- No category
MAR & CECs: PRISMA Flow Diagram & Search Strings
advertisement
1 2 Supplementary Material 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 S1. PRISMA 2020 flow diagram for new systematic reviews which included searches of databases and registers only 39 *Consider, if feasible to do so, reporting the number of records identified from each database or register searched 40 (rather than the total number across all databases/registers). 41 **If automation tools were used, indicate how many records were excluded by a human and how many were 42 excluded by automation tools. 43 From: Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 44 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ 2021;372:n71. doi: 10.1136/bmj.n71 45 Screening Identification Identification of studies via databases and registers Records identified from*: Scopus (n = 1174) Web of Science (n = 726) Updated search (n = 131) Records removed before screening: Duplicate records removed (n = 440) Records marked as ineligible by automation tools (n = 0) Records removed for other reasons (n = 0) Records screened (title/abstract) (n = 1591) Records excluded** (n = 1440) Reports sought for retrieval (n = 151) Reports not retrieved (n = 0) Reports assessed for eligibility (n = 151) Reports excluded: Language (n = 4) Not focussed on subsurface transport/MAR (n = 19) Included Not focussed on emerging contaminants included in this review (n = 15) Studies included in review (n = 89) Exceeding 10 papers per contaminant group (n = 24) For more information, visit: http://www.prisma-statement.org/ 46 S2. Search strings for Scopus and Web of Science 47 48 ( TITLE-ABS-KEY ( "managed aquifer recharge" OR "groundwater recharge" OR "bank filtration" OR 49 "basin filtration" OR "artificial groundwater recharge" OR "sand filtration" ) ) AND ( TITLE-ABS-KEY 50 ( pollut* OR "contaminants of emerging concern" OR cecs OR fluorocarbons OR fluorocarbon OR 51 c8 OR pfas OR PFAS OR pfoa OR pfos OR pfhxs OR perfluoro* OR perfluorinated OR 52 "perfluorinated acid" 53 "perfluorooctanoic acid" OR "perfluorooctanesulfonic acid" OR "perfluorooctane sulfonic acid" OR 54 "perfluorooctane sulfonate" OR "perfluorinated alkylated substances" OR "Perfluorinated alkyl 55 substances" OR "perfluoroalkyl acids" OR pfaas OR "Perfluorohexane sulfonate" OR "perfluoroalkyl 56 substances" OR "perfluorosulfonic acids" OR pfsa OR "perfluorocarboxylic acids" OR pfca OR 57 "perfluorooctane sulfonic acid" OR "fluorinated organic compounds" OR "Perfluorohexanesulfonic 58 acid" OR "Perfluorohexane sulfonic acid" OR pesticides OR pesticide OR fungicides OR fungicide 59 OR herbicide OR herbicides OR insecticide OR insecticides OR plastic* OR microplastic* OR 60 nanoplastic* OR "plastic particles" OR nylon OR polyethylene OR hdpe OR ldpe OR 61 polyvinylchloride OR pet OR pete OR pvc OR polypropylene OR polystyrene OR styrofoam OR 62 pharmaceutical* OR phac* OR "pharmaceutically active compounds" OR hormones OR antibiotic 63 OR antidepressant OR anti-inflammatory OR drugs OR nanomaterial* OR "engineered 64 nanomaterial*" ) ) AND ( TITLE-ABS-KEY ( "removal efficiency" OR fate OR mobility OR removal 65 OR retention OR attenuation OR "subsurface transport" ) ) – Scopus, 1174 results 66 ( TS=( "managed aquifer recharge" OR "groundwater recharge" OR "bank filtration" OR "basin 67 filtration" OR "artificial groundwater recharge" OR "sand filtration" ) ) AND ( TS=( pollut* OR 68 "contaminants of emerging concern" OR cecs OR fluorocarbons OR fluorocarbon OR c8 OR pfas 69 OR PFAS OR pfoa OR pfos OR pfhxs OR perfluoro* OR perfluorinated OR "perfluorinated acid" 70 OR OR "perfluorinated substances" "perfluorinated substances" OR perfluorooctanoate 2 OR OR perfluorooctanoate "perfluorooctanoic acid" OR OR 71 "perfluorooctanesulfonic acid" OR "perfluorooctane sulfonic acid" OR "perfluorooctane sulfonate" 72 OR "perfluorinated alkylated substances" OR "Perfluorinated alkyl substances" OR "perfluoroalkyl 73 acids" 74 "perfluorosulfonic acids" OR pfsa OR "perfluorocarboxylic acids" OR pfca OR "perfluorooctane 75 sulfonic acid" OR "fluorinated organic compounds" OR "Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid" OR 76 "Perfluorohexane sulfonic acid" OR pesticides OR pesticide OR fungicides OR fungicide OR 77 herbicide OR herbicides OR insecticide OR insecticides OR plastic* OR microplastic* OR 78 nanoplastic* OR "plastic particles" OR nylon OR polyethylene OR hdpe OR ldpe OR 79 polyvinylchloride OR pet OR pete OR pvc OR polypropylene OR polystyrene OR styrofoam OR 80 pharmaceutical* OR phac* OR "pharmaceutically active compounds" OR hormones OR antibiotic 81 OR antidepressant OR anti-inflammatory OR drugs OR nanomaterial* OR "engineered 82 nanomaterial*" ) ) AND ( TS=( "removal efficiency" OR fate OR mobility OR removal OR retention 83 OR attenuation OR "subsurface transport" ) ) – Web of Science, 726 results OR pfaas OR "Perfluorohexane sulfonate" 84 3 OR "perfluoroalkyl substances" OR 85 S3. Data table for reviewed literature reporting CEC partitioning coefficients and MAR removal 86 efficiencies 87 CEC type CEC class Removal [%] MAR system Study type log Kow log Koc Reference 1,5-Naphtalindisulfonat PPCPs 52 MAR Field NA NA [1] 17α-Ethynylestradiol PPCPs NA MAR Column 4,10 NA [2] 17α-Ethynylestradiol PPCPs NA MAR Review 3,67 4,68 [3] 17β-Estradiol Pesticides NA MAR Column 3,90 NA [2] 17β-Estradiol Pesticides NA MAR Field + batch 3,94 NA [4] 17β-Estradiol Pesticides NA MAR Review 4,01 4,21 [3] 1-Eicosanol PPCPs NA MAR Column 8,70 4,58 [5] 1-Tridecanol PPCPs NA MAR Column 5,26 4,56 [5] Acesulfame PPCPs NA SAT Field NA NA [6] Acesulfame PPCPs NA MAR Field -1,33 NA [7] Acesulfame PPCPs 66 MAR Field NA NA [8] Acesulfame PPCPs NA MAR Field -1,33 NA [9] Acesulfame PPCPs NA MAR Review -1,33 1,30 [3] Acesulfame PPCPs 34 MAR Field NA NA [10] Acesulfame PPCPs 10 MAR Field NA NA [11] Acesulfame PPCPs 93 SMART Field NA NA [11] Acesulfame PPCPs 75 SAT Column NA NA [12] Acesulfame PPCPs 1 MAR Column NA 0,86 [13] Acetaminophen PPCPs NA MAR Review 0,46 1,60 [3] Acetaminophen PPCPs 55 MAR Column + batch 0,46 NA [14] Acetaminophen PPCPs 75 MAR Column 0,46 NA [15] 4 Acyclovir PPCPs 84 SAT Field NA NA [6] Adenine PPCPs NA MAR Column -0,05 2,09 [5] Ametryn Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 2,98 2,59 [16] Atenolol PPCPs 93 SAT Field NA NA [6] Atenolol PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,16 NA [9] Atenolol PPCPs 96 SAT Field NA NA [17] Atenolol PPCPs 99 MAR Field + batch NA NA [18] Atenolol PPCPs 99 SMART Field + batch NA NA [18] Atenolol PPCPs 45 MAR Column + batch 0,16 NA [14] Atenolol PPCPs 100 MAR Column 0,16 NA [15] Atrazine Pesticides 7 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Atrazine Pesticides NA MAR Review 2,61 2,36 [3] Atrazine Pesticides not effective MAR Field + batch NA NA [18] Atrazine Pesticides not effective SMART Field + batch NA NA [18] Atrazine Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 2,61 2,24 [16] Atrazine Pesticides 16 MAR Column 2,61 NA [15] Benzoic acid PPCPs NA MAR Column 1,87 2,16 [5] Benzophenone Industrial 91 SAT Field NA NA [6] Benzophenone Industrial NA MAR Column 3,18 3,80 [5] Benzotriazole Industrial NA SAT Field NA NA [6] Benzotriazole Industrial NA MAR Field 1,44 NA [7] Benzotriazole Industrial 51 MAR Field NA NA [8] Benzotriazole Industrial NA MAR Review 1,44 2,17 [3] Benzotriazole Industrial 56 MAR Field NA NA [10] Benzotriazole Industrial 10 MAR Field NA NA [11] 5 Benzotriazole Industrial 83 SMART Field NA NA [11] Benzotriazole Industrial 79 SAT Column NA NA [12] Benzotriazole Industrial 72 MAR Field NA NA [20] Benzotriazole Industrial 0 MAR Column NA 1,25 [13] Benzotriazole Industrial 3 MAR Column NA NA [21] Bezafibrate PPCPs 96 SAT Field NA NA [6] Bezafibrate PPCPs 100 MAR Field 4,25 NA [7] Bezafibrate PPCPs 61 MAR Field NA NA [8] Bezafibrate PPCPs NA MAR Field 4,25 NA [9] Bezafibrate PPCPs NA MAR Review NA 3,82 [22] Bisphenol A Plastic NA MAR Column 3,60 NA [2] Bisphenol A Plastic NA MAR Review 3,32 3,35 [3] Bisphenol A Plastic 0 MAR Field NA NA [10] Caffeine PPCPs 95 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Caffeine PPCPs NA MAR Field -0,07 NA [9] Caffeine PPCPs 90 MAR Review -0,07 1,00 [3] Caffeine PPCPs 97 MAR Field + batch NA NA [18] Caffeine PPCPs 98 SMART Field + batch NA NA [18] Caffeine PPCPs 62 MAR Column -0,07 NA [15] Caffeine PPCPs 71 MAR Field NA NA [20] Candesartan PPCPs 0 MAR Field 2,79 NA [7] Candesartan PPCPs NA MAR Field 4,79 NA [9] Candesartan PPCPs 8 MAR Column NA NA [21] Carbamazepine PPCPs 16 SAT Field NA NA [6] Carbamazepine PPCPs NA MAR Column 2,30 NA [2] 6 Carbamazepine PPCPs 10 MAR Field 2,45 NA [7] Carbamazepine PPCPs 15 MAR Field NA NA [8] Carbamazepine PPCPs 2 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Carbamazepine PPCPs NA MAR Field 2,45 NA [9] Carbamazepine PPCPs 0 SAT Field NA NA [17] Carbamazepine PPCPs NA MAR Review 2,45 2,62 [3] Carbamazepine PPCPs NA MAR Review NA 2,70 [22] Carbamazepine PPCPs 2 MAR Column NA NA [21] Carbamazepine PPCPs 37 MAR Review 2,45 NA [23] Carbamazepine PPCPs 12 MAR Field NA NA [10] Carbamazepine PPCPs NA MAR Column + batch 2,45 NA [14] Carbamazepine PPCPs 27 MAR Field NA NA [24] Carbamazepine PPCPs 65 MAR Field NA NA [25] Carbamazepine PPCPs 10 MAR Column 2,45 NA [15] Carbamazepine PPCPs 73 MAR Column 2,45 NA [26] Carbamazepine PPCPs 10 MAR Field NA NA [11] Carbamazepine PPCPs 10 SMART Field NA NA [11] Carbamazepine PPCPs 75 SAT Column NA NA [12] Carbamazepine PPCPs 36 MAR Field NA NA [20] Carbamazepine PPCPs 11 MAR Column NA 2,35 [13] Cefepime PPCPs 42 MAR Field NA NA [10] Cetylalcohol PPCPs NA MAR Column 6,73 4,57 [5] Chlorpyrifos Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 5,27 3,70 [16] Climbazol PPCPs 95 SAT Field NA NA [6] Clofibric acid PPCPs NA MAR Column + batch 2,88 NA [14] 7 Codeine PPCPs 88 SAT Field NA NA [6] Decanoic acid PPCPs NA MAR Column 4,09 4,46 [5] DEET Pesticides 100 MAR Field 2,02 NA [7] DEET Pesticides 24 SAT Field NA NA [17] DEET Pesticides 90 MAR Review 2,18 2,73 [3] DEET Pesticides 50 MAR Field + batch NA NA [18] DEET Pesticides 78 SMART Field + batch NA NA [18] DEET Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 2,18 2,47 [16] DEET Pesticides 95 MAR Field NA NA [20] Diacetone alcohol PPCPs NA MAR Column -0,34 2,06 [5] Diatrizoate PPCPs 10 SAT Field NA NA [6] Diatrizoic acid PPCPs 33 MAR Field NA NA [8] Diatrizoic acid PPCPs 17 MAR Column NA NA [21] Diazinon Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 3,81 2,75 [16] Diclofenac PPCPs 96 SAT Field NA NA [6] Diclofenac PPCPs NA MAR Field 4,51 NA [7] Diclofenac PPCPs 36 MAR Field NA NA [8] Diclofenac PPCPs 77 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Diclofenac PPCPs NA MAR Field 4,02 NA [9] Diclofenac PPCPs 55 SAT Field NA NA [17] Diclofenac PPCPs NA MAR Review 4,51 2,92 [3] Diclofenac PPCPs NA MAR Review NA 3,84 [22] Diclofenac PPCPs 80 MAR Column NA NA [21] Diclofenac PPCPs 60 MAR Review 4,01 NA [23] Diclofenac PPCPs 38 MAR Field NA NA [10] 8 Diclofenac PPCPs 76 MAR Field + batch NA NA [18] Diclofenac PPCPs 85 SMART Field + batch NA NA [18] Diclofenac PPCPs 80 MAR Review NA NA [27] Diclofenac PPCPs 42 MAR Column + batch 4,51 NA [14] Diclofenac PPCPs 35 MAR Column 0,70 NA [15] Diclofenac PPCPs 62 MAR Column 4,51 NA [26] Diclofenac PPCPs 79 SAT Column NA NA [12] Diclofenac PPCPs 100 MAR Field NA NA [20] Diclofenac PPCPs 22 MAR Column NA NA [13] Dimethyl maleate PPCPs NA MAR Column 0,74 2,24 [5] Diuron Pesticides 68 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Diuron Pesticides NA MAR Review 2,68 2,13 [3] Diuron Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 2,58 2,21 [16] Diuron Pesticides NA MAR Field + batch 2,68 NA [4] DOC OM 16 MAR Batch NA NA [19] DOC OM 52 SAT Field NA NA [17] DOC OM significant SAT Review NA NA [28] DOC OM effective MAR Review NA NA [29] DOC OM 50 MAR Field + batch NA NA [18] DOC OM 67 SMART Field + batch NA NA [18] DOC OM 27 MAR Field NA NA [30] DOC OM 38 SAT Column NA NA [12] EDTA Industrial NA MAR Field -1,86 NA [7] EDTA Industrial 15 MAR Review -1,86 NA [23] Estriol PPCPs NA MAR Column 2,45 3,78 [5] 9 Estrone PPCPs NA MAR Review 3,13 4,48 [3] Estrone PPCPs 80 MAR Column + batch 3,13 NA [14] Fenoprofen PPCPs 59 MAR Column 3,90 NA [26] Fluconazol PPCPs 10 SAT Field NA NA [6] Fluoxetine PPCPs 97 SAT Field NA NA [17] Gabapentin PPCPs NA MAR Field -1,10 NA [7] Gabapentin PPCPs 77 MAR Field NA NA [8] Gabapentin PPCPs 20 MAR Column NA NA [21] Gabapentin PPCPs 17 MAR Field NA NA [11] Gabapentin PPCPs 58 SMART Field NA NA [11] Gabapentin PPCPs 79 SAT Column NA NA [12] Gabapentin PPCPs 91 MAR Field NA NA [20] Gabapentin-lactam PPCPs NA MAR Field 1,91 NA [7] Gabapentin-lactam PPCPs 89 MAR Field NA NA [11] Gabapentin-lactam PPCPs 94 SMART Field NA NA [11] Gemfibrozil PPCPs 99 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Gemfibrozil PPCPs 92 SAT Field NA NA [17] Gemfibrozil PPCPs 90 MAR Review NA NA [3] Gemfibrozil PPCPs 79 MAR Column 4,77 NA [15] Gemfibrozil PPCPs 69 MAR Column 4,77 NA [26] Guanine PPCPs NA MAR Column -1,77 2,13 [5] Haxazione Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 1,85 2,78 [16] Heavy metals Metals Al, Pb, Zn MAR Review NA NA [28] Ibuprofen PPCPs 99 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Ibuprofen PPCPs 47 SAT Field NA NA [17] 10 Ibuprofen PPCPs 46 MAR Column + batch 3,97 NA [14] Ibuprofen PPCPs 92 MAR Field NA NA [20] Imidacloprid Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 0,57 2,49 [16] Indomethacin PPCPs NA MAR Review NA 3,47 [22] Iodipamide PPCPs NA MAR Column 5,20 NA [2] Iohexol PPCPs NA MAR Column -2,80 NA [2] Iohexol PPCPs NA MAR Review NA 1,72 [22] Iomeprol PPCPs 79 SAT Field NA NA [6] Iomeprol PPCPs 100 MAR Field -2,79 NA [7] Iomeprol PPCPs NA MAR Review NA 1,89 [22] Iopamidol PPCPs 50 SAT Field NA NA [6] Iopamidol PPCPs NA MAR Field -2,42 NA [7] Iopamidol PPCPs NA MAR Review -2,42 0,12 [3] Iopamidol PPCPs NA MAR Review NA 2,35 [22] Iopromide PPCPs 98 MAR Field NA NA [1] Iopromide PPCPs 97 SAT Field NA NA [6] Iopromide PPCPs 100 MAR Field -2,05 NA [7] Iopromide PPCPs 98 SAT Field NA NA [17] Iopromide PPCPs 90 MAR Review -3,24 0,22 [3] Iopromide PPCPs NA MAR Review NA 2,14 [22] Iopromide PPCPs 80 MAR Column + batch -2,05 NA [14] Iopromide PPCPs 45 MAR Column -2,10 NA [15] Iopromide PPCPs 53 SAT Column NA NA [12] Iopromide PPCPs 100 MAR Field NA NA [20] Iron Metals 50 MAR Field + batch NA NA [18] 11 Iron Metals 75 SMART Field + batch NA NA [18] Ketoprofen PPCPs 76 MAR Column + batch 3,12 NA [14] Lamotrigine PPCPs NA MAR Field 2,57 NA [9] Lamotrigine PPCPs 41 MAR Field NA NA [24] Lamotrigine PPCPs 48 MAR Field NA NA [20] Lidocaine PPCPs 95 MAR Field NA NA [24] Lincomycin PPCPs 30 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Lincomycin PPCPs 13 MAR Column 0,29 NA [15] Lomustine PPCPs NA MAR Column 2,83 2,36 [5] Mecoprop Pesticides 82 SAT Field NA NA [6] Melamine PPCPs 18 MAR Column NA 0,72 [13] Meprobamate PPCPs 0 SAT Field NA NA [17] Metachlor Pesticides NA MAR Field 2,69 NA [9] Metachlor Pesticides 36 MAR Field NA NA [10] Metachlor Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 3,13 2,46 [16] Metformin PPCPs NA MAR Field -2,60 NA [7] Metformin PPCPs NA MAR Field -2,64 NA [9] Metformin PPCPs 87 MAR Field NA NA [11] Metformin PPCPs 93 SMART Field NA NA [11] Methylbenzotriazole Industrial 36 MAR Field NA NA [8] Methylbenzotriazole Industrial 28 MAR Column NA NA [21] Metolachlor Pesticides 39 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Metoprolol PPCPs 96 SAT Field NA NA [6] Metoprolol PPCPs 100 MAR Field 2,15 NA [7] Metoprolol PPCPs 0 MAR Field NA NA [8] 12 Metoprolol PPCPs 84 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Metoprolol PPCPs NA MAR Field 1,88 NA [9] Metoprolol PPCPs 85 MAR Column NA NA [21] Metoprolol PPCPs 3 SAT Column NA NA [12] Metoprolol PPCPs 100 MAR Field NA NA [20] Microplastic Plastic 50 MAR Column NA NA [31] 4-AAA PPCPs 100 MAR Field -0,13 NA [7] 4-AAA PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,76 NA [32] 4-AAA PPCPs 91 MAR Field NA NA [25] 4-AAA PPCPs 68 MAR Field NA NA [30] Naproxen PPCPs NA MAR Field 3,18 NA [9] Naproxen PPCPs 63 SAT Field NA NA [17] Naproxen PPCPs NA MAR Review 3,18 2,54 [3] Naproxen PPCPs 93 MAR Column 3,18 NA [26] 4-FAA PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,50 NA [7] 4-FAA PPCPs 9 MAR Field NA NA [8] 4-FAA PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,88 NA [32] 4-FAA PPCPs 78 MAR Column NA NA [21] 4-FAA PPCPs 70 MAR Field NA NA [25] 4-FAA PPCPs 54 MAR Field NA NA [30] 4-FAA PPCPs 62 MAR Field NA NA [11] 4-FAA PPCPs 78 SMART Field NA NA [11] 4-FAA PPCPs 76 SAT Column NA NA [12] 4-FAA PPCPs 87 MAR Field NA NA [20] NA MAR Column -0,64 NA [2] N-nitrosodimethylamine Industrial 13 N-nitrosomorpholine Industrial NA MAR Column -0,43 NA [2] Olmesartan PPCPs 0 MAR Field 0,73 NA [7] Olmesartan PPCPs 1 MAR Column NA NA [21] Oxazepam PPCPs 87 SAT Field NA NA [6] Oxazepam PPCPs NA MAR Column 2,30 NA [2] Oxipurinol PPCPs NA MAR Field -2,17 NA [7] Oxybenzone PPCPs NA MAR Review 3,79 3,10 [3] Paracetamol PPCPs 88 MAR Field NA NA [20] PFAS PFAS not effective MAR Review NA NA [28] PFOA PFAS NA MAR Review 5,00 1,66 [3] PFOS PFAS NA MAR Review NA 1,90 [3] PFOS PFAS 78 MAR Field NA NA [20] Phenazone PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,38 NA [7] Phenazone PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,59 NA [32] Phenazone PPCPs NA MAR Review 0,38 1,77 [3] Phenazone PPCPs 60 MAR Review 1,22 NA [23] Phenazone PPCPs 38 MAR Field NA NA [30] Phenytoin PPCPs 8 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Phenytoin PPCPs 36 SAT Field NA NA [17] PPCPs PPCPs 99 MAR Review NA NA [33] Pregabalin PPCPs NA MAR Field -1,35 NA [7] Primidone PPCPs 13 SAT Field NA NA [34] Primidone PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,91 NA [7] Primidone PPCPs 32 MAR Field NA NA [8] Primidone PPCPs 0 SAT Field NA NA [17] 14 Primidone PPCPs NA MAR Review 0,91 0,49 [3] Primidone PPCPs NA MAR Review 1,12 NA [23] Primidone PPCPs 41 MAR Field + batch NA NA [18] Primidone PPCPs 49 SMART Field + batch NA NA [18] Primidone PPCPs 9 MAR Column 0,91 NA [15] Primidone PPCPs 39 MAR Field NA NA [11] Primidone PPCPs 10 SMART Field NA NA [11] Primidone PPCPs 79 SAT Column NA NA [12] Primidone PPCPs 84 MAR Field NA NA [20] Primidone PPCPs 2 MAR Column NA NA [13] Prometryn Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 3,51 2,69 [16] Propranolol PPCPs 83 MAR Column 3,48 NA [15] Roxithromucin PPCPs 83 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Saccharine PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,91 NA [9] Salicylic acid PPCPs NA MAR Column 2,26 3,38 [5] Simazine Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 2,18 2,10 [16] Simazine Pesticides NA MAR Field + batch 2,10 NA [4] Sotalol PPCPs 91 SAT Field NA NA [6] Sotalol PPCPs 100 MAR Field 0,24 NA [7] Stearic acid PPCPs NA MAR Column 8,23 NA [5] Sucralose PPCPs NA MAR Field -1,00 NA [9] Sucralose PPCPs 25 MAR Review -1,00 1,00 [3] Sulfadiazine PPCPs 38 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Sulfamethazine PPCPs 2 MAR Column 0,89 NA [15] Sulfamethoxalol PPCPs 96 MAR Field NA NA [1] 15 Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 67 SAT Field NA NA [6] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 20 MAR Field 0,89 NA [7] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 46 MAR Field NA NA [8] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 0 SAT Field NA NA [17] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs NA MAR Review 0,89 0,53 [3] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 53 MAR Review 0,89 NA [23] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 20 MAR Field NA NA [10] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 23 MAR Column + batch 0,89 NA [14] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 21 MAR Column 0,89 NA [15] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 79 SAT Column NA NA [12] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 33 MAR Field NA NA [20] Sulfamethoxazole PPCPs 24 MAR Column NA 0,55 [13] Sulfathiazole PPCPs 34 MAR Column 0,05 NA [15] Tebuthiuron Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 1,62 1,83 [16] Terbuthylazine Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 3,21 3,18 [16] Terbutryn Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 3,74 2,85 [16] TOC OM significant SAT Review NA NA [28] Tolyltriazole Industrial NA MAR Field 1,71 NA [7] Tolyltriazole Industrial 43 MAR Field NA NA [10] Tolyltriazole Industrial 10 MAR Field NA NA [11] Tolyltriazole Industrial 10 SMART Field NA NA [11] Tramadol PPCPs 57 SAT Field NA NA [6] Tramadol PPCPs 24 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Tramadol PPCPs 88 MAR Field NA NA [35] Triallate Pesticides NA Stormwater Field 4,60 3,38 [16] 16 Triclocarban PPCPs NA MAR Review 4,90 3,73 [3] Triclosan PPCPs 0 SAT Field NA NA [17] Triclosan PPCPs NA MAR Review 4,76 4,27 [3] Triclosan PPCPs NA MAR Column 4,76 4,58 [5] Trimethoprim PPCPs 95 SAT Field NA NA [6] Trimethoprim PPCPs 98 MAR Batch NA NA [19] Trimethoprim PPCPs NA MAR Field 0,73 NA [9] Trimethoprim PPCPs 0 SAT Field NA NA [17] Trimethoprim PPCPs NA MAR Review 0,91 2,96 [3] Trimethoprim PPCPs 80 MAR Column + batch 0,91 NA [14] Trimethoprim PPCPs 100 MAR Field NA NA [25] Trimethoprim PPCPs 86 MAR Column 0,91 NA [15] Valsartan PPCPs NA MAR Field 4,00 NA [7] Valsartan PPCPs NA MAR Field 3,65 NA [9] Valsartan acid PPCPs NA MAR Field 1,59 NA [7] Valsartan acid PPCPs NA MAR Field 1,83 NA [9] Valsartan acid PPCPs 92 MAR Field NA NA [11] Valsartan acid PPCPs 95 SMART Field NA NA [11] Valsartan acid PPCPs 25 SAT Column NA NA [12] Valsartan acid PPCPs 98 MAR Field NA NA [20] Valsartan acid PPCPs 6 MAR Column NA NA [13] Venlafaxine PPCPs 88 SAT Field NA NA [6] Venlafaxine PPCPs 14 MAR Field NA NA [8] Venlafaxine PPCPs 65 MAR Column NA NA [21] Venlafaxine PPCPs 21 SAT Column NA NA [12] 88 17 89 References 90 1. 91 92 pharmaceutical residues? GWF, Wasser - Abwasser, 2007. 148(10): p. 698-703. 2. 93 94 Jekel, M. and S. Grünheid, Is bank filtration an effective barrier against organic substances and Patterson, B.M., et al., Behaviour and fate of nine recycled water trace organics during managed aquifer recharge in an aerobic aquifer. Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 2011. 122(1-4): p. 53-62. 3. Regnery, J., et al., The importance of key attenuation factors for microbial and chemical contaminants 95 during managed aquifer recharge: A review. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 96 2017. 47(15): p. 1409-1452. 97 4. Shareef, A., et al., Biodegradation of Simazine and Diuron Herbicides under Aerobic and Anoxic 98 Conditions Relevant to Managed Aquifer Recharge of Storm Water. Clean - Soil, Air, Water, 2014. 42(6): 99 p. 745-752. 100 5. 101 102 Mishra, S., P. Kumar, and I. Mehrotra, Fate of 15 wastewater originated organic micropollutants in a sand column. Sustainable Water Resources Management, 2021. 7(4). 6. Muntau, M., et al., Evaluation of the short-term fate and transport of chemicals of emerging concern 103 during soil-aquifer treatment using select transformation products as intrinsic redox-sensitive tracers. 104 Science of the Total Environment, 2017. 583: p. 10-18. 105 7. 106 107 compounds during field-scale bank filtration. Water Research, 2020. 173. 8. 108 109 Sanz-Prat, A., et al., A model-based analysis of the reactive transport behaviour of 37 trace organic Schaper, J.L., et al., The fate of polar trace organic compounds in the hyporheic zone. Water Research, 2018. 140: p. 158-166. 9. Hollender, J., et al., Comprehensive micropollutant screening using LC-HRMS/MS at three riverbank 110 filtration sites to assess natural attenuation and potential implications for human health. Water 111 Research, 2018. 1. 112 10. 113 114 Nagy-Kovács, Z., et al., Behavior of organic micropollutants during river bank filtration in Budapest, Hungary. Water (Switzerland), 2018. 10(12). 11. Hellauer, K., et al., Establishing sequential managed aquifer recharge technology (SMART) for enhanced 115 removal of trace organic chemicals: Experiences from field studies in Berlin, Germany. Journal of 116 Hydrology, 2018. 563: p. 1161-1168. 18 117 12. 118 119 chemicals in sand filter systems. Chemosphere, 2023. 335. 13. 120 121 Filter, J., et al., Influence of low oxygen concentrations on biological transformations of trace organic Zeeshan, M. and A.S. Ruhl, Fates of potentially persistent and mobile organic substances in embedded outdoor columns for artificial groundwater recharge simulation. Water Research, 2023. 245. 14. Im, H., et al., Simultaneous attenuation of pharmaceuticals, organic matter, and nutrients in 122 wastewater effluent through managed aquifer recharge: Batch and column studies. Chemosphere, 123 2016. 143: p. 135-141. 124 15. Park, S. and W. Lee, Removal of selected pharmaceuticals and personal care products in reclaimed 125 water during simulated managed aquifer recharge. Science of the Total Environment, 2018. 640-641: p. 126 671-677. 127 16. Page, D., et al., Environmental monitoring of selected pesticides and organic chemicals in urban 128 stormwater recycling systems using passive sampling techniques. Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 129 2014. 158: p. 65-77. 130 17. 131 132 Laws, B.V., et al., Attenuation of contaminants of emerging concern during surface-spreading aquifer recharge. Science of the Total Environment, 2011. 409(6): p. 1087-1094. 18. 133 Regnery, J., et al., Introducing sequential managed aquifer recharge technology (SMART) - From laboratory to full-scale application. Chemosphere, 2016. 154: p. 8-16. 134 19. Bertelkamp, C., et al. Organic micropollutant removal during river bank filtration: Batch studies. 2012. 135 20. Hrkal, Z., et al., Efficiency of micropollutant removal through artificial recharge and riverbank filtration: 136 case studies of Káraný, Czech Republic and Dresden-Hosterwitz, Germany. Environmental Earth 137 Sciences, 2023. 82(6). 138 21. 139 140 intermediate oxidation processes. Water (Switzerland), 2017. 9(3). 22. 141 142 145 Storck, F.R., et al., Factors controlling micropollutant removal during riverbank filtration. Journal American Water Works Association, 2012. 104(12): p. E643-E652. 23. 143 144 Hellauer, K., et al., Advancing sequential managed aquifer recharge technology (SMART) using different Henzler, A.F., J. Greskowiak, and G. Massmann, Modeling the fate of organic micropollutants during river bank filtration (Berlin, Germany). Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 2014. 156: p. 78-92. 24. Kondor, A.C., et al., Occurrence of pharmaceuticals in the Danube and drinking water wells: Efficiency of riverbank filtration. Environmental Pollution, 2020. 265. 19 146 25. 147 148 The Republic of Serbia. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2017. 24(2): p. 2075-2088. 26. 149 150 27. de Carvalho Filho, J.A.A., et al., Efficiency of the bank filtration technique for diclofenac removal: A review. Environmental Pollution, 2022. 300. 28. 153 154 Silver, M., et al., Fate of five pharmaceuticals under different infiltration conditions for managed aquifer recharge. Science of the Total Environment, 2018. 642: p. 914-924. 151 152 Kovacevic, S., et al., Occurrence and behavior of selected pharmaceuticals during riverbank filtration in Alam, S., et al., Managed aquifer recharge implementation criteria to achieve water sustainability. Science of The Total Environment, 2021. 768: p. 144992. 29. Hamadeh, A.F., S.K. Sharma, and G. Amy, Comparative assessment of managed aquifer recharge versus 155 constructed wetlands in managing chemical and microbial risks during wastewater reuse: A review. 156 Journal of Water Reuse and Desalination, 2014. 4(1): p. 1-8. 157 30. 158 159 Investigation of residues of phenazone-type analgesics. Chemosphere, 2008. 71(8): p. 1476-1485. 31. 160 161 32. 33. 168 Díaz-Cruz, M.S. and D. Barceló, Trace organic chemicals contamination in ground water recharge. Chemosphere, 2008. 72(3): p. 333-342. 34. 166 167 Maeng, S.K., et al., Organic micropollutant removal from wastewater effluent-impacted drinking water sources during bank filtration and artificial recharge. Water Research, 2010. 44(14): p. 4003-4014. 164 165 Hsieh, L., et al., Addition of biochar as thin preamble layer into sand filtration columns could improve the microplastics removal from water. Water Research, 2022. 221. 162 163 Massmann, G., et al., Behaviour and redox sensitivity of pharmaceutical residues during bank filtration - Mustafa, S., et al., Modelling contaminant transport for pumping wells in riverbank filtration systems. Journal of Environmental Management, 2016. 165: p. 159-166. 35. Kondor, A.C., et al., Occurrence and health risk assessment of pharmaceutically active compounds in riverbank filtrated drinking water. JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING, 2021. 41. 169 20
0
advertisement
Download
advertisement
Add this document to collection(s)
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersAdd this document to saved
You can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users