EVALUATION RUBRIC – CAPSTONE DESIGN PROJECT
PRELIMINARY DEFENSE
Excellent (5)
Very Good (4)
Acceptable (3)
Please check the appropriate points based on the following
assessment criteria.
Needs
Improvement (2)
Needs Significant
Improvement (1)
Research Title: __________________________________________________________________
Proponents: ______________________________
_______________________________
_____________________________
_______________________________
1. Problem Definition: States the research
problem/objectives clearly, providing motivation for
undertaking the research
2. Theoretical/ Conceptual Framework: Presents a
preferred approach which is built from a set of
theories/concepts linked to a planned system of design.
3. Review of Related Literature and Studies: Demonstrates
sound knowledge of literature in the area, and of prior work
on the specific research problem
4. Research Methodology: Provides a sound plan for
applying research methods/tools in solving the defined
problem and shows a good understanding of how to use
methods/tools effectively
5. Citation and References. Use appropriate references
with proper citation in APA format.
6. Quality of Oral Communication:
Communicates
clearly and
professionally. Questions were answered
directly and succinctly.
7. Critical Thinking: Demonstrates capability for
independent research in the area of study, preparedness in
core disciplines relevant to research, and ability to complete
the research.
8. Format and Organization. Document is well-organized
and logical. Guides the reader through the chain of reasoning
or progression of ideas.
Overall Assessment:
_________/ 40
OVERALL PERFORMANCE RATING:
_____ Does not pass/ Re-defense
_____ For reconsideration after major revisions
_____ Pass with minor revisions
_____ Accept in Present Form
( 19 points & below)
( 20 - 25 points )
( 26 – 30 points )
( 31 points & above )
Comments:
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________
Name of Panelist/Signature