Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
!#"$"&% http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
')(*,+.-&/01-
,
'
",+.2
3 5
47698;:=<>8@? 40AB5C5DEF;:HGJIKMLN:O540P :JNIRQ5L8CS8TVU @WG=4X8Y>8@:OUSI[Z\TL:OUSIWML>T]U^LNM4JU^LTZV_L`
L>_ML>8@:JNIRQ9G7_M4Xa:bQ54X@_:HML5UcL>Td:H8e69_fNgQ5569_ML>W_ML9L`5_ML>T4X@`h<>@IU @
iKjkilnm mJoXpqj
rKts@uwvBxKyauWsNuWyz[v|{~}Kyb@uWyaz[s@ yKdzvXxKyW[tyvXnsNzWs zKyvyK[xzKs@ sM yNvBxKyVy[vXx b@uWyzK[ns@zK
xKFyWbs@zby0zyKduyR\};v~ v 7=s@z zvXxyWN;vXuazWsKkvXxKv|{k}KyKb@uWyW@z[Nns@K[ 7@tyWs xKs
tyKv @tyvXxy@zKyt[zK9zvXxKyJv byz[vX@{ b@zWvyvXxKyWs@zKOy[v s u zKyKbyvsWvXxKyWKa{
uWy[vkN t7y¡@vXxKyWybyyK WNuWs@Kz[Fyz[vs@VsvXxKytqv~tyzKdu[xzy¢s@5vBxKya}zKaNz
uWNz;sKvBxKyV@uzKvXxzK
N@zK£{]ytya}KsvXxW[yK@¤yt=Kv ¥|yKs@tyW¥ y¦ #§Nynybs[u¨bs@z;¢y©yzKbyR>@zK£{ yzKOsNz[vytyKdxuª}[
[xK@zKOyazvXxKya}NVsvXxKyaxsKvyKcvy|}KsvXxWs@VbyKO[nsNz«ytyWsFyX@{ 7=[ vtvBzKa vBx¬Js@xz­NyK@0ny>
®y0¤yny[ xnsbs@xyV$xKsqvXKny«OsNzb[ns@K[zKybK¯hxnyW7yW7ytyv@¤zK@\@Nts[xKy°@zKa
bs@z[ytbvXns@za}KyKNzRNvXxy;}J±0yKJv s5$x ;x°xNz[vuWyvsWvXx =
{~xFduanbby9@¦ v@¤$@zKvXxKyW[}KbyK²MKyz;v~Nzy[vBxKv~@Nz¬Js@xzaxK9}yKyzWs@zNzvBxKy[ zsF
n[¤yd0 Mx[vkW$xKytyvXxKy;¦ dny[cv sKct$ vXxaNb@zKvXxv\vBxKyatvyWs ua©sKyuWyz;v]svyK[xzsNns
7=s@zKvsbbynytvyW@zKvXxKv 7yWytyWs@zKvs£}KyKbs@uWyats@}Ksv=s@5KbyW vBx°ts@}sKv«s@Vbs@uWy[vXxz
¤yvXxKv0Nz¬Js@xzWbs@z[vy0zKvXxKvVvXxn=bs@nz¦ v~xNKyzR\}Kyb@KbyvXxyatsN}sv=bs@nz¦ vk}KyWOsNzb[ns@KK
¯hxny{~xKdxKyNta[[xv@¤W}y[sNtyR5{kxKaNnK¢y v byz[vXnyz;v~©sN}sKv«ytyazvXxKyatyNu¨s5O[nyzKby
nJvB s@zNM®[vkzKs=@ts@u¨bs@uWyKs@zy{kty[KyKqvyK>5{ 7xKyK@0zKaJvBts@zKaNtMuWyz[vVvXxKvVvBxKy[7ytyW
zKyK@vy0uªKsb[} vt>>{]Fv@¤yzW@}K[¤[yK;KyK[n@ M yzaN¦ tsFyz@} vtWvs uWzKyW@zKa[tyKvy
vXxKy[vX©yN@{ @tyK ¤KzyK*vXxKvkzKy*vyK;xzKs@nsFM y¤yWyzKy;vXn«yzKzKyy0zKa@zKdzK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns7yty
NzKdKvXxKyasFyvs tyuWN¤yvXxKyWsN³ @V}[v ty@nJvB =@zKdu°uazKyz[v bbyzK@0 s´¢s@|z;vy yz[vkts@}Ksv
[00 OyKduWyN
{tv0¦n«yJWvsy[v@±µyaN}sN;v];K[xa}tyN¤OvXxts@xKK¯ yaxKyK@|zvXxyazKyK«@uWsJv y[Fys5bs@uWy
¤KzKasvyK;xzKs@ns O@Ks@\b; yz[vX =NzbyNF¶Ny[vVvXxn=7zKss@tzK@ tynJvXns@zN>{XzvBxKyaxKsvy}K@\@
FyauWyW K@vB @ty0z[v s xnvXxKyzs@vXxKOsNuazKd}Kss@¤@·¸N¹º »¹W¼½¾¿ÀÂÁ0ÀÄâÅÆÇÈ«ÆÉq¸ÀÂÊN¹ÌËHÍ7$xn[x
s@[vXzKyKa ;vs@n xKysNtyb&Îs@zKyazxn[xaxuW@zK=@zyKdzKyK@|uauWs@v@ v© }[ }KyKOs@u°zKas@zKyW$ vXx
ts@}KsvXnvyK;xzKs@nsFR>ÏzatyKzKd v0\ubyzKbyWs zKybyWs@z z[vyzK; nyKÐ|{V¢y v];tyaxKyaxKvs }y
zKytJvKvBzvBxKyW@zKyt\zKytJvvXzKvXxKyats@}K@} vts5 }Fas@[vOs@uyW@ns@zKvXxnKvXxN
{\s@zKduFby uWsJvVvXts@} yd}[ KbOFyWy[vNzKaÑÒËvs@ @zWbOyzK@0nsVÓ
THE NEW LUDDITE CHALLENGE
rKtJvkny[vkKKsJvBnKvyvXxKvVvXxKyWbs@ua[vyVb[nyz;vXnJv=[KObyKydzWy;Fy s@zKdz[vynyz;v~uW[xzKyvXxKv
1 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
b@zWs@[vXxzK}y[vtvyvXxK@zaxuW@z°}yzK=b@zWsWvBxKyu @{BzvBxKv]OFOyatyK;uWN} @K7s@0¤$}y
s@zKya}[WFqv0\x Mx s@tNz yKaJJvyuW«s uW[xzKy«@zKdzKs£xuW@zy;^s@v $}KyazKyKOyKbON vBxKyVs
v7sbbyuanx[v sb[X§5xKyauW[xzKyKuanx[vk}KyaKy0ua v©vyKvs£u@¤yWNKsvXxy\szyK[n[ns@zK=$ vXxKs@[v
xuW@zWsKyt; Mx[v0>s@Vynbyaxu@zWbs@z[vX©sNsKyvXxKyauW[xzKyu°nx[vk}Kyaty;v@zKyK
{tvXxKyauW[xzKy=Ntyay0ua vtvyvs uWN¤yW@;vXxKyVs$zWyK; ; s@zKÌ>7yWONzR¦ vkuWN¤yW@z[bs@zJ±0yKJvBtyK=vs
vXxKyaty[ vÌ\}Kyb@Kbya vk uaKsb[}nyvsMKyKbxKs)[[xau[xzyKu°nx;v~}yxKyN¯£ys@z Ks@z[v s@[v
vXxKvVvXxKyvyWsvXxKyaxu@zatbyW7s@nd}KyWvVvXxKyauWytqsKvBxKyauWF;xzKyK@{tvkua x;vk}KyWN©KyKvXxv\vBxKy
xuW@zatFOyW7s@n9zy[y|}Ky¢ss@ ;xyzKs@Kxvs£xK@zKasKyV@;vXxKyaKsyvsWvXxyau[xzyKKM®[v 7yW@ty
[KyKJvBz9zy vXxKy5vBxKv\vBxKyaxuW@zatFOyW7s@nFs@z[v@0 WvX0zaKs7y\syvsWvXxyau[xzyKzKs@5vBxKv
vXxKyauW[xzKy«s@n° by yaKs7yX¯hxKv yWs[yKqv~nvXxKvVvXxyaxuW@z°tbyauanx[v yK;
Ky³u° vk vby vs0 ^vkz[vs Ks[ vXns@zWsK5;K[xWyKyzKyzKOyWsNzvXxyau[xzyKvXxKvk v]s@ dxKyazKs
tJvXnb@[xKs@nbya}[vVvsFOby;v]@KsvXxKyauW[xzKy¦Ky[n[nsNzK5=bs[ny;vt@zKvXxKyats@}nyuWvXxKvVFOya v
}KyKOs@uyauWs@tyW@zKdus@tyWbs@uany[@zKduW[xzKyK}Kybs@uWyaus@tyW@zKduWs@tyaz[vy yz[v³\KysN yWny[v
uWF;xzKyKuW@¤yauWsN©ysvBxKyVyK[n[ns@zK¢s@vXxKyu>[ua }KyKb@byau;xzyJuyWyK[n[ns@zK=$}0zK
}Ky[v©vy|ty[ vvXxK@zauWNzRHuWyWs@zKyK
[yz[vBK@ qvyauWK }yatyK[xKyaKv x ;xvBxKyWy[n[ s@z
zKyKOyKbON Wvs ¤yKyvXxyWJFqvyu 0zzzKa$}KyWbsbs@ua y;WvXxKvkxuW@za}KyzK«}y°zKON@} yWs
uWN¤zKvBxKyu z;vy yz[vB vVvXxKv JvFyvXxKyauW[xzKy«}y°zWy[c¢yJvX FyWOs@z[vXts@ [yKs@nyW7s@z¦ vk}Ky
@}nyvs=±JKJvVvX³zvBxKyau[xzyK=s^©\}Kyb@KbyvBxKy[}KyWOsyKyzKyz[v s@zvXxKyuwvXxKvVvX³zzKvBxKyu sKc
7s@naNuWs@z[vVvs[n[ny@
Ï7zvXxyWsKvBxKy|xK@zKd v~nKsb[}nyvXxKvkxu@zWbs@z[vBtsNsKyvXxKyauW[xzKyu }Kyaty;v@zKyK5>{XzvXxKv bby
vXxKyWytyauW@z°uW xKFyWbs@z;vXts@KsFy\byv@za0 FvyauW[xzKyK=s xn=s$z[K[xWxn«ONVs@Îx
Ky©bs@zK@Kbs@ua[vy\}[v bs@z[vXts@Ksy| @tyWqFJvyuW=sK uW[xzKy=$}KyazvXxyaxK@zK=s5WvXz[y vy
±HJv F vk vsK\};v] vBxv7sM c¢ytyzbyK
|Kyvs uatsFyvyK[xzn²Ky7vBxKyWy vyW$xKFyWMtyKvy
bs@z[vXts@sKyvXxKyauWbby[Ð @zKd}KyKO@KbyaxuW@zW7s@0¤$$zKs ns@zKyÎ}yazKyKOyKbb@WvBxKyauObyK=$}Ky
[yKs@>£Kbynyb}tyzs@zvXxyqFJvyu @{tvBxKyWy vyan0;vXxnyKO7vBxKy[ uW[u° yK[nyvs
y[vy0uazKvyvXxyaub=s xu@z vt@{tvBxKy[@tyaxuW@zKyvXxy[ uW byats@K@zKs@\svXxy
KJ[xKs@nsnb@Ks@Î}ns@ns O@[vy[xzn²Kyvs tyKbyvBxKya}vXxatvyaz[vB;vXxKyauWb=sKxuWNz v© }KyKOsNuWy
y[vXzKJv0VnyKNzKvXxKyWs@0 vs´vXxKyWy vy@Ï\ vXxKyWy vyWbs@zK[nJv=s5bscv0HxyK@vy9}Kyt@n@vXxKy; u
yK; yvs nWvXxKyats@nyWs5ss°;xKyxKytvsWvXxKyatyJv svXxKyaxu@zatbyNF§5xKy[KOyKyvs£ vVvXxKv
y[ysNzy¦ x;F[nb@zyKyK«@tyWOKvB qnyK>NvXxKv @K[xntyzW@tyat@nbyKdzy|KJ[xKs@ns O@ x[nyzn
bs@zK vXns@zK@vXxKv y[ys@zKyaxK=$xKs@nyKOs@uyaxKs@}};Wvs ¤yKy°xuª}KJ>@zKvXxKv @z[Fs@zKyWxKs uW
}KyKOs@uyWnbOKvBnJnyKdzytsFy
vXtyvXuWyz[v vs[tyaxn
Jts@}nyu ÎÏ5bs@tbyR\ yW$}KyWbs
0sFOynyKbvBxKv~yKs@nyW$xKFyvs£}Kya}ns@ sM b@ s@ÎKqF[xKs@nsnb@ yzKzKyytyKay vBxKyvs ©yuWsFy
vXxKy|zKyyK¢s@vXxKyaKsy|tsbyKO=sN|uWN¤yvXxKyu µ;}uvy vXxKy\0 y¢s@ÎsFy|z[vsOs@uyaxK@0uanyKb
xKs@}}[§5xKybyWyzKMzyKytyKdxuW@z°}yzKuW }KyaxK@[ zW[K[xWOsF; y;vt\}[vVvBxKy[$uWsJv by v@z
zKsvk}KytyyNF§Mxy[$xKya}KyKyz°tyKOyKvsWvBxKyWJvvX«s5sNuWyJvXn=NzuW@nK
{XzvXxKya}Kss@¤[@Fs@Ws@z¦ v nbOsKy|z[vB;Fs@vX0zvXxKyaFyvXxKvVvXxKyW@[vXxs@\svXxnKbby°n#§5xKyKss@ty
bONzK[¤ vXxy \zN}sNua}KyX@{ @uªzKs@sNnsnJvV¢s@|bONzK[¤ n}Ks@u°}¤nyKvXxtyKyaKys@nyW0zKa
FyNvy0ts@\ONuaK@nzW@zKa7s@zKydu@z[svXxytKÏ7zyWsK x }Ks@ua}K=tFy zJ±Jty9uW0 yzK
\@ a¥|yny0z;vys@zKyWsvXxKyauWsJvk}0n@z[v Nz@n[nsNzN ´Os@u°;vyVb; yz[vXnJv=s5s@vXuy@ [¤yauW@z[
s uOsNnyKyK{\y vVvXxKv|{]OsN ayF; xKy°}yKyzvBxKy VzK@}Ks@u°}y¦ zKy;KvVv@ty;vH
bONzK[¤¡¦ =JvXns@zK=7ytyauatyts@K=@zK@VzauWNnyK >[0uazK@ zKb@zKy@5yan=[nyK@0 [K vyV}[v
[ua OK@zKvXxn=syKzKsv n[ua Ox =@tuWyz[vXÐ = ^ ; v v~n¢s@|uyvs[¤zKs$nyKy5{ b
bs@uWyauy0 v~zvXxKyatybs@zzKdzvXxn=[zKnyaKbOFyN@{Vy v bs@u°y yvsbs@z;ts@z[vk vH
bONzK[¤¡¦ =Fqvs@n@z@ ; s@zWyb[0}Kyzz;vyzyKabs@zKOyK²KyzKby>7y¡H¤zKs$zats@}nyu¨$ vXxvXxKy
yK; Mz@zKdKOyWsKvyK[xzKs@ s>@zKas@zKyvXxKvkn=[nyK@0 tynvyKvs=0x[¦ nF& z[KvBxzKvBxKv b@zs
$ts@zK>>$S©5JvXN @vXxn rzFM yR¦ nF >$x ;x°za vby 5;xKs7vXxKvkrKzKnyW70nx[vHÎÏ
sFy0KbyWs5@z[vX}nsvXnbxK yvs$xKvkuW }KyvXxKya} yKJv [[xats@}nyu¨OsW¢@bÓ@vBxKyWyuWytyzKOyWsK
@z[vX}nsvXnHty[nJv@z[v @zKduaK[xauWs@tyW@zKy©sN}Fqvy0n@­5ua @vXxzKxK@yzKy°xKyzWvtvyua[vvs
yu°zKvyauW@n@0 @uWsb² vsFyK[zK
M§ ONbyKvXxyuwvsb²ty §htyK[nJvNzbyÐkuW@nN0n@K@t[ vy
¤yK$nbyWb²MtyKdua vX¡µ0@Hty[nJv@z[v yzKyK §5xKyWb@KbyWs uW@z[[K;x;00nby«OyKyuW=[nyK@bÓ§5xKyWJJvyuWz[s@ yKa@tyWbs@uany[Vz;Fs@ NzK
z[vy©FqvXnsNzW@uWs@zKaNzyKy}K[¤W}Ky;v7yyzauW@z[ K@vKR z[[xK@zyKvs[K[xWqFJvyu¨KOFObyaz
7FvXxv]@tyW cn[ vVvs tyKnJvBÐVvXxn =y[KyK; @ WvX0KyWxKyzaxuW@zWFqvXns@zK=Ntyaz[s@ yK5
2 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
{]qv@vy°;xKs$zK0nyzvXxKyabONzK;¤KK²MKsvyts@uh·¸N¹º »¹W¼½¾¿ÀÂÁ0ÀÄâÅÆÇÈ=ÆÉJ¸ÀÂÊ@¹ËW{]7s@ dxK@zKvXxKyu
t7y¡¦ }Kss@¤[Vny[vVvXxKyuªtyKvXxy²MKsvy@zKvXxKyzKv[xvXxKy|tyFqvXnsNzWvXxKy;nbbsFytyKa$xs xK
$0 vtvyza vJv @ts@zKvXxKyWONuWyvXuWy{\s@zK5@zK ~s@tyK¦n}sFs@¤\¼N¼ÃVÈ ¹;ÁX¹È=ÆRÉq¸ÀÂÊN¹Ã¼
·Á0ÆÊËÌÉb¹;ÊNѹ;ÊÃÈ«À¡ÊNÑ ks@tFyn=s@zKyWsvXxKyanyKytzats@}KsvXnbtybyK@t[xR>@zKa7=WsNzKy\svXxy
7s@0n@¦ n@tyKqv~©sN}sKvB OtybyN©[xatst@uv 5@0zKyKM y kyns@z \z yt[ vt V¼ @¼ÃyauyauWs@ty
uWKvy0n@[vs´vXs@[v s@z°uW³ yzK7uWKvy0n@K[³0n[zK [sNvB yWs FOb@zK[¤Â¦n=NtMuWyz[vJrs@
y[@u°nyÓ
The Short Run (Early 2000s)
®nsNnsnb@K[yK[nyK=@uWsFqv~zy[Fy\;N yWyzKbs@z[vy©« vBx;Ky0 s@Vbs@uaKy[vB vsNt§Nyzauans@zyK@t=s
­Ns@[vXxW@zK5s@vXx uWy0nbytyWbyK@tvy9}[[z¤yz [@zK@u£nJvXxuaKK>­Ns@[vXx uWy0nb\¤y
KJvBtNnWvsFK>FKs@ vyKd}[ uWN©[n@uW@u°uW@n\zK[KMzKdKs@K;xKyKay² F@nyz[v«s tvÌ
yKytNzvB ytK¯hxKyzvBxKya qvXxuaK=bs@zzKyJvXzK5s@vBx@zK£­Ns@[vXx uWy0nb£tsbyV vVvss@¤$s@z WyK
vXxKs@KONzyK@t¢s@vXxKyazsNvBxKy0zanbyz[v@K[yK[ny> vBx;nx[vB uWs@tyWy[c¢yJvX y°uWy;v@}Ks@ [uW=@zK
tytsFMKJvX yWNz9zyFs@«qFJvyuWNvsn[nbyW@zKayuazKvy@uWsJv N[vBxKyWbs@[vXxy0zauWN©[n@nK
{XzWbs@uany[vy Wtyy°uW@0¤y[vXnbyR>[Ky0ns@ΩsN}sKv«s@n°;ty ^yKqv~xu@z«5s@vXx uWy0nb@z
nbyz[v@ =^yKqvyK£­Ns@[vXx uWy0nb@zauWN©[n@n @zKaFxu@zKxKyWKc¢yJvy°Os@z[vXnyKO«;KyK; y b
Ns@}KsvXnzKKJvB0nyK=7s@nabs@u°y[vy@ s@tsN[ NuWs@zKvXxKyuWby Fy¢s@|uvtvyyzKyt@zKa[KbyR
zK[nyz;v@ 0 @zKvBxKyÎ0 Oya}Ky[s@zKdxuW@z°ty[xN
VzN} yvs^sN©vBxKyazKyKOyKb; vB y=sK ¢yR
}ns@ snb@xuWNz«s@ d}KyWO²KyyKyKas@[v sK5y;NnJvyzKby@
§5xKytyants@}K@} bs@uWya}tyKvXxz9tss@u\}Kyb@KbyWyWs zKsvk yazbs@u° y;vy WtyKyauW@0¤y;vXnbyN
¥Îsy0zuWyz[v bsytbyzKs@zuWN³¤y[vk}KyxKNns@>y[Ky[n@ }[bs@nyKJvBzKvyKKR¬ ; s@[ @ny@
sFy0zuWyz[v@Kbsyt; s@zWbs@na[sNvkxu@zaKs@nvXns@zKz°xnxWJv©NnyWs@zvBxKy0 v«s ts@}Ksvkn@}Ks@
Ky³xK@K¢s@\£nsNz°x y@
9vy[KvB}Kss@¤$Fqvs@naÎ@zK~s@tyK ±JKJv y;vtvXzKa7s@z9N5yWsy=sNzvsnb[KOxsF)s@|uWNz±µs@}
zvBxKy5Jv byz[vX$}Ky µyzK[³zKabs@z[vBzKyKabss@KytvXnsNzts@uwvXxKyats@}KsvkzKKqvX0nyK 7}; Kb[zK
nF«yK[tyyzKvXxKvVvXxy[ }Ky Jznby Nzvsyb[0}KyaxKs)by0 s@K; Nzyts@K=£xuW@zONza}Ky 0s@zKby
vXt@zKJs@0uWyKdz;vs@zaz}sNzKyKa[Ky0z[vy yz[vkts@}KsvH ks@tFyK̦ NnyK nvXxKvVvXxKyats@}Ksv«
y[yz[vBK@ [bbyKydK vXxKvkxuW@zK=[nyK@0 W¢byWy;KvXzKqvXnsNz@
{]yK[ny9 v 7vXuWyvsWv@¤=vs£uW0nyzK\@zz[ nKV@zz[ }Kyb@uWy¢@uWs@K«vXxyWbs¢s@zKyVsK
§5xz¤KzKkF;xzKyKsN0sN©KvB s@z$xn[xa} v Wy Ks7yK@t@ yK[ytbs@ua[vyX \y[ vyau
[0tyz[v@±µs@}vX vXnyWs xny;V­N[nyz[vXnJv v|­5z = ;tsFqFJvyuW5{ @uªuWs@tyWbs@ua[vyVN©[x vyKqv\vBxK@zW
b[nyz;vXnJv0Nz {kty[KyKqv V@zz[¦ ¤KzsF yyWsvXxyaz[s@0uWKvB s@zW@zKdx[[nb@Kb[nyzKbyuWs@tyvXxK@zvXxKv
s5Nz;sKvBxKyV[zKnyaKytbs@z{~¤zKs
V@zz[ n=@ Os xnx ty@ty[vX³ qv]xKsWvBxz¤nsNz@vy0u ¢s@Fy@t«s xKyWJvNvyKvXxKy bs@zK5s rsNzKvXns@z>xn[xa }nzKa[ns[¤$y[nzKyvs nJv
[yK@tVzW@zWvtvyu°;v\vst)vtvyz[vXns@zvsWvBxKya vX [xKs@v vtvyz[vXns@zW[K@zWsK5s@Vbs[ny;vt>
0­Nyy §NyKqv]s@§5uy $À¡ÁX¹KÑ 5Ä VKy F5 ­Nsa{VnyK*v
s bs zKyny7s@5vBxKyWy[@tyKO0KsbyWs xKNzKazzKy\ vXx \@zz[@zKdxn=$ ¢yR [vX @{
7yz[vVvXxts@Kxau zKs=¢@uan@Îts@;vXzKy@vXtsvtvXzKas@[vVvXxKyany«@zKdKbOFyKvXxKv|{V¢s@zKabs
nJvX0}zK5
V@zz[¦ =@zKb7y ÎMtyJvya[KyK; nb@ vkt7y¡¦ =bOyzK@0nss xuW@zKuWytzKa$ vXx
ts@}KsvÎb@uWyWb$ ^vB >@zKa² vyW;00nby9uWy@
5yWb@n@>;ua NvXxKvVvXxyW[xK@zKy=7s@n°OsNuWy
tK@ >@zvBxKv]yW7s@nay[vkKbyvsWvBxKyu
®[v|{]MKyKO${ 7[zR¦ vVvsv@ ;00nby5@{kxKabyKyz²Ksvyts@u \@zz; zat7y¦n}sFs@¤WzW$xn[xaxKy
b@n@ B{0¦u¨¢s@zKas u }Ks=Nz;Fs@zKyV}[vk V{]O@z°}Ky$ vXxW }Kss5[ Os@z5{0¦;v@¤ya vHk{tv
byyuWyKvXxKvkxKyW7=vkKyKbyW vBxvBxntsbyKO«@zKd v=vtvyzK@z[vk0n[¤Ì>$xny{ 7zKsvH
¯hxnyv@¤zK°@zvBxz¤KzKa@}Ks@[vkt7y¡\bONz[¤K¡>@z ks@tFy5{ [Kyz tyuyua}Kyty°£zKsFy
{~xFdty°@uWsFqvÎyK@t=sa·¸N¹¸À â¹ÇÂƻŹOÍ=}[ rKt@z¤ y0}Kyv|7zW$x ;x£us@nyK;nN|}ns@ snJv
n«M0 yzazKb@zKya}[WvBxKyWbyzbynyKOuatyVs xn7@u° >F§sbyKy¤Wty[yzKyaxKyWbs@zKJvB0KJv=@zK
nbbyu°zKvy= zKy)Nz9x x OsNz;vns@K MKyvXxKvk¤K = y }[v bynyJvX Fy >
¯ y¦tya[¤b
bONzK[¤K7= uWvXxKyuWKvB ; @zVzKsv uWs@ y[n@Î} s@nsnJvH k{ 7=Nnbs£tyuazKy°svXxya®sNtasH¾VÃ^ÆÁ
·ÁX¹Í| x FyWs K@vB }ns@nsnb@ÂVK@vX ts@}KsvXn=[tyKvXtyK=$ vXxWqvXts@zKayKqvX0KqvX FyWJvX©yK@¤FM®sN©@H¤y
nbJvyt=N©yJv@nyWs5b[nyzKby JvB s@zR>bs$x[ xKzR¦ v|{~}KyyzauWs@tyWbs@zKby0zKyKa@}Ks@[v [K;x°©sN}sKvB
3 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
Fqvs@n«y@0ny«¯hx[7ytyzR¦ v svXxKyÎKys@ny°uWs@tyWbs@zKOy0zKy°@}sN;v\vBxKyKOyaz Mx[vXuW@0n[xWbbyz@0 s
[N v]svXxyWNzb7y\Oyv@z yzWs@VKv©vX vXKyvsF@tvBxKyazKy 7zWs@Î} vs7@tdzKJvNz;v
¢@uan@0 vt@zKdzK²yKJvB s@zzKabby[v@zKOyN5O[KJvs@uyvs @zKa$ vXxWNuWsJvkts@[vXzKyWb; yz[vX n
}tyN¤OvXxts@KMxK7yaxKFyy[vVvsbs@uyvsWvy0u= vBxvBxKy¢JvVvXxv\vBxKyausqv]OsNuaKyzK£5qv0µOyz[vB
vy[xzKs@nsnyK7ts@}KsvXnbyzKy;vXn=yzKMzKyy0zK>>@zKdzK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsa7KsbyWM c¢ytyz;v\vBxtyKvVvXxK@zvXxy
vy[xzKs@nsnyKvXxKvkxKFyWOsNuWya}Ky;¢s@ty@@­5Ky[ nb@ \ts@}KsvÌ>yzKzKyKytyKas@t@zn[uWNz9zNzsN}sKv=[xK@ty
@zKyts@K=@ua cNzK¢JvsNOÓ§Mxy[b@zWby ©Hty OKvyNR }Ks@ua}a }ns$zaWs@z sNzby7}[v s@zKya}Ksv
b@za}KyKOsNuWyauW@z[Nz°²Mn[¤K y;v]s@[v s5bs@z[vBts@S
=K[xWs usN³¤ syvXxKyaKqvÎyK@txK}KyKyzs@zWbs@ua[vy|zKy[vs@0¤KzK@$xKytyvXxKyWOyzKzKa@zK
tyKOy NzKas uybby=[tyKvyvXxKyWs@Ks@vBz vtW¢s@Vs@[v00st0bs@z[vXts@ty OKvB s@z@®[v $xnyatynbvXns@zaz
bs@ua[vyVs@\Os@u°;vy|zKy;v7s@0¤$b@za}KyW znb@zKbyR>v 7s@tJvk v]M O@} y= uW[xzKyWs@5vN¤yK=s$z
zKy;v7s@0¤$s@|zKy[v7s@0¤$byNnbyN VzKbs@z[vX©sNnyKaby ©HtynbvXnsNzazvXxKybyazKyKyvy[xzKs@nsnyK0zK= uaK;x
tyKvy|0 ;¤NÓ ³ ;¤ s5;}KJvNz;vXnN@uyazvXxKyax[F[nb@Ks@0
K[xWsvXxKybyvy[xzKs@nsnyK=@ Oss^ytz[vs@ dts@uanby5Ó§5xKy@ ; s@zWs zKyK@|u°uWs@v@ v©WvXxKvkt7y
byyKzaxnts@}Ksv tyK@uW=0 Fy7s@t7@tÐ yzKy[vB =yzKzKyKy0zKdubss@zatsNnyvBtyKvXuWyz;v\ zKsv
s@[vX0nx[v [tyK@¢s@|usqv]M OyKbyK;Ð @zKdzK@zKsvyK;xzKs@nsFRNz9zNzsNuWyn[zKyWb@ztyKO7y[vkuWs@tyanK
§NsFy[vXxyvXxKy;bs@n°; z nb@z[vX y[vyz°s@VFytya yW[K@zW@zKduatsyvBxKyW²K@ vts5s@Î FyK
¶Ny[v0$ vXxWyK[xWsvXxKybyvy[xzsNnsnyKÌ>OyK²KyzKbyWs5[uW@ÂVz NnK@ OyzK;} yWNzbyKnyKvs@z
b[uanvXns@zs5©yKvkKs7yV@zK@bs@zKbs@ua v@z[vX tyKv @zKyX
¯hxKv 7= ^ytyz[vkzvXxyKvXxWbyz[vX 5yv@z @vXxKyvy[xzKs@nsnyKzKy0 NzKvXxyyK@Ks@zK=s uWb
yKqvX0KqvXnsNz ¯ k7zK; y@\}ns@nsFM O@ÂNz°;xKyuanb@ ® kÎ7ytyaKs7yÂ@zKvBxKyW7y@Ks@zK=Nz
yzKs@0uWs@KvXxtyvH®;v~} Mz9z[nyK@V7yK@Ks@zKty²tyK>>vk yJvV¢s@VWvXuWy>ObyKbvs }KsvXxat@ty
zKyKy@>y;^yKqvX Fy zK@n@}ny7t uvy0nNn=@zKdxnx tsvyJvy9z[s@0uvB s@zÐk}ns@nsnb@K@zK
[xKyu°nb@KyK@Ks@zKts©NuW=@ OsWvyzKyvs tyK²Mtya @tyµOb@ yWJvB @ vXnyKK
§5xKy5Jv³µOyz[vXWvyK;xzKs@ns yÎyzKy;vXnbVzK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns@zKdtsN}svXnb ¥ kÎ@tyWbs£Ks7y [vBxKv
vXxKy;b@zW[K$zW$xKs@nyazKy)[ ObyK=s5b[nyz[v=@zKaN}KbyK
ksJv @zKyts@K[ @¢s@vXxKytqv\vBuWyR
vXxKybyWb[nyz[v=@zKa@}Kby«@tyW y $ vXxzvXxKyaty[xWsK zK @ MK@ =s@V[uWNKMtsNKKF§Mxy[$zKsv
tyK²M©y°n@ty[ vXnyK=s@|t@tyatF uWvy0 @nKMzKs$nyKyWNns@zKyW$KyzK@}nyvXxKyaKbyWsvXxyu
§5xK=7yaxKyvXxKyaKsb;} vt zKsv@±HKqv sK5yK@Ks@zK=s uWFO«yKJvB0KJvXns@za}[v s ¤KzKs yyRµyzK@}nyK
uWFO«yKJvB0KJvXns@z X
XNvBxn«yKJvB0KJvX yzKybxKy ´@ua nyKd}[WvXxyaKs7y\s5by ©Hty OvXnsNz@
{\vBxz¤W vknzKsy;FytvXns@zvsb7yW@tyWs@zvXxKyW[[WsKvBxKyvXxKyÎKy¢yJvXns@zWs5y[KvBtyuWyWy[@ÂNz
y @$xKsbyaKsO[} vt[tyK=7y}Ky[s@zKvXxKv $xn[xW7y@Ks@zK=sK uWb=yJvX0JvXns@z°}yK²KyvXxKyvs
[
vXxKyazKvB s@z0JvvyKsNzvs[00n[zKaNzvy00}nyWyuaKs7y0uWyz[v s5y[vXtyuyazK @ MK@
5svXxzKa@}Ks@[vVvXxKyW°{ svkz[Fs@ Fy° vXxWbs@u°[vyt«;KyJvyvs uWyvXxKv|{]«sNzKvs£}Ky¢[zK
vXxKybya¤KzK«s nb[yKK
| ¢yaxF}KyyzW0 Fyza}[yyazKyyKvs[¤$²MKyKqvXnsNz«@zKz°@zKO7yt¯hxKyz{]F {]
@ty tyKzK>>bs£uWvXxKy5vss@¤WuWyvsWvBxKyWynyuWyz;v@b[xsFs@¡>xKyty{ bv s@zvBxKya0zK[K@¡¦ nN
@zKdtyKdxu¨Jvs@>@{ JvNvyKab[xsFs@yK@0 \nvy\;¤KKy°ty@zKayKbONyKdz;vs }sFs@¤$k{ 7
zK[ty} uWsvX Fvyvs nyK@0z@@{];¤yKdnsv=s5²KyKqvXns@zK>scvyz³ @z° v7vsnJvBtFqvXns@zN
5=WvyyzKy { 7Fy z[vy©yKJvyKdzWb; yzKbyW@zKvy[xzKs@ns>>{]@z[vyvs }KyW xNu tnss@KytvsN
}[v nz¦ vkxKFyvXxKyauWs@zKy;Wvs };WvXxKyWyK²MuWyz[vJ5@uªtns7vBxKy{Xz[vy0zKy;v]s vvXuWy5Ó@Fy
nJvX FyR>@zKa² vyWbs@ v@ks@zKy[ nb[yK=[nyVu uWsvXxKyÎ[vkxKy¢ssv s$zk{ 7zKsv\vs }KyW
xK@uaÐ|{]F=@z[vXnbs[n@KyzKs@KxW@©yK>
{~uW zKsvkxKFyaxKduWNz;[nsFOy0nyz\}[v|{]F=7;x°za yKKM® x MxO[xKss@¡5{~x°nbOsFyty
vXxKyW©yKv b[nyzbynJvXns@zW$0 vytK@{ktyuWyu°}yVyK[Ky[n@ 5yz yz¦ Æ ¹¾¿ÆÉb¹ÌËÌÅÀÄà $À¡ÇÂÇ·Á0Æ ¹;Ç@@zK
5[uWsK¦ tÍ V¼N¼ÃÍ~$ vXxa vk§5x©yKy b7=s Ns@}KsvXnb@{ 7«yzK[xNz;vyKd}[WvBxKyWyKO[0[vXns@zK=s5[Kby
vXtFy¡>@zKa7@z[vyvs xKyWWvy ybbs@Kyvs nssN¤$vVvXxKyWqv@t[Ð [zKOy{kxKdzKs uWs@zKy;Wvs };sN|uW@¤y
4 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
s@zKy{];xKyK[¤yKd}Kss@¤=s@zvynybbs@KyRHuW@¤KzKas@[v sKvBxKya}©N@zKdty°@}Ks@[vkuW@¤KzKvXxKyuªzKJvy5@{
bs@tyKdz°u uWFMzKvB s@zN
§5xtbK z Mx[vu K@tyz[v«yz[vk}KszK@@zKa7ya¤Kn=JvKyKdxKs@uWyW@ s@zKy@@{tv 7vXxy°z Mx[v sK5¥|yzKy
Nsyz}Ky0¦n«s@0nzK@F¾VÃ^ÆÁ«·ÁX¹ Í~@zKvXxKyats©Nu uyW£}n9uatyb[ns@zs@zauWyN@{ b@uWyvsbOy[v
vzKsvXnsNzvXxv~xu@zxFaW[vXtyazW[FOy¯ yKJvy0z0Jvt@ny> vBx°} dxKytsyK=@zKaFRFyz[vXtyK
Nsyz}Ky0¦n7@n[nsNzWsvXxyOyz[vB0nyKvsOs@uyWF=s@zKyW vBxqvXts@zKdus@t@[@yKyua}KsnyKdzOsFyK
¤yvXxKy 0uy |tyKJvB y5Ó@vs zKsvkz;vyy©y°zvXxKyWy[FynsNuyz[v s ybvy[xzKs@nsnb@ NzbyK
[ N vXns@zKKF§Mx xKa@z°zK;tyK}nyW@KyN;vs uWyÐ y;vXxnb@xuWNz\zsKvkts@}KsvÌ>s@uazKvyKvXx [vXtyR
@zK£{\vss@¤WNsyz}y0¦ =tyK@u FK@v s usFzN
{]y;FOy ydzauWvXxKyuWvXnbzax MxO[xKss@¡>@zKa$xKyz{ 7yz[vVvsWvBxKy Vz Fyt[ vts «n[x NzW=@z
zKyttKvyWyzKzKyy0zKaJvBKyz;vÎ{Vvss@¤=vXxKyW@zKby°;00n[u¨svXxyauvXxyuWvXnbuO±0s@tK
­Ns@ @zK9uWvXxats@}nyu=7=@zWy[F; vBz°;xK@nyzKyV}[v $xyz{]M ObsFytyKabs@ua[vyt{\sNzK
bs@uWy[vXxz9uaK[xauWs@tyaz;vytyJvXzKÓ uWF;xzKyaz[vsxn[xFs@Wbs@n9[v tst@uwvBxKv Kv©vyua[vyKvs
bs@ FyW tsN} yu>^vyV$xn[xvXxKyauW[xzKyW² ;¤K [xKy[¤yvXxKyWbs@[vXns@zN§5xyOs@u°;vy|xKa[nyN
zKsvXns@zs5OsN0tyJv @zKdzbs@0tyKqv0NvB0KyW@zK¢@nbyN¯ ytyau nyK=bs@0tyJv k§5xKyauW[xzKyWbs@ vyuy@
§5xn«7ybyKqvX FyN
{]K;¤byzsNxvsy;v =±µs@}atst@uauaz°y@0 ;Kytbs@u°[vyt«@zKanbOsKytyvXxKyW@uWFzK
Ks7y\s n@tyauWF;xzKyKvs£zuWy0nb@ [uanvyW@zKbyKay[nzKK¯hxKyz{ 7yz[vVvsMtKvyWb;xKssN
v
®y0¤y y; zvXxyau°n@ 5{ Jv@vyKaJvNzKdanvys^vyzWNz x;v0\z[yz[vBz9zyK)7s@0n
zK[nyvXxKyauW[xzKyK@­Ns@ NzKdts@}nyu¯h0 vXzKvXxKyWOsFyvXxKv N©KyKabsJvXts@zKM Wvs }KyW$³ v©vyzN
{Xz·¸N¹º »¼ÊÒÆÊNÑ£Ã^¸@¹ @ÉBËKÃ^ÆËOÒÌÍ«{X@zK£­vs@zKy¦n} s©Nx O@zKsFyKs = ;xKyn@zKy s­vs@zKyWyKO[0}KyK
N Nn xKs = ;xKyn@zKy s£tynyKOyKvXxKyWJvvXKyKts@uwvXxKyWqvs@zKy H}©yK@¤KzKvXxKyauW@0}nyW[Ky¡ Îb@@z
ts@uwvBxKyauyzaxnu°zK {Xz°u uWsJv yKbqvvXnuWs@uWyz[vNvBxKyWbs^v7@tyazvBxKyWbs@ua[vy\yuyty
zvBxKyWb@uWy>ÏzKOy{kxKduzKy9 vkz°u uazK {Vy v\vBxKvk v 7=@tyKWvXxytyazvXxKyauW[xzKy
7@ vXzKvs }y°©ynyKby5@­vK@zK9@znx;v]OyKyuy°[uW@0nbyvs KWvsW©yKya vÎ vs FyvBxKya yK
bs@zK[ty;vysN³u
^vyVW¢y*FyN©«vk®y0¤yny[a{ JvNvyKvsbyzKas@[v bs@uWyWsvXxKyWbscv7@ty{kxK°0 vtvyzÎ@z
zKJvX0JvXns@zK@ [bb@KJJvyu Vz [vX vB y>@zKa´vy[v]y vs@Vb@ny@ xn[xa =JvB¡Nvs u[00nbyR
$ny KOyKduWsNtyvBxK@zyK@tnvy k vssvXxKyt=$xKs xFa[ua @V[uW@ $@zK uaznbs@ua[vyt§5xKyKOyWFRFyz[vXtyzWbscv7@tyWy[yz;vXK@ WvB0zKy9z[vs´vXxKya®y0¤y y;WFyt[ns@zsvXxy \z
s@KytvXzKaJJvyu>$x ;x°}Kyb@uWyW Kytbs@zK@ 0[KbOyKb=nbJvy kÎbs£u@z[ yKs@nyW7@z[vyd vVvXxKv|{
zKy[yzn[xyKdu
x k@{XzJvy { sv =±0sN}W7s@0¤zs@
V@0K [vtvXzKd®y0¤yny;
\z s@zvXxKy{Xz;vy0zy[v
@zK NzKd v\vs }Kyatyn@}nyW@zKvs 0z°n@tyatybyK@t[xW@nbvXns@zK=7y §5xn=7=@tyKvVz@z
Fy tyKNtMz5 zK>Nt@z¤K {]OF zKs£ts@}KsvxKy©y>s@V@z[FxKytyazyK@X
­vXÂV}[WvXxKyWy@0 h@F{]«MtsFzzK5F§Mxy \z tynyKbyK=ytyFy[KObyKOJÂ@zKdu vtvXny
tsO±µyJv s5s@zKyWbss@z°xFduWs@zKy[@zKabs@uWyWJvctV}[vVvXxKyatsN} yu¨vk®y0¤yny[F=@n7F=s^nbyW[Kby
tvXxKy5vBxK@z°uWs@zKy;° vBxKytyW[z¦ vktss@uwsNvXxyaxKyvXxKyatsO±0yKJvkzKyyKyK@bsxKyzvXxKyWsvXxy¢s@zKyt
sV­5z «n[tsJJvyuW«;xKs7y9{@±HuaKyaKvVvBxKyW[xK@zKbyvs=±0sNzvXxKyu Rv|­5z@vXxKyans@zK9xs@t
bs@z[vXzyKdz;vsWvBxKyWyK@0 F=s57s@0¤JvvXns@zK=@zKdKytbs@zNbs@u°[vyt>@zK£{kxKFyWyzJ±µsyK
K@vXn[KvXzKdzvBxKyW[tyKvB s@zWs5F@zKOyKdu°n[©sNtsbyKbOs@5vy[xzsNnsnyK=@zK£{Xz[vy0zKy;v\vyK[xzKs@ sny
[K;x¬H@zK¬z
rKts@u¨@[vXx Ì5{VvX0KJvk vk =; yNvXxKv|{ @uªzKsv [K vyN>{~xKyWNn7\tvBxKyVxKaJvXts@z9}Ky y; z
vXxKy@KyWsvBxKyWb[nyz;vX n=byK@t[xsNvX0;vXxWNz9zvXxKyW@} vts5tyKv yzzKyKy0zvs }0zKduWvy0n@
tstybKF§Mxy{XzKKqvX0nNNy;Fs@[vXns@z°xFuauy[t@} u°©sKyKay[ys@zKy¦n ¢yWsyvXxKyanJv bs@ny
xzKMtyKFy@t>@zK£{ @ K=y[@KyKJvyKdub@tyKy5vs£z[Fs@ FyvXxya} Mz°s5sNvBxK$xnyWbs@[vXns@zKvs
tyK@tsN} yuW>s@zKya©sN} yu¨v WvXuWyN
{~xKyazKsvk}KyKyzM O@Ks@z;vyK|7s@0¤WxKxKdus@tyauaKJvVvXxK@z{~xFay;Fy|xKs@Kys@\@zKdxK
}KyKyzaus@tyW y KbyvBxK@z{ bs@ndxKFyatyFOsNz@} y;NyKJvy5>{~xKyW[Kyz;v\vBxKyanFqv|yK@t=JvB
vX@zvsWntyWsN;v~xsF*vs uW@¤yWbs@ua[vyt=ty @}nyW{]7@z;v\vBxKyu vs }Ky ©vXxKy;N©yazKsv~zyK@0
vXxKytyFy;v Î@zKdxKs*vs uW@¤yvXxyu¨;uanyvs£Kby s@[vXxKvkxKuWy[v $ vXxWy[yzanyKbty vX y
[KObyKb q \y[ vyWbs@uWyatstyb@vXxKyats@}nyuvXxKvktyu@zWbyKyu¨y[yzauWs@tyW@z[vXzK
5 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
®[v $xny{]«NtyWsvBxKyaus@t@KMnyuauW«;0ts@zKMzvyK[xzs@ s¦ =bs@zKby²KyzKbyznyn¤y
7yNsNz©yKby@t[x5{ ndzKsv y[NyKJvVvXxKv|{ 7s@nabs@z[tsNz;v];K[xanb[KyzausFznyn@sNVvk yJvkzKsv
bsOsFs@z@
[y0xK@K vk =@n7FxK@tvsbyKyvBxKya}ny|uaKJv $xnyFs@WNtyazvXxKys@vy[s5;xK@zKy@rNzvs
zKytJvNzvBxKyWbs@zKby²KyzKby«s5s@|z;Fyz[vXns@zK=$xnyW7yW@tyazvXxyat@[vXtyWs5nbOsKy@zK
zzKsFvXns@zWbyKyuvs }KyWOsNuauWs@z@ v sK5O[nyz[vB qv=NzvyK[xzKs@ snJv[Ð 7yaxKya s@zKd}KyyzW0 Fyza}[
vXxKyWsyt@t[xzKay[tyvs ¤zKs*vXxKvkn7vBxKyazKvXtyWs5b; yzKbyR¦ =²KyJv0VzKsv Jvs@zKvs£zKsvXnbyvXxKvVvXxy
tstybvs zyK7y\@zKduWs@tyaKs7y;vyK;xzKs@nsFM y=b@zvN¤yWs@z£ yWsK v=s$z@
{~xKyansNz9ty@nyKvXxKvVvXxy°} aNzbyKzaz;¢s@0uWKvB s@zvy[xzKs@nsbs@uWyazKsvVts@uwvBxKyW7s@0¤$s
b s@ua[vy\O[nyz[vB qv>Os@u°[vyV@t[x vyJvÌ>s@\ynyKJvB0 ONyzKMzyKytÌ\};v\ts@uwvXxKv s x[[nb@Kb; yz[vXnJvK
§5xKyax[[n[nJv­vyxKyz¯ s@ ©Nu Nz9®ts; 5b[n[xKyÎz[vBtsFMKby9uWyVzvBxKyWyK@0 h@Nvs[xKs
vXxKys@Nz9zsNzzKy@\JJvyuWK@{XzvXxy9@FÌ5{k y@0zKyKa@}Ks@[v bs@uany[JJvyuts@u¨bs@z[ytbvXns@zK
$ vXx \@zz[
nNvBxKya}ns@ snJv|­vX@v~@[cuW@z@vXxKy 5s@}KyÂJnNtyKvyax[F[n[nJ
v =0t¥|y¡ k@zz>@zK
svXxKytK
ksJvktyKOyz[vB 5O[ ;xKyV@zKvXxKyWynyJvX0nb@KyzKzKyyVNz°y[Nnbyax[F[n[nJ
v k@0¤WNyyKdxKFy
}KyKyzW NzKduyazK; x;v~z[vsWvXxy°zK;tyK}nyaKsb;} vXnyK=s us@nyK;nNVynyJvXts@znb
{Xzaus$zWsN0¤;>=bsy[nzKyVsvXxtyyaua ;tsNtsbyKObs@\@t[x vyKJvBtyKk­ ]\nbs¬JK>@zK|¬ @zKaFvXxyWyK; zyVs5by[yt@uanyuWyz[vvXnsNz7vBxKytyst{0¦ Fya}yKyzWc¢s@ty°yKy@zK©JvXxK@zK
b²K@z[v@zKOyW$ vXx ksFs@tyR¦ rsNVybyKÌ kssNtyR¦ n xF=bs@0tyJvX tynJvyvBxKyWy[@Ks@zKyz[vXn@
tvyWs ua©sKyuWyz;v]s5byua OsNzKJvsNvy[xzsNns
Vz[vXnJvVFyN{k}Kyny[yKvXxKvVvXxKyatvys
F@zKOyKty qvyKd}[
kss@ty¦nn u°nx;v]Os@z[vXzKyWs@z z[vBtsNx a5[>$xyzWbs@uWyax[F; ON
ua v=7s@nd}KyKzvs£}KyatyK[xyK5>{tv]zsKv s@}[@ s@7vs uWyvXxKv zKy*vyK;xzKs@nsFR7s@n°@00 y°z
vXuWyvs ¤yKyaKy¢s@0uW@zKbyW@zK[zKa[uWssKvBx >
®[vk}KyKO@KbyWsvXxKyatybyz;vktN a@zKdtnb@tstybz°uWs@nyK[ @VynyKJvBts@znbÎ$xKytyaz NnK@
vs@u=@zKduWs@ y[nyKtynFOya vXxsFMtNxnb@ tzvBt@zK[nJvs@tÎ@zKdtynvyKdzK@zKsOb@ y
vy[xzKs@nsnyK7yW[xKs@nd}KyW@}nyvs uWyy[v s@\y;FbyyKvXxKy kss@ty¦nn tvyWs tstyb¢s@VNzsKvBxKy Fy@tK®a >yW@tya¤y Wvs }KyW@}nyvs£}n9uW[xzKy\zW²K@z[vB v©>£ua s@zvXuWyK=s7y
7vBxKyaKytbs@zK@Kbs@ua[vyt=svsaÎ[[cn[nyz;v\vs u° yuyz[vVvXxKyWMtyK@uW«s ©yK@zK~s@tyKK
5vXxn=yzKs@0uWs@K=bs@u°[vXzKdKs7yÎn=bs@ua}zKyKa$ vXxvXxy°uW@znvX FyW@zKby«svXxyax[F; O@
b[nyzbyK=@zKvXxKyazyK=yKyazKytJv@zKMzzWyzKy[vB O>yzKs@0uWsN7vBt@zKJ¢s@0uWvX FyasFy| }KyzK
znyK[xyK5F§5xKyKOyOs@u°}zKvB s@zK=s@Kyz°vBxKyWs@Ks@vXz v©Wvsbs@uany[vy tyKy[nzvXxKyWsN³ @@¢s@|}Ky[v©vy
s@\sNtOy5Ó§5xKyaty OKvBz°@zKay;Fs@ NzKdtsbyKObyKvXxv~xKya}KyKyzWbs@z[zKyvsWvXxyazKvXt@KsN³ a@ty
@}Ks@[vVvs }yKbs@uWyatyK@uW«s xu@zWyzKyKFs@X
{XzWyK; zz°OsKcvN©y@zKduan[ts@tsbybbs@t{~xKyazKy[y|xKvXxKyyKyzKvXxKv|{ 7«yK[nzz°@z
z[vynyz;v~uW[xzKy@§5xKyWbscv7@tyW@zKdxK@t@tya =bs´tnyWNzvBxKyWb@K@} vB y=sKvBxKyauWF;xzKyvs
vBxz¤ Îbs[nyK@0 @}Kbyz;v\vBxKv0>y;FyzWF= sFO[} vtNvBx xK=@n7F=byyuWyKFyW¢@|zvBxKy[vBtyN
®[vkzKs=$ vXxvXxKya©sF;KyKqv]s xu@zJny[FyKbs@ua[vBz9sFy|zW@}Ks@[v WFy@t>£zKyK ny[KyKqv
vby JÓ@vXxKv|{~uW }KyW7s@0¤zKvs[tyvyvss@n«xn[xW$yzK@}nyvXxyOs@zKJvX0JvXns@zsvBxKyvyK;xzKs@nsWvXxKv
uWK tynbyWs@\;KyK; yK
sF)s {\yKyK@}Ks@[vVvXxn
5y zKOs@us@v@}nyN 5NzKaJvX0nyKduyz[vXty
b@tyKy5vs }ndtynN} yWOsKcvNtyWqFJvyuW\ v byyuWvs uWyauWsNtyvBxK@za¤y vBxKvVvXxn[vBtyW$zKsv
7s@0¤$s@[v «yK=bs@uWyaKyKs@nyauWK uWzKyN Î ytbs@zK@Ky;Ny0nyzKOyW[KyKJv«yvyzvs
sFytyKJvBuWvyWs@VyK; Mz@} vB yK
¥7 yzvXxKyazK[ty}nyaKs7y\svXxKybyazKy*vyK;xzKs@nsFM y>;xKs@nz¦ v ya}KyW[¤KzKdxKs)7yWb@za}KyJv
bsy[@ qv $ vXxvXxKyu 7 z9 5s@Vs$zWy[vXzKJvXns@za = ¤y >s@Vy[yzaKsb[}nys@[vbs@uWyWs5s@
vy[xzKs@nsnb@Ky;Fyns@uWyz;v0>[xs@ Mz¦ v 7yatsFOyKy° vBxMtyKv b@[vXns@z
§5xKyWtyNu sK ©sN}sKvB On@tJv³NvXxKvkz[vynyz[vku[xzyK=b@zWss@V7s@0¤=sN|K@ns$zKdK yK=s
nyn[tyR\tyJvs@0zKdKvsyzNF¶Ny[vkz°x xnJvs@s5[[xa yK ÆÁ ÀÂʺ ¼Ê» Ãc¸N¹È«ÆÉq¸ÀÂÊN¹ÌËHÍ7¥ÎysNty
5bs@zW7@0zKÓ B{XzvXxKyW@uWyWs yWNz°y;Fs@[vXns@zvBxKy©y@tyvBxtyKyanFyt=v\vBxKyv@}ny5ÓVxu@za}Kyz
6 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
zKvXtyR>@zKduW[xzKyK@{ @uw0ua ´s@zvXxy; yWsK zKvBtyNM®[vkzKvX©y5{ [K;KyKqv0\n=s@zvBxKyW[nyWsvXxKy
uWF;xzKyKK 5=7yaxKyWbyyz ~s@tyK=tyKy\}y y;NzKa7yauW7yzKsv];N yvBxKyWyzbs@z[vy\ vXx
vXxKyW;Ky0ns@|ts@}Ksv];KyK; yK
5s)bss@zOsN a[[xWNzaz[vynyz[vktsN}sv~}ya} v k§5xKyWbs@uaz°@zKbyzWbs@ua[vXzKdKs7y\OyKyu
vs uW@¤ya vkKsb[}nya}[a > z°s@zKOyW@z°z[vynyz[vkts@}Ksv]y;NnJv\ vkn«s@z ;u@KJvyvs£ts@}Ksv
[Ky[nyK vs@zaz[vynyz[vktsN}sKvVvBxKv]O@z°uW@¤yWy;Fs@ FyKabs@ny«s vby µ
gOyKbs@zKaty@u¨s ts@}KsvXnb vXxKv yW$tK@ tynbyWs@tby yK=$ vXxWs@|ts@}KsvXn7vyK[xzKs@ s
[xny[@z9zyK@ÎuauWsN v@ vt };´s$znsFMz°s@Vbs@zKO[nsN[zKyKObyK;Ðk vknvXxntsbyKO7vBxKv\@zz[
vXxz¤«yW$KtK@ y[vkKbyvs@zKvXxKvk@K tyKyny@z[vX y;v@nz]·¸N¹º »¹W¼K½¾¿MÀÂÁ0À ÃÅÆÇ
È=ÆRÉq¸ÀÂÊN¹ÌË ¯£y@tya}yKzzzKvsbyKyaz[vXuWvXns@zK=sKvBxnzvXxKyauan@z[vvXns@zs5bs@ua[vyVy[@nbyKz[vs
vXxKyaxu@za}Ks>KJvBtvyKas@zvXxKy bsFy s $ÀÂÁX¹Ña > ®[vk 57yW@tyWs$znsyKdz[vssN5vyK[xzKs@ s>xKv]@tyvBxKyW[xK@zKbyvXxKv 7yW$[vXxytyKcvyÎ}Ky
s@tby yK=s@\y;Fyz°xuWNz ${tv byKyuW7vs uWy¢@ÎuWs@tya¤y WvXxKv ©sN}sKvB =y;NnJvyzKbyWsN dzKsvk}Kya¤yW
xuW@zWsNzyazW@z[byzKbyvXxKv yazKytJv@zK>NvXxKvVvXxy°©sN}sKv«s@n9zazKsOyzKOy°}yWsN\;xntyz@vXxKv
s@zvBxnKvBxs@|xuW@z vt uW7y}ya sJvJ
¥ÎyzKy[vB =yzKzKyy0zKdts@ua OyKvs ty;Fs@[vXns@znyW³ ; vBtya}[ zK[ty[zKa[ts@@nyn=$xnyatyK[zK
vXxKyaKOyWs KyKJvB ; yK[ÐVvs[tyvyvyz«svBxKs@Kb@zK=s zKsFyK[yK[nyK=s }KJvy0n\n@z[vÌNN0KOyK@zK
@zu@n[ÐVvs£tynbyatytsKqvXnsNzR>s@\;nyuWyz[vk v³>$ vXxW[ns@zzKÐVvs[tyvyW[ty¢s@ÎuW@z[nbybyKÌ
zK[tyF;z°s@| yW[K@zW@zKasN\²N vts yÐ @zKduaK[xR\uaK[xauWsN©yN¯ yazsF ¤zKs)$ vXxWby v@z;vt
vXxKvVvXxKybyatss@zKa[xK@zKyzvXxya} s@nsnb@Kb; yzKby«@tyauau°zKyz[v @zKa$[xK@ yzKyW@Ks@
zKsvXns@zK=s5$xKvk ya
§NyK[xzKs@ sny«;K[xWxuWNzW[ns@zzKdxKFyazaK@vXn[n@Ît@nby°s@V7@tyzKyKb=svXxyats¢s@zKay;vXxnb@
@zKdus@t@nb[yK=7ybyN>{tt@¢s@Vy[F@uany7yW7ytyvs ©yKyzzKyKy\s@tOy Fyz[vsby;FytNbyN©Kvy
@zKdzKyK²MK@K[Ky[nyKK;zKvXxyaKs7yVs5yzKy[vB =yzzKyKy0z@NvBxKyzW7yWsN vXxtyKvyzvBxKyazKsvXns@zWsK
yK²@ vtWvXxv~nvXxKyybs@0zytJvsNzyWsK5s@Vyus;tFq>
¥7 yzvXxKyazK[ty}nyaKs7y\s5yzKy[vB =yzzKyKy0zK@\ v0¦nzs[³0nbyvXxKvVvXxKytyW@tyW[nz nb@z[v by[vt
nb[Kyza vKby@
|W0nyz uWs@
bsNzKtyKOyz[vB OsFtsvy@ s@zKa$ vBx
z[vy
bsNzKÌ>@zWyK vs@0n@
vXxKvkts@ y=NzWybs@ snb@;NnyK)s5bs@uWyWsKvBxKyKOyW@zKy©K uWs@zKvXxKyVbs@zKOy0zKÓNvBxK
v vXxyazKyK
}Ksv@z[@ MzKvXxKyWy;Fy s@uWyz[v sK @z[v« vBxvXxKyVyKbs@zsNuan\zsKv y;Fs@[vXns@zK@[KbOyKb 0­NyKy §NNnyWs@§N7s ®svNz y 7Ky > us@¦ nsNz°ONtyy|xK}KyKyz¢s[KOyKas@zyzKytRNz9tybs@tOy
y[cn[nyzJ }[Wv@¤zKa$xKs@ny0JFJvyuw@nyK)s xuW@zHuWyWJJvyuW[Ð [K;x$xKs@ny0JFqvyu NnyK)s^vyz
zK=[uany[uW@v]OsN[vB s@zKvssvXxKyt$nbyWbyyuazK ^ ; v~tsN} yuW>@zKdnby[ ´@ny9xyty
«y
^vy|tyKzKvXxKy bs@z¦KyK vs@0n@Â{]O @zWs@µyd}[¥7tyKJvy0}tss@¤WzV·¸N¹ |¹ [¼Á ·À ¹ÌË
5syua}Ky7>Î Î@}Ks@[v yzy[vXnb@ yzKzKyyty°;ts@K\zKy5vXxyaxKyKzKy5Ó Jrss¢s@vXxKyarK;vXtyÓ
­Ns@uyV0 OyW$xKFya} v0Jz@ vNuazÎVznyKbvBxKy [K vy=$zN
t y uWsN@zK z[vybsNzK [K vyK 5yv@z zsKvJ@{k}Kyny[yW7yW@7s@n°MtyKyvXxKv s@nyz°0nbyR
$ vXxa v} v0HzN v@uazVV ts@}K@} ssFvXxz@\ 5y;Fyns@Ky° vBx°ts@KyVb@tyW@zKdtyK[yKJvVsN
vXxKya¤y @zKytz°uWsNzKayzKyK=[tsb=[yK[nyK}Ks@zK@0nyKK
57@tyzKyKb=svXxy@zKytzxKytyz;v~zWyzy[vXn=yzzKyKy0z9n}KyKMzzzKvsts >ty[ yJvydzvXxKy
bsNzK¦Ky vs@0 @ §5xKyWyzKyt@}n =7@tyWs©>@zKdzKyFqN}sN;v0>yzKy;vXnb@ uWs nyKsFsÌ>@zK
byyuW7vs }Kyatyq±µyJvXzKvXxKyazsKvB s@zvXxKv [[x¢ss=[xKs@nd}KyaKy³u° vtvyKvs }yazn@}KynyK
®[v yzy[vXn=yzzKyKy0zvyK[xzKs@ s n=@tyWFyW¢@VNns@zK5R5vXxKy bsNzKzKsvyRNvBxKy ­ 5 xK
@ty@tsFyaN}s@[v ´yzKy;vXnb@ yzKzKyytyKa[©sN7s@Îzua vyKdty ybyÐkuWs@tyvXxK@zaxK@ 5sKvBxKy
7s@0n@¦ =bs@}KyK@zK=@zKaWvXx©°s v=bs@0zazKs)bs@z[v@zWyzKy=[nbyKdzts@u¨svXxKy5s@0u=s ¢yN
¯hxnyvXxKy©y@tyauW@z[ u°s@v@z[vk O[KyxytyR\usFzauO±0sNVbs@zKOy0zW$ vXxWyzKy[vB =yzzKyKy0z9n
zK@0ts7ybÓ@vXxKvk v]M yKvXxKyasFyÎ$xKy;vXxKyÎua v@0 FO[nyz;v@ >s@ÎzWy}ytvyvy0ts@0nJv Fqv|
vs;tyKvyW¯hx vy yN
7 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
§5xKyauWNz;7s@zKyt«s zK@zsKvyK[xzKs@ sytytqv~uWzKyKd}[WvBxKy 5s@}Ky¡J @tyvyax[[n[nJvk5n[xK@t
ry;NzuW@zazW;KyKy[xaxKyWFyazd K>>[}KbyK²MKyz;vX }n[xKyKdzyvXxKyvB vB y ©§5xKytyR¦ yz[vts
Nss@u¨vVvXxKya®svtvsNu V§5xKya}Kss@¤=vXxKvkuWyW }nduatyb[ns@zWsNzauWyVzvXxyau°n@B¦ @>F 0n
Îty;Nnyµ¦ Ê»ÀÂÊN¹Ì˼
½ @ÁX¹[Æ@Ã^À¼KÊÍ=zxn[xaxKyWyKO[0}KyKd}Ky@[vX xKs uWNznKvB s@zWs uWKv©vyVvVvXxKy
vs@u°nny[yKbs@ a[tyvyW [vsN @z;vXtyWs5@}z@zKby$xKyty±HJv @}Ks@[v y[FyKvBxzKabs@n9}yauy
[xKy@ >@zKa@usJv @z[ uWz@} yWM OyKbyWs@Îx[F; ONts@}nyu¨OsN d}KyWOsN FydK[zK
zK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns@zKaN vX n[n@z[vynyzbyKK
g;}Kby²Kyz[vk}KssN¤;>Ê N¼ÅÊNÑÀ¡Ê» Ãc¸N¹FÅ@ÃÅÁX¹ k·¸N¹ ÆFÊ@¼Ã¹KÉJ¸ÊN¼Ç¼»Ò \¹ ¼ÇÅ@Ã^À¼ÊKÍ=xn[x Îty;NnyVbs$tsvy
uzKy«Os@uyWsvXxy;xK@zKy7vBxKvku°nx[vVvN¤yanbyazWs@0 axKytyWyaxK9uWs@nyK[n@J y;Fy
µbOyua}nytK 5Obyua}nyt=OsN duW@¤yaKsb[}nyazK[ty} s µbsJv bs@n@ÎsFy[ty7s@\ONzbyV@zK
vXxKyWOsNuauWs@zOsNnd}[@KuWyz;vvXns@zsvBxKyaxuW@z°uauazKyWJJvyuyKbOyz[vB @ bs@u° y;vyW[nyK@zs
vXxKyWyz[Nts@zuWyz;v0\zK[©yK} zKy[@KyzK; yaKs[¤y[v [ytbs@ua[vyt7zJv0Nz; tsKJv sN d}Ky
uWNz[¢JvBt@}nya}[bbyu°} yt=Kv bsJvkzKs©yKvy5vXxNzvXxKv s57ss£Î[Kby;nx[vkuWs@tyWFObyKO[}ny
vXxK@zvXt@zKOsFOyK@znvXtFy[vs@zKdtyKJvs@tKvB s@zWs5y[vXzKJv [Ky[nyK
{~tyuWyua}KyyKyzKass°@}Ks@[vkzNzsKvyK[xzKs@ scvy|tyFMzK Ê»ÀÂÊN¹Ì˼½@ÁX¹[Æ@Ã^À¼KÊ 5=Wvy[xzKs@nsnJv0
v]KyauyWbyzbyWs5b@u vXxKvkn\zK@zKsvyK[xzKs@ s;xKs7yKdKvXxKvkzK[ty}nyatstyb=7
Ksb[}ny@zKdzyKy9y0xK@KzKy;N v@}nyN>{t zK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns7=s@5[vXtyNvBxKyz{ nz¦ vVyKytybby
vsOs@ yWbs uW@z[ ts@}nyuWzvBxKyatybyz[vJ@{ 7s@nay[vVv
s Îty;Nny¦n;vs@n@z[vXtyazWKyvBuWyÐ|{
ua x;v]=7yKyzJ±0s yaus@tyazvXxKyaxKytyW@zKdzKs@{tv nzR¦ vku@¤yWbyzby FyzaxnNn[ns@zNvsJvK
@znx[v0N[vBxKyvXuWyN
Îty;Nnyµ¦ Nn[ns@z@nbs
nyvs nsv sK5ssFzN@{ 7s@nasbb[ns@zK@ y;vVvsyKb;0}yvBxKyW7s@zKyt=s
z @zKsvy[xzKs@nsWvssvBxKyt=$xs xKdzKsvkxKyK@tas vJcvyvy[zKvBxKyu $ vXxW@;vXxKyvXxzK |ty;Nny
K
yKO[0}KyK£{ 7s@na FyW xKs@uWyKs@0¤$FO[nzuWyz;v]s us$z5Ó byazK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsWvs;tyKvyW
F@uatyÐVs@\y;KvXt[tyKM v [©yKvyW@zWNz;vXnsvyN ¯h vXxvXxKybyW7s@zKyt=b@uWy; y@\NzytÌ>s5$xn[x{ 7=F;[vy 7@ty@5{ b@ av
zK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsbs@z[ytyzKbyaz9@ µ¯ yWONzR¦ v [u° ss@\O[nyzKOyWNz9zsKv sN0 ´@}sN;v\vBxKyKOy
y[vBx O@ O[KyK ®;v~u[}byK²MKyz[v OsNz;Fy©bvXnsNz« vXxax[F; ; qv=bs@z[NzKOyKduWyvBxKv
zK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns ua Mx[vkzKsv]y;Fyzs@0¤ÎsNµ>vk yJv0\ v 7s@nzR¦ v 7s@0¤$@z[KvBuWyWbss@zN>­5xKs@vX
vXxKytyKcvy{~uWsFyvs sNns@tsNvs;¤Kz¤$s@0¤{~x°Oy[vkNzvBxKy¢s[«s u7s@0¤$[x cvyvs
bs^v7@ty¢s@vXxKy{Xz;vy0zy[v0[Ky[ nb@ s@zanyKvXxKvk}Kyb@uy¬JF@zK¬zS
§5xKyzR\nFqv [uauy\®ts; 5b[n[xKy5vsNnduWyvXxKvkzK@zKsbb@nyauWsNnyK;n@\y yJvXts@znb=7zKs
tJvXnb@ §5xn=7OÊN¹ )zKy7v~nyFqv\vs uWyNz {VvXxz¤=vs uW@z[ KyKs@nyÎ@zKd v~tnb@ [xK@zKy
u´s@zns@zW@}Ks@[vkzK@zKsvyK;xzKs@ns>>{tv]Oyz[vkuWya}K[¤=vs Ê»ÀÂÊ@¹Ë¼
½ NÁX¹;ÆNÃcÀ¼Ê |@ytyFMz |ty[@ny¦ =sN0¤
^vyÎuWs@tyvXxNzd[WFy@t5{ 7=n[uWFyvs tyK@nyaxsF vtvXny{kxK9tyuWyua}KytyasK vnyzvXx[
byJvXns@zONnyK V@zKyt=Nz sNyK 7zK[KMzKa O[Kb; s@zWs xKs zK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsnyK=b@za}KyKOsNuWy
µyzKzKy«s5yJvX0JvXns@zN k{XzKyyK@Vz°u ty©yKzKasvXxn=b@[vXns@zK@ uvy0n@[vs{]@u¨qvX0K;¤W}[
xKs zK@ yWbs@uWyWsK |ty;Nny¦n«OKyKMK@t9ts@Ksb@ =byyu>@zKdxKs uaK[xWtyvy{N±JKyvXxKyW@zKyt
vs }yazKs*vXxK@zWy[FyzaxKyWbyKyuWyKvsWvBxKyz@
K@zKaNz;vXn[KvyKa@zKayb[0}Ky9uW@z[Wvy[xznb@K@zK
Ks@ vB ONts@}nyuW=$ vXxazK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns Îty;NnyVJv@vyKvXxKyars@tyK[nx[v|{XzJvX vX[vyazvXxy°nvyd@F
vs
xKyatyK@tyWbs[ny[vtWs@\@z[vB ;KvyKaF@zKOyKvy[xzKs@nsnyK k7uWsJvku°Ks@v@z[v0\zNzsvyK;xzKs@ sR> §5xKyWyzK@}zKd}tyN¤OvXxts@xvsbbyua}nyt=byyuW«²M vya¤y $ vXxzvXxKyazKy;Kv|WyK@tK ~s@nyK; @
ynyKqvXts@znb vXxKyazKy)[}[nynasK zNzsKvyK[xzKs@ sR´xKy©yazKM @nK@uWs@ y[nyK=@tyW[t[ v ynyuyz[v
[xKs@nduWKvBtyW²n[¤ @zKd}Kybs@uWyWyzKs@0uWs@K[ K[tvX FyW vBxzvBxn«yKbyR>b@K;z°£ @ty
zK[tyuyz[v@z[yKJvBuyz[vkzW@zK@zKsvy[xzsNnsnyK
Vz[¢s@vBzKvy >=$ vXxazK[nyNvy[xzKs@nsV v~n¢@VyK[nyvs[tyKvyyKJvB0KJvB yaKby7s@
zK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsWvXxK@zWbs@zKqvX0KJvB yWs@zKyKK 5@zKsvy[xzKs@ns xK=[nyK@|u° v@Nzvy0ts@0nJvkKby>@zK
Fs@azKyKydzKsv~}yW[n[n@[vs£tynyKbyW£uO[ y yJvX0JvX FyazK@zKsvyK[xzs@ snb@Ky[NnbyÎ;K[xWy[@nbyK
b@za}Kya} v\vs }KyWbynyKJvB y yJvX0KqvX FyR>^yKJvBz@Ns@\y;F@uany>s@z OyvNzWyKs©Nxnb@K@tyKsN
ts@Ws Kys@ yWxKs@tyWyzKy[vBnb@ nJvXzKqvH
a
z uauWyKnvyWbs@zKOyK²yzKOysvBxKyar@KJvB @za}K@t@zazWs@}[v@zzKvXxKyWMtyKvkKs7y\s zK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns
n7vBxKv]ya0zWtya0 ;¤ vXxKya0n[¤=vXxKv 7yauanx[v yJvXtsWvXxya}nsF;xKytyWsNzW$x ;x@ ¢yWyKyzK
8 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
5 Î
ty;NnyVy[@nNzKy Ó
n@z[v Î vBx JnyKFy 7zKs£us@tyWy;^ ; yz[vVvXxK@zvs¦n=bs@ @Vbyn=bs@n°s@[v³µbs@uaKy;vyatyK@ @z[v
[ts7MzKvBxKya}nsF;xKytyW$ vXxW@z°zKy}nys@ny@§Ns@KxWs@u°z s@ts@KH}KJvy0n Îbs@n°s@[v³µbs@uaKy;vy
tyK@}Fqvy0nVÓ§5xKy[Os@ a[tyKd¤ya} sz9sNnyzVtynbvyWO$ ^vX >@zKdtyKMKbyvXxKya} s[xKytyvs
Kqv~zW uWvtvy\s5K
V@zKy©sNtynbvs@t=bs@n°y[ }KyvssWvs@KxR>[uW@Â@zK9©N M
[tyzKvsJvs@ÎvknyKJvk 57yauWN¤yazKs tyK@tvXns@zN¯ yaxKFyvXts@} yWyzKs@KxWbs@z[vBtsNzKN0Kby
@zK0 vVnyK
W
u sNzvBxKyWbszKsbOyz[vBKs zK@zKsvyK;xzKs@ns@vXxnvXxtyKvkxK}Kybs@uWy°¤zKs$zWvXxKy 0tss
ts@}nyu V§5xKs@KxauWbbyK=s zKOs@z[vXts@ ydtynbvs@tzKyKydzKsv~}yWts@\ssy[NvBxKyvy³u µ©K
ss ÎyuaxK[nyKvXxKvkty bvsNt=@}nyvssN} vytvya yaua x;v~}ya ybzK[0zKvXxK@zW[zKM yW[yK[ny
s5[t@}Ktb§5xKy; uanx[vk}KyW;Ky³ s@|zW@zWy[sN[vB s@zK@byzKbyR\};v\vBxnzyKy9zKsvkuW@¤yvXxyu
F@K@}nyN
§5xKyWtssWvBxtyKvkuWN¤yK=s@zKyvXxz9Ky¢yJvX [nyNbÓ¯£yO@zzKsv Kc¢s@tabyv@z°¤zK=s5FO[nyz;v
$ vXxatynbvXzKabbyua}nytK
¥7tss7s@n°;ty }KyWy©yKb;zKayzKzKvss@|xuW@zWFyz[vXtyWs@z K@vXxRN¢@V7s@tbyvBxK@z
uWytytyWs@| Oy>@zKas@zKyvBxKv]OsN aJvyuwts@u¨;uanyanN}sN©KvsN ´O[nyz[vJ Ï|s@KK
{tvk uWsJv s5N[vBxKyaKs7y\s5yJvX0JvX FyWby tJtynbvXns@z°zWyzKy[vXnbÌ\zK@zKsvyK[xzsNns>@zKdts@}KsvXnb
¥ vBxKv [xKs@na yaKK@Kby@@­Ny ©Hty OvXnsNzanvXxKyauWsK=s@Kyt@zKMKs5yzy[vXn=yzKMzyKy³z@
$xn[xaKOyKvXxKyauW[xzKysKvBxKyWby;vs ty OKvya v«yK[nz>@zKvXxKya0uWyW@zKy|zKy0 @zKat
ss zazK@zKsvyK;xzKs@ns>>­vs@0nyK=s 0z0NuWs@¤Wts@}Ksv¤yvXxKya®s@t@VtynbvXzKas@Îua[vKvBzvsyKOb@Ky
ts@uwvBxKyWy[vBxnb@Kbs@zKJvBt@z;vuaKsbyasNzvXxyuª}[WvBxKyV[tyKvsNtÌ>@tyW7yyKJv@}n[xyKdzs@Vb[nyzKby
nJvB s@za}Kss@¤=@zKdus@ yK>{tv~n=y[yzaKsb[}nyvXxKv by tJtynbvXns@z°uW }KyauWs@tyz@uyz[v@[vBxK@zy
vXxKs@KMx[v0Nz9xyzKbyaxNtyÎs@\y;FyzauaKsb[}ny vsOsNz;vXts@ ©yKbyz[v @vXn[nya}[a­vXK@vk@[^uW@z
z Æ@âÅRÁX¹vX vXnyKX­Ny ©H@ynbvXns@z5Ó [yz [y[vB y \s {tv Înb[bby7vBxKyWnbbsFyWvXxKv µ@uazKsµ[n
Ky;vXnyWb@z µ@[vsOKv@ bya v=sFzWJNz[vBxKyK; ί yWs@z¦ vk¤KzsF xsF) yK[©yKvXxn=N} vt n\}[v
@[^uWNzazKsvyvXxKvk v~uW xz[v
v 0 ts@[vyvsby tJtyts[zKdus@nyK; @VJJvyu=s@zW }K[n¢@
$ny5vXxNzW¯ vOs@z 0 ;¤W}KbyJK@0z5 {XzvX0[vXxR>7yaxKyaxKdzaxK@zKsNFy@t=[ y@\@0zzK=svXxKyW@zKytzxKytyz[vkz yK[tyK
¤KzKs yyWs5¥ avyK;xzKs@ns yÎsKvBxKyaKsb[} vts ¤KzKs$nyyW@nsNzyWyzK@}zKdub=yJvX0JvXns@zN
®[vVvXxKybyW7@0zzKxKyzR¦ vk}KyKyzny }n[nyKÐVvBxKya}n= O[Kb; s@zKxKya}KyKyzW[ y@0
zKyK²vyNF§MxytyanzKs ts v~za}n[nKzKvXxyW@zKytK
§5xKyazK[nyNµ\}ns@ snb@¡>@zKa[xyuanb@ ® vy[xzKs@nsnyKKby9zKvBxµOyz[vB7yNsNz«s uWb
yKqvX0KqvXnsNzW7ytyW@zKa@tya @ty u° v@>y[ynsNyKdzsKy0zuyz[vk @}Ks@tvsN0nyK@{XzW[xN0Wbs@z[vBtJv0
vXxKy5Jv00byz;vX¥ avy[xzKs@nsnyKxKFyW[nyNVbs@uauWyt[n@KOyK=@zKaNtya}yzKay[yns@KyKa@usqv
y[[K[ Fy };bs@0Ks@tvyWyz;vy00 OyKK>{XzvXxn=FysvB0u°xK@z[v bs@u°uWyt[n@n[uNvyK[xzKs@ saÎ vBx
b[nyzbyW vxK@zu@nyz7n=y Fy0zKaby0 y=sK5@uWsJvkunb@z[yz[vB s@zKvBxKv]@tyvXxyausJv
xKyzKs@uyzK@ K;tKvB yWy[yVbyKyzN¯£yWNtyWMtyKb; y t;zKvXxKyats@uanbyK=svXxKybyazKy
vy[xzKs@nsnyK=$ vXxzvXxKyazKs Hz[xK@ yzKy°qFJvyu¨s5ns@}K@Kb@ v@n[u¨@zKd vu@z s@ zK@z[ @
zKbyz;vX Fy«@zKabs@uaKy;vX vX Fyatyb[tyK
§5xnnvXxKy©Jvkus@uWyz;v~zvXxKyaxnJvs@sK5s@|n@zKy[v xKyzW@z[[Ky[nyKÌ\}[ v=s$zFs@z[vNJvB s@z
xK}KyKOsNuWyWNzyvs vby VΫyKvsWJvkzua}Kyt«s5svXxytK
{tvku°nx;v~}yWW¢@uan@ÎtstyKO[nsNzRNvXt@zK;0z°s@zauWNz;7s@0nÎ n@zKy[v³\zKy$ W¢s@0uWyK>\n[n
ty[s@ yK=@ts@zKd v=Jv@0Ðk yW[ns$ W¢s@0uW[Ð ¤@ ynsbbs@ntsbyKO[ns@zs5[tyvXty«y;Fs@ Fy[Ð
z[vynyzbyWyuWytyK=$xn[xR>vk yJvkvs£Ks@z;v0>bs@z;¢y©«yzKs@0uWsN«;N N;F@KyÐ @zKvXxKyz
vy[xzKs@ns z[yz[vyK5>{tv $zK=s@zvBxKyu vXxKvVvXxKytyW@tyW[K[xvXxzK«n7=s 5vXtyRNvXxKvVvXxyKby
nF«O@z°}y°©y[Fy@ yd}[y[@Ky0uWyz[v³>@zKvXxKvk¤Kzs$nyKyWsvBxKyKbyan7=b@za}KyauWya}KsvXxvsOFy
@zKvsWv@¤ya yKV}KsvXxWs@z°ztyKOyKyz[vy°Ob@nyKK>­N[nyzKOyNvBxKy[ tybsznyt@z[vu°uWyzKbyaKs7ytK
{XzWWn[x@vXxKy;[tyKvyW7s@0n@µ@ vy0z°OsNz;vX0 F@zKbyK>­NsNuWyan@zKy[v@[ NnvXnsNz«OyKyvXxy\
vXxts@KMx\ byau° v=s@zW$xKvkuW´@zKaxKv~uaKqv~zsKvk}KyWsNzyNz°OKy KbvXxtsNxvXxKyvXuWyWs
9 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
Ky³nKÏ vBxKytVzKsv bs K;¤bs@\Os 0Kyz[v³\Ky0 ;xN
§5xKv~n5@0­NNzR>$0 vXzKdzd @VzÆǹ ÇŹ μÃÍ~£}Kss@¤ yKb;0}z9x Nn[ns@zWsvXxKyaxuW@z
;vXtyazW[Kby@@{]@u sNz zKs ty@nz9xKs)yyaxnz[nx[v 7@zK9xs OsN©y a{~uanbNz°
ua O\xnFs@nby@rs@V@ v«y s²MKyzKOy5­@FNzR¦ =bs@z[vX0};vXnsNzW7zKsvknyKJvVvXxKv s5[uanyOs@u°uWs@z
byzKbyÎ@zv©vX0}[vyvBxKv0>@ns@zKa$ vXxaxua vt\uW@z[svXxKyanyKzKasFOvyK=svXxKy5Jv00byz;vX
vy[xzKs@nsnyK=byKyuwvs£ ;¤F
{~tyuWyua}KytsNu u;x xssFvXxKvkut@zKuWsvXxyV7«qvXts@zK @zKJvVvXxKyWsy0KOyWsK
@z[vX}nsvXnbK>­5xKyaxKa7s@0¤y°;zbya}Ky[s@tyvXxKy©Jv ¯ s@0 a¯ @VF= ztbyW@zKdxKabs@uauWsNzbyzby
vtvX vXKyvXxKvVv@¤KzKa@z[vX}nsvXnbVznyKO7vBxKy[ytyW@}Kbs@[vy zyKbybb@>7}K¢s@Fs@N
{tvk zKsvVvXxKv [xyW7=NzWyzKyus tstybK@­5xyWb u°[x°tstyKOzW@z@uWsFq
v yK@|zt[zK
b@tyKy0Ðkut@zKKvBxKyn@}Ky;vXn\}yzKy; vy°MtyKvX Wts@uwvBxKyau°tsKyKvXtyvXuWyz[v7vBxKvk}KyKb@uWy
F@ @}nyaz°x ¢y;vXuy@®[v [xy\¤yauW@z[ ny[yxKyKydKyKs@ny7s@ndts@}K@} WvXxz¤W v tyKvB
@0ts@z[vV¢s@|K\zs=Nvs }KyWy[nzzKa ts@}KsvXn
HtynbyuWyz;v];KyK; y Î$xyzW7yWs@}[Nns@K; xKyWbs
uaK[xvXts@}nyauW@¤KzKdtynvX Fy ;uanyvXxzK«sN³¤[>@zKabs£u°[xvXts@}nyauW@zKzK Îs@Vy[yz
zKytJvNzzK Îs@©by FyK
{~ty@nyazKs*vXxKv [xKyaxKa@zWF@tyzKyb=svXxKyazKvXtyWsKvBxKyWs@tyVs y@zK°svBxKyazKyKOyKb; v©sK
@z° vBx@zKdty[KyJvXzKvXxKv s@tyX¯h vXxvXxntyK;KyKqv]OsNuWy«£zKyKOyKbON xua vtWvXxKv 7yR> vBxs@
yK@0 B5Jv³µbyz[vX[x[vKNxR\n[¤$v]s@|Ky0 F§MxyWbs@u°uWs@zKbyzKby@ y=ts@zKydzvXx tyK;KyKqv0\n
s^vyza0 Mx[v0VzWF@zbyWsvXxKyWb[nyz[vX n=y[@ yzKOyN§5xKyW; y@5t vt@zKdzKy[cn[nyzK[nyK=svXxKy
xuW@zHuWyWJJvyuW«yaxKFya} v [xKs@na FyaK=@K@KbyÐVvXxKyt vtsvXxyWJFJvyuW{~xKy
7s@0¤yKas@zbyv@z xua}nyKuWyN
¯ W
y [xKs@ndxKFyanyK@0zyKa nyKbOs@zts@uwvXxKyauW@¤KzKasvXxKytJv Kvs@u°n}Ks@ua}@zKvXxyatyK[ vBzKa@0uW
tbyN¯ yWnz¦ v]s7y;vXxKyz>@zKvXxy°@tNnynvss@V[³tyz[v [ vXKvB s@zW@tyvXts@}zK5
§5xKyWy[c¢s@vVvs£} vXxytJv vs@ua }Ks@ua}W7 y9};WvXxKya}0 @z[vkx;F[n[nJvV¬ÌMNs@}Kyv Ï7yzxKyuyX
Ï7KyzxyuWyV7zKsv~zKvBt@ z[vytyKqvyKdzaKs@ vXnb};v~}yKb@uWyaK@z[ 7@tyWs5$xKvkxKy
Ky©by FyaFvXxyWtFyvXxtyKvVvs¯ yJvy0zW[ N vXns@zts@uwvXxKy§5xtdNyn[x>´vXxtyv];ty ty
}KyKO@KbyWsvXxKyaKsO[} vtWvXxK
v vXnyÎuanx[v s@}[v@zazK[nyK@V7yNsNzK
zKytM yKd}[WvXx =bs@zKOy0zVxKy
}ts@Kx;v~x =JvBts@zK9z[vynyKJv³\Kb; s@z¢s@|x[[nb>@z°;xK@0 ;uvXnnyKyt[xW[¤K v
s bs7 n@uWs«@zK
nyKa t@naNz°;KbbybJKy;^s@v~};NzazK[ty}nyWbs@nyJvXns@zs5©yKvku°zKvs²n[¤ z[yz[vVvBxKy
}Ks@ua}N
¯hxKvk =qvX0¤KzKd xKs*vXx =y;^sNv bs@z;vXzKyKabs£zKvXt@ Kcvy5vBxKyaz vB @uaKy[vBK=7tyuWsFy5@{XzW
uWyKy[vBz°;xKs@vX ^vy V \$ vXxWbs@uWyax[[n[nJv=$xKs´¢y vVvBxKv~y0xK@KvXxyWy[c¢s@v [xKs@naJvs@
Ï7KyzxyuWyVN©KyKvsbs@z[vXzyN
=JvKvyKdtyKbs@zWbyyuW= } v JvXt@zKy5ÓVzKsvk}KyKO@KbyWsvXxKyyK@VsK
nNtyWb[K@ vXnyKts@u Nzaz[F; s@zWs¬H@K@zV}[vk}Kyb@KbyvXxy Vz vyK5vXns@zK>xn[xW7=bss@zvs }Ky
¢s@0uWyK>>[xKs@ dxKFys@ty¤zKs$nyKyWsK5vsNuan=7yK@Ks@zK us@tya¤y tybs@zvBxKyatsO±µyJv bs@z[vBzyK
n7vBxKyaus@uWyz;vXuwvBxKvkxK9} vk vXxKytJv vs@u°nvyJv0§M0z vt>FzKy@0 vkxK@zK
¯ a
y ¤KzsF*vBxKv~zatyK@0zvBxn7tJv Kvs@u°nvyJvVvXxKyax[[n[nJvtsOyKyKyKayK; vyW n@tyazua}Ky\s
Ksb[}nyW@zKytKF§Mxy[7ytyaz vXnN 7s@00nyK@V}Kby°s@zWb@n[ vXns@za}[KNt´§Nyny@vXxKv @z
vs@u°n=y[@ns[nsNzauanx[v by;v\tyvsWvXxyWKvBus;xKyty@ ty[@nbyKab@n[nvXns@z°tyKOyKvXxKyW@zKyVsK
yKqvXtsNzKvXxys@0 vsWvXxtyKyRHzµJua s@zW[xK@zKOyN §NynyVbFxKyWFnvyV@}nyvsM ;u°nbvXxKy
ts[KyJv s5vXuWsF;xKy0 nz vXns@zWyz[vXty ÎÏ7KyzxyuWyNvBxKs@Kx7=[[cn[nyz;vX bs@zKby0zKyKa@}Ks@[v
vXxKyaty[ v s@§M³z vtWvBxKvkxKyW@0tNzyKsNV sFO[}nyWy[F[vXnsNzWsvXxKyWOsN;vXxKyKJvkK@v svXxKyWqvvyWs
5yK ky[@nbs zK>>s5bs@tbyRNvBxKytyWFvBxKyW[nyK@\@zKyVs5Jv@vBz°£zK[nyK@V@0utby@
¯h vXxzW uWsNz;vXxWsvXxKvVtJv³>[KObyKOJ[vyJv0@v7svsNuan}Ks@u°}«yKJvBtsFyK ts[xuW@zK5b@¤S
­Ns@uyWO[nyz[vXnJvxK°;KyJvyvBxKv\vBxKya}Ks@ua};ua }KyWyuWsNzJvXtvy@\tvBxKyvXxK@zWts@KyasNz
¬H@K@zKybyW[ vXnyKÎb@zvBxKv\vBxn«s@n°MtyKvX u°tsKyvXxKyW[x@zKbyKs@\@0uW=bs@z[vXts@KcvyvXxKyW@ }[vVvs£zKsF@ ¯h vXxvXxyvBtyKR´s [yN0 5@0}Ks@\qvX;ty[xaz uWy0nb@zK̦RuazKÌ\ v]s@n9xKya}KyKyz
Fy ^ ; v\s@
ty[nyz[v§50uW@zvss@ty\yuWs@zKJvBtvXnsNzWsvXxyyK@Ks@zKtvXxyvXxK@zaKbyvXxyu¨
xKyWn£ vXxKyWy[tyvs²M ;¤K yzKvBxKyW7@\@z°byvXxKya FyKvXxv]s@ dxKya}KyKyz°nsJvkz@z;
z[F[ns@zWsK¬J@K@z7yqvXts@zK5F¶y;vVvXxKyWsFy00nzKvX0[vXxWFts@}K@} Wy[uany5Ó@5vXxKy
x[[n[nJvkrKtyyuW@z FOsNzanvyVb@n@ ©§5xKyatyKOsNzvXxKvk v 7=ts@Ky° ±JKJvVvXxKvkzKs@}sFR xKvBxKy
10 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
bs@tyWs@vXxKysNty[nx[vVvsb zKs
{tv0¦nuaKs@v@z[vVvs£tyK@ yaxKs)[xKs[¤yKvXxy°x[F; ; qv=7ytyazvXxKyWcvy0uWvXxWsvXxKya}sNua}zKas
ts[xuWs@z KJv | @§5xKy[yKb;0}yWby0 y=sK5FyK=s5yuWsvXns@z5Ó@tqv0>byzbyWs
uWyz[vVvXxKvVvBxKya}Ks@u°}WsN0¤yK>NvXxKyzaxKs@0ts@\v @;vXxKyaKys@ yvBxKvkxK9}yKyza¤nyK@@zKvXxKyz
bs@z[@zK;zyKyzKvXxv]s@zazKsbOs@z[v [xKs@na@zKsvXxKyÎ}Ks@ua}a}KyWts@Ky5¶Ny;v sK5OsNtbyW@zKsvXxKyÎ}sNua}
7=ts@Ky@>s@z 5b@¤ÂsNz WvBxtyKyWK=Kcvy5vBxKya}Ks@u°}z°s ts[xuW
{Xz 5sFyua}Ky7 @vXxtyyaus@z[vBxK=^vy5vBxKyWvs@ua }Ks@ua}zKÏ7KyzxKyuWyVJvss0ua }KyxzKvXxKy
b[nyz;vX n=vtvX vXKy>OK@zK@ B{tvknzsKvkKsb;} yvs }KyWO[nyz[vB qv~znyKbFs@a}Kyny[yvXxKvVvXxy°¤zKs$nyKy
svXxKyW7s@0n@@zKvBxKyaKs7y\xn[xvXxn= FyKÌ\n=WvXxzKa$x ;x°n=s z;vX0zK[nF@Kyvs xuWNz v©Nz
vXxKvVFs@W@tyaK[zKd v\vs xKyazvXxKyW[tyKasK ¤zKs$nyKyW@zKaN©yzKvsWvN¤yvXxKyWbs@zbyK²yzKOyKK Ï7KyzxyuWyV7yz;v]s@zvs7s@0¤[$ vXxWsvXxKyt>s@zvXxKy5;xKyKOsNzR [ yz[vXxK@©yKs@v0$xn[xR>5n[xK@t
5xKsy=bFz°x tybyz;v~}sFs@
¤ ÀnËÀ¼Ê˼½ ·Ì¹ÉJ¸Ê@¼KǼ»KÒ[Í ¢s@z°7Wvs ty[yz[v ; @zKyKJvBzKyazK[nyK@
@0utbyW vBxKs@[vktyKOsNvBzvs@0uWyKa7s@0nasFy³zuyz[v JÐVvXxKy\[yKqvXns@zF=´¢s@0u¨s
tyzK²n[xuyz[v s zK[nyK@V7y@Ks@zK=7s@0¤W}[ zKvXns@z0Jvvy7vs@zaz[vy0zKvB s@zK@KyzKJ
§5xntsNsb@nyKvsWvBxKya®@0K[x @z$xn[xWF=[}ua v©vyKvs´vXxKy Vz vy 5vB s@zKz¬zKyd
}[v
zKy[yVs@[vy BKy0xK@K}KyKONbyxKsyK=[yJvV®y0zNtd®@0K;x°xKJzK; qvyKas@za}tyzzK
vXxKyan@zW$ vXxWbs@z[yz[vB s@zK@KONzJvXns@zK vXxyty}[ zy[@ vN} ss@uazKd v³>y[yzvXxKs@x° v 7s@nµ@uWsFqv
byv@z xKya}KyKyzatyJ±0yKJvyKd}[a­v@z qv~Kb; Nz;F7 bÏvXxKy\y;^sN vvs ts@uWsvyWbyzK[}nyWJvyK
vs7@tdz[vy0zKvXns@zK@nz9zK[nyK@|Ks7yvs£ty[yz;v]@zW@0utbyat@zW¢s@y vXxKy\s ­gsN vXnb=@zK
z[vy³zK@KnJvX0Jv0sNVnJvX³KJvk}[WvXxKy­Ns@ y;vKF§5xKyWs@Ks@vXz v©WvssNnvXxKyW@0uWtbyW7 sJv³>@zK
Fy²n[¤
§N7sWyK@tnKvyVzd @>ÏKyzxKyuWy\byyuWyKvs£xKFyaty[xKyKa@zKsvXxyVJvyazaxn7vBxz¤KzK@
bNzK@ X{XzWbs@uWyWbs@v s5[0KyWOyzKOyW$xn[xazKsW@n@0 vtVzKs xus@VzKssytJvKvyuWyz;v]ONzW² vy
y[vXzKn[xRNvXxKyax[F; ; JvxKFya¤KzsFzW[zÐ @zKvBxnn= ¤zKs$nyKyvXxKy;b@zzKsvk sOyN
{Xzd @@vXxKy­Ns@ y;v=y[@nsFyKa@zvsNu }Ks@u°}@®h \}KsvBxvBxKy ­ @zKvXxKy­Ns@ y;v Vz s@zaxKvyKqvyK
x[FMtsyza}Ks@ua}K=[ v@}ny¢s@Vy Fy }[@t[t^vJ zKabs´vXxKyazK; y@\@0uWtbya}KyKNz@
5yK@0 aWFy@t«sVzvXxyWs[uWyz;v@·¸N¹ ÆÒ$º ½tù[Á=·Á0ÀÂÊÀÄà ÒÌÍ rKtyyuW@z FOsNzW[u°uW@0nyvXxKy
b[nyz;vX n=vtvX vXKyKvXxKvk}ts@Kx;v~7vsWvXxyazK[nyK@|ty[ Oy5Ó
X{kxKFyy vk vkuFOy µF§5xKyW v©vyVs zK; yNV7y@Ks@zKK>{tv~n0tyK; qvX} ya sNWbs@uWyvsWvBxKyu F=
b[nyz;vXnJvHF§s´¢yy v0¦nvXxKy©y°zFs@|xK@zKÌNvs£tynyKOyvBxn«yzKytWvXxKvVynvXxKyWJvNtÌNvs£ y;vk v s´Fs@
}nzK5F§Ns Ky¢s@0uwvBxKyKbyauat[nyK@vs ^v £u°ns@zvs@zK=s ts[¤Wz;vsWvBxKyW[¤b@{tvkn=bs@uy;vXxzKvXxKv
FyyKs@nyW@z°[nsNzWs ua vN} yasFy@zK9 vkn\zWbs@uWyW7FVtyK;Ks@zK[}ny¢s@VNKs@vXts@} y
vXxn$xKvVFs@aua Mx[v b@;vyK;xznb@K@0ts@zKbyRNvXxv]sytbs@uWyKKys@nyxKyzvBxKy[byyW$xKvVvXxKy;b@z
s vBxvBxKy|u°zKK
5s=FvXxyz7yW@tyW[tyvs@t«s zyK*vy[xzKs@nsnyK=@zKaJv@t=svXxKyauMzKy[vBty0 Fyz vBxn
vXuWy°};tyKvVzK@zK; @tyK7@t«@zKans@}K@Kbs@uaKy;vX vXnsNzÎy[ vyvXxyW[nyK@\@zKytÌ\xK@t
y[@KvBz°xKv~ vkuW }ya¤yvsWvXWvs yaz7s@0nvBxKv~nvXxKyaty@nJvB =s@[vOs@uyWs5$xKv yWNty
[tyKvBz°@zKduWFMzz5
{Xzd ·¸@¹ 5ÅÇÂǹRÃ^À¡Ê ¼½VÃ^¸@¹ºkâ¼ °ÀÉ7¾5ÉqÀ¹;ÊÃ^ÀnËÃ Ë }KyKNza;vtvXzKaVssNuWbK s;¤$sNza v=bsFyXrs@ÎuWs@ty
vXxK@z WFy@t\ vkxK=[xKs$zW@zWyKJvBuWvyWsvXxKyatynKvB yazK[nyNV@zKyV7yaxKFybyK@Vty[nyKJvBzvBxKy
[xK@zKMzKdz[vy0zKvXns@zK@Kbs@zKM vB s@zK§5xKyaxK@zK«s@zvXxKyW; s[¤WxKyausyK vXuWyK=@zKvsJv@zKzK
v~zzyau°z[vyKvs£u°nznx;v0\ty;nyKqv]Os@z[vXzzKa@zKdtyK@K@zyts@uªzK[nyK@V7yK@sNzK§5xKyatybyz;v
vXns@zsV{XzKM @zKÌ@¤ qv@zvsWvXxyanJv s zK; y@ÎKsytxKz[tyKbyvXxKyvXxtyKv sKM¢@©yWsKvBxKy
zKs@zts@ ¢ytKvB s@zWs@¡>@zKvXxn=@zKy\ty;nyKqvyKd}[ uWsNzKvXxKyaxNz=[nsFOyvs uanznx[vkz
{XzWsN5vBuWyVxKs u°[xW@zKy\s7yFOy\zsvN±JKJvVtsNu
vy[xzKs@nsnyK sF x xW@tyvXxyy;KvBzJvXns@z°0n[¤
11 of 18
zK[nyNV7y@Ks@zKV}[vVts@u¨@KsvXxyKby
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
§5xKyaxnsbs@xKy¬JsNxz by[ yaxF=JvBKnyKvXx =²yKJvB s@zW@zKabs@zK[KyvBxKvVvXxKya0n[¤$s xuW@z
y[vXzKJvXns@za =vknyKJv Ky©byz[v³ $xnyaN ©y}Kyny[yK=7yaxKy µ£}Ky[v©vyvXxK@zWy[yzW[xK@zbyWs
uWN¤zK9 vVvXx©sNx Î$ vXxvXxyOFyKvVvXxKvkxKyaxF0NnK}KyKyzb;Kby°s }KyzKaNzWs@[vXuanJvH 5sv
s@z NtyvBxKyKOyWyKJvXuWvyKzKsv yzKbs@tzK@V}[vVvXxKy;s zsKvkzK[KyvXxKyats@}K@} vts u@z[ xsN0³
s@[vbs@uWyKvXxKvknyW[xKs@v s5y[vXzKJvXns@zN
rby° vXxW[K[xWbbyb[uWyz[vbs@uyWOy0ns@KKyKs@nyW@tyW@©yK[KyKqvXzKvXxKv 7yW[ua usy
}Ky[s@zKK@vXxW«²Mn[¤K Ksb[}nyN¯ yW7s@n°Os@ s@znyvXxKyW@nK K;zKsNz 5yuW@zzats@}KyKÌ
$xn[xaxKs@ts@u Jv@\qFJvyuwvsJvNVJJvyuVtynbvXzKavXxKy[s>F§5xn«qvyW$K@usqv]Oyv@z }Ky
zKyKOyKbON °} s@zFy@t7ts@uªzKs s@Vbss@zKy| 5s@\OsNn@VJFqvyuªn=nbJvBtsN[ uaKJvyKd}[WvXxKy
u°KyzKzKabs@ ; s@zWs5sN\@nK vBxvBxKy zKts@uWyK@nK$ vXxzvXxKyazy[Kv }ns@zFyK@t X\}[vk
7yv@¤yat7yK@zKks@tFyK=vVvXxKyV7s@td vku°nx[vk}KyazyKbybb@ }[WvBxKyau°nM yWsvXx =byz[vX>
¯hxKv @tyvXxKyauWs@t@uanbvXns@zKxKyty ${t5y°uaKqv~uWsFya}y[Fs@z K@vBxvBxn«²Mn[¤K zs@ty5s@5vBxKy
[Ky[nyKvs[@ y>xKsOby[v7vBxKyatyK;Ks@zK[} v©W¢s@5vBxKy¢vysvBxKsby XuWsJv s KKcvy\@ Î$xKs@ty
ny[^vk}KyxzK7 z°y;Fyz° 5yObvtvy5vsWvXxyqv@tV ;z¦ vk v~¤y WvBxKv 7yauWKWvN¤yWs@Îts@}nyuW« vXxaK
s@5z@\nvyNvXxKvVvXxy[ xKys@ s7ydK
k§5xKyvyWs5sN\;KyK[ny«s@z K@vXxW@zKas@5vyazvBxKyW@nK
byyuªzKy;KvX0nb@} z¤y5
K
z svXxKyÎny nvsytyKJv by0nyK=s5[x y 7vsy;¢yzKaFNzKqv]y[xWsKMvXxKyW@zKyts@KvyK;xzKs@nsnyKKF§Mxy
­vXtvyn Vy[yzby{Xz vXnvX FyR\ts@Ksbyd}[WvXxKya@yK@zWFMu°znJvBtKvB s@zR>7=@zv©vyua[vVvsyK; Mz[[x
[x y a@zKJvVvXxyvXxtyKv s5 zK[nyK@VKv©v[¤=tsNu vXxKy­NsNny;v Vzns@zNM®[v F vBx Î @0¤y$xKs
70 KWvsnb[KO[ns@zK«@}sN;v\vBxKyatsO±µyJv0s@}KbyFy Ó t§5xKs@KMx° vku°nx;v~}yaKsb[}nyKvVJv y[NyzKOy
vsOs@zKJvX0Jvk sb@Ky[yzKOyWJFJvyuWvXxKv 7s@n£¦ s@z ¦ny[vVvXx©sNxWW¢y KytOyz[v s }K@nJvB uanb[nyK
vXxKyauaK[xvs@;vyKdnyKs5 zKvXns@zK@ua}tynzsNzbyzbyN [n7 N©yK;\Ky0xK@KvXxKyW©yKvyJv
y[@Ky0uWyz;v@x[[n[nJv svXxn=byz[vBVtyuW@0¤yvs uWyvXxKvVvXxyWFRFsbvy«s5[[xWb[xKyuWyK=7yty
¦ y }0nx[v ;F=$ vXxazKsbs@u°uWs@zWbyzbyNĦ n@0¤yWbs@z;vXzKyKÓ bss@¤KzKdz[vs us^vyzW[ns@K[Jv@}N¡5{ [K;KyKqv\vBxKv]´vsv@Ky;¢yzKbyauanx[v
zKyKyd}KyaKsb[}nyazbyz;vXs@Vbs®[vVvXxyvyK[xzKs@ sR z[s@ yKa7s@ndtsKOy>= };JtsKJv³
7yNsNz«OsWvy00}nyvXxKvkzKss@zKyWsN d}KsvXxyV$ vXxW@z[KvBxz°0ua vB yW}NnJvXnu°nb;nyK [
{Xz Ê»ÀÂÊN¹Ì˼½@ÁX¹[Æ@Ã^À¼KÊÍ 0n Îty;Nny|ts@KsbyvXxKv 7ya}naNzWJvB yazK@zKsvyK;xzKs@ns O@K[xnyn£Î
¢s@0u¨s uau°zKyWJJvyuw¢s@vXxKya}ns[xyty vsy[yzKa@zKJv @zKyts@Ktynbvs@t=s5@¤KzKvXxKv
ua x;v]ybb@Kyts@uªn@}Ks@tvs@0 y=s@\svXxKyt$nbya}KyauW@ ; s@K; ;tyKvy5®[vVvBxKyW[xnyndxKyats@Ksby
7s@nd vby }KyWy;KvXtyuWy @zKyts@K7zKsvXxzKabs@ndty[yz[vk vVts@u¨y[FynsNz°@[vsNuauazKy
ts@}nyuW=@zKaKv©v[¤zKvXxya}nsF;xKytya vby µ
­5u°n@\ cn[ vXnyK=@ Wvs´vXxKyWbs@zKqvX0KqvXnsNzWs5[xny «@zKJvkts@}KsvXnb=@zKayzKy[vB =yzzKyKy0zK5
§5xKyKOyvyK[xzKs@ sM y«@tyvsFs£Ks7y;vs }KyW;xnynyKa@zKJvkzvBxKyvXuWyt@uWyWsK z[vytyJvXÐ y;Fyza v
7ytyaKsb[}nyvs uanyuWyz;v]y[yzK[ yW[xnyn@vXxKyW; yWy;^yKqv=sKvBxKyVy[yns@uWyz[v 7s@ d}KyWvk yJv
«Nzyts@K=vXxKyvyK[xzs@ snyK=y@tyvBNzKvs tsvyKqv]@zKJvJ
§5xKyKOy°sb[} vXny«@tyW@[vXx«y vXxKyÎzyK[t@}nyWs@ÎzK[xny[@}nys@|}KsvXxNF§5xKyWs@z tyK@ qvXn
@ vy0zKvX y{]byyantyzK²Mn[xuWyz[vÓ@vs ua v y;Fy s@uWyz;v sKvBxKyvy[xzKs@nsnyKvXxKv @tyvss@zKyts@K
}[ ua vXzKas@Ît[ v s5by v@za¤zK«s ¤zKs$nyKyN
¶NyK{~¤zKs=V¤KzKs$nyyan«sFs>> vXxyOyK@t[xsN|zKyvB0[vXxK¯ yaxKya}KyKyzWbyKy¤KzKd¤KzKs yy
[zKbyW@zK; yz[vVvXuyKR 0 qvsvXnyWsNyzKy9x ky[v@x[F; O« vBxvBxKyW[uanyWJvvyuyz[vÓ uyza}[ zKvXty
yK;©yvs ¤zKs ί yaxKFyR>= }Kyts[¤=NKyazWs@\OsF; y;vt\nsNz°©yKyKas@zvXxKyNKyWs5s@Kyz
bbybvs z[sN³uvXns@zNz9tybsznyvXxKyats@} yuvXxKv @0nbyW$ vXxWvtvyua[vvs£tyKJvB0nJv FObyKO7vs@zK
y[yns@uWyz[v s ¤zKs$nyKyN@{Xzatybyz;v\vBuWy>yaxKFyWbs@uWyvs ty;FytyWb[nyz;vX n¤KzKs$nyy@
®[v yK; vyvXxKyWqvXts@zKdxnJvs@0nb@tybyyz[v\ 5s@KyzbOyKbvs@zKdzua vy°y[FynsNuyz[v s
¤KzKs yyaxKyzKby;¢s@vXxa;vK=NzW[nyK@V@zKy\s5y[vXzKJvB s@z@vXxKyzWbs@u°uWs@zWbyzbyWyuW@zKvXxKv y
tyKy;F@uazyWy[FyzvXxKybya}K[n\ns@zK@JxKy d}Kyny;¢K
{tv 7 ny[vb[xyW$xKs7@0zKyKdKÌ>vVvXxKyWyzKasKvBxKydvBxOyz[vXVzKsv]s@z WvXxKv ¥|s9n=yFd};v\vBxKv
@ vBx°zWb[nyzby$xn[xW^vyV@Ky;NnJvzKyz @} >b@zzsKv s7ya v=s@0nzvsONn[«s [vB vt@Ð~ v
uaKJvkxKFyWs@0nzKvyaÀ¡ÊËJ¿À ù¼½5vXxKyFqvVvXxKvVvXxKyWn[;vX vt@zKa@zKyts@K[zyKb=svXxKy¦n$;vsWvB0[vXx¦Ks
12 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
¦ vX³[vXxWv]@z[ 0 Oy¦ntsKyKvs£ v bs@zJv@z[vX k{©v~nvXxnvXxKy\@zKyvXxKv 7yazKs* WFOy vXxKy
bs@zKby²KyzKby«s5s@vX0[vBxµOyKy¤KzK5F§MxyvX0[vXxvXxKv O[ yzKbyWOyKy¤=b@zOyvNz }KyWbs@zK; yty°
@zKyts@K=[}KqvX vX[vys@\¥|s9 vk ¤y Wvs£ yvss@Vy[vXzKJvXns@zN
{t57yWbs@ atyy>=;KyK[ny>xKv]yW7@z[vy@$xKytyW7yW7ytyaxKyKy@>@z°x[@vXxKyzyW7s@n
uWN¤yWs@5[vXtyau°[xa yb=@zKyts@K vXxKyzWy°uanx[vkzytqv@zKa$xKv 7yWb@zW@zKa[xKs@n
tyzK²n[x@ÏvXxKyt$nby7yWb@zWyK[ uzKyW@zW@0utbyWy;Fy s@zKasFy\¥ avy[xzsNnsnyKÌ> v
n° vXxvXxKy ® dvy[xzsNnsnyKzvXxKyKvBxOyz[vB>F§5xnnKy0x@KvXxKyWtyvyKqv~0n[¤;Ns@\s@zKbyW;K[xW
tbya}KyzK\ v0¦n7y xNtvsyzKd vHF§Mx vXuWy7z¤yW0zvBxKy ~@zxKvtv@z tsb±0yKqvÎÎyW@tyz¦ v~zW
7@N[zKa@z°uanb@}nyyzKyuWvBxKv~nvXxtyvyzz°s@V[ N vXns@zÐ 7yW@tyW0 yzVzJvyF>\}[s@
xK@} vs@\yK[ty>s@VyKOsNzsNuan=JFqvyu>@zKas@Vbs@uaKy[vB vB yazKyKyvs ¤zKs
{~}y y;FyvBxKv]yW@$n[xWsN\bs@tbyWbs@nd}KyWy[vy0uazKyKd}[s@Vbs@ yJvX Fy@yKy[vXx O>@zK
uWsNt@nK>{t57yaxKa@zKyKduWs@tyWbs@nyKqvX FyW$nbs@u¨sFyvXxy°JvV¢yvBxKs@Kb@zKFy@tNvBxKyzWM @nsKy
vsWvBxn«yzKa7s@nd}KyauWsNtyatJvXnb@¡>@zKvXxKyazK[ty}nyaKs7yt«yW@tyWN}sN;v\vs z y[xW7s@n9zsKv
}KyazKyN³ bs´vXts@}zK5
Ï7zyW7s@nvBxz¤$7yauanx[vk}KyW0 Fyzvs[[xWn@ sMKya}[s@ÎzKqvXzKJvV¢s@Vby ©H©yKbyFvXns@zN
{XzK NnNn=[nyK@0 xKFyvBxn«yK[ty@Fy;v F=;KyK; y=sNÎ}KyxKNns@\OyKyuvs£}KyazKsvkzWs@¢sNX>{Xz
yK@zKa$ vXxvXxKyaz[nyK@5vBxtyKv³>7yWscvyzW[sN¤yWn[xKs@zKyJvX WvssNtby yK=@zKvsyF;xsvXxy@vXxKyty}[
tyKvB zK;tyK[zKvXxKya0n[¤K¯hxy[vXxyvXxn=7Ks@ vXnb@ usvX KvyK@s@Î}Kyb@KbyWyW[xKsbyazKsvVvs´vXxz¤
@xKyK@s@Î}Kyb@KbyWxKyzFOyKa$ vXxW[K;xMtFyvXxtyv=7yWJvyd0tvB s@zK@ sN;v]syK@{]s£zKsv
¤KzKs \};v~ v syKzKsvk}KsyW7yS
§5xKyazKyK [@zKs@t¦ }KsyK=s5yzy[vXnbÌ\zK@zKsvy[xzsNns>@zKdts@}KsvXnb=@tyWNuWsJv s@Kyz@Fy;v]yWbyKyu
xK@t Wvs xKyazKsvXnby5@{yK=b@z¦ vk}Kya;v~}F;¤WzW }sK@Ðkz¤yat@zu sN|[vsNzu@vXxKy;s@z¦ v
zKyKyvs }KyauazKy°@zKdty;zKyK>>@zKvXxKy;b@za}Kytyy bs@nyK5Ï7zbyvXxKy;@tyWsN;v0NvBxKy[@tyWs@[vH
xt[xtyuW@0¤y@VzWW@us@Kny[cv0JxK@zKyKabs@uauyz[v0@vXxKvVvXxKy uWy0 ONzaKys@ny@zvBxKy| yFyt
Hz[N³ @} s´vXxKya0nx[vVvXxzK>>^vyvXxKy; xKFyWy[@u°zKyay[FysvXxKy\@ vy0zKvX Fy@ k{XzvXx =bOy
xKs7y;Fy>7yauaKqv]JvkuWs@tyatyKO[nyz[vB >vssWvXxy°³ x;v\vBxzKasNz vknJvku }Kyvs nsFOyvXxKy
[xK@zKOyvss£ v v @
5#§MxsN©yK@Wb@ > µ¯£ys zKsvk0nyWs@zvBxKyat@tsÐk vk0 yKKs@zaK JÐ @zKvXxn =$xKv yau°KqvVnx[v0
zs@vXuWyN§5xy²MKyKqvXnsNzanVzKyKy@>¯hx [xanvs }y°uWJvy«¯hK7yW;N FyWs@vy[xzKs@nsnyK
¯ W
y @tya}KyzKdts@Ky y9z[vsWvXxnzKy Oyz[vB$ vXxazKs£nNzR\zKsbs@z[vXts@¡\zKs£}t@¤yKKyW7yW@tyK
s@zKyvssW@\sFzvXxKyaKvXxvsN vyVbs@tby ${]sNzR¦ vk}Kyny[yWbs\};v]yWN©yz¦ v\vBNzKFy;v0>@zKvXxya Jv
[xK@zKOyvsbbyv bs@z[vXts@R vXxKy¢@¡µbyaKs@z;v|#nt@n @ts[xzK5¯ yaxKFyWs@tJvkKy;vkts@}Ksv
«yK=bs@uauyt[n@ F@ @} yWyzKy;vXn«yzKzKyy0zKvyK;xzn²Ky>@zKas@|zK@zKsbb@nyvy[xzn²Ky=@ty
F@zK;z9t@n >¯hxnyvXxKyWy;Fy s@uWyz[v sKvBxKyKOyvyK[xzKs@ sM ytsbyKyvXxts@KMx£zua}KyVs
JvyKV vkn[z¦ v~zyKbybb@0 WvXxKyWbbyÎxK@KyzKy9zvXxKy k@zxKvtvNz tsO±µyJv @zKvXxKy§50z vtWvyJv| vXxKv
vXxKyanJv Jvyazats@z°´vyK;xzKs@nsFR n@tyW@zKdxK@t5§5xKya}tyK@¤bvBxts@Kxvs$ aby ©H©ynbvXns@z°z
ts@}KsvXnbyzy[vXn=yzKMzyKy³zK>>s@|zK@zKsvyK;xzKs@nsFRbs@n°OsNuWyW[yz \ty0n[zKvXxKyW[00nbyW7yy v
$xKyzW7yanyK@0zKy°svXxyW[nsNzz°s5 uW@uau@
K
z Fy;vÎ{k}Kyny;FyW7yWs£xKFyWJvXts@zKa@zKabs@ d}K[n¢s@|xKs@KyNÏ7\vtvyua[vvsyK@K vBxyK@Ks@zK
s ub=yJvX0JvXns@zazvXxKyanJv byz[vX tsNnyW;xzz°y;F@uanyWsK ©yz²n[xuWyz;v\s@Î7vs
bs@zK[nybÓ@vXxKyaznvyt@ ­ @}K@zKs@zuWyz[v0$ vXxKs@[vktybs@zK vXns@zKsvXxKyWy;Fy s@uWyz;v]s } s@nsnb@
7yNsNzK§5xntyzK² [xuyz[v Jvyuauyts@uwvXxyatyK@ vXns@zvBxKv $xny° v 7s@nv@¤yW@zWyzsN0uWs@K
y[c¢s@vVvs[tyKvyvBxKyKOyvy00}nyW7y@Ks@zK@vXxKy;´Os@ ts@uwvXxKyzWsNzWyF; }KyW OKvyKa@zK¢@z[vsWvBxKy
xK@zK=s tsKyazKvB s@zK=s@5vy0ts@0nJv ts@K
§5xKyW[nyK@Vbs@zK[K[ns@zW7vXxKv 7yW7s@na[tyvyW vXns@zK@[vXxtyvvss@tOy Fy}[ t[zvBxKyKOy
7yNsNz>@zKvXxKv yW7s@n9}yaus@tyWby[tya 57yWM dzKsvkt;KyvXxKyu ¯ yaxKFyWyua}KsnyKas@
tyzK²n[xuyz[v s }nsNnsnb@K@zKa[xKyua ON7yK@Ks@zzvXxKyd ® s@nsnb@K¯ yK@sNz s@z[Fyz[vXns@z
X®¯ Î@zKvXxKyd xKyuanb@K¯ y@Ks@zK5s@z[yz[vXns@z ¯ b [
5¢s@5vBxKyWbs@z[vBzz°; @}nyvXxtyv\ts@uªzK; y@\yK@Ks@zK$xn[xW7yaxKya yKa$ vXxazKs*¢s@|uWsNty
13 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
vXxK@z WFy@tNvBxKy ­9­Nyzvy¦ntybyz[vktyJ±0yKJvB s@zWsvXxKy 5s@uatyxKyz[ Fy§NyKqv~®@z§5tyKvt uW@¤y v [nyK@
tyzK²n[xz9zK[nyK@V7yK@Ks@zK=zKsvk}KyaKs@ vXnb@ yFq>M®[v 7yaxKFyW£zn²KyWs@Ks@vBz vt>$ vXx
vXxKyWyzKasKvBxKy 5s@na¯ @NvsKyv £u° vBKs@n@\@0uWtbyNM® Mz°s@zvXxKya®¯ h@zK ¯
tyzK²n[xuyz[vÌ>[KObyKOJK@}Ks@ vXns@zWs zK[nyK@V7yNsNz«Os@ dxKy°}nvs7@ta xN} v s
tyzK²n[xz°Nzyts@Kvy[xzsNnsnyK
t5qvXK@ \};´y[vtvBz90nas5@}[v=[ zK; y@\yK@Ks@zK
7s@0n$ny7ts@KMx vBxKyvsv@KyKJvB0KJvX yaKs7yVs5¯ s@0n°¯ @{0{]@zKabs@zK[ny©N} y[nyv[¤Î7y
bs@nayuazKvyvXx =y;KvXzKqvXnsNzvXxtyKvH 5y0 cNzKdtyzK²n[xuWyz[v $}KyW cn[ vkts@}nyu\}[vkzKsv Nzazbs@ @}nys@zyN¯ yW@tys@vXzKvyvs
xKFyW@tyKsNzy£nsKv s ty y;F@z[v 7s@0¤WzvXxKyWbs@z[vy[v]svXxya®¯ hNz°svBxKyvXtyKvB yKÏ7|uWb±0s@
v [¤$$}Kyvs@ WvXxnvsWvyK[xzKs@ sny7vBxKv NtyazKvBt@ uaK[xauWs@tyWbs@uauyt[n@[vXxK@zaua v@>
§5xKyW[}Kqv@z[vXn@zKyyKdxKytya sNvXt@zK;K@tyzKqF= cn[ vtsy0 nbvXns@za =tyJvX ts@Ks@vXns@zK@[vs
vXxKyW cn[ vts5nJvBzn[xzKdtyzK² ;xKyKts@u y vXuvyWJvB N vXnyKK
{\t@z¤K }Kyny;FyvXxKvVvXxyW[ vXKvXns@z°zd «;uanyvXxK@zvXxys@zKyWyazKs*¢byÓ§MxyazK[nyN
vy[xzKs@nsnyK=7ytyatyKbs@zK@} byK@t@}ny°z[vsbs@uauWyt[n@K@zKdua v@ Kby>@zKduWs@z vs@0zKa7
@ yKd}[WvXxKyazKvBtyWs5vs@u°nvyJv=@zKvXxKyWyFOyW$ vXxW$xn[xatnsJvX N vtbs@nd}KyauWyK[tyK5
NybyK@t[xWs@zaua v@@nbvXnsNz«OsN d}KyaysN0uWy°vkzKvXns@zK@n@}Ks@tvs@0nyK=[K[xW bs7 n@uWs
$ vXxvXxKyaty[ v¤y[v by[ty[v nsNz°Ksb[}ny@
§5xKyW¥ °vyK[xzKs@ sny«s zKsv NnyW[nyK@0 z[vsbs@u°uWyt[nNNz9ua vN byK;Ð FyzvXxyÎsKvyz[vB @
zvBxKyau@0¤y[v0V v0¦ xK@tvs uWzKyat;zKvXxKyu s@z zazKvXns@zK@n@}Ks@tKvs@0 yK¯h vBxvBxKy
$ny[tyFabs@uauWyt[n@t[ v0yz[s@t[zKdtyzK²n[xuWyz[v $tyK²tyW´Fy³ OvXnsNzatyuyW;ua @vs
vXxKvV¢s@|}ns@ snb@KyK@Ks@zKÌ\}[v s@zW@z°ztybyKyz[vyabb@nyN§5xnVzKy[@ vN} >t@nbyvyzK[ns@zK
}Ky[v7yyzWs@ÎzKM @ MK@0 FJ@zKay[ty¢s@|ts@0ny[vN z[s@0uvB s@z@zKvXxKyazKyyK¢s@Fy0 nbvXns@z
vs tsvyKqv~«@ ¯ yW$zs@}[vy yzKOsNz[vy\JvBts@zKdtyK[nJvNzbyvsWvBxnnsb=s 0 FJ@zK
tyyKs@u sK5JvB s@z@
5y0 cNzKvXxKyatyzK² ;xuWyz[v s5byv@z¥ avy[xzKs@nsnyK=$xKFyvssb[ÎzWJN}Kyt[KOy=7yK
v~x[F; ON;¢[ vB yK§5xKyW;0 vB O@nb[KyW}Kyvs uW@¤yvXxKyazyKbybb@WvXt@zK;K@tyzJbby[v@}nyazW
7s@0nasK tsN0ny[v@ z[sN0uWvXns@z\tyK[u@} }[ ©sK@nz9zyK*¢s@0uW=s tsvyJvXns@zs@Îz[vy yJvXN
ts@Kyvt>
5y0 cNzKabs@u°n@zKbyWK@nbs£tyK²tyvBxKv]O[nyz[vB qv=Nz°yzKzKyyt=s@[v JvBts@zK°OsyWs5y[vXx b@
bs@zKJv0VtyKbyu°}zKvXxy Ks[tvXn=sFvBx>@zKvXxKvVvXxy[ xKFyvBxKyWbs@tyvs$xnJvB y}ns
zKyKOyKbON >y;FyzvkxnxaKytbs@zK@KbsJvJ§5xn=7s@n°@zb7y5vXxyWb@R WFyK@t=^vy ts[xu 7}[
vXxKy 5s@}Kyn@tyKvy @zK®y[vXxKyR>s@zKyWsvXxyausJv byzns@\svXxy;N @z9uWyua}Kyt=svXxKy k@zxKvtv@z
tsO±µyKqv0NvBxKv NKO[nyz[vB Jv
µbybyW@zK°yK[nJvVts@u¨7s@0¤$[tyvXzK@>y[yns@z@\uatsNzK>>@zK
uWNz[¢JvB0zKdzK[nyNV7y@Ks@zK=Nz°svXxyV7yNsNz«s Ksvyz[vXn@uWb=yKqvX0KqvXnsNz@ {XzvXxKyJv
byz[vXNvXx ty²tyK@ n@zKbyW@zKdKytbs@zK@ty[Ks@zK[} v© }[WvXxKsbyWxKssN a7s@0¤$s@za}KsvXx ®
@zKa¥ avyK[xzs@ snyKvsFs@n9uanyuWyz;vXzKa7yK@Ks@zK=s uWb=yKJvB0KJvB s@zW@zKd¤KzKs yyRµyz@} y
uWFO«yKJvB0KJvXns@zN
§5xKs@tyK@W@ Osb@nvBxKv 7yW$}Ky J0 ;x°zats@Ks@vXns@zvsWvXxyazua}KyVsvXxzK«xn[xW7yWb@zW^sNtvs
ny[v @ s@zKy@ ί yWyK[xWbyy¤=vs£}KyaxK@[\};v~ v 7s@nabyKyu¨7s@vBxK$xnyvs²MKyKqvXnsNzWxKy[vXxyV7yazKyyKvs
v@¤yW;K[xW xnxa0n[¤$svsv@KyJvX³KJvXns@zvs@zFy;v~uWs@tya¤KzsFnyKyW@zKy[vkus@tyvBxzK[Ð OsNuauWs@z
byzKbyWbFvXxv\vBxKytyan= u° vVvss@|uWvy0n@zKyyKÎ@zKvXxKv byv@z°¤zKs$nyKyan7vsFs@zKyts@K
@zKd }KyJvV¢s@ts@zKy@
5y vXxyV[xKs@na7yat;KyazKyN|u°uWs@v@ vt$ vXxKs@[v OsNz[ny0zKvXxKyWOsFqv$ vXxKs@[v bs@zK; y0zKvXxKy
bs@uauyzK[©Kvyaz[tyKbyazvXxKya0n[¤$s5y;KvXzKJvB s@zN>{Xuaus@vN vt>$xnyaKy0xK@KvXxKyWs@0nzK@¡\n«Oyv@z
zKsvVvXxKyWs@z Ksb[}nya[vs@ @zWtyNu
{~tybyz[vX xKvXxKyWss¢s@vXzKyvs uWyKy;vVvXxKyWnJvBzn[xKy°@[vBxKs@\@zKab;xKs@ @¬Hb²MKyKvtvN¡>xKsby
}Kss@¤[À»ÊN¹ÌËÑ ¸N¼Á0À ¼ÊË ©È=ÀÂÇÂǹ[ÊÊÀÅ WÍ«zvBxKy zKn[xvXt@zK; vXns@z 7xKyKyKdzK[tyvXxy¬HFNz¬z
@ts[xvsWvBxKyWbs@uaz°yWs KyF[ yWbs@u°[vXzK@F©y[Nns@K[ yb[0}Ky9zvXxnuWFFzKyN>{Xz
xnzKyK }Kss@¤ Á0Æ@â¹[Á0ÊÀ ÃÌËHÍÎvtvNKyb[³}KyxKs)sN\©yK@u=s [vsN £xKFyW[xNzyKasFy5vBuWy5Ó
14 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
vVvXxyW$zWs5bs[ny[vXnyKÌ\uWyzWb*vXxKyÎKObyWs@z NvBxzKsvXxz9uWs@tyvXxK@zW n@}[N³z[vBxs Nz
v\vBxKyWyz°s5$x ;xqvss°ss@ÎnyKzK@@NnWvBxKyVyKvXxRNvs´vXxKyWbs@uaK@z[s5s=@zKvs Mâ¹[Á0ÊÀ Ã Ò ¯h vXxvXxKy 5y}tyK=NzvBxKyzvXxy¥tyy¤Ì>bs@uWyauWyzW@tyKtyKyvXxyuWby yKts@uwvBxKyKs@nsnb@Kyu@zK
@zKatyK@u¨s5@za yK@ v©$xKyty [À N¹;ÁJÃ Òa7s@ ns@0n[x@ÏvXxKy©\zKsvBzKvXxyWy[sN[vB s@zWsvXxKyauW@0¤y;v
bs[ny[v©\zKytJvssvXxKvVvXxKya}Kyv©sK5OsNuWyW7s@ ayz;v@;vXxKyW@ yzKvXns@zs5svXxyt@zKvXxKy;
bs@Kx;v
ÅÆÇ¡À Ã Ò ¬Hb²MKyKxKyyKduyazKytJv@zKdxKs*vXxKybyvXxtyKyW ^ytyz[vk[vs@n@zWs@ =y[@nJvkzvyzK[ns@zazWs@Vbs[ny[vt
vs> 5yWsyK=s@zvsyKb;0}y´¢s@vBx°;vs@n KÁ³ÆNù[Á0ÊÀÄà ÒÌÍ~xKsby¢s@zvXns@z°n=@ vB0n[u rK©Kvy0z vt
@ s@zKyWbOs[ vyKzK NnK@xNzKyKb= vBxvBxKyaxK@zKyb=sK5svBxKytÌ>^s@tzKvXxKyats@uanbyWs
by ©µ[Jv@zuWyz[vJ
§5xn«;FJvNnys@ÎuWyau ts@}nyu¨ vXxaty¡¦ =tyNu dvy[xzKs@nsnb@K@ts[xvs[vy0z vta
zKyK@|u°uWs@v@ vtWvXxts@KMx°ts@}KsvB O$7uW zKsvk}KyvXxKyauWsJv yK;©N} ya[vs@n@zKd vt[ vk}0zK
[nyK@V@zKytK
kN}yyW[xKs@ndty[vBxz¤$sNÎ;vs@nNzW[xsNnbyK
¯hxKytyWb@zya ss@¤=sNV zyK)y[vBx O@}K[nvsby;v s@\OsNtby {~xKy¢s@zKvXxy°nyzvXxKya}sFs@¤
Ã^¸ÀÉBË$½¢¼ÁÃ^¸N¹Î¹ È=ÀÂÇÂǹ;ÊÊÀÅ WÍ };vBxKy VNn@ b@uWNvs£}KyFy xKy[ 5ny0xK@K=7y¤KzKsz°}[v
v©vXny°xyKyyK@@vXxKy V@ @ ONuW@tMKyKvXxKvVvXxyausJvkuaKs@v@z[vVvXxzKdn¢s@Î7vsbs@zKMKJv s@Î Fy=$ vXx
nsKyW@zKabs@u°FO[nsNzsNVsvXxKytNzvBxKv]s@\bs[ny;vXnyKzKyKyvsy;FynsNWqvXts@zKyÎzsKvB s@zWs
z Fytb@ty[Ks@zK;} vt@zKasK5s@Îz[vytyyzKyzKqNÐkxKyats@KsOyK=JvNz@t°s sF; vB yWy[vXx ON
bs@zKJvV¢s@|zKM @nK@n«@zKabs[ny;vXnyKvXxKv byyuW=bs@zKbs@zK@z[v $ vXxvtv@¡¦ rK©Kvy0z vt ;vs@n>
§5xKy \@n@ b@uWWvXxKy\@tyKvXxKv 7yauaKJvkzytqv@zKa$xKvk v~nvXxKvkuW@¤yKKys@nyaxK@[>@zK
[¤KzsF yyvBxKyWJvXts@zKay;NnyzbyvXxKvkzKy vBxKy|uWKvy0n@tstybzKs@5vBxKyat; v]svBxKyaKs7y\s
¤KzKs yyanvXxKya¤y[a vXxKvVvXxytyW@tyaua vvsxKv b[nyzbyW@zKvBxKyWb[nyz[vX nt; v]@ns@zKyWb@zWs
Ï7\¯ yJvy0zazKsvXnsNzWs xK@zKyb=byyuW7vsbs@uWyts@uwvBxKyW¥tyKy¤$xKsy[zyKd v vBxKyWy[yt[nbyWs
N v@sFyt=@nsNz9zKyK=s5y[bynyzbyaz£ yWKc¢s@tzKvXxyu¨Obs@KyN nyK@0 7yazKyyKvs´zKduy@zzKK[xNnyzKyK=@zKa[[cn[nyz[v Obs@Kyazs@| yK 57yW@tyvs }yaxK@[
zxKvy[y|n7vsbs@uWyNM®[v|{~}Ky y;FyW7yauaKqv\zKaN vy0zKvX FyWs@[vB y;v¢s@Vs@\;tyKvX Fys@tby\}Ky;Fs@zK
vXxKyW; vBtyWs Ky³Ky[vBK@KyKbs@zsNuan=tskvXxÐVvXxn=tskvXxaxKnNty }KyKyzW }nyKO[zKs@\Oy[yt@
xzKMtyKFy@t\}[vk vkxKzKsvk}ts@Kx;v~zK@nsFy9x@zKyKO>@zKa7yauaKqv~zsF);xKssFOya}Ky[v7yKyz
vXxKyat[ v s ztyJvX0nJvyaNz9zKtyKqvyKatskvBxvXxts@KxWb; yzKbyW@zKvy[xzKs@ns@zKvXxKyW[nyN
bbs@uaK@z[NzKa@zKytK
{tvk zKs uWs@tyvXxK@zWWFy@\;zbyauWtJv yzKOsNz[vy\ vBx°@ MtyK@zK¬Hs@xz­NyN³ y@@{ byKyW@ts@z
uWyO@Kby¢s@|xKs@KyazvXxKyFs@nby7s@\ON;vXnsNzW@zKdtyzK² ;xuWyz[v @zKdzvXxsbyaKyKs@ny{kxKFy
nbbsytyKaxKs@tyW=bs@zKby0zKyKa{]@u¨@}Ks@[v s@V[0tyz[vktynb@uyz[vH>{\yKyÂ@vss>yKyKyzKy
byzKbyWs KytOs@zK@tyK;Ks@zK[} v©°7zsKvVs@5vXxyW7s@0¤{~xKyW@tys@zKyR\}[vVs@5vXxyW7s@0¤=vXxKv|{ku°nx[v
Fy;v]s>vVvXxKyWbs@z[KyzKOyWsKvBxKyWb[nyzKbyK
®[vkuWNz;sKvBxKy|KysN yWxKs ¤zKs)N}sN;v\vBxKyW@zKyt=JvXKbyyu¨JvBt@zKy [nyz;vH¯hxyzatyKObyK>NvXxy[
Xv tsv s@[vVvXxKy vXxn zKsvXxz9zKy 70KsJvyÎF 57@tyzyKb=s5$xKv bs@ndxK@Kyza ty[Ks@zKbyWyzKs@KxN
§5xKy[WvyuWy§5xytyW@tyaz Fyt[ vXnyKnyKa$ vXxa}nsy[vBx ; qv=$xKsJvXKRWvXxn=JvX[c5@ s@zK§5xKy[
b@ ;vXxnxK}yKyz0 v©vyzW@}Ks@[vk}Ky;¢s@tyR>@zKd}[y[@Ky vK§5xy[bs@uanNz¶NsN\sN³0 y=Nzs@
@tuWyz;v=NtyW@tyKR´s@ndxKvH
{]sNzR¦ vk¤KzKs)xKytyvXxyKbyayKs@nyaxnyvXxKyyK@X5=@zWN©[x vyKqv]s5OsNuany;´qFJvyuW{]yz[vy5vXx
@tyzK«yzyt@ qvH®[v ;xKs@ vBx =uazn[xaubs@zKOy0zK ${]@u F@tyWsK xsF uaK;x°xK}Kyyz
$0 vtvyzW@}Ks@[v0@v@¤yKa@}Ks@[v0@zKd yJvX©yKaN}s@[v bs@[vXxs@0 vKvB y >M®[v syKvXx uWyK@za v~xF
tyK[xyKdKyKs@ny \sy7vBxnuWyNzW7yWO@znbOs@z[vVvXxKyW@zKyt}Ky;¢s@tyaK
zKs$zKdnzsKv £tKvB s@zNnysN|zKsv JvXzK5 5@zW7yWs@}[vVvBxKv~¤zKs$nyKyaxK}KyKOsNuWyWyK@Ks@zW7y
$nyna@zJv sNtby yK
§5xKyWy[@Ky0nyzKbyK=svXxyWKvsNuan=b[nyz;vXnJv=[nyK@0 [xKs*vXxy°zyKyvsWv@¤yaytbs@zK@tyK[Ks@z[} vtNvXxy
15 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
@zKy5vBxKv\vBxzK=$uWsKyvssWJv0NzvBxKyW7 zxn[xW tsbyb=b@zv@¤yWs@zW yWs v=sFzN
¯ yWb@zFvXxy[n@[tyKvy°zK;0uWsNz[v@}nyats@}nyuWz@uWsFqvkzKsWvXuWynvH¯£yau°Kqv s uWs@ty
vXxz¤z9ts@z[vk 5yW@tyazKsv\vs }KyW[ua @0 [00nbyKa@zKa[xKs[¤yKd}[WvXxyOs@zKbyK²MKyzbyK=s5s@
z[Fyz[vXns@zKK
|bs@z[vXzzKdtsyKb; s@zK@Ks@0¤W =s@zauats@zvBxKyatynN} vts5bscv7@ty@@­Ns^v7@tya =´vss@ÂNz°
vss@}ny{ku°Kqv JvX0Kny vXxvXxKyaKbyvsxn[xvXxKyvss@n${kuW@¤yW@tya[vJ@{kxKFyW@n7F}Kyny[yK
W
vXxKvkuWN¤zKabs^v@tyaus@tyatyn@}ny Fyz° vuW@z[ Kby>uW@¤yvBxKyW7s@0nab¢y\@z9}Ky;vtvy
nbyÐk V{ 7ytyvsbs@uWyvs }y y;FyvBxKyWs@Ks[ vyRNvXxKyz{]sN d}KyauWs@t@ s@}nvyKvsJvs@vXxn=7s@0¤F
{]ONzazKs uWFMzy;K[xWK uWbs@uWyN
§5xn«@nyKyKuyazsKv @zKM }[v v~nyFqv]£} v~uWy @zK;xKs@nK 5yzby[s@vXx@¢s@|uyR\ts©yKb=$}Ky
bs@uWyK$xKvk} vtvytO7yKy;vH
\s´Fs@atyuWyua}Ky5vBxKya}KyK@;vX yz vBuWvyWbOyzKyaz ~@zxKv©v@zW$xKytyW¯ ssFRW nyzan @zKasNzaxn
bs@K[xW@zKv@¤KzKdz[vs´v@KyatyKOs@ty 5ya =0 vBz°[xKs@v Jvs@@}Ks@[vkKys@ yWxKs@tyW[©yKvXzK
zzKybybb@VzKytsvXnts@} yuW7s@5vBxKyuWby yKÌ\}Kyb@Kbya vk¤yKyKvXxKyuwtsNu yK@zKa$ vXxaus@ty
zKOsN F@} yRNvy00 ^@z9tsN} yuW«@}Ks@[vVvXxyaz FytbyN
5yanyKxuWby vs´vXxKyW²yKJvXns@z µ¯hx[ n yW7s@vXxa @zK Î@zKvsbs@zK; yV$xKvkuWN¤yK v
7s@vXx$xny¢s@ÎxuhÓ¥ts@K[xKs~@>¯hny kF@vXxKyWbybs@zKduWsKyuWyz[v sKvBxKy¬ vy­NuaxKs@z[
bs@n7 0uWJvBts@zK@¦ tybs@tzKas [svv
s yKd®yK k­N7yn[xauWsK@nyKVrKn@}Kyv0¦ ­Nyz;vXuyz[v@
KKOvXnsNzR k@0 s@za®t@zKsVrKt@z¤­5zKvXtNvBxKyW@nyK=@zKdKyK@t}[ K@zzKyRNvXxKyW;t@}K=Kv|­N@u¨¯ s¦ Ì
@zK@NzK@ NvXxy;xKs7Jvs@KybÓVx nsFy§5tJ¦ ¢by@
K[xWs KxK«s@Îty[ns@KvXxzKÌ>@zKa«yWb@ty¢s@vXxKyu¨7yansbvyvXxKyWybbyzKbyWs5s@|xuW@z vt>
X{ zvXxKyWyz@\ vkn}yKb@KOys5s@Vtyv]ONF; v©W¢s@Vb@0zvBxKv|{~tyu@zWsN;vXu°nJvB =yKOs@z[ts@z[vVvBxKy
@zKyts@K O[KyzKs }Ky;¢s@tyaK
|
uauWyKnvyaxKs@Kyanvs N vXn[Kvyaz£u°[xa @ty\M O[Kb; s@zWsvXxKyanb[yKt@ OyKdxKy©y> vBx
KyKs@ yts@uªuWNz; c¢ytyz;v~}F;¤ts@zKVzWby;vtvXzKzKsvktyn[KsbyvsWyK@\s@¢sNvy[xzKs@nsWsN
v=sFzO@¤yN
5=Jv@v³5{kxKFyv Oyat@ OyKdu@z[svBxKyKbyanb;KyK=v y[yz[v=[s@zKbs@tyKd}[WvBxKy5[Kyz{XzJvX vX[vyWNz
xKFyWbyK@tvy ©sNsFOyKvXxKvVvXxy uWy0 ONz5byusK v=Nz ­N; yzKby7v@¤yvXxKyuªW=@z
y[vyz[nsNzWs v=7s@0¤$$ vXxvXxy F7[x 5s@z[ytyzKbyK
§5xKyKOyaxKFya}KyyzaxKy a[zKbyd WvsM O[Kb
@0u=bs@z;vXts@ÂyK;KyK[n@ s z[nyK@\yK@Ks@zKÌ>@zKvsWs@0ua vyW7s@0¤@}nyaKs@ ; yK
{tv0¦nz;¢s@vXzKvyvXxKvVvXxy 7[xauWyKy;vXzK=Jv@vyasNz yK^vyvXxKyaz[nyK@\yznyW7=s@[v svXxKy
}KsvtvXny7ts@Kx h
yK@tvss nvy@¯ yW@tyW@ Osy;vtvXzKa }KynKvyKaJv@v s@zWby0ns@K[ tyb[zKvXxy
nb[Ky«@ts@z Jv00byz[vXWvyK[xzs@ snyK vXxyaty[yz[vB s@zWs ¤KzsF yyRµyzK@}nyKduWFO«yKJvB0KJvXns@z
@zKvBxKyVy byyuWzKbby[v@}ny@
­Nsa{0¦u¨JvXKby@t[xzKÐVvXxytyW@tyauW@z[ us@tyvBxzKvs nyK@0z@¯hxKy;vXxKy\yWN©yvs[bbyyKas@5N¡Nvs
[@ FyWs@5@;NnJvXuwvsWvXxKybyvy[xzKs@nsnyKVnzsKvVy[v yK; yK5>{0¦uª°nvyW@z7 v0¦n«@uWsJv ´@u
{0¦uwvBNzKvs£uWzKyWbs@uWya}Ky[v©vyV@zKbyt@vs }tyK@¤=vXxKyW;KyK@zK©yKyvXxKyuwtsNu vXxKyWJvs@zKyN
!"# %$&'()*+),.- / 102, 3' 3 465%, $7!89)1 *.:13; .<#="4 ,>!? +)9@, <A<).9
3+B>C4DFE6D4GIHHp J8KLBHlNMODP,<QB>C4DSR#T>PUClNVW4Xcp>VZYp.PX2!"[>!&!"4'Z>!A!" 38 ,L *4'Z , $!88@!"[,[, <]\]^A)F1 !_
`a b) < c64 8,>!"4894# [4 < 3!2!? a<*. . 4,d
e ^7!AffF!"* U$7@!? , .>\[ +[+; <L3[) b) , Q ,:!8F!"48g48 .' 94, <h$i4a U!_ +L-, j Ff# + ,
,>+ +\)k,:!_ [>!_6,<94!8[>+[+;1' >!6!"4:!? - ,]\F4 [[*.,*F!?>!64'4, Ff; <L<[!_ !?*l!6,<Z>!6 ;,*.43 4!A!_4!_?mA,<[!?>!n f>o;*!? +[1>!p 4, <]\@ [..*!?/ #3;>!_6<L !?9,<L !p,
3 4 N\
e ^@ <L>b;F!"4 <h!?'(,>!A!8 ;3 .4\]^8/ 'q) <[!_>+Z<) <,;/ !6.-['[)\]^a>\ e
16 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
J8T)GNlNVWBliD JXlXlNVWOX7C)DVT[p>M)D>J> .9@d "!"#]\$
%
c68>!&!?9 &" )\7B>C)D('Kp>MlNV;W YbmNTW;D@E6DGNmnj()MOD J"WlNVW l PD>T>PD.P lNVZT R|p>Jm+*,-;Xp"Ki]TbmNTV.D/4, ,9 01 d1243654!9
]9 )9 4\
1781 17 125!
g^ *:a. '>bZ<*.8 3 <[1>!n3 * 'F!_ '[!A$7'4 b) >I>$@>!_; *8 %$7 3>!p3>b) , ; #3 4-;<>=p?ÌpX ,
)9@ ,Z n@;&>f $A@443 !? *d \B: 3>!n'>+L,>!p ,l=_[ ;', 3 4 ,94894!_;4 Z , *!? ,94 >I ;'[,
3 4 ,[!8[*'F!8 48'O\2!4\B: 3>!n'Z!63>+[!?[<f) b;, !n3+L;'[,Z3 , .9>o;* !21[.*.< <
*,>$ *!A1 !?F!?
> !-&>:2\ C)B\ : 3>!p'Z!p>!8*!p !"f>#,>o) !8, * 9# ,Z *. ;>!8*!_ ,[<;#, !6*,>$& *!A1 !?
!?
> !647D]*,E
< &>:\
9
05#
5 *. 4, F1>!8[[,, >!2!?>!p3 ,d
F
ENp>V C;TkmG0pXXÄlNM«pFTJ?XÄl P>X7T[Tbm+.HVI.0p VJ.DXXcp
')A
C GHVZMZTJ8«
M p#HP pJmÂp|lNV[LP KF[V p>E
V .lNJ .0p>VLP .JlUT
'KpJmL
P p#HP pD J .C lÂpMD#HP pqmÂpF
T N4DJmnmÂpFTJ8J lUT
UT[M TI
V .C)(
D B4l+*bl LP .DFOT mnmOGµlNV4X&JD mnm DcX p
)!8,F!?,. !"!_; fd
D
BC)DP)D.PXp?]TJ?XÄl P>X P1C;TX7C VÌp[XgCÌpBWC4X2X^p#PUC[pG
G6C l+.COXgC4DFtJ pWC[PcX p>V)Î
D lN
V l X PfLP QD RJ m+p PP.C4DJmnm
*pX7C Ì
V pRX lNJV .m+*D M^X pPJ?D>TKZXgC4DFM TSJ m D#TP Q@JD mnm
l P1bT mnm4XgC4DFCT
V *ZXgC;TX]PD>J DP#XgC)P
D ;J8bT lNE
V .TI
V *p
e U F#,>!A48- ,[$&'( f<>1 ,;fA*. +L'< >m@!?>+L<Z4 34,Z!6 >+]\ U D)!8,[<; *.8 3!? ;*d f*4ib ,[$&' !_ '# ,Z #'Z , <]\ U +;f,<L,<;#-,> # 4[>b;7+L ,9*.7b;9@' 1' ! '9,<
>!A# !6<;4!_Z ,:!_ 7!6 $!_ [!8,F!"[*. !"F!? >j >$8\ e
B>C4D/V2W[p>Vj[TVJ* X7C)DP)J._P>X7T>PXj `A;3 <; +)9 0W )dXW9 H11@\$
!-U. ! [],>$i4, * [,\4, >!8*., +L ,kp*!83 ]49F!"4 -1!_ !_ < e @ >>!?[>$ []'Z>!">!_ 4,4\ e ;3 .<
,([@,< 9 ^\[A\),<(_'`&>1 .9< !8>\iEATV[pXDB.C;V[pJmÂp>WjX =@D.PD>TJ.CZTV*[Y;D J&PTQDB.X lDPLn5f^ a.9 0!@d !W4]\D
%F\N$i4. >! \ 4gb0[],>$i4, *Sb>5/\)X# 6b?\@, 2\ >!_'Z \
YZ
c ^", ; (0WCZ,>b; 'T;T
X G Pd')J8T4*Om DH<fi!7ea,,!p ') , <Z[g +3"3_ -[**. <,!21[F$i48'q>$A *[* <L *J3?, ,9
1 *. 3 *'4 <Z>! 'Z*.Z 4!8'Z>!_g49)$!?[*4, >\
f 4>$ $'[,9D!?7!\ e D $g3? *>!_ ,@d h>b;,>>!? <;1`A ^7! \ e \@>!?9 C]!9:6)! ]9 0WAd1W\
D %:\ ,!8>$7)\ <)H
bU$& b" H b>-4$ $&',HbU4-3?>!? <;>\ !_'Z \
i h; 9 _ ,)\iB>C)D OT jjV7XD>JB>J¢lNVl X j2[o02=Fp"4D>J?X, Q4Q@D>VC4DqlNMOD>J TV*LB>C4D/V X^p>Ml+.5ip>M >b;4 3 [>!
%:\ >+)'Z <<) *!\ *' $\
k f!_ '[>!8 # , &l / #3-)BC)P
D );V *7p"XgC4DS|
R p>J m+*2 BC)P
D .l D JV .DFTJV *l)4XgC l+._Î
P p?2m MZT
V )Ln]X lNV .X lÂp>?V < # 4g ,>!"
!?>!A!_ ;33 !&+Z>$@>o!_ ,*!? ,Z f.;3!8,>!? +L 46 $f[**>!-^4, <,o[]7!88/ #`A' <;>+P: )'4,!_9)1 *. .9
3;8 >$& +94!_>! e f[)>!A!8 >b[' *!",*F!8 3 b;F!?>!2[Fb;4i+Z o;*>!? , +Z4" +)9)$7 ,!"4, * ,:!_ 8 ! #p\ #4# F*,>!?9'[,Z ;'[,%# F# >b6>b b;<]\ f <L3['[ ,F$i4!_; ,- ,[!_>!
;'4,;- ,<[# , !6.7b) bF$i '4,+L'[[*,>!?8 .9 >!64 ,[* , F!_ >o+]J\ []7!88/ f<' <;>+Z4)',>!
<;.,/ !6,>!8[,>+L8 .-:!_ '[>!8 =?!p3>+L !8 $"\]^7!p f,4g',>!A$7 J?D Xl XP lNVW !_ [!? '>!81 *:[,>!8F1,
[*,. <;4b;48 # . 3 [<;,>\ -e @)>!? <;9 4W2d >9 C9 H125)\ $
qZ[@ 48-9:67!_;A[A\ e . <,>!".9 h>o)7!".9,<P:A!"4 <>\ e .l D>V.DH<r_, 59 4]\2@)8 ,>!"< e D]*. ,*[,<D]*. >!+ e
, s2J?DDÄX lNV;WTP <-')TSJ [p>2V t^i]T>PD *#iKl Q@D *>P u 'KpJmnm D . XD *l)PPUOT j>TP <-vw?xyXtSvwwz4D! \]5%7!? ,;/ {.9 42d 54!W]\
@o:6,<)9#`A>b) <EU8!6 ;!"# ,Z # 4 e @4 >!_ ,E\@, !"*;, +O`A>b 4;'[,!_9 e >b 3 >! %:\N$7. )>!\ 0 b"\,@)>0b b?U8l!|4]]\ !_'Z 9 e ^7$ < !?8 *!p 3 !+Zf,[ !88,>!? b;F!8 ) >!? , !Af <L3
' . 3 F$7A,>+Z<; b; !8 ,>!88, 4 F!?[*!6 $!_ 8 .- <!?8*!_ ,[>$!_Z3 . J $?9F!? !? * +[!?
*!_ b) !+Z $<>b; ,L,,>!8*., 4 +Z. <L,>b63 , <7!8-,)\ e U8!_/ f, +;. 1 >b# # !_, +Z>b;48,;'[,!
; >!_ ,F!" >!"*!p`3p,>!6[*4':$77!? ,[!?!\
% 5n 4,;9@5%>!&!?>F\ e 3 4'q>$A^] 4 *L}L,>\ e ,!8>!_ ,F!"F!_ ~ 9] 0]!_oD)!8>!8<L5%>!_ , >$!_ :6'[8 *4,`:a*<;4':+Z>$:67!"f,
< D]*. 4, *.9_ , 47
+ "C9 04]\ 'Z ,7b;)\ 4'*<]\ bU4g*. b;H b>3 >!_ ?, 1\ >!_' $
9 `a>!&+)9 N\ e U>!!8,Z5%,*ad \A*. 47}L4 ,/D)!8*.- /D)!_ @),>!A!?^ ;!@>!2!"
[@ b) >!? ,)\ e EAT;g
X J?8D <>1#!;9@`A*' 3 A 9 042d 5]C)\
BFD[ U ,{^4 !?/ ( >!&!"4!8. <;4,! [a ,>!",9>! %%F\N$7>\ b>3>!?*.?\ >!_' \
17 of 18
1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html
Y U 'Z !8,9 h < !_)\7BC)D(s2J?DD>K R#Tbj4A} \} \2\47!",a[])\ 9 0B12!d C5)\
ÀÂÇÂÇ[¼;ÒÌÍÎÉO¼½¢¼ÅÊNѹ[Á|ÆFÊ@Ñ @¸À¹;½¾5ÉJÀ¹;ÊÃ^À ËKÃ5¼K½¾5ÅRÊ°È=ÀÉqÁX¼;ËbÒKËâ¹ ËHÍ ÆËÉb¼ÉJ¸ÆÀÂÁk¼½VÃ^¸N¹=¿ÁB¹ËÀѹ[ÊÃcÀÂÆÇ
Éb¼ °À ËbËÀ¼KÊ ¼ÊdÃ^¸N¹½Å@âÅÁX¹W¼½b·$ÁX¹ÌË̹[ÆÁXÉq¸KÍ ÆÊNÑÀnËÉb¼ÆÅ@Ã^¸@¼KÁk¼½§5xKy¬Hb@zKKy­5yK[ OKvB s@zN ÀnË
μÁ ¼ÊdÃ^¸N¹ ÀÂÊÀ[¿5¹;Á bÆËÀ ¹WÉb¼ W¿5Å@ÃcÀÂÊ» ùKÉJ¸ÊN¼Ç¼»Ò ÆË$½¢¹;ÆNÃÅÁX¹KÑÀ¡Ê>¯htyK Valentine Robotics, Inc.
Automation Training and
Support Services
www.valentinerobotics.com
Robots and Robot Kits
Huge Selection of Projects and
Kits Cool Robots and Kits, Great
Prices!
3d Robotics Simulator
Realtime, physics simulation
of robots and microcontrollers.
www.eyewyre.com
www.robotbooks.com/hobby-robots.htm
>+)8 )>!
4C3!"##C
>+)8 )>!
4B123!"##Co}
[
[
18 of 18
New Book on Searle's Work
Conversations with John
Searle A discussion of his life
and ideas
www.librosenred.com/conv.htm
1@ ([],< \!-3 *>!? ,#^8, *>\B: 8 )>!"#47b;<]\
<L`6 !8 9@^8,*>\B:6 8 >!"#7b<\
1/19/2004 4:24 PM