ) is used. This is for the purpose of extending the time to half in the impulse waveform. The parallel connection of the additional parallel resistor (Rp ) with the test object is used for controlling the overshoot rate of the generated waveform. In 1978, K. Feser [8] proposed the approach for the selection of the appropriate circuit parameters—i.e. the charging capacitance (Cs ), Energies 2020, 13, 5399 3 of 19 the front-time (Rp19), d ), the additional inductance (Ld ), and the additional parallel resistance Energies 2020, 13, xresistance FOR PEER (R REVIEW 3 of as given in Equations (3) to (7). In addition, the appropriate tail-time resistor (Re ) has to be selected to obtain the undershoot voltage less than 50%(R ofd),the voltage inductance [7–11]. capacitance (Cs), the front-time resistance thepeak additional (Ld), and the additional parallel resistance (Rp), as given in Equations (3) to (7). In addition, the appropriate tail-time resistor Cs voltage ≈ T22 /LLless than 50% of the peak voltage [7–11]. (3) (Re) has to be selected to obtain the undershoot 2 −6 0.4 T2 × / L10 (3) RdC= /Cb (4) s L ( ) −6 −6 Rd L= = 0.41.25 10× /C bR 10 d (4) (5) d −6 Ld R = 1.25 d )/L = (R10L R p d L (5) (6) (6) (7) (7) d Rp = ( Rd LL p ) / Ld Re = 1.6 LL /Cs Re = 1.6 LL / Cs Ld G Cs Low frequency model of winding load Rd Re Rp Cb LL Figure 3. 3. Glaninger’s Glaninger’s generator generator circuit circuit for for the the lightning lightning impulse impulse voltage voltage tests tests on on the the winding. winding. Figure However, the the distortion distortion ininthe thewaveform waveformgenerated generatedbybythethe circuit with parameters from However, circuit with parameters from K. K. Feser’s suggestion was noted. A trial and error approach, then, is employed to adjust the Feser’s suggestion was noted. A trial and error approach, then, is employed to adjust the circuit circuit parameters to mitigate the waveform and to the waveform parameters, parameters to mitigate the waveform distortiondistortion and to obtain theobtain waveform parameters, according according to the standard requirement. An alternative method was proposed based on a neural to the standard requirement. An alternative method was proposed based on a neural network for network for the selection of appropriate Glaninger’s circuit parameters [11]. the selection of appropriate Glaninger’s circuit parameters [11]. Another concern characteristics cannot be represented well well by only lump Another concernisisthat thatimpedance impedance characteristics cannot be represented by simple only simple elements throughout the frequency range of the applied lightning impulse voltage. Especially the lump elements throughout the frequency range of the applied lightning impulse voltage. Especially frequency dependent impedance of the winding in the higher frequency range (>10 kHz) affects the the frequency dependent impedance of the winding in the higher frequency range (>10 kHz) affects waveform parameters—i.e. peakpeak voltage, frontfront time,time, time time to half, rate. In some the waveform parameters—i.e. voltage, to and half,overshoot and overshoot rate. In cases, some it is quite hard to adjust such waveform parameters according to the standard requirement [1–5]. cases, it is quite hard to adjust such waveform parameters according to the standard requirement In practice, for thefor generation of theofstandard lightning impulse voltages on the and [1–5]. In practice, the generation the standard lightning impulse voltages ontransformer the transformer reactor windings, test engineers have to select appropriate components with their experience, and also and reactor windings, test engineers have to select appropriate components with their experience, makealso attempts trial with and error approaches. The damage the windings their insulation, and make with attempts trial and error approaches. Theondamage on the and windings and their therefore, can occur unintentionally during the process of the voltage waveform adjustment. insulation, therefore, can occur unintentionally during the process of the voltage waveform It is noted that the combination of an equivalent circuit of a transformer or reactor winding with adjustment. circuit of an impulse generator to be taken into account that the proper impulsewinding voltage It parameters is noted that the combination of has an equivalent circuit of a so transformer or reactor waveform canparameters be generated impulse tests. Simulation been so proposed to with circuit of during an impulse generator has to beapproaches taken intohave account that the[12,13] proper investigate the interaction between a transformer or reactor winding and the impulse generator circuits. impulse voltage waveform can be generated during impulse tests. Simulation approaches have These methods [12,13] employtothe results ofthe frequency response analysis of the windings computing been proposed investigate interaction between a transformer or reactorfor winding and multi-port networks and input impedances of the windings. The network impedances combined the impulse generator circuits. These methods employ the results of frequency response analysis of with the equivalent circuit of the impulse networks generator and are utilized in the simulation the frequency the windings for computing multi-port input impedances of theinwindings. The domain, impedances and the results in the time can be circuit obtained by inversed Laplace transformation. network combined with domain the equivalent of the impulse generator are utilized in The generator circuit parameters are required to be adjusted to obtain the impulse voltage waveform the simulation in the frequency domain, and the results in the time domain can be obtained by according to the standard requirement. The results have shown that such methods provide very high inversed Laplace transformation. The generator circuit parameters are required to be adjusted to accuracy. However, most of these methods require the construction of the complicated model and obtain the impulse voltage waveform according to the standard requirement. The results have computation, andmethods it also cannot be implemented directly However, to the circuit simulator. is advantageous for shown that such provide very high accuracy. most of theseItmethods require the construction of the complicated model and computation, and it also cannot be implemented directly to the circuit simulator. It is advantageous for test engineers to use a circuit simulator, such as EMTP, to verify expected impulse voltage waveforms when performing impulse tests of the transformer or reactor windings. To implement cases on the circuit simulator, accurate equivalent Energies 2020, 13, 5399 4 of 19 test engineers to use a circuit simulator, such as EMTP, to verify expected impulse voltage waveforms Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 4 of 19 when performing impulse tests of the transformer or reactor windings. To implement cases on the circuit simulator, accurate equivalent circuits of the windings, as well as proper circuit components circuits of the windings, as well as proper circuit components of the impulse generator, have to be of the impulse generator, have to be identified. Therefore, the number of attempts for the waveform identified. Therefore, the number of attempts for the waveform adjustment in the experiments will adjustment in the experiments will be reduced significantly, and the risk of the damage to the reactor be reduced significantly, and the risk of the damage to the reactor under the waveform adjustment under the waveform adjustment process is also reduced. process is also reduced. In this paper, an approach for a realized equivalent circuit identification of the transformer and In this paper, an approach for a realized equivalent circuit identification of the transformer and reactor windings is presented. The determined equivalent circuit can be represented well by the reactor windings is presented. The determined equivalent circuit can be represented well by the characteristic in the lightning impulse voltage test. With the accurate circuit model, the effective characteristic in the lightning impulse voltage test. With the accurate circuit model, the effective approach based on the circuit simulation is also presented. The validity and accuracy of the proposed approach based on the circuit simulation is also presented. The validity and accuracy of the approach are ensured by comparison between simulated and experimental results. This paper is proposed approach are ensured by comparison between simulated and experimental results. This organized as follows. The identification of the accurate and realized equivalent circuit of the winding paper is organized as follows. The identification of the accurate and realized equivalent circuit of is presented in Section 2. The approach based on simulation for the lighting impulse voltage tests of the winding is presented in Section 2. The approach based on simulation for the lighting impulse the reactor and transformer windings is proposed in Section 3. Then, in Section 4, some study cases voltage tests of the reactor and transformer windings is proposed in Section 3. Then, in Section 4, are considered, and the comparison of the results used the proposed method and experiments are some study cases are considered, and the comparison of the results used the proposed method and presented for confirming the validity and accuracy of the proposed method. Finally, the conclusion is experiments are presented for confirming the validity and accuracy of the proposed method. addressed in the final section. Finally, the conclusion is addressed in the final section. 2. Equivalent Circuit Identification 2. Equivalent Circuit Identification For the equivalent circuit identification, the impedance of a transformer or reactor winding For the equivalent circuit the from impedance transformer reactor winding was was measured throughout theidentification, frequency range 10 Hzof toa10 MHz. Theor vector fitting [14] was measured throughout the frequency range from 10 Hz to 10 MHz. The vector fitting [14] was employed to extract the equivalent circuit by matching the model impedance with the measured one. employed to extract equivalentofcircuit byseries matching model impedance the measured The equivalent circuitthe is composed several sets ofthe RLC circuits, as shownwith in Figure 4. one. The equivalent circuit is composed of several series sets of RLC circuits, as shown in Figure 4. C11 L1 R11 R21 C1i C12 L2 Li R12 R22 C1n Ln R1i R2i R1n R2n Figure 4. 4. Equivalent Equivalent circuit circuit associated associated with with complex complex conjugate conjugate pairs. Figure pairs. However, it is possible that negative circuit parameters can be found from the vector fitting. In this However, it is possible that negative circuit parameters can be found from the vector fitting. In paper, the circuit components with the negative values were changed to be positive with the same this paper, the circuit components with the negative values were changed to be positive with the absolute value. Such changed circuit components were set as starting values in a genetic algorithm same absolute value. Such changed circuit components were set as starting values in a genetic with constraints of the only positive values. The genetic algorithm [15] was employed to search for the algorithm with constraints of the only positive values. The genetic algorithm [15] was employed to appropriate positive circuit parameters for obtaining the realized equivalent circuit and the guarantee search for the appropriate positive circuit parameters for obtaining the realized equivalent circuit of the passivity condition. and the guarantee of the passivity condition. The brief details of the vector fitting and the genetic algorithm are presented as follows: The brief details of the vector fitting and the genetic algorithm are presented as follows: 2.1. Vector Fitting 2.1. Vector fitting The vector fitting is an approach for fitting a rational function as expressed in Equation (8). The vector fitting is an approach for fitting a rational function as expressed in Equation (8). ! n X res n i res i (8) FF( s()s)= = es +esd++ d+ (8) s − pi 1 pi i = 1 is=− where, F(s) is the considered fitting rational function; e and are real real coefficients; coefficients; res resi and and ppi are are the the where, F(s) is the considered fitting rational function; e and dd are i i residue and and the the pole pole which which can can be be either either real real numbers numbers or or complex complex conjugate conjugate pairs. pairs. residue The approach has proven its performance in terms of stability, accuracy, and efficiency. The fine The approach has proven its performance in terms of stability, accuracy, and efficiency. The fine detail of the vector fitting approach can be found in [14]. detail of the vector fitting approach can be found in [14]. For two rational terms with the complex conjugate pairs, the equivalent circuit can be represented, as illustrated in Figure 5, and the impedance with Laplace variable (s) of the equivalent circuit can be derived as Equation (9). C1i Li R1i R2i Figure 5. Equivalent circuit associated with complex conjugate pairs. 2.1. Vector fitting The vector fitting is an approach for fitting a rational function as expressed in Equation (8). n resi 5 of 19 F( s) = es + d + (8) i = 1 s − pi where, F(s) is rational e and are real coefficients; resi and pi are the Forthe twoconsidered rational termsfitting with the complexfunction; conjugate pairs, thedequivalent circuit can be represented, as illustrated in Figure 5, and the impedance with Laplace variable (s) of the equivalent circuit can be residue and the pole which can be either real numbers or complex conjugate pairs. as Equation (9). its performance in terms of stability, accuracy, and efficiency. The fine Thederived approach has proven R detail of the vector fitting approach can be found in[14]. s + L1 1 i (s) = the complex R pairs, (9) can be For two rational termsZiwith conjugate the equivalent circuit R1 1 1 1i C1i s2 + R2i C1i + Li s + R2i Li C1i + Li C1i represented, as illustrated in Figure 5, and the impedance with Laplace variable (s) of the equivalent circuit can be derived as Equation (9). C1i Li R1i R2i Energies 2020, 13, 5399 Figure 5. Equivalent circuit associated with complex conjugate pairs. Figure 5. Equivalent circuit associated with complex conjugate pairs. The circuit parameters associated with Figure 5 and Equation (9)—i.e., C1i , R2i , Li , and R1i —can be calculated from the poles (p1 and p2 ) and residues (res1 and res2 ) of the complex conjugate pairs using Equation (10) to (13), respectively. 1 C1i = (10) (res1 + res2 ) # " (res1 p2 + res2 p1 ) (11) R2i = (res1 + res2 )/ −(p1 + p2 ) + (res1 + res2 ) Li = (res1 + res2 ) (res1 + res2 ) × (res1 p2 +res2 p1 ) (res1 p2 + res2 p1 ) p1 p2 + −(p1 + p2 ) + (res +res ) (12) L(res1 p2 + res2 p1 ) (res1 + res2 ) (13) 1 R1i = 2 2.2. Genetic Algorithm The genetic algorithm is a random-based classical evolutionary algorithm, which is often used for solving the constrained and unconstrained optimization problems. A simple genetic algorithm [15,16] applied in this paper relies on the process of natural selection, which is composed of reproduction, selection, crossover, and mutation. In this paper, parameter estimation based on a genetic algorithm (GA) [15,16] is employed to search for the most appropriate circuit parameters, in which the impedances of the transformer or reactor winding from calculation using the equivalent circuit model and experiment are matched. The objective function (Ob(X)), which the genetic algorithm uses in the minimization, is shown in Equation (14). Ob(X) = n X Zo(exp) (k) − Zo(sim) (X, k) 2 (14) k =1 where, X is the unknown circuit parameters—i.e. C1i , R2i , Li , and R1i ; Zo(exp) and Zo(sim) are the impedances from the experiment and the simulation model using the lumped circuit model, as shown in Figure 4; k is the k th frequency point, and n is the number of frequency points of the measured and simulated impedances. Only positive values of the parameters were set as the constraints in the genetic algorithm. The flowchart of parameter optimization for searching the proper circuit parameters by the genetic algorithm is shown in Figure 6. Energies 2020, 13, 5399 Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 6 of 19 6 of 19 Start Step 1: Import the recorded waveform data Step 2: 1) Initial Lumped parameters C, R2, L, and R1 2) Determine upper bound and lower bound Choose the initial population Evaluation Selection Step 3: Crossover Mutation Step 4: Calculate induce volatge form Matlab function Step 5: 1) Calculate objective function 2) Minimization of objective function i = i+1 i=n Save value Stop Figure 6. Flowchart of the proposed algorithm. Figure 6. Flowchart of the proposed algorithm. 3. Procedures of the Effective Approach 3. Procedures of the Effective Approach The procedure of the proposed method starts from the measurement of the input impedance of The procedure of theThe proposed method starts from theinmeasurement of the impedance of the considered winding. impedance analyzer, shown Figure 7, is used to input measure the input the considered winding. The impedance analyzer, shown in Figure 7, is used to measure the input impedance from the frequency range of 10 Hz to 10 MHz. Figure 7 also shows the example of the impedance from the range ofof10input Hz to 10 MHz. of Figure 7 also and shows the example of the experimental set up forfrequency the measurement impedance the reactor transformer windings. experimental set up for the measurement of input impedance of the reactor and transformer windings. Energies 2020, 13, 5399 Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 7 of 19 7 of 19 1 2 (a) 3 2 (b) Figure 7.7. Experimental upup forfor measuring input impedance of theof windings, where (1) is the(1) winding Experimentalsetset measuring input impedance the windings, where is the under test, (2) is the impedance analyzer, and (3) is the transformer under test. (a) Reactor winding winding under test, (2) is the impedance analyzer, and (3) is the transformer under test. (a) Reactor under tests. (b) tests. Transformer winding under tests. winding under (b) Transformer winding under tests. The The flowchart flowchart of of the the proposed proposed approach approach is is presented presented in in Figure Figure 8. 8. In In steps steps 11 and and 2, 2, the the proposed proposed approach approach is is initiated initiated from from the the identification identification of of the the realized realized equivalent equivalent circuit circuit of of the the considered considered winding, Then, the the generator generator circuit circuit is is selected selected from from the the criteria of the the low low winding, as as presented presented in in Section Section 2. 2. Then, criteria of frequency ), which which can can be be determined determined from from the the impedance impedance in the low frequency inductance inductance (L (LLL), in the low frequency frequency range range from 1 kHz to 5 kHz. When L is less than 15 mH, the Glaninger circuit, as shown in Figure 3, will L from 1 kHz to 5 kHz. When LL is less than 15 mH, the Glaninger circuit, as shown in Figure 3, will be be recommended the conventional conventional circuit circuit in recommended to to represent represent the the generator generator circuit circuit[7]. [7]. For For other other values values of of LLLL,, the in Figure selected as the generator circuit. FromFrom the identified equivalent circuit ofcircuit the winding Figure 22will willbebe selected as the generator circuit. the identified equivalent of the and the selected parameters, the circuit simulator is utilized to compute the winding and thegenerator selected circuit generator circuit parameters, the circuit simulator is utilized togenerated compute waveform, and the waveform parameters are evaluated according to the standards, IEC 60060-1 [1] and the generated waveform, and the waveform parameters are evaluated according to the standards, IEC [17–20]. the waveform parameters are not in parameters accordance with theinstandard requirement, IEC 61083 60060-1 [1] andIf IEC 61083 [17–20]. If the waveform are not accordance with the the circuit parameters of the generator circuit will be adjusted until the waveform parameters standard requirement, the circuit parameters of the generator circuit will be adjusted until are the required byparameters the standard obtained. determined parameters generator are employed in waveform areare required by The the standard aregenerator obtained.circuit The determined circuit the actual lightning impulse voltage tests. parameters are employed in the actual lightning impulse voltage tests. Energies 2020, 13, 5399 8 of 19 Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 of 19 Start Step 1: Import the recorded impedance in the frequency domain Step 2: 1) Utilize a vector fitting for determination of the rational function and its coefficient and the circuit parameters 2) Utilize a genetic algorithm for determination the realized circuit parameters form the initial parameters determined by the vector fitting Step 3: Determine the inductance (LL) at the frequency range of 1 kHz to 5 kHz LL < 15 mH Step 4: No Yes Select Glaninger’s circuit in the simulation Select the conventional circuit in the simulation Step 5: Select the initial circuit parameters according to Equation (1) to (2) or (3) to (7) Step 6: Determine the waveform parameters, i.e. peak voltage (Vp), front time (T1), time to half (T2), and overshoot rate (βe) The waveform parameters accord to the standard requirement Step 7: Adjust the circuit parameters No Yes Save the appropriate circuit and waveform parameters Stop Figure 8. Flowchart of the proposed approach for determination of the generator circuit parameters. Figure 8. Flowchart of the proposed approach for determination of the generator circuit parameters. 4. Case Studies 4. Case Studies To validate and investigate the accuracy of the proposed approach, case studies were performed To validate and investigate the accuracy of the proposed approach, case studies were on a reactor, a power transformer, and two distribution transformers. performed on a reactor, a power transformer, and two distribution transformers. 4.1. Reactor 4.1. Reactor In this a reactor with an inductance of 1.3of mH With the approach, In case, this case, a reactor with an inductance 1.3was mHconsidered. was considered. Withproposed the proposed the equivalent of an air-core was extracted fromextracted the measured input impedance approach, circuit the equivalent circuit reactor of an air-core reactor was from the measured inputof the impedance of theofreactor. Thewas number setsinwas four,9.asThe shown in Figure 9. Thedetermined circuit reactor. The number RLC sets four,ofasRLC shown Figure circuit parameters parameters determined by the vector fitting and proposed algorithms are expressed in Tables andsome by the vector fitting and proposed algorithms are expressed in Tables 1 and 2. It is found 1that 2. It is found that some by the vector fitting algorithm real,algorithm and parameters determined byparameters the vectordetermined fitting algorithm are negative real, andare thenegative proposed the proposed algorithm (combination of the vector fitting and genetic algorithms) can find (combination of the vector fitting and genetic algorithms) can find the realized appropriatethe circuit parameters (positive real). The good agreement between impedances from the experiment and the equivalent circuit model are observed and shown in Figures 10 and 11. Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 19 Energies 2020, appropriate 13, 5399 9 of 19 Energies 2020, 13, x FORcircuit PEER REVIEW 9 of 19 realized parameters (positive real). The good agreement between impedances from the experiment and the equivalent circuit model are observed and shown in Figures 10 and 11. realized appropriate circuit parameters (positive real). The good agreement between impedances C11 C13and shown in Figures 10Cand from the experiment and the equivalentCcircuit model are observed 11. 14 12 R11 L1 C R11 L1 R21 11 R12 L2 L2 R12 R21 C R22 12 L3 R13 L3 R13 C R2313 L4 R14 L4 R14 R23 R22 C14 R24 R24 Figure 9. An extracted equivalent circuit of an air-core reactor. Figure 9. An extracted equivalent circuit of an air-core reactor. Table 1. Figure Circuit9.parameters by theofvector fitting approach. An extracteddetermined equivalent circuit an air-core reactor. Table 1. Circuit parameters determined by the vector fitting approach. Circuit Parameters Table 1. Circuit parameters determined by the vector fitting approach. Section No. Circuit Parameters R1i (Ω) Li (mH) R2i (kΩ) Ci (pF) Section No. R1i (Ω) Li (mH)Circuit Parameters R2i (kΩ) Ci (pF) Section No. 1 42.95 40.18 85.57 C85.57 R1i (Ω) L0.0239 i (mH) R40.18 2i (kΩ) i (pF) 1 42.95 0.0239 2 −13.86 0.0860 13.80 659.30 42.95 0.0239 40.18 85.57 2 1 −13.86 0.0860 13.80 659.30 3 −15.05 0.1087 6.649 532.60 −13.86 0.0860 13.80 659.30 3 2 −15.05 0.1087 6.649 532.60 4 −22.43 1.1680 30.24 663.90 3 −15.05 0.1087 6.649 532.60 4 −22.43 1.1680 30.24 663.90 4 −22.43 1.1680 30.24 663.90 Table 2. Circuit parameters determined by the proposed approach. Table 2. Circuit parameters determined by the proposed approach. Table 2. Circuit parameters determined by the proposed approach. Section No. Section No. Section No. 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 R1i (Ω)R1i (Ω) R1i (Ω) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.001 0.001 0.001 0.001 0.001 0.001 0.021 0.021 0.021 Circuit Circuit Parameters Parameters Circuit Parameters R2iR(kΩ) LiL(mH) 2i (kΩ) i (mH) Li (mH) R2i (kΩ) 0.0079 0.309 0.0079 0.309 0.0079 0.309 0.0224 4.286 0.0224 4.286 0.0224 4.286 0.1087 13.030 0.1087 13.030 0.1087 13.030 1.1680 49.190 1.1680 49.190 1.1680 49.190 Ci (pF)Ci (pF) Ci (pF) 268.20 268.20268.20 549.40 549.40549.40 532.60 532.60532.60 663.90663.90 663.90 From thetheexperiment From experiment From thetheproposed From proposedmethod method Magnitudeof of input of the from thefrom measurement and the proposed FigureFigure 10. 10. Magnitude inputimpedances impedances of reactor the reactor the measurement and the Figure 10. Magnitude of input impedances of the reactor from the measurement and the proposed Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 10 of 19 method. proposed method. method. From the experiment From the proposed method 11. of Phase of impedances input impedances the reactor from the measurement the proposed FigureFigure 11. Phase input of the of reactor from the measurement and byand theby proposed method. method. This determined model has to be employed in combination with an impulse voltage generation circuit. From the flowchart shown in Figure 8, in the case that the inductance is less than 15 mH, Glaninger’s circuit must be employed for impulse voltage generation [7]. To present the necessity of Glaninger’s circuit for the generation of the standard lighting impulse voltage waveform on the low From the experiment From the proposed method Energies 2020, 13, 5399 10 of 19 This determined model has to be employed in combination with an impulse voltage generation circuit. From the flowchart shown in Figure 8, reactor in thefrom case the inductance is less than 15 mH, Figure 11. Phase of input impedances of the thethat measurement and by the proposed method. Glaninger’s circuit must be employed for impulse voltage generation [7]. To present the necessity of Glaninger’s circuit for the generation of the standard lighting impulse voltage waveform on the This determined model has to be employed in combination with an impulse voltage generation low inductance load, determined with conventional generator considered. circuit. Fromthe the flowchart shownmodel in Figure 8, inthe the case that the inductance is lesscircuit than 15 is mH, Glaninger’s circuit must be employed impulse voltage [7]. To the necessity In this case the capacitance of the model isforquite low (lessgeneration than 1 nF), sopresent it is necessary toofadd a load generation ofcircuit. the standard lighting voltage waveform on the was low set to be capacitance Glaninger’s (Cb ) of 2 circuit nF in for thethegeneration In case 1,impulse the charging capacitance inductance load, the determined model with the conventional generator circuit is considered. In this 0.5 µF, and the calculated front and tail time resistances (Rd and Re ) by Equations (1) and (2) are 200 Ω case the capacitance of the model is quite low (less than 1 nF), so it is necessary to add a load and 150 Ω, respectively. Figure 12, theInfront and time to half was are set 1.23 µs0.5 and 5.57 µs, capacitance (Cb)As of 2shown nF in thein generation circuit. case 1,time the charging capacitance to be and the front and tail circuit, time resistances (Rd and the Re) by Equations (1)the and R (2)e are respectively.μF,Based oncalculated the conventional to increase time to half and200C s should be and 150 , respectively. As shown in Figure 12, the front time and time to half are 1.23 μs and 5.57 increased. In case 2, Re was set to be infinity or no tail time resistor connected in the generator circuit. μs, respectively. Based on the conventional circuit, to increase the time to half the Re and Cs should be The front time and time to2,half are andor6.30 µs, respectively. In case there was no tail time increased. In case Re was set1.29 to be µs infinity no tail time resistor connected in the3, generator circuit. The frontintime time to half are 1.29and μs and respectively. In case 3, there was front no tail time time and time resistor connected theand generator circuit Cs 6.30 wasμs, changed to be 3 µF, but the resistor connected in the generator circuit Cs was changed to be 3 μF,are butpresented the front time time 12. It can to half are 1.30 µs and 6.62 µs, respectively. Alland generated waveforms inand Figure to half are 1.30 μs and 6.62 μs, respectively. All generated waveforms are presented in Figure 12. It be concluded that the conventional circuit is not appropriate to use in the generation of the standard can be concluded that the conventional circuit is not appropriate to use in the generation of the lightning impulse the cases ofinlow inductance loads. loads. standardvoltage lightningin impulse voltage the cases of low inductance Figure 12. Generated waveforms theconventional conventional circuit. Figure 12. Generated waveforms by by the circuit. The equivalent of the completed test system (an identified model andananimpulse impulse generator The equivalent circuit of circuit the completed test system (an identified model and generator circuit) is presented in Figure 13. Additionally, the experimental set up for lightning circuit) is presented in Figure 13. Additionally, the experimental set up for lightning impulse voltage impulse voltage generation on the reactor is shown in Figure 14. The initial impulse generator circuit generation on the reactor is shown Figure(3)14. TheThe initial impulse generator circuit parameters parameters are calculated by in Equation to (7). generated waveform with these circuit Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 11 of 19 are calculated by Equation (3) to (7). The generated waveform with these circuit parameters is not in accordance with the standard requirement, so these parameters required further adjustment. parameters is not in accordance with the standard requirement, so these parameters required further The proper circuit parameters are given in Table Good agreement the simulated and experimental adjustment. The proper circuit parameters are 3. given in Table 3. Goodof agreement of the simulated and experimental voltage waveforms observed, the results are shown Figure 15.time The front voltage waveforms is observed, and theisresults areand shown in Figure 15. in The front (T1 ), the time (T1), the time to half (Trate 2), and the overshoot rate (βe) collected from the experiment are 1.35 µ s, to half (Ttime ), and the overshoot (β ) collected from the experiment are 1.35 µs, 42.0 µs, and 4.60%, e 2 42.0 µ s, and 4.60%, respectively, whereas T1, T2, and βe from the simulation using the proposed respectively, whereas T1 , T2 , and βe from the simulation using the proposed model are 1.51 µs, 42.3 µs, model are 1.51 µ s, 42.3 µ s, and 3.11%, respectively. These parameters are in the accepted ranges of and 3.11%, These parameters are in the accepted ranges of the standard requirement. the respectively. standard requirement. Ld Rd Cs Re Cb Voltagedivider G LL Rp DSO Voltage Figure 13. Equivalent circuit of the completed test system for the lightning impulse test of the reactor. Figure 13. Equivalent circuit of the completed test system for the lightning impulse test of the reactor. 2 Volt DSO Voltage Energies 2020, 13, 5399 Figure 13. Equivalent circuit of the completed test system for the lightning impulse test of the reactor. 11 of 19 2 3 1 Figure 14. Experimental set of upthe of completed the completed system lightning impulse of the Figure 14. Experimental set up testtest system for for the the lightning impulse testtest of the reactor, where (1) isunder the reactor test,impulse (2) is thevoltage impulsegenerator, voltage generator, (3) is a voltage wherereactor, (1) is the reactor test, under (2) is the and (3) and is a voltage divider. divider. Table 3. Selected circuit parameters of the lightning impulse voltage generation circuit. Table 3. Selected circuit parameters of the lightning impulse voltage generation circuit. Circuit Parameters Circuit Parameters Cs (µF) Re (Ω) Ld (µH) Rd (Ω) Rp (Ω) Cs (µF) Re (Ω) Ld (µH) Rd (Ω) Rp (Ω) Cb (nF) Energies 2020, 13, 3.0 x FOR PEER REVIEW 40.0 100.0 200.0 250.0 3.0 40.0 100.0 200.0 250.0 2.0 Cb (nF) 2.0 12 of 19 Time scale of 1 ms/div Time scale of 10 ms/div From the experiment From the proposed method Figure Figure 15. Comparison of the impulse voltage collectedfrom fromthe the experiment 15. Comparison of generated the generated impulse voltagewaveforms waveforms collected experiment and computed by thebyproposed method. and computed the proposed method. 4.2. Power Transformer 4.2. Power transformer In thisIncase, power transformer (60(60 MVA 115 With proposed this a case, a power transformer MVA 115kV/24 kV/24kV) kV)was was considered. considered. With thethe proposed approach, the equivalent circuitcircuit of a 24-kV winding was was extracted. TheThe number of of RLC sets was approach, the equivalent of a 24-kV winding extracted. number RLC sets wasfour, as shown Figure The realized circuit parameters are expressed in Table 4. agreement four,inas shown9. in Figure 9. The realized circuit parameters are expressed in The Tablegood 4. The good agreement between from the and the equivalent model are observed between impedances fromimpedances the experiment andexperiment the equivalent circuit modelcircuit are observed and shown in and shown in Figures 16 and 17. Figures 16 and 17. 4. Circuit parameters determinedby bythe theproposed proposed approach. TableTable 4. Circuit parameters determined approach. Section No. 1 2 3 4 Section No. R11i (Ω) 2 0.000 0.101 3 0.402 4 0.515 Circuit Parameters Circuit Parameters R1i (Ω) Li (mH) R2i (kΩ) Ci (nF) R2i (kΩ)4.450 0.000Li (mH) 0.0018 0.021 0.101 0.0018 0.0063 0.061 0.021 14.130 0.061 16.120 0.402 0.0063 0.2350 0.819 0.819 8.663 0.515 0.2350 5.2400 10.120 5.2400 10.120 Ci (nF) 4.450 14.130 16.120 8.663 Section No. 1 2 3 4 Energies 2020, 13, 5399 R1i (Ω) 0.000 0.101 0.402 0.515 Li (mH) 0.0018 0.0063 0.2350 5.2400 R2i (kΩ) 0.021 0.061 0.819 10.120 Ci (nF) 4.450 14.130 16.120 8.663 12 of 19 From the experiment From the proposed method Figure 16.13,Magnitude ofREVIEW input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and the13 of 19 Energies 2020, FOR PEER Figure 16. xMagnitude of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and proposed method. the proposed method. From the experiment From the proposed method Figure 17. Phase of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and by the Figure 17. Phase of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and by the proposed method. proposed method. This determined model was employed in the proposed method in lightning impulse voltage This determined model employed in the proposed method in impulse voltage test. As with the procedure in was Section 3, the low frequency inductance of lightning 5.58 mH was computed. test. As with the procedure in Section 3, the low frequency inductance of 5.58 mH was computed. Therefore, Glaninger’s circuit is recommended to employ as an impulse voltage generation circuit. Therefore, Glaninger’s is recommended to (an employ as an model impulse voltage generation circuit. The equivalent circuit of circuit the completed test system identified and an impulse generation The equivalent circuit of the 18. completed testimpulse system (an identified model and an impulse generation circuit) is presented in Figure The initial generator circuit parameters are calculated by circuit) is presented in Figure 18. The initial impulse generator circuit parameters are calculated Equations (3) to (7). The generated waveform with these circuit parameters is not in accordanceby Equations (3) to (7). The generated waveform with these circuit parameters is notThe in accordance with with the standard requirement, so these parameters require further adjustment. proper circuit the standard requirement, parameters require adjustment. The proper circuit parameters are given in Tableso 5. these The good agreement of thefurther simulated and experimental voltage parameters are given in Table 5. The good agreement of the simulated and experimental voltage waveforms is observed, and the results are shown in Figure 19. The front time (T1 ), the time to half (T2 ), waveforms is observed, the results are experiment shown in Figure 19.µs, The front (T1), the time to half and the overshoot rate (βe )and collected from the are 1.15 41.0 µs, time and 4.23%, respectively, (T2), and overshoot (βe) collected the experiment are1.41 1.15 s, 41.0 µ s, and and3.32%, 4.23%, whereas T1 , the T2 , and βe from rate the simulation usingfrom the proposed model are µsµand 41.9 µs, respectively, whereas T 1, T2, and βe from the simulation using the proposed model are 1.41 µ s and respectively. These parameters are in the accepted ranges of the standard requirement. 41.9 µ s, and 3.32%, respectively. These parameters are in the accepted ranges of the standard requirement. Ld G Rd Cs Re Voltagedivider a Cb b c n the standard requirement, so these parameters require further adjustment. The proper circuit parameters are given in Table 5. The good agreement of the simulated and experimental voltage waveforms is observed, and the results are shown in Figure 19. The front time (T1), the time to half (T2), and the overshoot rate (βe) collected from the experiment are 1.15 µ s, 41.0 µ s, and 4.23%, respectively, whereas T1, T2, and βe from the simulation using the proposed model are 1.41 µ s and Energies 2020, 13, 5399 13 of 19 41.9 µ s, and 3.32%, respectively. These parameters are in the accepted ranges of the standard requirement. Ld G Re Cs Voltagedivider Rd a b c n A B C Cb DSO Voltage FigureFigure 18. Equivalent circuit of the completed for the thelightning lightning impulse of the power 18. Equivalent circuit of the completedtest testsystem system for impulse testtest of the power transformer winding. transformer winding. TableTable 5. Selected circuit parameters impulsevoltage voltagegeneration generation circuit. 5. Selected circuit parametersofofthe thelightning lightning impulse circuit. CircuitParameters Parameters Circuit C s (µF) R e (Ω) L d (µH) RRd (Ω) Rp (Ω) Cb (nF) C (nF) Cs (µF) Re (Ω) Ld (µH) Rp (Ω) d (Ω) b 1.0 600.0 100.0 40.0 100.0 0.0 1.0PEER REVIEW 600.0 100.0 40.0 100.0 0.0 Energies 2020, 13, x FOR 14 of 19 Time scale of 1 ms/div Time scale of 10 ms/div From the experiment From the proposed method Figure 19.19. Comparison of of thethe generated impulse voltage waveforms collected from thethe experiment Figure Comparison generated impulse voltage waveforms collected from experiment and computed by the proposed method. and computed by the proposed method. 4.3. Distribution Transformer 4.3. Distribution transformer In this part, two distribution transformers are considered. In the first case of the distribution In this part, two distribution transformers are considered. In the first case of the distribution transformers, a distribution (2 MVA 420 V/24 kV) was considered. With the proposed approach, transformers, a distribution (2 MVA 420 V/24 kV) was considered. With the proposed approach, the the equivalent circuit of a 24-kV winding was extracted. The number of RLC sets was 3. The realized equivalent circuit of a 24-kV winding was extracted. The number of RLC sets was 3. The realized circuit parameters are expressed in Table 6. The good agreements between impedances from the circuit parameters are expressed in Table 6. The good agreements between impedances from the experiment and the equivalent circuit model are observed and shown in Figures 20 and 21. experiment and the equivalent circuit model are observed and shown in Figures 20 and 21. Table 6. Circuit parameters determined by the proposed approach. Table 6. Circuit parameters determined by the proposed approach. Circuit Parameters Section No. (Ω) SectionR1iNo. 1 2 3 0.00 1 0.06 2 0.95 3 Circuit Parameters R2i (kΩ) Ci (nF) R1i (Ω) Li (mH) R2i (kΩ) Ci (nF) 0.0054 0.071 11.30 0.00 0.3352 0.0054 0.071 11.30 0.767 18.10 9.876 0.06 31.0200 0.3352 0.767 18.103.13 0.95 31.0200 9.876 3.13 Li (mH) Section No. R1i (Ω) 0.00 0.06 0.95 1 2 3 Energies 2020, 13, 5399 Circuit Parameters Li (mH) R2i (kΩ) Ci (nF) 0.0054 0.071 11.30 0.3352 0.767 18.10 31.0200 9.876 3.13 14 of 19 From the experiment From the proposed method Figure 20. Magnitude of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and the proposed method. the proposed method. Energies 2020, 20. 13, xMagnitude FOR PEER REVIEW 15 of 19 Figure of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and From the experiment From the proposed method Figure 21. Phase of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and by the Figure 21. Phase of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and by the proposed method. proposed method. This determined model was employed in the proposed method in lightning impulse voltage test. This determined model was employed in the proposed method in lightning impulse voltage As with the procedure in Section 3, the low frequency inductance of 31.0 mH was computed. Therefore, test. As with the procedure in Section 3, the low frequency inductance of 31.0 mH was computed. the conventional circuit, as shown in Figure 2, is recommended as an impulse voltage generation circuit. Therefore, the conventional circuit, as shown in Figure 2, is recommended as an impulse voltage The equivalent circuit of the completed test system (an identified model and an impulse generation generation circuit. The equivalent circuit of the completed test system (an identified model and an circuit) is presented in Figure 22, and the experimental set up is also presented in Figure 23. The initial impulse generation circuit) is presented in Figure 22, and the experimental set up is also presented in generator circuit parameters are calculated by Equations (1) to (2). The generated waveform with Figure 23. The initial generator circuit parameters are calculated by Equations (1) to (2). The these circuit parameters is not in accordance with the standard requirement, so these parameters are generated waveform with these circuit parameters is not in accordance with the standard required for further adjustment. The proper circuit parameters are given in Table 7. Good agreement of requirement, so these parameters are required for further adjustment. The proper circuit parameters the simulated and experimental voltage waveforms is observed, and the results are shown in Figure 24. are given in Table 7. Good agreement of the simulated and experimental voltage waveforms is The front time (T1 ), the time to half (T2 ), and the overshoot rate (βe ) collected from the experiment are observed, and the results are shown in Figure 24. The front time (T1), the time to half (T2), and the 1.02 µs, 52.5 µs, and 3.52%, respectively, whereas T1 , T2 , and βe from the simulation using the proposed overshoot rate (βe) collected from the experiment are 1.02 µ s, 52.5 µ s, and 3.52%, respectively, model are 1.21 µs and 53.9 µs, and 1.71%, respectively. These parameters are in the accepted ranges of whereas T1, T2, and βe from the simulation using the proposed model are 1.21 µ s and 53.9 µ s, and the standard requirement. 1.71%, respectively. These parameters are in the accepted ranges of the standard requirement. Rd G Cs Re oltagedivider A B C generated waveform with these circuit parameters is not in accordance with the standard requirement, so these parameters are required for further adjustment. The proper circuit parameters are given in Table 7. Good agreement of the simulated and experimental voltage waveforms is observed, and the results are shown in Figure 24. The front time (T1), the time to half (T2), and the overshoot rate (βe) collected from the experiment are 1.02 µ s, 52.5 µ s, and 3.52%, respectively, Energieswhereas 2020, 13, 5399 15 of 19 T1, T2, and βe from the simulation using the proposed model are 1.21 µ s and 53.9 µ s, and 1.71%, respectively. These parameters are in the accepted ranges of the standard requirement. Rd Cs Re A B C a b c Voltagedivider G DSO Voltage n Energies 2020,Equivalent 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW of 19 Figure 22. circuit of the completed test system for the lightning impulse test of16 the Figure 22. Equivalent circuit of the completed test system for the lightning impulse test of the Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 16 of 19 distribution transformer winding. distribution transformer winding. 2 2 3 11 3 Figure 23.Figure Experimental set up completed testsystem system the lightning 23. Experimental set of up the of the completed test for for the lightning impulseimpulse test of thetest of the Figure 23. Experimental set upwhere ofwhere the(1) completed test system fortest, the(2) lightning test ofvoltage the distribution transformer winding, (1)isisthe the transformer under is the voltage distribution transformer winding, transformer under test, (2)impulse is impulse the impulse generator,transformer and (3) is a voltage divider. distribution winding, where (1) is the transformer under test, (2) is the impulse voltage generator, and (3) is a voltage divider. generator, and (3) is a voltage divider. 7. Selected circuit parameters of the lightning impulse voltage generation circuit. Table 7. Table Selected circuit parameters of the lightning impulse voltage generation circuit. Table 7. Selected circuit parameters of the lightning impulse voltage generation circuit. Circuit Parameters Cs (µF)Circuit Re (Ω)Parameters Rd (Ω) Cb (nF) Circuit Parameters 0.5 0.0 R (Ω)300.0 100.0R (Ω) Cs (µF) e Cs (µF) Re (Ω) 300.0 0.5 300.0 0.5 d Rd (Ω) Cb (nF) 100.0 100.0 0.0 Cb (nF) 0.0 Time scale of 1 ms/div Time scale of 1 ms/div Time scale of 10 ms/div From Time scale of the 10 experiment ms/div From the proposed method the voltage experiment Figure 24. Comparison of the generated From impulse waveforms collected from the experiment From the proposed method and computed by the proposed method. In the second case of the distribution transformers, a distribution (250 kVA 420V/22 kV) was Figureconsidered. 24. Comparison the impulse voltage waveforms collected from the experiment Figure 24. With Comparison ofgenerated the approach, generated impulse voltage waveforms collected from the experiment theofproposed the equivalent circuit of a 22-kV winding was extracted. The RLC sets wasmethod. 2. The realized circuit parameters are expressed in Table 8. The good andnumber computed byproposed the proposed method. and computed byofthe agreements between impedances from the experiment and the equivalent circuit model are observed and in Figures In shown the second case25 ofand the26. distribution transformers, a distribution (250 kVA 420V/22 kV) was considered. With the proposed approach, the equivalent circuit of a 22-kV winding was extracted. Table 8. Circuit parameters determined by the proposed approach. The number of RLC sets was 2. The realized circuit parameters are expressed in Table 8. The good Circuit Parameters agreements between impedances from the experiment and the equivalent circuit model are observed Section No. R1i (Ω) Li (mH) R2i (kΩ) Ci (nF) and shown in Figures 25 and 26. 1 2.42 7.353 9.752 10.02 Energies 2020, 13, 5399 16 of 19 In the second case of the distribution transformers, a distribution (250 kVA 420V/22 kV) was considered. With the proposed approach, the equivalent circuit of a 22-kV winding was extracted. The number of RLC sets was 2. The realized circuit parameters are expressed in Table 8. The good agreements between impedances from the experiment and the equivalent circuit model are observed and shown in Figures 25 and 26. Table 8. Circuit parameters determined by the proposed approach. Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW Section No. R1i (Ω) Energies 2020, 13, x FOR 1 PEER REVIEW 2.42 2 17 of 19 Circuit Parameters 48.3 Li (mH) R2i (kΩ) Ci (nF) 7.353 331.2 9.752 159.09 10.02 0.741 17 of 19 From the experiment From the proposed method From the experiment From the proposed method Figure 25. Magnitude of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and the proposed method. Figure 25. Magnitude of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and the Figure 25. Magnitude of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and proposed method. the proposed method. From the experiment From the proposed method From the experiment From the proposed method Figure 26. Phase of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and by the Figure 26. Phase of input impedances of the transformer winding from the measurement and by the proposed method. proposed method. This determined model was employed in the proposed method in a lightning impulse voltage Figure 26. Phase of inputin thelow transformer winding from the measurement andcomputed. by the test. As with the procedure Section 3,ofthe frequency inductance ofa 320.3 mH was This determined modelimpedances was employed in the proposed method in lightning impulse voltage proposed method. Therefore, the conventional circuit, as shown in Figure 2, is recommended as an impulse voltage test. As with the procedure in Section 3, the low frequency inductance of 320.3 mH was computed. generation The equivalent circuit of theincompleted test system (an identified modelvoltage and Therefore,circuit. the conventional circuit, as shown Figure 2, is recommended as an impulse This determined model was employed in the proposed method in a lightning impulse voltage angeneration impulse generation is presented Figure 22. The generator circuit model parameters, circuit. Thecircuit) equivalent circuit ofinthe completed testinitial system (an identified and an test. As with the procedure in Section 3, the low frequency inductance of 320.3 mH was computed. impulse generation circuit) is presented in Figure 22. The initial generator circuit parameters, Therefore, the conventional circuit, as shown in Figure 2, is recommended as an impulse voltage calculated by Equations (1) to (2), can be used for lightning impulse voltage properly. The proper generation circuit. The equivalent circuit of the completed test system (an identified model and an circuit parameters are given in Table 9. Good agreement of the simulated and experimental voltage impulse generation circuit) is presented in Figure 22. The initial generator circuit parameters, waveforms is observed, and the results are shown in Figure 27. The front time (T1), the time to half calculated by Equations (1) to (2), can be used for lightning impulse voltage properly. The proper (T2), and the overshoot rate (βe) collected from the experiment are 1.15 µ s, 45.1 µ s, and 0.52%, Energies 2020, 13, 5399 17 of 19 calculated by Equations (1) to (2), can be used for lightning impulse voltage properly. The proper circuit parameters are given in Table 9. Good agreement of the simulated and experimental voltage waveforms is observed, and the results are shown in Figure 27. The front time (T1 ), the time to half (T2 ), and the overshoot rate (βe ) collected from the experiment are 1.15 µs, 45.1 µs, and 0.52%, respectively, whereas T1 , T2 , and βe from the simulation using the proposed model are 1.09 µs and 43.9 µs, and 0.61%, respectively. These parameters are in the accepted ranges of the standard requirement. Energies 2020, 13, x FOR PEER REVIEW 18 of 19 Table 9. Selected circuit parameters of the lightning impulse voltage generation circuit. Table 9. Selected circuit parameters of the lightning impulse voltage generation circuit. Circuit CircuitParameters Parameters Cs (µF) 0.5 Re (Ω)Re (Ω) Cs (µF) 0.5150.0 150.0 d (Ω) Cb (nF) RdR(Ω) 500.0 500.0 0.0 Cb (nF) 0.0 Time scale of 1 ms/div Time scale of 10 ms/div From the experiment From the proposed method Figure 27. Comparison of the generated impulse voltage waveforms collected from the experiment Figure 27. Comparison of the generated impulse voltage waveforms collected from the experiment and computed by the proposed method. and computed by the proposed method. 5. Conclusions 5. Conclusions In this paper, the effective simulation approach for lightning impulse voltage tests of transformer In this paper, has thebeen effective simulation approach a for lightningbetween impulseanvoltage and reactor windings proposed. In this approach, combination accuratetests wideof transformer and reactor windings has been proposed. In this approach, a combination between frequency model (10 Hz to 10 MHz) of transformer as well as reactor windings and the proper impulsean accurate wide frequency (10 HzFor to 10 of transformer as well as reactor windings and generation circuit has beenmodel described. theMHz) realized equivalent identification of the windings, thecombined proper impulse circuit hasand been For the have realized the methodsgeneration of the vector fitting thedescribed. genetic algorithm beenequivalent employed.identification The vector of the windings, the combined methods of the vector fitting and the genetic algorithm have has been fitting has been utilized to determine the starting circuit parameters, and the genetic algorithm employed. Thetovector fitting hasrealized been utilized determine (positive the starting circuit Case parameters, the been employed search for the circuittoparameters values). studiesand have genetic algorithm been a employed to search for thetwo realized circuit transformers. parameters (positive values). been performed on ahas reactor, power transformer, and distribution Additionally, Case studies have performed on a the reactor, a power transformer, and two experiments have beenbeen carried out to confirm validity of the proposed approach. Fromdistribution the good transformers. Additionally, experiments have been carried out to with confirm the validity of the agreements of the simulated and the experimental results, the validity a promising accuracy proposed approach. From the good agreements of the simulated and the experimental results, the has been confirmed. It has been shown that the realized circuit parameters of the winding high validity with a promising accuracy has been confirmed. It has been shown that the realized circuit frequency model function very well with the proper impulse generation circuits (both Glaninger’s parameters of the winding high frequency model function veryfor well with the proper impulse circuit and conventional circuit) in effective simulation approaches impulse voltage testing on generation circuits (both Glaninger’s circuit and conventional circuit) in effective simulation transformers and reactors. From this achievement, the possibility of the damage on the windings and approaches impulseunintentionally voltage testingduring on transformers reactors. this achievement, the their insulationfor occurring the process and of the voltage From waveform adjustment will of the damage on the windings and their insulation occurring unintentionally during the bepossibility reduced significantly. process of the voltage waveform adjustment will be reduced significantly. Author Contributions: Conceptualization, P.T. and P.Y.; Methodology, P.T. and P.Y.; Software, P.T. and P.Y.; Validation, P.T. and P.Y.; Formal analysis, P.T. and P.Y.; Investigation, P.T., P.Y. and A.K.; Writing-original draft preparation, P.T. and P.Y.; Writing-review and editing, P.T., P.Y. and A.K.; Supervision, P.Y. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. Funding: This work was financially supported by Research and Researchers for Industries (RRi), The Thailand Research Fund No. PHD57I0035. Acknowledgments: This work is financially supported by Research and Researchers for Industries (RRI), The Energies 2020, 13, 5399 18 of 19 Author Contributions: Conceptualization, P.T. and P.Y.; Methodology, P.T. and P.Y.; Software, P.T. and P.Y.; Validation, P.T. and P.Y.; Formal analysis, P.T. and P.Y.; Investigation, P.T., P.Y. and A.K.; Writing-original draft preparation, P.T. and P.Y.; Writing-review and editing, P.T., P.Y. and A.K.; Supervision, P.Y. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. Funding: This work was financially supported by Research and Researchers for Industries (RRi), The Thailand Research Fund No. PHD57I0035. Acknowledgments: This work is financially supported by Research and Researchers for Industries (RRI), The Thailand Research Fund No. PHD57I0035. The authors also would like to thank Sakda Maneerot of LAMOOL TRANSFORMERS and TESLA POWER Co Ltd for his technical advice. Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. IEC 60060-1. High-Voltage Test Techniques. Part 1: General Definitions and Test Requirements, 3rd ed.; International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC): Geneva, Switzerland, 2010. IEEE Standard 4TM-2013. IEEE Standard for High-Voltage Testing Techniques; Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE): Piscataway, NJ, USA, 2013. IEC 60076-1. Power Transformer. Part 1: General, 3rd ed.; International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC): Geneva, Switchzerland, 2011. IEC 60076-3. Power Transformer. Part 3: Insulation Level, Dielectric Tests and External Clearances in Air, 3rd ed.; International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC): Geneva, Switchzerland, 2013. IEC 60076-4. Power Transformer. Part 4: Guide to the Lightning Impulse and Switching Impulse Testing—Power Transformer and Reactors, 1st ed.; International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC): Geneva, Switchzerland, 2002. Kuffel, E.; Zaengl, W.S.; Kuffel, J. High Voltage Engineering: Fundamentals, 2nd ed.; Newnes: Oxford, UK, 2000. Glaninger, P. Impulse testing of low inductance electrical equipment. In Proceedings of the 2nd International Symposium on High Voltage Technology, Zurich, Switzerland, 9–13 September 1975; pp. 140–144. Feser, K. Circuit Design of Impulse Generators for the Lightning Impulse Voltage Testing of Transformers. Bulleytin SEV/VSE Bd 1987. Available online: www.haefely.com (accessed on 15 November 2019). Schrader, W.; Schufft, W. Impulse Voltage Test of Power Transformers; paper No. 13; HV Technologies, Inc.: Manassas, VA, USA, 2000. Karthikeyan, B.; Rajesh, R.; Balasubramanian, M.; Saravanan, S. Experimental investigations on IEC suggested methods for improving waveshape during impulse voltage testing. In Proceedings of the 2006 IEEE 8th International Conference on Properties & applications of Dielectric Materials, Bali, Indonesia, 26–30 June 2006. Tuethong, P.; Kitwattana, K.; Yutthagowith, P.; Kunakorn, A. An algorithm for circuit parameter Identification in lightning Impulse voltage generation for low-inductance loads. Energies 2020, 13, 3913. [CrossRef] Mirzaei, H. A Simple Fast and Accurate Simulation Method for Power Transformer Lightning Impulse Test. IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 2019, 33, 1151–1160. [CrossRef] Mirzaei, H.; Bayat, F.; Miralikhani, K. A Semi-Analytic Approach for Determining Marx Generator Optimum Set-up during Power Transformers Factory Test. IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 2020. Early Access. [CrossRef] Gustavsen, B.; Semlyen, A. Rational approximation of frequency domain responses by vector fitting. IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 1999, 14, 1052–1061. [CrossRef] Yang, X. Engineering Optimization: An Introduction with Metahueristic Applications; John Wiley & Sons, Inc.: Hoboken, NJ, USA, 2010; pp. 173–176. Mehdi, B.; Davood, A.; Hassan, B.; Ebrahim, R. Identification of Transient Model Parameters of Transformer Using Genetic Algorithm. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Power System Technology, Hangzhou, China, 24–28 October 2010; pp. 1–6. IEC 61083-2. Instruments and Software used for Measurement in High-Voltage and High Current Tests. Part 2: Requirements for Software for Tests with Impulse Voltages and Currents, 2nd ed.; International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC): Geneva, Switchzerland, 2013. Pattanadech, N.; Yutthagowith, P. Fast curve fitting algorithm for parameter evaluation in lightning impulse test technique. IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul. 2015, 22, 2931–2936. [CrossRef] Energies 2020, 13, 5399 19. 20. 19 of 19 Yutthagowith, P.; Pattanadech, N. Improved least-square prony analysis technique for parameter evaluation of lightning impulse voltage and current. IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 2016, 31, 271–277. [CrossRef] Yutthagowith, P.; Tuethong, P.; Pattanadech, N. Effective circuit parameter determination in lightning impulse voltage tests of air core inductors. In Proceedings of the 12th IET International Conference on AC and DC Power Transmission, Beijing, China, 28–29 May 2016. Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. © 2020 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )