Industrial Weighing Safe Accurate Smart Guide Book Edition 2 Hazardous Area Industrial Weighing Solutions Hazardous Area Guide Table of Contents METTLER TOLEDO provides this practical guide as a service to help customers. In reading or making any use of this document, you acknowledge and agree to the following: This document may contain inaccuracies and errors of both a substantive and/or typographical nature. METTLER TOLEDO does not guaranty the accuracy or completeness of the information or the reliability of any advice, opinion or statement in this document. If you rely on the information or any advice, opinion or statement, you are doing so at your sole risk. METTLER TOLEDO does not guaranty that this document or its contents are accurate, complete, reliable, truthful, current or error-free. METTLER TOLEDO will not be liable for any decision made or action taken by you or others in reliance on the information in this document. METTLER TOLEDO and its affiliates are not liable for any Damages based on claims arising out of or in connection with your use of this document. Chapter 1 Introduction: Safe Weighing Solutions 4-5 Chapter 2 Explosion Protection Basics 6-9 2.1 Flammable or Explosive Substances 2.2 Prevention of Explosion METTLER TOLEDO DOES NOT ASSUME ANY RESPONSIBILITY OR RISK FOR YOUR USE OF THE INFORMATION PROVIDED IN THIS DOCUMENT. THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT INTENDED AS LEGAL ADVICE. BEFORE MAKING ANY DECISIONS, YOU SHOULD OBTAIN YOUR OWN ADVICE ABOUT COMPLIANCE WITH LEGAL AND REGULATORY OBLIGATIONS. THIS INFORMATION IS PROVIDED WITHOUT ANY REPRESENTATIONS, ENDORSEMENTS, OR WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND WHATSOEVER, EITHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ANY WARRANTIES OF TITLE OR ACCURACY AND ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, OR NON-INFRINGEMENT, WITH THE SOLE EXCEPTION BEING WARRANTIES (IF ANY) WHICH CANNOT BE EXPRESSLY EXCLUDED UNDER APPLICABLE LAW. Chapter 3 International Standards and Regulations 10-19 3.1 International Overview 3.2 Classification at a Glance Chapter 4 Ignition Protection Methods 20-23 4.1 Intrinsic Safety and Protection 4.2 Marking of Electrical Equipment 4.3 Equipment Installation and Maintenance In no event will METTLER TOLEDO or its affiliates be liable for any Damages, even if METTLER TOLEDO is aware of the possibility of such Damages, arising in connection with the information provided herein. “Damages” includes but is not limited to all losses and all direct, indirect, incidental, special, consequential and punitive damages arising under a contract, tort or other theory of liability (including reasonable legal and accounting fees and expenses). Chapter 5 Weighing in Hazardous Areas – System Examples 24-37 5.1 Basic System 5.2 Advanced System 5.3 Active Control System 5.4 Active/Passive Control System 5.5 Passive Input/Output System 5.6 Fully Integrated Process Control No part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed in any form without written permission from METTLER TOLEDO Chapter 6 Summary 38-39 "How can I ensure safety and accuracy in hazardous zones?" Production Manager 2 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 3 Introduction 1. Safe Weighing Solutions Careful selection of weighing solutions to meet specific process requirements and regulations can be a challenging task for manufacturers that work within hazardous areas. However, it is essential to workplace safety as well as measurement accuracy. Explosion Protection Basics This guide illustrates how to avoid dangerous situation in hazardous areas with compliant equipment. It also provides illustrated recommendations for correct installation and maintenance on equipment in these areas. When electrical equipment is used in areas where flammable or explosive substances are present there is always a possibility or risk of fire or explosion. These are classified as hazardous locations or hazardous areas. Standards and Regulations Globally, explosion protection is regulated by the legislatures of the individual countries. Standards and mandatory regulations facilitate the free movement of goods by providing a uniformly recognized framework. Classification varies but generally, there are two types: ATEX and NEC. Ignition Protection The basic safety concept is to eliminate the simultaneous existence of possible ignition sources. The method of equipment protection will depend on the degree of safety needed for the type of hazardous area. Marking of electrical equipment is mandatory and must be placed on equipment before it is distributed. Weighing in Hazardous Areas Weighing is one of the most basic and important process variables in most manufacturing processes. However, it can be one of the most challenging parameters to control. To achieve reliable quality and repeatable results, you require efficient capture and communication of data to the existing plant network, which can be challenging in hazardous areas. 4 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 5 Flammable Substances Characteristics Flammable Gas As the percentage of gas increases, the risk is greater. When the concentration exceeds a certain limit, the air becomes saturated with the gas and ignition becomes less likely. Most manufacturing and processing industries generate potentially explosive atmospheres using flammable or explosive substances, such as flammable gases or vapors, flammable liquids, combustible dusts, ignitable fibers or debris. These substances can form an explosive atmosphere with oxygen normally present in air. When electrical equipment is used in or around such areas, there is always a possibility of fire or explosion. These areas are classified as hazardous. Flammable Liquids / Vapors Flash point is the minimum temperature at which the vapor near the surface is high enough to form an ignitable mixture. The higher the flash point of the liquid, the less the danger of ignition. Flammable Solids For dusts, information on particle size and density will be needed, once it has been shown that a particular dust can form an explosive atmosphere. 2.1 Flammable or explosive substances Explosive Limits Flammable or explosive substances may be present in the form of gases, vapors, mist, or dust clouds. Each material is present in a defined concentration and for a certain period. The properties of a dangerous substance that need to be known include the boiling point and flash point and whether any flammable gas or vapor involved is lighter or heavier than air. Mixture is too lean to cause an explosion anc e 1 Flammable or explosive substance n yge Ox Fla mm abl es ubs t 0% Vol. LEL 3 Components of Explosions Mixture is too rich to cause an explosion Explosive Mixture Explosion Limit Concentration of flammable substance UEL Explosion Protection - Basics 2. Explosion Protection – The Basics 100% Vol. Figure 2: Explosive limits diagram Lower Explosive Limit (LEL) The minimum concentration of explosive liquid vapor in air that will support the propagation of flame, or flame spread, through the entire volume of vapor-air mixture upon contact with an ignition source. Upper Explosive Limit (UEL) The maximum concentration of vapor in air that will support the propagation of flame. 2 Oxygen Explosion 3 Source of ignition Ignition source Figure 1: Triangle of fire 6 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 7 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH anc e ub st Fla mm abl es anc e ub st Triangle of fire anc e Ignition source ub st Secondary Explosion Protection Secondary explosion protection is related to preventing the ignition of potentially explosive atmospheres. This means avoiding sparks (mechanical, electrical, static), flames, hot gases or hot surfaces, as well as eliminating other possible ignition sources such as electromagnetic, ultrasonic etc. Equipment designers are searching for different ways to eliminate those sources. This can be done by: • Using appropriate housing materials, such as stainless steel, which prevents formation of sparks • Using proper earthing and conducting materials • Avoiding hot surfaces, e.g. by means of applying intrinsically safe circuits in the design of electrical equipment. Ignition source Fla mm abl es In the absence of flammable substances, no ignitable mixture will be created. As a result, no explosion risk will exist. This approach can, of course, only be applied to a limited extent. After all, the flammability of many substances is a desired product property that is either indispensable or which cannot be controlled, for example, gases and their release in the field of mining. In such cases, secondary explosion protection measures must be taken. Triangle of fire Triangle of fire n yge Ox 8 Primary Explosion Protection Primary explosion protection is based on the concept of preventing the formation of a potentially explosive atmosphere. These might include: • Using substitutes for flammable substances, for example, in-flammable organic solvents can be substituted with hydrous solutions • Using gas detectors • Preventing the formation of explosive atmospheres in hazardous areas, for example, by means of ventilation. n yge Ox • Hot surfaces are a result of energy loss from systems, equipment and components during normal operation. • Flames and hot gases (including hot particles) can occur inside combustion engines or analysis devices during normal operation and when a fault has occurred. • Mechanically generated sparks are produced, for example, by grinding and cutting devices during normal operation and are not permitted in a potentially explosive atmosphere. • Electrical apparatuses must normally be regarded as a sufficient ignition sources. Only very low energy sparks with energies of only micro Joules may be regarded as too weak to start an explosion. For this rea-son, suitable measures must be adopted to prevent these ignition sources. • Static electricity. The stored energy can be released in the form of sparks and function as an ignition source. Because this ignition source can arise independently of an electrical voltage supply, it must also be considered with non-electrical devices and components. It is connected with separation processes; therefore, these cases must be assessed where this ignition source needs to be taken into account. • Electromagnetic fields: Frequency ranges from 9 x 1000 to 3 x 1011 Hz. These include high-frequency equipment such as radio equipment or high-frequency generators. • Electromagnetic radiation: Frequency ranges from 3 x 1011 to 3 x 1015 Hz and wavelengths of 1000 to 0.1 μm. This includes optical radiation such as sunlight, lasers, lightning strikes, electric arcs. • Ionizing radiation: Ignition due to energy absorption, with causes such as short-wave UV rays, X-rays or radioactive materials. • Adiabatic compression and streaming gases: Due to the high temperatures that occur due to shock waves and in instances of adiabatic compression, an atmosphere subject to explosion can ignite. • Chemical reactions: Due to chemical reactions that cause heat development (exothermic reactions), materials heat up and can cause an explosion. To eliminate the risk of explosion, one of the three elements of the “Triangle of Fire” must be removed. en Ignition Sources This section discusses ignition sources related to equipment. These can be hot surfaces, mechanically generated sparks, electrical apparatuses and static electricity. Equipment suppliers reduce the risk of explosion by eliminating ignition sources and by keeping the system’s active ignition energy at the lowest possible level – lower than the minimum ignition energy. The minimum ignition energy is the smallest amount of energy required to ignite a combustible vapor, gas or dust cloud. The minimum ignition energy is measured in µ Joules. 2.2 Prevention of Explosion Fla mm abl es Oxygen Although an explosion usually occurs because of direct presence of oxygen in the mixture, this is not always true. For example a mixture of the (now seldom used) anesthetic gases, ethyl ether and nitrous oxide, can cause violent explosions because oxygen is formed from the nitrous oxide. If the oxygen concentration is above the percentage normally found in the air (21% by volume) flammable limits are normally exceeded, and the ignition energy is decreased. In addition, the explosion is often considerably more violent than at normal oxygen concentration in the air. Please note: The IEC/EN60079 series and products certified according to those approval standards only covers the standard concentration of oxygen in air and normal atmospheric pressure. yg Ox Explosion Protection - Basics Combustible Dusts When solids are processed in industrial environments, such as chemical plants and flour mills, often small particles are present in the environment in the form of dust or dust clouds. Dust is defined in IEC 60079-10-2 (Classification of areas - Explosive dust atmospheres) as finely divided solid particles no larger than 500 µm or fibers greater than 500 μm in nominal size in the atmosphere that are deposited due to their own weight but which remain in the atmosphere for some period of time in the form of a dust-air mixture. Ignition source Figure 3: Explosion protection concepts METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 9 International Standards and Regulations 3. International Standards and Regulations 3.1 Global Map of Guidelines and Standards Safety problems related to the design and use of electrical equipment in hazardous areas have led authorities to impose strict rules. It has also elicited awareness of safe equipment design. Globally, explosion protection is regulated by the legislatures of the individual countries. National differences in technical requirements and the required approvals for explosion protected equipment make significant demands, primarily on global players, and require considerable transparency in development and approval testing. Standards and mandatory regulations facilitate the free movement of goods by providing a uniformly recognized framework. They cover everything from product certification requirements to protective measures for employees who work with the products. Recognized authorities work to develop uniform standards on both a national and international scale. However, historical and country-specific developments have the result that many areas – including explosion protection – do not yet have a global standard in place. A basic map of global standards and regulations shows how hazardous-area guidelines and certifications are distributed around the world (Figure 4). Local hazardous location approval standards are based off IEC standards with national / regional differences applied. In Europe, for example, CENELEC is responsible for either creating or adapting IEC standards so that the standard is harmonized for all the members of the European Union. Notified Bodies use these harmonized standards to evaluate product to ensure that they meet the Essential Health and Safety Requirements of the ATEX directive. Regional Regulation China, Korea and Russia are all examples of regions that follow their own local laws regarding electrical equipment regulations. Based on requirements some accept IECEx test reports and ATEX reports and may issue approvals on their merit. If you’re located in one of these regions, be sure to review local requirements for equipment in hazardous areas. Global Regulations for Electrical Equipment There are two major global organizations that set hazardous-area standards globally. One is the International Electro-Technical Commission (IEC). This is the premier international standardization organization for electric, electronic and related technologies. The aim of the IEC is to harmonize the many different standards and regulations throughout the world and to remove trade barriers for related products. For example, the IEC 60079 standards are related to the general requirements for hazardous areas. The IEC system is followed in Europe, Asia, Australia, Africa and some other regions. The second system is the North American system with the National Electrical Code (NEC), which are published by the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA).The requirements for hazardous areas and safety in the workplace are defined in ATEX directives in the European Union and in NEC articles in the USA. Country Canada USA Brazil Guideline CEC NECTM INMETRO ATEX Europa Standard CSA FMUL INMETRO CENELEC Testing marks (nationally accredibid Testing abs or official mark) Examples: Examples: Russia China Japan Australia Korea EACEx/TR CU 012/2011 GOST 31xxx series CCC MHLW IEC KOHSA GB 3836.x JNOSHI IECEx KCs IEC ATEX CENELEC UL and FM OSHA/ NEC JPEX / TIIS PTB DEKRA NRTL'S Figure 5: Global view of hazardous standards and regulations Figure 4: Global map of guidelines and standards 10 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 11 International Standards and Regulations IECEx, ATEX and NEC at a glance A common route to compliance is to use pre-approved products in a specified manner and, if required, a notified body (for example DEKRA, Baseefa, Sira, TUV) to provide a conformity assessment to gain additional certification. Unfortunately, for global export, this is not always sufficient. An internationally acceptable solution was required to allow equipment designs to be used in any part of the world without significant modification. The approach would use recognized practice to achieve a common acceptable level of safety, with the goal of facilitating free trade of hazardous-area use products across all major markets. ATEX NEC/CEC IECEx Regulatory status Mandatory system Mandatory system Voluntary system Conformity basis EU-directives (EHSR) US/CAN standards e.g. ISA, UL, FM, CSA IEC standards Standards EN standards US/CAN standards IEC standards Area classification Zone Zone, Class and Division Zone Conformity assessor Ex notified bodies (Ex NB) manufacturer Nationaly Recognized Testing Laboratories (NRTL) / Standards Council of Canada Accredited Testing Laboratories (SCC) Ex certifying bodies (ExCB) Ex test labs - E C-type examination certificate - T est report (on request) -Q M certificate / report -Listing and Marking -Certificate of conformity -Test report (not public) -Audit report (not public) - Certificate of conformity - Test report (ExTR) - Quality assessment report - Full public access to all issued IECEx certificates European Union, some Latin American countries North America, Canada, some Latin American countries Australia, New Zealand Issued documents Acceptance Conformity mark Regional acceptance of Technical Report (TR) Level of ignition protection Conditions of operation Performance of protection M1 Methane, dust Very high Equipment remains energized and functioning when explosive atmosphere is present 2 independent protection methods or safe with 2 faults High Equipment is de-energized in the event of an explosive atmosphere Sufficient level of safety during the normal operating conditions Equipment Group II, (e.g. processing industries) Very high Equipment remains energized and functioning in Zones 0,1,2 (G) and/or 20,21,22 (D) 2 independent protection methods, or safe with 2 faults Cat.2 High Equipment remains energized and functioning in Zones 1,2 (G) and/or 21,22 (D) Suitable for normal operation and frequently occurring disturbances, or safe with 1 fault Cat.3 Normal Equipment remains energized and functioning in Zones 2 (G) and/or 22 (D) Suitable for normal operation Cat.1 Gas, vapor, mist, dust Examples for marks: Europe, North America, Japan, Brazil, China North America, Canada, Mexico 36 IECEx members states (status 2023) To prevent any risk of explosion or fire and improve safety of the process and employees, all potentially hazardous areas must be classified according to the processes conducted in these areas. It is in responsibility of the end user to define the hazardous areas within the operations. Area classification is the method of analyzing and classifying the environment where explosive gas atmospheres may occur so as to facilitate the proper selection of the electrical equipment. The concept of assessing the potentially explosive areas is crucial to limiting the risk associated with the installation of electrical equipment in potentially explosive environment. The assessment tests and appropriate areas classification allows preparation of safety procedures for plant operation and maintenance. Classification varies across the world, but generally, there are two types of classification: • European Classification System described by ATEX Directive • American Classification System described by National Electrical Code (NEC) Area Guide Hazardous atmosphere Table 3: Equipment group and category classification according to ATEX 2014/34/EU 3.2 Classification at a Glance METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Equipment Group I, (e.g. mines) Category of equipment M2 Table 2: Comparison of ATEX, NEC/CEC and IECEx 12 ATEX Group Classifications Group I equipment applies to equipment used in underground operations such as mines. Group II equipment applies to surface-processing industries. The petrochemical, chemical, pharmaceutical as well as food industries are typical processing industries. The equipment groups are further sub-divided into categories as shown in Table 3. Group I is divided into categories M1 and M2. Group II is divided into equipment categories 1, 2 and 3. ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ATEX 1999/92/EC Zone Classification According to the ATEX 1999/92/EC Directive, Equipment Group II, which is intended to be used in hazardous areas, is divided into three zones for gases and three zones for dust substances. The classification given to a particular zone, is made based on the frequency and duration of the occurrence of the explosive atmosphere (Table 4). This concept has been used successfully for many years for specification and selection of electrical equipment for explosive gas and dust atmospheres. The zones 0, 1, and 2 are used to denote explosive atmospheres containing gases and vapors. The zones 20, 21, and 22 are the zones containing explosive and flammable dusts. Zone classification Gas Dust Zone 0 An explosive atmosphere is present continuously or for long periods of time. Zone 1 An explosive atmosphere is likely to occur occasionally during normal operation. Zone 2 An explosive atmosphere is likely to occur infrequently or for short periods of time. Zone 20 An explosive atmosphere is present continuously or for long periods of time. Zone 21 An explosive atmosphere is likely to occur occasionally during normal operation. Zone 22 An explosive atmosphere is likely to occur infrequently or for short periods of time. Table 4: ATEX Zone classifiication ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 13 Hazardous Area Classification Gas and Dust Substance Group Up to this point, explosion-proof equipment has been divided into Equipment Group I (underground, for example working mines) and equipment Group II (surface equipment, for areas at risk of explosion excluding working mines). Equipment Group II, which is the focus of this guide, draws a further distinction by differentiating between areas at risk due to gases, vapors, mists and dust. The information in the table below shows the relationships between the gas/dust explosion group and the protection type required in each case (Table 5). Explosion group Type of group Characteristics of group Gas explosion group IIC Easily ignitable (e.g. hydrogen, acetylene) IIB Ignitable (e.g. coalgas, ethylene, ethylene glycol) IIA Less ignitable (e.g. acetone, benzene, toluene) IIIC Conductive dusts (resistivity ≤103Ωm) IIIB Non-conductive dusts (resistivity >103Ωm) IIIA Flammable fibers (length >500µm) Dust explosion group Table 5: ATEX substance group classification Div 1 Zone 1 Div 2 Zone 2 Div 1 Zone 0 Div 1, Zone 0 or 1 Figure 6: Zone classification according to IEC EN 60079-10 -1 (Gas) and ATEX 1999/92/EC, respectively NEC500 ATEX 2014/34/EU Equipment Categories & IECEx Equipment Protection Level Equipment to be used must correspond to the assigned equipment categories and equipment protection levels (EPL) as prescribed by the zone classification. These equipment requirements are categorized in relation to the European equipment categories based on EU Directive 2014/34/EU; the EPL, introduced by the IEC, applies on an international level. Both classifications can be used when marking equipment. This classification tells us about the probability of ignition, considering potentially explosive gas and dust atmospheres. Table 6 presents the definitions of equipment categories and equipment protection levels (EPL) and their differences. The definition of EPL is usually used in the IECEx marking system (see chapter 4). ATEX 2014/34/EU (formerly ATEX 95) - equipment category Classification of equipment for use in surface areas at risk of explosion within Europe divided into three equipment categories for areas at risk of explosion due to gas (G) or for areas with flammable dust (D) IECEx (IEC 60079-0) - equipment protection level Category 1: 1G or 1D Very high level of safety. Safe even when rare equipment faults occur. Two independent explosion protection measures, even safe when two faults occur independently of one another. Category 2: 2G or 2D High level of safety. Safe even in the case of equipment faults, which occur frequently or which are usually to be expected. Even safe when a fault occurs. Category 3: 3G or 3D Normal level of safety. Safe during normal operation EPL Ga or Da Equipment with "very high" protection level for use in areas at risk of explosion where there is no ignition risk during normal operation, or in the case of predictable or rare faults/ malfunctions EPL Gb or Db Equipment with "high" protection level for use in areas at risk of explosion where there is no ignition risk during normal operation, or in the case of predictable faults/malfunctions. EPL Gc or Dc Equipment with "extended" protection level for use in areas at risk of explosion where there is no ignition risk during normal operation, and which has some additional protective measures, which ensure that there is no ignition risk in the case of predictable equipment faults. Classification of equipment for use in surface areas at risk of explosion divided into three protection levels for areas at risk of explosion due to gas (G) or for areas with flammable dust (D) Table 6: Definition of ATEX 2014/34/EU equipment categories and IECEx equipment protection level Comparison of ATEX 2014/34/EU & ATEX 1999/92/EC Table 7 shows the comparison between two directives for equipment manufacturers and for users. There is a direct link between the two directives in that the three equipment categories specified in ATEX 2014/34/EU correspond to the three Zones used in ATEX 1999/92/EC for the classification of hazardous areas. Therefore, in Zone 2/22, equipment category 3 may be used, whereas in Zone 0/20 (explosive atmosphere can be present continuously), equipment category 1 must be used. Manufacturer requirements ATEX 2014/34/EU Definition of area of use of equipment, specification of equipment group / category Equipment Category 1 Equipment Category 2 Equipment Category 3 Comply with essential safety and health requirements or relevant standards Carry out a risk / ignition-hazard assessment of equipment User requirements ATEX 1999/92/EC Risk assessment of hazardous area in working places, employee safety Zone 0/20 Zone 1/21 Zone 2/22 Comply with installation and maintenance requirements Prepare conformity documentation Carry out a risk assessment of the work place, duty of coordination Prepare an explosion document Appropriate quality control Regular updates Table 7: Comparison ATEX 2014/34/EU and ATEX 1999/92/EC 14 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 15 Hazardous Area Classification North American NEC Class / Division Classification In the USA, all regulations related to manufacturing facilities at risk are found in the National Electrical Code (NEC) Handbook. Articles 500, 501, 502, 503 and 505, and 506 define the requirements for classification of hazardous locations into Classes, Groups, Divisions and Zones. According to NEC 500, hazardous locations are divided into Classes I, II, and III depending on the type of material present. Table 8 shows the classification of the hazardous locations according to NEC 500 - 505 articles. Substance Gases / vapors Substance Area Classification Class NEC500 NEC505 Class I (NEC 501) Division 1 Zone 1 Division 2 16 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide Zone 0 Zone 2 Sub- Substance Area Classification stance Class NEC500 NEC505/506 Dusts Class II (NEC 502) Division 1 Zone 20 Division 2 Zone 22 Division 1 Zone 20 or 21 Group IIIA Division 2 Zone 22 Group IIIA Zone 21 Hazardous location characteristics Explosion hazard present continuously or occasionally under normal operating conditions (1) In which ignitible concentrations of flammable gases, flammable liquid–produced vapors, or combustible liquid–produced vapors can exist under normal operating conditions, or (2) In which ignitible concentrations of such flammable gases, flammable liquid–produced vapors, or combustible liquids above their flash points may exist frequently because of repair or maintenance operations or because of leakage, or (3) In which breakdown or faulty operation of equipment or processes might release ignitible concentrations of flammable gases, flammable liquid–produced vapors, or combustible liquid–produced vapors and might also cause simultaneous failure of electrical equipment in such a way as to directly cause the electrical equipment to become a source of ignition Ignitable concentrations of flammable gases or vapors are not normally present, but could be present in the case of a fault (1) In which volatile flammable gases, flammable liquid– produced vapors, or combustible liquid–produced vapors are handled, processed, or used, but in which the liquids, vapors, or gases will normally be confined within closed containers or closed systems from which they can escape only in case of accidental rupture or breakdown of such containers or systems or in case of abnormal operation of equipment, or (2) In which ignitible concentrations of flammable gases, flammable liquid–produced vapors, or combustible liquid–produced vapors are normally prevented by positive mechanical ventilation and which might become hazardous through failure or abnormal operation of the ventilating equipment, or (3) That is adjacent to a Class I, Division 1 location, and to which ignitible concentrations of flammable gases, flammable liquid–produced vapors, or combustible liquid– produced vapors above their flash points might occasionally be communicated unless such communication is prevented by adequate positive-pressure ventilation from a source of clean air and effective safeguards against ventilation failure are provided. ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH Fibers Class III (NEC 503) Hazardous location characteristics Combustible dusts are present in quantities sufficient to produce explosive and ignitable mixtures (1) In which combustible dust is in the air under normal operating conditions in quantities sufficient to produce explosive or ignitible mixtures, or (2) Where mechanical failure or abnormal operation of machinery or equipment might cause such explosive or ignitible mixtures to be produced, and might also provide a source of ignition through simultaneous failure of electrical equipment, through operation of protection devices, or from other causes, or (3) In which Group E combustible dusts may be present in quantities sufficient to be hazardous. Combustible dust due to abnormal operations may be present in quantities sufficient to produce explosive or ignitable mixtures (1) In which combustible dust due to abnormal operations may be present in the air in quantities sufficient to produce explosive or ignitible mixtures; or (2) Where combustible dust accumulations are present but are normally insufficient to interfere with the normal operation of electrical equipment or other apparatus, but could as a result of infrequent malfunctioning of handling or processing equipment become suspended in the air; or (3) In which combustible dust accumulations on, in, or in the vicinity of the electrical equipment could be sufficient to interfere with the safe dissipation of heat from electrical equipment, or could be ignitible by abnormal operation or failure of electrical equipment. Easily ignitable fibers / flyings are handled or manufactured A Class III, Division 1 location is a location in which easily ignitible fibers/flyings are handled, manufactured, or used. Easily ignitable fibers / flyings are stored or handled A Class III, Division 2 location is a location in which easily ignitible fibers/flyings are stored or handled other than in the process of manufacture. Table 8: Hazardous locations classification system according to NEC 500 – 506 NEC Material Group Classification Each class is also divided into the material groups A, B, C, D, E, F and G. Article 500 defines the classification of the substance classes into substance groups according to their properties and ignitability. Table 9 presents this classification. The basis for definition of the substance group according to Article 500 is the degree of risk. In this case, it is a factor of the maximum experimental safety gap or minimum igniting current. ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 17 Hazardous Area Classification Substance Class I Material Group (NEC500) A Material Group (NEC 505/506) IIC T1 Acetylene T2 T3 T4 Acetylaldehyde Ethyl ether Hydrogen I Not relevant for weighing equipment IIB Ethylene IIA D IIA Propane E IIIC Methanol n-Amyl acetate n-Butanol Acetic Acid Ethyl acetate F IIIB Combustible metal dust Conductive dusts Carbonaceous dust Diesel fuel Aviation fuel Domestic fuel Oils n-Hexane n-Butane IIB Acetone Ethane Ammonia Benzene (pure) Carbon monoxide Methane Propane Toluene Ethylene IIC Hydrogen Acetylene Hydrogen Disulfide G Class III Temperature code C B Class II Substance Group Substance N/A Combustible dusts not in Group E of F IIIA Fibers and flyings Table 9: NEC 500 and NEC505/506 substance group classification Ignition Temperature and Temperature Code Flammable gases and vapors are classified into temperature codes according to their autoignition temperature (AIT). The ignition temperature of a flammable gas is the lowest temperature of a surface required to ignite a combustible vapor, gas or dust cloud. The equipment manufacturers are obliged to classify the electrical equipment in the temperature codes depending on the flammable material used depending on the maximum surface temperature the equipment generates. Temperature codes from T1 to T6 are defined for flammable gases and vapors as a means of ensuring safety and protection. In practice, this means that the maximum surface temperature of a piece of equipment must always be lower than the ignition temperature of the gas/air or vapor/air mixture. Increasing temperature code numbers correspond to lower surface temperature of the equipment. Ignition temperature gases and vapors >450°C Maximum surface temperature 450°C NEC 500 IEC EN / NEC 505 T1 T1 >300 300°C T2 T2 >280°C 280°C T2A - >260°C 260°C T2B - >230°C 230°C T2C - >215°C 215°C T2D - >200°C 200°C T3 T3 >180°C 180°C T3A - >165°C 165°C T3B - >160°C 160°C T3C - >135°C 135°C T4 T4 >120°C 120°C T4A - >100°C 100°C T5 T5 >85°C 85°C T6 T6 T5 T6 Carbondisulphid Table 11. Temperature codes vs. substance group system What type of hazardous area classifications and protection does your company use? NEC CEC standards ATEX /IECEx standards What type of hazardous substances may be present? Class I Gas and vapors Class II Dust Class III Fibers and flyings How often may hazardous substances be present in the atmosphere? What type of hazardous substances may be present? Zone 0, 1, 2 Gas and vapors Zone 20, 21, 22 Dust How often may hazardous substances be present in the atmosphere? Are likely to exist under normal operating conditions Are NOT likely to exist under normal operating conditions Continuously present for long periods of time under normal operating conditions Class I Gas and vapors Class, II, III Gas and vapors Zone 0: Gas & vapors Zone 20: Dust Are likely to exist under normal operating conditions Are NOT likely to exist under normal operating conditions Table 10: Ignition temperature classes American NEC and Canadian CEC Zone Classification Zone 1: Gas & vapors Zone 2: Gas & vapors Zone 21: Dust Zone 22: Dust Figure 7: Comparison NEC and ATEX /IECEx class and zone classification system The NEC allows hazardous locations to be classified using the Class/Division scheme per Articles 501-504 or using the American Zone scheme of Articles 505 and 506. The use of American zones is not as popular as the legacy Class/Div. classification scheme, but it is becoming more popular with global companies looking for uniformity between international jurisdictions. Canada requires all new hazardous location installations be classified using the zone scheme. Class / Division schemes are only for existing and expansions of existing Class / Division areas. 18 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 19 Ignition Protection Methods 4. Ignition Protection Methods The basic safety concept is to eliminate the simultaneous existence of possible ignition sources. The method of equipment protection will likely depend on the degree of safety needed for the type of hazardous location. Besides the degree of safety required for the classified area, other considerations must be made, such as the size of the equipment, its normal function, power requirements, installation costs and flexibility of the protection method for maintenance. Table 12 shows an overview of the standardized types of protection. It describes the basic principle of each protection method as well as the applicable standard and the classified area. The protection methods are standardized and the standards vary in different countries. However, the principles of protection are the same regardless of the country. When it comes to designing and developing weighing equipment for hazardous areas, the intrinsic safety and flameproof methods are mainly applied. Types of Protection (Divisions) Types of Protection (Zones) Electrical Equipment for Flammable Gases, Vapors and Mists Electrical Equipment Type of Protection Concept General Requirement General requirements for all Ex equipment Flameproof Contain explosion; extinguish the flame Purge and Pressurization Prevent ingress of explosive atmosphere; limit surface temperature Powder Filled Contain explosion; extinguish the flame Liquid Immersion Prevent ingress of explosive atmosphere; limit surface temperature Increased Safety No arcs, sparks or hot surfaces Intrinsic Safety Limit energy of sparks and surface temperature Type of Protection "n" Non-sparking devices Sparking devices Restricted breathing Encapsulation Ex Code Zone – – da 0 db 1 dc 2 pxb 1, 21 pyc 1, 21 pzc 2 q 1 ob 1 oc 2 eb 1 ec 2 ia 0, 20 ib 1, 21 ic 2, 22 nA 2 nC 2 nR 2 Prevent ingress of explosive atmosphere; limit surface temperature ma 0, 20 mb 1, 21 mc 2, 22 Optical Radiation Protected by shutdown, enclosure or inherently safe op pr 1, 21 op is 0, 20 op sh 0, 20 Protection by Enclosure Prevent ingress of explosive atmosphere; limit surface temperature ta 20 tb 21 tc 22 Standards Standards (ATEX/IECEx) (NEC/CEC) Type of Protection EN/IEC 60079-0 ANSI 60079-0 C22.2 No. 60079-0 Explosionproof Contain explosion and extinguish the flame EN/IEC 60079-1 ANSI 60079-1 C22.2 No.60079-1 Purge and Pressurization EN/IEC 60079-2 ISA 60079-2 C22.2 No.60079-2 Keep the explosive atmosphere out EN/IEC 60079-5 ANSI 60079-5 C22.2 No. 60079-5 EN/IEC 60079-6 ANSI 60079-6 C22.2 No.60079-6 EN/IEC 60079-7 ANSI 60079-7 C22.2 No.60079-7 EN/IEC 60079-11 EN/IEC 60079-15 – ANSI 60079-15 C22.2 No.60079-15 Intrinsic Safety Non-incendive Type of Protection Dust Ignition Protection Fiber and Flying Protection ANSI 60079-18 C22.2 No.60079-18 EN/IEC 60079-28 ANSI 60079-28 C22.2 No.60079-28 EN/IEC 60079-31 ANSI 60079-31 C22.2 No.60079-31 Class I Division Standards 1 C22.2 No. 30 UL 1203 FM 3615 2 1, 2 ISA 60079-2 C22.2 No. 60079-2 NFPA 496 (FM 3620) 1, 2 2 Limit energy of sparks and surface temperature 1 FM 3610 UL 913 2 UL 12.12.01 C22.2 No. 213 FM 3611 Electrical Equipment for Combustible Dusts Non-Incendive EN/IEC 60079-18 Concept Intrinsic Safety Pressurization Concept Class II Division ClassIII Division 1, 2 1, 2 C22.2 No. 25 FM 3616 UL 1203 – 1, 2 C22.2 No. 25 FM 3616 UL 1203 2 1, 2 ISA 12.12.01 C22.2 No. 213 FM 3611 1, 2 1, 2 ISA 60079-11 C22.2 No. 60079-11 FM 3610 UL 913 1, 2 1, 2 1, 2 1, 2 2 1, 2 Keep combustible dust out Limit energy of sparks and surface temperature Keep the explosive atmosphere out Standards 4.1 Intrinsic Safety Classification and Protection Levels Intrinsic safety offers three classification levels, "ia," "ib" or "ic," which are based on the safety level and number of faults possible. Each classification attempts to balance the probability of an explosive atmosphere being present against the probability of an ignition occurring. The level of protection "ia" is a prerequisite for Category 1 equipment and is suitable for use in Zone 0/Division 1. The level of protection “ib” for Category 2 equipment is suitable for use in Zone 1. The level of protection "ic" for Category 3 is suitable for use in Zone 2/Division 2. The classifications ensure that the equipment is suitable for an appropriate hazardous application. For example, having equipment classified as "Ex ib" means that the equipment is designed containing an intrinsically safe circuit and can be installed in the certified hazardous areas Zone 1. Moreover, the "ib" classification indicates that one fault is possible. ai ib ic Hazardous area Zone 0,1,2 / Division 1 Zone 1,2 / Division 2 Zone 2 / Division 2 Faults possible 2 1 Normal operation Table 13: Intrinsically safe protection levels NFPA 496 (FM3620) Table 12. Protection methods and related standards (current revision available on standardization bodies websites) 20 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 21 Ignition Protection Methods Terms to Know Intrinsically Safe Circuit A circuit in which no spark and no thermal effect can cause the ignition of a potentially explosive atmosphere. Minimum Ignition Energy The minimum ignition energy is the smallest possible electrical energy required to ignite a combustible vapor, gas or dust cloud. The minimum ignition energy is measured in µJoules. Intrinsically Safe Electrical Equipment All circuits of electrical equipment are intrinsically safe. The Voltage and the current in the intrinsically safe circuit are low enough such that a short – circuit, interruption or short – circuit to ground will not ignite the potentially ex-plosive atmosphere. Intrinsically safe electrical equipment is suitable for operation direct in hazardous area Zone 0, 1, 2 / Zone 20, 21, 22 and Division 1, 2.Typical marking: Ex ib IIC Flame Proof – Ex d The flameproof protection method is based on the explosion-containment concept and is in accordance with IEC EN60079-1 classified as "Ex d." This concept relies on equipment and wiring enclosures to prevent an internal ignition from escaping to the surrounding atmosphere. In other words, the explosion is allowed to take place, but it must remain confined in the enclosure that is designed to resist the excess pressure the internal explosion causes. The theory supporting this method is that the resultant gas jet coming from the enclosure is cooled rapidly through the enclosure’s heat conduction and the expansion of the gas. The hot gas is then diluted in the colder external atmosphere. That is only possible if the enclosure openings or interstices have sufficiently small and well-controlled dimensions. A flameproof system is generally considered somewhat simpler to design than an intrinsically safe system, as it doesn’t require completely new equipment design. However, it is generally more expensive to install because of the high cost of running field wiring inside a conduit, which must be sealed between the safe and hazardous areas. It is also often physically larger and much heavier than an intrinsically safe solution. Flameproof equipment is also more difficult and time-consuming to maintain because either the area must be known to be non-hazardous, or the equipment must have the energy drained before covers can be removed. Hot permits are required to perform maintenance work on these systems. Further, when covers are reinstalled, extra care must be taken that fasteners are precisely torqued to specified values. 22 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide Associated Electrical Equipment At least one circuit of the associated electrical equipment is intrinsically safe. Sensors connected to the intrinsically safe circuit can be in the hazardous area. How-ever the associated electrical equipment must not be in the hazardous area without further protection types. The type of protection is placed in the square brackets. Typical marking: [Ex ib] IIC. Ex d Figure 8: Explosion proof enclosure Increased Safety – Ex e The principal of increased safety is to ensure reliable prevention of unacceptably high temperatures and sparks or electrical arcs. The equipment usually has a maximum voltage, which is rating to 11 kV. The basic design requirements to construction and protection principles are described in the IEC 60079-7 standard. An enclosure must be constructed to withstand mechanical impact and pro-vide a specified degree of ingress protection (IP Rating). Two fundamental requirements of increased safety protection are that the equipment shall be protected to IP54 minimum for gas / vapor and IP6X for dust hazards. This method of protection can be used in both Zone 1 and Zone 2/Division 2 hazardous areas. Therefore, it is also often preferred to flameproof protection method “Ex d” due to the need for reduced levels of maintenance and inspection. Another major consideration is that increased safety equipment is often constructed from light-weight materials, which often leads to lower cost. Non-Sparking – Ex n Non–sparking protection is regulated by the IEC 60079-15 European standard. The nonsparking enclosure is permitted for use only in Zone 2/Division 2 hazardous areas. It is considered incendive so that it does not generate arcs or sparks or dangerous tem-peratures in normal operation. Internal component temperatures must be controlled and wiring connections must be selected with “non-sparking” in mind. The concept has simi-larities with the “increased safety – Ex e” philosophy but it is suitable only for Zone 2/Di-vision 2 hazardous areas. The equipment approved to “non-sparking” is not designed to withstand explosion and will usually employ a light enclosure metallic construction with a high ingress protection level. Encapsulation – Ex m IEC 60079-18 gives the specific requirements for the construction, testing and marking of electrical equipment, parts of electrical equipment and Ex components with the type of protection encapsulation "m" intended for use in explosive gas atmospheres or explosive dust atmospheres. This part applies only for encapsulated electrical equipment, encapsulated parts of electrical equipment and encapsulat ed Ex components, always referred to as "m" equipment. Pressurized – Ex p Pressurized or purged equipment, which is type “p,” relies on a combination of a positive static pressure applied inside of enclosure and a continuous flow of air or inert gas to expel any explosive mixture that may have entered inside. The system reliesa on purging schedules and monitoring systems to ensure the reliability and effectiveness of the overall protection. The IEC EN 60079-2 standard describes the requirements and design considerations. Figure 9. Increased safety enclosure Ex n Figure 10. Non-sparking enclosure Ex m Figure 11: Encapsulation enclosure Ex p Figure 12: Pressurized enclosure Oil Immersion – Ex o Permitted only in Zone 2/Division 2 areas where the likelihood of a flammable atmosphere is remote. The type “o” equipment or enclosures use the concept where the sparking components are inserted in oil and controlled venting is also a feature. Ex o Figure 13: Oil immersion enclosure ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 23 Electrical Equipment Marking 4.2 Marking of Electrical Equipment Solutions to automate the truck scale enable faster processing time, improve driver safety and help to reduce emissions from idling trucks. We have solutions from weigh-in-motion scales to transaction management software. Streamlining processes now can ensure readiness to meet increased demand while saving time and money in the process. ATEX CE Marking Marking is mandatory and must be placed on equipment before it is assigned to be distributed in the market or put into service. The intention is to facilitate the free movement of equipment within the European Union by signifying that essential health and safety standards have been met. It is a declaration that the product was produced in conformity with all applicable provisions and requirements of the Directive 2014/34/EU and that the product has been the subject of the appropriate conformity assessment procedures. The ATEX 2014/34/EU Directive specifies the minimum requirements for marking that must be implemented. Further information and requirements to marking of equipment for use in hazardous areas are given in the European standards. The IEC EN 60079-0 standard defines the requirements on electrical equipment for use in explosive atmospheres. 24 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide Marking Description II (2) [Ex ib] The brackets show that the product must be installed in the safe area but it can be connected to the equipment installed in the hazardous area The brackets indicate that the device must be installed in the safe area nA Non-sparking equipment; does not generate a spark during normal operation ic Energy limited, intrinsically safe during normal operation Table 14: Additional markings for electrical equipment (ATEX 2014/34/EU) ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 25 Electrical Equipment Marking NEC Marking Essentially, the NEC markings contain similar sets of information as ATEX markings; however, it is important to note the differences and ensure that equipment in use in any hazardous environment conforms to all appropriate safety standards. The equipment classified for Division area are marked in accordance to the area that it is classified. Class I, II, III Div. 1 Group A-F T4 Ta Temperature range (if outside of default range in standard) Temperature Code (Chapter 3.4) Hazardous substance group (Chapter 3.3.1) Division classification (Chapter 3.3) Equipment class (Chaper 3.3) Equipment approved by notified body Figure 16: Example of electrical equipment marking according to NEC500 Alternative marking is used by classification of areas according to Zoning methodology. An example of the. equipment marking to NEC505 is shown in Figure 17. The equipment within the Zone method is marked in accordance with the type of protection used similar to ATEX methodology. It is then the responsibility of the user to apply the proper method of protection in each Zone ATEX CE Marking II 2G Ex ib IIC T4 Gb Equipment protection level Class I Temperature Code Ta Type of ignition protection method (Chapter 4) Equipment category and hazardous atmosphere - gas Symbol of explosion protection, American Standards Equipment group Hazardous area classification (Chapter 3.3) Indication that this is an explosion-protected device Equipment class (Chapter 3.3) Figure 14: Typical electrical equipment marking (gas) according to ATEX 2014/34/EU IIIC IIB T4 Hazardous substance group (Chapter 3.2) 'Ex' indicates compliance with explosion proof standards ib ib Temperature Code (Chapter 3.4) Type of ignition protection method 2D Ex AEx Ambient temperature Hazardous substance group II Zone 1 Equipment approved by notified body Figure 17: Example of electrical equipment marking according to NEC505 T55°C Db - Equipment protection level Maximum surface temperature Material Groups Type of ignition protection method 'Ex' indicates compliance with explosion proof standards Equipment category and hazardous atmosphere - gas Equipment group Indication that this is an explosion-protected device Figure 15: Typical electrical equipment marking (dust) according to ATEX 2014/34/EU 26 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 27 Installation and Maintenance 4.3 Electrical Equipment – Installation and Maintenance Hazardous Area Inspections When electrical equipment is installed in a hazardous environment, there are different inspection stages that must occur to ensure equipment does not become the ignition source in the “Triangle of Fire.” The Triangle of Fire refers to the three elements required for a fire to ignite: flammable substance ignition source and oxidizing agent (chapter 1). The first stage of inspection happens prior to equipment being brought into service. An initial inspection is performed to validate that equipment meets the requirements of the hazardous area. Those requirements are defined by the customer in accordance with specifications defined by the equipment manufacturer. Once hazardousarea equipment is installed, a periodic inspection schedule should be set to ensure the equipment still meets the initial inspection requirements later. Types of Inspection According to IEC 60079-17:2013 [ed5], there are five different inspection methods that ensure the continued reliability of plant equipment used in a hazardous environment: initial, visual, close, detailed and continuous supervision. Initial Inspection The initial inspection provides a thorough assessment that the selected type of protection and its installation are appropriate. This inspection is validated using the control diagram produced by the equipment manufacturer. This validation should be performed at installation, prior to equipment use. Deterioration of Equipment When determining periodic inspection intervals, additional consideration should be taken for the environment in which the equipment is used and potential equipment deterioration or degradation over time. Intrinsically safe equipment inspection schedule A Equipment Detailed Close Visual 1 P P P P P 3 Circuit and/or equipment documentation is appropriate to the EPL/zone requirements of the location Equipment installed is that specified in the documentation – fixed equipment only Circuit and/or equipment category and group correct P P 4 IP rating of equipment is appropriate to the Group III material present P P 5 Equipment temperature class is correct P P 6 Ambient temperature range of the apparatus is correct for the installation P P 7 Service temperature range of the apparatus is correct for the installation P P 8 Installation is clearly labeled P P 9 Enclosure, glass parts and glass-to-metal sealing gaskets and/or compounds are satisfactory Cable glands and blanking elements are the correct type, complete and tight – physical check– visual check There are no unauthorized modifications P 2 10 11 Visual Inspection (periodic) The least invasive assessment of hazardous-area equipment is the visual inspection. This inspection is performed while the equipment is energized and does not require the equipment to be isolated or any special tools. It evaluates potential defects that are obvious by sight. Close Inspection (periodic) Building upon the visual inspection, the close inspection is also performed while the equipment is energized. However, the close inspection reveals defects that would not be apparent by sight. This inspection requires the use of additional tools and, for example, identifies loose bolts. A close inspection is appropriate whenever regular maintenance is performed. Factors to Determine Periodic Inspection Intervals Accurately determining an appropriate periodic inspection interval is a complex issue. The type of installation application helps to determine the periodic inspection interval, along with manufacturer’s guidance and factors impacting equipment deterioration. There are two main types of installation applications hazardous-area equipment falls under: fixed installations and moveable (portable) equipment. Fixed Installations For intrinsically safe equipment installed in a fixed location, the maximum interval between periodic inspections should not exceed three years without seeking expert advice. Once an interval is determined, additional periodic inspections should be performed to support or modify the proposed interval. Moveable (Portable) Equipment Moveable or portable intrinsically safe equipment is more prone to damage or misuse than fixed installations and therefore the interval between periodic close inspections should be a maximum of every 12 months. Enclosures that are frequently opened, such as battery housings, should have a detailed inspection at least every six months. Additionally, all equipment should be visually inspected by a trained operator before use to ensure that it is not obviously damaged. 28 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH P P P P P P P P 12 There is no evidence of unauthorized modifications 13 P 14 Diode safety barriers, galvanic isolators, relays and other energy limiting devices are of the approved type, installed in accordance with the certification requirements and securely earthed where required Condition of enclosure gaskets is satisfactory 15 Electrical connections are tight P 16 Printed circuit boards are clean and undamaged P 17 The maximum voltage Um of the associated apparatus is not exceeded P P Detailed Close Visual P B Installation 1 Cables are installed in accordance with the documentation P 2 Cable screens are earthed in accordance with the documentation P 3 There is no obvious damage to cables P P P 4 Sealing of trunking, ducts, pipes and/or conduits is satisfactory P P P 5 Point-to-point connections are all correct (initial inspection only) P 6 P 7 Earth continuity is satisfactory (e.g. connections are tight, conductors are of sufficient cross-section) for non-galvanically isolated circuits Earth connections maintain the integrity of the type of protection 8 Intrinsically safe circuit earthing is satisfactory P 9 Insulation resistance is satisfactory P 10 P 12 Separation is maintained between intrinsically safe and non-intrinsically safe circuits in common distribution boxes or relay cubicles Short-circuit protection of the power supply is in accordance with the documentation Specific conditions of use (if applicable) are complied with 13 Cables not in use are correctly terminated P Detailed Close Visual P P P P P P 11 C Environment 1 Equipment is adequately protected against corrosion, weather, vibration and other adverse factors No undue external accumulation of dust and dirt 2 P P P Table 15: Inspection table for intrinsically safe installations METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 29 Weighing in Hazardous Areas 5. Weighing in Hazardous Areas Weighing is one of the most basic and important process variables in a vast majority of manufacturing processes. However, it can be one of the most challenging parameters to control. Accurate and consistent filling, dosing and batching reduce variability in the product, which ensures consistently high quality. To achieve reliable quality and reproducible results requires efficient capture and communication of weighing data to the existing plant network, which can be challenging due to hazardous-area requirements. To prevent any ignition and provide safe operation of electrical weighing systems in hazardous areas, one possibility is limiting energy to safe levels. To achieve low energy and prevent ignition, the main components of weighing systems, such as load cells, junction boxes and weighing indicators are designed for intrinsic safety. Intrinsically safe technology prevents explosions by ensuring that the energy in intrinsically safe circuits is well below the energy required to initiate an explosion. Intrinsically safe electrical equipment and wiring is designed and certified mostly for use in Zone 1/Division 1 hazardous areas if they are approved for the location. Intrinsically safe circuits often combine elements with the various safety levels. Depending on functionality and the classification of the safety level, the circuit elements can be applied either in hazardous or non-hazardous areas. 5.1 Basic System In hazardous production areas, there are many processes which require simple standalone weighing applications. Filling tanks, drums or bags with hazardous powders or liquids is one example. A simple weighing system usually consists of strain gauge (analog) or digital weighing platforms or load cells controlled and monitored directly through a PC installed in a safe area. The weighing signal is interpreted by the hazardous-area indicator and transferred to the safe area computer or printer. As all components of the weighing system are intrinsically safe, the weighing system is powered by an intrinsically safe power supply. Communicating the weighing signal from the Zone 1/21, Division 1 to the safe area requires energy-limiting devices referred to as intrinsically safe barriers. These are barriers installed in the safe area that interface with the communication device to prevent excess energy from a fault occurring on the safe side from crossing over to the hazardous area. Entity parameters of intrinsically safe equipment This determines if the peripheral device is safe for connection to the intrinsically safe equipment. Entity parameters are usually found on the control drawing of the intrinsically safe device supplied by the manufacturer or on the Examination Certificate (see Table 16). There are some differences in the abbreviations of US Class/Division and Europe Zone classification. The US Class / Division system uses the abbreviation of entity parameters like VOC, ISC, and LA. In Europe, the safety parameters are referred to as VO, IO, CO, etc. Intrinsically safe weighing terminal (Intrinsically safe apparatus) Intrinsically safe barrier or communication module (associated apparatus) Open circuit voltage (Voc) ≤ Vmax Short circuit current (Isc) ≤ Imax Allowed capacitance (Ca) ≥ Ci + Ccable Allowed inductance (La) ≥ Li + Lcable Maximum Power (Po) ≤ Pi Table 16: Entity parameters of intrinsically safe equipment and associated equipment Benefits Limitations - Simple application through RS232 interface - Cost efficiency - Precise signal response - Small barrier footprint - Short signal distance (15 – 20 m max) - Safety barrier requires securely implemented earthing system. Basic System Example Hazardous Area Non-Hazardous Area Under normal operating conditions, intrinsically safe barriers have no arcing or heat-producing contacts, and if specially marked, they can be installed in the Zone 2/22, Division 2. In fault conditions, the barriers limit voltage and current to levels that are not sufficient to ignite the hazardous atmosphere Weighing Terminal - IDNet 3 components of these barriers PC connection SICSPro Interface Power Supply COM 1 - Intr. Safe RS232 1 The Zener diode, which limits the voltage to a value referred to as an open circuit voltage (VOC) Intr. safe RS232 2 A resistor, which limits the current to a specific value known as a short circuit current (ISC) Serial RS232 Zener barrier Digital platform IDNet 3 The fuse, which limits the maximum current that can flow through the diodes. When the Power supply current flows through diode, the fuse will blow. This interrupts the circuit and prevents the All apparatuses require equipotential bonding. All earthing points to the same location. diode from failing. As a result, the excess voltage does not reach the hazardous area. Figure 18: Direct RS232 communication in the safe area 30 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 31 Weighing in Hazardous Areas 5.2 Advanced System In the case of advanced data communication capabilities, such as communicating via Ethernet or programmable logic controller (PLC), the amount of transferred data can be increased. This requires a more powerful and sophisticated interface between the hazardous and safe area, as well as more powerful and sophisticated communication modules themselves. The intrinsically safe current loop interface performs best when large amounts of data must be communicated from the hazardous to the safe area. Figure 19 shows an example of advanced system set-up. Safe area communication is achieved by the intrinsically safe communication module, which has a functional principal that is based on a current loop interface. The current loop interface provides one or two full channels of bidirectional communication and is designed to use a copper-wire cable. High speed transmitters and receivers are used to increase data throughput. When combined with the communication module and its options, this permits remote operation in the safe area with Ethernet and PLC interfaces at distances up to 300 meters (1,000 ft.) from the intrinsically safe weighing indicator. Benefits Limitations - Long signal distance (up to 300M) - Enhanced high-speed data communication - Larger barrier footprint - Additional wiring Process Control Handling, filling, dosing, blending or batching of hazardous liquids or solids requires precise control. Small process changes can have a big impact on end-product quality. Variations in proportions, speed, flow, turbulence and many other factors must be carefully and consistently controlled to produce the desired end-product with a minimum of raw materials and energy. Process control through discrete internal Inputs/Outputs (I/Os) keeps the weighing process running within specified limits and allows more precise target limits to be set to maximize profitability and ensure quality and safety. Remote I/O technology can be a cost-efficient and flexible solution for data control in processing plants. However, good management of this type of system is particularly critical for hazardous areas where explosion protection measures for all system components are generally required 5.3 Active / Active Control In the case of active/active control (Figure 20), both active inputs and active outputs are installed in the hazardous area. Signal inputs are powered internally by the weighing terminal and are designed to be used with simple switches housed within the hazardous area. Signal outputs are also powered by the weighing terminal and provide 12V switching at 50mA total. These outputs are intended for use with extremely low power, intrinsically safe solenoids or piezo fluid control valves. Advanced System Example Active / Active Control Example Non-Hazardous Area Hazardous Area Non-Hazardous Area Hazardous Area Intrinsically safe control valve Up to 8 x active outputs / 12VDC max. 50mA total ACM500 - CL Weighing Indicator Power Supply Analog Interface COM 4 -CL Power Supply COM 5 -CL ACM500 - CL Weighing Indicator Power Supply Power Supply COM 4 -CL Analog Interface COM 5 -CL COM 1 - RS232 Analog platform COM 4 -CL COM 5 -CL ETHERNET COM 4 -CL COM 2 - RS232 COM 5 -CL COM 3 - RS232/422/485 ETHERNET COM 2 - RS232 COM 3 - RS232/422/485 I/O RS232 Printer RS232 RS232 PC connection Switch Remote terminal (Tare, Print, Zero, Clear) RS232 Power supply Junction box PC connection Remote display Power supply All apparatuses require equipotential bonding. All earthing points to the same location. All apparatuses require equipotential bonding. All earthing points to the same location. Figure 19: Current loop communication 32 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide Figure 20: Active / active control with internal discrete I/O module ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 33 Weighing in Hazardous Areas 5.4 Active / Passive Control 5.5 Passive Input / Passive Output Control In the active input/passive output set-up (Figure 21), active input controls are installed in the hazardous area. The passive outputs are usually high-voltage solenoids, which are not approved for hazardous-location use and must therefore be considered for installation in the safe area. Passive inputs allow connection of an external intrinsically safe voltage supply to power switches or other simple devices to trigger the input. Passive inputs can be used when the input signal is coming from the safe area or some other type of active device, such as a PLC. The protective switch amplifier provides controls passive outputs and high voltage solenoids or other controls in the safe area. The external switch amplifier receives a high voltage and converts it into an intrinsically safe voltage to send to the weighing indicator in the hazardous area. Passive outputs remain isolated while signaling to switch the higher AC or DC voltage through the switch amplifier. Both active inputs and passive outputs are powered by the intrinsically safe weighing indicator, which is installed in the hazardous area. The indicator, in turn, is powered through the external intrinsically safe power supply, which meets hazardous-area requirements. Passive Input / Passive Output Control Example Active / Passive Control Example Non-Hazardous Area Hazardous Area Non-Hazardous Area Hazardous Area ACM500 - CL ACM500 - CL Weighing Indicator Power Supply Weighing Indicator Power Supply Power Supply COM 4 -CL Power Supply COM 4 -CL Analog Interface COM 5 -CL Analog Interface COM 5 -CL COM 1 - RS232 COM 4 -CL COM 5 -CL Simple switch Up to 8 active inputs (3 Standard + 5 Optional) active inputs The simple switch can be protected by the galvanically isolated type of barrier. The barrier provides complete isolation and limits the high voltage coming from the switch, converting it to intrinsically safe voltage before sending it back to the I/O module in the hazardous area (Figure 22).The entity values of the safety barrier or the external power supply must be compared to the entity parameters of the intrinsically safe weighing indicator passive inputs. Slot 1 COM 1 - RS232 ETHERNET COM 2 - RS232 COM 3 - RS232/422/485 Slot 1 COM 4 -CL ETHERNET COM 5 -CL COM 2 - RS232 COM 3 - RS232/422/485 I/O I/O Switching amplifier Switching amplifier PLC Control valve Up to 11 passive outputs (3 standard + 8 optional) to external switching amplifiers Control valve Up to 11 passive outputs (3 standard + 8 optional) to external switching amplifiers PLC Galvanically isolated barrier Junction box Simple switch Junction box Power supply All apparatuses require equipotential bonding. All earthing points to the same location. Figure 21: Active input / passive output valve control 34 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide Power supply All apparatuses require equipotential bonding. All earthing points to the same location. Figure 22: Passsive input / passive output valve control ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 35 Weighing in Hazardous Areas 5.6 Fully Integrated Process Control To increase efficiency, reduce variability and ensure maximum safety, fully integrated process control is the method of choice. For example, in multipurpose plants where several components are filled, mixed, blended and dispensed at the same time, an internal I/O system supporting 12 inputs and 18 outputs can be the right choice. To achieve the maximum number of I/Os, safe-area active remote modules can be used. These mod-ules are not approved for installation in the hazardous area. Active remote modules can switch the high voltage to control the energy in the hazardous area and require advanced intrinsically safe communication modules, which serve both as a safety barrier and provide enhanced Ethernet communication. The current loop interface provides two-channel bidirectional communications to the hazardous area. Weighing data can be stored on the PC through the Ethernet communication or the system can be connected to the PLC using Profibus (Figure 23). Optional Safe-Area Peripheral Communications Depending on weighing process requirements and the degree of automation required, different communication possibilities allow efficient communication to the safe area. When defining data transfer requirements to efficiently communicate weighing results to higher level manufacturing execution systems (MES) or enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems, several points must be considered: • What type of information will be communicated between the weighing indicator and automation system? • What triggers initiate data transfer and how frequently will communication be made? • What are the present data format requirements? Are those requirements flexible? • What is the current communication medium? Are there other viable options? • How might data format requirements or the communication medium evolve in the foreseeable future? The key to data integration is having the correct connection to your wider control system. Whether it is a PLC, MES or an ERP system, connection requirements for hardware and software differs. Options include fieldbus interfaces, such as analog output, Profibus, DeviceNet or EtherNet/IP; and data interfaces such as Ethernet TCP/IP or serial interface communication. When purchasing a new weighing system, the data integration capabilities must match the data requirements of the wider manufacturing system. METTLER TOLEDO offers two different possibilities of communication in the safe area that can meet these system requirements. Fully Integrated Process Control Example Non-Hazardous Area Hazardous Area ACM500 - CL Weighing Terminal Power Supply Power Supply COM 4 -CL SICSPro Interface COM 5 -CL COM 1 - RS232 Slot 1 ETHERNET COM 4 -CL Advanced weighing applications require enhanced control as well as enhanced safe area communication. The communication module ACM500 plays an important role for such application types providing several optional interfaces from RS232 to PLC data integration. COM 2 - RS232 COM 5 -CL Intrinsically safe control valve Up to 8 x active outputs / 12VDC max. 50mA total The basic ACM 200 communication module approved for the safe area installation provides the connective link between the weighing system installed in the certified hazardous area and the computer, printer or remote-control indicator in the safe area. This module provides a flexible choice between different communication interfaces such as RS232, RS422, RS485 and CL20mA. COM 3 - RS232/422/485 If PLC data integration is not required, PC-based serial or Ethernet TCP/IP data communication options become viable. I/O Ex Control valve Simple switch Simple switch Up to 8 active inputs Up to 3 x ARM 100 modules Maximum 12 inputs & 18 outputs PC connection Zener barrier Digital platform IDNet Power supply All apparatuses require equipotential bonding. All earthing points to the same location. Figure 24: Communication modules: ACM200 (left) and ACM500 (right) Figure 23: Fully integrated process control 36 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 37 Summary and References 6 Summary References Safety is crucial for businesses that operate in potentially explosive environments. Standards and regulations play an important role in these hazardous manufacturing venues by specifying the framework of conditions that guide both equipment manufacturers and operators to help ensure safety in manufacturing. • C22.1-12 - Canadian electrical code, part I (22nd edition): Safety standard for electrical installations • Electrical apparatus for use in the presence of combustible dust • Directive 2014/34/EU on equipment and protective systems intended for use in potentially explosive atmospheres (ATEX); European Parliament and the Council • Directive 1999/92/EC on minimum requirements for improving the safety and health protection of workers potentially at risk from explosive atmosphere (ATEX); European Parliament and of the Council • IEC 60079-0:2017 Ed. 7.0; Explosive atmospheres - Part 0: Equipment - General requirements • IEC 60079-10-1:2015 Ed. 2.0; Explosive atmospheres - Part 10-1: Classification of areas - Explosive gas atmospheres • IEC 60079-10-2:2015 Ed. 2.0; Explosive atmospheres - Part 10-2: Classification of areas - Combustible dust atmospheres • EC 60079-11 Ed. 6.0 b:2011; Explosive atmospheres - Part 11: Equipment protection by intrinsic safety "i" • IEC 60079-17 Ed. 5.0 b:2013; Explosive atmospheres - Part 17: Electrical installations inspection and maintenance • IEC 60079-26:2014 Ed. 3.0; Explosive atmospheres - Part 26: Equipment with equipment protection level (EPL) Ga • National Electrical Code, Article 500, NFPA 70, 2011, Delmar: National Electric Code • National Electrical Code, Article 505, NFPA 70, 2011, Delmar: National Electric Code Many standards that are applied worldwide are based on other standards. While standards are similar throughout the world, there is still no uniform global standard. Furthermore, symbols on the respective labels differ. Therefore, products sold globally also must have various certifications for different explosion-risk environments. Many countries in Southeast Asia and Latin America have no local standards of their own and accept international and national IECEx, ATEX and FM approvals. However, locations such as China, Korea, Japan and Russia have local certification requirements to which equipment must be adhered, although primary certification schemes may be accepted for most purposes, depending on the nation. Weighing is an important component of many manufacturing processes, and it requires special attention when conducted in hazardous areas. Though weighing system components may be both intrinsically safe and nonintrinsically safe depending on where and how they are used, it is crucial to ensure they have an appropriate level of safety and provide required communication possibilities. There are several options when it comes to ignition protection in hazardous environments. Installing intrinsically safe weighing equipment is the safest method. It safely facilitates activities in the hazardous area and is low maintenance. When fire or explosive incidents occur, the units can be serviced without halting production, and it eliminates heat and sparks in the production area. METTLER TOLEDO focuses on development of intrinsically safe weighing systems. The intrinsically safe weighing solutions provide the benefits of modularity for a wide range of weighing platforms, weighing modules and control terminals. It also offers flexibility with various communication interfaces, such as serial interfaces and wide range of Fieldbuses. Additional METTLER TOLEDO Resources • Hazardous Area Resource Portal: } www.mt.com/ind-hazardous-compliance • Poster: Hazardous-Area Equipment Marking • eBook: How to Avoid Dust Explosions • On Demand Webinars: "Standards and Regulations" and "Hazardous-Area Protection Measures • Catalog: Weighing Solutions for Hazardous Areas Moreover, the weighing equipment is developed for use in hazardous areas and has obtained approvals on the global level, including IECEx, ATEX, and FM, which are accepted in most countries. 38 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 39 Service Offering Our extensive service network is among the best in the world and ensures maximum availability and service life of your product. Explore Our Service Solutions Tailored to Fit Your Equipment Needs METTLER TOLEDO Service delivers resources to enhance your efficiency, performance, and productivity by providing service packages that fit your operational needs, maximize your equipment lifetime, and protect your investment. ` www.mt.com/IND-Service Start with professional installation Installation services include support for your unique production situation: • Professional IQ/OQ/PQ/MQ documentation • Initial calibration and confirmation of fit-for-purpose • Hazardous area installations Calibrate for quality and compliance The professional Accuracy Calibration Certificate (ACC) determines measurement uncertainty in use over the entire weighing range. Corresponding annexes gives a clear pass/fail statement for specific tolerances applied, such as fit-for-purpose (GWP®), OIML R76, NTEP HB44, or further regulations. Extend your warranty coverage Add two years of preventive maintenance and repair coverage to protect your equipment purchase and achieve maximum productivity and budget control. Schedule maintenance Full preventative maintenance plans offer inspection, functional testing, and proactive replacement of worn parts. Health inspections offer a full assessment of current equipment condition with professional maintenance recommendations. Maintain accuracy over time Receive professional guidance (GWP® VerificationTM), including a routine testing plan that specifies four key factors to maximize your efficiency and ensure quality: • Tests to perform • Weights to use • Testing frequency • Tolerances to apply 40 METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH ©2023 Mettler-Toledo GmbH METTLER TOLEDO - Hazardous Area Guide 41 Additional Resources for Success Industrial Weighing YouTube Channel METTLER TOLEDO's Industrial Solutions YouTube Channel is dedicated entirely to helping you maximize yield and improve your weighing process. www.youtube.com/MTindustrial Truck Scale Buying Guide This comprehensive guide has everything you need to know when designing your next weighbridge. www.mt.com/TruckScaleGuide Raw Materials Resource Library Discover in-depth white papers, guides, brochures and more to help you streamline your weighing operation www.mt.com/ind-raw-materials-library Tank Weighing Handbook This handbook offers more than 150 fact-filled pages to help you create an ideal weighing and inventory control system. www.mt.com/ind-system-handbook www.mt.com/ind-hazcat For more information METTLER TOLEDO Group Industrial Division Local contact: www.mt.com/contacts Subject to technical changes © 06/2023 METTLER TOLEDO. All rights reserved Document No. 30220321 C MarCom Industrial