Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jlp Dynamic model for a heat exchanger tube rupture discharging a high-pressure flashing liquid into a low-pressure liquid-filled shell C.J. Ennis, K.K. Botros*, C. Patel NOVA Chemicals Corporation, 2928 - 16 Street N.E., Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2E 7K7 a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t Article history: Received 19 July 2010 Received in revised form 19 November 2010 Accepted 19 November 2010 Shell-tube type heat exchangers are often used to exchange heat between a high-pressure fluid and a lowpressure fluid. The pressure difference between these two fluids could be significantly high. In the event of a partial or full rupture of a tube, a problem may arise in that a transient pressure rise phenomenon could occur due to the flashing of the high-pressure sub-cooled fluid in the tube into the low-pressure shell, which may cause the shell to rupture with subsequent damage to equipment. This paper presents a dynamic model to describe the transient phenomenon occurring on the shell side following various scenarios of tube rupture. The spatial and temporal aspects of the flow transients along the pressure safety valve riser are accounted for by solving the one-dimensional continuity and momentum hyperbolic partial differential equations as applied to the liquid-filled riser. The dynamics of the attached piping system are also accounted for via two mechanistic models; the first is based on an inertial-resistive assumption of the fluids in this system, while the other is based on the assumption of anechoic perturbations passing through a long section of the attached piping. The latter is justified in cases where the attached piping is long enough such that reflections from the downstream end do not interfere with transients occurring in the shell during the initial phase of fluid flashing into the shell side following rupture. The various phases of this phenomenon are described, however the paper focuses on the initial phase of the phenomenon during which shell overpressure may be encountered. The model is applied to two ethylene heaters in tandem; the first uses propylene on the shell side to heat the ethylene on the tube side, while the second uses methanol, also on the shell side. The ratio between the shell design pressure to the tube design pressure in these two heaters are 0.169 and 0.154, respectively, hence the motivation to accurately model the transients involved in this phenomenon. The practical aspects and discussion around techniques to alleviate potential overpressure scenarios due to tube rupture are emphasized throughout the paper. Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Heat exchangers Tube rupture API 520 Pressure safety valve Flashing liquids Risk 1. Introduction Shell-tube type heat exchangers are often used to exchange heat between a high-pressure fluid and a low-pressure fluid, and the pressure difference between the two fluids could be significantly high. When the tube side contains a high-pressure flashing fluid or vapour and the shell side contains a low-pressure liquid (e.g., cooling water exchangers, or ethylene heat exchangers), a problem may arise in that if a partial or full tube rupture occurs, the relief device, such as a pressure safety valve (PSV) mounted on the shell side, would have to pass fluid at a ‘volumetric’ rate equal to the flashing fluids (or vapour) from the high-pressure tube side. This could cause a sudden rise in pressure due to the dynamic interaction between the liquid-filled shell and the relief device, particularly if * Corresponding author. Tel.: þ1 403 250 4790; fax: þ1 403 291 3208. E-mail address: botrosk@novachem.com (K.K. Botros). 0950-4230/$ e see front matter Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.jlp.2010.11.004 the relief device is not able to react quickly. The problem is accentuated when the relief device is not mounted directly on the exchanger shell. For example, if a pipe (riser) is installed to connect the shell to the relief device at a higher elevation away from the shell, transients along the riser itself can occur, which in turn, can cause fluttering of the PSV in response to such transients. Incidents of heat exchanger tube rupture causing damage to equipment and subsequent costly plant shutdown due to such a phenomenon have been reported in the literature (Simpson, 1972). Often relief systems are sized to be able to handle the ‘mass’ flow from the ruptured tube as in Wong (1992), as if this flow finds its way (i.e., ‘short-circuit’) to the relief device through the liquid-filled shell as shown schematically in Fig. 1. The problem with this approach is that the relieving calculations do not account for the inertia or dynamic effects on the shell side or along the relief riser, and the concern is that the shell side may fail before the relief device can react. The American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) has established pressure limits which the shell side may not exceed. 112 C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 Nomenclature A B c Cp Dh f G g h H K k L _ m P Q r T t U area (m2) bulk modulus (Pa) speed of sound (m/s) liquid specific heat at constant pressure (J/(kg K)) hydraulic diameter (m) Darcy friction factor () mass flux (kg/(m2 s)) gravitational acceleration (m/s2) enthalpy (J/kg) pressure head (m) vessel compliance (Pa) pressure drop coefficient () tube length (m) mass flow rate (kg/s) pressure (Pa) volume flow rate (m3/s) shell radius (m) temperature (K) time (s) velocity (m/s) Under Section VIII of the ASME (2010) code, the maximum shell pressure is 110% of the Maximum Allowable Working Pressure (MAWP). In meeting this code, the API (American Petroleum Institute) recommends that a complete tube failure be considered as a viable contingency in cases where the design pressure of the low-pressure shell side is less than two-thirds of the design pressure of the high-pressure side in API (1997). This ‘two-thirds’ value came about because the older practice was to hydrostatically test the pressure equipment (the shell in this case) at a pressure equal to 1.5 times its design pressure. Currently, the practice is to hydrostatically test at only 1.3 times the design pressure, hence the ‘two-thirds’ threshold value must be corrected to ‘ten-thirteenths’. Therefore, in the case of heat exchangers, if the design pressure of the shell side is less than ten-thirteenths the design pressure of the tube, a pressure mismatch arises (see schematic of Fig. 2), and a process containment concern will arise with regard to possible transients and overpressure of the shell that could occur if the tube side containing a high-pressure sub-cooled fluid flashes into the shell side in the event of a tube rupture. Fowler, Herndon, and Wahrmund (1968) and Simpson (1972) predicted pressure transients in the shell of heat exchangers and accounted for the effects of attached piping systems via a shellpiping volume-average approach which did not simulate the specific volume (m3/kg) volume (m3) shell wall thickness (m) distance along the riser (m) elevation of the pipe centerline above a datum (m) pipe acoustic impedance ((Pa s)/m3) density (kg/m3) longitudinal stress (Pa) correlating parameter () stagnation condition capacitance system downstream equivalent liquid phase difference between gaseous and liquid phases gaseous phase piping system riser shell-side fluid saturation condition tube-side fluid v V WT x z Za r sl u 0 c ds e f fg g p r s sat t dynamic behavior well. Sumaria, Rovnak, Heitner, and Herber (1976) used a lumped parameter approach to account for the dynamics in the attached piping and the PSV riser pipe. While this is a better approach, it still does not account for the spatial and temporal aspects of the transients in the riser pipe. Furthermore, Sumaria addressed the conditions where the fluid on the highpressure tube side is strictly gas, i.e., with no changes of phases across the tube break. In the present paper, the fluid on the high-pressure tube side is considered to be sub-cooled liquid which could potentially flash into two phases when it is released through the tube break into the low-pressure shell side. The spatial and temporal aspects of the flow transients along the riser are fully accounted for by solving the one-dimensional hyperbolic partial differential equations of the conservation of mass and momentum as applied to the liquid-filled riser. The dynamics of the attached piping system are accounted for with two models; the first is based on an inertial-resistive assumption, while the other is based on anechoic perturbations along the attached piping. The latter is justified in cases where the attached piping is long enough such that reflections from the downstream piping end do not interfere with transients occurring in the shell during the initial time when the shell side could become Shell Design Pressure (Ps-design ) < 10/13 Pt-design PSV Tube fluid flashing into shell due to tube rupture Heating Fluid (Outlet) Riser Heated Fluid (Outlet) Fluid to be heated (Inlet) Tube Shell fluid Shell Fig. 1. Common PSV sizing based on flashing fluid issuing from a ruptured tube. Heating Fluid (Inlet) Tube Design Pressure = Pt-design Fig. 2. Shell-tube heat exchanger with a mismatch of design pressures. C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 over-pressured. The various phases of this phenomenon are described in the next Section, however the paper focuses only on the first two phases. 2. Description of the dynamic phenomenon following tube rupture It is important to recognize four distinct phases of a tube rupture scenario where a high-pressure sub-cooled flashing liquid is released into a liquid-filled low-pressure heat exchanger shell. These four phases are schematically depicted in Fig. 3. Phase I is the most important phase and is the subject of this paper. Upon partial or full tube rupture, the flashing fluid (vapour and liquid) from the high-pressure tube side will cause the pressure on the shell side to increase. The rate of pressure increase as well as the maximum pressure reached depends on the following parameters: i) Rupture scenario and rupture opening area. ii) Thermodynamics and mass flux of the fluid released through the rupture opening. iii) Adiabatic flashing characteristics of the high-pressure fluid into the low-pressure shell. iv) Capacity of the relief device to relieve the liquid on the shell side. v) Riser size, length and elevation above the exchanger shell. vi) Shell volume, compliance, and the characteristics of the attached piping system. vii) Initial pressure of the liquid-filled shell in relation to the set pressure of the relief device. The above parameters are accounted for with the governing equations which will be described in the next Section. When the pressure on the shell side is relieved via the relief device, typically the pressure drops quickly depending on the combination of fluids in the shell at the time of relief and on the bulk modulus of the liquid on the shell side. This pressure relief marks the beginning of Phase II in Fig. 3. Phase IV is the inevitable steady state condition, where the mass flow of the high-pressure flashing fluid reaches the relief device. The final steady-state shell pressure at the end of this phase relative to the shell design pressure is also dependent on the above parameters. Phase III as shown in Fig. 3 is merely a transition between the end of Phase II where the pressure reaches its minimum, to the beginning of Phase IV where the shell pressure climbs to its final steady state condition. Shell Pressure Phase I Phase III Phase II Phase IV Shell Design Pressure Shell Test Pressure 113 3. Model governing equations 3.1. Dynamics of the tube side It is assumed that the fluid on the high-pressure tube side is primarily liquid with a certain degree of sub-cooling. Following partial or full tube rupture this fluid can flow through the break into the low-pressure shell side in either of the following two forms: i) liquid flowing through the break without phase change. ii) liquid flowing through the break with phase change due to flashing. The mass flux of this flow into the shell depends on the pressure and temperature of the tube-side fluid and on the flow path to the rupture location. If the rupture occurs at the tube sheet, one side of the break can be treated as flow through a nozzle (or an orifice) while the other side can be treated as flow through a tube of length L (which is the full tube length in the exchanger). If the rupture occurs somewhere along the span of the tube the flow through two tubes of lengths L1 and L2 (L1 þ L2 ¼ L) will contribute to the total mass flux into the shell side. The mass flux through a nozzle or an orifice is calculated through the methodology outlined in API (2000), API 520 Appendix D (Section D.2.2), which depends on the degree of sub-cooling of the high-pressure fluid relative to its saturation pressure at the inlet temperature. The mass flux is calculated under the assumption of a homogeneous equilibrium model (HEM), which was justified by Henry (1970) and Henry and Fauske (1971). The mass flux through a tube follows a slightly more complex procedure due to the effects of friction and the location along the tube where flashing may occur. In this case, the governing conservation equation for flow of flashing liquids through a tube can be written as follows (Leung & Ciolek, 1994): Mass Flux : G ¼ constant Momentum : dP þ G2 dv þ Energy : h0 ¼ h þ (1) f dL G2 v Dh 2 ¼ 0 G2 v2 Q 2 (2) (3) The above equations are applicable in the two-phase region under the assumption of a HEM. Note that the energy equation allows for heat transfer from the heating fluid to the heated fluid. This may be considered as an added complexity to the model, however, the present formulation assumes that Q ¼ 0. Solution of the above equations follows the approximate equation of state proposed by Leung and Grolmes (1988) and adopted by API 520 practices (API, 2000) in the form: v Psat ¼ u 1 þ1 P vf 0 (4) where u is a dimensionless correlating parameter given by: PSV Set Pressure Initial Pressure Before Tube Rupture Time Fig. 3. Schematic describing the phases following a tube rupture of high-pressure flashing fluid into a low-pressure shell. CP T0 Psat vfg0 u ¼ f0 vf 0 hfg0 !2 (5) Here, the properties are evaluated at saturation conditions corresponding to the inlet temperature of the fluid on the tube side. Leung and Ciolek (1994) provided a closed-form analytical integration to Eqs. (1)e(3) leading to two scenarios: choked (critical) or unchoked (subcritical) conditions. Once the mass flux (and hence the mass flow ¼ G At) is determined from the above procedure, an adiabatic flash calculation 114 C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 should be performed to determine the condition of the effluent fluid at the shell-side condition. The flash calculation should be used to determine the respective volumes of the vapour and liquid phases in the shell, as these volumes are the primary drivers for the increase in pressure on the shell side. 3.2. Dynamics of the shell side With the aid of Fig. 4, we will now consider the governing equations of the dynamics of fluids on the shell side when subjected to the influx of tube-side fluid. The incremental volume required by the flashing liquid from the tube side into the shell side is equal to: _ tg =rtg þ m _ tf =rtf dt m iii) Compressibility of the heating fluid already in the shell½Vsf =Bsf dP assuming changes in liquid pressure are isothermal (where Bsf is the isothermal bulk modulus of the shell fluid). iv) Elastic compliance of the shell material ½Vshell =Kshell dP (where Kshell is the isothermal shell compliance). v) Compressibility of the capacitance system (e.g., vessels, accumulator) attached to the shell side ½Vc =Bsf dP, where Vc is the liquid volume in the capacitance system. If there is a vapour space in this system, Vc would be the sum of the actual liquid volume plus an equivalent liquid volume Ve to account for the vapour space of volume Vsg via the following equation (Mohitpour, Botros, & Van Hardeveld, 2008): Ve ¼ Vsg (6) _ tg m rtg _ r =rsf dt m þ _ tf m (7) Fluid may also leave the shell through the attached piping system, reducing the volume by: _ p =rsf dt m dt ¼ rtf ! Vtg c2tg0 rtg Hence the net change in the volume of the fluid in the shell can be expressed as: rtg (9) ! rsf þ dt _p m ! rsf ! Vtf Vsf Vshell Vc dP þ þ þ Btf Bsf Kshell Bsf (11) or: _ tg m _ tg =rtg þ m _ r =rsf dt m _ p =rsf dt _ tf =rtf dt m m (10) _r m dt (8) ! Hence, the conservation of volume requires that: However, the fluid in the shell can leave the shell through the riser to the PSV, resulting in an incremental volume reduction equal to: rsf c2sf rsg c2sg dP ¼ dt þ _ tf m rtf _r m rsf _p m rsf Vtf Vsf Vshell Vc Vtg þ þ þ þ 2 ctg0 rtg Btf Bsf Kshell Bsf (12) This net change in volume is balanced by: Equation (12) is a dynamic relation of the change in shell pressure to the: i) Compressibility of the vapour phase from the tube fluid that has flowed into the shell side ½Vtg =ðc2tg0 rtg ÞdP assuming changes in vapour pressure are isentropic (where ctg0 is the isentropic speed of sound of the vapour phase). ii) Compressibility of the liquid phase from the tube fluid that has flowed into the shell side ½Vtf =Btf dP assuming changes in liquid pressure are adiabatic (where Btf is the adiabatic bulk modulus of the tube liquid phase). a) Pressures resulting from the influx of fluid from the tube rupture (first two terms on the numerator); b) Shell fluid flowing out of the shell via the PSV riser and the attached piping (last two terms on the numerator); c) Compressibility of the flashed fluid from the tube side in the shell (first two terms on the denominator); d) Compressibility of the shell fluid (third term on the denominator); Fig. 4. Schematic of a shell-tube heat exchanger with a tube rupture to aid with Eq. (12). C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 e) Compliance of the shell material (fourth term on the denominator); and f) Compressibility of the attached capacitance (accumulators) to the shell side (last term on the denominator). Fig. 4 shows a schematic representation to clearly illustrate the interaction between these terms. 3.3. Dynamics of the attached piping system Fig. 4 also indicates that there are three different piping systems attached to shell side: (1) A capacitance system, which could be an accumulator of the shell fluid feeding the shell-side fluid to the heat exchanger. (2) The PSV and riser. (3) The piping system which is composed of pipe sections, fittings, etc. The effect of item (1) is dealt with in Eq. (11). As for item (2), ideally, the PSV should be installed on the shell. However, a riser could be needed to connect the PSV to a relief header system. Therefore, it is important to account for the pressure/flow dynamics in the riser since the riser reacts to the shell pressure at one end and to the PSV opening/closing at the other end. The one-dimensional conservation equations describing the flow through the riser can be described as follows: 2 Continuity : vH vH csf 0 vU þU þ ¼ 0 g vx vt vx (13) Momentum : vU vU vH fUjUj þU þg þ ¼ 0 vt vx vx 2D (14) where the piezometric head H is related to the static pressure P via: P ¼ rsf gðH zÞ (15) Flow through the PSV depends on the PSV set pressure, its size (orifice area) and overpressure setting (typically 10% over the set pressure). The procedure for determining the instantaneous flow through the PSV again follows the methodology outlined in API 520 Appendix D (Section D.2.2), but applied here to the shell fluid instead of the tube fluid. Likewise, the mass flux depends on the degree of sub-cooling of the shell fluid relative to its saturation pressure at the inlet temperature, and is calculated under the assumption of a HEM. With regards to item (3) above (the attached piping system), an inertial-resistive and an anechoic model are considered below. 3.3.1. Inertial-resistive model A lumped parameter model is assumed to describe the dynamics of the fluid in the attached piping system while accounting for pressure drop due to friction and pipe fittings. The following equation of motion can then be written: rsf Vp dQ p Ap dt " ¼ Ap ðPs Pds Þ k rsf 2A2p ! Q p Q p # where: _ p =rsf ¼ Q p m (16) and Vp is the volume of fluid in the attached piping system (exclusive of the capacitance part); and k is the pressure drop coefficient for the attached piping system. 115 3.3.2. Anechoic model A pressure perturbation initiated at the inlet to the piping system (shell) is assumed to travel down the attached piping without reflection from the far downstream end. This assumption is valid for a long, straight piping system such that the time scale of the dynamic phenomenon occurring in the shell due to tube rupture is shorter than the time for a pressure wave to travel twice the length of the attached piping system. In this case, the relationship between the pressure perturbation in the shell dPs (positive or negative) is related to the flow perturbation at the pipe inlet dQp via (Munjal, 1987): rsf csf 0 dPs ¼ ¼ Pipe Acoustic Impedance ðZa Þ dQ p Ap (17) 4. Solution techniques The aim of the dynamic model is to predict the transient pressure on the shell side due to a partial or full tube rupture. This requires the solution of the primary ordinary differential equation (ODE), Eq. (12), along with the auxiliary equations (13)e(17). Equation (12) could be solved with a 4th order RungeeKutta method, although a simple explicit finite difference scheme could be adequate. The riser one-dimensional transient flow equations (13) and (14) are solved using the method of characteristics, where the hyperbolic partial differential equations are transformed into total differential equations. The total differential equations then lead to a set of algebraic compatibility equations along two characteristic lines and a flow path line as shown in Wylie and Streeter (1982). The compatibility equations, together with the respective characteristic lines, are integrated in the time-space domain. The boundary conditions to these equations are the pressure at the bottom of the riser (i.e., the instantaneous shell pressure) and the flow condition through the PSV valve. The flow through the PSV is either zero if the pressure at the top of the riser is less than or equal to the set pressure, or the relief rate determined as a function of the pressure if the pressure is greater than the set pressure. The PSV relief rate is determined following API 520 Appendix D methodology as mentioned earlier. The above set of equations including the primary ODE (Eq. (12)), the algebraic compatibility equations resulting from the method of characteristics, the ODE of the pipe flow using either Eq. (15) or Eq. (17), and other auxiliary equations are solved simultaneously in a marching-in-time numerical scheme from an initial condition just prior to tube rupture. The time step for the solution of these equations was selected to comply with that required by the method of characteristics for the solution of the riser flow equations according to Courant stability criterion (Courant, Friedrichs, & Lewy, 1967). The tube cold-side temperature (upstream of the heat exchanger) and the hot-side temperature (downstream of the heat exchanger), as well as pressure are used to calculate the mass flow of high-pressure fluid at every time step for the two sides of the break as shown schematically in Fig. 5a. The mass flow is determined by assuming that the break occurs at the tube sheet, hence one side of the rupture is assumed to be nozzle flow that can be solved following the API 520 Appendix D procedure, while the other side is assumed to be frictional flow along the entire length of the tube (L) and is solved by employing Leung’s methodology as described in Leung and Ciolek (1994). Both the nozzle and tube flows depend on the pressure in the shell and a rigorous procedure to check if the flow is critical or subcritical at each time step. Once the total mass flow is determined, the condition of the incremental mass of fluid from the high-pressure tube side is then adiabatically flashed from an average of the hot and cold side conditions to the pressure in the shell as shown in Fig. 5b, and the resulting fluid 116 C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 a Ps Ts P t,cold Tt,cold Pt,hot Tt,hot b Pt,average Tt,average Vapor & Liquid P s Ts Fig. 5. Adiabatic flashing of high-pressure fluid into the low-pressure shell side. a) Tube hot side and cold side flashing into the shell side. b) Approximation of an average tube inlet condition flashing into the shell side. thermodynamic properties are found with Aspen PlusÒ software (Aspen Technology, 2010). The PSV full opening and closing response time is assumed to be quick (within 4e5 ms) according to the experimental findings reported in the HSE reports (Ewan, Nelson, & Dawson, 2001 and Pipeline Simulation and Integrity, 2002), and hence is assumed to be instantaneously responding to the pressure at the top of the riser at each time step. A more accurate model would introduce the equation of motion of the PSV mass-spring-damping system and solve it along with the above equations. This complexity was found to be unnecessary given the findings in the HSE reports. 5. Application to ethylene heaters with different heating fluids The dynamic model described above is applied to two heat exchangers arranged in tandem. The function of these exchangers is to heat ethylene produced from an ethylene manufacturing plant from 26 C to 15 C before it is introduced into a pipeline for transmission to another location. The first heat exchanger, E1, uses a propylene mixture at 25 C (composition is given in Table 1) as the heating medium, while the second exchanger, E2, uses methanol at 64 C. A schematic of the layout of the two exchangers is shown in Fig. 6 with typical conditions of inlet and outlet pressures and temperatures. The design parameters of the tubes and shell of both exchangers are given in Table 2, along with properties of the heating media. Note that for both exchangers, the test pressure was equal to 1.5 times the design pressure in this case. The ratio of the shell-to-tube design pressures for both exchangers is much lower than ten-thirteens. In the case of E1, this pressure ratio is 0.169, while in the case of E2 it is 0.154. Clearly, these two exchangers warrant investigation into the dynamic effects and possibility of shell overpressure in the event a tube partial or full rupture. The case is accentuated by the fact that the respective shell-side PSVs of these exchangers are located at higher elevations than the exchangers and are connected to the shell side Table 1 Composition of the propylene mixture used for heating ethylene in exchanger E1. Mole fraction Propylene Propane Propyne Ethane But-1-ene 0.84 0.11 0.043 0.0071 0.00041 via approximately 10 m of 114.3 mm OD pipe as shown in Fig. 7. Other dimensions of both E1 and E2 including shell diameter, length and wall thickness, number and size of the tubes in each are given in Fig. 8. The following results are of dynamic simulations conducted on each heat exchanger assuming partial and full tube rupture scenarios. These scenarios are presented in terms of the size of the rupture area, ranging from 0.1A, 0.5A and 1.0A (representing partial tube rupture), 2A (one full tube rupture), 4A (two full tube ruptures) and 6A (three full tube ruptures), where A is the internal cross-sectional area of a tube in the respective exchanger. The mass flux from the rupture area is calculated assuming a nozzle-tube mode of rupture as discussed above in all of these scenarios. 5.1. Results of E1 tube rupture scenarios The E1 heat exchanger features a large accumulator (32 m3) immediately upstream of the propylene inlet to the shell. There is no check valve between the shell and the accumulator. A vapour space exists in this accumulator at a pressure equal to the vapour pressure of the propylene mix (approximately 1290 kPaa at 25 C). Although this vapour space would certainly help in damping any pressure spikes resulting from a tube rupture inside the E1 shell (refer to Eq. (10)), it is intentionally neglected in the present analysis so as to assume a worst case scenario where the accumulator is completely filled with liquid propylene mixture. However, the effect of propylene compressibility in the 32 m3 accumulator is accounted for. The outlet side of the E1 heat exchanger consists of a piping system (composed mainly of 406.4 mm OD pipe, 12.7 mm wall thickness). The distance between E1 and the farthest downstream vessel is 65 m, which, along with various fittings along the way, constitutes a pressure drop coefficient (k in Eq. (15)) of approximately 25. The farthest vessel is assumed to be maintained at a constant pressure equal to the vapour pressure of the propylene mix at the farthest vessel temperature. Table 2 gives the initial mass flux of ethylene into the shell side at conditions just after tube rupture. This mass flux is calculated based on ‘nozzle-tube’ rupture mode (as discussed earlier) and is approximately equal to 39,520 kg/(s m2). Hence, for a full tube rupture (i.e., flow area ¼ 2A), the discharge mass flow rate of ethylene from the ruptured tube into the shell is equal to 13.39 kg/s Table 3 and Fig. 9 show the results of adiabatic flashing of ethylene from the inlet average pressure of 10,196 kPaa and inlet average temperature of 7.8 C to different shell pressures to determine the vapour mass fraction of the ethylene introduced into the shell side, as well as the pertinent vapour and liquid properties of both phases. The data of Table 3 were curve-fitted to be used with the solver of the full set of dynamic equations described in Section 3. The set pressure and orifice area of PSV-1 are given in Table 2. From Table 2, at 110% of the indicated set pressure, the volumetric relief rate of the propylene mixture is approximately equal to 0.072 m3/s based on the API 520 Appendix D calculation. The results of the dynamic simulations for various rupture areas (i.e., 0.1A through 6A) are shown in Fig. 10. In this case, no credit is given from the inlet or the outlet piping of ethylene on the shell side; both inlet and outlet piping are assumed to be blocked off and the propylene mixture is not allowed to expand out or contract into the shell side. The results only shows Phase I and II from Fig. 3 since these two phases exhibits the possibility of overpressure exceeding the design or the test pressure of the shell. It is shown that the 6A rupture scenario results in a pressure peak that exceeds the shell test pressure by 1.3% for less than 30 ms, and that the 2A rupture scenario results in a pressure peak that exceeds the shell design pressure by 8.8% for less than 100 ms. The 0.1A, 0.5A and 1A rupture scenarios did not result in an exceedance of the shell design pressure. C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 117 Flow Meter To Pipeline Ethylene @ 10,020 kPa-a, 15 oC Methanol out E-2 Methanol (366 kPa-a & 64 oC) Propylene out Ethylene @ 10,159 kPa-a, 11 o C Ethylene @ 10,232 kPa-a, -26 o C E-1 PSV Riser Propylene (1290 kPa-a & 25 oC) Fig. 6. Example of two heat exchangers in series using different heating fluids to heat ethylene from 26 C to 15 C before entering a pipeline. Fig. 11 shows corresponding results for the same scenarios of rupture areas with the inlet accumulator of 32 m3 and the outlet piping system accounted for. Here the outlet piping system is modeled using the inertial-resistive model of Eq. (15). It is shown that when credits of both inlet and outlet piping are considered, the pressure increase in the shell due to the tube rupture scenarios is dramatically decreased when compared to the corresponding nocredit cases of Fig. 10. With the inertial-resistive model, the shell test pressure is not exceeded during any of the modeled rupture scenarios. The shell design pressure is exceeded during rupture scenarios with ruptured tube area greater than 2A. Fig. 12 shows the results from modeling the outlet piping with an anechoic assumption as in Eq. (17) (again taking into account the volume credit from the accumulator on the inlet). It is shown that the shell test pressure is not exceeded for the modeled rupture Table 2 Relevant properties and data pertaining to heat exchangers E1 and E2. Tube design pressure Shell design pressure Shell test pressure Area of one tube Flow area of full tube rupture Ethylene pressure Ethylene temperature Initial flux Initial flow through full tube rupture Units E1 E2 kPag kPag kPag mm2 mm2 11,204 1896 2848 169 339 11,204 1724 2586 143 287 kPaa C kg/s/m2 kg/s 10,196 7.8 39,520 13.4 10,090 12.8 24,344 7.0 Properties of propylene mixture Properties of methanol Temperature Initial pressure Initial density Speed of sound Isothermal bulk modulus C kPaa kg/m3 m/s MPaa Set pressure Overpressure (110%) Orifice area Flow at 110% pressure kPag kPag mm2 m3/s 20 1290 514 570 167 64 366 749 894 600 PSV-1 PSV-2 1724 1896 1836 0.072 1276 1404 1835 0.066 areas, and that the shell design pressure is exceeded during rupture scenarios with ruptured tube area greater than 4A. It is also shown that the time required to reach the peak pressure is greater than the time required for the no-credit and inertial-resistive models. 5.2. Results of E2 tube rupture scenarios The same numerical procedure is applied to the E2 heat exchanger which features a check valve located immediately at the inlet of the methanol to the shell, therefore preventing any methanol expansion out from the shell side to the inlet piping system. The outlet side of the E2 shell consists of a piping system (composed of a 168.3 mm OD pipe, 7.11 mm wall thickness). The distance between E2 and the farthest vessel is 165 m, which, along with various fittings along the way, constitutes a pressure drop coefficient (k in Eq. (15)) of approximately 20. The boundary condition at the farthest vessel is assumed to be maintained at a constant pressure of 366 kPaa. Table 2 gives the initial mass flux of ethylene into the shell side at conditions just prior to tube rupture. Note that the ethylene average temperature in this case is 12.8 C which is above the critical point of ethylene of 9.2 C, hence Section D.2.1 in Appendix D of API 520 is used to calculate the mass flux. This mass flux is calculated based also on ‘nozzle-tube’ rupture mode and is found to be approximately equal to 24,344 kg/(s m2). Hence for a full tube rupture (i.e., flow area ¼ 2A), the initial ethylene mass flow rate is equal to 7.0 kg/s Table 4 and Fig. 9 show the results of adiabatic flashing of ethylene from the tube inlet average pressure of 10,090 kPaa and average temperature of 12.8 C to different shell pressures to determine the vapour mass fraction of the ethylene introduced into the shell, as well as the pertinent vapour and liquid properties of both phases. The data of this table were also curvefitted to be used with the solver of the full set of dynamic equations described in Section 3. The set pressure and orifice area of PSV-2 are given in Table 2 showing that at 110% of the indicated set pressure, the volumetric relief rate of methanol is approximately 0.066 m3/s based on the API 520 Appendix D calculation. The results of the dynamic simulations for various rupture areas (i.e., 0.1A through 6A) are shown in Fig. 13. In this case, no volume credit is given from the inlet or the outlet piping of ethylene on the shell side; the inlet is blocked off by the presence of a check valve. 118 C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 PSV-1 PSV-2 1.9 m 1.9 m 2.0 m Pipe O.D. = 114.3 mm Pipe W.T. = 6.02 mm Pipe O.D. = 114.3 mm Pipe W.T. = 6.02 mm 2.7 m 0.7 m E-2 E-1 Fig. 7. Geometric dimensions of the PSV risers on E1 and E2. E = 200 GPa, u = 0.3 E-2 E-1 WT = 9.53 mm E = 200 GPa, u = 0.3 Volume (less tubes) = 0.72 m 3 WT = 9.53 mm Volume (less tubes) = 0.58 m 3 ID = 0.686 m ID = 0.337 m L = 3.35 m L = 11.0 m 540 tubes (OD = 19.1 mm, 14 gauge) 125 tubes (OD = 19.1 mm,12 gauge) Fig. 8. Geometric dimensions of the exchangers E1 and E2. The results again only show Phase I and II of Fig. 3. It is shown that the 4A and 6A rupture scenarios result in a peak pressure that exceeds the shell test pressure by 9.2% and 30.5%, respectively, for less than 100 ms each. The 2A scenario results in a peak pressure that exceeds the shell design pressure by 23.6% with a total exceedance time of 60 ms. The 0.1A, 0.5A and 1A rupture scenarios did not result in an exceedance of the shell design pressure. Fig. 14 shows corresponding results for the same rupture areas with the outlet piping system accounted for. Here the outlet piping system is modeled using the inertial-resistive model of Eq. (15). It is shown that when the outlet piping is considered, the pressure increase in the shell due to the various tube rupture scenarios is decreased. The 4A and 6A rupture scenarios result in a peak pressure that exceeds the shell test pressure by 7.7% and 26.3%, respectively, for less than 100 ms each. The 2A rupture scenario exceeds the shell design pressure by 22.2% and the pressure exceeds the design pressure for 52 ms. The results from modeling the outlet piping system with an anechoic assumption as in Eq. (17) are shown in Fig. 15. With the anechoic downstream model, the 4A and 6A rupture scenario result in an exceedance of the shell test pressure of 1.0% and 16.8%, respectively, both for less than 100 ms. The 2A scenario exceeded the shell design pressure by 14.0% with a total exceedance time of 41 ms. 6. Discussion The overpressure due to a tube partial or full rupture depends greatly on whether the attached piping is considered or not. Using Table 3 Results of adiabatic flashing of high-pressure ethylene at 7.8 C and 10,196 kPaa into the low-pressure shell using the RK-Soave EoS (exchanger E1). P (kPaa) T ( C) Vapour mass fraction Vapour density (kg/m3) Liquid density (kg/m3) Vapour speed of sound (m/s) Liquid adiabatic bulk modulus (MPa) 1290 1490 1690 1890 2090 2290 2490 2690 2890 3090 4090 5090 6090 7090 8090 9090 10,090 44.1 39.4 35.1 31.2 27.6 24.2 21.0 18.0 15.2 14.5 13.1 11.9 10.8 9.9 9.1 8.5 7.9 0.27 0.24 0.21 0.18 0.15 0.12 0.08 0.05 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 23 27 31 35 39 44 48 53 58 e e e e e e e e 472 463 453 445 436 428 420 411 403 401 397 393 390 386 384 381 379 262 261 259 257 255 254 252 250 249 e e e e e e e e 319 281 249 221 195 174 154 136 120 119 132 144 156 169 181 193 205 Fig. 9. Adiabatic flashing of ethylene from initial conditions corresponding to E1 and E2. C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 Fig. 10. Results of dynamic simulations of various tube rupture scenarios in exchanger E1 without credits from the inlet or the outlet propylene piping systems. a resistive model on the downstream end of the E1 heat exchanger and increasing the effective volume of the shell by including the upstream accumulator resulted in a 10.5% mitigation of the peak pressure with the 2A rupture scenario. The use of the anechoic model on the downstream end further reduced the peak pressure by 13.9% below the no-credit scenario. The shell greatly benefits from the upstream accumulator that increases the total system volume by 32 m3. The increase in shell pressure due to the influx of tube fluid is proportional to the shell total volume through the bulk modulus: Bsf ¼ Vsf vPs vVsf (18) From Eq. (18), an increase in volume vVsf will effect a pressure increase vPs that will vary in proportion to the initial shell-side fluid volume Vsf, therefore an increase in the system volume will dampen pressure increases caused by the tube-side fluid influx to the shell. The simulated E1 shell peak pressure is greatly mitigated by taking into account the upstream accumulator, even though the accumulator fluid was assumed to be fully liquid phase with no vapour space. The decision of applying either the inertial-resistive or anechoic flow simplifications is dependent upon the attached piping Fig. 11. Results of dynamic simulations of various tube rupture scenarios in exchanger E1 accounting for an accumulator on the inlet side and an inertial-resistive flow on the outlet side of the propylene piping system. 119 Fig. 12. Results of dynamic simulations of various tube rupture scenarios in exchanger E1 accounting for an accumulator on the inlet side and an anechoic flow on the outlet side of the propylene piping system. configuration. The applicability of the anechoic flow assumption depends on the piping length attached to the heat exchanger shell, the pipe acoustic impedance and the pressureetime profile. If the attached piping is of sufficient length that the pressure front will not be reflected back to the shell within the time of the pressure peak (Phase I in Fig. 3), the model may present a viable representation of the flow condition. Given a relatively short length of attached pipe with multiple resistive elements, the inertial-resistive lumped parameter model is a more appropriate flow model. The inertial-resistive model is shown to predict higher shell peak pressures than the anechoic model as shown in Fig. 11 as compared to Fig. 12 for the E1 heat exchanger and in Fig. 14 as compared to Fig. 15 for the E2 heat exchanger. The difference between the pressure profiles predicted for the E1 heat exchanger given the two different downstream models is greater than the difference predicted for the E2 heat changer; this difference is likely due to the increased length of downstream attached piping Table 4 Results of adiabatic flashing of high-pressure ethylene at 12.8 C and 10,090 kPaa into the low-pressure shell using the RK-Soave EoS (Exchanger E2). P (kPaa) T ( C) Vapour mass fraction Vapour density (kg/m3) Liquid density (kg/m3) Vapour speed of sound (m/s) Liquid adiabatic bulk modulus (MPa) 290 490 690 890 1090 1290 1490 1690 1890 2090 2290 2490 2690 2890 3090 4090 5090 6090 7090 8090 83.3 71.2 62.4 55.3 49.3 44.1 39.4 35.1 31.2 27.6 24.2 21.0 18.0 15.2 12.4 0.4 3.0 5.6 7.8 10.3 0.61 0.57 0.54 0.51 0.49 0.47 0.44 0.42 0.40 0.38 0.35 0.33 0.30 0.27 0.24 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 6 9 13 16 20 23 27 31 35 39 44 48 53 58 63 96 e e e e 540 521 506 494 482 472 463 453 445 436 428 420 411 403 395 348 329 309 288 272 271 270 268 266 264 262 261 259 257 255 254 252 250 248 247 238 e e e e 716 586 503 417 363 319 281 249 221 196 174 154 136 120 105 48 56 66 75 83 120 C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 Fig. 13. Results of dynamic simulations of various tube rupture scenarios in exchanger E2 without credits from the inlet or the outlet methanol piping system. Fig. 15. Results of dynamic simulations of various tube rupture scenarios in exchanger E2 accounting for an anechoic flow on the outlet side of the methanol piping system. for the E2 heat exchanger and therefore the more relevant application of the anechoic model. The E2 heat exchanger does not show as pronounced a difference between the no-credit and inertial-resistive or anechoic models as compared to the E1 heat exchanger pressure profiles. This is likely due to the presence of a check valve upstream of the E2 shell, and therefore no credit being given on the upstream flow side for all three flow models. When considering the conservative no-credit E1 heat exchanger case in Fig. 10, the 2A rupture scenario results in an exceedance of the shell design pressure by 8.8% while remaining below the shell test pressure. In this case, the design pressure exceedance duration is expected to be less than 100 ms. The 2A rupture case is not predicted to result in an exceedance of the shell design pressure for either the inertial-resistive or anechoic flow models. Again during the 2A rupture scenario, the conservative nocredit E2 heat exchanger case in Fig. 13 is predicted to result in an exceedance of the shell design pressure by 23.6% while remaining below the shell test pressure. The 2A rupture scenario is still predicted to result in a shell overpressure when taking into account the credit from the downstream piping in the inertial-resistive and anechoic models as shown in Figs. 14 and 15, respectively. The 2A rupture scenario is expected to exceed the shell design pressure for a maximum duration of 100 ms when simulated with the no-credit, inertial-resistive and anechoic models. 7. Concluding remarks In assessing the degree of heat exchanger shell overpressure due to tube rupture containing much higher pressure fluid than the design pressure of the shell, attention should be given to several parameters involved in the rupture scenarios. Among these parameters are: the thermodynamics and mass flux of the fluid released through the rupture opening, the adiabatic flashing characteristics of the high-pressure fluid into the low-pressure shell, the capacity and location of the relief device to relieve the liquid on the shell side, the shell volume, compliance, and the characteristics of the attached piping system, and the initial pressure of the liquidfilled shell in relation to the set pressure of the relief device. However, the important indicator that would alert the designer to conduct a dynamic analysis to determine the degree of the overpressure is the ratio of the design pressure of the shell to the design pressure of the tube. One complication that could make the analysis complex, which is emphasized in the present paper is the flashing of the high-pressure fluid from the tube into the low-pressure side. In the present examples of exchangers E1 and E2, full single tube rupture scenarios were shown to cause an overpressure in the heat exchanger shell that is less than 1.3 times the shell design pressure when evaluated with a conservative no-credit shell criterion. This peak pressure is further reduced when the exchanger attached piping is taken into account through either an inertialresistive or anechoic flow model, and in the case of E1, an accumulator on the shell inlet side. However, a risk assessment should be considered to assess the probability of more than one tube rupturing during a failure event, as the 6A (i.e., three tube ruptures) rupture scenario is predicted to result in an exceedance of the shell test pressure with the E1 no-credit flow condition and the 4A and 6A scenarios are predicted to exceed the shell test pressure with the E2 no-credit, inertial-resistive and anechoic flow conditions. Acknowledgment Fig. 14. Results of dynamic simulations of various tube rupture scenarios in exchanger E2 accounting for an inertial-resistive flow on the outlet side of the methanol piping system. The authors wish to thank David Gent for his foresight in initiating this investigation and for his guidance and technical C.J. Ennis et al. / Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 24 (2011) 111e121 discussion throughout. Thanks are also due to Andrew Hawryluk for his guidance during coding the model with Python programming language, and to Abdul Salad, Beverly Perozzo, Arcadio Zamora and Karin Douglas of NOVA Chemicals (Joffre Site) for their interactive technical dialogue through the present work. The support of Michel Berghmans and Chris Foy and permission to publish this paper by NOVA Chemicals Corporation is hereby acknowledged. References American Petroleum Institute. (2000 Jan). API 520, sizing, selection, and installation of pressure-relieving devices in refineries, part I, sizing and selection, appendix D, sizing for two-phase liquid/vapor relief (7th ed.). American Petroleum Institute. American Petroleum Institute. (1997 Mar). API 521, guide for pressure-relieving and depressuring systems (4th ed.). American Petroleum Institute. American Society of Mechanical Engineers. (2010 Jul 01). Boiler and pressure vessel code, section VIII, division 1: Rules for construction of pressure vessels. American Society of Mechanical Engineers. Aspen Technology, Inc. (2010). Aspen PlusÒ (Version 7.1). [Computer software]. Courant, R., Friedrichs, K., & Lewy, H. (1967). On the partial difference equations of mathematical physics. IBM Journal, Mar, 215e234. Ewan, B. C. R., Nelson, D., & Dawson, P. (2001). (University of Sheffield, Department of Chemical and Process Engineering, Sheffield, UK). Examination of the effects of relief device opening times on the transient pressures developed within liquid filled shells. Offshore technology report. Norwich (UK): Health and Safety Executive. Report No.: 2000/130. 121 Fowler, D. W., Herndon, T. R., Wahrmund, R. C. (1968 Sep 22e25). An analysis of potential overpressure of a heat exchanger shell due to a ruptured tube. Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute Annual Petroleum Mechanical Engineering Conference, Dallas, TX. Henry, R. E., & Fauske, H. F. (1971). The two-phase critical flow of one-component mixtures in nozzles, orifices and short tubes. ASME Journal of Heat Transfer, 93, 179e187. Henry, R. E. (1970). The two-phase critical discharge of initially saturated or subcooled liquid. Nuclear Science and Engineering, 41, 336e342. Leung, J. C., & Ciolek, W. H. (1994 Sep). Flashing flow discharge of initially subcooled liquid in pipes. American Society of Mechanical Engineers Journal of Fluids Engineering, 116, 643e645. Leung, J. C., & Grolmes, M. A. (1988 Apr). A generalized correlation for flashing choked flow of initially sub-cooled liquid. American Institute for Chemical Engineers Journal, 34(4), 688e691. Mohitpour, M., Botros, K. K., & Van Hardeveld, T. (2008). Pipeline pumping and compression systemsdA practical approach. New York: ASME. Munjal, M. L. (1987). Acoustics of ducts and mufflers with application to exhaust and ventilation system design. New York: Wiley. Pipeline Simulation and Integrity, Ltd. (Leeds, UK). (2002). Testing and analysis of relief device opening times. Offshore technology report. Norwich (UK): Health and Safety Executive. Report No.: 2002/023. Simpson, L. L. (1972) Tubing rupture in liquid-filled exchangers. Proceedings of the 7th symposium on loss prevention in the chemical industry, pp. 93e98. Sumaria, V. H., Rovnak, J. A., Heitner, I., & Herber, R. J. (1976 May 12). Model to predict transient consequences of a heat exchanger tube rupture. Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute Division of Refining, 55(41), 631e654. Wong, W. Y. (1992 Feb 01). PRV sizing for exchanger tube rupture. Hydrocarbon Process, 71(2), 59e64. Wylie, E. B., & Streeter, V. L. (1982). Fluid transients. Ann Arbor: FEB Press.
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )