Uploaded by sreekanth Mylavarapu

Pump Failure FMEA Worksheet: Reliability Analysis

advertisement
Wear / Seize
Prob
abilit
y
2
D-2
EBC
Proposed Task
Task
Duration(Hr)
Consequence
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Task
Responsibility
TA
(YES / NO)
Maintenance
Level
Daily
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
No
LEVEL 2
No
LEVEL 1
No
No
No of Pax
C1
C2
C3
Shift
Shift
Task Remarks
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Periodic Condition
Maintenance (Vibration,
Temperature & Noise)
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Bearing spalling
1
Task Frequency
Task Type
Mitigated risk
Failure Effect
Probability
Normal wear and
tear
Detection Mechanism
Asset
Reputatio
n
Failure
Cause
People
Environm
ent
Description of Failure
Mode
Unmitigated
risk
Failure Modes
Asset
Reputatio
n
Component
People
Environm
ent
Consequence
Functional
Failure
1
1
D
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
1
1
Bearing
Bi
Weekly
1M
3M
Mechanical
Rotating - CBM
Shift
Shift
Daily
Operation
C2 - Moderate (D3)
C1 - Major ( D4)
For all
To Check for oil level and condition
Lack of Lubrication Casual Observation
Breakage
Coupling
Bearings have reduced
operability or seized.
External influence
(high vibration,
misallignment,
Coupling failure due to
Maintenance error
Clearance/Alignmen excessive misalignment
t failure
Overload
Membrane Fatigue
Corrosion
Off Spec Product
Condition monitoring
Periodic condition
monitoring
Inspection
Off-design service Condition monitoring
Production inteference
Erosion
Errosion of impeller
surface by foreign
Condition monitoring
material causes flow
angle to deviate and may Off-design service
induce fatigue crack and
impeller rupture if left
undetected
Impeller
Pump totally
fail to deliver
medium;
pump seizure
Fatigue
Fatigue crack from
stress in runner
Off-design service
blade/vane due to
frequent start/stop of the
pump or excessive
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Inspection
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
EBC
1
1
2
1
D
D-2
CNM
1
1
2
1
D
D-2
CNM
1
1
2
1
D
D-2
SCH
1
1
2
1
D
D-2
CNM
1
1
2
1
D
D-2
EBC
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Production inteference
D-2
CNM
D-2
Deformation
Breakage
Shaft
High Vibration
Fatigue deformation from
misalignment, shaft
Off-design service
imbalance and other
dynamic phenomena
Shaft damage by foreign
object ingestion due to
inadequate flushing of
pump suction line or
fatigue crack from
operating under stress
outside envelope
Overload / High
vibration/ Fatigue
Production inteference
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Production inteference
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Production inteference
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Production inteference
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Check coupling element/disk condition. Replace if
necessary.
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Bi
Weekly
Bi
Weekly
Process parameter monitoring
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Mechanical
Rotating - CBM
Mechanical
Rotating - CBM
1M
3M
1M
3M
6M
6M
6M
AMT Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Bi
Weekly
1M
3M
Mechanical
Rotating - CBM
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Shift
Shift
Daily
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1
1
Bi
Weekly
1M
3M
Mechanical
Rotating - CBM
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1
1
Bi
Weekly
1M
3M
Mechanical
Rotating - CBM
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
TA
Level 3
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Process parameter monitoring
EBC
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
D-2
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
EBC
D-2
CNM
EBC
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
EBC
1
1
2
1
D
EBC
D-2
D-2
1
Periodic condition
monitoring
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
CNM
SCH
Clearance/Alignmen
Impeller clearance failure
t failure
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
1
2
1
D
1M
3M
Inspection during pump overhaul
1
1
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
1
1
TA
Condition Condition
Based
Based
Mechanical
Rotating
Mechanical
Rotating
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
6M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Process parameter monitoring
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Verify Pump operating as per pump curve
CNM
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
CNM
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Erosion
Fatigue crack from
Off-design service
errosion/corrosion attack
Condition monitoring
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
D-2
1
1
2
1
D
Verify Pump Flow is Above Minimum Flow
Verify Switch Setting & Valve Arrangement Correct
For Auto Start Function
CNM
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
Check packing boxes, bearings (bearing housing),
or pump casing for overheating
Wear ( Follow
above)
Bearing spalling
Expected wear and
tear
Condition monitoring
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Bearings
Overheating
Coupling
Lube oil degradation
Coupling failure due to
Clearance/Alignmen excessive misalignment
t failure
and compression/
expansion stress
contamination
Maintenance error
Casual Observation / Oil Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
sampling analysis
production due to redundancy
Condition monitoring
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
D-2
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Clean Sight Glass, Constant Level Oiler, Water
Collector - if applicable
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
SCH
CNM
D-2
Flush bearing housing, replace oil in bearing
housings and lube oil filter (if required) per
manufacturer's recommendations
Check packing boxes, bearings (bearing housing),
or pump casing for overheating
Clean Sight Glass, Constant Level Oiler, Water
Collector - if applicable
1
1
2
1
D
SCH
Flush bearing housing, replace oil in bearing
housings and lube oil filter (if required) per
manufacturer's recommendations
EBC
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
To Check for oil level and condition (colour)
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
D-2
4
2 Force
feed . TA
6M
6M
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
SCH
Check coupling and bolting condition and alignment.
Rectify if necessary
1Y
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
SCH
Check coupling element/disk condition. Replace if
necessary.
1Y
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
6M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Process parameter monitoring
Casing
Leakage
Casing Leaks Due To
Gasket Degradation,
sealing surface wear or
corrosion that leads to
premature external or
internal casing leaks
External influence Casual Observation
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Cavitation
Bubble formed from
pressure drop below
liquid vapor pressure
implodes and trigger
shockwaves
causing
Errosion of impeller
Off-design service
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Erosion
Impeller ( use
same as above)
Open
surface by foreign
Off-design service
material causes flow
angle to deviate and may
induce fatigue crack
Condition monitoring
Condition monitoring
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
1
2
2
1
D
D-2
EBC
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
D-2
D-2
CNM
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
same as above)
Fatigue
Pump
delivering
process
medium at
reduced
efficiency;
high vibration
Fatigue crack from
stress in runner
blade/vane due to
frequent start/stop of the
pump or excessive
Operating error
Clearance/Alignmen
Impeller clearance failure Maintenance error
t failure
Material wear on seal
faces, springs or O-rings
Mechanical seal
Wear & Tear
Condition monitoring
Condition monitoring
Casual Observation
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Seal flush cooler
fouling
Clogged
Condition monitoring
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
Potential reduced or no pumping capability,
Process Impact
Periodic condition
monitoring
Potential reduced or no pumping capability,
Process Impact
Periodic condition
monitoring
Periodic condition
monitoring
Potential reduced or no pumping capability,
Process Impact
Potential reduced or no pumping capability,
Process Impact
CNM
D-2
CNM
CNM
D-2
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
1
1
2
1
D
EBC
1
1
2
1
D
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Leakage
Loss of seal flush flow
which cause damage to
the seal faces
1
D-2
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
Misalignment
SCH
Regularly inspect seal flush tubing by
disassembling, include seal detection piping
Deformation
Shaft ( follow
above)
Breakage
Fatigue deformation from
misalignment, shaft
Maintenance error
imbalance and other
dynamic phenomena
Shaft damage by foreign
object ingestion due to
inadequate flushing of
pump suction line or
fatigue crack from
operating under stress
outside envelope
Condition monitoring
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
CNM
CNM
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
D
1
1
2
1
CNM
D-2
D
CNM
SCH
4
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
6M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
6M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1Y
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
3M
Mechanical
Rotating
No
LEVEL 2
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
1M
Operation
No
LEVEL 1
1
1
1
1
D
D-1
2 Condition Condition Condition
Base
Base
Base
Inspect seal flushing line orifice condition. Rectify if
necessary
SCH
CNM
EBC
1
Check for leakage
Verify Level, Pressure, quality and outlet
temperature of buffer fluid/flushing fluid is OK.
Monitor seal flush temperature on gauge, listen for
abnormal noise
Regularly inspect seal flush cooler and tubing
including orifice.
SCH
High Vibration
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Replace Buffer Fluid
SCH
D-2
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Monitor Seal flush temperature
Clean and unclogged seal flushing and cooling
water line
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
4
2
6M
6M
1Y
Bi
Weekly
1M
3M
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Check coupling and bolting condition and alignment.
Rectify if necessary
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Operating error
Condition monitoring
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
Verify Pump Flow is Above Minimum Flow
D-2
Verify Switch Setting & Valve Arrangement Correct
For Auto Start Function
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Check for abnormal sound / vibration / operating
parameter
Erosion
Pump suction
(strainer) /
discharge
Open
Blockage/plugged
Fatigue crack from
errosion/corrosion attact
Blockage due to debris
or inadvertently closed
suction valve
Off-design service
Off-design service
Condition monitoring
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
production due to redundancy
Pump failure will cause insignificant impact on
Production inteference production due to redundancy
1
1
2
1
D
CNM
Verify Pump Flow is Above Minimum Flow
D-2
Verify Switch Setting & Valve Arrangement Correct
For Auto Start Function
1
1
2
1
D
1
2
2
1
D
CNM
D-2
EBC
Perform offline vibration collection and analysis
Process parameter monitoring ie:. PDI across
strainer, pump discharge pressure, discharge flow.
Download