DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS Dimensional analysis is a tool in fluid mechanics and engineering that helps simplify physical problems by reducing the number of variables. It is especially useful when dealing with complex systems that do not have direct theoretical solutions. Dimensional analysis is a method used to: • • • • • Simplify physical problems by reducing the number of variables. Present and interpret experimental data efficiently. Verify the correctness of equations using dimensional homogeneity. Identify the relative importance of different physical parameters. Assist in physical modeling and scaling of experiments. Dimensions vs. Units • • Dimension: The fundamental nature of a physical quantity (e.g., Length, Time, Mass). Unit: The measurement scale used (e.g., meters, seconds, kilograms). Fundamental Dimensions in Fluid Mechanics The most used fundamental dimensions are, Mass (M) → kilogram (kg), Length (L) → meter (m), Time (T) → second (s) and Temperature (π½) → kelvin (K). Certain physical quantities are combinations of these fundamental dimensions: Quantity Area Volume Velocity Force Pressure Density Dynamic Viscosity Kinematic Viscosity Symbol π΄ π π πΉ π π π π£ Dimensions πΏ2 πΏ3 πΏπ −1 ππΏπ −1 ππΏ−1 π −2 ππΏ−3 ππΏ−1 π −1 πΏ2 π −1 Principle of Dimensional Homogeneity This principle states that all terms in an equation must have the same dimensions for the equation to be physically valid. This principle ensures consistent relationships between different physical quantities. However, it does not determine numerical constants. Buckingham’s Pi Theorem Buckingham’s Pi theorem is a mathematical tool used in dimensional analysis to reduce the number of variables in a physical problem. It helps simplify complex equations and is particularly useful when conducting experiments or modeling real-world systems. If a physical problem involves n variables and m fundamental dimensions, the problem can be expressed using n - m dimensionless groups (called Pi groups, π ). Instead of dealing with many variables, we can reduce the problem to a few non-dimensional parameters. Mathematically: π(π£1 , π£2 π£3 , … π£π ) = 0 Is rewritten as: π(π1 , π2 , … , ππ−π ) = 0 How to Construct Non-Dimensional Groups? STEP 1) Identify All Variables in the Problem: List all the variables that affect the phenomenon you are studying. STEP 2) Determine the Fundamental Dimensions: Identify the fundamental dimensions (M,L,T) of each variable STEP 3) Find the Number of Pi Groups: Number of Pi groups = π − π STEP 4) Select the Repeating Variables: Pick m variables that contain all fundamental dimensions (M, L, T). These are called scaling variables. STEP 5) Form the Pi Groups: Each remaining variable forms a Pi group with the repeating variables. ππ = (π£πππππππ)(π ππππ1 )π (π ππππ2 )π (π ππππ3 )π Where powers, π, π, π are determined algebraically so that each Pi group is dimensionless (setting exponents equal to zero) EXAMPLE 1 Suppose we are analysing the drag force (πΉπ· ) on a sphere moving through a fluid. The relevant variables are: • • • • • Drag Force, πΉπ· (N) Fluid density, π (kg/m3) Velocity, V (m/s) Sphere diameter, D (m) Fluid viscosity, π (Pa.s) Thus, we have n = 5 variables: πΉπ· , π, π, π·, π. We then identify the fundamental dimensions of each variable: Variable Drag Force Density Velocity Diameter Viscosity Symbol πΉπ· π π π· π Dimension ππΏ−2 ππΏ−3 πΏπ −1 πΏ −1 −1 ππΏ π The fundamental dimensions used here are M (mass), L (length), and T (time), so we have m = 3 fundamental dimensions. The number of dimensionless Pi groups is: ππ’ππππ ππ ππ ππππ’ππ : π − π = 5 − 3 = 2 We now pick π variables (3 in this case) FROM THE RELEVANT VARIABLES that contain ALL the fundamental dimensions (M,L,T). A good choice would be, fluid density (π), velocity (π) and diameter (π·). We form the first Pi group using drag force (ππ«) with the repeating variables: π1 = πΉπ· × ππ × π π × π· π Substituting the dimensions and expanding π1 = (ππΏπ −2 )(ππΏ−3 )π (πΏπ −1 )π (πΏ)π π1 = (π1+π )(πΏ1−3π+π+π )(π −2−π ) We now solve for exponents, π, π, π by setting exponents to zero: π0 πΏ0 π 0 = (π1+π )(πΏ1−3π+π+π )(π −2−π ) For π΄: 1 + π = 0 → π = −1 For π³: 1 − 3π + π + π = 0 → π + π = −4 For π»: −2 − π = 0 → π = −2, ∴ π = −2 Thus, the first Pi group is: π1 = πΉπ· × π−1 × π −2 × π· −2 ∴ π1 = πΉπ· ππ 2 π·2 This is the drag coefficient, commonly written as: πΆπ· = πΉπ· ππ 2 π·2 Now, form the second Pi group using viscosity (π): π2 = π × π π₯ × π π¦ × π· π§ Substituting the dimensions and expanding and setting the exponents equal to zero: π2 = (ππΏ−1 π −1 )(ππΏ−3 )π₯ (πΏπ −1 )π¦ (πΏ) π§ π2 = (π1+π₯ )(πΏ−1−3π₯+π¦+π§ )(π −1−π¦ ) For π΄: 1 + π₯ = 0 → π₯ = −1 For π³: −1 − 3π₯ + π¦ + π§ = 0 → π¦ + π§ = −2 For π»: −1 − π¦ = 0 → π¦ = −1 ∴ π§ = −1 The second Pi group is now: π2 = π × π−1 × π −1 × π· −1 ∴ π2 = π πππ· π2 = 1 π π This is the inverse of the Reynold’s number: By Buckingham’s Pi theorem, the original function πΉπ· = π(π, π, π· π) is now rewritten in terms of two dimensionless groups: πΆπ· = π(π π) This shows that drag force depends only on the Reynolds number, making it much easier to analyse and apply experimentally. EXAMPLE 2 ππ Obtain an expression in non-dimensional form for the pressure gradient, ππ₯ in a horizontal pipe with flow velocity V, pipe diameter D, fluid density ρ, fluid viscosity µ and pipe wall roughness e. SOLUTION The relevant variables are: ππ • Pressure gradient, ππ₯ (kg/m2.s2) • • • • • Velocity, π (m/s) Diameter, π· (m) Fluid density, π (kg/m3) Fluid viscosity, π (Pa.s) Relative roughness, π (m) ππ Thus, we have n = 6 variables: ππ₯ , π, π·, π, π, π. We then identify the fundamental dimensions of each variable. Variable Pressure Gradient Symbol ππ ππ₯ π π· π π π Velocity Diameter Fluid Density Fluid Viscosity Relative roughness Dimension ππΏ−2 π −2 πΏπ −1 πΏ ππΏ−3 ππΏ−1 π −1 πΏ The fundamental dimensions used here are M (mass), L (length), and T (time), so we have m = 3 fundamental dimensions. The number of dimensionless Pi groups is: ππ’ππππ ππ ππ ππππ’ππ : 6 − 3 = 3 We now pick π variables (3 in this case) FROM THE RELEVANT VARIABLES that contain ALL the fundamental dimensions (M,L,T). A good choice would be, fluid density (π), velocity (π) and diameter (π·). Forming the first Pi group with pressure gradient: π1 = ππ × ππ × π π × π· π ππ₯ π1 = (ππΏ−2 π −2 )(ππΏ−3 )π (πΏπ −1 )π (πΏ)π π1 = (π1+π )(πΏ−2−3π+π+π )(π −2−π ) π0 πΏ0 π 0 = (π1+π )(πΏ−2−3π+π+π )(π −2−π ) For π΄: 1 + π = 0 → π = −1 For π³: − 2 − 3π + π + π = 0 → −2 − 3(−1) + π + π = 0 → π + π = −1 For π»: − 2 − π = 0 → π = −2 ∴ π = 1 Thus, the first Pi group is: π1 = ππ × π−1 × π −2 × π·1 ππ₯ ∴ π1 = ππ π· ππ₯ ππ 2 Forming the second Pi group (π2 ) using viscosity (π): π2 = π × π π₯ × π π¦ × π· π§ π2 = (ππΏ−1 π −1 )(ππΏ−3 )π₯ (πΏπ −1 )π¦ (πΏ) π§ π2 = (π1+π₯ )(πΏ−1−3π₯+π¦+π§ )(π −1−π¦ ) π0 πΏ0 π 0 = (π1+π₯ )(πΏ−1−3π₯+π¦+π§ )(π −1−π¦ ) For π΄: 1 + π₯ = 0 → π₯ = −1 For π³: −1 − 3π₯ + π¦ + π§ → −1 − 3(−1) + π¦ + π§ = 0 → π¦ + π§ = −2 For π»: −1 − π¦ = 0 → π¦ = −1 ∴ π§ = −1 Thus, the second Pi group is: π2 = π × π−1 × π −1 × π· −1 ∴ π2 = π πππ· Forming the third Pi group is: π3 = π × π π × π π × π· π π3 = (πΏ)(ππΏ−3 )π (πΏπ −1 )π (πΏ)π π0 πΏ0 π 0 = (πΏ)(ππΏ−3 )π (πΏπ −1 )π (πΏ)π For π΄: π = 0 For π³: 1 − 3π − π + π = 0 → π − π = 1 For π»: −π = 0 → π = 0 ∴ π = −1 Thus, the third Pi group is: π3 = π × π0 × π 0 × π· −1 ∴ π3 = π π· Similarity and Model Testing In fluid mechanics, similarity refers to the idea that a scaled-down model can be used to study the behaviour of a real-life system (called the prototype) as long as certain conditions are met. There are three types of similarity that must be satisfied to ensure an accurate model test: 1. Geometric Similarity (Shape and Size) • The model and prototype must have the same shape, but the size can be different. All corresponding lengths, areas, and volumes must maintain the same ratio. This ensures that flow patterns remain the same. 2. Kinematic Similarity (Velocity and Acceleration) • The model and prototype must have the same ratios of velocities and accelerations at corresponding points. This ensures that fluid particles move in the same way in both the model and the prototype. 3. Dynamic Similarity (Forces) • The forces acting on the fluid particles in the model and prototype must be in the same ratio. This ensures that forces like gravity, viscosity, pressure, and inertia behave in the same way. To maintain similarity, we use dimensionless numbers that compare the importance of different forces. The most common ones are: Non-Dimensional Number Reynold’s Number (Re) Froude Number (Fr) Cauchy Number (Ca) Mach Number (Ma) Euler Number (Eu) Weber Number (We) Strouhal Number (St) Formula πππ· π π = π πΉπ = π √ππΏ ππ 2 πΈπ£ π ππ = π πΆπ = π ππ 2 ππ 2 πΏ ππ = π πΈπ’ = ππ‘ = ππΏ π Significance Compares inertia forces to viscous forces. Used in viscous flows. Compares inertia forces to gravitational forces. Used in free surface flows (e.g., ships, rivers). Compressible Flows Compares inertia forces to compressibility effects. Used in high-speed flows (e.g., aircraft, rockets). Compares pressure forces to inertia forces. Compares inertia forces to surface tension forces. Used in bubble/droplet flows. Oscillating Flows To ensure that a model experiment accurately represents the prototype, we ensure that the relevant nondimensional numbers are the same for both. EXAMPLE A prototype gate valve which will control the flow in a pipe system conveying paraffin is to be studied in a model. Perform dimensional analysis to obtain the relevant nondimensional groups. A 1/5 scale model is built to determine the pressure drop across the valve with water as the working fluid. DATA: ππ = 800 kg/m3, ππ = 0.002 kg/m.s, π£π€ππ‘ππ = 1.12 × 10−5 m2/s a) For a particular opening, when the velocity of paraffin in the prototype is 3.0 m/s what should be the velocity of water in the model for dynamic similarity? b) What is the scale ratio of the quantity of flow? c) Find the pressure drop in the prototype if it is 60 kPa in the model. SOLUTION The pressure drop is expected to depend upon the gate opening h, the overall depth H, the velocity V, density ρ and viscosity µ. Variable Pressure Drop Gate opening Overall Depth Velocity Fluid Density Fluid Viscosity Symbol βπ β π» π π π Dimension ππΏ−1 π −2 πΏ πΏ πΏπ −1 ππΏ−3 ππΏ−1 π −1 ππ’ππππ ππ ππ πΊπππ’ππ = 6 − 3 = 3 Selecting the scale variables, overall depth (π»), velocity (π) and fluid property (π) π1 = βπ × π» × π × π π2 = β × π» × π × π π3 = π × π» × π × π After performing dimensional analysis, we obtain: π1 = βπ β π , π2 = , π3 = 2 ππ π» πππ· a) Dynamic similarity requires that all non-dimensional groups be the same in model and prototype; i.e. π1πππππ = π1ππππ‘ππ‘π¦π , π2πππππ = π2ππππ‘ππ‘π¦ππ , π3πππππ = π3ππππ‘ππ‘π¦ππ βπ βπ ( 2) = ( 2) ππ ππππ‘π ππ πππππ β β ( ) =( ) π» ππππ‘π π» πππππ π π πππ· πππ· ( ) =( ) →( ) =( ) πππ· ππππ‘π πππ· πππππ π ππππ‘π π πππππ Since the problem involves fluid flow through a valve, Reynolds number similarity must be satisfied. ππ ππ π·π ππ ππ π·π = ππ ππ Solving for ππ (because ππ is given as 3 m/s): ππ ππ π·π ππ = ππ × × × ππ ππ π·π ππ = 3 ( 800 0.002 1 )( )( ) −6 1000 1.12 × 10 5 ∴ ππ = 6.72 π/π b) Flow (volumetric, π) can be written as the product of velocity and area (πΏ3 π −1) ππ ππ π·π 2 3 5 2 = ( ) = ( ) = 11.2 ππ ππ π·π 6.72 1 c) We can use the first Pi group to solve for βππ βππ βππ = 2 ππ ππ ππ ππ2 ππ ππ 2 ( ) ππ ππ 800 3 2 βππ = (60) × ( ) = 9.57 πππ 1000 6.72 ∴ βππ = βππ × Even though we do not have the diameters, we know the ratio of the prototype and the model.
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )