TWENTIETH-CENTURY AMERICA A Social and Political History SECOND EDITION CHAPTER 1 The American Journey in 1900 Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Intro to the Course • • • • • About Me Syllabus Expectations Presentations Mondays – Review Previous Week/ Questions Student Presentation Lecture • Thursdays Finish Lecture Discussion/ Partner work Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Photographer Lewis Hine’s portrait of a young Jewish woman arriving from Russia at Ellis Island, 1905. Like hundreds of thousands of other immigrants who passed through the portals of New York harbor, this young woman’s expression carries the hope, fear, and remembrance that touched her fellow wanderers as they embarked on their new life in America. Courtesy: George Eastman House. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Introduction Russian Jewish teenager Mary Antin reached Boston with her family in the mid-1890s. By 1900, the United States had been transformed by large-scale immigration and rapid industrialization. Great cities were home to 40 percent of the nation’s population. Mary’s memoirs capture the mix of anxieties and exhilaration felt by many immigrants, though she was luckier than many with her professional success. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger CHRONOLOGY Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger American Federation of Labor • • • The A.F. of L. was a loose grouping of smaller craft unions, such as the masons' union, the hatmakers' union or Gompers's own cigarmakers' union. Every member of the A.F. of L. was therefore a skilled worker. Unions were growing in size and status. There were over 20,000 strikes in America in the last two decades of the 19th century. Workers lost about half, but in many cases their demands were completely or partially met. The A.F. of L. served as the preeminent national labor organization until the Great Depression when unskilled workers finally came together. Smart leadership, patience, and realistic goals made life better for the hundreds of thousands of working Americans it served. https://www.ushistory.org/us/37d.asp Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Dawes Act • • • The Dawes Act (sometimes called the Dawes Severalty Act or General Allotment Act), passed in 1887 under President Grover Cleveland, allowed the federal government to break up tribal lands. The federal government aimed to assimilate Native Americans into mainstream US society by encouraging them towards farming and agriculture, which meant dividing tribal lands into individual plots. Only the Native Americans who accepted the division of tribal lands were allowed to become US citizens. This ended in the government stripping over 90 million acres of tribal land from Native Americans, then selling that land to https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/dawes-act.htm How do you think this impacted Native Americans? Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Interstate Commerce Act • • On February 4, 1887, both the Senate and House passed the Interstate Commerce Act, which applied the Constitution’s “Commerce Clause”—granting Congress the power “to Regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States”—to regulating railroad rates. Small businesses and farmers were protesting that the railroads charged them higher rates than larger corporations, and that the railroads were also setting higher rates for short hauls than for long-distance hauls. Although the railroads claimed economic justification for policies that favored big businesses, small shippers insisted that the railroads were gouging them. It took years for Congress to respond to these protests, due to members’ reluctance to have the government interfere in any way with corporate policies. In 1874 legislation was introduced calling for a federal railroad commission. The bill passed the House, but not the Senate. When Congress failed to act, some states adopted their own railroad regulations. Those laws were struck down in 1886, when the Supreme Court ruled in Wabash v. Illinois that the state of Illinois could not restrict the rates that the Wabash Railroad was charging because its freight traffic moved between the states, and only the federal government could regulate interstate commerce. Continued public anger over unfair railroad rates prompted Illinois senator Shelby M. Cullom to hold the hearings that led to the enactment of the Interstate Commerce Act. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Interstate Commerce Act • • • That law limited railroads to rates that were “reasonable and just,” forbade rebates to high-volume users, and made it illegal to charge higher rates for shorter hauls. To hear evidence and render decisions on individual cases, the act created the Interstate Commerce Commission. This was the first federal independent regulatory commission, and it served as a model for others that would follow, from the Federal Trade Commission to the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Evolving technology eventually made the purpose of the ICC obsolete, and in 1995 Congress abolished the commission, transferring its remaining functions to the Surface Transportation Board. But while the ICC has come and gone, its creation marked a significant turning point in federal policy. Before 1887, Congress had applied the Commerce Clause only on a limited basis, usually to remove barriers that the states tried to impose on interstate trade. The Interstate Commerce Act showed that Congress could apply the Commerce Clause more expansively to national issues if they involved commerce across state lines. After 1887, the national economy grew much more integrated, making almost all commerce interstate and international. The nation rather than the Constitution had changed. That development turned the Commerce Clause into a powerful legislative tool for addressing national problems. https://www.senate.gov/artandhistory/history/minute/Interstate_Commerce_Act_Is_P Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger assed.htm Sherman Antitrust Act • • • • • • The Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 was the first measure passed by the U.S. Congress to prohibit trusts. A trust was an arrangement by which stockholders in several companies transferred their shares to a single set of trustees. In exchange, the stockholders received a certificate entitling them to a specified share of the consolidated earnings of the jointly managed companies. The trusts came to dominate a number of major industries, destroying competition. For example, on January 2, 1882, the Standard Oil Trust was formed. Attorney Samuel Dodd of Standard Oil first had the idea of a trust. A board of trustees was set up, and all the Standard properties were placed in its hands. Every stockholder received 20 trust certificates for each share of Standard Oil stock. All the profits of the component companies were sent to the nine trustees, who determined the dividends. The nine trustees elected the directors and officers of all the component companies. This allowed the Standard Oil to function as a monopoly since the nine trustees ran all the component companies. The Sherman Act authorized the Federal Government to institute proceedings against trusts in order to dissolve them. Any combination “in the form of trust or otherwise that was in restraint of trade or commerce among the several states, or with foreign nations” was declared illegal. The Sherman Act was designed to restore competition but was loosely worded and failed to define such critical terms as “trust,” “combination,” “conspiracy,” and “monopoly.” Five years later, the Supreme Court dismantled the Sherman Act in United States v. E. C. Knight Company (1895). The Court ruled that the American Sugar Refining Company, one of the other defendants in the case, had not violated the law even though the company controlled about 98 percent of all sugar refining in the United States. The Court opinion reasoned that the company’s control of manufacture did not constitute a control of trade. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Antitrust Laws • Play Video https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a /antitrust.asp • Can you think of any modern examples of the government regulating companies in this way or companies violating antitrust laws? Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Industry Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Industry The United States of 1870 was an agricultural nation of farmers, merchants, and artisans. By 1900, it was an industrial nation, producing more than one-third of the world’s manufactured goods. How has the U.S. Changed in terms of industry? Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Industry • Discuss: Patents Immigration U.S. as innovator Examples: - Pepsi - Microsoft (recent years & Canada) Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Industry (cont’d) • Inventing Technology: the Electric Age by 1900 electric power transformed: - manufacturing • factory location - labor • machines replaced workers - city life • electric lights, appliances, electric trolleys, movies Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Thomas Edison, The Success of the Electric Light (1880) Electricity conquered space and the night. the yellow glow of incandescent bulbs, the whiz of trolleys, and the rumble of elevated railways energize the Bowery, an emerging entertainment district in lower Manhattan at the end of the nineteenth century. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Industry (cont’d) • Inventing Technology: the Electric Age technological innovation: not just borrowing - research and development laboratories • Innovations in Corporate Management entrepreneurs consolidated for efficiency - Rockefeller, Carnegie Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Corporation and Its Impact • Rockefeller & Carnegie – “consolidating operations and gobbling up smaller competitors” – p. 5 Modern example – Facebook and Google Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Industry (cont’d) • Changing Nature of Work corporate control of work conditions - deskilling unions: AFL, ARU • Rural Americans Interdependent with Cities migration Populism Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Industry (cont’d) • Government Responds regulation - Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) more on state than federal level; regional differences ideal of opportunity [“opportunity” = economic prosperity] • Do you think there are any areas the government should regulate more now? Discuss Elon Musk and Charging Stations recent comment 12/2021 Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Immigrants Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Immigrants Between 1880 and World War I, most immigrants were young men who planned to earn money and return to the Old World; about half of them did. Jews generally moved permanently, as families. Large urban factories attracted many workers. Female migration and chain migration increased by 1900. Mexicans and Japanese migrants often worked in agriculture. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Map 1–1 Patterns of Immigration, 1820–1914 The migration to the United States was part of a worldwide transfer of population that accelerated with the Industrial Revolution and the accompanying improvement in transportation. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Growth and Cities • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R Rhjqqe750A Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Immigrants (cont’d) • Cultural Connections in a New World neighborhood clustering vs. assimilation maintaining cultural traditions - religious, communal institutions • Jewish landsmanshaften - ethnic newspapers, theaters, schools Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Immigrants (cont’d) • The Job work availability for immigrants determined by: - skills - local economy - local discrimination • ethnic stereotyping of low-skilled, low-wage labor Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Immigrants (cont’d) • The Job Los Angeles Japanese: market garden crops costs/benefits of stereotypes for various groups - Jews in needle trades few married women worked outside of the home common goal: business ownership Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Immigrants (cont’d) • Nativism historic antiforeign sentiment - prevalent 1830s–1860 • especially against Irish Catholic immigrants - echoes today “scientific” racism - belief that ethnic groups represented inferior races Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Immigrants (cont’d) • Nativism assimilation [or, adjustment] - dynamic • created new cultural forms, modifications of traditions black-white, red-white: biggest racial divides - immigrants assert “whiteness” • Nativists label immigrants “black” Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Chinese Exclusion Act (1882) Thomas Nast’s 1870 attack on nativism. White workers, many of them immigrants themselves, objected to labor competition from Chinese immigrants and eventually helped to persuade Congress to pass the Chinese Exclusion Act in 1882. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Chinese Exclusion Act • • • The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was the first significant law restricting immigration into the United States. Many Americans on the West Coast attributed declining wages and economic ills to Chinese workers. Although the Chinese composed only .002 percent of the nation's population, Congress passed the exclusion act to placate worker demands and assuage prevalent concerns about maintaining white "racial purity." The Opium Wars (1839-42, 1856-60) of the mid-nineteenth century between Great Britain and China left China in debt. Floods and drought contributed to an exodus of peasants from their farms, and many left the country to find work. When gold was discovered in the Sacramento Valley of California in 1848, a large uptick in Chinese immigrants entered the United States to join the California Gold Rush. Following an 1852 crop failure in China, over 20,000 Chinese immigrants came through San Francisco’s customs house (up from 2,716 the previous year) looking for work. Violence soon broke out between white miners and the new arrivals, much of it racially charged. In May 1852, California imposed a Foreign Miners Tax of $3 month meant to target Chinese miners, and crime and violence escalated. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Modern Immigration Acts • Discuss Trump Era Policies Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue African Americans faced deteriorating conditions, particularly in the South. In 1900, 90% of the black population of the United States lived in the South. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue (cont’d) • Black Aspirations and White Backlash young post-slavery blacks vs. “Lost Cause” whites worsening rural economy in South, 1890s urban black-white contact, competition Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue (cont’d) • Lynch Law massive scale of lynchings, especially 1890s white rage, “orgy of violence” Ida B. Wells-Barnett Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Lynch Law in Georgia Lynching became a public spectacle; a ritual designed to reinforce white supremacy. Note the matter-of-fact satisfaction of the spectators to this gruesome murder of a black man. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue (cont’d) • Segregation by Law racial segregation diminished in North after 1865 legal separation increased in South, 1890s railroads - symbolize modernity, mobility - social rules unclear - Plessy v. Ferguson, 1896 • segregation not unconstitutional Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue (cont’d) • Segregation by Law Jim Crow laws black men excluded from trade unions - deskilling • Disenfranchisement political isolation of the South blacks disenfranchised, despite 15th Amendment - poll tax, secret ballot, literacy tests, grandfather clauses Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Overview The March of Disfranchisement Across the South, 1889–1908 Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue (cont’d) • A National Consensus on Race widespread dehumanizing black stereotypes Northern white opinion supported Southern white policy • Response of the Black Community black organizations had little success in 1890s moving as most realistic option Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue (cont’d) • Roots of the Great Migration sharecropping: new rural labor system - (white) landlords provide house, land, supplies - (black) farmers provide part of crop, pay debts • debt often exceeds income Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Settling the Race Issue (cont’d) • Roots of the Great Migration Northern job opportunities - blacks compete with immigrants (often lose) - limited opportunities for women • domestic service segregated housing - community institutions Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger The Great Migration An african-american religious meeting, New York City, early 1900s. Black migrants from the South found vibrant communities in Northern cities typically centered around black churches and their activities. Like immigrants from asia and europe, who sought to transplant the culture of their homelands within the urban United States, black migrants reestablished Southern religious and communal traditions in their new homes. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Cities Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Cities Novelist Theodore Dreiser called the American city a “giant magnet.” The rapid urbanization of the late nineteenth century (by 1900, 19% of the U.S. population lived in cities of more than 100,000) was spread across many cities. Within each city, residents grouped by ethnicity and social class. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Cities (cont’d) • Centers and Suburbs tall buildings downtown residential rings/suburbs - Russell family in Short Hills, NJ • • home design family recreation growing fragmentation: social and class divisions Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Cities (cont’d) • The New Middle Class increasing numbers of “white-collar” office workers residential subdivisions within cities, or suburbs Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Cities (cont’d) • A Consumer Society goods, not land, as symbol of prestige homes feature new technologies, appliances time-keeping and value of time change advertising creates demand, brand loyalty newspapers and tabloids - tabloids unify urban society with universal appeal Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Cities (cont’d) • A Consumer Society department stores - anchor urban downtowns after 1900 - democratizing - female-friendly Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Cities (cont’d) • The Growth of Leisure Activities some recreation reinforces social differentiation - private clubs for those who can afford fees - saloons for working men some recreation undermines social differentiation - baseball for much of middle- and workingclass - amusement parks for all • Coney Island Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger New Cities (cont’d) • The Ideal City urban energy and opportunity the “White City” - 1893 World’s Fair exemplifies possibility of “ideal city” Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Attacking the American Indian Problem Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Attacking the American Indian Problem Loss of Indian lands, especially due to the Dawes Act, reinforced white reformers’ efforts to suppress Native American culture. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Attacking the American Indian Problem • Dawes Act, 1887 land ownership by individual Indians, not tribes - more than half of Indian lands lost, 1887– 1900 Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Accounts of the Wounded Knee Massacre (1890s) As white people pushed into the West to exploit its resources, Indians were steadily forced to cede their lands. By 1900 they held only scattered parcels, often in areas considered worthless by white people. restricted to these reservations, tribes endured official efforts to suppress Indian customs and values. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Attacking the American Indian Problem (cont’d) • Reformers banned traditional religious practices - 1890 suppression of Ghost Dance among Sioux • Wounded Knee Massacre missionaries attempt conversion to Christianity off-reservation boarding schools instruction in white farming practices - disruption of gender roles Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Attacking the American Indian Problem (cont’d) • Failure of Assimilation Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger An Emerging World Power Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger An Emerging World Power The United States emerged as a world power by 1900. Foreign affairs were influenced by prejudices and a “crusading spirit.” Urban life was fragmented and flawed, but also energetic and open. Overall, ideals and institutions developed that allowed immigrants and minorities to participate – under increasingly fair conditions – in the American journey. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger Class Discussion Questions In what ways did labor conditions change for the working class in the 50 years after the Civil War? Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger • Industrialism was growing largely unchecked in the United States after the Civil War, creating new jobs and new problems simultaneously. Immigration was continuing in unprecedented numbers, especially from eastern and southern Europe, forever altering the makeup of the workforce. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger How did nativist groups attempt to halt the mixture of culture that came to the United States in the period 1880–1910? Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger • • • By the 1880s, nativists began to target immigrants from Asia, particularly in the western United States. The Page Act of 1875 barred Chinese women from entering the country, and in 1882, the Chinese Exclusion Act made all immigration from China illegal. Millions of Italians, Jews, Poles, and Slavs migrated to the United States during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, generating intense fear and hatred of immigrants among many Americans. Responding to nativists who demanded limits on the number and national origins of immigrants, in 1924 Congress passed the Johnson-Reed Act, which implemented a rigid quota system. The immigration laws of the 1920s remained in place until 1965, when the Immigration and Nationality Act redistributed the quota system to allow for a greater diversity of immigrants. Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger In what ways did the Dawes Act aid and/or harm Indians? Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger What social developments reveal the emergence of a predominant middle-class culture in the United States? Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger • Address the following statement: “Despite the great wealth produced by the industrial boom, class divisions in America were sharply divisive in the period of 1880–1910.” Twentieth-Century America: A Social and Political History, Second Edition Goldfield | Abbott | Argersinger | Argersinger