SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Module 1: Introduction to Media and Information Literacy At the end of the module, I can: 1. Describe the nature of communication and the concepts related to it. 2. Describe how communication is affected by media and information. 3. Identify the similarities and differences of media literacy, information literacy, and technology literacy. 4. Editorialize the value of being a media and information literate individual. 5. Relate critical thinking with media and information literacy in the production, consumption and transfer of media, and information products by the society. 6. Identify the characteristics of responsible users and competent producers of media and information. 7. Share media habits, lifestyle, and preferences to other people. Without consulting other sources of information, ask yourself what the following words mean to you: Communication Media Information Technology Literacy Try to compare your own understanding of these terms to those presented in this module. How similar or different are your ideas with those in the discussion? You have heard time and again the adage “No man is an island.” What does this saying really mean to you? How do you feel when you are alone? And you have no one else to talk to or share your thoughts with? How about if you accidentally left your mobile phone at home, or you are not able to connect to the internet and chat with your friends? Do you feel a sense of distance or disconnection from the world? Humans are social beings. Despite the few occasions of solitude, chatting with friends either face-to-face, through a telephone, or online seems to be a more likable situation to be in. People value the simplest opportunities to communicate not just with themselves, but most especially with other people. Communication is a natural and inescapable fact of life. Every individual is born with it. This is precisely the reason why you are taught to learn how to speak, read, write, or use communication gadgets at an early age. Communication is all about these skills your parents would like you to learn when you were younger. Defining Communication Littlejohn and Foss (2008), who are scholars and experts in the field, regard communication as “one of those everyday activities that is intertwined with all of human life so completely that we sometimes overlook its pervasiveness, importance, and complexity.” They suggest that communicating feels so natural to people that oftentimes the act itself is taken for granted. Whether it is through verbal or nonverbal, or at this day and age, digital, humans are creatures of expression. This is so, by necessity and desire. People communicate to be more closely integrated with and to the society they belong to. You communicate because expressing yourself means contributing ideas for whatever purpose or cause; but first, you must understand the concept of communication. Perhaps one good way to do so is by looking at the origin of the word. Communication is from the Latin term communicare, which means “to share” or “to divide out.” It may also be thought to originate from another Latin word communis, which roughly means “working together.” 1 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT You now begin to understand that communication has a lot to do with a sense of sharing. As explained by Bulan and de Leon (2002) in their book Practical Speech Fundamentals, “without speech or oral communication, societies could not attain levels of civilization; communities could not organize into living and working groups, mark and ritualize practices and traditions, debate and decide difficult issues, and transform society for its good.” Essentially, what they tell you is that communication functions in more ways than you can imagine. Explaining the Communication Process through Models To understand better the process of communication, here are some models as discussed by communication scholar Denis McQuail (2005) in his book McQuail’s Mass Communication Theory: 1. Transmission Models. Perhaps the most popular among these is Harold Laswell’s representation of communication as an attempt to answer the question “Who says what to whom, through what medium, and with what effect?” One such revision is a model by Claude Shannon and Warren Weaver which incorporates the concept of noise that refers to anything that interferes with the message. The model is a more mechanical look at communication. Fig. 1.2. Shannon Weaver’s Communication Model Another transmission model is by Bruce Westley and Malcolm Maclean, Jr. Where they argued that instead of a having a sender merely relaying messages, you have a communicator who relays his or her account of a selection of events or views/voices in society. Westley and Maclean, Jr. Also said that communication is “guided by interests and demands of an audience that is known only by its selections and responses to what is offered (McQuail, 2005).” Fig. 1.1. Laswell’s Communication Model The model is relatively straightforward and tells you that communication originates from someone and their message flows through a channel, either through sound waves or light waves, and that someone on the other end receives the message with a corresponding effect. Later improvements in the model were introduced by other experts in communication Fig. 1.3. Westley and Maclean Model of Communication 2 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT A more sophisticated transmission model was provided by George Gerbner where “someone perceives an event and reacts in a situation through some means to make available materials in some form and context conveying content of some consequence (McQuail, 1985).” Relating these transmissions] models to your own communication experiences: for example, you are telling a story to a friend; your primary intention is to successfully get across the story from you to him or her as accurately and as clearly as possible so that he or she can respond accordingly. Can you think of any other instances where you see the application of these transmission models? 2. Ritual or expressive model. This is an alternative way of looking at how communication works. In the expressive model, communication happens due to the need to share understanding and emotions. Communication has an integrative consequence in the society it is done to build social relationships. An example would be when you use certain symbolisms or euphemisms to indirectly refer to certain things, but you are sure that your audience still understands what you are trying to say. The communication is ritualized because the meaning is suggested more than explicitly stated and the understanding of it, though connotative, is mutual. 3. Publicity Model. This model explains that communication involves audiences as “spectators rather than participants or information receivers (McQuail, 2005).” Attention is important because it is a measure of how successful the communication has transpired. Imagine yourself telling a friend about a potentially boring story but you tell it in a compelling and animated manner to keep his interest and attention. Another example is how television commercials aggressively convince the audience to buy the products that they advertise. 4. Reception Model. In this model, you come to understand communication as an open process, which means that messages sent and received are open to various interpretations based on context and the culture of the receiver. In other words, there might be various meanings to a single statement that is communicated. One such model illustrating this is Wilburs Schramm’s depiction of cyclical communication where the sender and receiver have alternating roles in the loop. A communicator who produces and sends the message is called an “encoder” and the one who receives and interprets is the “decoder.” Fig. 1.4. Schramm’s Model Another reception model is the one by David Berlo that accounted for factors that affect how communicators are influenced when they send and receive a message. These factors include the following: Communication skills such as reading, writing, speaking, listening, and watching. Knowledge about a subject or topic. Attitude toward the topic and the audience. Social and cultural aspects that influence the content of the message and the manner by which it is sent. 3 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT all the more made possible through the use of media. Ponder on one of those occasions where you read a magazine, watched a program on television, listened to the radio, went to see a film at a movie house, or surfed the Internet. Any such activity involves media, information, and communication. In a sense, you cannot do away with communicating, that is, getting and sharing information and utilizing media to achieve both. A Closer Look at Media and Information Have you ever wondered what word mediate means? The base word of this term is media. Like communication, media have been defined in several ways by different sources. Strictly speaking, media is the plural form of medium, although the former is already acceptable as a singular noun. Take a look at Table 1.2 for some of these definitions of media and a description of categories of media in Table 1.3. Table 1.1. Berlo’s Model The reception models show that it is not just about saying the message but also considering how the message may be received because of factors that may influence reception. That is why when someone breaks a bad news to someone else, he or she does not say it as straightforward and blatant. He or she will have to consider how the other person will react to the news or what possible interpretations the other person might have about the news. Media and Information: The Means and the Ends in Communication What is evident among all the models discussed is that there are many ways of defining what communication is or how it works. But you have probably observed two distinct elements that are intrinsically interconnected with the concept of communication media and information. They are so intertwined that information is one of the reasons why communication is done in the first place; and this information can be shared through media. When you further study communication in a more advanced level, you would learn that one of the functions of communication is to inform. This is Table 1.2. Different Definitions of Media Source Definition Oxford Learner’s The main ways that large numbers of people Dictionaries receive information and entertainment, that is television, radio, newspaper, and the internet. UNESCO Media and Refers to the combination of physical objects Information Literacy used to communicate or mass communication Curriculum for through physical objects such as radio, television, Teachers computers, or film, etc. Also refers to any physical object used to communicate media messages. Source of credible information in which contents are provided through an editorial process determined by journalistic values and therefore editorial accountability can be attributed to an organization or a legal person. 4 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT The Penguin Dictionary of Media Studies (2007) David Buckingham (2003), director of the London University Centre for the Study of Children, Youth and Media (Callison & Tilley, (2006) Encyclopedic Dictionary of Semiotics, Media, and Communications (2000) Presidential Decree No. 1018 (1976) Means of distributing texts and messages to a large mass of people. Carries a certain degree of intellectual baggage or currency with it. Something we use when we want to communicate with people indirectly, rather than in person or by face-to-face contact. Provide channels through which representations and images of the world can be communicated indirectly. Any means, agency, or instrument of communication. The physical means by which a sign or text is encoded (put together) and through which it is transmitted (delivered, actualized) Refers to the print medium of communication, which includes all newspapers, periodicals, magazines, journals, and publications and all advertising therein, and billboards, neon signs and the like, and the broadcast medium of communication, which includes radio and television broadcasting in all their aspects and all other cinematographic or radio promotions and advertising. Table 1.3. Categories of Media Category Examples Modality Text, audio, video, graphics, animations Format Digital or analog Way of transmitting Electromagnetic or radio waves, light waves Mass media form TV, radio, print, Internet, telephone, or mobile Media modality refers to the nature of message, whether it is relayed using text, audio, video, graphics, animation, or a combination of any of these things. The media format is the way the data is arranged. The data or message may be transmitted through radio waves (for audio) and light waves for other modalities. The mass media form refers to the particular media technology to which the message is transmitted. All the definitions of media suggest that it is a conduit for transmitting something called information. With the proliferation of media technology, you are bombarded with numerous information from a vast collection of sources that you are hardly able to distinguish what is useful to you and what you can discard. There may be occasions where you even get confused as to where to start looking for information that you need. One of the more convenient sources of information nowadays is the World Wide Web. But with the volume of information it provides comes the challenge of choosing which to use. This presents a problem in communication because sharing wrong, inaccurate, or lacking information distorts the quality of your message to your audience. But before you begin to identify the information you need and the places to look for it, you have to be familiar with the nature of information. The UNESCO Media and Information Literacy Curriculum for Teachers regard information as a “broad term that can cover data, knowledge derived from study, experience, or instruction, signals or symbols.” when you use media, information is referred to as the “knowledge of specific events or situations that has been gathered or received by communication, intelligence, or news reports.” As can be seen in the communication models presented earlier, media serves as a source and a channel for relaying information. Information is the content that you share during communication. Thus, the ubiquity of communication, media, and information makes it imperative for you to be 5 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT skilled in the access and use of each of these. This is where media and information literacy enters the picture. Media, Information, and Technology Literacy: Laying the Groundwork In general terms, you may come to understand literacy to be equivalent to a skill. The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, or UNESCO, defined literacy as the “ability to identify, understand, interpret, create, communicate, and compute, using printed and written materials associated with varying contexts.” Table 1.4. Definition of Media Literacy, Information Literacy, and Technology Literacy Media Literacy (UNESCO Media and Information Literacy Curriculum for Teachers) Information Literacy (UNESCO Media and Information Literacy Curriculum for Teachers) Technology (Digital) Literacy (University of Illinois) This involves understanding and using mass media in either an assertive or non-assertive way, including an informed and critical understanding of media, what techniques they employ and their effects. The ability to read, analyze, evaluate and produce communication in a variety of media forms, e.g. television, print, radio, computers, etc. Another understanding of the term is the ability to decode, analyze, evaluate, and produce communication in a variety of forms. Refers to the ability to recognize when information is needed and to locate, evaluate, effectively use, and communicate information in its various formats. This is the ability to use digital technology, communication tools or networks to locate, evaluate, use, and create information. It also refers to the ability to understand and use information in multiple formats from a wide range of sources when it is presented via computers and to a person’s ability to perform tasks effectively in a digital environment. Digital literacy includes the ability to read and interpret media, to reproduce data and images through digital manipulation, and to evaluate and apply new knowledge gained from digital environments. Technology advances every now and then, and literacy is a measure of how well you keep up with the pace of these advancements. With the multitude of technological platforms for social, cultural, and political participation, literacy in media, information, and technology is a recipe for success. From the simple choice of clothes to buy, or food to eat, or to the more complex ones such as ideas to include in a research or an opinion to be shared in a discussion, you consult and, perhaps, rely on media and other forms of technology for information you need. As UNESCO puts it, “a literate community is a dynamic community, one that exchanges ideas and engages debate; illiteracy, however, is an obstacle to a better quality of life and can even breed exclusion and violence.” The Danger of Desensitization According to Potter (2011) in his book Media Literacy, there is a need to be media and information literate to counteract “the physiological and psychological tendency (automaticity) towards the much information that is encountered every now and then.” Automaticity, or automatic response, is “a state where our minds operate without any conscious effort from us.” In other 6 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT words, you become so desensitized with the things you encounter because they already seem so natural to you. Potter also explained that “the programmed and predictable response (normalization) toward the information that limits your opportunity to recognize and maximize the gains of that message” is something that media and information literacy can address. Normalization is when “the mass media continually reinforce certain behavioral patterns of exposure until they become automatic habits.” According to Callison and Tilley (2006), you are a media and information literate individual if you are able to do the following: Pose worthwhile questions Evaluate the adequacy of an argument Recognize facts, inferences, and opinions and use each appropriately Deal with quandaries and ill-formed problems that have no fixed or unique solutions Give and receive criticism constructively Agree and disagree in degrees measured against the merits of the issue and audience Extend a line of thought beyond the range of first impressions Articulate a complex position without adding to its complexity We live in an environment that is far different from any environment humans have ever experienced before. And the environment changes at an ever-increasing pace. This is due to the accelerating generation of information and the sharing of that information through the increasing number of media channels and the heavy traffic of media vehicles traversing those channels. Messages are being delivered to everyone, everywhere, constantly. We are all saturated with information, and each year the media are more aggressive in seeking our attention. It is a hopeless expectation to keep up with all the information available. The most important challenge now lies in making good selections when the media are constantly offering us thousands of messages on any given topic. What It Takes to Be Media and Information Literate There are two factors that can influence you to become a media and information literate individual. One is clarifying your goals and motivations for seeking information. The greater your need, the more effort you exert to become selective of the information at your disposal. Another is acquiring more skills in discerning, appreciating, and filtering information. This involves being more media savvy and better acquainted with information sources. Table 1.5 shows the typology of media literacy provided by Potter (2011) which can help you assess the stage you are in as media and information literate individual. Table 1.5 Typology of media literacy. Stage Acquiring Fundamentals Characteristics Learning that there are human beings and other physical things apart from one’s self; these things looks different and serve different functions. Learning the meaning of facial expressions and natural sounds Recognizing shapes, form, size, color, movement, and spatial relations Recognizing rudimentary concept of time-regular patterns 7 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Language Acquisition Narrative Acquisition Developing Skepticism Intensive Development Recognizing speech sounds and attach meaning to them Being able to reproduce speech sounds Orienting to visual and audio media Making emotional and behavior responses to music and sounds Recognizing certain characters in visual media and follow their movement. Developing understanding of differences between: - Fiction vs. Nonfiction - Ads vs. Entertainment - Real vs. Make-believe Understanding how to connect plot elements - By time sequencing - By motive-action-consequence Discounting claims made in ads Sharpening differences between likes and dislikes for shows,characters, and actions Making fun of certain characters even though those characters are not presented as foils in their shows Strongly motivated to seek out information on certain topics Developing a detailed set of information on particular topics (sports, politics, etc.) Has high awareness of utility of information and quick facility in processing information judged to be useful. Experiential Exploring Critical Appreciation Seeking out different forms of content and narratives Focusing on searching for surprises and new emotional, moral, and aesthetic reactions. Accepting messages on their own terms, then evaluating them within that sphere Developing very broad and detailed understanding of the historical, economic, political, and artistic contexts of message systems. Ability to make subtle comparisons and contrasts among many different message elements simultaneously Ability to construct a summary judgement about the overall strengths and weaknesses of a message 8 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Social Responsibility Taking a moral stand that certain messages are more constructive for society than others ; this is a multidimensional perspective based on through analyses of the media landscape Recognizing that there some actions an individual can take to make a constructive impact on society Source:http://uk.sagepub.com/sites/default/files/upm-binaries/34589_2.pdf(a ccessed16September2015) Critical Thinking: An Important Component of MIL As producers and consumers of information, you must displays the ability to evaluate the kind of information you access and share. This ability is known as critical thinking. Being critical means being capable of judging the merit of something based on certain standards or parameters. According to media scholar Art Silverblatt, there are eight fundamental elements of media literacy: 1. A critical thinking skill enabling audience members to develop independent judgments about media content 2. An understanding of the process of mass communication 3. An awareness of the impact of media on the individual and society 4. Strategies for analyzing and discussing media messages 5. An understanding of media content as a text that provides insight into our culture and our lives 6. The ability to enjoy, understand, and appreciate media content 7. Development of effective and responsible production skills 8. An understanding of the ethical and moral obligations of media practitioners Do you agree that these elements also pertain to attributes of a responsible user and a competent producer of mediated communication? The media literate person is in control of his or her media experiences because he or she understands the basic conventions of various media and enjoys their uses in a deliberately conscious manner. The media literate person understands the impact of music and special effects, for example, in heightening the drama of television program or film. However, this recognition does not lessen the enjoyment of the action. What Have I Learned So Far? 1. Who is a media and information literate individual? 2. How is critical thinking related to media and information literacy? 3. Write a 1000-word blog entry in the form of a reaction paper to discuss what you can contribute to your community and to your country if you are a media and information literate individual. You may use the following to guide you in developing your arguments: Media and information literacy as practiced on both personal and professional level Media and information literacy as expression of freedom of speech/expression Media and information literacy as tool for civic responsibility and nation-building Beyond Walls 1.1 Apply It in Real Life Imagine yourself to be a content writer for an online health magazine. You are commissioned by your editor to write an article about Garcinia cambogia which is a component of most slimming supplements. Your dilemma is that you are not familiar with it and your editor expects that you create a highly informative article! You have been given a tight deadline; thus, your only resort is to look for information online. You have been told by your editor that he will evaluate your article’s factual accuracy and quality of information before publishing it in the Web site. 9 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT How will you handle the situation knowing that you have no idea about the topic? How will you manage the diverse information available online? you are technologically or digitally literate, you are able to utilize different “digital technology, communication tools or networks to locate, evaluate, use, and create information.” Critical thinking is necessary for discerning the media source and the kind of information that you use. Beyond Walls 1.2 Go Online It has been mentioned earlier how critical thinking is important to an individual in evaluating the source and kind of information one needs. In the Web site below, you are to download and accomplish the critical evaluation survey as an exercise for testing the extent of your media and information literacy. http://www.schrockguide.net/uploads/3/9/2/2/392267/evalhigh.pdf(accessed on 16 September 2015) After answering the critical evaluation survey, find a partner in class and collaborate on writing a synthesis paper comparing your survey results. Use your learning on what it takes to be media and information literate as guide for your discussion in your paper. The paper should be saved as .doc or .pdf file and uploaded in a file sharing platform that your teacher has set up for your class. ESSENTIAL LEARNING Communication is a process that involves transmission of messages, performance of rituals, competing over attention, and reception of messages as dictated by context and culture. There are various attempts to explain the process and these explanations are presented through communication models. Apparent in most of these models are the concepts of media and information and how they relate to the process of communication. Media and Information are necessities of your communicative lives. When you understand and use various media forms to access information, you consider yourself media literate. An information literate person, on the other hand, is able “to recognize when information is needed and to locate, evaluate, effectively use, and communicate it in its various format.” When 10 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Module 2 The Evolution of Traditional to New Media At the end of this module, I can: 1. Identify traditional media and new media, and their relationships. 2. Assess the type of media in the Philippines vis-a-vis the normative theories of media. 3. Editorialize the roles and functions of media I democratic society. 4. Search latest theory on information and media. Over the years, media forms and the technology that come with them have involve dramatically. This display of ingenuity is a testament of how media has been ingrained in every human beings sensibility. Now take a look at this picture. What d you think does it suggest? Study the media forms indicated in the first column on the table below. Put a check mark on the corresponding cell identifying whether the media form is traditional or new. Media form Traditional Magazine Tabloid Broadsheet Paperback Novel Radio Television Online Video Games Web Video Portals Online Telephony and Messaging Capability New Fig 2.1. Evolution of Media The McLuhan Mantra Marshall McLuhan, Who is famous for the phrase “the medium is the message” and is the proponent of the media theory on technological determinism, believed that society is driven by changes in media and communication technology. McLuhan (2007) explained that society adapts to advances in technology. Thus, changing cultural, political, and even historical aspects of that society. Take for instance the case of a mobile phone and a computer. How did these two gadgets change the way people live their lives today? Some of you might think that it is almost unimaginable to revert back to the old times where these two did not yet exist. People who agree with the technological deterministic idea believe that media and communication have and will always significantly affect and change our way of life. The only thing constant and inevitable is change. Thus, some look at technology as an indication of progress. Social change is typically associated with technological advancement. As technology stabilizes, users and consumers adapt their behavior to the features and perceived benefits of this technology, oftentimes making people overly reliant to technology. 11 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Fig. 2.2. Evolution of Media Perceived by McLuhan (1962) The picture above illustrates McLuhan’s (1962) view of the evolution of media and communication technology. A media form that emerges from an older form has its features and format primarily patterned from the one that it followed. The internet is not exactly an original concept but rather a hybrid or derivative of the older forms such as print media, broadcast media, and film. The mobile phones are built on the old idea of telephony, and smart phones and tablets, on the idea of the internet and computer technology. Hot and Cold Media? In the language of McLuhan, “hot” media refer to the forms requiring little involvement from the audience and examples include film and television. They are hot because, metaphorically speaking, they cannot be “touched” and thus the experience is relatively passive and static. “Cool” media are those with high-level user interactivity, where the experience is more dynamic and the audience is more involved. Media forms utilize animation, such as video games, or provide participation, like online media platforms, are examples of cool media. Fig. 2.3. Media Map of History Milestones in Media Evolution For McLuhan (1962), the three most significant inventions in communication would be the phonetic alphabet, the printing press, and the telegraph. Each of them linked one period to another. As mentioned earlier, the most recent forms of media carry the features of the older media. In the media map shown, there are four main periods in the history of communication. It begins with the tribal age where hearing was the predominant and most valuable sense of reception. Early human ancestors relied heavily on their sense of hearing to hunt for food and to stay alert from danger. The next period is the literacy age where the sense of sight was dominant. If the tribal age was highly acoustic, the literate age was highly visual. This is because of the invention of the alphabet, allowing humans to learn to read. The printing press was invented in the print age, which meant mass-producing written texts. Having more copies of these texts gave humans the liberty to read them at their own pace and to share them to others. With a growing number of produced and reproduced reading materials came the inevitable. The building of libraries and other repositories. McLuhan’s (1989) idea of the “global village,” a community where everyone in the world is interconnected through media, was evident in the electronic age. In this period, the telegraph was invented which paved the way to the invention of more recent technologies such as the telephone, television, mobile phone, and the Internet. The communication technology at this time led humans to instantly connect to each other even in great distances. An example is when you log on to play in an online video game while simultaneously chatting with other players from other parts of the world. The electronic age is the age of sound and tactile sense of reception. An example would be the incorporation of touch screens in smart phones, tablets, and laptop computers these days. In addition to the media map of history are two other time periods not covered in McLuhan’s periodization. One is information age when the world 12 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT entered into a new era of media experience in the 21st century. Also known as the digital or new media age, this is a time in human history where everything relied heavily in the use of computers to run major industries. Information was utilized based on personalized needs and motivations. Global communication and networking were enhanced. Digital technology and Internet become pervasive, thus, pushing the world to enter the infrastructure age. A car with global positioning system built with it, a railway system which runs digitally, or even simple appliances or gadgets at home that can be controlled using the internet are all examples of infrastructures in this age. There is more involvement in the cyberspace. Internet banking transactions and online purchases are other proofs to this. Culture Shapes Technology Despite the views provided by McLuhan, not everyone agrees with his propositions. Contrary to the idea of technology affecting change to society, cultural determinism explains that culture and society shapes technology. According to Winston (1986), a media scholar who advanced the idea of cultural determinism, society is still in control of technology and the innovations over time do not dictate how it must adapt and function in relation to these technologies. The radical potential of a given technology to affect change may be suppressed by societal factors. In other words, technology is a product of need and not the other way around. If there is no need for the technology, or it does not have a practical use, it will perish. Traditional vs. New Media In the beginning of this lesson, you were asked to identify which of the media forms stated are considered “traditional” and which ones are “new.” What were your bases for your answers? Traditional Media are those forms in the earlier periods of McLuhan’s media map. They are traditional because of the specific characteristics that they have functionalities that they offer. According to McQuail (2005), traditional media is one-directional. The media experience is limited and the sense receptors used are very specific (i.e., print media requires sense of sight, radio requires sense of hearing, and television and film requires both). With new media, the experience is more interactive. The audiences are more involved and are able to send feedback simultaneously. New media integrates all the aspects of traditional media. It is much less easy to distinguish these media from each other than it used to be. This is partly because some media forms are now distributed across different types of transmission channels, reducing the original uniqueness of form and experience in use. Secondly, the increasing convergence of technology, based on digitalization, can only reinforce this tendency. -Dennis McQuail (2005) What is New about New Media There are four main categories of new media and all of them share “certain channel similarities and are approximately differentiated by types of use, content, and context,” according to McQuail. 1. Interpersonal communication media. Examples would be the telephone, mobile phone, and e-mail where “content is private and perishable and the relationship established and reinforced may be more important than the information conveyed.” 2. Interactive play media. Video and computer-based games, plus virtual reality devices compose this category. 3. Information search media. The Internet and the World Wide Web become repositories or sources of a vast collection of information that can be accessed real-time despite geographical location. Broadcast teletext and radio data services are also examples. Information retrieval is no longer limited to personal computers because this functionality has been extended to smart phones and tablets. Other means of information storage 13 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT and retrieval include the personal video recorder, CD-ROM, compact disc, and DVD. 4. Collective participatory media. This refers to the use of the internet for “sharing and exchanging information, ideas, and experiences and developing active (computer-meditated) personal relationships (McQuail, 2010).” Key characteristics of new media, according to McQuail, include interactivity, social presence (or sociability), media richness, autonomy, playfulness, privacy and personalization. New media use expanded opportunities for self-expression especially among the youth through Web logs, online forums, Web discussion boards, social media, and messaging applications. The new media generation considers itself globally networked made possible by the internet. But as much as there is greater virtual participation by this generation, the members of this group have grown to be more isolated and extremely expressive of their thoughts. Observe your social media account for such manifestations. Functions of Communication and Media Media, whether traditional or new, has a role to play in the proper functioning of a democratic society such as the Philippines. In order for a democratic society to function in an ideal wa, media and communication must fulfill its mandate. According to McNair, communication and media function to 1. Inform citizens of what is happening around them (also called the monitoring function); 2. Educate the audience as to the meaning and significance of the “facts”; 3. Provide a platform for public political discourse, facilitating the formation of “public opinion” and feeding that opinion back to the public from whence it came, [including] the provision of space for the expression of dissent; 4. Give publicity to governmental and political institutions (known as the “watchdog” role of journalism); and 5. Serve as a channel for the advocacy of political viewpoints. Media and Government: A Love-Hate Relationship The relationship of media and government is oftentimes adversarial. This is normal and healthy because media, being a “watchdog,” keeps everything at bay. Before you can fully understand the nature of media in the Philippines, familiarize yourself first with the normative views of media. Table 2.1 summarizes the four theories of the press. Table 2.1 Normative Theories of the Press View Propositions All forms of communications are under the control of the governing elite, authorities, or influential bureaucrats. Controlling the media is necessary to protect and prevent the people from national threats through any form of communication Authoritarian (information or news). (communicationtheory.org.) The government has all the rights to restrict/censor any sensitive issue from press to maintain peace and security in the nation. Different types of censors include political censor, moral censor, religious censor, military censor, and corporate censor. Soviet Media The government undertakes or controls the 14 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT (communicationtheory.org.) Libertarian (communicationtheory.org.) Social Responsibility (McQuail, 2005, pp. 171-172) total media and communication to serve [and educate] working classes and their interests. The state has the absolute power to control any media for the benefits of the people. The state puts an end to private ownership of the press and other media. Government media provides positive thoughts to create a strong socialized society as well as providing information, education, entertainment, motivation and mobilization. The public is encourages to give feedback which would be able to create interests toward the media. Liberalism means information is knowledge and knowledge is power. Libertarianism is free from any authority or any control or censorship and is an idea of individualism and limited government which is not harmful to another. The people are more than enough to find and judge good ideas from bad [because] people are rational. The press should not restrict anything, even a negative content may give knowledge and can help make better decision during worst situations. Social responsibility should be reached by self-control, not government intervention. View media ownership as a form of public trust or stewardship, rather than as an unlimited private franchise. Media has obligations to society, and media ownership is a public trust. Media should follow agreed codes of ethics and professional conduct. The government must not merely allow freedom; it must actively promote it when necessary; therefore, the government should act to protect the freedom of its citizens. Under some circumstances, the government mat need to intervene to safeguard public interest. As you can see, the normative theories mentioned place expectations on how media conduct themselves and illustrate the dynamics between media and government vis-a-vis censorship. ESSENTIAL LEARNING Traditional media is still prevalent despite the emergence of new media. New media may be viewed as an addition rather than a replacement for old media. Media experience has been enriched by new media forms because of the added value they provide. In a democratic society such as the Philippines, the media has a very important role and function as a great equalizer. Media monitors events, educates the audience, provides a venue for debate, acts as a “watchdog,” and serves as a channel for active participation in political affairs. Theories on media and information are helpful lenses in understanding, interpreting, analyzing, and communicating assumptions, concepts, explanations, and principles on media, information, and communication. 15 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Module 3 Information Literacy At the end of this module, I can: 1. Define information needs. 2. Locate sources of information. 3. Assess, organize, and communicate information. 4. Identify relevant ethical standards or principles in information and media use. 5. Demonstrate ethical use of information. Assess yourself. 1. What is your primary source of information especially for schoolwork? 2. What are your considerations when looking for particular information? Do you need a quick fact or a critical analysis? 3. Do you prefer unbiased information or an opinion? Current information or a historical one? 4. Do you automatically use a Web search engine to locate for the information you need? What do you use and why? 5. Do you check just any kind of Web site? What are your personal criteria for selecting a Web site as your source of information? 6. If you use traditional sources of information such as print, broadcast, and electronic media, which among these do you often refer to and why? 7. What good and bad practices do you commit during information search and sharing? In module 1, you have been introduced to the concept of information and information literacy, as well as the characteristics of a media literate individual. But before you dive deeper into information literacy approach, you have to take note that an information literate individual is one who can do the following: Determine the extent of information needed Access the needed information efficiently and effectively Evaluate information and its sources critically Incorporate selected information into his or her knowledge base Use information to accomplish a specific purpose Understand the economic, legal, and social issues surrounding access and use of information Access and use information ethically and legally Information literacy is an important skill in life. An individual who is literate in the location, access, evaluation, and use of information also displays a certain sense of critical literacy. When you are information literate, you are able to evaluate what information you need, what to discard, and how to use the information you selected. As students, you unknowingly and unwittingly display information literacy when you search for information to address certain tasks such as projects, assignments, or research papers. Information takes many forms. It is often interchanged with data which is essentially “raw information” and knowledge which is characterized by effective use of information. What Determines Your Need of Information? Information seeking is relatively synonymous to the idea of research. When you locate information, you employ the necessary skills to engage in the research process. Your need for information depends on your prior knowledge and experience, as well as your goals and objectives. Your information needs to rely on what questions or problems you would like to solve or simply, what you need the information for. These needs also depend on the relevance of the information you seek to the task you are supposed to accomplish. Ask yourself who will consume and/or benefit from the information you are trying to locate. You must also identify how much information you need and its adequacy to address your task. Consult your 16 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT personal knowledge base so that you can plan what else to search to augment what you already know. The Effective and Efficient Information Seeker. A successful search strategy is one that allows you to judge at the onset what information is relevant, thus, limiting the possible overload of information sought. It also involves and understanding of information search systems such as indexes, online catalogs, or Boolean logic. When you are able to judge the “potential value of information,” you will be able to maximize its use. According to Callison and Tilley (2006), an effective and efficient information seeker is one who can do the following: Understands how to utilize a variety of information sources and agencies, as well as human resources, in order to gain useful information Understands the value of consulting with resource specialists and critical peers to reframe and refine questions and inquiries, if necessary Identifies information important to a need and assesses its reliability, bias, authority, and intent. Organizes new information in meaningful ways to determine where gaps may exist and to formulate the central question or thesis that can be addressed (Doyle, 1994) Aside from being information literate, you are also expected to display information fluency which refers to “the ability to analyze information needs and to move confidently among media, information, and computer literacy skills, resulting in the effective application of a strategy or strategies that will best meet those needs (Callison & Tilley, 2006).” Typology of Information According to www.lib.odu.edu, the kind of information you are looking for may be categorized as the following: 1. Factual vs. Analytical Factual Information is based on evidences and findings provided by reliable sources. These sources may include academic texts such as books, encyclopedia, periodicals, or technical reports by agencies and institutions. Analytical information, on the other hand, is an analysis or interpretation of facts by an individual, usually an expert on the subject. Examples of such would be feature articles, commentaries, or reviews. 2. Subjective vs. Objective When you consult and expert opinion, such as those found in the editorial section of a newspaper or in Web log entries of prolific writers, you are using a subjective kind of information. This is because the information is about the discussion and elaboration of a thesis statement which is still anchored on facts. It is important to evaluate the validity of the claims in subjective information because a valid argument is more often than not a successful argument. If the information is unbiased and does not lead you to judge the information in a certain way, then it is objective information. Scientific papers and news reports are common sources of objective information. 3. Current vs. Historical The currency of information refers to how up-to-date or how recent the information is. It does not necessarily follow that the more current the information, the more reliable and useful it is. There are information that are historical or old but are very helpful in providing insights and comparison of events. Publication date of the source material is the usual basis for currency. A combination of current and historical information, especially in research, provides a more holistic picture. You are able to establish trends or patterns when you make use of both. But the requirement for the use of either current or historical information depends on the discipline that makes use of them. In the hard or natural sciences, the more recent findings are preferred. For the humanities, historical information is primarily used to describe an event 17 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT or phenomenon. The social sciences usually consult both current and historical information. 4. Scholarly (Academic/Professional/Technical) vs. Popular When you are asked to write an academic paper, what sources does your teacher ask you to consult? Scholarly information comes from academic sources. It is a product of an author’s expertise and study on the subject matter. It is usually peer reviewed. Popular information, on the other hand, appeals to general interest and is usually found in general circulation materials such as magazines, coffee table books, or online feature articles. Table 3.1 differentiates a scholarly source and a popular source of information. Table 3.1. Scholarly Resources vs. Popular Resources Scholarly Resources Popular Resources Authors Written or reviewed by Written by the publication’s experts in the discipline staff writers Audience Written for researchers or Written for the general public practitioners in a particular or lay person discipline Publisher Professional society or Commercial publisher organization or university Content In-depth analysis of topic or Review of an event or report of original research research project, highlighting key points Language Use technical language which Understandable by a lay may not be understood by a person lay person Appearance Illustrations include Often use slick paper graphs and tables and more color Articles are usually long Many advertisements References Almost always include a list of sources consulted and graphics Articles are usually very short Rarely include a list of sources consulted 5. Primary vs. Secondary vs. Tertiary The origin and the levels of transfer of the information is also an important factor to consider in your information search. A description of and examples for primary, secondary, and tertiary information is shown in Table 3.2. Table 3.2. A Comparison of Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Sources Information Characteristics Examples Source Primary Original, first-hand Creative work information. Diary Hasn’t been interpreted, Speech analyzed, condensed, or Letter changed. Interview Information may need to News film footage be constructed with raw Autobiography data. Photograph Official record Historical document Email written by a researcher to a colleague which includes data from an experiment Professor’s lecture Tweet or other dispatch 18 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Secondary Tertiary One or more steps removed from a primary source and may interpret or analyze a primary source Usually written by someone other than the original researcher or author. Topic review; and usually include bibliographies of primary and secondary sources. Provide access to materials on specific topics. via a social media outlet News commentaries Articles in magazines and newspapers Critical review of a literary scholar Textbooks Encyclopedias Research papers Bibliography (citation list) of primary and secondary sources about a person or topic Encyclopedias Databases and indexes 6. Stable vs. Unstable Information may be stable or unstable. Stability becomes a consideration especially when the information you have obtained is published digitally over the internet. It is often difficult to know how long a certain web site or page will last. But an online source may still be predicted to be stable or otherwise by evaluating it based on the following questions (Ballenger 2009): Has it been around for a long time? Is it routinely updated? Are print versions of an online document available? Is the site associated with a reputable institution? If your answer to the most questions is “Yes,” then be confident that the Web site or page is stable enough for you to use as information source. Information seeking, like any other human activity, expects that a certain level of ethical conduct be upheld. The Online Dictionary for Library and Information Science defined information ethics as “the branch of ethics that focuses on the relationship between the creation, organization, dissemination, and use of information, and the ethical standards and moral codes governing human conduct in society.” responsible handling of information from access down to sharing is necessary to promote a fair and just utilization of information. ESSENTIAL LEARNING There is a lot of information out there. Among the many challenges that you face is managing this vastness of information. Information literacy equips you with the ability to effectively and efficiently identify your information needs and handle the access, evaluation, utilization, and relay of information. Information is very valuable to a student like you. There are various categories or typologies of information that may address your information needs. And while you address these needs, you should evaluate your sources of information appropriately by employing the tips on searching for information in physical and online archives. Knowledge of ethical standards related to information literacy will also guide you to be responsible consumers and transmitters of information. 19 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Module 4 Types of Media At the end of this module, I can: 1. Classify contents of different media types. 2. Define media convergence through current examples. 3. Relate media with culture. 4. Discuss in class how a particular individual or society is portrayed in public using different types of media. 5. Demonstrates the role of Philippine media in the global media landscape. All about the Different Forms of Media It has been argued earlier in Module 2 that as media evolves, the newer one carries with it the features of the predecessor. If you are to trace the history of media and communication technology, you will observe that the usual observable sequence of the main media forms or types would be: PRESS-->CINEMA-->RADIO-->TELEVISION-->VIDEOGAMES--> INTERNET/WWW Some will argue against this arrangement. But more than their historical sequence, it is important to note what each of these media types are, what they offer, and how they complement each other. Print Media Media is undeniably the most efficient way of communicating to a large audience because of its capacity to relay the message across cultures and distances. The variety of media forms provides a menu of choices for where and when you can access information. One such media form is print media. Also known as the press, this type of media refers to materials that are written and are physically distributed. Perhaps the most significant event in the history of printing in the invention of the printing press by Johannes Gutenberg in 1440. This eventually led to the mass production of books, which gave people an access to knowledge that they never dreamt of during those times. Print media can either be in the form of a book, a newspaper, or a magazine. Books are the very first mass media in human history. Baran (2010) considers books as very personal because they contain records of past experiences and human knowledge that are passed on to later generations. Books also provide opportunities for escape and personal reflection as experienced by one who reads a novel. Although targeted to a specific kind of audience, books are very specialized in that they offer more ideas about a topic, unlike other mass media forms which are beholden to advertising rules. When you read a book, you are able to stretch your imagination and think deeper about ideas that you do not normally encounter in your everyday life. Books are movers and shakers of culture. As a testament to this, books in physical form are being stored digitally as e-books. In contrast to books, newspapers and magazines are advertising-based. This means that a larger bulk of the earnings of magazine and newspaper publishers come from advertising products rather than selling the magazine or the newspaper. Newspapers and magazines are published regularly, whereas books may come out depending on the publisher’s prerogative. Magazines and newspapers may be targeted for the general audience or may address the interests of a particular group of readers. Magazines typically contain features or human interest articles, whereas newspapers will definitely have news stories and occasionally has other types of articles. Both the magazine ad the newspaper may also have online versions for them to reach a wider and larger audience who are more often virtually connected through the Internet. Film/Cinema The film as a media form is one that is considered impressionable and has a cathartic effect to its audience. With moving/motion pictures, the film is able 20 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT to enhance the media experience of its consumer because of the audio-video component which heightens both the sense of hearing and sense of sight. Films are very important cultural artifacts because, like books, they reflect the desires, ideologies, and sensibilities of the culture to which they originate from. Broadcast Media One of the most distinctive characteristics of the broadcast media is their ubiquity. They are considered” household” media because they can be found in practically any corner of a home. The broadcast media come in two forms – radio and television. According toBaran(2010), radio was the first electronic mass medium and the precursor of television. Because of radio, television was a success in most parts of the world. For a long time, radio was the “young people’s media”. This is evident in the proliferation of FM radio stations catering to the musical taste of younger generations, also known as format radio. In the Philippines, you customarily expect FM programming to be format radio, whereas AM programming is dominated by a news format. The landscape is slowly changing as news format has already gone into frequency modulation. The AM radio still remains the same but more specialized radio broadcasts have emerged catering to particular niches such as community radio. Broadcasting has also started to conquer the internet and mobile technology through internet-based radio and television. Some people have mixed feelings about television as a media form. Some think that next to printing press, it is the second most important invention. “Television has changed the nature, operation, and relationship to their audiences of books, magazines, movies, and radio.” Others think that television has significantly dumb-down its content to adhere to what they call the “least common denominator” which means that television programs avoid burdening the audience of complex and complicated messages. Video Games Video games continue to grow popular to both young and old because of their increased interactivity, “from game consoles to personal computers to the Internet to cell phones (Baran, 2010)”. The internet, on the other hand, is a development in media technology that is at the heart of all the convergence that you see occurring in traditional media. The internet made it easier to address a wider audience in all corners of the world. Ideas reach other people in a shorter span of time. Thus, societies are more connected than ever. Access to content whenever and wherever is almost possible. Points of Intersection among Media Forms Synergy and convergence are what describes the media of today. According to freedictionary.com, synergy is an “interaction of two or more agents or forces so that their combines effect is greater than the sum of their individual effects”. Convergence, on the other hand, means the combination of various elements to create a new whole. Think of the traditional media forms converging into a newer media from that optimizes your media use. There is a very thin line that separates each media form. Synergy is the rationale behind the concentration of media in one company or organization. Say for instance, a local network giant that has its main free-air channel with affiliate cable channels and a cable company subsidiary owning a print media arm and a film production unit. Synergy is also a driving force for mergers and acquisitions in the media and telecommunications industries, according to Baran. You probably have heard of the news in recent years about a telecommunication magnate having an interest to buy another local television station to directly compete with the biggest network in the country so far. Convergence is a trend that cannot be done away with because the audiences are getting more fragmented. Media organizations would like to 21 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT reach as many as they can by diversifying the delivery of their message. Also, audiences are no longer biased over one form of media to access content. Smart phones these days have radio and television applications, which is a clear example of convergence. Media Type/Form Video game Online interactive gaming Internet-capable handheld game devices Advergaming Advocacy gaming Internet and the World Wide Web Functionalities of the traditional media moving to the Web platform Internet technology incorporated to mobile technology (e.g., smart phones and tablets) Internet connected, Wi-Fi capable television monitor Convergence E-books Print on demand (POD) Newspaper Online version Mobile application version Magazine Online publishing Custom publishing Movement from print to television (vice versa) Advertorial Book television Internet-based television Video on the Internet Interactive television Phone-over cable Mobile video Television recording Film Concept movies Sequels, remakes, and franchises Television, comic book, and video game remakes Radio Digital radio Internet-based radio and podcasting Radio on television (and vice versa) Television Video cassette recorders (VCR) Digital video disc (DVD) Digital Video Recorder (DVR) Digital television or high-definition Potter (2011) considered cross media convergence as a way of breaking down barriers that separate each traditional media. An illustration that you probably can relate well with would be memes and videos over the Internet that people customize so they are able to produce their own version. ESSENTIAL LEARNING Media utilizes mass communication to reach a large number of audiences. It transcends boundaries and cultures. This may seem overwhelming for some but media may be utilized to address certain needs of an individual and 22 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT society to become better members of the community. The information offered through media technologies come from diverse sources, thus, requiring that you as consumers of information should be very critical of the content you consume. Media and culture are very well ties together in that media becomes a storyteller of culture. They portray images and interests of a society that they cater to. Print media, such as books, magazines, and newspapers, serve as repositories of our past. Film or cinema enhances the experience earlier provided by print media because of film’s use of audio and visual elements. Broadcast media, such as radio and television, are so pervasive that they attempt to appeal to the “least common denominator” or the lay people. Video games have significantly improved through time and have attracted attention of more adults and young people alike. Video games also reflect the culture, the values, and sensibilities of its consumers. The lines that separate these media forms have become blurred due to media convergence. Convergence, or the coming together of various media components to create a new whole new media, is what characterizes the Internet and other technological infrastructure that goes with it. Philippine media is very much involved in the global media landscape as can be seen in the importation of foreign concepts and localizing them for Filipino audiences, as well as exportation of media product, such as Philippine soap operas, which are growing in popularity in other parts of the world. Module 5 Media and Information Sources At the end of this module, I can: Compare potential sources of media and information. Assess information quality. Interview an elder from the community regarding indigenous media and information sources. Which information sources (i.e., indigenous, library, internet, mass media) do you prefer to use for the following topics? Why? 1. Human genome project 2. The cultural practices of the Lumads of Mindanao 3. The current state of the touism and hospitality industry in the Philippines 4. Political conflicts and strife in different parts of the world 5. Human expedition on Mars 6. Agricultural practices in Central Luzon 7. Recent events in the last decade that changed the world 8. The ASEAN integration 9. Most promising careers for graduates of senior high school 10. The trends in the mobile application industry 11. The history of the Bangsamoro 12. Human organization and behavior 13. The global phenomenon on Korean pop 14. Paralympics Your information needs to dictate your choice of media and information sources. Sources are not all the same and are not created equal. In an article written by Meyer (2005) on the nature and the effective use of information in rural development, it was suggested that resources may be evaluated by looking at the information that they contain. In other words, the content says a lot about the source. 23 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Judging the value of information is not as easy as it seems. It becomes all the more difficult for you when you have a limited idea about what you are looking for. You may not realize it, but there are occasions when you feel dumfounded when there is too much information available. This puts you to a dilemma of whether to adapt the whole gamut of information or just ignore them and look for some other sources that can provide you with simpler and more straightforward information. Information, unlike raw data is processed and refined. It is an interpretation of the data by the author or producer of the information. As a consumer, you have to exert more effort to look past the information and check its validity and relevance to you. Information may also become obsolete and may not be applicable to current contexts and utility. In your case as students, you are expected to discern the changes in the content and claims of the information that you locate, use, and share. Uncertainty is a key driver for one to seek information. As someone curious about how things work, you would like to reduce this uncertainty by consulting various materials that come from different sources. These sources may be in the form of indigenous or community knowledge, physical materials in archives such as libraries, multimedia, texts, and objects found in the internet, or media messages from the different mass media forms. Indigenous Knowledge and Indigenous Media A rather unconventional source for information is the so-called indigenous knowledge (IK). Indigenous knowledge is defined by Warren (1991) as the “knowledge that is unique to a given culture or society.” IK contrasts with the international knowledge system generated by universities, research institutions and private firms. It is the basis for local-level decision making in agriculture, health care, food preparation, education, natural resource management, and a host of other activities in rural communities. Warren (1991) Indigenous knowledge is relayed either through people media (which are the persons involved in the use, analysis, evaluation, and production of media and information) or through indigenous media. The Asia Indigenous Peopled Pact or AIPP defined indigenous media as media: … owned, controlled ad managed by indigenous people in order for them to develop and produce culturally appropriate information in the languages understood by the community by utilizing indigenous materials and resources, reflecting community needs and interest groups. It is highly participatory, involving the community members in planning, management and production. AIPP (2014) Also known as community media, indigenous media is any form of media that is created and controlled in the community, for the community, about the community and by the community (either a geographic community or a community of identity or interest) [and] is separate from commercial media, state-run media, public broadcasting. Indigenous communities are typically known to adhere to oral tradition of communication. This means that they are not reliant on mainstream media. They store information in their memories so the danger of losing the information is greater. Information exchange is characterized by face-to-face interaction, limiting the transfer and access of information over long distances and containing it within the borders of the community. And because of this, 24 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT the creation and maintenance of indigenous media helps in storing indigenous knowledge for posterity. The AIPP observed that “the ASEAN media landscape is generally characterized by an urban-centric media system in flow, content, consumption and ownership that limits indigenous people’s access to media and information and news coverage of their own issues and conditions.” Some of the other observations of the group include the following: Flow of information starting from metropolitan areas, tending to be one-way as no effective mechanisms are in place for media organizations to gather news from rural indigenous areas. Distant locations of many indigenous territories and poor infrastructures as big obstacles to indigenous peoples’ access to information from mass media. Complex biases and serious lack of interest in the lives of indigenous communities in news coverage and selection of mainstream media. Privately owned mainstream media catering more to interests of urban consumers rather than the needs of rural communities, particularly indigenous ones. Indigenous Media as Tool for Expression and Participation Information offered by indigenous media is primarily to “open up other spaces for the discussion of indigenous peoples’ issues (AIPP, 2005).” New media and ICT infrastructures have dramatically helped boost community media in certain parts of ASEAN region “providing the opportunity for extending communication outreach in remote rural areas.” The AIPP added that the indigenous youth of some ASEAN countries are exploring online platforms such as social media for their news and information consumption. In the ASEAN region, there are indigenous organizations that have initiated the promotion of freedom of expression and have increased access to information among indigenous peoples (IPs). An example in the Philippines is the Northern Dispatch Weekly, or NORDIS, which is a weekly newspaper covering the Ilocos Region, the Cordilleras, and the Cagayan Valley region places where indigenous communities in Northern Luzon live. NORDIS extends its effort for media to reach the IPs and the rural communities. The newspaper is a nonprofit and promotes a more democratic ownership of media facilities, and more reader-oriented industry practitioners. The Library as Repository of Information You know libraries to be places “in which literary, musical, artistic, or reference materials (as books, manuscripts, recordings, or films) are kept for use but not for sale (Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary).” Libraries came into existence because of the birth of printing press. Libraries are evaluated on the extent of their collection of materials and the kinds and quality of services they offer to information seekers. Libraries are expected to select and provide you contents that are easy to access. Libraries are considered to be stewards of good information collection. Libraries bought books (which they then owned ), organized them, made them available through library facilities, and took steps to ensure the longevity of the volumes for future use… Libraries acquire and secure ownership of digital content (typically through license), store the content on local servers, and make it accessible to a target community. Libraries attempt, as protocols permit, to ensure long-term access to the digital collection through license conditions and through practices to create backup and redundancy, and to migrate the content over time. In a variation of the model, some libraries host commercial content or centrally manage content of other campus units. In both of these cases, the classic collection stewardship model is sustained largely intact. A defining characteristic of this traditional model is the library’s ability to 25 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT exercise primary responsibility for and control over the content and future access to that content. - Media Type/Form Council on Library and Information Resources The main role of a library is to organize and provide you access to information. This role is no longer static or limited to purely collecting physical materials for archiving. It has extended to acquiring new modes of providing information such as the use of digital sources and facilities that utilize media. A library is one place where you can expect ne search strategies to be employed, thus, motivating information seekers like you to be more adept in effectively and efficiently locating information. Books Libraries are no longer limited to being repositories of informational materials. Modern libraries are connected to the internet to provide library uses of a myriad of sources and databases from various places in the world. According to the Council on Library and Information Resources, “Library Facilities also serve a social function, providing a common ground for users to interact or a neutral site for individuals from different disciplines to come together. Media as Information Tools Apart from indigenous knowledge and library sources, media also provides information as previously stated in the earlier modules in this unit. Media has been extensively discussed in Module 2. For your purpose of understanding media as a source of information, ponder on the advantages and disadvantages of each media type shown in Table 5.1 as outlined by the World Heritage Communication and Media Training Workshop in 2013. Table 5.1 Pros and Cons of the Different Types of Media as Sources of Information Magazines and Newspapers Cinema PROS CONS Portable/transferable information Affordable by volume, depending on size of print run Enduring medium that can last for many years Ideal for content that may not change drastically over time (historical, academic works, catalogues of cultural artifacts/works of art) Loyal (but shrinking) readership Target a geographical area Can be shared with others Inserts and leaflets attracts attention “Print is dead” or is it? Costly typesetting and design Costly publication in multilingual editions Expensive storage and shipping Prohibitively expensive reprinting/revising of outdated information Environmental issues Reaches many demographics, literate or illiterate Can be entered in local/international film festivals and competitions Expensive production May or may not hold interest attention Newspaper valid only for a day Message can be lost (most papers have more than 60% advertising) Magazines have niche audiences 26 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT Radio Television World Wide Web for further exposure Trusted medium with loyal followers Community radio has loyal audiences interested in local activities National broadcasters can carry messages for nationwide events 24/7 interaction with target audiences Niche market: stations cater to specific types of listeners Audience will tune out Background medium (hard to hold attention) Difficult to incite action (hard to remember broadcasted contact details or website URLs Quickly spreads the message on different channels and times of day Improves credibility Best suited for large-scale communications activities Expensive Short message that must be repeated to sink in Advertisements can be skipped through PVRs (Personal Video Recorders) Traditional TV is less watched by younger people Main point of contact between user and audience Acts as a hub for all other activities/content (audio/video/text/events/so cial media aggregator) Easy to access from multiple platforms Perceived difficulty to set up High cost maintenance (constant updating) Information control Social Media Reach the correct audience through hashtags/following relevant groups Attract large number of people in short time Drive traffic to other communication actions Bring people together Gather information about target Easy feedback Place for real-life experiences to be exchanged Give a voice to timid people Very time consuming to engage directly with followers Need to keep content fresh across platforms to stay visible Cannot control the message or how people react to online contents Campaigns can get hijacked by detractors Bad news can go viral Mistakes can happen in real time with thousands of witnesses Negative feedback cannot be ignored Do not capture tone Evaluating Your Information Sources When the information suits your needs, it is considered of good quality. To measure information quality, you may consider the following aspects. 27 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT 1. The information provided by a source is credible and reliable. One aspect of judging credibility of information is the reputation of the source. The authoritativeness of the information and the source must be readily verifiable; otherwise, the information may not be useful. 2. Breadth and depth of the discussion on a topic is also a consideration. The extent of the research done by the source to organize the information is an indication of rigor and judiciousness. A lazy source is one who is content on providing secondary and tertiary sources as well as popular and less academic information. 3. The information can be cross-referenced. This means that the information can also be checked in other sources and can be supported by them. 4. The manner on how the information has been dealt with by the source is ethical and legal. ESSENTIAL LEARNING Almost everything at your grasp is a source of information. It just depends on what you need them for and how you use them. When the information is unrefined or unprocessed, it is called raw data. The data will only make sense when it is interpreted and utilized based on your needs. Validity, reliability, credibility, and relevance are the primary considerations for evaluating information. But not all sources offer the same quality of information. These sources may be indigenous or community knowledge, physical materials libraries, or media resources. As you strive to become more media and information literate, the higher is the expectation to be judicious and more selective and critical of your information sources because quality is everything with the vast information you can assess. 28 GRADE 12 | MEDIA AND INFORMATION LITERACY