Taking the Flash Out of Electrical Safety October 10, 2020 Arc Flash Study Prepared for: XYZ Company Someplace, USA Prepared by: Zarheer Jooma Electrical Engineer CONTENTS Arc Flash Study Overview Incident Energy Summary Report Equipment Evaluation Report PPE Poster Arc Flash Model Drawing (502) 716-7073 Office (502) 371-6300 Fax 3018 Eastpoint Parkway Louisville, KY 40223 www.e-hazard.com info@e-hazard.com October 10, 2020 2 October 10, 2020 Bob Someone XYZ Company Bob, Thank you for the opportunity to provide this Arc Flash Study. This binder contains all information relevant to your Arc Flash Study, including drawings and spare Arc Flash labels. In addition, electronic versions of the files in PDF, and the study data files are saved on a USB flash drive provided in an envelope in the binder. The relevant engineering software package (such as SKM PowerTools or EasyPower) is required to open the study files. It is recommended the USB drive be retained in a secure, documented location within your organization, as it contains important information that may need to be referenced over time as changes in equipment and personnel occur. e-Hazard retains an electronic version of all related files, in the event further discussion is needed, or questions arise. For any additional clarification, relative to this report, please call me at (502) 716-7073. Thank you, Zarheer Jooma Electrical Engineer Pr. Eng. SMIEEE Zarheer@e-Hazard.com (502) 716-7073 Office (502) 371-6300 Fax 3018 Eastpoint Parkway Louisville, KY 40223 www.e-hazard.com info@e-hazard.com October 10, 2020 3 Arc Flash Study Overview Introduction The SKM PowerTools version 9.0 software program was used to determine Arc Flash incident energy levels and arc flash boundaries based on the IEEE 1584™ 2018 Guide for Performing Arc-Flash Hazard Calculations and the NFPA 70E® 2018 Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace. This project also provides the short-circuit current analysis and equipment evaluation. The results of the calculations and models are presented in drawings based on the facility’s distribution system. The calculations have been based on the data provided by the plant. Utility Contribution The utility contribution data was supplied by ABC Utility and is attached at the end of this report. Operation of Disconnects and Breakers The study results show various arc flash energies ranging from “Level 4” all the way down to “Less than 1.2cal/cm2”. In general, all disconnects that directly supply a machine or control panel indicate an energy of less than 1.2cal/cm2 and would not require any specific arc rated levels of PPE. Certain panelboards (Panel 1, 2, and 5) require at least 8cal/cm2 (Level-2) arc rated PPE. The Siemens main switchboard, Panel A (main breaker), and Panel B (main breaker) will require a 40cal/cm2 flash suit, appropriate safety training, and qualifications to switch. The extracted text from NFPA 70E® 2018 edition is provided next to assist with your risk assessment. 130.2 Electrically Safe Working Conditions. (A) Energized Work. … (4) Normal Operating Condition. Normal operation of electric equipment shall be permitted where a normal operating condition exists. A normal operating condition exists when all of the following conditions are satisfied: (1) The equipment is properly installed. (2) The equipment is properly maintained. (3) The equipment is used in in accordance with instructions included in the listing and labeling and in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions. (4) The equipment doors are closed and secured. (5) All equipment covers are in place and secured. (6) There is no evidence of impending failure. Informational Note: The phrase properly installed means that the equipment is installed in accordance with applicable industry codes and standards and the manufacturer’s recommendations. The phrase properly maintained means that the equipment has been maintained in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations and applicable industry codes and standards. The phrase evidence of impending failure means that there is evidence such as arcing, overheating, loose or bound equipment parts, visible damage, or deterioration. NFPA 70E® 2018, pg. 22 (502) 716-7073 Office (502) 371-6300 Fax 3018 Eastpoint Parkway Louisville, KY 40223 www.e-hazard.com info@e-hazard.com October 10, 2020 4 130.7 Personal and Other Protective Equipment. (A) General. Employees exposed to electrical hazards when the risk associated with that hazard is not adequately reduced by the applicable electrical installation requirements shall be provided with, and shall use, protective equipment that is designed and constructed for the specific part of the body to be protected and for the work to be performed. … Informational Note No. 1: The PPE requirements of 130.7 are intended to protect a person from arc flash and shock hazards. While some situations could result in burns to the skin, even with the protection selected, burn injury should be reduced and survivable. Due to the explosive effect of some arc events, physical trauma injuries could occur. The PPE requirements of 130.7 do not address protection against physical trauma other than exposure to the thermal effects of an arc flash. NFPA 70E® 2018, pg. 29 Table 130.5(C)(15)(A)(a) Estimate of the Likelihood of Occurrence of an Arc Flash Hazard Incident for ac and dc Systems Task Equipment Condition … Operation of a circuit breaker (CB), Normal switch, contactor, or starter All of the following: (1) The equipment is properly installed. (2) The equipment is properly maintained. (3) The equipment is used in in accordance with instructions included in the listing and labeling and in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions. (4) The equipment doors are closed and secured. (5) All equipment covers are in place and secured. (6) There is no evidence of impending failure such as arcing, overheating, loose or bound equipment parts, visible damage, or deterioration. Likelihood of Occurrence* No NFPA 70E® 2018, pg. 26-27 NFPA 70E makes it clear the determination of this condition can only be made by the responsible person in charge of the facility. If the facility has evidence and documentation as per the requirements of NFPA 70E 205.3, 205.4 and 210.5 that all five conditions are met, then no arc rated PPE would be required to operate disconnects with the doors properly closed and latched. It is, however, unlikely that equipment is maintained to the exact specifications of the manufacturer. For reference see the NFPA extracts listed below. The facility should adopt a safer approach by providing appropriate Arc Rated clothing as specified in the NFPA 70E® 2018 Table 130.5(G) Selection of Arc-Rated Clothing and Other PPE When the Incident Energy Analysis Method Is Used. At minimum these would require the use of arc rated clothing and equipment by the task qualified workers including at least an arc rated face shield, arc rated balaclava, arc rated clothing, leather gloves, and standard issued PPE when performing the lock out procedure or to interact with the MCC, (502) 716-7073 Office (502) 371-6300 Fax 3018 Eastpoint Parkway Louisville, KY 40223 www.e-hazard.com info@e-hazard.com October 10, 2020 5 panelboard, or disconnect in question. If this approach is taken, the under-layer clothing shall be 100% natural fiber non-melting clothing per NFPA 70E. After the disconnect switch is operated to the “off” position and electrically verified then lock out procedures can be performed on the equipment under an electrically safe work condition without any arc rated PPE. 205.3 General Maintenance Requirements. Electrical equipment shall be maintained in accordance with manufacturers’ instructions or industry consensus standards to reduce the risk associated with failure. The equipment owner or the owner’s designated representative shall be responsible for maintenance of the electrical equipment and documentation. Informational Note No.1: Common industry practice is to apply test or calibration decals to equipment to indicate the test or calibration date and overall condition of equipment that has been tested and maintained in the field. These decals provide the employee immediate indication of last maintenance date and if the tested device or system was found acceptable on the date of test. This local information can assist the employee in the assessment of overall electrical equipment maintenance status. Informational Note No. 2: Noncontact diagnostic methods in addition to scheduled maintenance activities of electrical equipment can assist in the identification of electrical anomalies. 205.4 Overcurrent Protective Devices. Overcurrent protective devices shall be maintained in accordance with the manufacturers’ instructions or industry consensus standards. Maintenance, tests, and inspections shall be documented. 210.5 Protective Devices. Protective devices shall be maintained to adequately withstand or interrupt available fault current. Informational Note: Improper or inadequate maintenance can result in increased opening time of the overcurrent protective device, thus increasing the incident energy. NFPA 70E® 2018, pg. 40-41 Equipment Labeling The switchboard sections will be labeled to the actual incident energy levels per the requirements of IEEE 1584 and NFPA 70E for testing, troubleshooting and interacting with the device with exposed energized parts. All disconnects that could require maintenance, testing or trouble shootings will be labeled to the requirements of NFPA 70E® 130.5(H). (502) 716-7073 Office (502) 371-6300 Fax 3018 Eastpoint Parkway Louisville, KY 40223 www.e-hazard.com info@e-hazard.com October 10, 2020 130.5 (H) … 6 Arc Flash Risk Assessment. Equipment Labeling. Electrical equipment such as switchboards, panel boards, industrial control panels, meter socket enclosures, and motor control centers that are in other than dwelling units and that are likely to require examination, adjustment, servicing, or maintenance while energized shall be field-marked with a label containing all the following information: (1) Nominal system voltage (2) Arc flash boundary (3) At least one of the following: a. b. c. Available incident energy and the corresponding working distance, or the arc flash PPE category in Table 130.7(C)(15)(b) or Table 130.7(C)(15)(b) for the equipment, but not both Minimum arc rating of clothing Site-specific level of PPE Exception: Labels applied prior to September 30, 2011 are acceptable if they contain the available incident energy or required level of PPE. NFPA 70E® 2018, pg. 25 The method of calculating and the data to support the information for the label shall be documented. The data shall be reviewed for accuracy at intervals not to exceed 5 years. Where the review of the data identifies a change that renders the label inaccurate, the label shall be updated. The owner of the electrical equipment shall be responsible for the documentation, installation, and maintenance of the field-marked label. The labels provided are based on a site-specific PPE selection as per NFPA 70E-2018 130.5(H)(3)(c) and the PPE Poster in this report. Refer to the table below and further details provided at the end of the Incident Energy Summary Report. Level Incident Energy Arc Rated Clothing 0 0.0 - 1.2 cal/cm2 Nonmelting or Untreated Fiber with Weight >= 4.5 oz/sq yd 1 2 3 4 1.2 - 4.0 cal/cm2 4.0 - 8.0 cal/cm2 8.0 - 25.0 cal/cm2 25.0 - 40.0 cal/cm2 Dangerous 40.0 – 999.0 cal/cm2 Site Specific PPE Selection (502) 716-7073 Office (502) 371-6300 Fax Arc-rated shirt & pants + arc-rated coverall (min 4cal/cm2) Arc-rated shirt & pants + arc-rated coverall (min 8cal/cm2) Arc-rated shirt & pants + arc-rated coverall + arc-rated arc flash suit (min 25cal/cm2) Arc-rated shirt & pants + arc-rated coverall + arc-rated arc flash suit (min 40cal/cm2) DO NOT WORK ON LIVE! 3018 Eastpoint Parkway Louisville, KY 40223 www.e-hazard.com info@e-hazard.com October 10, 2020 7 System Mis-coordination The Incident Energy Summary Report indicates no areas of over current device mis-coordination on Samtec equipment. Equipment Evaluation Report The Device Evaluation Summary Reports indicate no devices of marginal ratings relative to the device in question. Additional NFPA 70E Requirements A written Electrical Safety Program (ESP) is required by NFPA 70E. This requirement incorporates criteria for all aspects of electric safety. An Electrical Safety Program provides a framework for assessing risks, i.e. an arc flash study, training and procedures related to maintenance, labeling, and safe work practices. 110.1 Electrical Safety Program. (A) … (C) … (H) General. The employer shall implement and document an overall electrical safety program that directs activity appropriate to the risk associated with electrical hazards. The electrical safety program shall be implemented as part of the employer’s overall occupational health and safety management system, when one exists. Informational Note No. 1: Safety-related work practices such as verification of proper maintenance and installation, alerting techniques, auditing requirements, and training requirements provided in this standard are administrative controls and part of an overall electrical safety program. Condition of Maintenance. The electrical safety program shall include elements that consider condition of maintenance of electrical equipment and systems. Risk Assessment Procedure. The electrical safety program shall include a risk assessment procedure and shall comply with 110.1(H)(1) through 110.1(H)(3)… (1) Elements of the Risk Assessment Procedure. (2) Human Error. (3) Hierarchy of Risk Control Methods. NFPA 70E® 2018, pg. 14 NFPA 70E requires initial qualified training and retraining every three years for your qualified electrical workers. We typically recommend electrical safety training after the labeling activity as this can provide a customized session for your specific equipment and what the labels require as far as proper work practices. (502) 716-7073 Office (502) 371-6300 Fax 3018 Eastpoint Parkway Louisville, KY 40223 www.e-hazard.com info@e-hazard.com October 10, 2020 110.2(A) (1) (3) 8 Training Requirements. Electrical Safety Training. Qualified Person. A qualified person shall be trained and knowledgeable in the construction and operation of equipment or a specific work method and be trained to identify and avoid the electrical hazards that might be present with respect to that equipment or work method. (a) Such persons shall also be familiar with the proper use of the special precautionary techniques, applicable electrical policies and procedures, PPE, insulating and shielding materials, and insulated tools and test equipment. A person can be considered qualified with respect to certain equipment and methods but still be unqualified for others. … Retraining. Retraining in safety-related work practices and applicable changes in this standard shall be performed at intervals not to exceed three years. An employee shall receive additional training (or retraining) if any of the following conditions exists: (1) The supervision or annual inspections indicate that the employee is not complying with the safety-related work practices. (2) New technology, new types of equipment, or changes in procedures necessitate the use of safety-related work practices that are different from those that the employee would normally use. (3) The employee must employ safety-related work practices that are not normally used during his or her regular job duties. NFPA 70E® 2018, pg. 15-16 This arc flash study should be reviewed and updated anytime there is a significant change in equipment, facility expansion/renovation, or at least every five years as required by NFPA 70E. If the utility contacts you for a service interruption, ask the question for what purpose. If they are upgrading the transmission line or transmission / distribution transformers, this is your indication to find out what the change will be to your incoming fault current and relay clearing times which can affect the arc flash calculations. If the utility hasn’t changed anything relative to your incoming service fault current and you have not changed anything in your distribution system on site, then the review can be a very simple process of noting this fact every five years. A verification from the utility contribution as indicated in the utility information in this document and listed on the drawing is all that would be required. General Information The panelboard located outside of the distilling area was not locked. Since it is accessible to the public, it should be locked. Panelboards A and B doors and covers are severely misaligned and should be repaired or replaced. Several electrical panels had items stored within 38”. Those items should be removed to allow for emergency access to electrical equipment. The calculations and resultant incident energy levels are based upon the overcurrent device operating as designed and maintained. Maintenance intervals should be based on the manufacturer’s recommendations or industry consensus testing standards. This is typically a 3-year interval based on the conditions of the equipment. The NETA documents provide guidance to adjust these intervals based on location conditions. Layering of Arc rated clothing is allowed, as long as it has been tested as a system. This information is available on the clothing makers WEB sites as well as on ArcWear.com. Contact your clothing supplier for rating information on your specific PPE. (502) 716-7073 Office (502) 371-6300 Fax 3018 Eastpoint Parkway Louisville, KY 40223 www.e-hazard.com info@e-hazard.com Taking the Flash Out of Electrical Safety SERVICES OVERVIEW ARC FLASH INCIDENT ENERGY SUMMARY REPORT elect rical WORKPLA CE SA FETY INCIDENT ENERGY SUMMARY REPORT 1 2 3 4 A Bus Name AIR COMPRESSOR 3 5 DISC 6 7 BOILER 2 8 BOTTLING CONTROL 9 PANEL 10 BOTTLING CP DISC 11 12 BOTTOM AUGER 13 14 15 CIRC PUMP BOILER 1 16 17 CIRC PUMP BOILER 2 18 COOLING TOWER 19 20 DISC C REAR BLDG COOL RM 21 22 DISTILLING CP FEED 23 #1 24 DISTILLING CP FEED 25 #2 26 DOCK CONTROL 27 PANEL 28 DOCK CONTROL 29 PANEL DISC 30 HAMMER MILL CONTROL PANEL 31 32 LGE CUBICLE 33 34 MARLEY PUMP 35 36 B Protective Device Name C D E F G Bus Prot Dev Prot Dev Bus Bus kV Bolted Arcing Bolted Arcing Fault Fault Fault Fault (kA) (kA) (kA) (kA) PNL 1 BRK 20 0.208 2.23 0.89 2.23 0.89 PNL 2 BRK 2 H I J K L M N O P Q Working Arc Trip/ Breaker Equip Electrode Box Box Box Gap Delay Opening Type Config Width Height Depth (mm) Flash Distance Boundary (in) Time Time/Tol (in) (in) (in) (sec.) (sec.) (in) 0.0084 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 R Incident Energy (cal/cm2) S PPE Level / Notes (*N) 0.02 Level 0 0.208 2.73 1.11 2.73 1.11 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.02 Level 0 PANEL D BRK 0.208 1 1.79 0.70 1.79 0.70 1.737 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 18 18 < 1.2 Level 0 (*N15b) PANEL D BRK 0.208 1 2.43 0.98 2.43 0.98 0.017 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 2 18 0.04 Level 0 PNL 2 BRK 19 0.208 1.54 0.60 1.54 0.60 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.01 Level 0 (*N15b) PNL 2 BRK 7 0.208 2.46 0.99 2.46 0.99 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.02 Level 0 PNL 2 BRK 13 0.208 2.20 0.88 2.20 0.88 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.02 Level 0 PNL 1 BRK 19 0.208 0.96 0.36 0.96 0.36 1.958 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 18 18 < 1.2 Level 0 (*N15b) DISC C REAR 0.208 BLDG BRK 1.29 0.43 1.29 0.43 0.9586 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 14 18 0.84 Level 0 (*N3) (*N15b) PNL 1 BRK 1 0.208 8.91 4.04 8.91 4.04 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 3 18 0.08 Level 0 PNL 1 BRK 2 0.208 8.91 4.04 8.91 4.04 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 3 18 0.08 Level 0 PNL 1 BRK 13 0.208 (PD-0039) 4.65 1.99 4.65 1.99 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 2 18 0.04 Level 0 (*N5) PNL 1 BRK 13 0.208 4.87 2.09 4.87 2.09 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 2 18 0.04 Level 0 PNL 1 BRK 8 1.50 0.50 1.50 0.50 1.853 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 18 18 < 1.2 Level 0 (*N3) (*N15b) XFMR 648409 0.208 15.92 FUSE 6.37 15.92 6.37 1.695 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 122 18 25.7 Level 4 (*N3) PNL 1 BRK 26 0.208 0.79 1.99 0.79 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.01 Level 0 (*N15b) 0.208 1.99 Page 1 of 4 INCIDENT ENERGY SUMMARY REPORT 1 2 3 4 A Bus Name MASH COOLING B Protective Device Name C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q Working Arc Box Box Gap Bus Prot Dev Prot Dev Trip/ Breaker Equip Electrode Box Bus Bus kV Bolted Arcing Bolted Arcing Delay Opening Type Config Width Height Depth (mm) Flash Distance Boundary (in) Fault Fault Fault Fault Time Time/Tol (in) (in) (in) (kA) (kA) (sec.) (sec.) (kA) (kA) (in) PNL 1 BRK 37 0.208 1.43 0.48 1.43 0.48 1.269 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 18 18 R Incident Energy (cal/cm2) < 1.2 Level 0 (*N3) (*N15b) 37 38 39 40 PANEL 1 PANEL 1 HAMMER 41 MILL 42 PANEL 1 MILL 43 DISCONNECT 44 PANEL 2 45 46 PANEL 2 BLOWER 47 FAN 48 PANEL 2 49 COMPRESSOR 50 PANEL 3 51 52 PANEL 3 MAIN 53 54 PANEL 4 55 56 PANEL 4 MAIN 57 58 PANEL 5 MAIN 59 60 PANEL A 61 62 PANEL A MAIN 63 64 PANEL B 65 66 S PPE Level / Notes (*N) FUSE 3 PANEL 1 0.208 10.81 4.28 10.81 4.28 0.5968 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 49 18 5.93 Level 2 (*N3) PNL 1 BRK 7 (PD-0038) 0.208 5.03 2.17 5.03 2.17 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 2 18 0.04 Level 0 (*N5) PNL 1 BRK 7 0.208 5.29 2.29 5.29 2.29 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 2 18 0.04 Level 0 FUSE 6 PANEL 2 0.208 10.81 4.28 10.81 4.28 0.5968 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 49 18 5.93 Level 2 (*N3) PNL 2 BRK 14 0.208 2.80 1.14 2.80 1.14 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.02 Level 0 PNL 2 BRK 1 3.73 1.56 3.73 1.56 0.0083 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 2 18 0.03 Level 0 PANEL 3 MAIN 0.208 11.00 BRK 5.05 11.00 5.05 0.01 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 4 18 0.12 Level 0 FUSE 2 PANEL 3 0.208 11.15 4.42 11.15 4.42 0.0269 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 7 18 0.28 Level 0 (*N3) PANEL 4 MAIN 0.208 10.80 BRK 4.96 10.80 4.96 0.01 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 4 18 0.11 Level 0 FUSE 1 PANEL 4 0.208 10.94 4.33 10.94 4.33 0.0294 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 7 18 0.30 Level 0 (*N3) FUSE 5 PANEL 5 0.208 5.49 2.05 5.49 2.05 0.8713 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 38 18 3.99 Level 1 (*N3) PANEL A MAIN BRK 0.208 15.09 7.01 15.09 7.01 0.025 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 9 18 0.41 Level 0 XFMR 648409 0.208 15.32 FUSE 6.13 15.32 6.13 1.882 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 127 18 27.4 Level 4 (*N3) PANEL A MAIN BRK0 6.96 14.98 6.96 0.025 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 9 18 0.41 Level 0 0.208 0.208 14.98 Page 2 of 4 INCIDENT ENERGY SUMMARY REPORT 1 2 3 4 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 A Bus Name PANEL B MAIN B Protective Device Name C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q Working Arc Box Box Gap Bus Prot Dev Prot Dev Trip/ Breaker Equip Electrode Box Bus Bus kV Bolted Arcing Bolted Arcing Delay Opening Type Config Width Height Depth (mm) Flash Distance Boundary (in) Fault Fault Fault Fault Time Time/Tol (in) (in) (in) (kA) (kA) (sec.) (sec.) (kA) (kA) (in) XFMR 648409 0.208 15.20 6.08 14 10 25 128 18 15.20 6.08 1.921 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 FUSE R Incident Energy (cal/cm2) 27.7 Level 4 (*N3) PANEL C WH SUB 0.208 PANEL C BRK 7.77 3.00 7.77 3.00 0.1504 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 16 18 1.03 Level 0 (*N3) PANEL D PANEL D MAIN BRK 0.208 7.48 3.34 7.48 3.34 0.01 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 3 18 0.08 Level 0 PANEL D EXHAUST FAN PANEL D BRK 0.208 2 0.77 0.28 0.77 0.28 2 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 17 18 1.14 Level 0 (*N9) (*N15b) WH SUB 0.208 PANEL D BRK 7.55 2.91 7.55 2.91 0.1789 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 18 18 1.18 Level 0 (*N3) PNL 1 BRK 31 0.208 2.23 0.89 2.23 0.89 0.0084 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.02 Level 0 PNL 1 BRK 32 0.208 2.23 0.89 2.23 0.89 0.0084 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.02 Level 0 PNL 1 BRK 25 0.208 1.01 0.33 1.01 0.33 1.23 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 14 18 0.82 Level 0 (*N3) (*N15b) PNL 3 BACKDOCK PNL 3 BRK 10 0.208 2.00 0.68 2.00 0.68 0.2647 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 9 18 0.38 Level 0 (*N3) (*N15b) PNL 4 FOAMER OUTLET PNL 4 BRK 5 0.208 1.99 0.68 1.99 0.68 0.2662 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 9 18 0.38 Level 0 (*N3) (*N15b) 0.208 2.08 0.71 2.08 0.71 0.3347 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 10 18 0.50 Level 0 (*N3) 0.208 5.56 2.08 5.56 2.08 0.0279 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 4 18 0.13 Level 0 (*N3) 0.208 2.00 0.68 2.00 0.68 0.2647 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 9 18 0.38 Level 0 (*N3) (*N15b) 0.208 1.99 0.68 1.99 0.68 0.2662 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 9 18 0.38 Level 0 (*N3) (*N15b) PANEL D MAIN 75 76 77 PNL 1 HEATER 1 78 79 PNL 1 HEATER 2 80 PNL 1 HOIST 81 82 83 84 85 86 S PPE Level / Notes (*N) PNL A 3PH CHARGER 3PH CHARGER 87 BRK 88 PNL AT REAR BLDG PNL REAR 89 BLDG BRK 90 PNL3 FORKLIFT PNL 4 BRK 15 CHARGER 91 92 PNL4 FORKLIFT PNL 4 BRK 37 CHARGER 93 94 Page 3 of 4 INCIDENT ENERGY SUMMARY REPORT 1 2 3 4 95 96 97 98 99 100 A Bus Name ROLLER MILL C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q Working Arc Box Box Gap Bus Prot Dev Prot Dev Trip/ Breaker Equip Electrode Box Bus Bus kV Bolted Arcing Bolted Arcing Delay Opening Type Config Width Height Depth (mm) Flash Distance Boundary (in) Fault Fault Fault Fault Time Time/Tol (in) (in) (in) (kA) (kA) (sec.) (sec.) (kA) (kA) (in) PNL 1 BRK 14 0.208 1.06 0.40 1.06 0.40 1.697 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 18 18 R Incident Energy (cal/cm2) S PPE Level / Notes (*N) < 1.2 Level 0 (*N15b) 2 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 126 18 27.0 Level 4 (*N9) 1.54 0.60 0.0086 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 1 18 0.01 Level 0 (*N15b) 3.34 8.58 3.34 0.0949 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 13 18 0.73 Level 0 (*N3) 3.09 7.98 3.09 0.1356 0.0000 PNL VCB 12 14 10 25 16 18 0.95 Level 0 (*N3) SIEMENS MAIN SWBD XFMR 33669 FUSE 0.208 12.52 5.79 12.52 TOP BAG AUGER PNL 2 BRK 8 0.208 1.54 0.60 FUSE 4 PANEL 6 0.208 8.58 PD-0040 0.208 7.98 YORK CHILLER 101 DISCONNECT 102 YORK CHILLER UNIT 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 B Protective Device Name 5.79 Device with 80% Cleared Fault For additional information refer to NFPA 70 E, Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace. (*N3) - Arcing Current Low Tolerances Used (*N5) - Miscoordinated, Upstream Device Tripped (*N9) - Max Arcing Duration Reached (*N15b) - Apply exception if Bolted Fault Current < 2000 A (IEEE 1584 2018 Section 4.3) IEEE 1584 2018 Bus Report - Comprehensive Fault (80% Cleared Fault Threshold, include Ind. Motors for 5.0 Cycles, mis-coordination checked #Equip Eval Failed = 0 #Bus Equip Eval Failed = 0 Level 0: Nonmelting or Untreated Fiber with Weight >= 4.5 oz/sq yd 0.0 - 1.2 cal/cm^2 Level 1: Arc-rated shirt & pants or arc-rated coverall. Arc-rated blaclava & face-shield or arc flash hood. 1.2 - 4.0 cal/cm^2 Level 2: Arc-rated shirt & pants or arc-rated coverall. Arc-rated blaclava & face-sheild or arc flash hood. 4.0 - 8.0 cal/cm^2 Level 3: Arc-rated shirt & pants + arc-rated coverall + arc-rated arc flash suit & hood. 8.0 - 25.0 cal/cm^2 Level 4: Arc-rated shirt & pants + arc-rated coverall + arc-rated arc flash suit & hood. 25.0 - 40.0 cal/cm^2 Level Dangerous!: DO NOT WORK ON LIVE! 40.0 - 999.0 cal/cm^2 Page 4 of 4 #Level 0 = 43 #Level 1 = 1 #Level 2 = 2 #Level 4 = 4 Taking the Flash Out of Electrical Safety SERVICES OVERVIEW ARC FLASH EQUIPMENT EVALUATION elect rical WORKPLA CE SA FETY EQUIPMENT EVALUATION 1 Device/Bus 2 Manufacturer A 3 3PH CHARGER BRK 4 PANEL A B Status Description Bus/Device/ Rating% Calc/Dev/Series Rating% Passed THQB 208 15.55 (*N1) 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 THQB 86.67 70.69 THQB 208 15.40 (*N1) 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 69.99 5 GE 6 7 DISC C REAR BLDG BRK 8 PANEL B Passed 9 GE 10 11 FUSE 1 PANEL 4 12 SIEMENS MAIN SWBD 15 FUSE 2 PANEL 3 16 SIEMENS MAIN SWBD Passed Passed 19 FUSE 3 PANEL 1 20 SIEMENS MAIN SWBD 22 23 FUSE 4 PANEL 6 24 SIEMENS MAIN SWBD 27 FUSE 5 PANEL 5 28 SIEMENS MAIN SWBD 31 FUSE 6 PANEL 2 32 SIEMENS MAIN SWBD 33 GOULD SHAWMUT 200.00 83.20 6.26 208 12.52 TR, 250V Class RK5 TR, 250V Class RK5 TR Passed Passed 200.00 6.26 208 12.52 250 200.00 83.20 6.26 208 12.52 15-600A 250 200.00 83.20 6.26 TR, 250V Class RK5 208 12.52 15-600A 250 200.00 83.20 6.26 TR Passed 250 83.20 TR, 250V Class RK5 TR 29 GOULD SHAWMUT 30 12.52 250 15-600A 25 GOULD SHAWMUT 26 208 TR 21 GOULD SHAWMUT INT kA 15-600A 15-600A Passed E TR, 250V Class RK5 TR 17 GOULD SHAWMUT 18 D Voltage (V) THQB 13 GOULD SHAWMUT 14 C TR, 250V Class RK5 208 12.52 15-600A 250 200.00 83.20 6.26 TR 34 Page 1 of 6 F C-L kA G X/R Calc/Dev/ Rating% 1.96 1.94 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95 EQUIPMENT EVALUATION 1 Device/Bus 2 Manufacturer A 35 PANEL 3 MAIN BRK 36 PANEL 3 MAIN B Status Description Passed HQR2 39 PANEL 4 MAIN BRK 40 PANEL 4 MAIN Passed 41 SIEMENS 42 43 PANEL A MAIN BRK 44 PANEL A MAIN Passed 47 PANEL A MAIN BRK0 48 PANEL B MAIN 50 51 PANEL D BRK 1 52 PANEL D 54 55 PANEL D BRK 2 56 PANEL D 57 SIEMENS 58 59 PANEL D MAIN BRK 60 PANEL D MAIN 63 PD-0038 64 PANEL 1 MILL DISCONNECT 65 BUSSMANN 208 10.94 100-250A, UL 240 65.00 86.67 16.84 SGDA, Spectra RMS 208 15.32 125-400A 240 65.00 86.67 23.57 208 15.20 SGDA, Spectra RMS BLH, 2 & 3-Pole Passed 65.00 23.39 208 7.48 240 22.00 86.67 33.99 208 7.48 15-100A 240 22.00 86.67 33.99 HQR2 208 7.55 100-250A, UL 240 65.00 86.67 11.62 HQR2 Passed 240 86.67 BLH, 2 & 3-Pole BLH 61 SIEMENS 62 HQR2 BLH Passed 11.15 17.15 15-100A 53 SIEMENS Calc/Dev/Series Rating% 208 65.00 SGDA Passed Bus/Device/ Rating% 240 125-400A 49 GE INT kA 86.67 SGDA Passed E HQR2 HQR2 45 GE 46 D Voltage (V) 100-250A, UL 37 SIEMENS 38 C FRS-R, 600V Class RK5 208 5.29 1-600A 600 200.00 FRS-R 34.67 2.64 66 Page 2 of 6 F C-L kA G X/R Calc/Dev/ Rating% 1.68 1.64 1.99 1.97 0.82 0.82 0.82 0.66 EQUIPMENT EVALUATION 1 Device/Bus 2 Manufacturer A 67 PD-0039 68 DOCK CONTROL PANEL DISC B Status Description Passed FRS-R, 600V Class RK5 69 BUSSMANN 70 71 PD-0040 72 YORK CHILLER DISCONNECT Passed 73 GOULD SHAWMUT 74 75 PNL 1 BRK 1 76 PANEL 1 79 PNL 1 BRK 13 80 PANEL 1 Passed Passed 83 PNL 1 BRK 14 84 PANEL 1 86 87 PNL 1 BRK 19 88 PANEL 1 91 PNL 1 BRK 2 92 PANEL 1 95 PNL 1 BRK 20 96 PANEL 1 97 CUTLER-HAMMER 1-600A 600 200.00 FRS-R 34.67 2.43 TR, 250V Class RK5 208 8.58 15-600A 250 200.00 83.20 4.29 BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/65.00 86.67 16.63 208 10.81 BAB, 3-Pole BAB, 3-Pole BAB Passed Passed 10.00/65.00 16.63 208 10.81 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/65.00 86.67 16.63 BAB Passed 240 86.67 BAB, 3-Pole BAB 93 CUTLER-HAMMER 94 4.87 15-100A 89 CUTLER-HAMMER 90 Calc/Dev/Series Rating% BAB 85 CUTLER-HAMMER INT kA 208 15-100A Passed E Bus/Device/ Rating% BAB 81 CUTLER-HAMMER 82 D Voltage (V) TR 77 CUTLER-HAMMER 78 C BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 BAB 98 Page 3 of 6 F C-L kA G X/R Calc/Dev/ Rating% 0.62 1.31 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 EQUIPMENT EVALUATION 1 Device/Bus 2 Manufacturer A 99 PNL 1 BRK 25 100 PANEL 1 B Status Description Passed BAB, 3-Pole 103 PNL 1 BRK 26 104 PANEL 1 BAB Passed 105 CUTLER-HAMMER 106 107 PNL 1 BRK 31 108 PANEL 1 Passed 111 PNL 1 BRK 32 112 PANEL 1 114 115 PNL 1 BRK 37 116 PANEL 1 118 119 PNL 1 BRK 7 120 PANEL 1 121 CUTLER-HAMMER 122 123 PNL 1 BRK 8 124 PANEL 1 125 CUTLER-HAMMER 126 127 PNL 2 BRK 1 128 PANEL 2 129 CUTLER-HAMMER 49.15 49.15 BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 208 10.81 BAB, 3-Pole BAB, 3-Pole 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 208 10.81 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/65.00 86.67 16.63 BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 BAB Passed 10.00/22.00 86.67 BAB Passed 240 86.67 10.81 BAB Passed 10.81 10.00/22.00 15-100A 117 CUTLER-HAMMER Calc/Dev/Series Rating% 208 240 BAB Passed Bus/Device/ Rating% 208 15-100A 113 CUTLER-HAMMER INT kA 15-100A BAB Passed E BAB, 3-Pole BAB 109 CUTLER-HAMMER 110 D Voltage (V) 15-100A 101 CUTLER-HAMMER 102 C BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 BAB 130 Page 4 of 6 F C-L kA G X/R Calc/Dev/ Rating% 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 EQUIPMENT EVALUATION 1 Device/Bus 2 Manufacturer A 131 PNL 2 BRK 13 132 PANEL 2 B Status Description Passed BAB, 3-Pole 135 PNL 2 BRK 14 136 PANEL 2 BAB Passed 137 CUTLER-HAMMER 138 139 PNL 2 BRK 19 140 PANEL 2 Passed 143 PNL 2 BRK 2 144 PANEL 2 146 147 PNL 2 BRK 7 148 PANEL 2 150 151 PNL 2 BRK 8 152 PANEL 2 153 CUTLER-HAMMER 154 155 PNL 3 BRK 10 156 PANEL 3 157 SIEMENS 158 159 PNL 4 BRK 15 160 PANEL 3 161 SIEMENS 49.15 49.15 BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 208 10.81 BAB, 3-Pole BAB, 3-Pole 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 208 10.81 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 BAB, 3-Pole 208 10.81 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.15 BL, 2 & 3-Pole 208 11.00 15-125A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.98 BL Passed 10.00/22.00 86.67 BAB Passed 240 86.67 10.81 BAB Passed 10.81 10.00/22.00 15-100A 149 CUTLER-HAMMER Calc/Dev/Series Rating% 208 240 BAB Passed Bus/Device/ Rating% 208 15-100A 145 CUTLER-HAMMER INT kA 15-100A BAB Passed E BAB, 3-Pole BAB 141 CUTLER-HAMMER 142 D Voltage (V) 15-100A 133 CUTLER-HAMMER 134 C BL, 2 & 3-Pole 208 11.00 15-125A 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.98 BL 162 Page 5 of 6 F C-L kA G X/R Calc/Dev/ Rating% 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.62 1.66 1.66 EQUIPMENT EVALUATION 1 Device/Bus 2 Manufacturer A 163 PNL 4 BRK 37 164 PANEL 4 B Status Description Passed BL, 2 & 3-Pole 167 PNL 4 BRK 5 168 PANEL 4 BL Passed 169 SIEMENS 170 171 PNL REAR BLDG BRK 172 PANEL B Passed 175 WH SUB PANEL C BRK 176 PANEL A Passed 178 179 WH SUB PANEL D BRK 180 PANEL B Passed 182 183 XFMR 33669 FUSE 184 LGE TLM#33669 BUS 185 COOPER 186 187 XFMR 648409 FUSE 188 LGE TLM#33669 BUS0 189 COOPER Passed Calc/Dev/Series Rating% 208 10.80 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.08 10.80 240 10.00/22.00 86.67 49.08 THQB 208 15.40 (*N1) 15-100A 240 10.00/22.00 THQB 86.67 69.99 TMQB 208 15.09 240 42.00 TMQB 86.67 35.93 TMQB 208 14.98 240 42.00 86.67 35.66 TMQB Passed Bus/Device/ Rating% 208 60-125A 181 GE INT kA 15-125A 60-125A 177 GE E BL, 2 & 3-Pole BL 173 GE 174 D Voltage (V) 15-125A 165 SIEMENS 166 C F C-L kA Calc/Dev/ Rating% 1.62 1.62 1.94 1.96 1.94 Bay-O-Net Current Sensing Fuse Link, 23kV 12470 3.81 5.27 C4-C17 15500 2.50/5.00 6.23 353C10 80.45 76.16 84.46 Bay-O-Net Current Sensing Fuse Link, 23kV 12470 3.81 5.27 C4-C17 15500 2.50/5.00 6.23 353C10 80.45 76.16 84.46 190 191 192 (*N1) System X/R higher than Test X/R, Calc INT kA modified based on low voltage factor. Page 6 of 6 G X/R 8.00 8.00 Taking the Flash Out of Electrical Safety SERVICES OVERVIEW ARC FLASH MODEL elect rical WORKPLA CE SA FETY LGE TLM#33669 SystemNominalVoltage 12470.0 V Isc 3P 3808.0 Amps X/R 3P 8.0000 LGE TLM#64840 SystemNominalVoltage 12470.0 V Isc 3P 3808.0 Amps X/R 3P 8.0000 XFMR 33669 FUSE Manufacturer COOPER Frame/Model 353C10 Sensor/Trip 25.0 A Settings 25.0 Amps XFMR 648409 FUSE Manufacturer COOPER Frame/Model 353C10 Sensor/Trip 25.0 A Settings 25.0 Amps P S P LGE XFMR 33669 Size 225 kVA Pri FLA 10.4 A Sec FLA 624.5 A %Z 1.8000 % S CBL-0001 (2) Size 500 kcmil Copper THWN 250.0 ft Ampacity 760.0 A LGE XFMR #64840 Size 225 kVA Pri FLA 10.4 A Sec FLA 624.5 A %Z 1.6200 % CBL-0008 (2) Size 500 kcmil Copper THWN 175.0 ft Ampacity 760.0 A LGE CUBICLE SIEMENS MAIN SWBD Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 12518.23 A AF_TripTime 2.000 s IncidentEnergy 26.97 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 126 inches FUSE 1 PANEL 4 Manufacturer GOULD SHAWMU T Frame/Model TR Sensor/Trip 200.0 A FUSE 2 PANEL 3 Manufacturer GOULD SHAWMUT Frame/Model TR Sensor/Trip 200.0 A FUSE 3 PANEL 1 Manufacturer GOULD SHAWMU T Frame/Model TR Sensor/Trip 400.0 A FUSE 4 PANEL 6 Manufacturer GOULD SHAWMUT Frame/Model TR Sensor/Trip 200.0 A FUSE 5 PANEL 5 Manufacturer GOULD SHAWMU T Frame/Model TR Sensor/Trip 200.0 A FUSE 6 PANEL 2 Manufacturer GOULD SHAWMU T Frame/Model TR Sensor/Trip 400.0 A CBL-0002 (1) Size 4/0 AWG Copper THWN 21.0 ft Ampacity 230.0 A CBL-0003 (1) Size 4/0 AWG Copper THWN 18.0 ft Ampacity 230.0 A CBL-0004 (2) Size 4/0 AWG Copper THWN 46.0 ft Ampacity 460.0 A CBL-0005 (1) Size 4/0 AWG Copper THWN 65.0 ft Ampacity 230.0 A CBL-0007 (1) Size 4/0 AWG Copper THWN 175.0 ft Ampacity 230.0 A CBL-0006 (2) Size 4/0 AWG Copper THWN 46.0 ft Ampacity 460.0 A PANEL 4 MAIN Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 10944.44 A AF_TripTime 0.029 s IncidentEnergy 0.3 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 7 inches PANEL 3 MAIN Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 11147.91 A AF_TripTime 0.027 s IncidentEnergy 0.28 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 7 inches PANEL 4 MAIN BRK Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model HQR2 Sensor/Trip 225.0 A Plug 225.0 A Settings Fixed PANEL 3 MAIN BRK Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model HQR2 Sensor/Trip 200.0 A Plug 200.0 A Settings Fixed PANEL 4 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 10797.60 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.010 s IncidentEnergy 0.11 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 4 inches PNL 4 BRK 5 Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model BL Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Thermal Curve (Fixed) INST Fixed (525A) CBL-0014 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 45.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A PNL 4 FOAMER OUTLET Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1988.65 A AF_TripTime 0.266 s IncidentEnergy 0.38 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 9 inches PNL 4 BRK 37 Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model BL Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Thermal Curve (Fixed) INST Fixed (525A) CBL-0015 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 45.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A PNL4 FORKLIFT CHARGER Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1988.65 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.266 s IncidentEnergy 0.38 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 9 inches YORK CHILLER DISCONNECT Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 8581.52 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.095 s IncidentEnergy 0.73 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 13 inches CBL-0017 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 45.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A PNL 3 BACKDOCK Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1995.64 A AF_TripTime 0.265 s IncidentEnergy 0.38 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 9 inches CBL-0043 (1) Size 4/0 AWG Copper THWN 15.0 ft Ampacity 230.0 A PNL 4 BRK 15 Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model BL Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Thermal Curve (Fixed) INST Fixed (525A) YORK CHILLER UNIT Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 7979.51 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.136 s IncidentEnergy 0.95 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 16 inches CBL-0018 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 45.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A PANEL 5 MAIN Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 5486.32 A AF_TripTime 0.871 s IncidentEnergy 3.99 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 38 inches PNL 2 BRK 1 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Tr ip 40.0 A Plug 40.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0044 (1) Size 8 AWG Copper THWN 30.0 ft Ampacity 50.0 A PNL 2 BRK 7 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 20.0 A Plug 20.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0045 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 35.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A CIRC PUMP BOILER 1 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2464.95 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.02 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PNL 2 BRK 13 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 20.0 A Plug 20.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0046 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 40.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A CIRC PUMP BOILER 2 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2201.78 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.02 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PNL 2 BRK 19 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 20.0 A Plug 20.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0047 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 60.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A BOTTOM AU GER Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1540.17 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.01 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PNL 2 BRK 2 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 40.0 A Plug 40.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0048 (1) Size 8 AWG Copper THWN 45.0 ft Ampacity 50.0 A BOILER 2 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2726.78 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.02 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PNL 2 BRK 8 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0049 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 60.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A TOP BAG AUGER Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1540.17 A AF_TripTime 0.009 s IncidentEnergy 0.01 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches CBL-0010 (2) Size 250 kcmil Copper THWN 12.0 ft Ampacity 510.0 A PANEL A MAIN Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 15320.73 A AF_TripTime 1.882 s IncidentEnergy 27.39 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 127 inches PANEL B MAIN Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 15204.81 A AF_TripTime 1.921 s IncidentEnergy 27.74 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 128 inches PANEL A MAIN BR K Manufacturer GE Frame/Model SGDA Sensor/Tr ip 400.0 A Plug 400.0 A Settings MAX PANEL A MAIN BRK0 Manufacturer GE Frame/Model SGDA Sensor/Trip 400.0 A Plug 400.0 A Settings MAX PANEL 2 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 10812.38 A AF_TripTime 0.597 s IncidentEnergy 5.93 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 49 inches PANEL 2 COMPRESSOR Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 3729.98 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.03 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 2 inches PANEL A Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 15089.71 A AF_TripTime 0.025 s IncidentEnergy 0.41 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 9 inches WH SUB PANEL C BRK Manufacturer GE Frame/Model TMQB Sensor/Trip 125.0 A Plug 125.0 A Settings Fixed PNL 2 BRK 14 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0050 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 30.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A CBL-0022 (1) Size 1/0 AWG Copper THWN 65.0 ft Ampacity 150.0 A PANEL 2 BLOWER FAN Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2797.93 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.02 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PANEL C Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 7770.63 A AF_TripTime 0.150 s IncidentEnergy 1.03 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 16 inches 3PH CHARGER BRK Manufacturer GE Frame/Model THQB Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0019 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 45.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A PNL A3PH CHARGER Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2080.15 A AF_TripTime 0.335 s IncidentEnergy 0.5 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 10 inches PNL3 FORKLIFT CHARGER Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1995.64 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.265 s IncidentEnergy 0.38 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 9 inches PANEL B Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 14976.99 A AF_TripTime 0.025 s IncidentEnergy 0.41 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 9 inches PNL REAR BLDG BRK Manufacturer GE Frame/Model THQB Sensor/Trip 100.0 A Plug 100.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0020 (1) Size 2 AWG Copper THWN 75.0 ft Ampacity 115.0 A PNL AT REAR BLDG Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 5556.26 A AF_TripTime 0.028 s IncidentEnergy 0.13 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 4 inches DISC C REAR BLDG BRK Manufacturer GE Frame/Model THQB Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Fixed WH SUB PANEL D BRK Manufacturer GE Frame/Model TMQB Sensor/Trip 125.0 A Plug 125.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0021 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 75.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A CBL-0023 (1) Size 1/0 AWG Copper THWN 68.0 ft Ampacity 150.0 A DISC C REAR BLDG COOL RM Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1289.59 A AF_TripTime 0.959 s IncidentEnergy 0.84 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 14 inches PANEL D MAIN Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 7554.00 A AF_TripTime 0.179 s IncidentEnergy 1.18 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 18 inches PANEL D MAIN BRK Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model HQR2 Sensor/Trip 200.0 A Plug 200.0 A Settings Fixed PANEL 1 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 10812.38 A AF_TripTime 0.597 s IncidentEnergy 5.93 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 49 inches PNL 1 BRK 1 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Tr ip 100.0 A Plug 100.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0024 (1) Size 2 AWG Copper THWN 15.0 ft Ampacity 115.0 A DISTILLING CP FEED #1 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 8911.09 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.08 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 3 inches PNL 1 BRK 7 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 100.0 A Plug 100.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0025 (1) Size 2 AWG Copper THWN 65.0 ft Ampacity 115.0 A PANEL 1 MILL DISCONNECT Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 5289.20 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.04 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 2 inches PD-0038 Manufacturer BUSSMANN Frame/Model FRS-R Sensor/Trip 100.0 A CBL-0041 (1) Size 2 AWG Copper THWN 6.0 ft Ampacity 115.0 A PANEL 1 HAMMER MILL Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 5029.94 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.04 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 2 inches Arc Flash Model, SKM Filename: MAIN DRAWING CBL-0009 (2) Size 250 kcmil Copper THWN 10.0 ft Ampacity 510.0 A PD-0040 Manufacturer GOULD SHAWMUT Frame/Model TR Sensor/Trip 200.0 A PANEL 3 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 10996.14 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.010 s IncidentEnergy 0.12 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 4 inches PNL 3 BRK 10 Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model BL Sensor/Tr ip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Thermal Curve (Fixed) INST Fixed (525A) Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 15924.02 A AF_TripTime 1.695 s IncidentEnergy 25.69 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 122 inches PNL 1 BRK 13 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Tr ip 100.0 A Plug 100.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0026 (1) Size 2 AWG Copper THWN 75.0 ft Ampacity 115.0 A DOCK CONTROL PANEL DISC Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 4869.99 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.04 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 2 inches PNL 1 BRK 19 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0027 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 100.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A COOLING TOWER Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 960.04 A AF_TripTime 1.958 s IncidentEnergy < 1.2 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 18 inches PNL 1 BRK 25 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 20.0 A Plug 20.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0028 (1) Size 12 AWG Copper THWN 60.0 ft Ampacity 25.0 A PNL 1 HOIST Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1009.52 A AF_TripTime 1.230 s IncidentEnergy 0.82 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 14 inches PNL 1 BRK 31 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 50.0 A Plug 50.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0029 (1) Size 6 AWG Copper THWN 90.0 ft Ampacity 65.0 A PNL 1 HEATER 1 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2232.92 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.02 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PD-0039 Manufacturer BUSSMANN Frame/Model FRS-R Sensor/Trip 100.0 A PNL 1 BRK 37 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0030 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 65.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A MASH COOLING Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1432.21 A AF_TripTime 1.269 s IncidentEnergy < 1.2 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 18 inches PNL 1 BRK 2 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 100.0 A Plug 100.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0033 (1) Size 2 AWG Copper THWN 15.0 ft Ampacity 115.0 A DISTILLING CP FEED #2 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 8911.09 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.08 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 3 inches PNL 1 BRK 8 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 40.0 A Plug 40.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0034 (1) Size 8 AWG Copper THWN 90.0 ft Ampacity 50.0 A HAMMER MILL CONTROL PANEL Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1497.11 A AF_TripTime 1.853 s IncidentEnergy < 1.2 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 18 inches PNL 1 BRK 14 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0035 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 90.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A ROLLER MILL Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1059.98 A AF_TripTime 1.697 s IncidentEnergy < 1.2 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 18 inches PNL 1 BRK 20 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 50.0 A Plug 50.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0032 (1) Size 6 AWG Copper THWN 90.0 ft Ampacity 65.0 A AIR COMPRESSOR 3 DISC Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2232.92 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.02 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PNL 1 BRK 26 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 30.0 A Plug 30.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0036 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 45.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A MARLEY PUMP Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1988.81 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.01 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PNL 1 BRK 32 Manufacturer CUTLER-HAMMER Frame/Model BAB Sensor/Trip 50.0 A Plug 50.0 A Settings Fixed CBL-0031 (1) Size 6 AWG Copper THWN 90.0 ft Ampacity 65.0 A PNL 1 HEATER 2 Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2232.92 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.02 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 1 inches PANEL D Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 7478.71 A AF_Tr ipTime 0.010 s IncidentEnergy 0.08 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 3 inches PANEL D BRK 1 Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model BLH Sensor/Trip 60.0 A Plug 60.0 A Settings Thermal Curve (Fixed) INST Fixed (675A) PANEL D BRK 2 Manufacturer SIEMENS Frame/Model BLH Sensor/Trip 60.0 A Plug 60.0 A Settings Thermal Curve (Fixed) INST Fixed (675A) CBL-0038 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 30.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A CBL-0039 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 120.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A BOTTLING CP DISC Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 2427.47 A AF_TripTime 0.017 s IncidentEnergy 0.04 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 2 inches CBL-0042 (1) Size 2 AWG Copper THWN 6.0 ft Ampacity 115.0 A PANEL D EXHAUST FAN Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 773.13 A AF_Tr ipTime 2.000 s IncidentEnergy 1.14 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 17 inches CBL-0040 (1) Size 10 AWG Copper THWN 15.0 ft Ampacity 35.0 A DOCK CONTROL PANEL Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 4647.31 A AF_TripTime 0.008 s IncidentEnergy 0.04 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 2 inches BOTTLING CONTROL PANEL Voltage 208.0 V InitSymRMS 3P 1792.86 A AF_TripTime 1.737 s IncidentEnergy < 1.2 Cal/cm^2 WorkingDistance 18 inches AF_Boundary 18 inches XYZ Company , Base Project: Date: October 10, 2020 Page No.: 1 Taking the Flash Out of Electrical Safety SERVICES OVERVIEW PPE POSTER elect rical WORKPLA CE SA FETY Personal Protective Equipment g n i t a R c r A E P P r d r u o a z y a e H r u e s h t s d e Make e c x E Taking the Flash Out of Electrical Safety for equipment assessed using arc flash calculations (502) 716-7073 e-Hazard.com Arc-Rating (AR) Must Be ≥ Estimated Incident Energy (IE) Recommended Best Practice when IE < 1.2 cal/cm2 IE = 1.2 – 12 cal/cm2 IE > 12 cal/cm2 Hard Hat Shirt, long-sleeve & Pants Head Hearing Protection AR Face Shield with AR Balaclava or Gloves: Leather, AR, or VR Hands Leather Footwear Feet ALL clothing made of Non-melting/Natural Fiber Safety Glasses/Goggles Body Eye Protection Hearing Protection Hard Hat Face Shield NFPA 70E / CSA Z462 Required Required, Choices Available As Needed AR Arc Flash Hood AR Shirt, long-sleeve & AR Pants or AR Coverall or AR Arc Flash Suit Heavy-duty Leather Gloves or AR Gloves or Rubber Insulating Gloves with Leather Protectors Leather Footwear AR Outerwear Requirements per NFPA 70E (2018), Table 130.5(G) / CSA Z462-18, Table 3 v1808 | © 2018 e-Hazard Management, LLC. Taking the Flash Out of Electrical Safety SERVICES OVERVIEW Utility Data electrical WORKPLA CE SA FETY XYZ Company Some place USA We are seeking the following details for an engineering and arc flash study at the facility listed above. There are two services and we have highlighted these on the picture below: Image Removed Due to Confidentiality Red shows the first service and its meter. Blue shows the second service with its meter in a cabinet inside the building. Request for information for Service #1 is on pages 2 & 3. Request for information for Service #2 is on pages 4 & 5. Thank you for your assistance. My contact details are as follows: Zarheer Jooma Pr Eng SMIEEE (SM) Electrical Engineer e-Hazard | www.e-hazard.com +1 (502) 609-1765 Mobile zarheer@e-hazard.com Page 1 of 5 Transformer #1 cabinet locked, and the meter covered appears to be damaged by the sun – the meter number unavailable 1 Transformer MVA 2 Transformer Pri/Sec Voltages 3 Transformer %Z 4 Available 3phase Short Circuit current at the primary terminals 5 3 ph X/R ratio at the primary terminals 6 Internal primary fuses (expulsion or bayonet) available? If “YES”, what are the fuse(s) types and rating? If “NO”, then a) what are the first fuses on the primary side and how far away are these fuses b) What is the available 3phase short circuit current and available X/R at the location of the fuse? [if it is far enough to change the values at the transformer) 7 Does LG&E have any fuses or protection on the secondary side of the transformer or inside the customers building? (See Pictures below) Pictures of Service #1: Page 2 of 5 Page 3 of 5 Transformer #2 pictures are attached. 1 Available 3phase Short Circuit current at the primary terminals 2 3ph X/R ratio at the primary terminals 3 Type of fuse and rating for the internal fuse links Type of fuse and rating for the Bayonet fuse 3 Does LG&E have fuses (or similar protection) in the Siemens cabinet shown on the next page: If “YES”, what are the fuse(s) types and rating? Pictures of Service #2: Page 4 of 5 Page 5 of 5 XYZ Company, Some place USA Transformer #1 (west xfmr) 1 Transformer kVA 2 3 4 5 6 7 9-28-20 TLM# 64840 on LG&E circuit CW1224 225kVA Transformer Pri/Sec Voltages Transformer %Z Available 3phase Short Circuit current at the primary terminals 3 ph X/R ratio at the primary terminals Internal primary fuses (expulsion or bayonet) available? If “YES”, what are the fuse(s) types and rating? If “NO”, then a) what are the first fuses on the primary side and how far away are these fuses b) What is the available 3phase short circuit current and available X/R at the location of the fuse? [if it is far enough to change the values at the transformer) Does LG&E have any fuses or protection on the secondary side of the transformer or inside the customers building? (See Pictures below) 12.47kV-120/208V 1.62% 3861 Amps at 12.47kV 4.11 Yes C10 25 amps No Transformer #2 (east xfmr) TLM# 33669 on LG&E circuit CW1224 1 Available 3phase Short Circuit current at the primary 3808 Amps @ 12.487kV terminals 2 3ph X/R ratio at the primary terminals 3.67 3 Type of fuse and rating for the internal fuse links 4 Type of fuse and rating for the Bayonet fuse C10 25 amps 5 Does LG&E have fuses (or similar protection) in the No Siemens cabinet shown on the next page: If “YES”, what are the fuse(s) types and rating?