ETHICS LESSON 1: BASIC CONCEPTS IN PHILOSOPHY INTRODUCTION • Logic is offered as a first course in philosophy. In such a case, most of the students in Logic may have not have adequate background in Introductory Philosophy. Therefore, to help the students gain insight on the nature or the general notion about what philosophy is, it is deemed necessary to orient them on this topic before they go to the study of Ethics. MEANING OF PHILOSOPHY Philosophy may be defined in two ways: nominal (etymological) and real. Etymological Definition of Philosophy • The term philosophy is derived from the Greek words “philos” or “philein” (to love, to desire) and “sophia” (wisdom). • Literally means love of wisdom. • Thus, a philosopher is a “lover of wisdom” just like Socrates, Plato and Aristotle. • Wisdom, in this broadest sense, connotes knowledge – knowledge directed to the fundamental and pervasive concerns of existence. • Wisdom is all-encompassing. It is understanding on how we ought to live. It is how you systematically organize, structure and relate all available data and experiences. • Wisdom in philosophy consists of participation in life – the way you change things, to solve human problems or how you discover the meaning of life. • In short, the wisdom in philosophy is in how you help yourself think more clearly, precisely and systematically. Pythagoras (580 – 500 B.C.) ▪ a Greek mathematician and philosopher ▪ coined the word “love of wisdom”. ▪ founded the Pythagorean school known as Metempsychosis. ▪ Pythagorean Theorem is also attributed to him. ▪ Metempsychosis which stressed that the soul of man imprisoned in his body could be purified through selfexamination and strict discipline. ▪ Pythagorean Theorem stressed that the hypotenuse of a right-angled triangle is equal to the sum of the squares on the other sides. ▪ In one of his travels in an ancient Greek kingdom, he was asked by the king if he was a Sophos (a wise man), he said that he was not, but only a “lover of wisdom.” Gorgias (485 – 380 B.C.) ▪ a Greek orator and famous sophists (Greek word, sophistes). ▪ forerunner of the Aristotelian logic and Socratic dialectic. ▪ first to systematize the laws of thought but later, they emphasized material success and the ability to argue any case irrespective of its truth. Protagoras (580 – 500 B.C.) ▪ a Greek mathematician ▪ He is also a forerunner of the Aristotelian logic and Socratic dialectic like Gorgias. ▪ With Gorgias, they systematize the laws of thought but later, they emphasized material success and the ability to argue any case irrespective of its truth. 1 Herodotus (485 – 425 B.C.) ▪ a Greek historian known as the “Father of History”. ▪ Originally, he gave the literal meaning of philosophy. ▪ With Gorgias, they used the term philosophy as theoretical knowledge, that is, knowledge studied for its own sake. The study of philosophy has been expanded from its traditional meaning to include the study of man, matter and universe. Real Definition of Philosophy Since philosophy is too comprehensive and to various authors define philosophy according to what they think, what they believe, and what they ought to be done in the subject. Here are some of the definitions of various authors: 1. Philosophy is a process by which men ponder, discuss or argue over the use, application, limits or meaning of important ideas (Bresman and Gould, 1977). 2. Philosophy is quest for wisdom; an attempt to provide a vision of the world that is systematic and clear, in which the connection between significant facts are made manifest. It is the search for first thing (first principles) and last things (ultimate implications) (Minton and Shipka, 1982). 3. Philosophy is asking the right question that initiates philosophical thinking and direction (Barry, 1983). 4. Philosophy is the sum of all man’s beliefs and views about the world which guide his actions (Ariola, 1989). 5. Philosophy is the art of questioning everything; the goal of philosophy is wisdom and the wisdom requires questioning what is questionable (Kolak and martin, 1990) 6. Philosophy focuses on conceptual clarity and understanding from ignorance to knowledge (Earle, 1992). 7. Philosophy is the love or pursuit of wisdom; the search for the basic principles (The New Webster’s Dictionary of the English language, 1995). 8. Philosophy is the science of the things by their ultimate principles and causes, as known by natural reason alone (Pinon, 1995). 9. Philosophy is an attempt to see the wonders at our existence and at our place in the scheme of things (Melchert, 1999). 10. Philosophy is a systematic, reflective, critical, primarily reason-bound inquiring into the basic assumptions and guiding beliefs that people use to make sense of any dimension of their live (Christensen, 1999). 11. Philosophy is a human search for meaning; an intellectual quest that goes beyond the boundaries of concrete knowledge, towards the realm of the abstract where the inquisitive mind finds some satisfaction and wonder (Gualdo, 2000). 12. Philosophy is the never-ending search for the total human meaning of our experiences. It is a discipline that attempts to look for answers to man’s inquisitive mind that begins in wonder and ends in awe (Bauzon, 2002). 13. Philosophy is a rational critical thinking of a more or less systematic kind about the conduct of life, the general nature of the world, and the justification of belief (Encyclopaedia Americana, 2003). Thus, philosophy may be viewed as an activity undertake by men who are deeply concerned about who they are and what everything is all about in this world. The essence You can do it! ETHICS of philosophy is asking the right question that gives the right direction. IMPORTANCE OF PHILOSOPHY Philosophy as a subject: Enables the student to study, learn, and master the various branches and divisions of philosophy and the theories and beliefs of philosophers. Helps the student to develop the ability to form opinions and beliefs. Helps the student to be resilient and philosophically calm in the face of disorder and doubts, uncertainty, indefiniteness and chaos. Deepens the student’s self-awareness. Increases the student’s self-awareness and awareness of the world. Helps student to be creative. Helps the student to be imaginative. Provides the student with better intellectual perspective and outlook. Gives the student personal freedom. Helps the student to refine his power of analysis. Top Five (5) Reasons to Study Philosophy 1. Philosophy is a fascinating subject matter. Those who study philosophy are engaged in asking, answering, evaluating and reasoning about some of life’s most basic, meaningful, and difficult questions, such as: • What is to be human? • Is there a God? • What is truth? Is anything true? How can we tell it is true? • How do words come to have meaning? • Do mathematical objects exists? • What is time? Is time really real? 2. A wide variety of interesting courses taught by outstanding professors. There are philosophy courses that address moral issues, others that focus on the nature of science and technology, and many that explore some of the most important philosophical works written across the history. Some of the courses are broad survey courses, others are in-depth studies of particular issues, texts, or philosophers. 3. Skill development of students The study of philosophy will enable student to think, carefully, critically, and with clarity, take a logical approach to addressing challenging questions and examining hard issues, reason well and evaluate the reasoning of others, discuss sensibly and write effectively. Philosophy enhances analytical, critical, and interpretative capacities that are applicable to any subject matter and in any human context. 4. Great preparation for any career or graduate study Most students of philosophy don’t go on to become philosophy professors. But they do go on to get good jobs in a wide range of fields, including law, medicine, business, education, journalism, public policy, government, religion, communication fields, public relations, retail management, social service and many more. 5. For personal development The study of philosophy can be truly enriching and highly gratifying and it is excellent preparation for lifelong learning and an enhanced intellectual, political and social existence. 2 Philosophy’s critical skills also provide the best defense against popular foolishness and falsehoods. BRANCHES OF PHILOSOPHY SCHOOLS OF PHILOSOPHY The schools may be classified according to eastern and western philosophy. ‒ Eastern philosophy includes Taoism, Confucianism, Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism, Shintoism, among others. ‒ Western philosophy may be divided into Ancient, Medieval and Modern Schools. These schools are presented in the following: 1. ANCIENT AND MEDIEVAL SCHOOL OF PHILOSOPHY • Aristotelianism (derived from Aristotle) – is the excessive use of discursive reason and abstract aspects in proving scheme of things. • Atomism (Greek word atoma, “cannot be divide”) rational explanation of the general aspects of phenomena. • Eleaticism - deals with existence, thought and expression coalesced into one • Epicureanism (derived from the philosophy taught by Epicurus) or Hedonism - means that happiness is the chief good. • Monasticism - moral and physical disciplines based on worldly renunciations • Platonism (derived from the teaching of Plato) - deals with the doctrine of forms and numbers. • Pythagoreanism (derived from the teaching of Pythagoras) - deals with the metaphysics of numbers and reality – that reality is mathematical in nature. • Scholasticism – an intellectual discipline which shows the doctrines of the church are constant with reasons. • Skepticism - raising doubts about any knowledge beyond the control of directly felt experience about the world so that one still looks for truth. • Sophism - deals on a whole series of questions in order to seek ample solutions along clearly defined lines. • Stoicism - deals on the conduct of man characterized by peace of mind and certainty of moral truth. 2. MODERN SCHOOLS OF PHILOSOPHY • Analytical and Linguistic are concerned with the close and careful examinations of concepts. • Developmentalism is a child-centered point of view based on a careful study of the child. • Disciplinism refers education of the whole man through appropriate discipline. • Empiricism (from Greek word emperia, “experience”) means that what is true and real are those that are confirmed by actual experience. • Existentialism deals on the interpretation of human existence in the world that stresses concreteness and its problematic character. You can do it! ETHICS • • • • • • • • • Humanism stresses personal culture, individual freedom and development as the best way toward full and rich lives. Idealism deals with reality as spirit or consciousness and whatever that exists are chiefly mental or ideas and abstraction and laws are fundamental in reality, not sensory things Naturalism is concerned with the natural goodness of man and the formation of society based upon the recognition of natural rights. Phenomenology concerned with phenomena or events that are common experienced. Positivism deals with knowledge of the matter that is based on positive data of experience and is beyond pure logic and mathematics. Pragmatism is concerned with what is true and real that are useful, workable and practical. Rationalism deals with reason as the chief source and test of knowledge. Realism refers to the philosophy that is concerned with the activities of life and understanding of the individual in the society which he lives Utilitarianism deals with the philosophy that an action is right if it provides happiness of individual and everyone affected, it is wrong if it promotes dissatisfaction and unhappiness. SUB-FIELDS OF PHILOSOPHY ‒ Philosophy can be sub-divided into several sub-fields; each has its own particular doctrine in answering key questions. These sub-fields are described briefly in this section: • Philosophy of Arts deals on aesthetic value, expression, and other concepts that critic employs. • Philosophy of Education deals with speculation and application of philosophical method in the study of its issues and problems. • Philosophy of History deals with description of events and actions of man’s past happenings and those that are to happen in man. • Philosophy of Language deals with languages their meanings and how to use and manage the language to man’s existence. • Philosophy of Law deals with the formulation of theories and concepts to help man, understand its nature, its sources of authority a role in society. • Philosophy of Logic deals with the laws of thought, rules of right reasoning, principles of valid argumentation and truth based solely on the meaning of the term they contain. • Philosophy of Mathematics is concerned on the critical examination of basic mathematical entities, mathematical theories and number system. • Philosophy of Mind deals with the nature of the mind, desire, emotion, pleasure, and pain and how they enter into the explanation of human action. • Philosophy of Nature deals with whatever issues regarding the actual features of nature as reality and is divided into philosophy of physics and biology. • Philosophy of Politics deals with the questions of the origin of the state and authority and the law of the land. • Philosophy of Psychology deals on the actual theories and research efforts of contemporary psychologists. • Philosophy of Reading deals on a set of beliefs on how reading should be taught based on research and current thinking about reading. 3 • • • Philosophy of Religion deals on situations, experiences, issues and problems relating to religion and its methodology. Philosophy of Science provides intellectually and accurately satisfying explanations of a broad range of natural phenomena. Philosophy of Society deals with questions about personal morality in relation to man’s existence as member of society. MORAL PHILOSOPHY ‒ Branch of philosophy that contemplates what is right and wrong. It explores the nature of morality and examines how people should live their lives in relation to others. Branches of Moral Philosophy (Areas of Study in Ethics) 1. Meta-ethics, concerning the theoretical meaning and reference of moral propositions, and how their values (if any) can be determined. Meta-ethics answers the questions: What is morality? What is justice? Is there truth? How can I justify my belief as better than the beliefs held by others? 2. Normative ethics, concerning the practical means of determining a moral course of action. Normative ethics answers the question: What we ought to do? 3. Applied ethics, concerning what a person is obligated (or permitted) to do in special situation or a particular domain of action. Applied Ethics answers the question: Should we lie to help a friend or co-worker? LESSON 2: ETHICS OR MORAL PHILOSOPHY ETHICS OR MORAL PHILOSOPHY ‒ Branch of philosophy that involves the systematizing, defending, and recommending the concepts of right and wrong conduct. ‒ The term “ethics” derives from the Ancient Greek word (ethikos), which comes from the word (ethos) or “Habit”, “custom”. The branch of philosophy which is axiology comprises the sub-branches of ethics and aesthetics, each concerned with values. ‒ It tries to create a sense of right and wrong in the organizations and often when the law fails, it is ethics that may the organization from harming the society or environment. IMPORTANCE OF ETHICS It satisfies basic human needs. o Being fair, honest and ethical is one of the basic human needs. It creates credibility. o An organization that is believed to be driven by moral values is respected in the society even by those who may have no information about the working and the businesses or an organization. It unites people and leaders. o This goes along the way in aligning behaviours within the organization towards achievement of one common goal or mission. It improves decision-making. o Decisions are driven by values. It brings long term gains. o Organizations guided by ethics and values are profitable in the long run, though in the short run they seem to lose money. It secures the society. o Ethics succeeds because there is a law in safeguarding the society. You can do it! ETHICS CODE OF ETHICS FOR LEADERS ▪ The code of ethics leaders use determines discipline procedures and the acceptable behaviour for all workers in the organization. ▪ When leaders have high ethical standards, they encourage workers in the organization to meet that same level. ▪ Ethical leadership also enhances the company’s reputation in the financial market and community. ▪ A solid reputation for ethics and integrity in the community may improve the company’s business. 2. 3. 4. EMPLOYEE ETHICS ▪ Employee behaviour among workers in an organization ensures that employees complete work with honesty and integrity. ▪ Employees who use ethics to guide their behaviour adhere to employee policies and rules while striving to meet the goals of their organization. ▪ Ethical employees also meet standards for quality in their work, which can enhance the company’s reputation for quality products and services. 5. 6. ETHICAL ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE ▪ Leaders and employees adhering to a code of ethics create an ethical organizational culture. ▪ The leaders of business organizations may create an ethical culture by exhibiting the type of behaviour they would like to see in their employees. ▪ The organization can reinforce ethical behaviour by rewarding employees who exhibit the values and integrity that coincides with the company’s code of ethics and discipline those who make the wrong choices. BENEFITS OF ETHICS TO THE ORGANIZATION 1. A positive and healthy corporate culture. a. It improves the morale of workers in the organization which may increase productivity and employee retention; this, in turn has financial benefits for the organization. 2. Higher levels of productivity. b. It improves the efficiency in the company, while increasing employee retention reduces the cost of replacing employees. 3. Ethics and morals direct decision-making. c. It regulates how people should behave in a given culture. 4. Ethical rules and virtuous business practices rely on moral standards as their bases. 5. Ethics and morals help keep government and cultures from descending into anarchy. WHY SHOULD STUDENTS STUDY ETHICS? ➢ Ethics allows student to live an authentic and meaningful life. ➢ Ethics makes student more successful. ➢ Ethics allows student to cultivate inner peace. ➢ Ethics provides for a stable society. ➢ Ethics may help out in the afterlife. MEANING AND IMPORTANCE OF RULES Rules are defined in several ways: 1. Rules are instructions that tell you what you are allowed to do and what you are not allowed to do. Raise your hand when you want to ask questions. You are not allowed to go to the canteen while classes are going on. 4 7. A rule is a statement telling people what they should do in order to achieve success or a benefit of some kind. Eat nutritious food to maintain a healthy life. Study your lesson well in order to get high grades in the Ethics class. Rules are statement that describe the way things usually happen in a particular situation. In English, adjectives generally precede the noun they modify. In Science, all objects thrown up, go down. Rule tells you the normal state of affairs. Schools are established for the education of the individual. Policemen have the duties to maintain peace and order. Rules influence or restrict actions in a way that is not good for a person. It has been found that fear can ruin our lives and make us ill. Unauthorized persons are not allowed to enter this room. Rules tell us something that is true or should happen and then the authority has officially decided that it is true. The court has decided that the respondent is liable for civil damages. The judge has finally decided that the protest is in favour of the complainant. Rules are principles or regulations governing conduct, action, procedure, arrangement. Fall in line when entering the classroom. Knock before you enter. Importance of Rules Prudent laws are the foundations of a nation because they define the parameters of civil society. If laws become elastic, the boundaries become dysfunctional. Laws organize our lives. We are able to deal and live together because of rules and laws. Rules help us get along together and show respect to each other. If there are no rules to follow, everyone is free to do whatever he wants. Most things we do are governed by rules. Imagine if a student ignores the rule against talking in class, the teacher will not be able to achieve her goal and other students cannot concentrate. Drivers who disobey traffic rules can cause serious accidents. Rules organize the relations between individuals and between societies to make it clear to them what is right and wrong. They are designed to ensure fairness, safety and respect for each other’s rights. Rules make the world a peaceful place to live. Rules are needed in our community because they serve as balances between laws and rights. If there are more laws than rights, there is more chance that people will revolt because of the lack of their rights. LESSON 3: DILEMMAS AND THE FOUNDATION OF ETHICS DIFFERENCE BETWEEN MORAL STANDARDS AND NONMORAL STANDARDS Moral means… • Moral quality (rightness or wrongness, goodness or badness) is present, that is, what is either right or wrong. • What is right or morally good and this is opposed to immoral, that is ---- wrong is morally bad. You can do it! ETHICS Moral Standards ‒ Those moral actions which are within the moral sphere and are thus objects of moral judgments. Non-moral actions or standards ‒ Those are actions devoid of moral quality and thus excluded from the scope of moral judgment. INSTINCTIVE ACTION • An instinctive action is one in which an individual feels himself impelled without knowing the end to be accomplished yet with the ability to select, the methods for the attainment of an object. • Instinctive tendencies are found most explicitly in lower animals and are expressed in the activities displayed by them in seeking food. Actions of animals and insects. Grazing of a cow Mourning of a dog or cat Actions of young children and insanes and idiots Actions done under compulsion Actions under the spell of hypnotic forces • These actions are not morally wrong, because they are not moral actions. They are incapable of discriminating between right and wrong. Moral Dilemmas and the Foundation of Ethics A moral dilemma is a situation where: You are presented with two or more actions, all of which you have the ability to perform. There are moral reasons for you to choose each of the actions. You cannot perform all of the actions and have to choose which action, or actions when there are three or more choices to perform. Since there are moral reasons for you to choose each action, and you cannot choose them all, it follows that no matter what choice you make, you will be failing to follow your morals. In other words, someone or something will suffer no matter what choice you make. THREE (3) LEVELS OF MORAL DILEMMA ➢ INDIVIDUAL o An individual moral dilemma is experienced by individuals who have a hard time to choose the right action from two or more actions. No matter what choice, the individual has someone or something will suffer no matter choice the individual makes. ➢ ORGANIZATIONAL o In an organizational moral dilemma, administrative decisions are characterized as having routines and challenges. o In business, organizations, there are always dilemmas encountered by the administrator and the employees. It is really very hard to pin down the necessary morals to benefit the company. Guiding institutionalization and nurturing conflict are both viewed as useful in moral leadership within organizations. ➢ SYSTEMIC o Systemic types of dilemma occur in the ordinary conditions of life. Why do dilemmas occur in ordinary everyday life? Some, however, may not seem to be dilemmas at all but an ordinary ethical problem. Also, while it is common in a modern ethics to address dilemma merely to propose 5 theories to resolve, it must be remembered that systemic dilemmas may betray a structure to ethics that means they cannot be resolved. ‒ ‒ ‒ Dilemmas are dilemmas because they are well, dilemmas. More moralists or philosophers skip over the question of why they are systemic dilemmas, from the conviction that we all want the dilemmas resolved and this is the only significant issue. Such an attitude, however, is hopeless if it turns out that the nature of dilemmas is to remain a system’s dilemmas. FOUNDATION OF ETHICS ● Around 800 BC, an individual’s moral duties stemmed from his or her position in society. ● This was because society was composed of very tightly knit clans which placed loyalty to clan above everything else. ● Achilles or Odysseus had to behave in certain ways because their identity as kings enjoined upon them a particular code of moral behavior. o The violation of which would be a crime. ● Around 5th century BC in Athens, as the strength of clans declined, moral dilemmas began to crop up. ● What may be considered moral from the standpoint of the clan can be considered immoral from the standpoint of the Greek city-state. ● When these moral dilemmas arose, people found very difficult to resolve them. ● In Greek literature, moral dilemmas at that time were usually resolved by the intervention of the gods. ● Same as the Mahabharata, where moral dilemmas are resolved through the intervention of Lord Krisma. ● Some Philosophers of the Ancient Greece were so smart enough to realize that the gods don’t really intervene to help people resolve their moral dilemmas. ● Therefore, with the lack of divine interventions, moral dilemmas will forever remain unresolved ● Thus, these philosophers, known today as Sophists, argued that there are no foundations to ethics, and that one must be able to argue for either side of the moral dilemma. ● Believing Greece gods don’t really intervene to help people resolve their moral dilemmas. You can do it! ETHICS ● ● This view generated the reaction in the form of the great triad of Greek philosophy: Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. All of them argued for strong foundations for ethics. Their views, especially Aristotle’s formed the general backbone of moral philosophy in Europe and the Islamic world until the 17th century. THREE (3) FOUNDATION OF ETHICS 1. Teleology ‒ Greek word – TELOS, meaning purpose. ‒ Ethics is important because it serves s purpose. ‒ The purpose (telos) is raising the human nature from the raw to unfinished state of life. ‒ For Aristotle, the philosophical foundation of ethics lay in its ability to transfer human nature from its raw form to its highest potential. 2. Utilitarianism ‒ It is the belief that human nature compels man to move towards pleasure and move away from pain. ‒ Thus, a good system of ethics will allow the maximum number of people to move towards pleasure and away from pain – in other words, “the greatest good for the greatest number.” Would you torture someone if you thought it would result in information that would prevent a bomb from exploding and killing hundreds of people? ‒ The moral system founded by English philosopher Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832) and encapsulated in the principle of “the greatest good for the greatest number”. 3. Deontology ‒ It is the belief that morality must be followed for its own sake. ‒ According to the deontologists, “A good act is intrinsically good, and it must be performed without regard to consequences, but because it is the individual’s duty as a rational being to perform good act, the individuals must be aware of the consequences of their actions.” ‒ These school of thought was criticized by Friedrick Nietzche. According to him, “these schools of thought were nothing but mere rationalizations that concealed the WILL to POWER, that is the desire to dominate others." ‒ There are some small group of philosophers who consider themselves to be Aristotelian who argue that Friedrick Nietzche’s critique is plausible only if the people reject Aristotle’s teleology. RELATION BETWEEN ETHICS AND BELIEFS • Magda Healey o She said that Ethics (moral philosophy) asks fundamental questions of: ▪ how human beings should live, ▪ what goals and values would they strive for, ▪ what is right and what is wrong, ▪ what is virtuous and what is wicked. • Religious beliefs give meaning to people’s lives and professes the existence and ultimate supremacy of a spiritual, supernatural, scared or divine realm that transcends the material reality of the day-to-day life. • The realms of Ethics and Religious belief overlap but are not identical. o Most – Thought not All ▪ Religious belief proved their faithful with guidance as to ethical conduct. o Much – but by no means All 6 Moral philosophy has roots in or connections to religious belief. Many religious systems adopt a super-naturalist, or God-based, ethics The deity is the only source of moral rules, and people must do what God wants them to lead a good life. God speaks directly to people through the prophets and recorded texts o This approach is notable in the Abrahamic religious: Judaism, Christianity and Islam God’s rules are passed directly to the people and recorded in the holy scriptures. o The Ten Commandments of Moses, much of Christ’s preaching in the Gospels and many of the Quran’s suras are such direct teachings concerning ethical conducts. o Hindu Vedas are another examples of words of the deity revealed directly. Direct communication from the deity is only one-way religious teach about ethics. The best ways to live one’s life and solve moral dilemmas are explored indirectly in many sacred books and texts of religious significance, from the Hindu epic Ramayana to the whole tradition of Christian apologetics to the Taoist To Te Ching. Besides the written word, the priests, monks, and teachers of most religions, from the Zen Buddhist gurus to Judaistic rabbis are considered to be moral authorities, able to provide ethical guidance through their deep understanding of the spiritual realm. Most people would agree that one should lead a good life, whatever the definition of the good life their particular belief system proposes. A supernaturalist approach dominates the Abrahamic religion and refers to God’s will as the ultimate moral authority: o People should do what God desires, and what God desire is good. Although Moral Philosophy is rooted in religious beliefs, secular ethics have a tradition going back to the ancient times. Many intellectuals’ thinkers who subscribed to some forms of a religious belief system recognize that it is possible to live a good life without recourse to religion. o The Apostles Paul of the New Testaments and the current Dalai Lama, who called of universal “Human Values” with “no relationship with any particular religion and this is particularly true even today.” Although it is clear that Atheists can live ethical existence, the difficulty they grapple with is a justification for ethics, the question of where the morality ultimately comes from. o The most common answers point to shared social convention and contract or to universal human nature with its evolutionary roots. ▪ • • • • • • • • • • • • ETHICAL BELIEFS AND MORAL BELIEFS • Ethics recognizes the existence of a set of universals about life, or at least about human life that establish principles that make for a healthy society of healthy individuals. • These societies establish a set of principles that can be phrased and held as beliefs. They are subject to exploration and interpretation. • Four Principles / Guidelines that are Generally Found Across Human Culture You can do it! ETHICS o o o o • • • • 7 Non-killing principle Non-lying principle Not stealing principle Not breaking vows of sexual conduct principle. Societies that are murderous, dishonest, lawless, and licentious don’t do well Various religious and moral systems can frame (non-killing, non-lying, not stealing and not breaking vows) as coming from God or arising from some other bases of authority. These core principles (non-killing, non-lying, not stealing and not breaking vows) and their interpretations and practices can be seen as ethics. Note: that in wide variety of interpretations. Non-killing principle ▪ There are many valid perspectives that can be phrased as questions ▪ Does this require vegetarian? ▪ Does it mean that all war is wrong? ▪ What does it say about death penalty? Morality is related to ethics but is bound in a cultural context and history of interpretation which is partly conscious, and partly not. So, the religious system of all religious that lay out and interpret ethical principles and also present other values and rules about life are moral beliefs. You can do it!