Uploaded by migishinichi0128

Research Analysis.

advertisement
2
REVIEWED AND PREPARED BY:
• Salvatierra, Eloisa Aubrey L.
• Santos, Avi Lorenxo M.
• Selecia, Shane Angel S.
• Silvestre, Ma. Graciela D.
• Torres, Ezer Gabriel F.
CONTENTS:
Statement of Problem and Specific Objectives
Related Theories
Research Methods
Results or findings
Conclusion
Citation of Reference (Author of thesis and Title)
PROFESSIONAL WELL-BEING
CHART RETRIEVED FROM
STUDY
STATEMENT OF
THE PROBLEM
THE STUDY HIGHLIGHTS A COMPLEX INTERPLAY OF FACTORS
CONTRIBUTING TO DISSATISFACTION AMONG CIVIL ENGINEERS,
IMPACTING THE PROFESSION'S OVERALL WELL-BEING. THESE
FACTORS INCLUDE THE PROFESSION'S LOW PUBLIC PROFILE,
CHALLENGES IN ATTRACTING TOP STUDENTS TO ENGINEERING,
DECLINING TECHNICAL SKILLS IN GRADUATES, AN OVERSUPPLY OF
ENGINEERS IN THE JOB MARKET, INTENSE COMPETITION
AFFECTING FEES, AND REDUCED INCOME FOR PRACTICING
ENGINEERS. THESE ISSUES FORM A FEEDBACK LOOP, WHERE ONE
PROBLEM LEADS TO OTHERS, RESULTING IN A DECLINE IN THE
PROFESSION'S REPUTATION. RECENT LITERATURE SHOWS A
GROWING CONCERN AMONG ENGINEERS ABOUT UNIVERSITIES'
DISCONNECT FROM PRACTICAL NEEDS, THE NEED FOR MORE
PROMOTION OF ENGINEERING, WORRIES ABOUT OVERSUPPLY,
UNEMPLOYMENT AMONG TOP GRADUATES, LOW SALARIES, AND
SKEPTICISM ABOUT PREDICTED SHORTAGES OF ENGINEERS.
ADDRESSING THESE ISSUES COMPREHENSIVELY IS CRUCIAL FOR
IMPROVING THE PROFESSION'S STANDING AMIDST ECONOMIC
PRESSURES.
SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES
• Improve Graduation Standards: Implement corrective measures for graduating students to
demonstrate proficiency in at least one aspect of civil engineering, with a proposed minimum
80% average in a student-selected field of specialization.
• Certification Integration: Integrate distinct certifications into diplomas for meeting minimum
criteria in specific subdisciplines of civil engineering, linking academic certification requirements
to professional registration and practice.
• Market Awareness and Training: Create a mandatory final-year practical course on marketing
engineering services to enhance awareness of market forces and teach effective methods of
operation within market pressures.
• Quality Control and Professional Registration: Tighten quality control through rigorous
examinations for specific civil engineering designations, ensuring equivalence in practice
standards for registered engineers, including immigrants, through specific certification and
examination processes.
• Legitimacy of Engineer Title: Enhance the legitimacy of the engineer title by demonstrating
competency through stringent exams and educating clients about the relationship between
quality and fees in engineering services to promote fair pricing and recognition of value.
RELATED THEORIES
The Human Capital Theory, while highlighting
the impact of education on productivity and
earnings, falls short in addressing the complex
challenges faced by professions like civil
engineering. These challenges, including public
image, student attraction, technical excellence,
market dynamics, competition, income gaps,
and innovation, cannot be adequately tackled
through a narrow educational lens. The paper
advocates for a comprehensive approach,
stressing the need for economically viable
solutions that recognize the interconnectedness
of these factors. Utilizing tools like the
Professional Well-Being Chart, the focus is on
holistic strategies rather than solely
emphasizing education's role in professional
success.
The proposed framework for addressing
professional dissatisfaction and enhancing
the civil engineering profession's well-being
also aligns with Change Management
Theory, drawing from established models
like Kotter's, Jick's, and GE's. This
framework emphasizes a structured and
methodical approach to change,
incorporating practical strategies from realworld contexts, such as a Fortune 500
defense industry firm. It integrates
methodologies like mind mapping, lessons
learned, storytelling, and metaphors, typical
in change management practices, to
enhance communication and engagement
among stakeholders. By combining
theoretical principles with practical tools, the
framework aims to offer comprehensive
guidance for successfully navigating
organizational change within civil
engineering.
RESEARCH METHODS
The paper advocates for a comprehensive approach
to improving the civil engineering profession,
emphasizing economic viability and addressing
multiple aspects of the profession's challenges. It
introduces a research method centered on the
Professional Well-Being Chart, which tracks key
parameters impacting the profession's state. The
methodology suggests tactics derived from this chart
data, ensuring that proposed improvements are both
feasible and financially sustainable. In essence, the
methodology offers a systematic and economically
viable strategy to enhance the condition of civil
engineering.
FINDINGS
In his research, Michel Bruneau explores ways to enhance the
well-being of the civil engineering community, emphasizing a
comprehensive approach with multiple effective strategies.
These strategies include:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Enhancing the public image of civil engineers.
Attracting top talent to the field.
Ensuring excellence in graduating students.
Upholding high standards for professional engineers.
Adapting market conditions for civil engineering services.
Improving job prospects for engineers.
Encouraging innovation, research, and development.
The analysis of each strategy considers both its benefits and
limitations. The research underscores the need for coordinated
action to implement these strategies effectively, as significant
reforms cannot happen without widespread collaboration.
Immediate adoption of this action plan is recommended to
enhance the overall health and well-being of civil engineers.
9
CONCLUSION
The research identifies crucial measures for
improving the well-being of civil engineering. It
suggests key initiatives and a comprehensive plan to
address major challenges highlighted by Bruneau
(1993). Urgent action is emphasized, stressing the
need for collaborative efforts to bring meaningful
change. The proposed approach aims to initiate
constructive dialogue and progressive reforms for a
resilient and thriving civil engineering profession.
10
CITATION OF REFERENCES
Bruneau, M. (1994). Strategies to Enhance Well‐Being of Civil
Engineering Profession. Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering
Education and Practice, 120(4), 341–359.
Marginson, S. (2019). Limitations of human capital theory. Studies in
Higher Education, 44(2), 287–301.
Mento, A., Jones, R., & Dirndorfer, W. (2019). A change management
process: Grounded in both theory and practice. Journal of Change
Management, 3(1), 45–59.
THANK
YOU!
Download