Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community Case Author: Alexandra E. Upton & Justin O’Brien Online Pub Date: January 04, 2021 | Original Pub. Date: 2021 Subject: Consumer Behavior, Direct Marketing, Electronic Marketing Level: | Type: Indirect case | Length: 4897 Copyright: © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Organization: Glossier | Organization size: Medium Region: Northern America | State: Industry: Other manufacturing| Retail trade, except of motor vehicles and motorcycles Publisher: SAGE Publications: SAGE Business Cases Originals DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781529740691 | Online ISBN: 9781529740691 SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 This case was prepared for inclusion in SAGE Business Cases primarily as a basis for classroom discussion or self-study, and is not meant to illustrate either effective or ineffective management styles. Nothing herein shall be deemed to be an endorsement of any kind. This case is for scholarly, educational, or personal use only within your university, and cannot be forwarded outside the university or used for other commercial purposes. 2022 SAGE Publications Ltd. All Rights Reserved. The case studies on SAGE Business Cases are designed and optimized for online learning. Please refer to the online version of this case to fully experience any video, data embeds, spreadsheets, slides, or other resources that may be included. This content may only be distributed for use within University of Exeter. https://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781529740691 Page 2 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases Abstract Vogue trained Emily Weiss created a USD 1.2 billion valued social media beauty business from scratch, spun out from her side project blog Into the Gloss. Weiss spotted a clear gap in the market for a fully integrated beauty advice community for real, rather than idealized, women. The vertically integrated Glossier brand used data analytics and insight gleaned from community posts and feedback to provide a powerful understanding of its audience. This enabled the development of compelling and highly engaging advice content and the capability to effectively identify unsatisfied product formulation needs. A bottom up, customer centric launch strategy using sophisticated search engine optimization, a strong focus on user experience, and a distinctive communications style all helped to differentiate the new brand of Glossier from its better known and better financed competitors. Weiss recognized early on that her company needed to maintain her blog’s original voice and brand identity whilst simultaneously scaling up to fund investment in leading digital marketing tech. Through the application of insightful user generated content strategies, the Glossier management team were able to cut costs, build awareness, and maintain their voice in an authentic way. But, as big brands wised up to community based social marketing techniques and large influencers eyed lucrative direct-to-consumer beauty product brand extensions, could Emily Weiss’s Glossier continue to be a trailblazing success? This student-academic, co-created case study uses only publicly available information. It is designed to encourage marketing students to appreciate how innovative search engine optimization practice and a powerful direct-to-consumer business model was used to scale a passion blog into a unicorn beauty community, by leveraging user generated content and peerto-peer recommendation. Case Learning Outcomes By the end on this case study, students should be able to: • • • • Explain how customer engagement can be used to enhance user experience Appreciate a range of innovative search engine optimization practices Consider the threat posed by direct-to-consumer businesses to traditional, established brands Describe the importance of peer-to-peer and influencer-to-consumer word of mouth and electronic word of mouth in the beauty industry • Evaluate how founder Emily Weiss successfully scaled her blog into a unicorn business and how it might counter the threat of future competition Introduction In 2019, Glossier’s founding entrepreneur 33-year-old Emily Weiss told her 450,000 Instagram followers that she had successfully raised USD 100 million in venture capitalist funding. In so doing she had propelled herself into a very elite group of female unicorn (USD 1 billion+ valued business) chief executive officers (CEOs). Glossier, a “barely there” skincare and cosmetics brand, was valued at over a billion U.S. dollars, just 5 years after its inception (Gross, 2019). Initially, back in 2014, just four products (balm, mist, skin tint and moisturizer) were launched by a tiny team Page 3 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases that fulfilled 953 client orders on the first day of trading. But five successful years on, Glossier had grown to serve 3 million customers who were buying from a range of roughly 30 products (Weiss, 2019). The Glossier brand was born from the New York University art graduate’s blog, Into the Gloss (intothegloss.com). Weiss had started writing in the early mornings before her day job as a full-time fashion assistant at fashion publisher Vogue. Weiss’s blog sought to decipher the perplexing aspects of the USD 250 billion cosmetics industry for everyday women (Hart, 2019). Featuring interviews with influential women in the modeling, acting, and business world, Into the Gloss quickly established a sticky, engaged community who generated more than 10 million-page views per month. A cult following where remarkably 60% of readers checked-in daily (Smith, 2015). Sticky clients are those hard-to-find, repeat, regular, or returning purchasers who may be described as the loyal customer base, where advocates are most likely to be found. They are attractive not only because their advertising cost of acquisition may be lower, but also for their bigger sales baskets and their potential to generate powerful and low-cost peer-to-peer influence. Weiss had identified that large, traditional beauty brands (e.g. Estee Lauder, MAC, Clinique, L’Oreal, Maybelline, Covergirl, Shisheido, Lancome, and Chanel (Shen & Bissell, (2013)) lacked meaningful consumer electronic word-of-mouth (eWoM) support. Although they often benefitting from being part of substantial, international firms and were backed by powerful marketing muscle, these well-known legacy brand names, for all their advantages, struggled for traction in social media (Bertrand, 2013). Additionally, after 3 years of hands on community building by publishing celebrity “interviews, product reviews and more” (intothegloss.com, 2019), Weiss was able to draw on an extensive body of curated audience feedback about experimentation with products, insightful reviews, and critiques of both cosmetic products and application regimes. Back in 2004, fast moving consumer goods (FMCG) brand Dove had successfully launched its “real beauty” campaign, using groups of real women with diverse body shapes. It pledged to feature only real women, not models, portrayed as they were in real life without any form of digital distortion. Dove’s overarching aim was to help girls build self-esteem and empower positive body confidence (Unilever, 2017). Having undoubtedly been aware of this ground-breaking campaign in the mass market, Weiss had spotted, during her time as a model and whilst hobby blogging during her time at Vogue, that there was an important gap: the large, premium beauty brands did not focus on real women, instead they profiled an idealized version of perfection (Johnson, 2019). Weiss, who had zero formal business training (Ellison, 2019), launched her new brand, Glossier, to help fill this void with a compelling and authentic promise to “never cover you up, turn you into someone else, or overcomplicate your routine” (CNBC, 2019). She created a highly curated line of accessible products that focused on addressing fundamental skin issues, described as a “skin first, make up second” philosophy. Weiss had also engineered a peer recommendation and product delivery network that fulfilled her clients’ needs in a way that was appropriate for the new digital age (Siegal, 2015). At Glossier, customers’ feedback was at the forefront of product development and business strategy, and Weiss had realized that social media had game changed consumers’ roles in brand storytelling, moving from merely listening passively to more active participation, often dubbed co-creation (Singh & Sonnenburg, 2012). Glossier’s innovative SEO practice and a powerful direct-to-consumer (D2C) business model was used to scale a passion blog into a unicorn beauty community by leveraging user-generated content (UGC) and peerto-peer recommendation. But, as big brands wised up to community-based, social marketing techniques, and large influencers eyed lucrative D2C beauty product brand extensions, could Emily Weiss’s Glossier continue to be a trailblazing success? D2C Business Model By 2018, Weiss’s fast-growing firm boasted 200 employees and turnover was in excess of USD 100 million. It had essentially become a D2C web proposition that boasted just two permanent shops (New York and Los Angeles), some semi-permanent pop-up stores, and 2.2 million Instagram followers (Ellison, 2019). In leap frogging traditionally high-cost elements of the beauty value chain, notably by largely ignoring third party retail distribution and deploying only a modest marketing spend focused on the website, product packaging, Page 4 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases and micro influencers, Weiss was able to offer quality cosmetics via a web-enabled, convenient, fast delivery service at a more affordable price point. This form of luxury promotion of relatively inexpensive products has been dubbed “masstige” (from mass market + prestige) (Kestenbaum, 2017). Peer recommendations for high involvement purchasing categories, such as beauty, play an extremely important role at the point of brand selection, known sometimes as the zero moment of truth (ZMOT) for online transactions (Bertrand, 2013). Glossier was one of an increasing number of marketing, tech-based, beauty start-ups that was tapping into and promoting the content created by everyday people. Other beauty startup examples include Pat McGrath, Mario Badescu, and Milk Makeup (Mahoney, 2019). Weiss had created and effectively leveraged a network of remunerated and unpaid influencers to amplify her brand’s proposition (Mendell, 2018). This system of influencing has been shown to be particularly effective; close friend referrals can account for as much as 86% of purchase decisions (Lammertink, 2019). Glossier attributes 79% of its sales from peerto-peer sources (Wischhover, 2017). Using affiliate marketing, Weiss’s team developed a powerful network of about 500 micro influencers (whose followers were typically measured in tens of thousands). These influencers were formal representatives paid to endorse Glossier to their substantial social media following (Zerbo, 2019). Micro influencer fees were cheaper than the big names and often delivered appreciably higher engagement rates, typically 60% (Porteous, 2018). The micro influencers were given their own page to endorse from, hosted on the Glossier website, where the well ranked blogs and high-quality content captured from the influencers pages helped validate the Glossier website and boosted its SEO performance, as well as increasing brand awareness (Montti, 2019). Weiss tapped into changing consumer decision making trends that put less emphasis on rational product evaluation and objective measures of service quality, in favor of emotional engagement and social experiences (Tynan et al., 2010). The CEO of QVC (a television shopping channel), Mike George, highlighted a “collapse of institutional and brand authority” caused by four key factors: a less trusting society, an ecommerce-fueled price race to the bottom, a desire for authenticity, and a change in influence sources (Kestenbaum, 2017). In this dynamic context, Weiss defined Glossier as an experience company that transcends mere physical products and digital interfaces to enable offline experiences (Ellison, 2019). People-Powered Ecosystem When Emily Weiss launched Glossier as a separate entity from Into the Gloss, a team of salaried staff editors, dubbed the gTeam, became central to Glossier’s people-powered digital ecosystem. The gTeam grew to comprise 30 editors, who were carefully chosen to compile and reflect the opinions of customers, and determine how to market products effectively (CustomerThermometer, 2019). Functioning as a part of the marketing department, Weiss claims the gTeam was much more than just a standard customer service team. Acting as the beating heart of a customer centric organization, a peoplepowered ecosystem, the editors worked in real time to gather insights from customers and provide authentic customer voice input for product development. Each editor had hundreds of conversations daily, spanning a range of social channels, focused on creating salient conversations about products in a highly personalized manner and distilling the market intelligence into key actionable insights (Schiffer, 2018). The gTeam played a critical part in the company’s feedback loop, enabling it to intimately source ideas from a wide array of individuals through digital information feeds. Weiss was convinced the gTeam enabled insights and customer care was invaluable, delivering Glossier an important edge. The editorial team successfully created a true community, transcending the initial status as a single person hobby blog. gTeam editors were able to identify a range of customer stakeholder perspectives, for example: identify where item descriptions on the website were deficient; synthesize what customers expected from particular products; evaluate catchy, new product names; and assess new formulations (Danziger, 2018). Curated UGC, in the form of reviews and testimonials, was augmented with exposure provided by a group of paid micro influencers to help encourage customers to choose to buy Glossier products. Forbes (2016) notes that when combined, these opinions and thoughts can be more persuasive Page 5 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases than brand manager messages. Leveraging this authentic UGC, Glossier was able to develop an enduring portfolio of roughly 30 affordably priced products, staples that many shoppers often categorized as automatic repurchases. However, from a business ethics perspective, Weiss was undoubtedly aware that her grass roots business relied on the unpaid good-will of the Glossier community of contributors. The majority of content generators and influencers were unlikely to see an equitable return on their efforts. Duffy (2017) calls out this exploitation of immaterial labor, an inequity that sees many passionate individuals not getting paid fairly to do work they love, whilst some ingenious individuals, such as Emily Weiss and others, have been able to create lucrative businesses by harnessing the opinions and influence of the crowd. Glossier’s Optimization According to Weiss, Glossier views all of their product, packaging, and names as content, and their digital feeds reflect this. The brand’s signature pink color theme, carefully orchestrated photos, benefit boasting copy, and superlative descriptions are curated to communicate the brand in a way that is easily shareable. Web content uses succinct headlines that telegraph benefits and body text that identifies problems, whilst then adroitly emphasizing how each product solves them. Reviews, presented in reverse chronological order with most recent first like blogs, are easy to access and use the popular and familiar five-star evaluation grading system. They are filterable by skin type, age range and skin shade, enabling customers to quickly access just the feedback and comments from “people really like me,” should they wish to. Pared back metrics show the volume of community-generated reviews to inspire trust. Low comment volumes may indicate poor customer engagement and are more likely to be biased by fake reviews. Simple star rating graphics are augmented with clearly labeled customer and paid influencer testimonials, which, when woven together on the uncluttered web pages, create a powerfully credible peer-to-peer endorsement. Weiss is clear in her mind that word-of-mouth is more influential than anything a brand can say, and this philosophy underwires the D2C business model in bypassing the need to invest substantially in traditional advertising channels and retail distribution. When tagged in social media, Glossier gTeam editors incorporate UGC on their channels (Hart, 2019). This is important, not only because the beauty brand’s feed reflects its users in an authentic way, but because it can substantially increase exposure at low cost. UGC has been proven to increase rankings on search engine results pages (SERPs), as people co-create relevant content (Union, 2017). As a D2C company, Glossier owns the entire sales funnel. The company thus has complete, interconnected data sets and the ability to track consumer behavior throughout the five-step awareness–consideration–trial–repurchase–advocacy customer journey (Willits, n.d.). With very limited offline sales through its modest retail footprint, Glossier’s majority online business model can reliably measure marketing effort and efficacy at each step of the consumer journey (also known as the user experience or UX). This provides a major advantage over other legacy beauty brands, whose retail distribution is often in the hands of third parties. This knowledge-is-power, big data insight enables Glossier to corroborate the qualitative comment posts, creating a powerful, positive feedback loop. Each step of the UX can be then optimized based on this heady blend of rich qualitative, attitudinal information, and actual quantitative behavioral data, that combined help drive changes aimed at enhanced customer satisfaction and delivering the all-important goal of profitable sales growth (Rodgers, 2018). In 2019 Glossier was ranked 23rd worldwide for SEO in the beauty and fitness sector and averaged 2.4 million visits per month. This high rank is impressive for a company that is younger and offers less products than its lower-ranked competitors like Tarte, which ranked 27th with 2.3 million monthly views, and Estee Lauder, which ranked 46th with only 1.1 million monthly views (SimilarWeb, 2019). Particularly notable was Glossier’s social media engagement rate (comprising: comments, likes, shares, and retweets), which was more than four times the rate experienced by Estee Lauder. In part, the lower rankings of its competitors may be due to a failure of utilizing keywords in URL structures, a practice that Glossier has deployed successfully. Glossier URL’s are clear, succinct and uncluttered when compared with beauty conglomerate Estee Lauder’s more complex format: • glossier.com/products/milk-jelly-cleanser • esteelauder.com/products/681/26959/product-catalog/skincare/advanced-night-repair/synchronizedrecovery-complex-ii. Page 6 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases From inception, Glossier had been attentive to SEO. Their URL structure has contained keywords placed near the front, a hierarchy that places product-search first (Ryan, 2017). They have also utilized other forms of optimization: • breadcrumbs (keyword summary of the route through a web page) to build internal links and define their link architecture; • title tags for user clarity on the SERP; • smaller compressed files to make photos load faster; • alternative descriptive names so both people and bots can understand the content (Doiron, 2017); and • rel=canonical tags, which consolidate multiple links to pages, but count all the different versions as links, increasing SEO relevance (De Valk, 2019). In addition, regularly updated product review content has kept pages fresh with new content optimized for long-tail (secondary) keywords and added microdata (Smith, 2018). Glossier’s SEO strategy also extended to YouTube, the world’s second largest search engine, a platform also owned by Google (Davies, 2018). Here, UGC videos and reviews are linked to the Glossier website, educating and inspiring community members on ways to use Weiss’s products (Ho, 2018) whilst providing content that Google could index with Glossier and be paired with the metadata encapsulation to increase search results relevance (Ryan 2017). Glossier Investing in Big Data Technology At its launch, Glossier had relied on Into The Gloss’s vocal community of voluntary commenters to provide inspiration. However, over time, this voice was augmented with an employed team of data analysts and the gTeam to filter and distill the myriad ideas emerging out of an ever-growing community. From inception, images of diverse women, product shots from consumers, and the signature millennial voice from Instagram had been the focus of core community content. However, over time, the company began to rely more heavily on the in-house tech (technology) department to engineer tools to create new UXs centered around the sticky community it had created, to discover ideas for future products and to optimize the website. To track users who were not active commenters, the company had initially used cookies (a record of an individual user’s visit to a website), which allowed the computer server to recognize customers when they returned to a page (Riermer, 2019). However, cookies were found to be blocked by 64% of browsers (Benes, 2018) and changes to data privacy laws have also subsequently affected how the company was allowed to gather data (European Commission, 2002). To fix these unscalable issues, and drive further growth, the company started using customer data platform segmentation and cross-domain analytics to connect the movements around and across Glossier and the Into the Gloss blog. The move from a wide network of site information to a richer data lake meant that the company could start to use machine learning to automate and quantify the information (Milnes, 2017). From this, Glossier has been able to build a fit-for-purpose data warehouse to house the large amounts of information used to run analytics on UX at an extremely specific level and to learn what factors really impacted customer behaviors (Heintz, 2019). Glossier worked to integrate its in-store experiences into its online presence and built its own point-of-sales system to synchronize payment methods from both online and in-store purchases (Tom, 2018), creating a more seamless experience. The approach of attempting to offer a consistent and fully integrated customer journey, that is platform and channel neutral, is often referred to as omnichannel marketing (Manser Payne et al., 2017). Weiss hoped to extend this even further by developing a social-selling platform to serve different archetypes of customers and create a centralized place where consumers could build relationships with each other to; discuss products instead of relying on traditional sources (publications like Vogue), and to help make purchase decisions (Bloomberg, 2018), essentially retrofitting WoM marketing ideas into digital-first channels, enabling people to meet up and collaborate with each other in an accessible way (PRNewswire, 2019). Page 7 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases Summary: What Next? Entrepreneurial founder Emily Weiss successfully leveraged authentic customer engagement and powerful user generated reviews to scale her side project blog into a highly successful, disruptive, D2C, community beauty business. The billion-dollar brand was founded with the aim to address a profound, unmet need: beauty advice from real women, for real women. Emily managed to scale her founder empathy and industry expertise by hiring a 30-strong team of editors, ensuring that a powerfully customer-centric culture was retained through scale up growth. The gTeam successfully engaged with and listened to customers, and used these insights to carefully engineer an expansion of the product range, whilst designing an appealing, slick, online, customer journey experience. Always adept at digital marketing, Glossier’s early trading success was built on increasing sales and sticky, engaged customers. As part of this strong growth, additional venture capitalist funding was invested to build a powerful data warehouse and create an omnichannel analytics capability. Whilst accepting that Glossier had become a community-centric, marketing tech-enabled unicorn, Weiss refused to frame the company she had birthed as merely an authentic online cosmetics firm, or just an excellent digital journey provider. Instead she hoped it would be a highly successful emotive brand that enabled high-value offline experiences. However, with a range of similar, high profile entities emerging in the beauty industry (e.g. Fenty Beauty), this hope was in question. Furthermore, because the fundamentals of influencer-enabled D2C business models were becoming better understood, the question of how much longer Glossier could be at the forefront of digitally-enabled success needed to be considered. Incumbent beauty brands would surely start responding and other potential new entrants (e.g. globally renowned influencers such as; entertainer Rhianna and celebrity Kylie Jenner) were particularly well placed to follow with a similar model. What would you recommend Emily Weiss to do next? Discussion Questions 1. 2. 3. 4. How is consumer engagement used to optimize Glossier’s UX? What techniques does Glossier use to enhance its chances of being found online? Describe, as concisely as possible, the Glossier business model. Evaluate the triple threats faced by Glossier from traditional beauty brands, emergent D2C beauty brands, and new entrant influencers with a large audience. Further Reading Brion, B. (2019). People are ditching iconic makeup brands and flocking to buzzy skincare companies like Glossier, and that’s terrible news for Ulta. https://www.businessinsider.com/cosmetics-industry-struggles-tokeep-up-in-age-of-glossier-2019-8 Chaffey, D. (2019). E-commerce conversion rates – how do yours compare? https://www.smartinsights.com/ ecommerce/ecommerce-analytics/ecommerce-conversion-rates/ Estee Lauder. (2019, March 25). Estee Lauder Front Page. Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/ esteelauder/?hl=en Estee Lauder. (2019, March 28). Advanced Night Repair. Product. https://www.esteelauder.co.uk/product/ 681/26959/product-catalog/skincare/advanced-night-repair/synchronized-recovery-complex-ii Fenty Beauty. (2019, March 28). Pro Filt’r Soft matte Longwear Foundation. Product. https://www.fentybeauty.com/pro-filtr/soft-matte-longwear-foundation/FB30006.html Glossier (2019, March 25). Glossier Front Page. Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/glossier/?hl=en Glossier (2019, March 28). Milk Jelly Cleanser. Product Site. https://www.glossier.com/products/milky-jellycleanser Glossier, (2019, September 16). Cloud Paint. Glossier. https://www.glossier.com/products/cloud-paint Goldman Sachs. (2019). Emily Weiss: Rethinking the Business of Beauty 18 January. Video File. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSQ0boMmqrk Helizberger, S. (2019, March 20). Glossier: How this 33-year-old turned her beauty blog to a $1 billion brand. CNBC.com. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/20/how-emily-weiss-took-glossier-from-beauty-blog-to-1-billionPage 8 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases brand.html Milk Makeup. (2019, March 28). Hydro Grip Primer. Product. https://www.milkmakeup.com/hydro-gripprimer.html?cgid=skincare-face Rogers, C. (2018). Why direct-to-consumer beauty brand Glossier is ripping up the marketing playbook. https://www.marketingweek.com/2018/06/25/glossier-ripping-up-marketing-playbook/ Tarte Cosmetics. (2019, March 25). Tarte Cosmetics Front Page. Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/ tartecosmetics/?hl=en Tarte Cosmetics. (2019, March 28). Big Ego Vegan Mascara. Product. https://tartecosmetics.com/en_US/ makeup/eyes/mascara/big-ego-vegan-mascara/1634.html References Benes, R. (2018). Web Browsers reject About Two-Thirds of Cookies. https://www.emarketer.com/content/ web-browsers-reject-about-two-thirds-of-cookies Bertrand, G. (2013). Social media research: Developing a trust metric in the social age. International Journal of Market Research, 55(3), 333–335. Bloomberg. (2018). Glossier Hits $100 Million in Sales and Takes Aim at Big Beauty. https://www.businessoffashion.com/articles/beauty/glossier-hits-100-million-in-sales-and-takes-aim-at-bigbeauty CustomerThermometer. (2019). How customer feedback drives the Glossier phenomenon. https://www.customerthermometer.com/customer-case-studies/customer-feedback-online-glossier/ Danziger, P. (2018). 5 Reasons That Glossier Is So Sucessful. https://www.forbes.com/sites/pamdanziger/ 2018/11/07/5-keys-to-beauty-brand-glossiers-success/#77a1d1f6417d Davies, D. (2018). Meet the 7 Most Popular Search Engines in the World. https://www.searchenginejournal.com/seo-101/meet-search-engines/ De Valk, J. (2019). rel=canonical: the ultimate guide. https://yoast.com/rel-canonical/ Doiron, A. (2017). 8 Ways to Optimize Your Product Page SEO like Glossier. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/ 8-ways-optimize-your-product-page-seo-like-glossier-alicia-doiron/ Duffy, B. E. (2017). (Not) getting paid to do what you love: Gender, social media, and aspirational work. Yale University Press. Ellison, J. (2019, August 7). Glossier’s Emily Weiss: ‘We’re creating the Estee Lauder of the future’. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/352ded56-b509-11e9-8cb2-799a3a8cf37b European Commission (2002). Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy directive. https://ec.europa.eu/ipg/basics/legal/ cookies/index_en.htm Forbes, K. (2016). Examining the beauty industry’s use of social influencers. Elon Journal of Undergraduate Research in Communications, 7(2), 78–87. Gross, E. (2019). Glossier raises $100 M and now has a Billion Dollar Valuation. https://www.forbes.com/ sites/elanagross/2019/03/19/glossier-raises-100m-and-now-has-a-billion-dollar-valuation/#335f2576720d Hart, K. (2019). The Glossier Marketing Machine: How Emily Weiss Hacked Culture to Build a $100 Million Business that’s Disrupting Beauty. https://jumpermedia.co/glossier-marketing-machine/ Heintz, M. (2019). Bayesian versus Frequentist A/B testing for the Curious Glossier Data Scientist. https://medium.com/glossier/bayesian-versus-frequentist-a-b-testing-for-the-anxious-glossier-data-scientistec604c6ceec9 Ho, B. (2018). 3 Awesome Video Makerting campaigns from Nike, REI, and Glossier. https://www.criteo.com/ insights/video-marketing-campaigns/ Into The Gloss (2019). “Interviews, product reviews and more.” Landing Page Popup. https://intothegloss.com Johnson, E. (2019). Full Q&A: Glossier CEO Emily Weiss on the “art and science” of the beauty industry. https://www.recode.net/podcasts/2019/1/16/18185512/glossier-ceo-emily-weiss-beauty-makeup-interviewpodcast-recode-decode-kara-swisher Kemmis, A. (2019). The Difference between Direct and Organic Website Traffic Sources. https://www.smartbugmedia.com/blog/what-is-the-difference-between-direct-and-organic-search-trafficsources Kestenbaum, R. (2017, June 19). How the Beauty Industry is Adapting to Change. Forbes.com. https://www.forbes.com/sites/richardkestenbaum/2017/06/19/how-the-beauty-industry-is-adapting-tochange/ Page 9 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases Lammertink, I. (2019). Why Glossier embodies the future of shopping and B2C marketing. https://medium.com/swlh/why-glossier-embodies-the-future-of-shopping-and-b2c-marketing-6b88a863ebc5 Mahoney, S. (2019, April 15). Search Secrets of D2C Beauty Brands. Mediapost.com. https://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/334501/search-secrets-of-d2c-beauty-brands.html Manser Payne, E. , Peltier, J. W. , & Barger, V. A. (2017). Omni-channel marketing, integrated marketing communications and consumer engagement: A research agenda. Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing, 11(2), 185–197. Mendell, J. (2018). Has Millenial Cult-Favorite Beauty Brand Jumped The Shark. https://www.forbes.com/ sites/jannamandell/2018/02/05/has-millennial-cult-favorite-beauty-brand-glossier-jumped-theshark/#cf71a732397f Milnes, H. (2017). How Glossier uses data to make content and commerce work. https://digiday.com/ marketing/glossier-uses-data-make-content-commerce-work/ Montti, R. (2019). Link Building Fundamentals. https://www.searchenginejournal.com/fundamentals-of-linkbuilding/315385/ Porteous, J. (2018). Micro Influencers vs Macro influencers, What’s Best for Your Business? https://www.socialbakers.com/blog/micro-influencers-vs-macro-influencers PRNewswire. (2019). Glossier Inc. Raises $100 Million to Build the Future Beauty Company. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/glossier-inc-raises-100-million-to-build-the-future-beautycompany-300814345.html Riermer, A. (2019). What Digital Marketers Need To Know About Cookies and Tracking. https://www.searchenginejournal.com/cookies-tracking-what-digital-marketers-need-to-know/287381/ Ryan, D. (2017). Understanding Digital Marketing: Marketing strategies for engaging the digital generation (4th ed). Kogan Page. Schiffer, J. (2018). How Glossier’s gTeam is changing the definition of customer service. https://digiday.com/ marketing/glossiers-gteam-changing-definition-customer-service/ Shen, B. , & Bissell, K. , (2013). Social media, social me: A content analysis of beauty companies’ use of Facebook in marketing and branding. Journal of Promotion Management, 19(5), 629–651. Siegal, E. (2015). Emily Weiss On Glossier And Into The Gloss In 2015. https://www.forbes.com/sites/ emilysiegel/2015/05/05/emily-weiss-glossier/#2eceacc57a42 SimilarWeb. (2019a, March 28). Website Analysis Overview Report Glossier. SimilarWeb. (2019b, March 28). Website Analysis Overview Report Tarte Cosmetics. SimilarWeb. (2019c, March 28). Website Analysis Overview Estee Lauder. Singh, S. , & Sonnenburg, S. (2012). Brand performances in social media. Journal of interactive marketing, 26(4), 189–197. Smith, W. (2015). 2015 30 Under 30: Emily Weiss. https://www.forbes.com/pictures/mlf45eimef/emilyweiss-29/#429338411d82 Smith, J. (2018). Why Customer reviews are Important for SEO. https://www.seohermit.com/articles/whycustomer-reviews-are-important-for-seo/ Tom, M. (2018). How Glossier leveraged tech to build a next-generation cosmetics company. https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/startups/how-glossier-leveraged-tech-to-build-a-next-generation-cosmeticscompany/ Tynan, C. , McKechnie, S. , & Chhuon, C. (2010). Co-creating value for luxury brands. Journal of business research, 63(11), 1156–1163. Unilever. (2017). Announcing the Dove Real Beauty Pledge. https://www.unilever.com/news/news-andfeatures/Feature-article/2017/Announcing-the-Dove-Real-Beauty-Pledge.html Union. (2017). Influencer marketing: It’s Word of Mouth 2.0. https://union.co/articles/influencer-marketing-itsword-of-mouth-2-0 Weiss, E. (2019). A letter for Emily Weiss, Founder and CEO. glossier.com. https://www.glossier.com/articles/ five-years Willits, L. (n.d.). Understanding the Marketing Funnel: 5 Strategies to Improve your Email Marketing. aweber.com. https://blog.aweber.com/email-marketing/understanding-the-marketing-funnel-5-strategies-toimprove-your-email-marketing.htm Wischhover, C. (2017). Glossier is Going After New Customers With An Army of Reps. https://www.racked.com/2017/7/12/15949530/glossier-international-shipping-canada-uk Zerbo, J. (2019). From Fans to Nano Influencers, a Look at the Evolution of Influencer Marketing. http://www.thefashionlaw.com/home/fans-and-micro-micro-influencers-the-answer-to-growing Page 10 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community SAGE © Alexandra E. Upton and Justin O’Brien 2021 Business Cases https://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781529740691 Page 11 of 11 Glossier: From Beauty Blog to Billion-Dollar Brand Community