Midterm Assignment: Mock-Advising #1 Reflections & Evaluations
ADVISOR Name (Your name):
Your Advisee's Name:
Link to the Video Recording:
Your 250-word reflection on the advising session:
Instructor's evaluation out of 25
Criteria
Superior
(4-5)
Sufficient
(2-3)
Minimal ( 1)
1
Depth of Reflect
ion
Response demonstrates an in-depth r
eflection on observation. Viewpoint
s and interpretations are insightfu
l and well-supported. Clear, detail
ed examples are provided.
Response demonstrates a general ref
lection on observation. Viewpoints
and interpretations are supported.
Appropriate examples are provided.
2
Required Compone
nts (Advising St
rategies and Pri
nciples)
Response includes all components an
d meets or exceeds all requirements
indicated in the instructions. Each
question or part of the assignment i
s addressed thoroughly.
Response meets almost all requireme
nts indicated in the instructions.
Each question or part of the assign
ment is addressed sufficiently.
3
Structure
Writing is clear, concise, and well
organized with excellent sentence/p
aragraph construction. Thoughts are
expressed in a coherent and logical
manner. There are no more than thre
e spelling, grammar, or syntax erro
rs per page of writing.
Writing is mostly clear, concise, a
nd well organized with good sentenc
e/paragraph construction. Thoughts
are expressed in a coherent and log
ical manner. There are no more than
five spelling, grammar, or syntax e
rrors per page of writing.
Writing is unclear and/or disorg
anized. Thoughts are not express
ed in a logical manner. There ar
e more than five spelling, gramm
ar, or syntax errors per page of
writing.
4
TEACHER OVERALL:
4-5
2-3
1
Instructor's Feedback:
Response demonstrates a minimal r
eflection on observation. Viewpo
ints and interpretations are uns
upported or supported with flawe
d arguments. Examples, when appl
icable, are not provided or are i
rrelevant to the assignment.
Response is missing some compone
nts and/or does not fully meet t
he requirements indicated in the
instructions. Some questions or p
arts of the assignment are not a
ddressed.
Unacceptable
(0 points)
Response demonstrates a lack of
reflection. Viewpoints and inter
pretations are missing, inapprop
riate, and/or unsupported. Examp
les, when applicable, are not pr
ovided.
Response excludes essential comp
onents and/or does not address t
he requirements indicated in the
instructions. Many parts of the
assignment are addressed minimal
ly, inadequately, and/or not at
all.
Writing is unclear and disorgani
zed. Thoughts ramble and make li
ttle sense. There are numerous s
pelling, grammar, or syntax erro
rs throughout the response.
Unacceptable
(0 points)