8/13/2025
International Management
WEEK 5
1
Costs and Benefits of
doing International
Business
8/13/2025
2
2
1
8/13/2025
Benefits of Internationalization
Internationalization provides a firm opportunity to exploit its ‘VRIN’ resources
and capabilities in larger markets
• A firm can gain higher profitability by exploiting its resources and capabilities,
especially intangible ones, in international markets
• Enables a firm to realize economies of scale and scope
Helps reduce fluctuations in revenue by spreading investment risks over
different countries
Helps reduce costs and increase revenues by increasing a firm’s market power
over its suppliers, distributors, and customers
Lowers costs by enabling arbitrage of differences in input and output markets
Firm’s subsidiaries in disparate host countries help it to enhance its knowledge
base, capabilities, and competitiveness
Firms also benefits from host country location-specific advantages
8/13/2025
3
3
Costs of Internationalization
Costs of internationalization mainly arise due to – ‘liabilities of newness and
foreignness’
◦ Cost of setting up of new operations - purchasing and installing facilities, staffing, and establishing
internal management systems and external business networks.
◦ Liabilities of foreignness also result in mistakes in various business decisions.
◦ These costs are amplified by high cultural and institutional differences between home and host
countries
◦ Firms home grown sources of advantages may also be sticky and may not be transferable to foreign
markets
8/13/2025
4
4
2
8/13/2025
Costs of Internationalization
Costs of internationalization also arise due to increased
transaction and coordination costs
◦ For example, coordination difficulties, information asymmetry, and incentive
misalignment between headquarters and divisional managers in multidivisional
firms
As the number of internal transactions increases with foreign
subsidiaries, governance costs rise rapidly to a point at which the
governance costs exceed any internalization benefits
◦ These costs are compounded if the firm expands into a number of host countries
Example – For pharmaceuticals, automobiles, consumer goods
and electronics, regulatory approvals, product modifications etc.
may significantly increase coordination costs
5
8/13/2025
5
A Generic Relationship between
internationalization and
performance
Performance
S-Curve
Stage 2
Stage 1
Liabilities of foreignness
and newness
8/13/2025
Economies of scale and
scope
Internationalization
Stage 3
Transaction and
coordination costs
6
6
3
8/13/2025
Multinationality and
performance – 3 stage model
Source: Lu & Beamish, 2004
7
8/13/2025
7
The Case of Walmart
Sources of advantage
Transferrable to international markets
Hub and spoke distribution model
No – depends on infrastructure availability
in foreign markets
Store locations
No – Unlike US, in others markets such as
Mexico, India, China such stores are
located in a more urban setting
Merchandising skills
No – Consumer tastes and beliefs vary in
different countries
IT and Management skills
Yes
HR Practices
No – Some practices are determined by
host country regulations
Purchasing scale
No
Administration/Low cost mentality
Yes
8/13/2025
8
8
4
8/13/2025
High Fungibility
Eg : auditors,
power
generation
equipment
E.G : Brand
name,
computer
operating
system
Low fungibility
Capabilities and expansion
Eg : personnel
with specific
technical
expertise,
steel plant
Eg : patents,
customer
relationships
Non-scale free (+ve
opportunity costs
Scale free (zero
opportunity costs
Levinthal, D. A., & Wu, B. (2010). Opportunity costs and non‐scale free capabilities: Profit maximization, corporate scope, and profit margins. Strategic
Management Journal, 31(7), 780-801.
8/13/2025
9
9
Relationship between
internationalization and
performance
Research suggests that the relationship of
internationalization and performance is not fixed and
depends on context
•
•
•
•
Firm specific factors
Industry context – e.g. service vs. manufacturing
Home and host countries differences
Motives of internationalization
8/13/2025
10
10
5
8/13/2025
Relationship between
internationalization and
performance
Firm level factors that positively effect performance upon
internationalization
Firm Size
• Portfolio diversification
• More resources – man power, capabilities
• Ability to take risky decisions
• A robust and functional organizational structure in place
• Stronger reputation, higher bargaining power with host country
stakeholders
Firm’s resources – technological and marketing
◦ Internationalization offers a broader market to exploit
CEO’s/TMT’s internationalization exposure (experience/nationality)
8/13/2025
11
11
Internationalization and
performance, service vs.
manufacturing
The services sector is different from manufacturing because of its
unique characteristics like • Inseparability, heterogeneity, intangibility and perishability
For service firms, the initial threshold required to turn profitable is less
as compared to manufacturing firms
• This is largely due to lower initial fixed investments, lesser financial capital
• Social and relational capital is more important in the initial stages of
internationalization
Higher need for adaptation for services because of their intangible
nature escalates the costs for services
8/13/2025
13
13
6
8/13/2025
Internationalization and
performance, service vs.
manufacturing
But services differ among themselves in terms of inseparability, heterogeneity, intangibility and
perishability
• Some services require extensive customization and cultural adaptation
Capital based service sectors - Air Transport, hotels, restaurants, fast food chains, retail trade,
wholesale trade etc vs. Knowledge Based service sectors - IT, accounting, legal services, market
research etc.
Knowledge-based sectors reap the positive (Stage 2) benefits of internationalization earlier
Knowledge-based sectors ‘over-internationalize,’ reaching the suboptimal Stage 3, whereas capitalintensive sectors usually do not.
For capital intensive service firms -
Higher initial costs of investment due to the intangibility of service skills, makes them difficult to transfer
to third parties without significant transaction costs
Difficult to achieve economic of scale and scope due to higher costs of international operations arising
from • Inseparability of production and consumption in services
• Heterogeneity of services
8/13/2025
14
14
The case of emerging
market firms
8/13/2025
31
31
7
8/13/2025
EMFs performance upon
internationalization
“…companies headquartered in BRIC countries remain among the most distrusted of
businesses”.. Edelman Trust Barometer (2018)
Source: Edelman Trust Barometer Special India report (2018)
According to the Edelman Trust 2018 report:
“…trust is a predictor of whether stakeholders will find you credible in the future..
…ongoing trust-building activities should be one of the most important strategic priorities
for every organization.”
32
13/08/2025
32
Various reasons of Trust deficit of Indian Businesses
Brand awareness
Uncertainty over firm’s technical/design capabilities
Alignment with consumer expectations and values
Business’ leadership
Treatment of employees
Source: Edelman Trust Barometer Special India report (2018)
13/08/2025
33
33
8
8/13/2025
Costs of Internationalization – An
Emerging Market Perspective
Sarik Tara, chairman of Enka Holding, Turkey’s biggest construction
company, has learnt to search for contracts in difficult places.
“I am stamped ‘Made in Turkey’, not ‘Made in Germany’,’’ says Mr. Tara.
‘‘I have to try harder. No one is going to ask me to build anything in the
Champs Elysees.”
Products manufactured in India and China are perceived of poorer
quality
8/13/2025
34
34
Costs of Internationalization – An
Emerging Market Perspective
Developed country managers do not prefer to work under
emerging market bosses
In 2006, the governments of France and Luxembourg initially
opposed the takeover of the steel firm Arcelor by Mittal Steel
(which had an Indian management), while being more
amenable to a Russian takeover
Acquisitions by Chinese State Owned firms are seen with
suspicion
• State owned firms receive subsidies from home governments, a
practice that conflicts with the norms of free-market principles
• Hidden motives of Chinese governments
8/13/2025
35
35
9
8/13/2025
Costs of Internationalization – An
Emerging Market Perspective
Emerging market MNEs face discrimination, lack of trustworthiness in international markets
Cause - “Liabilities of Origin”
Poor quality of products and lack of
brand awareness
o Capability deficit
Concerns regarding ‘behavioral intent’
or trustworthiness of EMNEs
̶
Weak enforcement of contracts, state
intervention, poor shareholder protection, and
opaque governance standards of firms
o Legitimacy deficit
36
13-08-2025
36
Emerging market firm’s
capabilities
Emerging market firm’s typically compete on their unconventional capabilities
(adaptability-amalgamation-ambidexterity) in international markets
Adaptability
• Ability to adapt to newer technologies
• Host country environments with poorer institutional developments
o
red tape, regulatory hindrance, policy uncertainty, weak legal protection, poor public services, and
corruption.
• Diverse cultural environments
Amalgamation
• Ability to combine all available (internal and external) resources (including those purchased
from global open markets)
• Creating products with impressive price–value ratios suited to mass global and domestic
consumers who are generally cost-sensitive.
Ambidexterity
• Simultaneously fulfill two disparate or conflicting goals that are critical to the firm’s longrange success
• The yin–yang principle
8/13/2025
37
37
10
8/13/2025
Legitimacy
• ‘Legitimacy’ is a resource equal, if not more important, as
capital, technology, manpower and network
• Failures to address legitimacy could impact performance and
even survival
• Legitimacy judgement – a function of the type of audience
(potential alliance partners, customers, suppliers, employees,
government and regulators, media, society, and analysts)
• Various types of stakeholders throw up diverse legitimacy
challenges and each legitimating action is aimed at specific
host country stakeholder.
8/13/2025
38
38
Sources of Legitimacy Deficit
Practice of manipulating public policy or economic conditions as
a strategy for increasing profits
◦ Weak institutional setups which manifest in violation of the
norms of contracts, attempts to draw unilateral benefits
◦ Poor corporate governance practices
◦ High family shareholding
◦ Appropriation of benefits at the cost of minority shareholders
◦ Lesser number of (really) independent directors
Such malpractices at home do not go un-noticed by host
country stakeholders
8/13/2025
39
39
11
8/13/2025
Signaling Theory
• Signaling theory is concerned with reducing information asymmetry
between two parties (Spence, 2002)
̶
Two broad types of information where asymmetry plays an important role Information about quality and information about intent of transacting parties (Stiglitz
2000)
• Signals that are observable and costly (Bird & Smith, 2005, Certo et al. 2001) are most
credible means to reduce information asymmetry
13-08-2025
40
40
How do emerging market firm’s
overcome ‘legitimacy deficit’?
Cross-listing - List company’s stocks on foreign stocks
exchanges
Benefits
•
•
•
•
•
Gain exposure and access to more capital
Help in improving a company’s structure of corporate governance
Attract more and better talent
Improves the reputation of a company
Ex - Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories, ICICI Bank, Infosys Ltd., MakeMyTrip
Limited, Tata Motors Ltd. and many more
8/13/2025
41
41
12
8/13/2025
How do emerging market firm’s
overcome ‘legitimacy deficit’?
Provide operational autonomy to their foreign subsidiaries
Delegating autonomy to subsidiaries helps overcome “negative
heritage” associated with home institutions.
Adopt polycentric human resource strategies
Hire senior executives from the host-country market, who can act as
"offshore champions”
Helps in distancing from the image of the parent company, and build
their own reputation and legitimacy
8/13/2025
42
42
How do emerging market firm’s
overcome ‘legitimacy deficit’?
Corporate Social Responsibility reporting
Symbolic impression management efforts
Conveys firms’ attitudes on relevant societal issues and willingness
to align practices with global stakeholder norms and expectations
CSR has positive consequences for firms –
• lesser government and community scrutiny
• greater levels of societal trust,
• and better network connections, social capital with non-market stakeholders
CSR reporting can compensate for the poor home-country image,
assuring foreign market stakeholders of the firm’s commitment to
product quality and safety, environmental and social stewardship, and
anti-corruption behaviors
8/13/2025
43
43
13
8/13/2025
How do emerging market firm’s
overcome ‘legitimacy deficit’?
Adopting globally accepted corporate governance practices
Corporate governance attributes are credible, concrete and
observable that signal to host country stakeholders regarding
firms conduct
Voluntary Enhancement in CG practices signal –
• Higher quality of firm’s conduct
• Transparency, professional functioning decreases
opportunism concerns
o Reduced family shareholding
o Increased institutional investors (including FIIs) shareholding
o Reputed auditors
8/13/2025
44
44
Thank You………..
8/13/2025
45
45
14