Urban Water Journal ISSN: 1573-062X (Print) 1744-9006 (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/nurw20 Preliminary sizing of surge vessels on pumping mains Ahmed M. A. Sattar, M. Soliman & Amgad El-Ansary To cite this article: Ahmed M. A. Sattar, M. Soliman & Amgad El-Ansary (2019) Preliminary sizing of surge vessels on pumping mains, Urban Water Journal, 16:10, 738-748, DOI: 10.1080/1573062X.2020.1729388 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/1573062X.2020.1729388 Published online: 24 Feb 2020. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 12 View related articles View Crossmark data Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=nurw20 URBAN WATER JOURNAL 2019, VOL. 16, NO. 10, 738–748 https://doi.org/10.1080/1573062X.2020.1729388 RESEARCH ARTICLE Preliminary sizing of surge vessels on pumping mains Ahmed M. A. Sattar a,b , M. Solimanc and Amgad El-Ansarya a Department of Irrigation & Hydraulics, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt; bCivil Department, German University in Cairo, Cairo, Egypt; cFaculty of Engineering, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt ABSTRACT ARTICLE HISTORY Anew and simple model for sizing surge vessels on pumping mains has been developed. The Monte Carlo Simulation (MCS) is utilized to generate 2000 realizations for various cases of up- and down-surges. Approximate models are developed for the prediction of the initial and the expanded vessel’s gas volume. The developed models outperformed the existing design charts; yielding better scores in various statistical indicators, e.g. a high coefficient of determination of 0.94 and four orders of magnitude less error. The vessel’s initial gas volume is found to be affected mostly by the pipe diameter and static head, while the expanded gas volume depends on the initial gas volume and the static head. The error analysis revealed that the predicted models had a low error band of þ = 0.36 compared to þ = 0.78 for previous design charts. These developed approximate models can serve as a basis for preliminary surge protection size selection during feasibility study phases. Received 12 July 2019 Accepted 7 February 2020 Introduction Water hammer in pumping mains has a substantial adverse effects on pipes, leading to pipe burst in the case of high transient pressure or pipe collapse in the case of extremely low transient pressure (Wang et al. 2014). In the case of pump power failure or pump trip a down-surge is generated at the pump. This initial down-surge travels from the pump towards the discharge end of the pipeline and reflects back as an upsurge. If the down-surge drops below the vapor pressure for water (about 10 m below atmospheric pressure at 20 °C), cavitation and water column separation can occur. The separation leads to oscillating water columns, which can subsequently rejoin after the collapse of air bubbles leading to over pressure. These down-surges can be effectively controlled by means of surge vessels. Many researchers have worked on the sizing of surge vessels for rising pumping mains. Initial studies go back to the 1900s, e.g. De Sparre (1911), Evangelisti (1938), and Evans and Crawford (1954). They assumed that the pressure oscillations are less than one half of the surge caused by instantaneous valve closure, and they utilized the rigid column equations to provide charts for quick design. Some of these charts did not include pipe friction and others had distributed friction not correctly accounted for. Graze and Horlacher (1982, 1986) developed design charts showing the pressure profile along the pipeline length. They separated the pipe friction loss from the orifice resistance. Graze and Horlacher (1989) proposed a chart for flow throttling for pumping cases with low static heads, where down-surge would be the governing factor. Using the rigid column assumptions, Stephenson (1989, 2002) developed a monograph for surge vessel sizing in the case of pump failures. He suggested new dimensionless variables with fewer parameters than the Graze and Horlacher (1986) charts. CONTACT Ahmed M. A. Sattar ahmoudy77@yahoo.com © 2020 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group KEYWORDS Surge vessel; water hammer; hydraulic transients; gene expression programming; method of characteristics; Monte Carlo Simulation Under the elastic theory hypothesis, De Martino and Fontana (2012) presented two approximate expressions for the calculation of pipeline pressure for the quick sizing of surge vessel volume and orifice resistance. Recently, the artificial neural network (ANN) has been utilized for the development of models that are capable of predicting the initial air volume of the surge vessel on rising mains (Izquierdo et al. 2006), and water distribution networks (Ramalingam and Lingireddy 2014). Data used for model development were either collected from Graze and Horlacher (1986) charts with the rigid column assumption, or hypothetical assumed cases. Izquierdo et al. (2006) did not show the range of various parameters used in model development and reported the need for more data to validate the developed model and enhance its predictions. Their ANN model did not include throttling of the surge vessel, which allows for volume reduction when high pressure is the critical situation. On the other hand the Ramalingam and Lingireddy (2014) model required more than 35 input parameters, most of which have to be processed from the initial steady state solution. Their study was limited to very small surge vessels with a maximum volume of three cubic meters. Numerical models are indeed powerful, but their use is time consuming, especially for repeated simulations. Consequently, sizing tools are helpful and are of great practical use in the selection of initial vessel size in planning stages. Due to the limited range of input parameters and the lack of completeness, De Martino and Fontana (2012) suggested that many of these charts and models cannot be used in even the preliminary stages of surge protection design. Many of these models are based on the simplifying assumptions of the rigid column and the De Sparre rule, which make them very limited in applicability. Other models and charts have neglected important URBAN WATER JOURNAL parameters that have a big influence on the surge vessel’s size, such as the throttling of the surge vessel and pipeline friction. While the ANN models are built on runs made assuming full elastic pipe theory, they have been built using a narrow range of input parameters and some of them used data generated by the rigid column assumption. In addition, the ANN models are grey box models with no clear or simple equation that can be used by practitioners who have no access to the model itself. Most importantly, none of the available models provided the final expanded air volume; only initial air volume could be calculated from them. Thus, the main objective of this study is to develop a new simple approximate model for the prediction of optimum size of surge vessels on pumping mains due to pump failure, which overcomes many of the above limitations. Moreover, the model comprises simple straight-forward relations that produce initial and final air volumes explicitly. These relations can be used by non-experienced users for preliminary sizing, more easily and faster than any available software that would require many iterations and experienced users. The Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) is used to generate stochastic inputs covering a wide range of pumping main cases. The gene expression programming (GEP) is used to develop a predictive model for the initial and expanded air volumes. The developed GEP models are statistically compared with available design charts. The prediction errors are further quantified, and a parametric analysis is performed for verification. Methodology Numerical modeling of surge vessels and optimum sizing approach Using the method of characteristics (MOC) the one-dimensional momentum and continuity equations describing unsteady flow in pipes can be numerically solved, considering the following internal boundary conditions of a surge vessel (Chaudhry 2014): QatþΔt ¼ QtþΔt þ QstþΔt b (1) HatþΔt ¼ HtþΔt b (2) where a, b are two arbitrary points before and after the surge vessel, t = the current time step, t þ Δt = the following time step along the solution time domain, H is the piezometric head, and Qs = the flow to the surge vessel. In this case, the volume "air and pressure Hair of the compressed air during a transient event can be written as follows: t "tþΔt As zstþΔt zst (3) air ¼ "air tþΔt ¼ HtþΔt þ Hbar Hair b zst htþΔt loss (4) where zst = the height of the liquid in the tank, As = the crosssectional area of the surge vessel, Hbar = atmospheric pressure, hloss = head loss for flow through the orifice and expressed as tþΔt tþΔt Qs htþΔt , where Qs is the flow in (-ve) or out loss ¼ Closs Qs (+ve) of the surge vessel, and Closs = coefficient of orifice head loss. According to the direction of flow, either to/from vessel, the coefficient of orifice loss is adjusted to account for the 739 variation/throttling in the connecting pipe diameter and the bypass. With the assumption that the enclosed air at the top of chamber follows the polytropic relation for a perfect gas, then m tþΔt m HtþΔt ¼ constant ¼ Hoair "oair (5) "air air where Hoair , and "oair = steady state air head and corresponding air volume, and the ‘constant’ can be calculated from the volume and pressure of enclosed air at steady state conditions prior to the transient event, and m = exponent with value of 1 for isothermal and 1.4 for adiabatic expansion of air. The pump boundary condition is solved within the MOC numerical scheme as explained in Chaudhry (2014). The combined inertia of the pump rotating elements is calculated from Thorley (2004): 1:48 ρgQH Itot ¼ 118 þ 1:5 3:6 106 η N 0:955 ρgQH (6) 107 3:6 106 η N3 where I = inertia, N = the pump rotational speed, which is set to 1500 rpm, covering the practical range of centrifugal pumps, η= pump efficiency and taken as 0.85, and Q, H = pump flow and head at the best efficiency point. The standard fourquadrant pump transient representation (Chaudhry 2014) is utilized to model the pump through various zones of operation following a transient event. The four-quadrant pump transient curve is chosen (Knapp and Calif 1937) based on the pump’s specific speed. These equations are solved for the expanded volume of the air "fair that determines the final surge vessel size. Optimization of the surge vessel size is an iterative process that depends on the bounding limits of maximum and minimum allowable pressure surges. This numerical model solves for the pressure transient wave propagation using the MOC in a deterministic way; that is to say, given a sequence of inputs to the model, the outputs are uniquely determined. However, a wide range of input parameters with various random combinations would be needed to generate enough data that is descriptive for the process of pressure surge attenuation in surge vessels. Therefore, a stochastic approach using MCS is adopted in this study to generate random combinations of input parameters that represent many pump main cases. The numerical model is run using these input parameters to determine the corresponding required volume of the surge vessel. The framework of stochastic analysis using MOC and MCS is shown in Figure 1 and explained by the following steps: (1) Input parameters, pipe length, pipe diameter, pipe material, wave speed, flow initial steady velocity, pump discharge, pump head, and static head, are all assigned a uniform probability distribution for sampling purposes. (2) Random samples for each parameter are drawn from each distribution according to a specified number of MCS realizations. (3) Combinations of random parameters for each realization are fed to the numerical model and solved in a deterministic manner for the pressure variation along the pipeline. Each deterministic case is run several times 740 A. M. A. SATTAR ET AL. Figure 1. Framework of stochastic analysis. to optimize the surge vessel size. The optimum size is defined as the smallest vessel size that meets the requirements for maximum and minimum system pressures as well as ensuring that the surge vessel does not drain. (4) Using the output of MOC in the previous step, the least square linearization (LSL) (Sattar 2014a) is utilized to identify the least contributing input parameters, which can be excluded from further analysis without a loss of accuracy. This is done through calculation of a sensitivity coefficient for each parameter, defined as: 100 wi2 σ2Δvi SVi ¼ Pn 2 2 i¼1 wi σΔvi (7) where wi is the regression coefficient, Δvi is the difference between vi , the random chosen sample of parameter i and mVi , the mean value of parameter i of all the random samples, and σ2δv is the variance of the calculated i difference Δvi . (5) Matrices of chosen input parameters and the corresponding optimized surge vessel’s volume for all realizations are then utilized to develop an approximate relation that can complement the complicated MOC numerical simulations. Gene expression programming for predictive equation development Functional relationship between the surge vessel volume and the input related parameters generated by MCS/LSL can be determined by multi-regression analysis or machine learning methods (e.g. ANN and GEP). The GEP has been proved to be useful in many hydraulic engineering applications and surpasses the traditional multi-regression analysis and ANN in developing complex relations between various parameters (e.g. Sattar 2014a, 2014b; El Hakeem and Sattar 2015; Najafzadeh and Sattar 2015; Sattar and Gharabaghi. 2015). As described in Sattar (2014a), the GEP uses a random distribution of functions and terminals as chromosome genes to create ‘parents’. The parent passes along its own genetic information to generate offspring. High-performing genetic operators (crossover and mutation) are used to yield offspring, which are adapted to the environment with greater fitness and with a higher chance of survival; the offspring is a better fit than the previously unfit parent. The criterion of fitness of the offspring is evaluated based on its ability to achieve a value within a pre-determined error of the correct value of the function. This evolutionary strategy allows GEP to identify an optimal offspring, without preventing the evolution of the next generation. Genetic mutations are the main essence of genetic evolution in GEP. The GEP code developed by Radi and Poli (2002) has been utilized in this study to develop the predictive models. More details on the GEP and utilization in predictive model development are found in Sattar (2016). The final GEP-model (the fittest offspring of generation i) is scored on a set of performance indicators as stated by Sattar (2016) and shown in Table 1. Results and discussions Model setup – deterministic runs In general, the process for calculating the surge vessel’s size is an optimization process that involves an iterative procedure of solving the water hammer equation for the system’s unsteady flows and heads, until final optimum size is reached according to preset pressure limits. There is no universally agreed limit for the maximum up-surge Hmax, e.g. in the USA and England (Ghorbanian, Karney, and Guo 2016). This limit is mainly controlled by pipe material rating and engineering practice. On the other hand, some researchers suggested the zero gauge pressure head as a limit for the minimum down-surge Hmin, e.g. Ramalingam and Lingireddy (2014) and Sun et al. (2016); while Ghorbanian, Karney, and Guo (2016) reported −7 m gauge head recorded during transient events in seven US water networks. However, practice showed that a limit of −3 m gauge pressure head resulted in a substantial decrease in vessel size with no effect on pipe integrity compared to the condition of zero pressure head. Therefore, the surge vessel size is calculated in this study to avoid the worst case scenario for the pipe and to limit Hmax to a value of 40% above the steady state pump head Hpump, and to limit Hmin to a pressure head of −3 m. The system, shown in Figure 2 consists of a linearly rising pipeline that is connected to a pump at the upstream and a reservoir at the downstream. The surge vessel is placed on the pipeline after the pump location. The vessel volume comprises water and the compressed gas above it. The initial gas volume is practically within the range of 25% to 75% of the total tank volume, while the final gas volume is larger and depends on the specific transient case. In the figure, D = pipeline diameter, and Dcon = diameter of connecting pipe. The pump suction pipe is URBAN WATER JOURNAL 741 Table 1. Performance indicators used for testing developed models. Performance indicator Coefficient of determination Root mean square error Coefficient of efficiency Index of agreement Gradients of the regression Slope of regression line Cross testing coefficient Standard deviation of errors Equation Variables 12 P is the value predicted by the program i for fitness case j, Tj is the target value P (ij) n P for P 1 ðT TÞðPðijÞ PÞ n j¼1 j fitness case j, T ¼ 1=n nj¼1 Tj , and n is the number of samples, P ¼ 1=n nj¼1 Pj , A q ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Ri 2 ¼ @qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi Pn Pn Pn 2 P 0 2 2 2 ðPðijÞ PÞ =n ðTj TÞ =n R2O ; RO2 ¼ 1 k0 ; kÞ2 = ni¼1 ðPi PÞ j¼1 j¼1 i¼1 Pi ð1 Pn ðTi Pi Þ2 Esn = 1 – Pi¼1n ðTi TÞ2 Pn i¼1 2 ðT i Pi Þ Dag = 1 - Pn i¼1 ðjPi TjþjTi TjÞ2 i¼1 n n P P k ¼ ðTi Pi Þ=Pi2 or k0 ¼ ðTi Pi Þ=Ti2 i¼1 i¼1 0 m0 ¼ R2 R2O =R2 and n0 ¼ R2 RO2 =R2 qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi R2 R2 Rm ¼ R2 1 O sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi n P n 2 P ej ¼ Pj Tj , and e ¼ ej . Using þ = 1.96 Se yields an approximately 95% ej e Se ¼ 1=ðn 1Þ 0 j¼1 j¼1 confidence band. Figure 2. Schematic of pumping main and a typical surge vessel for protection of pumping mains. assumed to be short and thus neglected from the analysis. In Figure 2, L = pipeline length from pump to reservoir, f = Darcy friction coefficient, and Hs = static head. Following power failure, the pump begins to decelerate with a speed that depends mainly on the pump’s initial rotational speed and inertia. A check valve is placed on the pump discharge to prevent flow reversal through the pump. The pump’s inertia determines the valve closure time, which is always greater than zero depending on the time taken by the transient wave to reverse and flow back to the pump. Therefore, the flow stoppage following pump failure becomes a gradual stoppage influenced by pump inertia. Two example cases of pumping pipelines are considered to illustrate the optimization process of the surge vessel following pump failure. In case a, the up-surge governs the optimization process (f = 0.015, L = 3666 m, v = 1.65 m/s, Dcon = 1300 mm, D = 1900 mm, Hs = 74 m, a = 800 m/s, and ROL = 2.5), while the down-surge governs in case b (f = 0.009, L = 6800 m, v = 2.16 m/s, Dcon = 700 mm, D = 1070 mm, Hs = 12.5 m, a = 1000 m/s, and ROL = 1). Where, a = pressure wave speed, v = flow velocity, and ROL is the ratio between head loss in the bypass pipe to surge tank and the head loss in outlet pipe from surge tank. In the deterministic solution of the surge vessel problem, the full water hammer equations with their boundary conditions, as explained above, are solved assuming an initial air volume. The final and optimum volume of the surge tank is equal to the calculated expanded air volume in addition to an extra 10% (Larock, Jeppson, and Watters 1999). This would provide safety against possible emptying of the vessel during down-surges, and would provide the pipeline with the required pressurized water to compensate for these down-surges. The pressure head profile along the pipeline is calculated following pump failure and checked versus the allowable upand down-surge head limits; Hmax ‡1:4Hpump and Hmin † 3m. Normally, the correct and most economical vessel volume that satisfies the pressure limits would not be available from the previous problem. Thus, further iterations would be required to reach the optimum vessel size (Jung and Karney 2006,; Fathi, Haghighipour, and Samani 2013). The exact number of iterations to reach the optimum solution is variable and 742 A. M. A. SATTAR ET AL. changes according to the experience of the user and how close the initial guess is. In our work, we needed – in many cases – 14 and 16 iterations to reach the optimum solution. In some other few cases it took us only four and six iterations. Table 2 shows examples of change in vessel volume with various iterations. When down-surge occurs in a pipeline, such as in case (b), the water is forced to exit the surge vessel at a high rate to compensate for the pressure loss created in the pipe and thus the air inside the vessel is largely expanded. The volume of the expanded air is larger than the original air volume, and the total vessel volume has to accommodate it to avoid draining and releasing air in the pipeline. Therefore, the initial air volume of the surge vessel in case (b) is 50 m3, while the final expanded air volume is 160 m3. On the other hand, in the case of maximum pressure surge, such as in case (a), the water column is accelerated to the vessel where the air inside it acts as a cushion for the up-surge causing a reduction in the air volume. Following this decrease in the air volume, it is further expanded in the last part of the surge cycle to push the attenuated surge wave back to the pipeline. Similar to the previous case, the expanded air volume is larger than the initial volume. In case (a), the initial air volume is 170 m3, while the final expanded air volume is 270 m3. Vessel outflow throttling can be achieved by decreasing the diameter of the connecting pipe Dcon with respect to the main pipe diameter with throttling ratio defined as D/Dcon. Figure 3 shows the effect of flow throttling on surge vessel flow, gas Table 2. Change of vessel volume along various iterations. Case (a) (b) Iteration # 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 "oair (m3) 10 50 100 150 170 5 10 20 30 50 Hmax =Hpump 2.47 1.99 1.66 1.45 1.4 2.72 2.18 1.55 1.19 1 Hmin (m) −12.00 −10.00 −3.10 −0.60 0.0 −8.76 −10.00 −3.74 −6.25 −3.00 "fair (m3) 190 120 180 250 270 58 73 95 120 160 volume, and gas head in the case of limiting the up-surge (case a). It is clearly shown that increasing the throttling ratio decelerates the oscillating water column to the pipeline. When the throttling ratio increased from 1 to 1.4, the maximum flow from the vessel was delayed by around 10s (Figure 3(a)). This delay was accompanied by a reduction in the vessel flow rate that is clearly shown at the point of maximum flow which coincides with the initial gas volume. The maximum gas volume, which coincides with the point of zero flow from the vessel, has decreased from 280 m3 to 260 m3 by increasing the throttling ratio from 1 to 2 as shown in Figure 3(b). Thus, a throttling ratio of 2 reduced the expanded gas volume inside the surge vessel at the point of zero flow and this led to a more economic vessel design in case (a). A similar delay in timing and reduction of magnitude of maximum peak air head is observed in Figure 3(c). However, the same throttling ratio of 2 was found to be critical in the case of limiting down-surges as in case (b). The increase of throttling ratio reduced the amount of flow coming out of the vessel making it not sufficiently quick – in many cases – to compensate for the pressure loss in the pipeline causing undesirable low pressures that approached the vapor pressure. Figure 3(d,e) shows the maximum and minimum pressure head profiles in the case of pump failure for case (b) compared with steady state HGL; throttling ratios are varied from 1.4 to 2. Using the surge vessel, the maximum upsurge was controlled to drop and be very close to the steady-state HGL. It is observed that the minimum head dropped below the steady state HGL at the high end-point of the pipeline with a drop value of around −8 m, which is not desirable. Thus, from Figure 3(e) and from practice, it was found that a throttling ratio of 1.4 would lead to an economic surge vessel size in the case of limiting up-surge and maintain safe pressure border in case of limiting down-surges. Therefore, an outflow throttling ratio of 1.4 is used for all cases in this study. On the other hand, further reduction in the size of the vessel can be achieved by throttling the inflow to the vessel in case of only limiting the up-surge transients. The up-surge is damped by the air cushioning inside the vessel beside the additional friction in the bypass throttled inflow pipe. This results in less reverse flow into Figure 3. Effect of outflow throttling on surge vessel, (a) flow, (b) gas volume, (c) air head, (d) maximum pressure transient, (e) minimum pressure transient, and (f) inflow throttling on maximum upsurge head. URBAN WATER JOURNAL the vessel and subsequent overpressures. A practical and economical approach is to set the inlet head loss (through the bypass pipe) to 2.5 times the outlet head loss, thus, the ratio between these two losses (ROL) is taken as 2.5 in this study only in cases of limiting up-surge transients, and 1 otherwise. As stated, vessel inlet/outlet throttling has an impact on the vessel size in cases of maximum up- and down-surges. Increasing throttling can reduce the size of the vessel and lead to a more economical design. However, the relation between the increase in throttling and the reduced vessel size is not linear. The vessel size reduces with the increase in throttling until a specific throttling is reached; afterwards, the vessel size increases. This is obvious in Figure 3(f) showing a variation of maximum upsurge head versus inflow throttling, represented by the ROL. The surge vessel’s size is reduced by an average of 10–15% at the inflection point. The ROL at the inflection point is known as the optimum throttling as stated by Graze and Horlacher (1986). Model setup – stochastic runs The initial discharge is set based on the intersection of the system curve (depending on system parameters) and the pump curve (depending on the chosen pump). Therefore, varying discharge in this work is equivalent to the random choice of a new pump for every simulation. To develop the new equation, the velocity is used instead of discharge as input variable to go along with the previous research on sizing air vessels, which presented the initial vessel air volume as a function of the initial steady-state velocity, e.g. AvL/a in Graze and Horlacher (1982) and Av2L/Hs in Stephenson (2002). To perform stochastic analysis for the problem of surge protection of rising pumping mains following power failure, a wide range of input parameters has to be considered. The initial steady state velocity v is varied from 0.5 m/s to a maximum of 2.5 m/s, static head is varied from 5 m to 80 m, and wave speed is varied from 250 m/s to 1400 m/s. All possible pipe materials from plastic to steel are considered with a DarcyWeisbach friction coefficient from 0.008 to 0.05. Pipeline length L is varied from 200 m to 15 km and pipeline diameter from 200 mm to 2000 mm. Only discrete commercial values of the pipeline diameter are allowed. Pump specific speeds are calculated based on the pump flow and head. The calculated specific speed ranges from 600 rpm to 7800 rpm covering a wide range of radial-flow and mixed-flow pumps. In order to generate enough cases to represent various operating conditions, and in light of the absence of confirmed distributions for various input parameters controlling the surge vessel size on pumping mains, the input parameters are represented by assuming an equal probability of each sample (Sattar 2016); this is achieved by assuming a uniform probability density function bounded by the range of parameters specified. To start generating various cases (realizations) using MCS, a random combination of the chosen input parameters (each sampled from uniform probability distributions) was prepared. This random combination of parameters is used as input for the numerical model to run a single MOC-deterministic run. Using multiple iterations as discussed before, the initial and final expanded volumes of the air were determined for this single 743 case. This process was repeated for 2000 deterministic simulations using new random parameter combinations for each run. The accuracy of the stochastic analysis using the MCS depends normally on the number of MC realizations performed, which is greatly dependent on the specific physical problem. Choice of number of MC realizations is made by monitoring the variance of a selected target output. For a small number of MC realizations, the variance of the output usually shows fluctuations until a certain number of realizations is reached, where the variance fluctuations diminish and variance reaches a steady state. Previous research reported from 2000 to 10,000 realizations for water hammer probabilistic problems using MCS (Sattar 2016). In this study, the variance of the surge vessel’s initial air volume, and final expanded volume were monitored for the required number of MC realizations. It was observed that the variance started to reach a steady state value after 1500 MC realizations. Thus, the chosen number of realizations (2000) is statistically sufficient for a good solution and fair representation for various possible parameter combinations. On studying the probability distributions of the calculated initial and expanded air volumes, it was shown that the calculated vessel volumes followed a generalized extreme distribution. Most of the MC realizations had initial gas volumes ≤ 165 m3, and an expanded air volume ≤ 245 m3. Very few realizations were calculated with an expanded air volume > 285 m3. From a practical point of view, such large tanks are completely uneconomic – and sometimes impossible – to construct and practitioners use multiple tanks in such cases. In this case, a required large vessel volume is divided equally over multiple vessels in a series reaching to an appropriate volume of one vessel ≤ 100 m3. A similar pattern is observed when plotting the probability distribution of the absolute calculated initial and expanded air volumes in a non-dimensional form expressed by Graze and Horlacher (1986) S’, such that S0 ¼ "oair a=nALv. Parameters selection From previous research and practical experience, the initial volume of air in the surge vessel can be assumed to be a function of the pipeline and flow characteristics, as follows (Stephenson 2002): "oair ¼ Fðv; a; D; Dcon ; L; f ; Hs ; Hmax ; Hmin ; ROLÞ (8) The pump-motor combined rotating inertia is a dependent variable that is a function of Q and H, both of which are sampled input variables. Thus, the effect of the inertia is implicitly reflected in the calculated initial and expanded air volumes. On the other hand, the final expanded air volume is a function of the same parameters as Equation (8) in addition to the initial air volume as follows: "fair ¼ F v; a; D; Dcon ; L; f ; Hs ; Hmax ; Hmin ; "oair (9) In this study, Hmax has been limited to 1.4Hpump, and Hmin has been limited to a pressure head of −3 m. The importance of the other controlling parameters and their contribution to the initial and the expanded air volume have not been discussed in detail before. Therefore, the LSL is used, as discussed before, 744 A. M. A. SATTAR ET AL. to rank the pipeline and flow parameters according to their influence on the surge vessel’s size in rising mains due to pump failure problems. It was found that the initial air volume "oair is most sensitive to the pipeline diameter with 90% influence, followed by the static head Hs with about 5%. Other input parameters such as velocity and pipe length had a lower contribution to the initial air volume with about 1% influence, while the wave velocity yielded the least influence on "oair with 0.02%. On the other hand, the static head Hs had a larger impact on "fair than on "oair with a value of 36%. It was found that the initial air volume "oair had the largest impact on choice of final expanded volume "fair with a 64% influence. Other parameters, such as a, L, v, and f had almost no influence on the expanded air volume as their effect has been accounted for in the initial air volume "oair . Assuming the inflow throttling or ROL as an output variable, which is a function of the above variables, and using the LSL to determine parameter influence. Results showed that ROL had the least dependency on the pipeline diameter with 12% influence compared to the pipeline length and static head with the highest influence of 36%. These two parameters together determine the condition of the critical pressure surge. In the case of a low static head and long pipeline, severe down-surges are expected and need to have no inflow throttling, (ROL of 1); for other cases, the upsurges govern the vessel design and a ROL of 2.5 or more needs to be specified. Developed GEP models GEP-based models were developed using combinations of the most influential parameters on initial air volume, expanded air volume, and ROL chosen based on score inSVi . No strong correlation or interdependency was found among the predictor variables, thus eliminating the problems that could arise in the analysis from exaggerating the strength of the relations between variables. The database was randomly divided into training and testing subsets. Several combinations were considered and the selection was made such that the main Figure 4. Design flowchart for optimum vessel throttling and corresponding size. statistical descriptive parameters (mean and standard deviation) of both the training and testing subsets were consistent. Of the 2000 values, 1500 (75%) were used to develop the models, and 500 (25%) were used to test the models developed by using the GEP. Using the optimum parameter settings for the GEP algorithm (mutation rate of 0.05, inversion rate of 0.1, transposition rate of 1, head size of 3, and number of chromosomes of 30), the following GEP models for the prediction of initial and expanded air volumes, and ROL had high scores and low prediction errors. Figure 4 shows a flow chart for the developed GEP model for the preliminary sizing of surge vessels. The developed ROL-GEP models for inlet/bypass throttling assume an average inlet velocity to the surge vessel of less than 15 m/s to avoid abrasive damage to the vessel (Stephenson 1989). The optimum throttling value and corresponding initial and final vessel volumes were recorded and, all together, used to develop new GEP models for preliminary optimum throttling ratios and corresponding vessel sizes. Table 3 shows a general statistical overview for the performance of the developed GEP models for prediction of the initial and the expanded air volume. The GEP models for "oair and "fair performed well for both the training and testing datasets, with an average coefficient of determination, R2 of 0.94 for training and of 0.93 for testing datasets. The error measures, root mean square error (RMSE) and root absolute error (RAE), show low values for training and testing datasets. The RMSE for "oair is 14.15 and 6.11, respectively for training and testing sets, while the RAE is 0.14 and 0.15, respectively for training and testing sets. The RMSE for "fair is 56.87 and 50.46, respectively for training and testing sets, while the RAE is 0.18 and 0.17, respectively for training and testing sets. Similar trends are observed in the RAE calculated values. On the other hand, the coefficient of efficiency (Esn) and the index of agreement (Dag) showed very good values with average values of 0.95 and 0.97 for training and testing subset. While the R2 for the ROL model was lower than that for the initial and expanded air volumes with a value of 0.6, the RAE was low with an average value of 0.23 and the Esn and Dag indices showed very good values with an average of 0.88. Statistics for the ROL-GEP model showed superior URBAN WATER JOURNAL 745 Table 3. Statistical performance and error analysis of developed GEP prediction models. Model Graze and Horlacher (1982) Stephenson (2002) GEP-"oair GEP-"fair ROL Data Partitioning NA NA Train Test Train Test Train Test RMSE RAE Esn Dag Mean prediction error Width of error band 95% prediction error interval R2 0.49 209.58 1.16 −1.85 0.36 +0.02 þ = 0.78 +0.03 to +34 0.77 71.11 0.46 0.67 0.84 −0.33 þ = 0.69 +0.09 to +51 0.94 14.15 0.14 0.94 0.97 0.92 6.11 0.15 0.92 0.98 −0.01 þ = 0.26 +0.20 to +2.4 0.94 56.87 0.18 0.94 0.97 0.95 50.46 0.17 0.95 0.99 −0.02 þ = 0.20 +0.42 to +1.93 0.60 1 0.237 0.53 0.89 0.59 1 0.242 0.54 0.88 −0.04 þ = 0.26 +0.33 to +3.58 performance when compared to the ANN model developed by Ramalingam and Lingireddy (2014), which had an R2 of 0.3. The Q-Q plot in Figure 5 shows the optimized "oair and "fair using the numerical MOC code and that predicted by the GEP models. The figure shows the quality of prediction of the GEP models when applied to training and testing datasets. It is clear that the GEP models for "oair and "fair showed excellent agreement with slight errors and with no significant over- or under-predictions. Comparison of the GEP models and existing design charts In literature, two classical charts have been developed for the prediction of the initial volume of air in surge vessel on pumping mains: Graze and Horlacher (1982) and Stephenson (2002). These charts are considered to be classical pillars for benchmarking models for the preliminary sizing of surge vessels on rising mains. However, they have been developed using the rigid column theory and considered pump failure as sudden Figure 5. MOC-optimized "oair and "fair versus that predicted by the GEP-model, and previous design charts. Table 4. Comparison between Graze and Horlacher (1982) and Stephenson (2002) charts, and the developed GEP model. Parameter Theory Graze and Horlacher (1982) Rigid column Pump Sudden valve closure Throttling ROL n Hmax Hmin "oair a S0 ¼ nALv Hmax Hs av=g Hmin Hs av=g Inflow only 2.5 1, 1.2, 1.4 Various Various 0 to 160 GEP-"oair Full elastic Gradual valve closure based on pump inertia Inflow & outflow 2.5 1.2 1.4Hpump –3 m 0 to 150 0.1 to 1 0.02 to 1.5 –0.8 to – 0.1 –2 to – 0.02 Parameter S0 ¼ "oair gðHs þHBar Þ ALv 2 Hmax þHBar Hs þHBar Hmin þHBar Hs þHBar Stephenson (2002) Incompressible flow Sudden valve closure Inflow & outflow 2.5 1.2 Various Various 0.5 to 8 GEP-"oair Full elastic Gradual valve closure based on pump inertia Inflow & outflow 2.5 1.2 1.4Hpump –3 m 0.1 to 10 1 to 2.2 1.1 to 2.5 0.2 to 0.7 0.1 to 0.4 746 A. M. A. SATTAR ET AL. valve closure rather than pump-inertia-dependent gradual closure with other simplifications. Table 4 shows a general comparison between the charts and the developed GEP model for the vessel initial air volume. The table also shows the Graze and Stephenson non-dimensional parameters computed for the GEP model based on the adopted parameter range. The range of non-dimensional variables is very close for both the GEP models and traditional charts. The developed GEP models, are developed based on data samples from distributions spanning assumed practical ranges for various problem parameters. While it will be unfair to compare the GEP model based on the full elastic analysis to the charts that are based on rigid column theory, the comparison values shall provide rough benchmarking for the GEP models. It is to be noted that inlet throttling is considered in both charts with ROL 2.5, while Graze and Horlacher (1982) charts did not consider outflow throttling. The Graze and Horlacher (1982) model yielded the lowest R2 with a value of 0.49 compared to 0.77 from the Stephenson (2002) model. This is much lower than that for the GEP model for that had a higher R2 of 0.94. Thus, the available design charts are capable of representing only 50% to 70% of the data. The RMSE for these design charts, when applied on the optimized initial air volume, showed extremely high values ranging from 70 to 210, which are two to five orders of magnitude higher than those of the GEP model. These results are shown clearly in the Q-Q plot of the MOC optimized initial air volume versus that predicted by the available design charts (Figure 5). Both of the Graze and Horlacher (1982) and Stephenson (2002) models show wide scatter around line of perfect fit, with large underestimation errors for the Stephenson (2002) model; this is consistent with the reported low R2 values. Moreover, the results of Esn and Dag indices for both available design charts were low and unacceptable, ranging from −1.85 to 0.3. The advantage of using the developed GEP model is clearly shown through the low errors in predictions compared to extremely high errors using the available design charts. This confirms that more economical surge vessel sizes can be obtained using the developed GEP models compared to the design charts from literature. Testing and error analysis of the GEP models As discussed before, the performance of developed models on testing data subsets can be used to test their prediction capability. Models have to satisfy some or all of the testing criteria. The gradients of the regression line for the predicted versus observed initial and expanded air volumes were close to 1 and within the recommended ranges of 0.85 to 1.15. This was accompanied by good values for the coefficient of determination for the regression line with average values of −0.10. The condition of cross testing was also satisfied for all developed models. This shows a good and accepted performance of the developed GEP models against the test dataset. The calculated errors in predictions of the developed GEP model as compared to those of previous researchers are presented in Table 3. The error analysis is applied to the complete air volume dataset used in this study. Table 3 shows the mean prediction errors of the various models, the width of the error band and the 95% prediction interval error. Since all previous models and charts did not include the calculation of the expanded air volume, the comparison is made mainly with the initial air volume. It is observed that the developed GEP models for "oair and "fair had an absolute mean prediction error much lower than those of the design chart models of Graze and Horlacher (1982) and Stephenson (2002), with an average value of 0.02. The design chart models had higher mean prediction errors with four orders of magnitude larger than that of the GEP model for "oair . The deviation of prediction error for the GEP models was 1/4 that of the available empirical models with values of 0.10 and 0.4, respectively. According to the mean prediction error, the GEP models for "oair and "fair slightly underpredicted the initial air volume and the expanded vessel volume. This was also observed in the predictions of Stephenson (2002), but with higher (30 orders of magnitude) under-predictions. The Graze and Horlacher (1982) model had an opposite trend of over prediction with a high error, around 40 orders of magnitude more than the GEP model. The error band width for the GEP models are similar and had values of þ = 0.26, and þ = 0.20 for "oair and "fair , respectively, which is much lower than that of existing charts reaching to þ = 0.78. The GEP models, had the lowest mean prediction error and the smallest error bands of all the compared models. Parametric analysis of the GEP models This section is intended to show the robustness of the developed GEP models and how they provide correct physical trends for the predicted vessel initial air volume versus input parameters as confirmed and shown in previous research. Figure 6 shows the initial gas volume as calculated by the GEP and from Graze and Horlacher (1982) and Stephenson (2002) charts. The initial vessel gas volume is plotted against the pipeline diameter and steady state flow velocity. It is observed that the increase in pipeline diameter causes an associated increase in the surge vessel volume. For pipe diameter ≤700 mm, the increase in vessel initial air volume is minimal. However, for pipe diameters ≥700 mm, the initial vessel air volume required increased with a rising gradient. This behavior is observed for the GEP model and previous design charts. Stephenson (2002) and Graze and Horlacher (1982) charts gave close values for the initial gas volume less than that calculated by the GEP model. This behavior of an increase in initial air volume with the increase in pipe diameter has been confirmed by various researchers (e.g. Chaudhry 2014). When the pipe diameter increases, the sub-atmospheric pressure liquid-region created, following the pump trip, will increase, requiring more water to be drawn from the surge vessel to compensate for low pressure, and this means a larger initial gas volume and eventually a larger expanded air volume. Stephenson (2002) provided a descriptive equation for the volume of the sub-atmospheric pressure liquid-region created due to pump failure. The equation was deduced from the incompressible flow model and relates the region volume with the pipe area in a direct proportional relationship. The same equation presented by Stephenson (2002) relates the sub-atmospheric pressure liquidregion volume with the steady state pipeline velocity, which confirms the trend in Figure 5 for the GEP model and previous charts. However, the GEP model had a smaller exponent for the URBAN WATER JOURNAL 747 Figure 6. MOC-optimized "oair versus D, v, Hs, and pipe friction as predicted by the GEP and the previous design charts. velocity than that of the Stephenson (2002) equation, with 0.33 and 2 for the GEP and Stephenson (2002), respectively. Comparing the results of the incompressible flow equations and the full elastic water hammer equations, Stephenson (2002) reported an overestimation for the incompressible flow theory in the calculation of the initial vessel gas volume. On the other hand, the variation of the initial gas volume with friction head loss and static head is shown in Figure 6. Again, the predictions of the GEP model were in harmony with the design charts of Stephenson (2002) and Graze and Horlacher (1982) and showed the same trend. The increase in the system static head decreased the possibility of the down-surge to go below the pipeline HGL. Thus, fewer gas volumes are needed for the compensation of sub-atmospheric pressure in the pipeline. On the other hand, Ruus and Karney (1988) reported that the increase in pipeline friction would reduce an up-surge, such that it is very likely that the up-surge may never reach the initial HGL. This behavior is clearly shown in Figure 6 for the GEP model and other design charts, where predictions for the initial gas volume decreased with the increase in friction. The predictions of the GEP model were close to those of Stephenson (2002) whose model showed less dependency of the initial air volume on pipe friction compared to the Graze and Horlacher (1982) model. When the pipe friction losses increased by 100% (from 10 m to 20 m), the initial air volume decreased by 10%, and 15% for Stephenson (2002) and the GEP models respectively. While, in the Graze and Horlacher (1982) model, the initial gas volume decreased by a pronounced value of 60%. Conclusions This research has presented a novel and simple approximate model for estimation of the surge vessel size on rising mains. The model included three equations for the prediction of the initial air volume, the final expanded air volume in surge vessel, and the requirement for inflow throttling. The developed models outperformed the exiting design charts in all statistical performance indicators, e.g. a high coefficient of determination of 0.94 and an error four orders of magnitude less. The vessel’s initial gas volume is found to be affected mostly by the pipe diameter and the pipeline static head, while the final expanded volume depended on the initial gas volume and the static head. These developed models can serve as a basis for surge vessel selection and sizing in a preliminary study phase, and can complement complex commercial modeling software in the exact design phase. Nevertheless, transient analysis is intrinsically complex, it is always recommended to check any approximate solution for reasonableness prior to usage. List of notations ANN GEP HGL LSL MOC MCS RAE ROL RMSE a As Closs Dag Dcon D Esn f hloss Artificial neural network Gene expression programming Hydraulic grade line Least square linearization, Method of characteristics, Monte Carlo simulation, Root absolute error, Ratio of losses, Root mean square error, Wave speed, The cross-sectional area of the surge vessel, Coefficient of orifice head loss, Index of agreement, Diameter of connecting pipe, Pipe line diameter, Coefficient of efficiency, Darcy friction coefficient, Head loss for flow through the orifice, 748 A. M. A. SATTAR ET AL. Hbar Ha;b o Hair Hmin, max Hs I L m mVi n N P(ij) Q Qpump Qs R2 S’ t Tj "oair "fair v wi zst η vi 2 δvi Atmospheric pressure, Piezometric head a, b are two arbitrary points before and after the surge vessel, Steady state air head, Down-surge and up-surge, Static head, Pump inertia, Pipeline length from pump to reservoir, Exponent with value of 1 for isothermal and 1.4 for adiabatic expansion of air, Mean value of parameter i of all the random samples, Number of samples, Pump rotational speed, Value predicted by the program i for fitness case j, Discharge in pipeline, Pump operating flow, Flow to the surge vessel, Coefficient of determination, Non-dimensional form expressed by Graze and Horlacher (1986) Time step along the solution time domain, Target value for fitness case j, Steady state air volume at surge vessel, Expanded volume of the air, Flow velocity, The regression coefficient, Height of the liquid in the tank, Pump efficiency and taken as 0.85, Sample of parameter I, Variance of the calculated difference Δvi , Disclosure statement No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors. ORCID Ahmed M. A. Sattar http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2608-6979 References Chaudhry, M. H. 2014. Applied Hydraulic Transients. 3rd ed. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold. De Martino, G. D., and N. Fontana. 2012. “Simplified Approach for the Optimal Sizing of Throttled Air Chambers.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 138: 1101–1109. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)HY.1943-7900.0000633. De Sparre, M. 1911. “Des coups de bélier dans les conduites.” La Houille Blanche, no. 10: 257–263 (in French). El Hakeem, M., and A. M. Sattar. 2015. “An Entrainment Model for Non-Uniform Sediment.” Earth Surface Processes and Landforms 40: 1216–1226. doi:10.1002/esp.3715. Evangelisti, G. 1938. “Il colpo d’ariete nelle condotte elevatorie munite di camera d’aria.” L’Energia Elettrica 600–613. Evans, W. E., and C. C. Crawford. 1954. “Design Charts for Air Chambers on Pump Lines.” Transactions of American Society of Civil Engineers 119: 1025–1045. Fathi, M., S. Haghighipour, and M. Samani. 2013. “Design-Variable Optimization of Hydropower Tunnels and Surge Tanks Using a Genetic Algorithm.” Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 139 (2): 200–208. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)WR.1943-5452.0000243. Ghorbanian, V., B. Karney, and Y. Guo. 2016. “Pressure Standards in Water Distribution Systems: Reflection on Current Practice with Consideration of Some Unresolved Issues.” Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 142 (8): 04016023. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)WR.1943-5452.0000665. Graze, H. R., and H. B. Horlacher. 1982. “Air Chamber Design Charts.” In Proceedings of the 8th Australian Fluid Mechanics Conference, 14–18. NewCastle, UK. Graze, H. R., and H. B. Horlacher. 1986. “Design Charts for Throttled (By-pass) Air Chambers.” In Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Pressure Surges, 309–322. Hannover: BHRA. Graze, H. R., and H. B. Horlacher (1989). “Design of Optimum Sized Air Cushion Surge Chambers.” In Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Pressure Surges, 383–397. Cambridge: BHRA. Izquierdo, J., P. A. Lopez, G. Lopez, F. J. Martinez, and R. Perez. 2006. “Encapsulation of Air Vessel Design in a Neural Network.” Applied Mathematical Modelling 30 (5): 395–405. doi:10.1016/j. apm.2005.11.010. Jung, B., and B. Karney. 2006. “Hydraulic Optimization of Transient Protection Devices Using GA and PSO Approaches.” Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 132 (1): 44–52. doi:10.1061/(ASCE) 0733-9496(2006)132:1(44). Knapp, R. T., and P. Calif. 1937. “Complete Characteristics. Of Centrifugal Pumps and Their Use in the Prediction of Transient Behavior.” Transaction of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers 59: 683–689. Larock, B. E., R. W. Jeppson, and G. Z. Watters. 1999. Hydraulics of Pipeline Systems. Boca Raton, FL: CRC. Najafzadeh, M., and A. M. Sattar. 2015. “Neuro-Fuzzy GMDH Approach to Predict Longitudinal Dispersion in Water Networks.” Water Resources Management 29: 2205–2219. doi:10.1007/s11269-015-0936-8. Radi, A., and K. Poli. 2002. “Genetic Programming Discovers Efficient Learning Rules for the Hidden and Output Layers of Feedforward Neural Networks.” Lecture Notes in Computer Science 1598: 120–134. Ramalingam, D., and S. Lingireddy. 2014. “Neural Network-derived Heuristic Framework for Sizing Surge Vessels.” Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 140: 678–692. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)WR.19435452.0000371. Ruus, E., and B. Karney. 1988. “Discussion of Effect of Valve Closure Schedule on Water Hammer by P. H. Azoury, M. Baasiri, and H. Najm, 112(10).” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 114 (5): 562–563. doi:10.1061/(ASCE) 0733-9429(1988)114:5(562). Sattar, A. M. 2014a. “Gene Expression Models for the Prediction of Longitudinal Dispersion Coefficients in Transitional and Turbulent Pipe Flow.” Journal of Pipeline Systems Engineering and Practice 5 (1): 04013011. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)PS.1949-1204.0000153. Sattar, A. M. 2014b. “Gene Expression Models for Prediction of Dam Breach Parameters.” Journal of Hydroinformatics 16 (3): 550–571. doi:10.2166/ hydro.2013.084. Sattar, A. M. 2016. “A Probabilistic Projection of the Transient Flow Equations with Random System Parameters and Internal Boundary Conditions.” Journal of Hydraulic Research 54 (3): 342–359. doi:10.1080/ 00221686.2016.1140682. Sattar, A. M., and B. Gharabaghi. 2015. “Gene Expression Models for Prediction of Longitudinal Dispersion Coefficient in Streams.” Journal of Hydrology 524: 587–596. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2015.03.016. Stephenson, D. 1989. Pipeline Design for Water Engineers. 3rd ed. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Stephenson, D. 2002. “Simple Guide for Design of Air Vessels for Water Hammer Protection of Pumping Lines.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 128: 792–797. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9429(2002)128:8(792). Sun, Q., Y. Wu, Y. Xu, and T. Jang. 2016. “Optimal Sizing of an Air Vessel in a Long- Distance Water-Supply Pumping System Using the SQP Method.” Journal of Pipeline Systems Engineering and Practice 7: 05016001. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)PS.1949–1204.0000236. Thorley, A. R. D. 2004. Fluid Transients in Pipeline Systems. 2nd ed. St Edmunds, UK: Professional Engineering Publishing. Wang, R., Z. Wang, X. Wang, H. Yang, and J. Sun. 2014. “Pipe Burst Risk State Assessment and Classification Based on Water Hammer Analysis for Water Supply Networks.” Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 140 (6): 04014005. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)WR.19435452.0000404.
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )