Saito is a strong advocate against Capitalism, for communism, and opposes the
current world mindset which encourages worsening environmental conditions. Saito
explains that the current growth oriented-Capitalist mentality is the main contributor to
the current world climate issues. Many other factors impact our Earth’s climate but most
seem to be trickle-down effects from Capitalist economics. One of the first arguments
Saito makes against capitalism is the constant reliance upon growth which cannot be
decoupled from worsening climate change. For climate issues to be less severe the
world would need to achieve absolute effective decoupling. (Saito 36-38) This
immediately leads to several other ideas that Saito discusses which are the growth and
productivity traps. The essence of these two traps is that Capitalism is measured by
several metrics with the two most important being the Gross Domestic Product (GDP)
and Total Aggregate Supply and Demand (TASD). The important takeaway of these two
metrics is that a country's level of wealth is measured by its ability to produce more
products that are later purchased by individuals, businesses, the government, or foreign
countries. It quickly becomes clear that to make a profit entities need to increase
productivity at the cheapest rate possible so they can sell their product at the highest
amount that consumers will still purchase in large quantities. This leads to both the
growth and productivity trap because as a country's GDP expands there is more wealth
among businesses and individuals which is then used to generate more wealth for
themselves. As already mentioned the simple idea of generating wealth is expanding
production cheaply. Therefore capitalism is in a constant cycle of growing, hiring more
labor, and producing more goods. If this cycle were to shut down at any point then
growth would stop occurring, productivity would slow down and unemployment would
increase thus generating unhappiness in a country. Capitalist countries cannot afford to
have unemployment or unhappiness in their country because there are not enough
government provisions for unemployment, health care, and so forth to support mass
unemployment. For these factors, Saito points out both the growth and productivity
traps (Saito 36-38). There are many other Arguments that Saito will raise against
Capitalism but at its core, these are the fundamental reasons that Saito believes that
Capitalist growth and Positive Climate Change cannot be absolutely decoupled.
Gathje 2
I discuss the previously mentioned Arguments from Saito’s paper because I am
currently studying Economics here at TUJ. We all know that Temple University is an
American University so nearly 99% of my studies revolve around American Economics
and more specifically Capitalism. I find Saito’s direct contrast to the capitalist system
intellectually exciting because it challenges the very things that I am being taught are
fact or law. I have found that Saito does not refute the effectiveness of Capitalism but
instead attacks the principles in a moralistic sense as well as points out its flaws
regarding the climate. These factors are the major reasons why I have enjoyed giving
significant thought to the points that Saito mentions in his Degrowth Manifesto. Saito as
an economist obviously has a solid grasp on the capitalist system, but rather than being
spiteful tries to point out the negative aspects that need to be recognized else humanity
will have significant struggles in what he claims will be the near future. Quite possibly
the biggest factor that Saito has drawn my curiosity into is the morals of capitalism and
the general disregard for the wellbeing of the laborers that business utilizes to increase
their profits. I cannot say that I am swayed to the side of communism or for absolute
degrowth of the economy, but I can say that Saito has opened my eyes to many failures
of capitalism as well as the possibilities that “the common man” is being abused by this
system. These points drew me to research other scholars who comment on Saito’s
degrowth paper and discuss factors that are related to Capitalism but also how it could
be altered to better favor the common man and the climate.
In his article, Hickel states that “If we assume that global GDP continues to grow
at 3% per year, then decarbonization must occur at a rate of 10.5% per year to achieve
the goal of 1.5 degree Celsius or 7.3% per year for 2 degrees Celsius”. (Hicken 55)
Hickel goes on to discuss several other factors that imply that the current system of
capitalism as well as the current proposals for change are completely inadequate to
achieve the goals that were set. Hickel discusses various technologies that many
current organizations believe could be what fixes the climate change issue by the turn of
the century, but Hickel agrees with Saito that it is too slow of a fix for the issue. To
combat these concerns Hickel is a bit less radical compared to Saito. Hickel first argues
that we should redefine prosperity. Instead of the GDP-focused idea of prosperity which
simply measures transactions, output, and production. Society instead needs to swap to
Gathje 3
a prosperity mindset in which health, education, and leisure determine a person's
wealth. To achieve these ideas Hickel proposes that there be shorter workweeks and
expansions of public services. Both of these ideas would lead to greater happiness
among people, more time for leisure, and help to reduce carbon emissions.
Kallis discusses the idea that rather than degrowth, Capitalist economies could
instead manage positive climate change if TASD were to remain constant. This could be
achieved by placing limits on resources, energy, and other production that contribute to
aggregate supply and demand (Kallis PG 9-10). Kallis does not explicitly argue against
degrowth but rather is a proponent that there should be limits to economic growth for
each nation. Kallis also is a proponent that for any realistic shift from growth to growth
limits, or degrowth there would need to be improvements in quality of life. A few policy
packages that Kallis discusses in his article are maximum incomes and more
progressive tax systems to fight income inequality. Additionally, policy would need to
exist to encourage divestment from “dirty sectors” while promoting investment in green
sectors. Kallis also discussed the positive impacts of reducing working hours to promote
degrowth scenarios. To promote quality of life, Kallis offers suggestions such as shorter
working hours and work sharing. Kallis uses Cuba as an example from the 1990s, which
shows that Cuba adopted a somewhat-degrowth-based mindset which led to a
decrease in imports and an increase in organic and green-based technologies. Kallis
mentions that Cuban life expectancy rose during this time, relative socio-economic
equality, and increases in public healthcare. (Kallis 12).
I think if Hickel, Kallis, and Saito all met in the same room they would be
inclined to agree with each other’s points. I think the common theme is that Saito is a bit
more severe in his expectations than the others, but all of them have an equal amount
of concern for the current capitalist system and the trajectory of our world’s climate. All
three thinkers believe that some measure of degrowth or the stoppage of growth is
essential to stop exacerbating the issues of carbon emissions. If degrowth is to occur
the three thinkers disagree slightly on how societal changes would need to occur for
society to continue to thrive and benefit. Hickel and Kallis are proponents for
improvements in quality of life and changes in mindset. Saito is not in direct contrast to
Gathje 4
this but rather begins to lean more heavily on his Marxist ideals by promoting the
principles of communism and other changes. Hickel’s main factor for changing quality of
life would be a change in wealth mentality from possessions to health, education, and
leisure time. Kallis would likely agree with this point as both of these economic thinkers
are proponents of shortening work hours to promote general quality of life among “the
common man”. These factors would shift the situation from the current status of
Laborers being exploited to promote other people’s wealth but instead allow these
laborers to have a bit more control over their daily lives. Kallis has a more communityminded approach than Hickel and offers ideas of work sharing, cooperative housing,
and other things of this nature. Another common theme among these thinkers is their
belief that under the current trajectory, there is not enough time or evidence to support
that we are or will defeat climate change. Hickel and Saito both discuss absolute
decoupling as I previously mentioned because that will be a requirement for our world to
truly achieve success on the front of Climate change. I think the two sections from
Hickel and Kallis as well as Saito’s ideas all point to several wider issues within society.
One of these points is the various levels of wealth inequality among many capitalist
societies. This may initially seem like an unimportant issue that has little to do with
climate change, but I disagree. Wealth inequality leads many humans in society to have
differing qualities of life and therefore differing interests and concerns. Take for example
a working man or woman who works overtime every night and makes barely enough to
feed and support their family. This person does not care about climate change and the
incoming disasters that could come from it because this person has much more
immediate and pressing disasters that are sure to come. On the contrary, those who are
benefiting from Capitalism have little reason or desire to achieve income equality
because this would lead to a reduction in what they have and that is just not how human
nature tends to operate. From these two simple but opposite situations we can see why
many people do not care about or take the time to consider climate change. Therefore,
the point I am trying to make is that if governments promote income equality, quality of
life, and other basic rights to support and guarantee survival then humanity would be
able to have a more united front against climate change. I agree with the principles and
the logic that these economic thinkers discuss to alter capitalism and promote climate
Gathje 5
change, but I think that they ignore many simple factors that lead to many humans not
caring about the arguments that they propose in their articles and papers. In conclusion,
I lean closest to Hickel’s arguments that first, we need to achieve a change in the way
that our society thinks about success and wealth. If we can achieve greater income
equality as well as change how our society views said wealth then I think people will
begin to explore greater concerns outside of their immediate fight to maintain wealth or
survive desperate situations.
Gathje 6
Citations
Saito, Kohei. Slow Down: The Degrowth Manifesto. Translated by Jamie Mackay, Polity
Press, 2022.
Hickel, Jason. “Degrowth: A Theory of Radical Abundance.” Ecological Economics, vol.
170, 2020, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2019.106549.
Kallis, Giorgos, et al. “Research on Degrowth.” Annual Review of Environment and
Resources, vol. 43, 2018, pp. 291–316, https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-environ102017-025941.