PROJECT MANAGEMENT K. Mare Learning Objectives • • • • • Having completed this course participants will be able to: Describe the main aspects of the project lifecycle and detail the major responsibilities of a project manager Explain the effect of the project parameters of project Scope, time, cost and performance in establishing the project and its execution. Summarise the process of obtaining Human Resources and contracting for building project teams Describe the systems & procedures for project execution and application of PERT/CPM for scheduling and monitoring projects. Identify techniques for Project direction, coordination and control. 1 The Nature of Projects and Project Management Concepts Chapter Objectives At the end of the chapter the learner shall be able to; Define a project and its attributes Define project management and its application. Describe project management and key elements of the project management framework. Understand the nine knowledge areas Discuss the relationship between project, programme, and portfolio mgt and their contribution to organisational success Benefits of Project Management Definition A project is a temporary endeavour undertaken to create a unique product, service or result (Clements and Gido, 2012:04). A project is temporary in that it has a defined beginning and end in time, and therefore defined scope and resources. Definition Project Management is a set of principles and techniques for effective planning, scheduling, execution and controlling of projects to produce the desired outcomes. In other words, it provides an organization with powerful tools that improve the organization's ability to plan, organize, lead and control unique and sensitive activities to give them better chances for success. Project V operations What is not a project? A project is distinguished from regular work in that it’s a one-time effort to change things in some way. So the creation of a new web site would be a project; ongoing maintenance and minor updates would not. Project management is applicable to small as well as very large projects e.g Building the Titanic or a small activity like lighting a fire without matches. DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PROJECT AND OPERATION PROJECT A project is temporary The project is undertaken to produce a unique output, for example, a product, service, or a result. A project has a definitive start and end: It cannot continue forever. It has to end when the objective is achieved, or it is terminated. Projects have a fixed budget OPERATION Operations are permanent in nature, and their only constraint is to make profit for the organisation. Operations don’t produce anything new, but they are necessary to maintain and sustain the system. Operations are ongoing. Operations are used to run regular business models, achieve the goals of the business, and sustain the business. Operations have to earn a profit in order to run the business. Project Characteristics A project is not normal day to day activity undertaken by organization rather it is specific, non-routine activity of varying time frame and impact viability of the business in the long run. A typical project has the following characteristics: Project Characteristics Are unique in nature. Have a defined timescale. Have an approved budget. Have limited resources. Involve an element of risk and uncertainty Achieve beneficial change. Clear objective with specific deliverable A project has a sponsor or customer A project is carried through a series of interdependent tasks The Triple Constraints The balance quadrant Projects must be delivered within cost Projects must be delivered on time Projects must meet the agreed scope – no more, no less Projects must also meet customer quality requirements The balance quadrant demonstrates the interrelationship between the four aspects and how a change to one aspect will unbalance the quadrant. For instance, an increase in the project’s scope will have an impact on the time, the cost, and the quality of the project. The balance quadrant Why you need to understand the triple constraints These are the primary competing project constraints that you have to be most aware of though there may be additional constraints You have to balance the needs of these constraints against the needs of the stakeholders and your project goals. For instance, if your sponsor wants to add functionality to the original scope, you will very likely need more money to finish the project, Why you need to understand the triple constraints Or if they cut the budget, you will have to reduce the quality of your scope, and if you don’t get the appropriate resources to work on your project tasks, you will have to extend your schedule because the resources you have take much longer to finish the work. The constraints are all dependent on each other. Why you need to understand the triple constraints As a project manager, you need to educate your customers about project management's triple constraint or balanced quadrant; any project decision you or your clients make will have an impact on these four aspects—might make the project more expensive, take longer, be of lower or higher quality, or affect its scope? Project Stakeholders • • • • • Stakeholders are the people involved in or affected by project activities. Key stakeholders can make or break the success of a project. The most key of all stakeholders is the customer. Even if all the deliverables are met and the objectives are satisfied, if the customer is not happy then the project has failed. Stakeholders cannot be classified under one umbrella as they have different interests, there are positive and negative stakeholders. Project Stakeholders • Stakeholders include: • • • • • • • • Project sponsor Project manager Project team Support staff Customers Users Suppliers Opponents to the project Stakeholder Relations Tips Analyze stakeholders Assess influence Understand their expectations Define “success” Keep stakeholders involved Keep stakeholders informed Objectives of Project Management The basic purpose for initiating a project is to accomplish some goals. The reason for organizing the task as a project is to give the endeavour complete attention. Project Management fulfils two purposes: Technical: Documentation techniques to generate and communicate the plan, Human: Managerial skills to be a better 'manager' of people as well as the project Technical and Human Objectives The project management tools and principles provide the means for project breakdown into tasks and sub-tasks finding interdependencies between the tasks allocating resources, human and material and smoothing resources estimation for total project duration and budget monitoring more efficiently project progress Project life cycle phases A typical project is divided into 5 phases; 1. Initiation Phase: Brainstorming is done to solve the problem or grab an opportunity and feasibility studies are undertaken. “Project Charter” is an essential outcome of this phase. 2. Planning: Plans and project objectives are set to manage cost, quality, risk, changes and time. Covers the list of activities, the time frame, dependencies, constraints, and potential risks. Project life cycle phases 1. 2. 3. Executing: Activities and milestones established earlier are executed in a timely and orderly manner. This phase utilizes maximum of all resources. Controlling: Involves measuring the performance of the project and tracking progress. It begins in the execution phase. Closing: Project deliverable is handed to the customer or is handed over to the operations team for commercial production. Project life cycle phases 9 Project Management Knowledge Areas PMBOK recognises nine knowledge areas typical of almost all projects It can be divided into four core elements: n n n n Scope Time Cost Quality 9 Project Management Knowledge Areas The other knowledge areas provide the means of achieving the deliverable objectives, namely: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Integration Human resources Communication Risk Procurement. The duties of a Project manager Activity and resource planning Organizing and motivating a project team Controlling time management Cost estimating and developing the budget Ensuring customer satisfaction Analysing and managing project risk Monitoring progress Managing reports and necessary documentation Suggested Skills for Project Managers • • • • • • Communication skills: Listens, persuades. Organizational skills: Plans, sets goals, analyzes. Team-building skills: Shows empathy, motivates, promotes esprit de corps. Leadership skills: Sets examples, provides vision (big picture), delegates, positive, energetic. Coping skills: Flexible, creative, patient, persistent. Technology skills: Experience, project knowledge. 2 Project Initiation Defining the project outcomes Outcomes are the events, occurrences, or changes in conditions, behavior, or attitudes that indicate progress toward a project’s goals. Stating in advance project outcomes provide guidance during the execution and help ensure your project’s overall success. Outcomes are specific, measurable, and meaningful. Defining the project outcomes Outcomes are not: Activities or processes (hosting an event is an activity, increasing awareness is an outcome). Immeasurable long-term change. Often project outcomes are not fully achieved because: Project outcomes were not clearly defined at the onset; Outcomes were changed but not communicated; Stakeholders were not all aligned; or Objectives were incapable of being measured. Value of Outcomes By focusing on project outcomes, You can Pick performance problems early, execute project activities that deliver the intended outcomes, and more easily measure and demonstrate results. Stakeholder consultation A project is successful if stakeholders are satisfied therefore, you must identify the stakeholders at the onset of the project and manage them throughout the life cycle. The project team identifies internal and external, positive and negative, and performing and advising stakeholders in order to determine the project requirements and the expectations of all parties involved. Stakeholder consultation The project manager should manage the influences of these various stakeholders in relation to the project requirements to ensure a successful outcome. Stakeholders have varying levels of responsibility and authority when participating on a project. This level can change over the course of the project’s life cycle. Stakeholder consultation Their involvement may range from occasional contributions in surveys and focus groups to full project sponsorship which includes providing financial, political, or other support. Some stakeholders may also detract from the success of the project, either passively or actively. These stakeholders require the project manager’s attention throughout the project’s life cycle, as well as planning to address any issues they may raise Stakeholder identification Stakeholder identification is a continuous process throughout the entire project life cycle. Identifying stakeholders, understanding their relative degree of influence on a project, and balancing their demands, needs, and expectations are critical to the success of the project. Failure to do so can lead to delays, cost increases, unexpected issues, and other negative consequences including project cancellation. Stakeholder identification An important part of a project manager’s responsibility is to manage stakeholder expectations, which can be difficult because stakeholders often have very different or conflicting objectives. Part of the project manager’s responsibility is to balance these interests and ensure that the project team interacts with stakeholders in a professional and cooperative manner. List of stakeholders Sponsor. A sponsor is the person or group who provides resources and support for the project and is accountable for enabling success. The sponsor may be external or internal to the project manager’s organization. The sponsor leads the project through the initiating processes until formally authorized, and plays a significant role in the development of the initial scope and charter. For issues that are beyond the control of the project manager, the sponsor serves as an escalation path. The sponsor may also be involved in other important issues such as authorizing changes in scope, phase-end reviews, and go/no-go decisions when risks are particularly high. The sponsor also ensures a smooth transfer of the project’s deliverables into the business of the requesting organization after project closure. List of stakeholders Customers and users. Customers are the persons or organizations who will approve and manage then project’s product, service, or result. Users are the persons or organizations who will use the project’s product, service, or result. Customers and users may be internal or external to the performing organization and may also exist in multiple layers. For example, the customers for a new pharmaceutical product could include the doctors who prescribe it, the patients who use it and the insurers who pay for it. In some application areas, customers and users are synonymous, while in others, customers refer to the entity acquiring the project’s product, and users refer to those who will directly utilize the project’s product. List of stakeholders • • Sellers. Sellers, also called vendors, suppliers, or contractors, are external companies that enter into a contractual agreement to provide components or services necessary for the project. Business partners. Business partners are external organizations that have a special relationship with the enterprise, sometimes attained through a certification process. Business partners provide specialized expertise or fill a specified role such as installation, customization, training, or support. List of stakeholders • • • Organizational groups. Organizational groups are internal stakeholders who are affected by the activities of the project team. E.g marketing and sales, HR, legal, finance, operations, manufacturing, and customer service. There is generally a significant amount of interaction between the various business elements of an organization and the project team as they work together to achieve project goals. These groups may provide input to requirements and accept deliverables necessary for a smooth transition to production or related operations. List of stakeholders Functional managers. The functional manager may provide subject matter expertise or their function may provide services to the project. Members of functional teams may also be assigned to work in project teams thereby creating a dual reporting system. Other stakeholders. Additional stakeholders, such as procurement entities, financial institutions, government regulators, subject matter experts, consultants, and others, may have a financial interest in the project, contribute inputs to the project, or have an interest in the outcome of the project. STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION PROCESS Planning questions; What are the aims and objectives? Who are the key stakeholder groups? How accessible are they? Are there any hard-to-reach groups? How can their co-operation and engagement be gained? What is the best method of consulting with the groups? What do they need to see beforehand? How can this be disseminated? Will any pre-consultation be required to prepare stakeholders for the exercise? STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION PROCESS The process; The “process” stage is the “doing” stage; this involves carrying out the consultation. Good planning will ensure this stage runs smoothly. Considerations in this stage mainly centre on developing effective relationships with stakeholders and facilitating open and honest sharing of views, and accurate recording of the process and the data. STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION PROCESS Presentation; The next stage, “presentation“, is concerned with the analysis and the reporting of the data. The data will need to be analysed and reporting prepared for the relevant audiences i.e. back to the corporation, to policy makers, etc. but also feedback to those who have engaged in the process and taken part. The form of reporting will need to take into account audiences and ensure the highest possibility of actions as a result of the consultation. STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION PROCESS Promise; The final stage relates to the promise. Part of the process of engaging with stakeholders is the investment in a longer-term relationship of mutual benefit and trust. Without demonstrable use of stakeholder feedback in resultant action, this can be damaged. The final stage, therefore, has an element of PR contained within it; communications about resultant actions need to be carefully considered to reach stakeholder audiences. Determining the scope of the project Project scope— is the work that must be done in order to deliver a product with the specified features and functions. Project Scope Management are the processes required to ensure that the project includes all the work required, and only the work required, to complete the project successfully. It is primarily concerned with defining and controlling what is or is not included in the project. Importance of defining scope Define the boundaries of the project. Improves accuracy of cost, duration, and resource estimates Defines baseline for performance measurement and control Facilitates clear responsibility assignments Identify constraints that limit a project team’s options for developing a solution. List assumptions regarding decisions outside the project team’s control. Dangers of Poor scope definition Poor scope definition results in: Higher final project costs Changes that disrupt the project rhythm Rework Increase in project time Lower productivity Lower morale of workforce Steps to Developing a Project Scope Statement 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Understand why the project was initiated. Define the key objectives of the project. Outline the project statement of work. Identify major deliverables. Select key milestones. Identify major constraints. List scope exclusions. Write an official project scope statement and get the client to sign Scope Creep What is Scope Creep? Scope creep in project management happens when additional features, functions, requirements or work are added beyond the agreed-upon scope with no consideration to impacts on time, cost and resources or stakeholders/customer approval. Reasons for scope creep Scope definition (unclear, ambiguous, and unrefined, etc.) Poor management of scope and requirements (change management wasn’t followed) Inconsistent collection of project requirements Stakeholders’ or sponsor engagement (lack of sponsorship or stakeholder involvement) Length of a project (the longer a project, the greater the chance for scope creep) 3 Project Planning Stage Project planning is the process of defining your objectives and scope, your goals and milestones (deliverables), and assigning tasks and budgetary resources for each step. A good plan is easily shareable with everyone involved, and it’s most useful when it’s revisited regularly. Project planning is often used to organize different areas of a project, including project plans, work loads and the management of teams and individuals. Reasons for planning to understand your project better to work out the best way to approach things to communicate to both your team and the client or customer exactly how the project is going to be approached to help you get work done and keep track of progress to provide direction Establishing the project goals The very first step in all projects is to define goals and objectives. This step defines the projects outcome and the steps required to achieve that outcome. Poorly defined goals and objectives, or goals without objectives, pushes a project into overruns, territory battles, personality clashes, missed milestones, and unhappy clients. Goals and objectives must be clear statements of purpose. Each with its own purpose that drives the end result of the project and they must be measurable. Goals and Objectives Goals and objectives are statements that describe what the project will accomplish, or the business value the project will achieve. Goals are high level statements that provide overall context for what the project is trying to achieve, and should align to business goals. Objectives are lower level statements that describe the specific, tangible products and deliverables that the project will deliver. The statement of work A Statement of Work (SOW) is a document within a contract that describes the work requirements for a specific project along with its performance and design expectations. The main purpose of the SOW is to define the liabilities, responsibilities and work agreements between parties. SOW should be written in precise language that is relevant to the field of business. This prevents misinterpretations of terms and requirements. Contents of SOW Purpose and scope of work Deliverables and due dates Location of work Tasks that make up the deliverables Task responsibility distribution Deliverables timeline Criteria for acceptance Payment schedule Importance of SOW A Statement of Work Shows Your Project Stakeholders Your Methods SOW show contractors and internal teams what you require from them. SOW also show the clients and stakeholders how the work will be tackled and may be useful in winning a tender. Once they have evaluated the SOW, they will approve it if they are satisfied. Milestones and schedules o o o o o o Planning a project schedule is a 6-step process: Break down the project into pieces small enough to work with Identify dependencies. Estimate how long each piece will take. Add some contingency. Consider the risks. Represent the plan in a format that the team, board, and stakeholders will understand. Work Breakdown structure The Project Management Body of Knowledge defines the work-breakdown structure as a "hierarchical decomposition of the total scope of work to be carried out by the project team to accomplish the project objectives and create the required deliverables. A work breakdown structure defines all the things a project needs to accomplish, organized into multiple levels, and displayed graphically. Work Breakdown structure The WBS describes everything you need to accomplish in the project in a chart. The purpose of this chart is to break down complex activities into smaller, management constituents. Example 1Yard project WBS Example 2 WBS for bicycle assembly Project Charter The project charter is a document that officially starts a project or a phase. It formally authorizes the existence of the project and provides a reference source for the future. A project charter names the project manager and defines the authority of the project manager. It gives the project manager the power to utilize organizational resources to accomplish the project objectives. Project Charter It covers the scope of what the project will achieve, as well as the people involved, milestones, budget, and possible risks. Many organizations consider this document as an essential part of project planning—although it's not the same thing as a project plan because it doesn't get into the details of individual tasks within the project. It thus precedes the work breakdown structure. Project Charter Project Charter is issued during the Project Initiation It is used as the basis to create the Project Plan. The Project Charter contains the following attributes within it: Project Scope Project Authority Critical Success Factors Purpose of project charter Outline the project scope and objectives Ensure project sponsors and all stakeholders are in alignment on a project Be a clear, single reference for all involved in a project Help project sponsors get approval of stakeholders when buy-in is still needed Act as a contract between the project sponsor, key stakeholders and the project team. The project Budget The Project Budget is a tool used by project managers to estimate the total cost of a project. A project budget template includes a detailed estimate of all costs that are likely to be incurred before the project is completed. The project Budget Budget inputs WBS Project contract or initial budget Resource requirements Resource cost estimates Activity duration estimates Historical information Market conditions Donor and organization policies The project Budget Budget Outputs Outputs: The project team will use the above information to develop three important documents for the project: Cost estimates by activity The Project Budget The Budget Variance Report Project Roles The project manager documenting the detailed project plan; Availing project resources; managing assigned resources according to the defined scope of the project; implementing the project processes(time/cost/ quality/change/risk/issue/ procurement/ communication/acceptance management); Project Roles The project manager monitoring and reporting project performance (schedule, cost, quality and risk); ensuring compliance with the processes and standards outlined in the quality plan; adjusting the project plan to monitor and control the progress of the project; reporting and escalating project risks and issues; managing project interdependencies. Project Roles The project team: Each project team member undertakes the tasks necessary to design, build and implement the final solution. Responsibilities include: completing tasks allocated by the project manager; reporting progress to the project manager on a frequent basis; maintaining documentation relating to the execution of allocated tasks; escalating risks and issues to be addressed by the project manager. Project Teams In order to kick start the project there is need to first establish the project team that will shoulder the responsibility of the project. The Project Team Is comprised of the people with assigned roles and responsibility for completing the project and they are led by the project manager. As a precursor to project team there is need for an HR plan first. Develop Human Resource Plan Human Resource plan provides guidance on how project human resources should be defined, staffed, managed, controlled, and eventually released, it includes: - Roles and Responsibilities - Project Organization Charts. - Staffing management plan: - Staff acquisition. 37 Develop Human Resource Plan Human Resource plan - Resource calendar. - Staff release plan. - Training needs. - Recognition & Rewards. - Complains & Safety. 47 Project Organisational Structure The choice of organisation structure is key to the success of a project. A good structure can be a source of strength that give the project a distinct advantage. The essential qualities in all structures is that they should clarify authority lines, identify the main roles in the project and the responsible officers in charge of them, and spell out the sub teams that make up the project for easier control and sharing of project resources. Project Organisational Structure Functional Organisation structure Most popular for regular operations Project team operate within existing functional departments and the functional head such as operations manager or IT manager has the ultimate authority. Project Organisational Structure Projectized Organisational structure Give the project manager complete authority Team members may still be grouped on functional speciality lines but they are responsible over project roles only Project Organisational Structure Matrix Organisational structure Is a hybrid of the two earlier structures Creates a dual reporting structure -between the functional head and the project manager Project team members are not fully dedicated The Project team - The first step in building the Project Team is the process of confirming human resource availability and obtaining the team necessary to complete project assignment. - Then next is the process of improving the competencies, team interaction, and the overall team environment to enhance project performance. 97 The Project team - They should focus on developing and sustaining the project team throughout the project life cycle, and - promote working together interdependently in a climate of mutual trust. 08 The Project team - Project mangers should acquire skills to identify, build, maintain, motivate, lead, and - inspire project team to achieve high team performance and meet the project’s objectives. - Because of the differentiation among the project team, the project management team should capitalize on the cultural differences, 18 The Project team Objectives of developing a project team include: - Improve knowledge and skills. - Improve feeling of trust and agreement among team members. - Create a dynamic and cohesive team culture to improve both individual and team productivity, team spirit, and cooperation. 28 The Project team Stages of Project Team Development 1- Forming: this phase is where the team meets and learns about the project and what their formal roles and responsibilities are. . . 2- Storming: the begins to address the project work, technical decisions, and the project management approach. 38 The Project team Stages of Project Team Development 3- Norming: people know where they fit in, conflicts are resolved and there is a stronger sense of belonging to the group. 4- Performing: team that reach the performing stage function as a well-organized unit. . . 5- Adjourning: the team completes the work and moves on from the project. 48 Leading a Project Team 58 Manage Project Team Manage Project Team is the process of tracking team members performance, providing feedback, resolving issue, and managing changes to optimize project performance. The project management team observes team behavior, manages conflicts, resolves issues, and appraises team member performance. 68 Manage Project Team Team management involves a combination of skills with special emphasis on communication, conflict management, negotiation, and leadership. Project manger should provide challenging assignments to team members, and provide recognition for high performance. 78 4. Network Scheduling and Techniques Network FundamentalsRules in constructing a network 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. No single activity can be represented more than once in a network. The length of an arrow has no significance. The event numbered 1 is the start event and an event with highest number is the end event. Before an activity can be undertaken, all activities preceding it must be completed. That is, the activities must follow a logical sequence (or – interrelationship) between activities. In assigning numbers to events, there should not be any duplication of event numbers in a network. Dummy activities must be used only if it is necessary to reduce the complexity of a network. A network should have only one start event and one end event. Project Management Techniques There are several techniques utilized for project management. Some of the techniques are as follows, and they are mainly used for project scheduling. Gantt Charts: These charts are used to depict the project tasks against time. It monitors progress of individual project tasks and also highlights dependency if any between those project tasks. Gantt Chart MAR Locate new facilities Interview staff Hire and train staff Select and order furniture Remodel and install phones Move in/startup 17-91 APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Network Planning Techniques These techniques show the relationship between project activities, project duration, critical path, constraints of non-critical activities and resource utilization. There are two types of network planning techniques Critical Path Method (CPM) and Program Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT). Work Breakdown Structure Project X Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 17-93 PERT and CPM PERT: CPM: Program Evaluation and Review Technique Critical Path Method Graphically displays project activities Estimates how long the project will take Indicates most critical activities Show where delays will not affect project The Network Diagram Network (precedence) diagram – diagram of project activities that shows sequential relationships by the use of arrows and nodes. Activity-on-arrow (AOA) – a network diagram convention in which arrows designate activities. Activity-on-node (AON) – a network diagram convention in which nodes designate activities. Activities – steps in the project that consume resources and/or time. Events – the starting and finishing of activities, designated by nodes in the AOA convention. The Network Diagram (cont’d) Path Critical path Critical activities Slack 17-96 Sequence of activities that leads from the starting node to the finishing node The longest path; determines expected project duration Activities on the critical path Allowable slippage for path; the difference the length of path and the length of critical path Network Conventions a c a b c b a c b d a b c Dummy activity Network Conventions Example – Activity on Arc Activity Predecessor A - locate facilities B - Interview C - Order furniture A D - Remodel A E - Hire and train B F - Furniture setup C G - Move in F,D,E Time (Weeks) 8 4 6 11 9 3 1 Project Network – Activity on Arc AOA Locate facilities Order furniture 2 4 Remodel 1 Interview 3 Furniture setup 5 Hire and train Move in 6 Project Network – Activity on Node AON Locate facilities 1 Order furniture 2 Remodel 5 S Interview 3 Hire and train 4 Furniture setup 6 Move in 7 Example Activity A B C D E F Pred A C D B,E Example b a 9 5 c 17-103 2 f 4 d e 6 10 Example with Dummy Activity A B C D E F Pred A,B C B D,E Example 1 Solution Critical Path Path 1-2-3-4-5-6 Length (weeks) Slack 18 2 1-2-5-6 20 0 1-3-5-6 14 6 17-105 When to use dummy activity Dummy activity: An activity which does not consume any kind of resources but merely depicts the technological dependence is called a dummy activity. Dummy activity is inserted : i. ii. To make activities with common starting and finishing points distinguishable. To identify and maintain the proper precedence relationship between activities those are not connected by events. When to use dummy activity Lets consider a situation where A and B are concurrent activities and activity D is dependent on B and C is dependent on both A and B. Such a situation can be handled by use of dummy activity. When two or more activities are exactly parallel such that they would start at the same node (event) and finish at the same node. A dummy would be inserted between the end of one of the activities and the common finishing node. Time Estimates Deterministic Time estimates that are fairly certain Estimates of times that allow for variation Probabilistic Example 1 Deterministic time estimates 6 weeks 1 te a c Lo ilities fac In 4 weeks te rv iew 3 17-109 3 weeks re nitu Fur p setu 8 weeks 2 4 er e d r O itur n fur Rem ode l 11 weeks r Hi d n ea in tra 9 weeks 5 Move in 1 week 6 Computing Algorithm Network activities Used to determine 17-110 ES: early start EF: early finish LS: late start LF: late finish Expected project duration Slack time Critical path Probabilistic Time Estimates Optimistic time Time required under optimal conditions Time required under worst conditions Pessimistic time Most likely time Most probable length of time that will be required Time-cost Trade-offs: Crashing Crash – shortening activity duration Procedure for crashing Crash the project one period at a time Crash the least expensive activity Only an activity on the critical path Multiple critical paths: find the sum of crashing the least expensive activity on each critical path Advantages of PERT Forces managers to organize Provides graphic display of activities Identifies 17-113 Critical activities Slack activities Limitations of PERT Important activities may be omitted Precedence relationships may not be correct 4 Estimates may include a fudge factor May focus solely on critical path 2 1 5 142 weeks 3 6 Chapter 5 Project pricing and Estimations Global pricing strategies Types of estimates Pricing process Pricing out the work Systems pricing Estimating pitfalls Estimating high risk projects Overhead rates Project pricing and Estimations Project cost estimation is the process of predicting the quantity, cost, and price of the resources required by the scope of a project. Since cost estimation is about the prediction of costs rather than counting the actual cost, a certain degree of uncertainty is involved. This uncertainty arises from the fact that the project scope definition is never entirely complete until the project has been finished. Global pricing strategies one of two situations prevails when one is pursuing project acquisitions competitively. First, the new business opportunity may be a oneof-a-kind program with little or no follow-on potential, a situation classified as type I acquisition. Second, the new business opportunity may be an entry point to a larger follow-on or repeat business, or may represent a planned penetration into a new market. This acquisition is classified as type II. 2 GLOBAL PRICING STRATEGIES Type I Acquisition: One-of-a-Kind Program with Little or No Follow -On Business 1. Develop cost model and estimating guidelines; design proposed project/program baseline for minimum cost, to minimum customer requirements. 2. Estimate cost realistically for minimum requirements. 3. Scrub the baseline. Squeeze out unnecessary costs. 4. Determine realistic minimum cost. Obtain commitment from performing organizations. 5. Adjust cost estimate for risks. 6. Add desired margins. Determine the price. 7. Compare price to customer budget & competitive cost informn. 8. Bid only if price is within competitive range. 2 GLOBAL PRICING STRATEGIES Type II Acquisition: New Program with Potential for Large Follow -On Business or Representing a Desired Penetration into New Markets o Design proposed project/program baseline compliant with customer requirements, with innovative features but minimum risks. o o o o o Estimate cost realistically. Scrub baseline. Squeeze out unnecessary costs. Determine realistic minimum cost. Obtain commitment from performing organizations. Determine "should-cost" including risk adjustments. Compare your final cost estimate to customer budget and the "most likely" winning price. 2 GLOBAL PRICING STRATEGIES 1. 2. 3. 4. Determine the gross profit margin necessary for your winning proposal. This margin could be negative! Decide whether the gross margin is acceptable according to the must-win desire. Depending on the strength of your desire to win, bid the "most likely" winning price or lower. If the bid price is below cost, it is often necessary to provide a detailed explanation to the customer of where the additional funding is coming from. The source could be company profits or sharing of related activities. In any case, a clear resource picture should be given to the customer to ensure cost credibility. Types of estimates 1. 2. Order-of-magnitude analysis - made without any detailed engineering data. Use past experience (not necessarily similar), scale factors, parametric curves or capacity estimates, accurate to ±35%. Approximate estimate (or top-down estimate) made without detailed e data, accurate to ±15%. Estimate is prorated from previous projects than in scope and capacity, and may be done by rule of thumb, or cost of similar activities adjusted for capacity and technology. Types of estimates 1. 2. The definitive estimate, or grassroots buildup estimate, is prepared from well-defined engineering data, vendor quotes, fairly complete plans, specifications, unit prices, etc. Also referred to as detailed estimating, has an accuracy of ±95 %. Use of learning curves. Learning curves are graphical represents repetitive functions in which continuous operations will lead to a reduction in time, resources, and mo theory behind learning curves is usually applied to manufacturing operations. Pricing process The pricing process requires development of a work-break-down structure, then one of 3 models can be adopted. o Fixed Price Model: the price for a project consists of the project costs plus certain markup added by the contractor. Works effectively when a project is characterized by well-defined requirements and well-elaborated plan – probably it is a standardized or recurring project. Pricing process 1. 2. Time and Material Price Model: the price for a project is reasoned by a unique amount of labour and materials consumed. Works well for a flexible and agile project execution where the client requires a great portion of individualized approach. Milestone-based Price Model: this way of project pricing is based upon a concept of progressive payments and is managed through progress monitoring by the customer who pays according to a visible milestone achieved and appraised level of progress done. Pricing out the work, step 1-13 Step 1: Provide a complete definition of the work Step 2: Establish a logic network with checkpoints. Step 3: Develop the work breakdown structure. Step 4: Price out the work breakdown structure. Step 5: Review WBS costs with each functional manager. Step 6: Decide on the basic course of action. Step 7: Establish reasonable costs for each WBS element. Step 8: Review the base case costs with upper-level management. Step 9: Negotiate with functional managers for qualified personnel. Step 10: Develop the linear responsibility chart. Step 11: Develop the final detailed and PERT/CPM schedules. Step 12: Establish pricing cost summary reports. Step 13: Document the result in a program plan. Estimating pitfalls There are many things that can undermine the accuracy or validity of your estimates. Some you have control over and many that you can’t really control. Pitfalls in cost estimating include failing to correctly estimate costs, including overhead, which will result in a low bid, but ultimately your company will lose money. In the event a company overestimates costs, the bid will be too high and your company will probably not get the job. Estimating high risk projects It is tempting at times to avoid looking objectively at the project when one is eager for business. A risk assessment should always be carried out, no matter the size of the project. Risk assessments are necessary for the following reasons: A good risk assessment will inform you as to whether or not the project is worth taking on. It will inform what contingencies need to be accounted for in order to avoid cost overruns. The bigger the risk, the more detailed the assessment Overhead rates Failure to account for overheads will hurt your profit margins. You need to have an accurate reading as to what your mean overheads are. As your business scales over time, your overhead costs should be reviewed accordingly. Project risk Management According to PMI’s PMBOK (Project Management Body of Knowledge), a risk is a “situation or condition that, if it occurs, has a positive or negative impact on project objectives.” Risk management exists with one purpose — to maximize the chances of project success. In project management, this is done by identifying risks, analyzing them, and creating response plans for each one. Tolerance of risk Risk and returns tend to move together so one cannot completely avoid risk. People (and organisations) have different risk tolerance i.e the level of risk they can accept. 3 levels of risk tolerance exist; 1. 2. o Risk avoider Risk neutral Risk lover Definition of Risk Management Risk management is the act or practice of dealing with risk. It includes: planning for risk, assessing risk issues, developing risk handling strategies, and monitoring risk to determine how they have changed. Certainty risk and uncertainty Decision-Making Categories Complete uncertainty Relative uncertainty (partial information) Complete certainty Complete uncertainty Certainty risk and uncertainty Developing and using pay off tables Five Steps To Develop Payoff Table List all the alternatives. List the future consequences of each alternative. Identify the payoffs associated with each combination. Assess the degree of certainty that these combinations will materialize Decide on a decision criterion. List all the alternatives. Risk management process Risk planning Risk assessment Risk identification Risk analysis/quantification Risk handling Risk monitoring Risk planning Risk planning is the first step in managing project risk. It is the acknowledgement of the presence of risk in the first place. It involves evaluation of different risk categories where risk can emanate e.g Technical, Cost, Schedule, Client, Contractual, Weather, Financial etc The past experience of the project team, project experience within the company, and experts in the industry can be valuable resources for identifying potential risk on a project. Risk Assessment Assessment of risk involves identifying the risk and quantifying or classifying. One common way of identifying risk is by brainstorming together with your team and stakeholders. Once you identify risks, you can begin to analyse them. This step includes analysing the likelihood, severity, and response plan for each risk you have found. Risk handling o o o o Every risk needs to be eliminated or contained. There are four possible responses to risk events: Avoid. Eliminate the threat. Transfer. Off-load the risk to a third party. Mitigate. Reduce the probability or impact of the risk event. Accept. Sometimes there is no other alternative than to proceed with the project and accept the risk. But producing documentation, holding meetings, and communicating the risk with stakeholders can go a long ways toward minimizing the damage. Risk monitoring This step is tracking the progress of the initiative chosen for risk resolvement. Whoever is in charge of the risk will also be responsible to monitor and report its progress towards resolution. Risk management process The risk management process is a framework for the actions that need to be taken. It begins with risk planning, then an assessment of the risks through risk identification and risk quantification, then a solution is implemented and finally, the risk is monitored. Modern developments in project management Select this paragraph to edit
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )