Pay Stubs, Decoded: What Yours Should
Show (and Why It Matters)
If you’ve ever opened a paycheck and wondered, “Where did this number come from?”, you’re
in good company. Most of us glance at the deposit and move on, yet the details on a pay stub tell
a fuller story—hours worked, rates applied, taxes withheld, and the little line items that shape
your take-home pay. Nakase Law Firm Inc. is often asked what information should a pay stub
contain by owners and workers alike (https://nakaselawfirm.com/what-information-should-apay-stub-contain/), and that question taps into everyday needs like budgeting, loan applications,
and peace of mind.
Here’s the thing: a pay stub isn’t just an accounting printout; it’s a receipt for your time. Think
about grabbing groceries—if the total feels off, you check the receipt. Same idea here. And to
ground this in real rules, as California Business Lawyer & Corporate Lawyer Inc. notes,
California labor code section 226 sets out in clear terms (https://california-business-lawyercorporate-lawyer.com/california-labor-code-section-226-wage-statement-requirementspenalties/) what has to show up on every pay stub in the state, so everyone knows what’s being
paid and why.
The basics: who and when
Start with the obvious, because it matters for everything else. Your full legal name belongs on
the stub, often with an employee ID or the last four digits of your Social Security number. Add
the exact dates for the pay period. This avoids those “Was that holiday overtime from last week
or the week before?” debates. If you’ve ever tried to reconcile overtime after a busy month, you
know that precise dates save a lot of back-and-forth.
The employer’s stamp
The pay stub should show who cut the check—company name and address. Lenders and
landlords look for this, and it also helps if you work at multiple locations. Picture applying for an
apartment and being asked to verify employment. A clear employer line on the stub often settles
it in seconds.
Dollars in: gross wages
Gross pay is the top-line figure before anything gets taken out. It should reflect regular hours,
overtime, bonuses, and any other earnings. Say you picked up a last-minute weekend shift at
time-and-a-half; that extra should be visible right here. If you’ve ever felt shorted and then found
the missing hours in this section, you know how valuable this line can be.
Dollars out: itemized deductions
Now for the part everyone scans with a tiny wince. Deductions should be listed line by line—
federal and state taxes, Social Security, Medicare, health insurance, retirement contributions, and
any other elected items. A vague “withholdings” line doesn’t help anyone. Clear entries turn
“Why is my check smaller?” into “Okay, that’s the new pre-tax health premium.”
The final number: net pay
This is the figure that lands in your account. It’s easy to focus only on this line, and yes, it’s the
one that pays the bills. Still, it’s the result of everything above it. If the math doesn’t seem to add
up, the rest of the stub gives you the breadcrumbs to trace the route from gross to net.
Tracking hours worked
Hourly workers need to see total hours—regular, overtime, and sometimes double time. Imagine
logging an extra Saturday shift only to find the total looks off. A good stub shows the full count
so you can compare it with your own notes or time app. This line protects both sides: you can
verify pay, and your employer can show the calculation.
Rate of pay
Rates matter as much as totals. If you have different pay rates—regular, overtime, shift
differential, piece-rate—each one should appear with the hours tied to it. Picture a week with 40
regular hours at $20 and five overtime hours at $30. When your stub displays both lines, you
don’t have to guess where the numbers came from.
Employer contributions
Some companies pitch in for benefits like medical coverage or retirement. Listing those
contributions (even when not strictly required) helps you see the full value of your
compensation. A quick example: seeing a monthly employer 401(k) contribution on the stub
often nudges people to increase their own match—free money is hard to ignore.
Year-to-date totals
YTD lines give you the year’s running tally—earnings, taxes withheld, and contributions so far.
When tax season rolls around, those numbers make life easier. Instead of digging through
months of files, you already have a rolling summary. Handy for mid-year checkups too: thinking
of adjusting your withholding? These totals help you decide.
State rules and why they matter
Federal rules set a baseline, and states often add extra detail. California tends to be meticulous
about wage statements, and those rules are designed to keep everyone on the same page. If you
operate across multiple states, it pays to check each set of requirements so your payroll doesn’t
trip over a missing line item. No one likes surprise penalties, and clear stubs help prevent them.
Paper or digital?
Most pay stubs now arrive online through portals or email. The format doesn’t change the
content rules. You should be able to view, download, and print the same details you’d expect on
paper. By the way, keeping a simple folder—digital or physical—makes it much easier to pull up
proof of income when a lender or tax preparer asks.
Why employees should care
Picture this: you’re applying for a car loan and the lender asks for the last two pay stubs. They’re
not just checking the net number—they look at employer info, pay period dates, and consistency.
Or think about catching a small overtime error in week one rather than month six. A quick skim
after each payday can save a long call later.
Why employers should care
Clear pay stubs calm worries before they start. When employees can read a stub and see the story
behind the deposit, trust grows. Payroll teams also benefit: fewer tickets, fewer “Can you explain
this?” emails, and better records when questions do arise. In short, clarity today avoids disputes
tomorrow.
Common pitfalls to avoid
Here are the missteps that pop up again and again:





Missing pay period dates
No breakdown of deductions
Overtime hours not shown
Pay rates not listed for each category
YTD lines skipped
A quick internal check every so often can catch these. Think of it as spring cleaning for
payroll—light effort, helpful results.
Real-world moments that bring this home
Two short snapshots. First, Jordan, a barista who picked up three closing shifts before a holiday.
Her stub showed the exact overtime hours and the higher rate, so when she compared it with her
time app, everything matched—end of story. Second, Diego, a warehouse lead, noticed his health
premium changed mid-year. The deduction line spelled out the new amount, and the employer
contribution line confirmed the company’s share, so his HR email was one sentence long:
“Looks good—just checking that this is the new rate.” Simple and done.
Wrapping it up
So, what information should a pay stub contain? Enough detail to retrace every step from hours
worked to dollars deposited, with names, dates, rates, totals, and deductions spelled out. Next
payday, take sixty seconds to scan yours. Do the dates line up? Do the hours and rates make
sense? If the answer is yes, you can move on with confidence. And if something looks off,
you’ve got the facts you need to ask for a fix.