1ST SEM FINAL EXAMINATION: REVIEWER GEED07: Science, Technology, and Society DVM 1B | PROF. Hyzel P. Agliam | SEM 1 2022 LESSON 7: GOOD LIFE THE NICHOMACHEAN ETHICS (NE or EN) ● by Aristotle ● good can be classified as either instrumental good or intrinsic good. ● The intrinsic good or the ultimate good, is considered to be better than the instrumental good because it is goodness in itself while the instrumental good is using others or something else to come up with the good. EUDAIMONIA: THE ULTIMATE GOOD 1. PLEASURE ➢ Can pleasure be the ultimate good? No. ➢ Pleasure cannot be the ultimate good because it does not encompass all the aspects of life. 2. WEALTH ➢ Can wealth be the ultimate good? No. ➢ Many people would aim to be rich or financially stable. However, is it also common for people to say that they would want to be rich in order to achieve something else. 3. FAME AND HONOR ➢ Can fame and honor be the ultimate good? No. ➢ Many people today seem to be motivated by a desire to be known, however, these cannot constitute the ultimate good because they are based on the perception of others. Fame and honor can never be good in themselves. 4. HAPPINESS ➢ Can happiness be the ultimate good? Yes. ➢ In the Aristotelian sense, happiness is living well and doing well. Among the Greeks, this is known as Eudaimonia and came from the root words eu meaning good and daimon meaning spirit. ➢ Eudaimonia transcends all aspects of life for it is about living well and doing well in whatever one does. Happiness transcends all things, is permanent and not based on the judgment of others therefore, happiness or eudaimonia is the ultimate good. Eudaimonia: Uniquely Human? ● Eudaimonia according to Aristotle is a unique function of human because accordingly, it can only be achieved through rationality or the wise use of the mind and judgment TRIPARTITE SOUL ● Conceptualized by Aristotle ● He claimed here that humans should have rationality. Arête and Human Happiness ● Eudaimonia is what defines a good life and a good and happy life is achieved by living a life of virtue. ● Intellectual virtue or virtue of thought is achieved through education, time and experience. ● Moral virtue or virtue of character is achieved through habitual practice. Some of the key moral virtues are generosity, temperance and courage. ● Rationality balances virtue. Good Life and Technological Progress ● Living a good life in the times of scientific and technological progress is not impossible. By using our intellect, without losing our rationality and morality as humans, we can develop materials and advanced mechanisms that could further help in improving and solving the present problems of the society through science and technology. LESSON 8: WHEN TECHNOLOGY AND HUMANITY CROSS BOOK: THE YEAR 2000 ● Herman Kahn & Anthony J. Wiener ● It was said in the book that 100 technological innovations will be made in the span of 30 years (2030) ● In 2020, some predictions from the book came true (gene, multimedia, etc.) TECHNOLOGICAL OPTIMISM ➢ It is the belief that technological advancements and innovations will sustain human life as the human population continues to increase. Negative implications in advancing science and technology can also have negative implications or effects. 1. Atomic Bombing in Nagasaki, Japan ➢ This happened during World War II; the war between Japan and US ➢ Albert Einstein Concept (Atomic Bombing) ➢ Components: Nuclear & Radiation ➢ The US first bombed Heroshima, Japan. After 3 days, they bombed Nagasaki. ➢ After Effects of Atomic Bombing: Triggers cancer cells 2. Human Genome Project ➢ Genetic Modified Organisms ➢ “Designer Babies” - gene that has bad characteristics will be edited ➢ CRISPR CAS9 - edits genes by precisely cutting DNA and then letting natural DNA repair processes to take over ➢ In 2018, there was a Chinese scientist who saw a HIV gene from a baby. By then, embryology gene editing takes place. Healthy twins were born and they are now resistant to HIV. They also have high IQ, but have high risks of getting cancer. The scientist and her team got jailed. 3. Using diesel-powered automobiles and coal-powered plants ➢ Evidence of climate change: Strong typhoons ➢ Satellite image of Typhoon Haiyan or Yolanda, the strongest typhoon in history passing through the Philippine archipelago on November 2013 ➢ Masinloc Coal Power Plant located in Masinloc, Zambales 4. Construction of Dams ➢ Disadvantages: (1) Dams can disrupt spawning of fishes and limit the flow of natural water to downstream water sources such as rivers and streams. (2) Dislocation/Displacement, (3) Reduces the productivity of organisms, (4) Ecological imbalances. (5) Floods ➢ Advantages: (1) Reservoir of water, (2) produces electricity/hydropower 5. Agent Orange ➢ U.S. helicopter spraying defoliant in dense jungle during the Vietnam War, 1969 (herbicide) ➢ The primary goal of US were to reduce Vietnam's plants/trees and kill their crafts ➢ Human who inhaled got affected by this, it even passed down to other generation (lumiliit, kulang body parts, mobility difficulties) 6. ILOVEYOU Virus ➢ The infamous cyber attack made by Filipino IT student, Onel de Guzman, affected millions of computers worldwide including systems of the Pentagon (US Military Base) and the British Parliament. ➢ Thesis proposal about virus that got disapproved Protecting Humanity from Negative Effects of Technology 1. Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Article 27) ➢ This document affirms everyone’s right to participate in and benefit from scientific advances, and be protected from scientific advances, and be protected from scientific misuses. The right to the benefits of science comes under the domain of “culture” so it is usually examined from a cultural rights perspective 2. UNESCO Recommendation on the Status of Scientific Researchers - 1974 (Article 4) ➢ This document affirms that all advances in scientific and technological knowledge should solely be geared towards the welfare of the global citizens, and calls upon member states to develop necessary protocol and policies to monitor and secure this objective. Countries are asked to show that science and technology are integrated into policies that aim to ensure a more humane and just society 3. UNESCO Declaration on the Use of Scientific Knowledge - 1999 (Article 33) ➢ This document states, “Today, more than ever, science and its applications are indispensable for development. All levels of government and the private sector should provide enhanced support for building up an adequate and evenly distributed scientific and technological capacity through appropriate education and research programs as an indispensable foundation for economic, social, cultural and environmentally sound development. This is particularly urgent for developing countries. This declaration encompasses issues such as pollution - free production, efficient resource use, biodiversity protection and brain drains. ● ● ● ● ● LESSON 9: WHY THE FUTURE DOESN'T NEED US? THE BRAVE NEW WORLD ● A world with pure technology and no sexual engagements (meaning all humans are product of science and techology) ● Written by Aldous Huxley in 1932 ● It said to represent the future of our society ASIMO ➢ the world’s most advanced technology ➢ ASIMO is a humanoid robot created by Honda in 2000. ➢ It is displayed in the Miraikan museum in Tokyo, Japan. WHY THE FUTURE DOES NOT NEED US? ● The most advanced technologies created by humans such as robotics, genetic engineering and nanotechnology threatened the human species to go extinct. ● AI (artificial intelligence) and robotics may lead to robotic rebellion and kill humanity. ● Genetic engineering may create new crops and potentially super species such as mutants and superbugs. ● Nanotechnology may be used to create super weaponry and advanced biological weaponry. Government may not disclose confidential information to the public therefore humanity may not be prepared for the worst. Computers are practically controlling everything in society from the stock market to entertainment. Robots become more and more common displacing skilled human workforce. Robotic technology and their applications to our everyday lives as human beings based on the article written by Goel. Robots - in the military (used for surveillance and disarming bombs.) ● in the medical field ( used in surgery and drug administration) ● cooking robots ● Robots (used as teachers) ● Robots (as friends) LESSON 10: INFORMATION AGE ● ● The information age has heavily influenced the way people connect with each other. It allowed information relay and communication to be done in a much easier and convenient way compared to methods used in the past eras. GUTENBERG PRESS ● It was the pioneer of communication and laying information ● The Gutenberg Press was one of the most cost-effective inventions created during the Renaissance period. ● It made a historic impact on society because people were able to print hundreds of books copied at a fast rate. ● Through it, information spread at a cheaper and faster rate, thus, making it more accessible to the public. Over the centuries, the printing press was further refined, allowing for different methods to print and reproduce texts. THE RISE OF SOCIAL MEDIA ● Mark Zuckerberg - the developer of Facebook social media application ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● Friendster in 2002 Myspace in 2003 Facebook, Twitter, IG in 2004 The ever - increasing presence of social media is clearly felt in society. Noyes (2020) estimated that there are 2.74 billion active Facebook users worldwide as of October 2020. The Philippines, on the other hand, accounts to 83 million Facebook users as of May 1, 2021 (statista, n.d.). Social media has influenced almost every aspect of society with even institutions using different social media platforms for various purposes. 2.934 billion Number of Facebook users in the world (monthly active users): 2.934 billion (July 2022) Number of people who use Facebook each day (DAU): 1.968 billion (July 2022) 83.85 million users Facebook users in the Philippines in 2022 Data published in Meta's advertising resources indicates that Facebook had 83.85 million users in the Philippines in Feb 15, 2022 ADVANTAGES OF SOCIAL MEDIA ● Social media currently plays a large role in the advertising industry. ● Social media can also help people engage in political matters. ● Social media has also allowed people to express their opinions on virtually anything for other people to read. ● Social media is ultimately used as a means for leisure and most users used it to connect with family, friends and loved ones DISADVANTAGES OF SOCIAL MEDIA ● One primary problem encountered by many social media users is the issue of privacy and identity theft. ● Cyberbullying is also an issue associated with social media. According to the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS, 2013), it is estimated that 22 million students in America experienced some form of cyberbullying each year. ● Social media also has effects on the way the society establishes its norm and ideologies. Social media is often chosen as a tool for asserting social norms, as the platform thrives in social participation. LESSON 11: BIODIVERSITY AND HEALTHY SOCIETY BIODIVERSITY ● Biological diversity or biodiversity is defined as the variability among living organisms in the terrestrial, marine and other aquatic resources of the planet. 3 TYPES OF BIODIVERSITY 1. SPECIES BIODIVERSITY ➢ is the heterogeneity of living species in a given region or habitat. Organisms belonging to species level are a group of organisms that have the capacity to interbreed. ➢ A current estimate of the number of species of the world varies from 5 million to nearly 100 million. There are 1.7 million that have been identified to date. A complete list of species is difficult to obtain, as many organisms, such as fungi, protozoans and bacteria have not been identified. 2. GENETIC BIODIVERSITY ➢ It describes the difference of genetic make-up within organisms belonging to the same species. The extent of variation among species is dependent on various factors such as mutation and environmental causes. ➢ It is said that the degree of diversity in the level of genes is crucial for species survival because much diverse genes would mean greater adaptations and chances of passing on their genes to their offsprings. 3. ECOSYSTEM DIVERSITY ➢ It refers to the variation in ecosystems within a region or habitat. Ecosystem is defined as a biological community that includes all living things (animals, plants and microorganisms) interacting with the non-living components of the environment such as weather, climate, soil, sun and air in a specific habitat. THE PHILIPPINE BIODIVERSITY ● The Philippines is regarded as one of the 17 mega diverse countries in the world because of its rich diversity and endemicity of species. Endemic species are plants and animals that can only be found in a certain region in the world. ● 7,620 plants and animals can be found in the Philippines and 5,382 are endemic. ● Given this, the Philippines ranked 23rd in the world and 6th in Southeast Asia in terms of plant diversity. ● The Philippines is also ranked 4th in terms of bird endemism and 5th in terms of mammalian and reptilian endemism. ● Approximately 33% of flora, 75% of amphibians, 70% of reptiles and 44% of birds are endemic in the Philippine archipelago. ● Dr. Heavy’s expedition led to the discovery of 140 species of mammals that are only found in the country such as the smallest water buffalo, the world’s largest rat and the world’s largest and smallest bats. ENDEMIC PLANTS AND ANIMALS IN THE PHILIPPINE ARCHIPELAGO ● Pandaka Pygmea - smallest fish in the world ● Rafflesa Philippensis - one of the largest flower in the world ● Tarsier - world’s most smallest primate PRESSURE TO BIODIVERSITY ● Habitat destruction ● Invasive or alien species introduction ● High population density and growth rates ● Climate change ● Illegal wildlife trade ● Deficiencies in the knowledge on biodiversity ● Inadequate enforcement of environmental laws and poor political will ● Failure to put value on the environment LESSON 12: GENETIC MODIFIED ORGANISMS AND GENE THERAPY GENETICALLY MODIFIED ORGANISMS ● Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are products of artificial manipulation and alteration of a species’ genetic material in a laboratory using genetic engineering. ● Plant, animal, bacteria and virus genes may be combined or crossbred to produce another kind of species that do not naturally occur in the environment. HISTORY OF GMO ● In 1953, the discovery of DNA by James Watson and Francis Crick opened the gates for the countless possibilities of genetic engineering. ● In 1973, Herbert Boyer and Stanley Cohen were the first scientist to genetically modify an organism by combining the genes of two different E. coli, a species of microorganism. ● In 1982, the US Supreme Court ruled to allow patenting of GMOs. The first patented genetically modified microorganism was made by Prof. Ananda Mohan Chakrabarty. He created a GMO microorganism, the Pseudomonas putida, that has the capacity to consume oil and hydrocarbons which is later used to solve problems on oil spill and pollution. This relish allowed the Exxon Oil company to start using microorganisms that can consume oil. ● In the same year, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved the first GMO - Humulin, a type of insulin produced using genetically modified E. coli bacteria to be available in the market to support the treatment of diabetes mellitus. ● In 1993, FDA approved bovine somatotropin (bST), a metabolic protein hormone used to increase milk production in dairy cows for commercial use. However, health concerns such as the possible effects of hormonal transfer to humans and the increase antibiotic doses given to these cows because of frequent mastitis brought about by too much milk production are still being questioned ● In 1994, the FDA approved the Flavr Savr tomato by Calgene Inc. for sale ● ● ● ● ● ● ● in grocery stores. This kind of tomato has delayed ripening effect which in return has longer shelf life compared to naturally grown tomatoes. In 1997, the European Union ruled in favor of mandatory labeling on all GMO food products, including animal feeds. In 1998, a genetically modified papaya in Hawaii was found to be resistant to Ringspot virus and produced the Bacillus thurengensis toxin, a bacterium that has no toxic effects to humans but are documented to affect some insects when ingested In 2000, golden rice was developed in the Philippines to address vitamin A deficiency. Golden rice is a variety of rice wherein its rice grains are genetically modified to biosynthesize beta carotene, a precursor of vitamin A. The introduction of golden rice was opposed by the environmental and antiglobalization advocates because this GMO was thought to compromise food production, nutrition and financial security. In 2003, a Bt-toxin-, Helicoverpa zea, was found feasting on GMO Bt cotton crops in the Southern US. This proves that animals and insects may become resistant to GMOs in a long run. In 2006, Yorkshire pigs (Enviropigs) were genetically modified to produce offsprings that produced the enzyme phytase in their saliva to digest plant phosphorus. Pigs are normally supplemented by phytase enzymes by farms so that they are able to utilize the phosphorus present in their feeds. Phosphorus is needed by livestocks for growth and health. With the production of the Enviropigs, farmers were guaranteed to have good quality livestocks while lessening the cost for phytase supplementation. In 2001, a researcher in eastern Quebec found Bt toxins in the blood of pregnant women and showed evidence that the toxin could be passed on to the babies. ● As early as 2013, corn and poplars were genetically modified and used to produced biofuels, which is regarded as an efficient substitute for petroleum products. WHAT ARE THE BENEFITS OF GMO’s? ● One of the best tools farmers have to help and preserve water, air, land, and limit impact of climate change. ● Increased crop yields by +22% (based on 2014 data) ● Reduced pesticide applications by -8% (based on 2015 data) Farmers kept 48 million acres out of production ● Decreased deforestation & harm to the ecosystem. ● Help improve air quality ● Till less often use less use of fuel ● Trap co2 in the soil ● Decrease carbon emissions by 58.8 billion lbs ● Help reduce water pollution ● Better retention, reduced run-off ● Prevent clogging of water bodies (saving 6,000 bodies of water) ● It benefits not just the environment but also our daily lives GENE THERAPY VS GENETIC ENGINEERING ● Genetic engineering - is the process of using recombinant DNA (rDNA) technology to alter the genetic makeup of an organism. ● Gene therapy is the method of inserting genes or nucleic acid into cells as a drug to treat genetic diseases. ● In 1972, Theodore Friedman and Richard Robin proposed that people with genetic disorders can be treated by replacing defective DNA with good DNA. ● In 1985, Dr. W. French Anderson and Dr. Michael Blasse worked together to show that cells of patients with Adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency can be corrected in tissue culture. ADA is an inherited type of disease affecting the immune system ● The first commercial gene therapy product Gendicine was approved in China in 2003 for the treatment of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Ethical Issues in Genetic Engineering ● Could have unknown effects or outcomes. ● Allergic reactions ● High costs ● Could result in the toxicity of an organism to humans or other organisms. ● Justice and equity ● Cross contamination ● Potential harms to health ● Potential environmental harm ● Stem cells are from human embryo’s (which has ethical issues) 2. CNT - based membranes are used for water desalination and nanoscale seniors to identify water contaminants. 3. Nanoscale titanium dioxide photocatalysis has antibacterial effects that can be applied to air and water treatment, anti-fogging and self- cleaning. 4. The nanoparticles of anatase titanium dioxide are also capable of eliminating harmful air pollutants. ETHICAL DILEMMA OF NANOTECHNOLOGY ● With the identified potential hazards that nanoparticles can bring to human health and the environment, should people disregard the benefits that nanotechnology provides them? LESSON 14: CLIMATE CHANGE AND ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS ● ● Climate: a long term weather (summer, winter, fall) Weather: a short term that happens and varies every day (rainy day, sunny day) LESSON 13: NANOTECHNOLOGY APPLICATIONS OF NANOTECHNOLOGY ● In the medical field, nanotechnology is used in drug delivery techniques, particularly using dendrimers, a kind of nonmaterial. This is a type of nanostructure that can be designed and manufactured to carry different materials that can recognize diseased cells, diagnose diseases, deliver drugs and report therapy outcomes. ● In First Aid, a bandage that is waterproof, elastic and able to dissolve in the skin over time was developed by the MIT led by Karp and Langer. The bandage is composed of nanopillars that function similar to the feet of geckos the use chemical interactions between nanopillars and biosurfaces 1. CNTs - are distinct carbon fibers that are traditionally used in industrial products such as tennis rackets, baseball bats, car and airplane frames and batteries. ● ● ● There have been increasing experiences of extreme weather patterns in the last 30 years. Scientists are also concerned with the alarming increase in the earth’s atmospheric temperature, a phenomenon called global warming or climate change. Climate change is defined as a global or regional change in the climatic patterns brought upon by the increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide produced by burning fossil fuels and other human activities. According to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCC), climate change is caused directly or indirectly by human activities. (Kyoto Protocol) DRIVING FORCES OF CLIMATE CHANGE 1. Rise in global temperature. (too much emission can raise global temperature) 2. Rise in ocean temperature. (very dangerous for the marine ecosystem since it needs balance temperature) 3. El Niño 4. Melting of ice sheets ( if it melts it can wash out the Philippines) 5. Glacial retreat (it has big effect on close country but as well on tropical countries) 6. Decreasing snow cover 7. Rise in the sea level (there are some organisms that cannot cope up to the rising of sea level) 8. Extreme events THE PHILIPPINE ON ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS ● In the public sector of the country, laws have been enacted to protect the environment 1. Republic Act 7942, also known as the Philippine Mining Act of 1995. This law aims to protect the environment by regulating the extraction of mineral resources by mining companies while expanding foreign investments and increasing mining output. 2. Republic Act 8749, known as the Philippine Clean Air Act of 1999. This law aims to reduce pollution by incorporating environmental protection into developmental plans. Likewise, it sets emission standards or motor vehicles and pollutant limitations for different industries. 3. Republic Act 9512, known as the National Environmental Awareness and Education Act of 2008. This law requires different government agencies in the field of education to promote environmental awareness in the curriculum. Schools must discuss the threats of harming and exploiting the environment. The citizens’ responsibility to the environment and the value of conserving, protecting and rehabilitating natural resources in the context of sustainable development. Ozone layer - is the protection of the earth from the sun, and radiation. Muñoz, Franciane Mae B. DVM1B