SMIB 2017-2018
Competitive Strategy
Short Syllabus
Becoming a Strategist
Instructor : Olivier Fourcadet, Office N202
Mob. 06 87 49 90 66
Fix. 01 34 43 32 65
Fourcadet@essec.edu
Skype : olivier.fourcadet
What is the topic of this course?
What is competitive strategy?
What is not competitive strategy?
Competitive strategy can be simply defined as an organization, e.g. a firm, strategy
within an industry. The term "Competitive Strategy" was first coined by Harvard
Professor Michael E. Porter. The foundation of Competitive Strategy is Industrial
Organization, i.e. a branch of the micro-analytic economic approach. Do not worry,
there is no equation (well, maybe just a few!). Competitive Strategy differs from
corporate strategy (corporations can be involved in many industries) and functional
1
strategy (marketing strategy, R&D strategy, …) It focuses on the business level, i.e., in
between the corporate and the functional levels.
Competitive Strategy focuses on a component of the business level strategy. It
concentrates on the strategic interactions between companies within an industry.
Business strategy is also about supporting organizational arrangement, resources and
capabilities management. Even the best strategy, if poorly implemented, will never
deliver good results.
Competitive Strategy tries to answer the major strategic question: How to build a
long-term competitive advantage? This question may have several possible answers
(Who told you there is only one good strategy?) or none.
From content to process, principles and Attitude (A2PS)
A strategy is the result of a process, the strategy formation process. It is rather an
iterative process (Will it ever end?). The course will focus on strategic processes. A
strategy is only a temporary object. And a good strategy for company A may not be the
best strategy for a company B. Principles are rules. They provide guidance on making
choices. If you apply principle P (in the context C), you are more likely to generate a
good result.
Strategists think strategically. Thinking strategically is, at first, quite challenging. Read
online the article: Business Chess by R. L. Istvan. For more on this topic: "The Mind of
the Strategist". When all companies have the same information, the same technologies,
see the same opportunities …… The only possible advantage may be the way the CEO
team thinks.
2
Target Audiences
The course is designed for two audiences:
● future managers and consultants who will elaborate strategies for their clients.
● bankers and other players who will assess companies' strategy and make
investment decisions based on the result of their analyses.
Structure of the course
The course is divided into three parts:
1. The first four classes are rather “formal” classes: They are designed to help us
acquire a good strategic mind set. Before you run the marathon (cases) you need
to train yourself on short distances.
2. Classe 5 concentrates on the Quiz Project, a discussion between the
professor and the group. This year project topic is exit strategy. Group of
participants (4 to 5) will work building a conceptual model that could help a
company design the best exit strategy. Where Exit is the termination of an activity
(not the sale of the business to another firm).
3. Six classes are case discussions (part 1) and feedback (part 2). These are
reserved for the participants enrolled into the Consulting Track.
The quality of the classes depends on the student participation (we learn by
doing) and follow their path of learning. Therefore, the course is driven by the students.
3
The syllabus given below is what can happen during the class, but not what will happen.
It is up to you!
The 3 major lines that will be followed during the course are:
1. Value Creation and Appropriation,
2. Context: the industry (the business landscape, the ecosystem)
3. Strategic interactions
Most of the time (but it often changes according to students’ interest and goals)
Lesson 1 is divided into two parts
- The first part introduces the students with several key concepts such as Value creation
and value appropriation, competitive advantage, competitive arenas, industry, and
refines the definition of strategy.
- The second part of the class is made of two games.
Lesson 2 - 4 : We will look at different battlefields (Threat from entry, threat from
substitutes, bargaining power, rivalry, etc.) using mini cases. I do not mention the issue
we will tackle during specific session: the strategist needs to learn to identify the issue.
Lesson 6 - 10: Class discussions of assigned cases
We will cover several types of industry settings, different type of strategic decision, etc.
During the second part of the course I will provide feedback, comments and
suggestions.
4
During the classes 6-10, a first group of students will present its analysis and strategic
recommendations to the rest of the class and the second group of students will play the
role of an outsider : the challenger.
The format of the presentation follows a company presentation to a community of
financial analysts who will ultimately recommend or not to invest into your company. All
the students will have to prepare the case (a short synthetic note is required from all the
students and for all case discussion classes, a more elaborated document and
presentation are required for the two groups). Discussion is mandatory for all. Strategy
thinking is just like cycling: you must practice to learn how to become a good strategist.
Evaluation (Grade) is based on the analysis of the cases (3 critical point paper) and
class participation plus a self-assessment about “learning.”
For the six cases (1. Resotech / 2. Nutrasweet vs HSC / 3 Cat fight in the pet food
industry / 4 Zipcar / 5 Coursera 6/ Flipkart) the class is divided into 3 groups:
● Group 1: The participants in group 1 will present the case. (more on this below)
● Group 2: The participants in group 2 will challenge group1. (more on this below).
● Group 3: All the other students are asked to provide a one page analysis of a
unique critical point related to the case (more on this below)
I have selected a panel of cases to cover almost all major strategic issues. The first 3
cases are related to the old economy (durable, ingredients and consumption goods) and
the 3 last cases are about the new economy (e-commerce, new mobility, online
teaching). Case N°3 provides a out-of-box perspective of an industry (similar to
information available to consultants).
Be aware of the following critical mistakes in the handling of the case:
● The issue mentioned (first) in the case may not be the most critical issue for the
company.
5
● Removing “problems” one after the other (problem solving approach) may not be
appropriate in strategy.
● Egocentrism: never forget that you are not alone in this world. Other players have
also strategies. Never take their current strategies for granted, they are also
trying to improve their position.
● Relying too much on the past: the future can be different.
● Relying too little on the past: things do not change overnight.
● Take time into account (Strategic implementation requires time)
Be sure you understand clearly what an analysis is! (And what it is not, what is a
synthesis? What is an evaluation? (Analysis, Synthesis and Evaluation are the most
important generic strategists’ skills.)
Group 1: Case Presentation
You will put you in the shoes of the management team or a group of consultants that
has been appointed to provide “a solution” to the board of directors. In all cases do not
take for granted the suggestions that have been made to you. (Powerpoint presentation)
The performance of the group is based on the following items:
Key issues:
Definition of the strategic problem
Key subsidiary issues
Analysis
Qualitative and Quantitative Analysis
Ability to build idea
Alternative Design and Evaluation
Logical tie-in to analysis
Use of strategic principles
Realism and practicality of solutions
Quality of the evaluation process
Plan of action
Consideration of cost and control issues
6
Time line
Analysis of risk exposure
Presentation form and style
Communication Skills
Professionalism
Good use of time
Handling of questions
Ability to defend position
Consistency with presentation
Ability to answer questions
Smoothness and balance of group
General Comments and Suggestions
Major Strengths
Area for improvement
Please pay a great deal of attention to the form of the presentation. The form is not the
design of the slides, but it is the sequence of the presentation.
Please avoid common mistakes such as:
1. Forming a diagnosis that is not supported by an analysis (It is fine to have an opinion,
but in that case this is just an opinion not the result of an analysis).
2. Piling up pieces without links between them – things are often connected
3. Performing an analysis without mentioning its conclusions and its strategic
implications.
Group 2: Challengers
Because the approaches followed by presenting groups are often conservative, the
challengers have to develop alternative analyses of the issue and strategies.
Challengers do not just “nasty” questions, but rather develop alternative views of the
situation at hand. There are often many ways to interpret a situation. Their approach
7
must be based on the art of asking “questions”. The must be prepared to support their
challenging views.
The paper is often a document with a list of critical issues that are explored in a creative
manner (length must be appropriate).
Group 3: Critical analysis (1-2 pages)
The cases are the occasion to concentrate on a unique aspect of the case and provide
a deep analysis of that item. Instead of building on the many pieces of the puzzle, the
participants are required to take a critical dimension (but not the main issue) and to
explore it in detail. For example, What are the most likely reactions of the competitors to
a move made by my company ? How do regulations will affect the demand space ?
How do I evaluate the size of the market ?
Learning process
I also suggest adopting a professional learning scheme and a reflexive position.
Three questions are suggested:
● What did I learn today about strategy ?
● What did I learn about myself (as a strategist) ?
● What should I do differently and how ?
8